Janet Enosi on the role of technology in sustainable African aquaculture
21 minAudio
Our twentieth guest is Janet Enosi. Janet is currently a Master's in Aquaculture student at the University of Highlands and Islands, the University of Crete, and the University of Nante. She’s passionate about transforming complex underwater data into Actionable Environmental Intelligence for the future of sustainable aquaculture and offshore management. Welcome to Fork The System - a podcast spotlighting the innovators, researchers, and advocacy leaders reimagining how we feed the world. Resources: Janet's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/janet-enosi-096b8b22a/ Aquabyte: https://www.aquabyte.ai/ OptoScale: https://optoscale.no/?lang=en
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00I think it would be better to involve the people on the ground more, the community, the farmers, the people who work, because those people depend on this resource directly or depend on this livelihood directly. Therefore, they are willing to do what it takes to save it and to see it grow and become better.
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to Fork the System, a podcast spotlighting the innovators, researchers, and advocacy leaders reimagining how we feed the world. I'm your host, Sherry Shu, exploring how we can build food systems that are sustainable, ethical, and free from animal suffering. Today, I'm here with Janet Innossi. Janet is currently a Masters of Aquaculture student across the University of Highlands and Islands, the University of Crete, and the University of Nante.
SPEAKER_01She's passionate about transforming complex underwater data into actionable environmental intelligence for the future of sustainable aquaculture and offshore management. Janet, it's so great to speak with you today. Yeah, just starting off, very curious, what got you interested in the problem space of aquaculture and marine resources management?
SPEAKER_00I would definitely say scarcity of food and a way in which we could make sustainable food systems work globally, simply because people say there's not enough food, but there's actually a study that contradicts that by saying there's enough food, but people waste more. So yeah. And that's what drove me to joining aquaculture and just focusing on what we can give the world to make it a better place for everyone. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's an amazing mission. Earlier on, we were talking about uh where you grew up and kind of how your origins also prepared you for this role because you mentioned that aquaculture is such a critical industry in the country that you come from. So, do you mind elaborating a bit on that? Like, what is the role that aquaculture plays in the economy there?
SPEAKER_00Aquaculture is a sector in its conception stages. So coastal communities mostly rely on fisheries simply because it's been there for generations and generations and it has been easily accessible and it's something that has been passed down from one family to another. So aquaculture just came in as a new sector or a new type of farming that doesn't involve so much input compared to land-based farming and has been used to definitely motivate and be a source of income mostly to women, that is in seaweed farming.
SPEAKER_00And there's also shrimp farming and crab farming that is communal and really helps the socioeconomic variable of these communities.
SPEAKER_01That's really important. And yeah, I'm glad you highlighted, I think, the special role plays, especially with female employment. So it really seems like it's a cornerstone of the economy and society. What is problematic about how we manage fisheries and marine resources in Africa more broadly?
SPEAKER_00I think in Africa the major problem is definitely the lack of adequate technology
SPEAKER_01to
SPEAKER_00help boost what we already have. And that definitely makes us lag behind scientifically and also produce-wise, because we we really rely on natural and environmental factors to influence the kind of food we get. So if you know there's prolonged drought or there's flash floods, that really affects a lot of African countries in terms of food production. So we definitely need the adequate technology to come up with ways to combat this or have a spare kind of thing we can do to make sure when this doesn't work out, or when the land isn't fertile, or when it's too dry and the sun is out and it's hot and our crops have died, we can actually still get food from something else.
SPEAKER_01I see your note, you're kind of pointing out two things there. One is the ability to get food from somewhere else, which seems to be kind of diversifying production beyond maybe existing sources, right? But then the other thing you note is kind of natural disasters and the weather, which are you referring more to technology to manage what happens after these unpredictable events and still keep the land and the waters like good for production? Or is it more so technology that predicts when they will happen and what types of conditions will happen such that we can adapt to these conditions?
SPEAKER_00It's definitely more on predictive technology.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00And also not just to predict, but also get use technology as an alternative to get us the kind of food production we need, both on land and in the ocean.
SPEAKER_01Okay. What are some examples of the most exciting forms of technology you've seen in the predictive space or maybe in this like diversifying production space?
SPEAKER_00Well, mostly I've dealt with climate modeling,
SPEAKER_01where
SPEAKER_00there's just different forms of models that, let's say, with the ocean, kind of ocean movements we can get, what is being spread from one location to another. And that kind of affects also fisheries and fish migration. So why are our fishers not getting the normal catch they got they get at this time of the year from this particular space where they used to fish and what has happened till right now, the catch is few, and people are not getting what they are used to getting.
SPEAKER_00This also affects their livelihoods at large.
SPEAKER_01Very interesting. And I know a lot of that is probably because of climate change as well, right? It's probably resulted in a lot of differences in currents and fish populations. Have there been any specific, I guess, trends you're noticing from your work with this predictive technology, like specific areas where catches a lot smaller, or specific things that are kind of happening because of climate change or other conditions now that are changing the way fish behave or catches exist?
SPEAKER_00Ocean warming is generally becoming frequent,
SPEAKER_01and
SPEAKER_00not just in Africa, because what when you're modeling, sometimes you do want to see the globe at large, which has also resulted to coastal areas in certain countries facing a lot of inundation due to floods and the circulation patterns just becoming very intense to a level where the human being cannot actually control. We can just predict and try to adapt to it, but I don't think we can actually prevent it.
SPEAKER_01Right. Okay, so that's where I guess the predictive technology comes in. It's more for us to be aware of like where catches are lower or fish stocks might be dwindling and things like that. Okay, that's good to know. And then, yeah, on the second whole area you talked about when it comes to diversifying the sources of food we get, how does technology play a role there?
SPEAKER_00Okay, now this goes deep into biotechnology, and this does not only apply to fish or aquaculture, it also runs through agriculture. And actually, in modern day, most of the grains we take are genetically modified, even plants.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00The normal, the average size of a tomato has increased over the over the years. You know, it's purposefully done by people in labs and all that. So um, it's more of using technology to give us what we want to hopefully get to an amount that can feed nations or entire populations.
SPEAKER_01Interesting. Are there specific examples of where this technology has been trending? Because I know I think everyone is aware of GMOs now, but are there ways in which this technology has been trending or changed over time? Like, what are some of the most exciting new updates in the whole genetics modification or food modification space?
SPEAKER_00Well, like aquaculture, some you can actually like choose particular genes you want in a certain fish just to make sure. Yeah. So just to make sure you know your fish grows to have more fat or filet.
SPEAKER_01Whoa,
SPEAKER_00compared to what you would find in wild populations. Not that that makes the fish unhealthy. No, it just gives you, gives the market what it wants, you know, the the consumer, you want more fillet than bones, so you get that.
SPEAKER_01I guess this type of technology where you're kind of increasing the fish's fat might be really, really controversial, right? Some people might be like, this is unnatural. What is your take on all of this new technology? Are you excited by all of it? Or is there specific technologies you're particularly excited about in this new era of growing food?
SPEAKER_00My take on technology is that I am actually enthusiastic about technology. I am it's not what the technology does, it's what we use it for and the control of it to give us what is healthy for a human being. And that's where the controversy comes in. Because me modifying a lemon, an orange to become an a lemon isn't the problem.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00The problem is if you consume that lemon, what effects does it have to you?
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Health-wise. And what have I added or not added? What is what kind of vitamin is needed or not needed that the newfound lemon doesn't have compared to the orange that you are consuming?
SPEAKER_01Okay. That makes sense. Are there any instances though where the modification could result in bad nutritional outcomes? So, with the example of the fish modification, for instance, is there not a risk that you modify the fish to maybe be more fatty or more meaty than it used to be? But that actually causes fish itself to become more high in saturated fat or something than the or the natural or normal fish before it was modified.
SPEAKER_00No, no, no. Everything is measured. Definitely. Everything has its levels, and the scientists know that this is the appropriate level for human consumption. This is what the body needs. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Okay, fair enough. Is there any worries about how it might affect the animals themselves? Because I know there's a whole crowd that maybe is more focused on the animal welfare.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So
SPEAKER_00um, fish welfare is actually a priority, especially in the EU these days. So the labs that do it, the companies that work on that know that they are governed by law, where the fish welfare is actually it's a hot topic, and a fish, it is an animal and it should have um a certain level of treatment.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00And also in the long run, as the producer, if your fish aren't doing well, if they're well phased and nice, you won't get good produce.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00It's the same thing with agriculture. You know, you want to make sure chicken, okay, for you to get a lot of eggs. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01For sure.
SPEAKER_00So
SPEAKER_01I actually I was recently reading and kind of hearing about like a lot of places in Norway. I guess that's because where I'm studying right now. Um, the salmon industry in particular is really struggling with fish lice. Um,
SPEAKER_00and
SPEAKER_01that's just a big it's not only obviously bad for the fish to be experiencing the pain of dealing with lice in their face, right? But it's obviously bad for the catch because then you have like these kind of disfigured, the meat is like
SPEAKER_00spotting
SPEAKER_01off, and then no one quite
SPEAKER_00yeah,
SPEAKER_01no one wants to eat this type of fish, right? Like fish that is clearly unhealthy. Um, so I guess it does create this kind of incentive matching between both like you obviously want have incentives to ensure economically that your fish are doing well, but also you have incentives to make sure that the fish are actually like healthy and taken care of and treated well, which is good. But yeah, I'm curious, I guess, the future of technology, maybe we'll see more opportunities to almost engineer fish or kind of deal with these types of problems like lice or like um suffering in in better ways.
SPEAKER_01I noticed that you're very interested in like kind of data and AI. And on this whole topic of technology, what specific roles do you think AI plays that uniquely allow for the improvement of uh welfare and sustainability?
SPEAKER_00I would say technology plays a role in um, first of all, just monitoring what goes on in these fish cages, because a human being isn't under the water 24-7 to tell you, you know, this thousand in one salmon are dealing with this and this. So it plays a role in monitoring what we are farming. That's number one. The second thing is it does use, especially in machine learning, where you do train a model to know this is a healthy kind of fish, this is how it looks.
SPEAKER_00It's easier to spot discrepancies or problems in your stock when you're using technology. So, in other words, technology makes the work easier for you, for you to be able to quickly combat any issue you might get.
SPEAKER_01Okay, that's very interesting. So that's what precision aquaculture is essentially like being able
SPEAKER_00to
SPEAKER_01use this AI or this data or this technology in the way to
SPEAKER_00and again all the way
SPEAKER_01up
SPEAKER_00to like the feeding, like what time should your fish be said? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Okay, and it you said it tracks feeding, it tracks the health of the fish, and it also tracks like conditions of the water, what's going on, exactly, and
SPEAKER_00welfare and everything.
SPEAKER_01Oh cool, yeah. Has this been deployed across fisheries everywhere? Is it mainly just in Europe right now?
SPEAKER_00It's something that is coming up and is mostly deployed in Norway, actually, where you are.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, okay.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it's it's fun to see what people are coming up with each and every day. You know, and there are companies that are working in this, which I think is very interesting and something I would really love to engage in.
SPEAKER_01Do you know of any companies currently working
SPEAKER_00through my research on like LinkedIn?
SPEAKER_01Okay,
SPEAKER_00yeah, the ones I normally see. Um, there's an AI company called Aquabytes, there's also Octoscale. Yeah, I think there are a few companies. However, it's more of a startup, I would say. It's a field that's still being explored. It's not something you'll find in every fish farm
SPEAKER_01for sure
SPEAKER_00in the entire EU. Also, because it's also expensive, you know. Do you
SPEAKER_01know how much something like that would cost? Because obviously Norway is a country that's very, very wealthy and can fish farms probably can afford this technology.
SPEAKER_00But
SPEAKER_01is it like how much is it? Is it millions?
SPEAKER_00Well, I don't know how much it is. Yeah,
SPEAKER_01fair enough. But like, yeah, it definitely seems like something that'd be difficult for fisheries in in countries where maybe smaller fisheries or countries that are slightly less developed, it seems harder to execute, right? If it's so high cost. Um, but I guess with over time with development, the cost might come down. That's kind of what happens with most technologies.
SPEAKER_00With technology, exactly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And
SPEAKER_00it becomes more refined instead of using large inventions or machines, you know. Now it gets smaller and better for people to access it in the market, even price-wise. For example, in storage, in the past, like you needed a whole huge computer to store space. Now you have a flash disk that can have like 5 GB and you have the space you need, or like a microchip. Yeah, it just gets better with time
SPEAKER_01when
SPEAKER_00people are refining their technology every day.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, totally makes sense. Do you see any then big bottlenecks when it comes to adopting more sustainable practices? Whether, I guess in this case we were kind of talked about the cost bottleneck for a lot of producers. Are there other more like governance-related bottlenecks, or just any bottlenecks that are kind of what like the gap between where we want to be in terms of sustainable fishing and where we currently are?
SPEAKER_00I think in most countries globally, it's because what what is used is a top-down approach. It can be effective because essentially the people at the top know, you know, are educated enough to make the decisions and know what is happening, they know what is happening geopolitically, so they have to shift the paradigms to feed countries and their current state to make sure everyone is on the same page. But um I think it would be better to involve the people on ground more, the community, the farmers, the people who work, because those people depend on this resource directly or depend on this livelihood directly.
SPEAKER_00Therefore, they're willing to do what it takes to save it and to see it grow and become better. And they're also the ones on ground. They know what the community around them wants, what it wants to see, what how receptive it is to different measures, sustainable measures, and what makes some sustainable activities or restoration programs work or not work.
SPEAKER_01Right. That's very well said. I think like there's so many issues where taking a more grassroots approach is the better approach, but it's so easy to just have the halls of power, people in the most powerful governance positions be the only one calling the shots when clearly local knowledge prevails because people, as you say, on the ground have so much more of that expertise. Do you see this getting better? Um, who currently, I guess, like is the most powerful figures in like fisheries or ocean governance?
SPEAKER_01And do you see them actually like taking in more diverse voices and getting more local opinion and local expertise?
SPEAKER_00Well, government-wise, I really can't speak about that. Every government is different,
SPEAKER_01right?
SPEAKER_00But like um, non-governmental organization-wise, I would say the most common is the UN. The UN is everywhere, and I think they do try to diversify their portfolio. There's definitely a gap over there. I don't think a local fisherman knows even about the UN. Yeah. Um, simply because you would find the bosses or the people in charge come down over to the community frequently. It could happen once in a while, their holidays, their special locations, the special projects.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but to just integrate with the community and see what's happening simply because also these people don't have that kind of time and they have a lot of stuff to do. But it would be better if they stationed representatives in different communities and that the representative is a community member. That's also very important.
SPEAKER_01That's a great idea. I think that's definitely something the UN or other global governance organizations should consider, like a local representative for every region's interest. That could be really, really good at getting people's voices without also taking away from their busy schedules and everything else they have to do. Like, I think it's amazing that there are these efforts being made already by people like yourself who are signing organi uh treaties like this um to get more representation from voices in the aquaculture space. Thank you so much for I guess sharing all of that about your background and also the way you kind of see the industry progressing with technology and where it can go next in terms of improvements for who makes those decisions, who gets to be at the table, providing their voice as to the future of oceans and water management.
SPEAKER_01Are there any kind of final suggestions or things you want to leave the audience with as people who might be interested in the sustainable aquaculture space but don't really know where to start or just want to kind of learn more about the space?
SPEAKER_00I think the best way to learn something is to actually try it. You know, just try it, get into it, get involved in projects that do it, people that do it, see what is happening wherever you are in the globe, whatever country you're in. And that's when you get to really see do I like this or do I not like this? Is the goal you are trying to meet being achieved. You also get to see what goes wrong in your country when people are planning this kind of stuff. What happens? You will you'll be able you'll know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, just by interacting with people in this field. However, I feel like everyone who makes sustainable food production their priority should keep doing it. Food is a it's a basic need, you can't avoid it. People eat food till the end of the world. So
SPEAKER_01for sure. If it's unavoidable, we might as well try to make the process of getting that food better so it doesn't destroy us or cause a lot of problems. Okay, well, thank you so much, Janet. That was a really, really interesting conversation. I learned a lot, and thank you for taking the time to share all that with me. That's it for this episode of Fork the System. If you have a guest or topic you'd like to hear about, share your ideas using the feedback form linked below. Until next time.
Our nineteenth guest is Caroline Cotto, a Director at Food System Innovations who oversees NECTAR, an initiative accelerating the alternative protein transition through taste. Her commitment to saying “yes” has led her...
Our eighteenth guest is Monica Chen, the Executive Director of the New Roots Institute. New Roots educates high school and college students on the devastating impacts of factory farming and supports them as they become...
Our seventeenth guest is Matthew Dominguez, the U.S. Executive Director at Compassion in World Farming, where he leads a team dedicated to improving the welfare of farmed animals and advancing a food system that is...
Our sixteenth guest is Dr. Renan Danielski, a New Harvest Postdoctoral Fellow at Lethbridge Polytechnic’s Advanced Post-Harvest Technology Centre, specializing in the upcycling of agricultural co-products into...
Our fifteenth guest is Margrethe Aanesen, a Senior Researcher at SNF - Centre for Applied Research at the Norwegian School of Economics in Bergen. Her work focuses on the management of marine ecosystem services and the...