Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Fork The System

Fork The System artwork

Matthew Dominguez on stopping the Save Our Bacon Act

Aug 4, 202634 minAudio

Our seventeenth guest is Matthew Dominguez, the U.S. Executive Director at Compassion in World Farming, where he leads a team dedicated to improving the welfare of farmed animals and advancing a food system that is better for animals, people, and the planet. With more than 15 years of experience in animal welfare and food policy, he has driven major corporate commitments and public policy reforms for farmed animals and regenerative agriculture. The grandson of a cattle rancher, Matt brings a unique and grounded perspective to conversations about food, farming, and animal welfare. Welcome to Fork The System - a podcast spotlighting the innovators, researchers, and advocacy leaders reimagining how we feed the world. NOTE: The Senate Agriculture Committee is scheduled to mark up the Farm Bill this Thursday, August 6th, when the Save Our Bacon Act (SOBA) could still be added as an amendment. Now is the time to speak out. Contact Your US Senator BY THURSDAY, AUGUST 6TH TO STOP SOBA: https://secure.humaneworld.org/page/186341/action/1?ea.tracking.id=web_aa SHARE this post: https://www.instagram.com/p/DVq3KegFueE/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&igsh=NTc4MTIwNjQ2YQ== Matt's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/matthewdominguez/ Matt's Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/matthew_t_dominguez/ Feedback Form: bit.ly/forkthesystemfeedback

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01So you have states' rights, you have an affront to democracy, you have genuine health concerns and food safety issues and disease and prevention controls. And then on top of that, you have the humane treatment of animals. You have so many reasons to oppose the Save Our Bacon Act. And frankly, there's not one credible argument for why it should pass.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back to Fork the System, a podcast spotlighting the innovators, researchers, and advocacy leaders reimagining how we feed the world. I'm your host, Sherry Shu, exploring how we can build food systems that are sustainable, ethical, and free from animal suffering. Today, I'm here with Matthew Dominguez. Matt is the U.S. Executive Director at Compassion and World Farming, where he leads a team dedicated to improving the welfare of farmed animals and advancing a food system that's better for animals, people, and the planet.

SPEAKER_00With more than 15 years of experience in animal welfare and food policy, he has driven major corporate commitments and public policy reforms for farmed animals and regenerative agriculture. The grandson of a cattle rancher, Matt brings a unique and grounded perspective to conversations about food, farming, and animal welfare. Matt, it's so wonderful to have you with us today to talk about SOBA and US Farm Bill and policy in the US.

SPEAKER_01I think I actually need to update my bio because I think it's probably been more than 15 years based on the white in my beard. It's a real honor to be on. Thank you so much for having me.

SPEAKER_00No problem. Just kicking things off, I'd love to learn a bit more about the US Farm Bill, the legislation at the core crux of this debate. What does it do? Like what are its key sections that govern farmed animal welfare and agricultural policy, and what power does it give the federal government?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean it's a great question because first and foremost, we need to separate the two things, which is the Save Our Bacon Act, which I think you and I will refer to it as SOBA moving forward, and then you have the farm bill itself. And so I think the best way to look at this is the Save Our Bacon Act is a standalone bill in Congress that's been introduced by a representative and uh senators in Iowa that seek to preempt animal welfare laws on the state level. Now we can get into a little bit more detail about what SOBA is, but to answer your question, the farm bill is the vehicle to which they're trying to sneak the Save Our Bacon Act in because they can't get it passed as a standalone bill.

SPEAKER_01So the Farm Bill. You know, it's one of the largest uh expenditure bills that happens in the U.S. It's supposed to be every five years that there is a farm bill that passes that that funds a whole host of things. I mean, this this bill is thousands of pages long, it's billions and billions and billions of dollars. But one of the biggest parts of it is the SNAP program. So think of it as welfare. So it's really food stamps and other federal grants that help people who are low income and people that live in areas where they're not able to afford food.

SPEAKER_01So that's a big part of the farm bill is funding that SNAP program. And then on the other side is unfortunately a massive handout when it comes to our federal government and the taxpayer dollars that goes to subsidies and really it goes to paying large industrial, agricultural, federal funds to operate. And so this is a massive bill that touches a whole host of issues. Unfortunately, there is no real animal welfare aspect to the farm bill. I mean, this is really just a massive bill of spending by the federal government.

SPEAKER_01And again, they're trying to sneak a few people are trying to sneak the Save Our Bacon Act into that large bill.

SPEAKER_00Great synopsis. That makes sense. If it is the case that this bill does not have an explicit like animal welfare provision, uh, but it's focused on subsidies, is there precedent for sneaking in this type of additional provision that's focused on preventing what states can do with animal welfare? Like, I don't I don't see the connection.

SPEAKER_01This has been, I think this is the third farm bill. Uh well, the th the farm bill is currently late. It's uh I think it's two, three years overdue, uh, which is you know hilarious. Is that you know, our Congress, the entire job of sitting members in Congress is to pass budgets, to to do bills like this, and they're two, almost three years late now on this farm bill. And I think you and I, if we were two or three years late on a school project, we would be kicked out of college or we'd be fired from our job. For sure. However, these people continue to be remaining in their seats. Uh so the farm bill's extremely late, which as you can imagine, puts a lot of pressure on getting one done as quickly as possible.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. But yes, this farm bill is not unique in that they have been trying, and when I say they, I mean industrial agriculture, particularly the pork industry, has been trying to pass a version of the Save Our Bacon Act and shove it into the farm bill the last two times that this bill has passed. So, two farm bills ago, so you're talking about 10 plus years ago, it was the King Amendment. So, Representative Steve King from Iowa, he was the originator of this type of language that preempts and stops states from passing laws to be able to protect farm animals.

SPEAKER_01So originally it was the King Amendment, so it failed to get into the farm bill, you know, during his time in office. Then it was turned into the EATS Act. So that was, again, a standalone bill that was trying to be passed. And they tried to sneak it into the last farm bill and were not successful. And then they did a little bit of rebranding where they thought that, well, if we call it Save Our Bacon, maybe we can get a little bit further along. And that's where you see the representatives and the senators from Iowa that have sponsored bills on the House and Senate side that is the Save Our Bacon Act.

SPEAKER_01And then again, now in this farm bill, they're trying to sneak it in.

SPEAKER_00I see. Okay, so it has some history of trying to.

SPEAKER_01There's precedent that they have been trying to do this for the last two farm bills. This farm bill's not unique in that category. But uh again, it's because they know that on its face that if they tried to pass this piece of legislation by itself as a normal standalone bill, that they would not even have a snowball's chance in hell.

SPEAKER_00So got it. Can you then elaborate a bit more? I know we've already been talking around it, but what does the Save Our Bacon Act like what powers would it actually give the federal government or what would it prevent states from doing? And what are the key arguments behind why the agricultural industry is supporting it and defending it?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I think we have to go back a little bit. You know, you have to go back a decade plus to really understand the farm animal protection movement here in the United States and the great work that has been done to try to at least increase the welfare of animals that are on factory farms. And so, as I'm sure you and many people know, that there's a large number of animals, we're talking billions of them, that are raised and killed and slaughtered in the United States for meat, you know, dairy, and eggs. Now, the vast majority of mother pigs in the pork industry are confined in what are called gestation crates.

SPEAKER_01And so these are cages that are, you know, six feet by two feet, basically not much larger than a pig's own body where she can't even stand up, turn around, and extend her limbs. She will live in intensive confinement for nearly her entire three-year life. That's the life of one of the smartest animals on this planet, is confined in a space where she can't even turn around. And then in the egg industry, you also have hundreds of millions of egg-laying hens. I think it's we're well over 300,000 egg layers in the United States. And about half of them, but a decade ago, nearly all of them were in barren battery cages, which are similar to the gestation crate, but these wire cages that house a handful of birds that don't even have enough space to spread their wings.

SPEAKER_01So you can imagine for these animals, this is you know the seventh circle of hell where they're living a life not worth living. There's an incredible amount of suffering that they go through. And the farm animal movement for years has been working both through state legislatures and also in the ballots, which is in the United States, about 25 states allow voters to collect signatures and put before the voters during an election the passage of a statutory bill. And in multiple states, when the question was put before them, the do you want to give farm animals enough space to stand up, turn around, extend their limbs, and get rid of this intensive confinement?

SPEAKER_01Overwhelmingly, both legislatures and voters have passed reforms. So key reforms are Prop 12 in California and Question 3 in Massachusetts. Those passed by over 60% in California and over 70% in Massachusetts. And in an election, that is a blowout. Very few things ever get that level of approval when it both from Republicans and Democrats. So they have laws on the books in California, in Massachusetts, and in a handful of other states that have been passed through the legislature that says that animals be able to stand up, turn around, and extend their limbs.

SPEAKER_01And more importantly, if you want to sell into our state that you must comply with our law that an animal be able to stand up, turn around, and extend their limbs. Now, one thing that I get often is people say, wait, is that all these laws do? And the question is and the answer is yes. That's it. This entire fight on the Save Our Bacon Act is about a pig being able to stand up, turn around, and extend their limbs in a factory farm. That is all we're talking about here. It's crazy. Um I mean, you would think that we passed a law that gave them the right to be in the Hilton suite somewhere and that they were, you know, given massages all day, that this is this major issue for the industry.

SPEAKER_01It's not. It's so that they can stand up, turn around, and extend their limbs and get rid of gestation crates and battery cages. So that's the history. So we've been successful on the state level, and of course, it needed to be on the state level because our federal government is essentially owned by industrial agriculture, and there's very little chance of ever passing a federal ban on the intensive confinement of farm animals. So we've gone to the states. So there's a handful of laws across the country that protect farm animals from abuse in extreme confinement. What has happened is that the industry has fought this.

SPEAKER_01They've lost in the legislature, they've lost in ballots, they've taken this all the way up to the Supreme Court, where the Supreme Court, the conservative Supreme Court, has said, nope, California and Massachusetts have a right to pass these laws, so they're perfectly constitutional. And then, of course, as a last resort, the pork industry, they've gone to Congress, they've basically bought a handful of lawmakers in Iowa and North Carolina to carry their water for them. And that's where the Save Our Bacon Act comes in, is that they've introduced a bill that would essentially take away and preempt states from being able to pass animal welfare laws and set a higher standard.

SPEAKER_01So what this does is it basically says to states across the country, all 50 states, when it comes to agricultural practices around the treatment of farm animals, you do not have the right to be able to pass laws. What we're fighting for is the ability for states to pass laws to protect farm animals both within their state, and if you're going to sell into their state, that those animals be able to at least be treated in the way that your own state laws are, which is 100% constitutional.

SPEAKER_00Right. And what exactly is the argument that the agricultural industry has told these farmers that are kind of doing their bidding that spout out? Is it just financial, like, oh, we need to reduce costs, otherwise it gets passed on to consumers? Like, is there anything else?

SPEAKER_01It's all the BS you could ever think of, right? Like they say that you're gonna walk into the store and you're not gonna be able to find uh pork on your shelves. You're not gonna be able to find bacon. That's it. It's gonna cost a thousand dollars. I mean, it's it's just it's all it's the typical arguments you make when you want to try to pass something. It's scare tactics. It's saying, you know, it's going to increase cost, it's gonna reduce supply, it's a burden on farmers, all of you know the standard talking points that you use to be able to pass something. But the thing is, is it's not backed in any type of data or any type of fact.

SPEAKER_01The fact is that Prop 12 and question three have been, they've been in force for years. And what we have seen is that the pork and the eggs and the other products that need to comply with this law, they've really not gone up more than typical inflation. What it comes down to, and it really is just the pork industry, at least with the egg industry and the veal industry, which also is covered by Prop 12 and question three, those industries have seen the writing on the wall. They know that voters, consumers, that people simply do not want animals tortured that are in this food system.

SPEAKER_01They do not want animals confined in a space that they can't even stand up again. Stand up, turn around, and extend their limbs. It's all we're talking about here. But there's one industry. There is one industry that is stubborn, that they are unwilling to even come to a compromise, they're unwilling to even have a conversation around maybe we need to treat these animals better. If you talk to your average pork producer, if you talk to a true American family farmer, they don't want to use gestaan crates. They want to move away from them. In fact, over 30 to 40% of the pork industry has already shifted away from them.

SPEAKER_01There's major producers that have already shifted away from them. There's small family farms that don't use gestation crates. This is not only doable, but it's something that is 100% the future if you want to be aligned with your consumers and the companies that are buying pork from you. It comes down to they're just stubborn. They don't want to change. They have spent millions of dollars on lobbyists, on donations to political campaigns, to TV ads. They have spent millions and millions of dollars to try to pass this law that, frankly, I don't think that they have much of a chance of passing.

SPEAKER_01All of that money could have gone into transitioning. All of that money could have gone into supporting their actual farmers so that they can feed their family and that they can transition into more and better systems. So it's one of those things where you have to sometimes scratch your head to think about in 2026, we are debating in Congress whether a pig should stand up, turn around, extend their limbs, and whether an industry that treats animals cruelly should continue trying to pass this type of legislation. It is, I find myself dumbfounded even having these conversations half the time.

SPEAKER_00I am curious why it's the pork industry. Is there something about the pork industry that gives it more financial influence or is changing more expensive? Or is cage-free more normalized in a way that like chicken farmers feel like they have to comply, but you know, gestation creates like I'm actually going to be able to do that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's safe to say, like, when it comes to the treatment of animals, every industry we fight, the egg-laying industry, the broiler industry, the dairy industry, they're not great.

SPEAKER_00I mean, they are they have their own interests in mind. Yeah. They care about the bottom line.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And in their own brain, they think that doing this is how they make the most amount of money, which actually doesn't even line up with fact. Um, there was a study that was done by the United Egg producers many years ago, and I think the data still pretty much holds up that it's something like around a penny per egg to go from battery cages to cage-free. I mean, think about that. The egg industry continues to condemn over 150 million egg-laying hens to the worst possible life they possibly could have for a penny per egg. I mean, the degree of selfishness, the degree of greed, it's absolutely disgusting.

SPEAKER_01Please don't take my comments about the pork industry, which, you know, on this issue is the worst industry when it comes to this particular issue. I mean, they're all refusing to move to higher welfare systems. Now, granted, there's a lot of producers and there's a lot of companies that want to do that, but the industry itself, they always drag their feet. They're always going to fight reforms when it comes to treating animals better. Shoot, they fight reforms that treat humans better. I mean, the broiler industry is actively continuing to lobby and fight to get the line speeds on the slaughter lines to increase, which has been shown to be unbelievably detrimental to workers, both from physical and mental issues that they face.

SPEAKER_01I mean, these workers are hurt at alarming rates. But on this issue, the pork industry is the main leader. Every other industry is really not fighting for this because they see the writing on the wall. And I think that that's a great question for them. I really don't understand why they are so stubborn. I think it really just comes down to that they don't want to evolve. They view that they have a system that works and they don't want to change it. And when shown that it's actually better for your industry, both from a profit standpoint and better for the animals and better for the workers, they should just move out of this, but they don't want to because they're stubborn.

SPEAKER_01They just don't care. They don't care about the environment, they don't care about workers, they don't care about food safety, they don't care about the pigs. I mean, it's as simple as that.

SPEAKER_00In the states that have successfully passed propositions to make welfare practices better, you mentioned uh New York, California, and I believe Massachusetts were the three. Are there any others that have passed and which states are actually at stake here of losing these propositions and have they tried to fight back knowing what's at stake?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's uh it's a great question. So there's about 12 states, 12, 13 states that have laws that would be nullified. Um well, it really depends, right? Because the farm version right now really only attacks the sales component of these ballot measures. So again, you have two types of laws that the farm animal movement has passed. One is a production ban. So let's say that you lived in Portland, Maine, right? Okay. If Maine passed a law which says that in our state, you cannot confine an animal in a space to stand up, turn around, and extend their limbs.

SPEAKER_01That would be called a production ban. So it would basically say that in our state, you can't do a certain thing. And there's about 12, 13 states that have, whether it's laws that ban that for pigs, veal calves, or egg-laying hens. Not every state bans all of them. Most states have at least one or two that they do ban, if that makes sense.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Now, some states from the ballot measure, but then also some states have gone further to say, well, if I'm going to say you can't do this practice in my state, well, then I'm gonna make sure that you can't just ship things out of state into my state that come from those horrible practices. Right. So that's a sales ban. A production ban says you can't do it in my state, and then a sales ban says you can't bring it into my state from out of state. The Supreme Court has said this is 100% constitutional. A state has a right to protect its food system for food safety, animal welfare, all of these things.

SPEAKER_01The thing that's concerning is that the current version in the House side, this farm bill, because the House version of the farm bill has Save Our Bacon in it, the Senate version doesn't have it. The House bill does and it's passed. The Senate version is a draft bill that has not yet passed and it doesn't include it. But the industry is going to try to shove that language in. What's to stop them from adding a few more words to that to get to not only sales bans but production bans? What's stopping them from including puppy mills and ban on fur? We need to be unbelievably due diligent on the fact that at any moment they can sneak in language that takes out everything.

SPEAKER_01And so we need to treat it like it's the five-alarm fire that it is. Now, if it stays as it is and bans the sales productions and preempts those, that would be devastating to our movement. That is, that alone is a meteor headed towards Earth. Now, if they expand it and try to include more, which I wouldn't put it past this industry or other industries to try to do that, why wouldn't they? It would be like having five meteors headed towards Earth. And so, you know, each one is going to destroy us, but together, it's absolutely the biggest threat that we're facing is a movement.

SPEAKER_01And so you have states like Colorado, in Michigan, in Arizona, in Florida, in Rhode Island, and New York, and California and Massachusetts that all have passed laws that have banned this type of confinement. I mean, think about this, Sherry. I mean, I don't know how much you know about American politics.

SPEAKER_00Um, but probably, yeah. But do tell.

SPEAKER_01I'm sure you're aware that there's a state called Florida, and I guess, and if you had to guess which political way it leans, it would lean very conservative and very red. Now, it was even more red and conservative 20 years ago. Okay. Actually, I will use the exact number. Twenty-four years ago, uh-huh, the state of Florida through the ballot measure on a referendum, the voters passed a ballot measure to ban the extreme confinement of mother pigs. They didn't just ban it 24 years ago and overwhelmingly support it.

SPEAKER_01They put it in the constitution. So mother pigs are protected from extreme confinement in the state of Florida 24 years ago. The next state to do that was Arizona, which again is one of the most conservative states in our country, especially 20 years ago. So this is not a Republican, Democrat, right versus left, blue versus red. Conservative states, Democratic states, all of these states have overwhelmingly passed these. What we're facing is this issue where it is a small special interest group of the pork industry purchasing a couple lawmakers in North Carolina, which is one of the largest hog producing states in Iowa, which is one of the largest hog producing and factory farming states in the country.

SPEAKER_01And that's why I think we're going to be successful because again, Republicans, Democrats, independents, there's so much opposition to this. But again, we have to fight like our lives depend on it because the billions and billions of lives do depend on us making sure that this doesn't pass.

SPEAKER_00You mentioned the divide in the Senate and the House drafts right now. So knowing this, what's the actual status on SOBA as of we're recording this on Friday, July 17th. And so what what's going on in both the House and the Senate right now? And what is the current timeline for the decisions, the action to start happening on the draft?

SPEAKER_01Yep. All right. So where as of July 17th, uh at uh 1037 a.m. Eastern Standard Time. Very exactly where where we currently sit is you have the House of Representatives and you have the Senate that makes up the U.S. Congress. So the House version of the Farm Bill was introduced by the House Agricultural Committee. It was amended. It included the uh the Save Our Bacon Act in it. We fought to try to get stripped out of committee. Unfortunately, we fell short. It then went to the House of Representatives onto the floor for debate and amendments.

SPEAKER_01We tried to do an amendment, unfortunately, it failed to strip the language. Out. It then passed the House. Um, it narrowly passed the House. I mean, it almost didn't pass with the number of votes that it got. I mean, there was a lot of opposition to the House version of the Farm Bill. So the House version of Farm Bill is done. Uh, it includes the Save Our Bacon Act language, which is not great.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01The Senate usually waits for the House to pass a farm bill to then take up the farm bill debate on their side. So there's a Senate Ag Committee. There's a House Ag Committee. The Senate AG Committee has done all the work behind the scenes, and there's been a really big kind of political divide. Like the Republicans and Democrats in the Senate are not working well together. There's really no bipartisanship going into really anything right now in Congress, let alone the Farm Bill. The Farm Bill was released a couple weeks ago out of the Senate AG.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_01And so we have a Senate Farm Bill in the Senate Ag Committee that does not have our Save Our Bacon Act, which is a great thing. Like that we should all be very, very happy about where we're currently sitting.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_01Apparently, and this is again, we don't know, next week, the Senate AG Committee, we hear, could take up the bill to debate and offer amendments. So obviously that's why I'm in DC. And what we're fighting for is to make sure that an amendment that is offered during markup in the committee doesn't get a Save Our Bacon Act language put in. We're feeling pretty good. Um we've pulled one of the bill sponsors off. So Senator Marshall, who's on the committee, he's removed his name. Chuck Schumer, who's the minority leader for the Democrats in New York, he has publicly come out strongly against Save Our Bacon.

SPEAKER_01And there's other, there's dozens of Democrats, and there's other Republicans that are opposed to this as well. So we're hopeful that we get out of the Senate AD Committee with a farm bill that doesn't include Save Our Bacon. So next is markup. Then there's a vote. We don't really know when it's gonna happen. There's a recess in August, they come back in September, but also we have to be weary of November elections are coming around, and it's gonna be a doozy here in the United States. I mean, there's a very good chance that Democrats pick up a ton of seats in the House and probably flip the Senate or flip the House and pick up a ton of seats in the Senate.

SPEAKER_01So there's a lot of unknowns about what the political makeup is gonna be post-November.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So we don't really actually know when the bill's gonna move and we don't know when the actual markup's gonna be. But if it passes out of committee, hopefully without the save or bacon, it will then go to the floor. Now, to add more complication, let's say that the Senate does pass a farm bill before the end of the 119th Congress. Well, you have a Senate version and you have a House version. And they're just they do not look like each other. Those then, if they're passed by their respective chambers, they then go to conference and then select members of the Senate and select members of the House, go into conference committee, they debate, they negotiate, they fight, they then come out with a single package bill, a single farm bill, and then that's taken to the Senate and the House for a vote.

SPEAKER_01And then if it passes both chambers, it's then sent to the president for signature.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01I just don't see on the calendar when we have time. So I'm actually really hopeful. I'm hopeful that we survive, not only because we keep it out of the Senate version, but because there's no farm bill. But as you can imagine, there's a lot of unknowns. I mean, there's a lot of hurdles the farm bill needs to get passed in order for it to happen.

SPEAKER_00Great explanation of how the U.S. bicameral government works. I'm honestly like uh yeah, it's complicated, clearly. It's a mess.

SPEAKER_01I mean, you can add in the complexity of one of the issues that the Senate ad committee is facing right now, not to get too much in the weeds, but I think it really emphasizes just how insane this is, is that the Senate is controlled by the Republicans. So they have the majority and then the Democrats are the minority.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Now you have on each committee, you have the minority and you have the majority. Now, as you can imagine by the names, the majority typically has more seats on that committee.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01The problem is Senate McConnell, Senator McConnell of Kentucky, he's on the Senate Act Committee. But the Senate Act Committee is made up of 12 Republicans and 11 Democrats. He's no longer able to vote. I mean, we don't even know if he's alive, which is insane to that we don't even know if a sitting senator is alive at this current moment. However, that puts it 11-11. So we're in a situation where the majority of the Senate AG Committee doesn't even have a majority vote. I mean, if Senator McConnell pops out of his hospital bed and comes into the Senate tomorrow, probably not tomorrow because it's Saturday, but comes into the Senate office, that's a whole new ballgame.

SPEAKER_01We don't know what's going to happen. So that's where we have to be really, really on top of this because so many different things can happen.

SPEAKER_00But as you mentioned, with the Senate, not all the Republicans on the Agricultural Committee support the safer. That's exactly right, right?

SPEAKER_01All the Democrats are opposed to this. Okay. And then you have select members of the Senate Ag Committee that are, they don't want this. They know it makes them look bad. And then when you get out of the Senate Ag Committee, you have all Democrats that are opposed to this. You have the minority leader that's opposed to this. And then you have senators that are sitting in states that do not have hog production that are like, this is a state's rights issue. We're not I may not agree with Prop 12. I may not agree with the humane treatment of animals, which unfortunately I think some people just don't care.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01They're at least opposed to this because of states' rights. And another added layer to this, one of the biggest issues, on top of the fact that you're stealing states' ability from doing something, which is a state's rights issue, and taking away voter pass laws, which is an issue around democracy. There are over 600 laws that have been identified by Harvard Law School that would be nullified by the current language because it's drafted so poorly. And these are laws around zoonotic diseases.

SPEAKER_01Uh, this is around things like um uh uh livestock and agricultural controls in certain states. Currently, there is a screw worm that's making its way into Texas that is really devastating to the beef industry. And there are laws on the books that require certain testing for you to take animals across state lines for this exact reason for prevention of disease control, and those laws would be nullified. So there are over 600 laws currently that would be knocked out by the Save Our Bacon Act. So you have states' rights, you have an affront to democracy, you have genuine health concerns and food safety issues and disease and prevention controls.

SPEAKER_01And then on top of that, you have the humane treatment of animals. You have so many reasons to oppose the Save Our Bacon Act. And frankly, there's not one credible argument for why it should pass.

SPEAKER_00Well said. Knowing this, then, for the US listeners or even for non-U.S. listeners myself, like myself, is there anything we can do with the timeframe you've established to stop SOBA from passing?

SPEAKER_01Well, what I will say is this is the most important thing that anyone could spend their time on. If you consider yourself an animal advocate or you care about the food system, there is probably nothing you could be working on that is more important in this moment than stopping Safe Ar bacon. It not only represents one of the biggest threats that I think the animal protection movement in the United States has ever faced in the U.S., it also sets a very, very dangerous precedent. Basically, if this passes, what we're doing is we're signaling to all these terrible industries that abuse animals and abuse workers and destroys the environment and destroys our food system that all you got to do is go to Congress, you got to make some political donations, and then you can get a preemption law passed yourself and nullify the laws that hold you accountable in different states.

SPEAKER_01That is a very dangerous precedent. And for your non-US folks, our agricultural policies here in the United States have a huge impact on the agricultural policies in other countries as a part of our trade agreements. Right. A lot of other states, like the European Union, the UK, have passed laws that ban the extreme confinement of farm animals and do things to raise the welfare of animals. In fact, in the EU right now, the EU is really on their trajectory to finally ban and end the cage age for nearly all farm animals, really, really soon.

SPEAKER_01Now, what happens with the imports from the United States? Right? It puts your governments in a very bad position where you have higher welfare food that is coming from your country, and then you have subpar, very low welfare food that's going to try to be imported, and it puts your own agricultural policy and trade agreements at risk. So there's a lot of reasons to oppose this, whether you're an American or if you are living somewhere else. So the question is what can people do? If you live in the United States, you have two U.S. senators. You need to call them and you need to make it clear that you are opposed to the Save Our Bacon Act.

SPEAKER_01All you have to do is Google like U.S. Senate hotline. You will get a number, it's a 202 number. You call that number, you tell them what state you live in, or you give them their zip code, they will connect you with your two U.S. Senate offices. It'll be a wonderful intern or a fellow that is sitting on the phone, and you just say to them, hi, like in my case, hi, my name's Matt. I live in Brooklyn, New York. I'm calling to ask Senator Schumer, Senator Gillibrand to oppose the Save Our Bacon Act and make sure that it's not included in the Farm Bill. Now, in my case, I would be calling Senator Schumer and thanking him for his opposition and making sure he continues to fight, but that's a little bit of a nuance.

SPEAKER_01But realistically, call your senators, ask them to oppose the Save Our Bacon Act, tell them you do not want it in the Farm Bill, and if it is included in the Farm Bill that you want them to vote no, you also want them to make a public statement. Those are the things that you can ask them. And I would call every single day until your Senate office tells you where they stand and that they oppose this bill. These are your elected officials. They represent you in Congress and they have a right to hear from you. Now, you don't want to annoy them and bug them and be harassing them, but I do think it's safe on something that's this important to call every single day.

SPEAKER_01It's also important to post on social media. They do see these posts. And so if you see a post about Save Our Bacon from myself or someone like Leah Garcis or the Humane League or other organizations that are fighting this, share it. Comment on it, send it to your friends and family. Ask your friends and family to call their senators. These are the most important things that you can do today to help ensure that the Save Our Bacon Act is not included in the farm bill and that farm animals get a victory at the end of this Congress.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much, Matt. This was a very sobering episode because of what's going on, but very, very informative. And for myself and everyone else who wasn't fully aware of what was going on with the Save Our Bacon Act, it was really helpful to hear from you and learn about what's going on. And of course, it's because of people like you and the hard work that you do that there is a future where this bill does not exist.

SPEAKER_01I am optimistic that farm animals will win the day. Um, and I will tell you, there are thousands and thousands of people that are working on this, and I'm so proud of our movement to step into this moment. I really do fundamentally believe that in five to ten years from now, the National Pork Producer Council and the folks that are fighting for this are gonna look back and they're gonna realize this was a very stupid mistake because not only did they waste money and time and energy, not only did they lose in Congress and probably lose some of their political power because of this and spend a lot of their political capital.

SPEAKER_01I think they're gonna realize that they woke a sleeping giant. I think that they're gonna realize that they've organized us in a way that we probably would not have organized if it wasn't for this defensive fight. This will end up turning into offense for us, and it will end up giving us political power. It will end up strengthening our movement. So not only do I think we win, I think this is actually a good thing exercise for us, and I think it's gonna make us stronger because of it. And we never know what thing is gonna cross the line of losing to winning. So one phone call could make the difference into one Senate office that flips their vote or whatever that is.

SPEAKER_01So, people that are listening, I know that there's a lot of great people and a lot of great organizations that are fighting on this, but this fight needs more people. We need every single person to take action.

SPEAKER_00That's it for this episode of Fork the System. If you have a guest or topic you'd like to hear about, share your ideas using the feedback form linked below. Until next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Janet Enosi on the role of technology in sustainable African aquaculture

    Nov 17, 202621 minAudio

    Our twentieth guest is Janet Enosi. Janet is currently a Master's in Aquaculture student at the University of Highlands and Islands, the University of Crete, and the University of Nante. She’s passionate about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Caroline Cotto on why taste is plant-based's defining problem

    Oct 13, 202630 minAudio

    Our nineteenth guest is Caroline Cotto, a Director at Food System Innovations who oversees NECTAR, an initiative accelerating the alternative protein transition through taste. Her commitment to saying “yes” has led her...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Monica Chen on building passionate youth leaders in food

    Sep 8, 202630 minAudio

    Our eighteenth guest is Monica Chen, the Executive Director of the New Roots Institute. New Roots educates high school and college students on the devastating impacts of factory farming and supports them as they become...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Renan Danielski on using sugar beets for cellular agriculture

    Jul 14, 202634 minAudio

    Our sixteenth guest is Dr. Renan Danielski, a New Harvest Postdoctoral Fellow at Lethbridge Polytechnic’s Advanced Post-Harvest Technology Centre, specializing in the upcycling of agricultural co-products into...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Margrethe Aanesen on the future of the Norwegian aquaculture sector

    Jun 9, 202628 minAudio

    Our fifteenth guest is Margrethe Aanesen, a Senior Researcher at SNF - Centre for Applied Research at the Norwegian School of Economics in Bergen. Her work focuses on the management of marine ecosystem services and the...

    Credit the people on this episode