Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Footnotes2Plato Podcast

Footnotes2Plato Podcast artwork

Skepticism and Spiritual Science in an Unfinished World: An Anthroposophical Chat w/ Ishmael Hodges

Sep 5, 20262 hr 17 minAudio

I was sitting in a hotel room in Denver’s River North Arts District earlier this evening for my live chat with Ishmael, with the window behind me facing east, away from the Rocky Mountains. It was an appropriate orientation for a conversation about Rudolf Steiner. The mountains were hidden on the west side of the hotel building, though at sunset their shadows were projected into the atmosphere along the eastern horizon. Something real can shape what appears without itself appearing directly. We both laughed nervously when I joked that things were bound to get weird. Before getting to Steiner, Ishmael asked me to guess his Sun sign. I guessed Aquarius immediately, then lost my nerve and added Scorpio and Capricorn as alternate possibilities. He’s an Aquarius. So am I. It was a playful way into the epistemological problem that would occupy us for the next two hours. What exactly are we doing when we entertain something like astrology? I don’t feel any need to insist that my correct guess of Ishmael’s Zodiac sign proves that celestial bodies transmit occult influences shaping personality. I am suspicious of that kind of deterministic certainty, whether it stems from astrology or, in a different way, from the mechanistic mindset of scientific materialism. But I also don’t think intellectual seriousness requires pretending that symbolic practices are worthless unless they can be translated into conventional causal mechanisms. Astrology has been useful to me as a symbolic mirror. It has helped me think about my biography, relationships, and historical events. Perhaps some of that is projection. Perhaps all of it is. But when it comes to cultural and historical interpretation, narrative identity construction, working through romantic intensities and familial conflicts, projection may be unavoidable. The more interesting question is whether psyche and cosmos are as separable as modernity has taught us to suppose. Whatever the epistemic and ontological status of horoscope astrology, I’m convinced the old hermits had it right, after all: as above, so below. My attraction to Steiner has never depended on believing everything he said. What first mattered to me was the way Steiner made it possible to entertain the hypothesis that the modern picture of reality - the picture according to which human consciousness is a late arising accident trapped inside an otherwise meaningless machine - might not be the inevitable conclusion of scientific knowledge. This possibility arrived at an important time in my life. I encountered anthroposophy in my early twenties, when I was already moving through Nietzsche, Jung, Alan Watts, comparative religion, German philosophy, and various attempts to escape the narrow materialism that had shaped my earlier understanding of the world. Robert McDermott introduced me to Steiner at CIIS. Here’s Robert and I giving a talk on Steiner’s worldview pluralism back in 2019: Unfortunately, or perhaps appropriately, my earliest exposure included some of the strangest material anthroposophy has to offer: elaborate Christological narratives about two Jesus children, reincarnation of Zarathustra’s I, and the role of Buddha’s Nirmanakaya. My initial response wasn’t reverence. It was something more like cognitive shock.What the hell am I supposed to do with this? That reaction has always remained with me. I feel it should continue to. What first allowed me to enter Steiner’s world was not his clairvoyant re-reading of the Gospels. It was The Philosophy of Freedom. That book did something much subtler. Instead of asking me to believe in angels or previous planetary incarnations of the Earth, Steiner asked me to notice what I was doing while thinking. He redirected attention from the products of my thought and objects of my perception to my own thinking itself, which I immediately recognized to be a spiritual activity unconditioned by anything else. Here are my opening remarks at a session of a reading group on Steiner’s Philosophy of Freedom from 2023: Most of our experience arrives in our consciousness already divided into a subject over here looking at objects over there. But subject and object are both already conceptual determinations. They are not the thinking thinker but what is thought about. When attention turns toward thinking in the act, something peculiar happens. I am no longer simply confronting something given to me. The activity I am observing is also the activity by which I observe. Steiner called this an “exceptional state.” Thinking becomes, for a moment, transparent to itself. This is how Steiner first grabbed my attention. I had already encountered the Cartesian cogito, but Steiner’s move felt different from Descartes’. Descartes uses the certainty of thinking to then establish a mental substance set over against a material extended substance. Steiner treats thinking instead as an activity the cultivation of which can help us begin to dissolve the apparent wall between mind and matter. Contra Descartes, thinking activity is not a private interior doubter isolated from an external world, forced to reconstruct a passable imaginary representation of it. Thinking is not a retreat from or onlooker’s gaze upon reality, but our most potent means of participation in it. Whitehead gave me another language for this. There are no self-contained substances that subsequently enter into relations. Actuality is relational all the way down. Experience is not something mysteriously added to an already constituted material world. The world is constituted through acts of feeling, inheritance, integration, and creative advance. What Steiner taught me epistemologically and phenomenologically, Whitehead helped me articulate ontologically. This is why anthroposophy gradually became less for me a collection of extraordinary claims and more a methodological provocation. What happens if human consciousness is not a spectator accidentally produced by aimless matter but one of the ways nature becomes conscious of itself? What does natural science become, in that case? Ishmael and I spent a long time on this question. Neither of us wanted to denigrate the scientific method. Quite the contrary. One of the great achievements of modern science has been its disciplined attempt to compensate for human wishful thinking. Replication, measurement, experimental controls, and mathematical formalization allow us to discover otherwise unexpected patterns in nature. The trouble begins when this extraordinarily powerful method quietly hardens into a metaphysics. Science discovers a great deal by pretending, methodologically, that the observer is not part of the system under observation. But it does not follow that reality itself is what remains when human observers (with all their subjective values, qualities, purposes, and meanings) have been subtracted from it. Science never operates in a vacuum. Someone decides what questions deserve investigation. Someone funds the laboratories. Military institutions have purposes. Corporations have purposes. Governments have purposes. Scientists themselves have hopes, aesthetic preferences, political commitments, metaphysical intuitions, rivalries, careers. We can bracket value methodologically. But we cannot sustain a viable cultural life without value. This is where Steiner’s spiritual science continues to provoke me. I do not think the answer is to abandon experimental rigor for private revelation. The question is whether empiricism itself can be enlarged. Goethe was indispensable for Steiner here. Goethe’s “delicate empiricism” sought to attend to phenomena without immediately forcing them into the conceptual machinery of mechanistic explanation. An organism is not merely an arrangement of parts occupying positions in space. It is a temporal achievement, a self-transforming pattern, a melody of development. To know a plant, one must learn to perceive its metamorphosis. Steiner radicalized that Goethean wager by proposing that cognition itself coul… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit footnotes2plato.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01We'll begin in a second, Ishmael, but I just have to guess your sun sign because you were curious. So I'm not a professional astrologer, and a few caveats before I try to guess. You know, the theosophists—and this will be relevant to our conversation about anthroposophy because Rural Steiner kind of comes out of theosophy— They kind of popularized horoscope astrology again in the early 20th century,

SPEAKER_01and newspapers started publishing, you know, if you're this sign, you should expect this to happen over the next week or whatever. But only focusing on your sun sign is a very egocentric way of doing astrology because there's all this other stuff going on in a natal chart. Who you are and all the complexities of your personality is going to involve way more than just the sign that your sun is in. That's sort of like your egocentric point of orientation in the world,

SPEAKER_01and it leaves out your ascendant and your moon sign and where all the other planets are and the aspects those planets form, which is kind of like the conversations these different archetypes are having with each other. So I'm not Especially adept at guessing people's sun signs. I have met people who can do it based on the shape, the physiognomy of people's faces. I've seen, there's at least two people I know who can do this reliably. 80% of the time.

SPEAKER_01I don't know what to do with that information. Okay. Because I'm not a professional, I'm hoping you'll give me a one in four chance. And so I'll share three signs that I've I'm an Aquarius. I have four planets in Aquarius. So you shared this note on Sostack about if you were the type of person

SPEAKER_01who would refuse to be identified, have your Sun sign identified because you're worried it would kind of reduce your personality, and they'd have some preconception of you that you would feel would be unfair, what sign would astrologers imagine Someone like that would have. Initially, I thought Aquarius, but I'm an Aquarius, so I might be projecting. Aquarians like to be different. But then I thought, maybe you're a Scorpio, because you're kind of trying to hide the depths of who you are.

SPEAKER_01And your name's Ishmael, and I thought of Moby Dick, and if you're familiar with that book. Ishmael's like, you can call me Ishmael, but the critics are always unclear. Who is Ishmael? That's kind of the Scorpio depth, like the hiddenness. But then I thought the skeptic in you might be a Capricorn, might be related to Capricorn. So I took three guesses. They could all be wrong, but I know I'm giving myself an extra opportunity by naming three.

SPEAKER_01One in four chance, I guessed right, but

SPEAKER_00You didn't need three. Oh, really? It was the first one? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Well, we're both Aquarians then, so

SPEAKER_00that's great. February 12th.

SPEAKER_01Awesome. Well, that was my first guess. And then the other two were second guesses, like, oh, maybe not. I should have stuck with my gut and just said, you're definitely an Aquarius. So there you go.

SPEAKER_00I got a rebrand now. It's all over. We're going woo, baby. No. Well, some people will consider this conversation a move in that direction, but whatever. They'll be okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It was Berger Crisis who asked for this, and he's very pleased in the live chat, I see.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And you got it right. It is a weird one, too, because it's like I've always had a little bit of a I've always been a little torn on that whole thing. Because, you know, coming sort of from the, well, I was very much on the, you know, initially the religious believer side of things. And then I was into, I was hardcore into the conspiracy theorism side of things for a decent period. And during that conspiracy theorism time, I was very much on the sort of the new age side of it.

SPEAKER_00But the horoscopes and astrology, like it was always something that was a little Odd to me because I and I'm aware now of sort of the skeptical argument against it and sort of tying tying it to things like cold reading, things like that. So like I and this is honestly this is where I land with a lot of these sort of different topics, whether it has to do with like high strangeness or miracles, you know, where it's like.

SPEAKER_00I know the skeptical sort of answers, and I think that they're probably, oftentimes, I think the skeptic is coming up with explanations that are more likely. But there's always this nugget of stuff that is, it just seems a little too accurate sometimes to be just chance. So it's, It's always this sort of weird balancing act in my head where I'm like,

SPEAKER_00you know, because it's that whole like keep your mind open but not so much your brain falls out type of a thing. So it's like, I don't know, it's always hard to navigate. I've gotten to the point now where I'm like, I don't, in particular, whether it comes to astrology, tarot, things like that, like I don't really understand conceptually how it would be a real thing that worked, but it doesn't mean that there's nothing to it. You know what I mean? My particular level of understanding of it doesn't necessarily say much about it.

SPEAKER_00These things aren't sort of created equal in my head. Like I mentioned UFOs, abductions, this kind of thing. I'm pretty convinced on that topic that there's a there there. I'm not sure what it is, but... It seems like there's more there than can just be dismissed by all these sort of stereotypical, skeptical explanations that they try to give.

SPEAKER_01There's a there there with astrology, and I have no doubt about that. It's just a question of is this just a matter of psychological projection and more or less like we're in this Jungian Hall of Mirrors where all we can do is relate to each other. In terms of our own psychological conditioning and astrology provides a really potent language for talking about that. Or is this some deeper metaphysical cosmic thing where our own consciousness is like

SPEAKER_01a tuning fork receiving frequencies from these planetary spheres? I have some openness to exploring that possibility also. But whatever it is, even if it's all just projection, I have found it to be insightful in a very pragmatic way for understanding myself, my own biography. I don't use it for predictions. Some people are really good horror-y astrologers.

SPEAKER_01They make predictions, and I've been impressed. But personally, I look at it as a way of interpreting my past, a way of interpreting history, and... It's really helpful for, there's something called synastry, which is looking at relationships with friends or lovers or parents or whoever. And I've also found that to be at least a helpful mirror to project onto, to talk about my family system or failed relationships or new relationships.

SPEAKER_01And it's just a way of getting to know yourself. So it's a symbolic mirror. And that's enough for me. If it does have some metaphysical or cosmological truth, okay, let's explore that. I'm not committed to that, but it's just a psychological language, regardless of whether it's true or not.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think because I try to kind of hold all these things at once as much as I'm able to, at least. And I think that for me is, you know, I don't really put a lot of labels on myself, but I've realized that I think I'm essentially a pragmatist. And so I think it really just depends on like, like we're talking about it now, it just sort of depends on like how the person is sort of framing it, whether that be a discussion about religion or whether that be Something like this.

SPEAKER_00You know, if the person is sort of coming on really hard and really forcefully and making these really like strong ontological sort of assertions saying, well, no, this is literally true. And here's how it works. And here's, you know, like this very sort of forceful of the idea. I think at that point, that's when my sort of skeptical side wants to sort of kick in a bit more and be like, all right, you're really exhibiting like a lot of confidence here. I would kind of like to see something pretty substantial to back that up. But at the same time,

SPEAKER_00and this comes up a lot because I've, you know, I talked to a lot of religious people. It's like, I think it's a real mistake, whether you're coming from skepticism or like the new atheism side of things or something like that, to just sort of project this very, like sometimes sort of hostile or nasty spirited attitude Towards people who just because you find

SPEAKER_01out that, oh, they're a Christian or they're, you know, religious in some way or another, or they believe in

SPEAKER_00astrology or, you know, I think there's this reflexive, really sort of nasty dismissive reaction. And I don't think that's really warranted. Like, I won't I won't preclude that it might not become apparent that that sort of reaction might be appropriate. So I'm not saying for like my skeptic friends out there that like, oh no, you just have to like keep your mind open to all these things. It's like, no, but I think we do each other a disservice when we sort of just show up to the conversation,

SPEAKER_00presuming, and I'm more familiar with it in a religious context now, like just presuming like, oh, you say you're a Christian. And so you believe this, this, this, this, and this, you know, you believe in the literal, you know, and we, I think oftentimes, and I've been super guilty of this. Um, like for the longest time, because I was, we talked a little bit before on air, like I, I grew up as a fundamentalist Christian, like a fundamental, independent, fundamental Baptist Christian, um, up north. Um, you know, and once I left that, um, you know, that was what I needed to do.

SPEAKER_00But that way of thinking was still how like Christianity was represented in my head. And so then when I would encounter, encounter other Christians, I would essentially be like arguing against my own demons in a way where I would be arguing against this sort of horrible specter of Christianity that had had like a really bad impact on my life. And sometimes the person you're talking to does turn out to be like a literalist fundamentalist with a bunch of ideas that I frankly consider to be really abhorrent.

SPEAKER_00But oftentimes they're not. Like Christianity is such a broad... Rich tradition with so many different ways of approaching it. And I think whether it's as skeptics or as atheists, we can really like sort of just right up front, screw ourselves out of having productive conversations with people that very likely might have much more in common with us than we would imagine. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I mean, a teacher of mine, Richard Tarnas, who's a cultural historian, philosopher and astrologer, He says, skepticism is the chastity of the intellect. We should value it very highly. But we also have to be skeptical of skepticism, because if the nature of reality in any way involves us, in other words, if there's a participatory structure to the nature of existence,

SPEAKER_01then the attitude we take towards it is going to shape How we perceive it and shape our experience at such a basic level that we're going to blind ourselves, potentially. If we're not skeptical of our own skepticism, we're going to blind ourselves to possibilities that would otherwise become apparent to us if we just had a more open mind. There are aspects of reality that require our consent and assent and credulity

SPEAKER_01to reveal themselves. And so, yeah, seeing is believing, but Believing is also seeing. If you open yourself and you say, okay, maybe this is true, let me have a look under the assumption that there might be something there, all of a sudden it appears to you. Whereas if you're just a skeptic who's shitting on any possibilities other than what you assume to be the mundane truth, you're desensitizing yourself to what you might otherwise see.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And also with people who are fundamentalist Christians or fundamentalist Muslims or whatever form of fundamentalist, fundamentalist flat earthers or whatever it may be, there's a kind of trauma which has occurred in that person, I think. And we can still be empathic. We can still feel sympathy for someone who's been raised into... A community,

SPEAKER_01their parents and the church community they were part of, from the time they were a very young age, told them like, hey, if you don't believe what we tell you, you're going to burn in hell forever. Telling that to a child is going to deform their sense of self and shrink their world. And it's child abuse. And those people grew up with spiritual trauma. And so I feel like if we are Compassionate people, when we encounter someone who believes that kind of a simplistic story

SPEAKER_01about reality, maybe it's not best to argue with them about it. Maybe there's another approach we could take to surface what's behind those beliefs. Why do they feel like they need to assert this with such certainty? Are they really sure? What sort of fears are motivating people? Those dogmatic beliefs about themselves in the world because we could debate all day and feel intellectually superior, but at the end of the day,

SPEAKER_01if we're going to move this collective conversation forward, if we're going to have a healthy culture, it's because we're going to meet traumatized people with compassion instead of scorn and one-upmanship and I'm going to slaughter you in a debate right now.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think there can be a place for sort of formal debate, but I don't think it's very helpful, particularly in like one-on-one conversations. Because that's the other thing, I think, too, as having been raised, you know, a fundamentalist Christian, and you mentioned about the telling kids about the health thing. You know, I was four years old the first time. I got saved, as we say it. And that was the age at which the hell thing was first laid on me.

SPEAKER_00And so the other thing, though, I think that people don't realize is that that sort of kind of high control religion, it knows that it's going to have people that come against it. And so they're pretty prepared for People coming at them aggressively and they have sort of sometimes like Bible verses that they sort of they've got they've always got in their back pocket.

SPEAKER_01Um, to sort of shoot down any questions

SPEAKER_00to the way, you know, or I can say we, cause I was, you know, part of it for so long that we used to do things, you know? So when, when people might bring up some sort of a logical issue, you know, you would just pull out the verse about, you know, the, you know, the ways of God will seem as foolishness to those who don't believe or God's ways are not man ways. You know, there's, there's this sort of immune system almost that's like built into that type of religion. Um, And so, you know, as you said, if you really kind of come in hard in what to me, I think is a very egocentric way.

SPEAKER_00Um, yeah, the person is just going to shut down like that, that immune system, that sort of spiritual, or maybe it's not even spiritual, you know, that sort of dogmatic.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, dogmatic immune system is going to sort of kick in the minute you just kind of show up with a big splash. And then that's why you end up with these arguments where both people come away from it. And I've seen it in these arguments between atheists and theists sometimes. And you'll see it in the comment section sometimes if it's something that was recorded where it's like, You've got you've got the fans of both sides in the comments being like, oh, man, that was so crazy. You know, like William Legg absolutely William Lane Craig absolutely schooled Sam Harris.

SPEAKER_00And and then at the time I'm sitting there going like, what fucking conversation were you listening to? You know what I mean? But but based on how they approach things that both sides are like, yeah, my guy's killing it, you know, and I. Like I said, I never want to go so far as to say those things don't have any purpose, but I really am doubtful at this point as to how effective they really

SPEAKER_01are. When I was in undergrad, I remember sitting by the fountain in the main quad and the Campus Crusaders for Christ came over to talk to me. There's this immune system thing, right? And I was... I was 19 and I was already reading. I had read this book recently at the time when I was 19 by Alan Watts called Beyond Theology, The Art of Godmanship, I believe is the subtitle. And it's all about, it's kind of him giving a non-dual reading of Christianity from like his study of

SPEAKER_01the Vedas and the Bhagavad Gita and the Upanishads and this kind of Hindu understanding of spirituality that, you know, The whole world is God in drag. And so he reads Christianity in that light. And so I was just tuned in to mysticism and non-dualism. And rather than debating these campus crusaders, I started talking about St. Augustine and Gregory of Nyssa and Maximus the Confessor and Meister

SPEAKER_01Eckhart and the experience that one can have of unity with the Godhead. And how, you know, I just asked them the question instead of engaging them in debate. I was like, what if, you know, when Jesus says, like, is it not written, yea, all are gods? And what if we are, in a sense, participants in the divine life? And, you know, we're not all a bunch of sinners, but actually, you know, God loves us. And that means, like, we are members of the body of God.

SPEAKER_01And I'm trying to repeat to them what I understand to be their own religion. And the immune system wasn't activated. It was kind of like a Trojan horse approach. So I slid through the immune system, but then I was talking their language, kind of, in a mystical register, and they were confused. And they just sort of slowly backed away and said, see ya. And I don't know what the effect of that was on them. At the time, I thought I was really clever. Yeah. Maybe they just went back to having the immune system close in,

SPEAKER_01but maybe that planted some seeds.

SPEAKER_00Oh, it's very possible. That's the thing you don't realize is there's a good chance that you won't, like if you're interacting with one of those people, and that would be how, in a one-on-one, definitely, that would be how I think I would try to interact with somebody now, would be mainly just to ask questions, ask them, why do you think that? Let them actually talk. But the thing is, even if you sort of get something in there that really unsettles them in some way,

SPEAKER_00because it happened to me, they're going to have their initial reaction. You're very unlikely for them to stop and sort of give it to you and be like, oh, you know, yeah, that's a really good point. They're probably just going to regurgitate something, you know what I mean? Or they might do some sort of... The non-present appeal to authority, like, oh, well,

SPEAKER_01I'll have to ask my pastor about that, or something along those lines.

SPEAKER_00They did say that, actually. Yeah. Yeah. So there'll be this deference, which you do see not uncommonly. I've had conversations with people about that before. I've had conversations with people about that before, where... They sort of will be like, oh, well, you know, I don't know the answers to these questions, but, you know, I'm sure my, you know, someone, some sort of spiritual authority in their life does. And I'm like, okay, well, you know, we'll ask him in the back of my head.

SPEAKER_00I'm like, he doesn't know either. Like, I'm pretty certain, you know, he doesn't know either. But yeah, it's definitely, yeah, I mean. I always hold that space open. And, you know, this is something that is particularly with a lot of this like sort of Christian nationalism sort of BS that's happening in the US now. Not that it's a new development, but it definitely has sort of taken off a bit that like I'll always hold. I wrote an article about that the other day. About, you know, whether whether new atheism sort of as an attitude should die.

SPEAKER_00And I sort of came to the conclusion that, like, I really don't think that that's sort of what what people associate with the new atheism movement of this very contentious, very combative attitude. I don't really think that's the way anymore. I think that it can wind up shooting us in the foot if we hold that as sort of our default attitude. And I very much think that we need to have a default of compassion. But I don't think that also though, I don't think that precludes us from, um, like, as I said, I said, it was like, uh, you know, coming to the field with great rhetorical force.

SPEAKER_00If the situation actually calls for it, if you do have like an actual genuine Christian and

SPEAKER_01Christian nationalist

SPEAKER_00type of organization that's trying to exert undue force. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I mean, I, I think that, um, fundamentalist Christianity and new atheism are are both symptoms of a spiritual trauma, actually. The kind of new atheism that is aggressive, like debate bro energy, I think it's still an obsession with God the Father. And it's an adolescent rebelliousness from God the Father. That's all new atheism is as far as I can tell.

SPEAKER_01And so it's the same trauma. It's just a fuck you to it. I hate the fact that God might exist instead of maybe there's another way of imagining the divine. There's a way in which what is needed in this moment is a kind of collective healing, a cultural reconciliation.

SPEAKER_01So that we can recognize that these two responses, the two extremes of fundamentalist theism and fundamentalist atheism, are hurting from the same wound, and that wound is modern freedom and individuality, which is a relatively new phenomenon, a few hundred years old. And feeling alone in the universe is what has led To modern fundamentalism of

SPEAKER_01the Christian sort, just as much as it's led to this secular form of disenchantment and the sense that the human being is just, and maybe we can start to transition here to anthroposophy a little bit. Yeah. A stranger in a strange world and that we don't belong here and this universe doesn't care about us and there is no purpose to life ultimately

SPEAKER_01than the one you might make up and good for you if you can make up some meaning for yourself but ultimately you're gonna die and rot in the grave and it's as if you never existed and you know we're just here to like experience pleasure and you know maybe Create a legacy for ourselves that will allow us to be remembered a little bit longer, but then the sun's going to explode and wipe away everything, so who cares? That's the modern scientific materialist picture.

SPEAKER_01And I think fundamentalists, because I think Christianity did a lot of bad things for thousands of years as an institutionalized religion, but... It wasn't until the modern period that this sort of fundamentalist attitude and biblical literalism and all that was really born. There was a lot more to the Christian worldview than what it became the last few hundred years. Fundamentalism, just as like atheism,

SPEAKER_01is a response to this modern trauma of feeling like we're just sensitive creatures trapped in a giant machine. And constantly at risk of being crushed by the gears. And what has drawn me to Rudolf Steiner and anthroposophy is the sense that maybe that's not true. Maybe actually scientifically and experientially and psychologically, that's not true.

SPEAKER_01Maybe there's a way of understanding modern physics and And biology and psychology and sociology in a fully scientifically adequate way that suggests a different interpretation of what human beings are and what the universe is. And Steiner has provided me with a way of taking that possibility seriously. He says a lot of weird things that I can't claim to be capable of verifying,

SPEAKER_01but he also I think develops a method and sort of opens a pathway forward for scientifically informed, intelligent, modern human beings to reengage with spiritual stuff. Seriously, as though there is such a thing as spiritual reality. And we're not just lumbering robots driven by our selfish genes trying to make copies of ourselves.

SPEAKER_01That's a myth. And rather than pretend like new atheists often do and scientific materialists often do that, you know, we need to grow out of myth and just be rational and scientific. I don't think we can escape myth.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, because it's still a story. That's the thing. And I think we're

SPEAKER_01always telling stories.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that is what bothers me. And I always try to be careful because I've got friends pretty much in every one of these, just about every one of these major ways of thinking, idealism, physicalism, panpsychism. I don't know if I have any dualist friends. There's a dualist friend slot open. No, just kidding. There's not. No, I'm kidding. Um, no fucking duelist. It's like that, like that moment from, uh, what was that movie?

SPEAKER_00Sideways or like, they're trying to go to the wine tasting. He's like, all right, I'll go. And I'm not drinking any fucking Merlot. Um, but so it's like, I never, I always want to represent sort of people's ideas accurately, but I will say particularly for, and I do, I do like that you said materialist because,

SPEAKER_01um, And I do want to stick with Steiner.

SPEAKER_00So maybe we can start. And here in a second, you can give us a little bit of background on him and where he sort of fits in maybe the landscape of sort of different views that people might be more familiar with. But I feel like sort of metaphysically, a lot of physicalists, they're really sort of metaphysically minimalist in a way. This sort of like a Neil Seth guy Like closer to, I guess,

SPEAKER_00to it's more method focused where they're not really making an overt claim about metaphysical reality. They're just sort of like, well, we're kind of sticking with the method. We're only going to like, we're going to contain ourselves to what this method that's done so good for us has done. But if you're talking about like this sort of more old school materialism, um, I think I really totally agree with you. And I think the thing that bothers me is,

SPEAKER_00I think some of these other views are more in touch with the fact that they are, that doesn't mean they don't take their view seriously, but they're more in touch with the fact that there's a very sort of a narrative element to their view and what it is they're doing. And the thing that bothers me a lot with both, like I said, I see it all the time in the skeptic community, In this sort of, you know, more science, whatever you want to call it, science-based community. I always hate to say that because I'm a huge fan of science and I'm never trying to,

SPEAKER_00like, you know, take the piss out of the sails of how amazing science is at all. But the thing that bothers me is it seems like a lot of those people have gotten to this place where they... They're sort of completely ignoring the hand that they're having in developing their own views where they're like, well, I just care about as evidence and reason and all these other kind of things.

SPEAKER_00And they end up talking about those things, about reason in particular, in a very sort of religious way where it's like, You'll hear these terms like, oh, it's like the conclusion a perfectly rational agent would arrive at or something along these lines. And I don't even know what that means. You know what I mean? It's like rational according to who? You know what I mean? And usually this perfectly rational agent that they propose just so happens to agree

SPEAKER_00with all of their views on everything. And it's tough because it's like, and I think we'll get into that because It's sort of conceptually we touched on a bit when we talked about Whitehead. But you have from this sort of more materialist and even physicalist type of view, And I think I understand where the desire comes from, this desire to try to remove ourselves. And to me, that's a lot of what science really is. The method and arguably why it's been so successful in its relevant domains is

SPEAKER_00because it has this understanding of human beings that we can fall into things like wishful thinking. And so that we want to, you know, that's sort of the power of the method is that in requiring things to be replicated, The hope is that it allows the bias of, say, the individual researchers and such to sort of get washed out, hopefully, as something gets repeated more and more often, then you're able to hopefully eliminate,

SPEAKER_00you know, maybe fingers that were on the scale to make experiments and such come out to certain conclusions. But it's a very because of that, it ends up it ends up in this incredibly detached place. And so in sort of trying to locate the human being and in particular to locate the human mind, it ends up in this position where it's doing its best to adopt this third person view,

SPEAKER_00which I think is a noble goal, but it always seems to run afoul of not understanding that you really can't truly do that. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Right. Which is why the scientific method is so valuable. Because when we pretend as if we were not part of the universe, and we just try to measure what happens when we're not looking as it were, as if we could observe without disturbing, we learn a lot. But the thing is, when you, like, you know, Anil Zeth, really, I think, he strikes me as an honest researcher who's in pursuit of a deeper understanding

SPEAKER_01of reality. I've read his book, Being You. Yeah, it's a good book. He's more sort of fair-minded about alternative positions to his own more or less physicalist orientation, but he's emphasizing the method of science. And the thing is, you can bracket metaphysics, you can bracket metaphysics, Axiology, which is sort of deeper than just ethics. It's like, what's the source of value in the universe? You could bracket all that stuff and just have the scientific method and see what appears to you when you pretend that you're not part

SPEAKER_01of what you're observing. But look at the 20th century. The scientific method, as just a method, has given us the standard model of particle physics. It's fucking brilliant. It's given us atom bombs as well. And so there's this kind of moral neutrality, value neutrality. Let's just do the scientific method. I don't think we're gonna survive much longer as a species if we just keep doing the scientific method, because what happens is, who's funding all of this objective science?

SPEAKER_01Military interests? Corporate interests? They have values. The Pentagon's top priority is to defeat the enemy. If they're not sure who the enemy is, they're gonna create one. That's their goal. And they're gonna fund science that helps them kill people that they deem to be the enemies. Great. Corporations on the planet Earth right now, in our global capitalist society, their value is profit. Extract as much energy from The earth as you can and extract as much labor value

SPEAKER_01from human beings as you can, turn in a profit for some shareholders, done deal. Science is invested in nowadays. Basic research and tinkering around the edges is invested in by big corporations and militaries. And so those values are what are driving the scientific method. So a really valuable method for arriving in a kind of truth that is Not just our own projection and wishful thinking and everything, but if we don't have a deeper metaphysical sense of who we are as human beings

SPEAKER_01and what we're supposed to be doing in this universe, on this planet, then we're going to continue creating weapons of mass destruction, and we're going to continue allowing corporations to tell science what to research. And I don't think anybody really wants that. And so I think we need to do better than just, oh, I follow the scientific method. Well, what is science? How is it possible that human beings could have this type of knowledge of the universe?

SPEAKER_01And what happens when we stop pretending as if we're not part of the universe and recognize that whatever human consciousness is, which includes our thinking activity, our feeling capacities, and our thinking, feeling, and willing, very important for Rudolf Steiner, We're a part of this world, and somehow this world has generated thinking, feeling, willing creatures, organisms like us. And what begins to become apparent when you pay attention to your own thinking,

SPEAKER_01feeling, and willing, according to Steiner and according to me, I guess, because I have followed through in this exercise of paying attention to thinking, feeling, and willing, it begins to dawn on you that the world The cosmos is kind of unfinished. And we have a role to play in bringing it to completion. And it's not like there's any simple prescription here as to what we're supposed

SPEAKER_01to make or build in this world. We have to figure that out together. What draws me to anthroposophy is this view that Steiner has that the world is incomplete because each of us as individuals has something to contribute uniquely that only we can, like that I can, that you can. And whatever this universe is, it's not just a bunch of atoms banging into themselves. It's actually a process of divine awakening and we have an important role to play

SPEAKER_01in helping God, or the universe if you prefer, learn more about itself. And what's driving science with that kind of an imaginative background or cosmological context is the desire to learn, and even deeper, God learning about God's self. And so this whole conflict between science and religion is a bit of It's a trauma response.

SPEAKER_01It's a division at the heart of what it is to be a human being, as if we could live without a sense of cosmic purpose. It's not enough for us to feel like, oh yeah, we can make up our meaning and that's like, whatever. I know I'm going to die one day and it'll all be for naught. That doesn't actually function. We can't actually function psychologically like that. We need a deep cosmic purpose, such as what religion provides us with. But we also, we want to know for ourselves. We have this We have scientific attitude and we have our senses and we want to observe and test and not just be told what's true.

SPEAKER_01So we have science, we have religion, we have art, these modes of expressing our feeling and rather than like competing over, oh no, it's science that's the best and we should just be scientific. Or like, no, no, we got a hold of these religious truths that we've had for thousands of years and ignore the temptation of worldly wisdom and science because that's just going to confuse us. We have the revelation. It's like, no, I feel like what we're in desperate need of,

SPEAKER_01and it's not just anthroposophy that provides this. There are different ways that we can reconcile these two sides of ourselves. But that's the challenge we're faced with right now, I think, is reconciling them. And getting over the need or the delusion that reason might win out over emotion or passion or belief or story and myth. Rationality only functions when it is coherently sort of ensconced within healthy stories.

SPEAKER_01Like science, scientific investigation, If it's situated within a healthy story that's believable, that we can make life better for human beings, it will function well. If it's situated in a story of, well, the planet's only so big, and there's a bunch of nations who are fighting with each other over whatever scraps are left among the natural resources here, then we better use our national industry and technoscience

SPEAKER_01to Beat those other countries out at getting access to those resources. If that's the story, then the scientific method, we got a few decades left, maybe if we're lucky, and then we're gonna destroy ourselves. So what story are we telling ourselves? That's not just extra sort of metaphysical extravagance that only... Woo-woo people should talk about. That's actually at the core of making sure our civilization can survive the next decades.

SPEAKER_01Science has a role to play in human civilization, obviously, but if it's undirected by a deeper spiritual compass and cosmological orientation, it's a death sentence.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that there can be, as we've been talking about, none of the scientific... No scientific inquiry happens in a vacuum. Because, you know, I remember when I was a kid, you know, and you go to your, you know, you have science class and things like this. There's this sort of like, you think about scientists and the sort of the project of science is this like, oh, they, like they figured this out or

SPEAKER_01they figured that out.

SPEAKER_00And when I was really young, I had this, I had this idea as a kid and it was very naive. But you're like, Oh, all these different questions, all these sort of scientific questions. You almost have this idea that like, oh, there's a scientist that's assigned to like all the different, you know, possible questions. And it's like, as you pointed out, you know, obviously you've got Oftentimes, when it comes to funding, you've got these sort of big levers of power that very much, like you said,

SPEAKER_00we can even be accurate in saying that, like, oh, maybe the method itself doesn't have a narrative attached to it. But those funding it absolutely do have a narrative that they're sort of trying to carry out. But you just also have, you also have this element where even aside from sort of big, big, you know, powerful entities with these like really overt, maybe even, you know, not always malevolent. I think there's good money that goes into science to try to make life better for people.

SPEAKER_00You know, so that's the case as well. But I think there's a deeper level where, um, People cannot realize the impact that just sort of basic philosophy and maybe even things like sort of basic metaphysics do come into play because there's such a degree to which I think what's sort of going on under the hood for us when we're trying to engage in any sort of scientific inquiry is affected.

SPEAKER_00It shows up in what questions, the sort of questions that we think it makes sense to ask. And there's sort of a momentum, I think, to scientific inquiry across the board, where I don't think it's about looking at it through this lens of like, oh, well, that things have necessarily gone wrong. But I think that we sort of can forget, as we've sort of been talking about, that how much the human element is involved in all of this.

SPEAKER_00And there can be whole areas of inquiry and ways of thinking that Pretty much just get ignored. And some of what, with the bit of reading that I've done about Steiner, a little bit I've done with Goethe, we talked about Whitehead. It's kind of bothersome to me when you look at the story with some of these guys. Not to say that all of their ideas are going to stand up to the test of time, because that's almost never the case.

SPEAKER_00But it bothers me the degree to which, when you look into the story with some of these guys... Oftentimes the reason that their ideas got really spurned and sort of buried, it wasn't necessarily always for really good. Sometimes it was, to be clear, but it wasn't always really for great reasons of like, oh, well, we're just going to reject everything that Whitehead said because we've now proven yada yada that everything he said was false.

SPEAKER_00Like there may be certain ideas of his that that have now been shown to not hold up. But a lot of times the reason that these guys would get sort of sidelined was just. Just typical, like very human, catty, social kind of bullshit, you know, where you had. Yeah. Where it was like, oh, well, this guy's doing something different. Let's like close the ranks and make sure, you know, this very cliquish sort of thing that you see even today, I think happen in science. And so like,

SPEAKER_00while some of Steiner's ideas, you know, might seem a bit out there and maybe some of them are, and, you know, I'm sure, you know, things move forward. There's probably ideas of fizz that have been shown to be okay. Yeah, that's definitely not how that works. It really bothers me that we just discount thinkers entirely. And we end up with these very sort of oversimplified straw man understandings of what they were saying. And, you know, granted, take this with a grain of salt.

SPEAKER_00I'm not a scientist. I'm not a professional of any stripe, really. But whether it was Steiner or Whitehead, you know, if you really dive in there and read these guys, it's like, All right. There was something going on here, you know, like there, there's definite things to be taken. Um, so when it comes to Steiner, what would you say is sort of the core thrust of anthroposophy that, that you think is really valuable that really gets overlooked? Because what I'm sort of picking up so far in the context of this conversation,

SPEAKER_00and it's sort of in the name, I think, to a degree of anthroposophy anthropo meaning, you know, man, um, And then, you know, the wisdom of man, it, to me, it seems like this, uh, broadly this effort to sort of in, in the context of what we've been discussing to insert ourselves back into the mix and like sort of very upfront acknowledge ourselves as part of what we're doing, whether it be science or spirituality or all these things, it's another sort of attempt to unify what I think in many people's minds.

SPEAKER_00Are these very sort of disparate concerns of like science and spirituality and such. So what's sort of the core for you that really stands out to you about Steiner as opposed to say someone like Whitehead?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I think maybe one way to begin would be to contrast anthroposophy with anthropology where, you know, we do have this science that's supposed to study man, but it studies man as an object. Um, it, Anthropologists will do participatory action research, and sometimes the boundary between research and observation and activism gets blurred there. But a lot of anthropologists are more like forensic anthropologists,

SPEAKER_01and they're interested in archaeology, and they're studying bones, and they're studying the human being as an object, more or less. And anthroposophy is... Actually trying to direct us back upon ourselves to study the human as a subject, which doesn't mean to just go inward and get all obsessed with your own psyche or something, but rather, I mean, Steiner in, you know, the 1890s, he writes a book called Philosophy of Freedom that's a phenomenology of thinking.

SPEAKER_01He wants to direct our attention to our own first-person activity of thinking and In that, recognize how through an experiential exercise that to bring us to the perspective where we recognize that there's one place in the whole universe where if anything is to happen, we have to be the one to do it. And that place is in our own thinking activity where we're no longer a subject observing objects that are just given to us in perception.

SPEAKER_01In our own thinking activity, there is no subject and object yet. Subject and object are concepts that actually flow out of this thinking activity. Before you perceive an object, before you think a thought, there is thinking activity. And so it's a simple sort of redirection of attention that he's attempting in this book. And it's like 250 pages or something. It's dense philosophical argument in lineage with German idealism and

SPEAKER_01in conversation with Goethe and Hegel and Schelling and He's trying to be a philosopher, but do so in a way that would be generative of a kind of spiritual experience or an awakening to this easily missed, he calls it exceptional state, where we recognize that we're in effect creating ourselves moment by moment through the direction of our attention To this activity, he calls it thinking.

SPEAKER_01If we were speaking Whiteheadese, we could just refer to creative process. But it's the creative process that we're not observing happening out there somewhere. It's like our own stream of consciousness in the American pragmatist William James's sense. And it's from that exceptional state and the realization of it and this form of attention That we can cultivate to our own thinking activity that he then sort of peels back the layers of the materialism that was the dominant worldview already

SPEAKER_01in the late 19th century when he was writing this book. And he kind of, he's trying to open up a portal to a new way of seeing reality where we don't, we don't leave ourselves out anymore, but we see everything that we claim we, or think we know about nature out there that's going on without us. It's a product of our thinking. We have assented to the view of what they, the scientists, have told us about how atoms operate and how there's this billion-year evolutionary process that lets our species walk in

SPEAKER_01the earth at this particular moment in geological history. And all of that might be true, but it's true if and only if we assent to it in our thinking. There's a very theoretical part of this that's, or I should say, an epistemological part of this book. It's just forcing us to take responsibility for our own beliefs and knowledge claims. But then there's also a practical side of the book or an ethical side of it about, well, okay,

SPEAKER_01if this is true and all of what I think I know about the world is ultimately something I have assented to as a thinker, The practical side of the book is, how does that shape my action in the world? What does it say about ethics and morality? And there's a whole account of what Steiner calls moral imagination, where we recognize that in the practical sphere and consens, which is all about morality and how we act and our freedom,

SPEAKER_01we're not free if we're just obeying someone else's moral law. We're just inheriting a set of mores or ideas about what good behavior means and just trying to fit in by not rocking the boat in that sense. We're morally free if we act based on our own free thinking activity. And we might be uncertain about certain things about the nature of reality.

SPEAKER_01But there's one thing we can be certain of, and this is where Descartes actually had something. Despite the dualism that he unfolds and how disastrous that's been, Descartes was aware of his own thinking activity, and that's the one thing he couldn't doubt. And Steiner's pointing to a similar insight. He's not accepting where Descartes ends up going with this insight, but the insight itself, that the one thing that we can't doubt is our own thinking activity. We can be certain that we exist as thinkers.

SPEAKER_01And from there, we can develop a whole moral philosophy, this is the proposal at least, that's able to recognize that, okay, I'm not the only thinker. You're a thinker. Every human being has this mysterious core where they are creating themselves moment by moment and deciding, am I going to believe this idea? Or that idea? Am I going to perform this action or that action?

SPEAKER_01And most of our lives we're caught up in the inertia of habit and we don't pay attention to the fact that we're free. But if we do pay attention to the fact that we're free, we can cultivate that freedom and expand that freedom and deepen it to reshape our habits. We can learn how to behave differently, not just instinctually and out of assumptions that we've inherited, but out of our own Free cognitive activity. And so that's the beginning for Steiner.

SPEAKER_01And as a philosopher, I mean, it's not only a solid argument, and it's not only continuous with a philosophical tradition that I studied academically, German idealism, but it opens into, I think, a new way of relating to reality that has deep spiritual value to me. And so in the 1890s, this is after Steiner had already been asked to edit Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's scientific work for the national edition,

SPEAKER_01collecting Goethe's work on plant morphology and the Fabanlera, his work on color theory, his work on morphology, etc. Goethe developed a whole Scientific method and applied it in all these different ways. Steiner edited that, introduced it, and was considered to be a reputable academic philosopher and historian. And he writes this book, Philosophy of Freedom. Then he goes on to teach at a Marxist college. He teaches history at a Marxist college in Berlin, I believe.

SPEAKER_01And then only later, around the turn of the century, does he get asked by the theosophists, the Theosophical Society, to start lecturing on his esoteric ideas. And Steiner had been, throughout all of this academic work and editing Goethe and writing this deep philosophical treatise and continuous with German idealism, he'd always experienced the world a little differently from most people. He claimed to be clairvoyant, he could see dead people and talk to dead people. He had these paranormal experiences from the time he was a kid.

SPEAKER_01And whatever you want to make of that, this is his own report. But he kind of hid that until the theosophists are like, you seem to know what you're talking about. Why don't you come lecture for us? So he leaves the Marxist college, starts doing theosophy. Hey, kitty.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01This is Newt. Hey, Newt. And was doing that for several years until the Theosophical Society Annie Besant and Charles Ledbetter and others decided that Krishnamurti was the second coming. And Steiner was like, I don't know about that. Krishnamurti would later say, yeah, I don't know about that either. And he branched off. He was the head of the German Theosophical Society and he branched off and created

SPEAKER_00Anthroposophy.

SPEAKER_01I think it was like 1908 or 1909. I think that's right. And then, you know, Anthroposophy became its own spiritual movement and he began lecturing About all sorts of topics that go far beyond what you would usually consider academic philosophy. About spiritual beings and the angelic hierarchies and the different phases of the evolution of the cosmos that go way beyond what we consider the physical world to be.

SPEAKER_01And things can get really wild really fast at that phase. But I think I always start introducing him With this book, Philosophy of Freedom, it's kind of the opening into even being able to begin to take seriously the things that he says in this later period. If we can accept what it means to be clairvoyant, which I think is just a heightened sensitivity to our own embeddedness in the universe and that our normal rational conscious mind

SPEAKER_01and our physical senses are just the surface of experience and through cultivation or through grace if you're just born as an exceptional person who has this ability, a sign or thought you could also cultivate it, you can deepen below just our normal intellectual form of reflection and physical sensory experience to perceive as Goethe did the living world as a An archetypal process of metamorphosis. And then you can go even a layer deeper than Goethe was capable to perceive what

SPEAKER_01the theosophists and Steiner would call the astral realm. And anyone who's done psychedelics, who smoked some DMT or, you know, done some ayahuasca and had that profound, gone through a profound visualization type of experience has been to the astral realm. I mean, that's I think that's a touchpoint for people. Anthropocifists have a lot of problems with psychedelia and all of that. They call it gate crashing. It's like people are just blasting off into the astral realm. They haven't done the preparation for it. It can be really dangerous.

SPEAKER_01But nonetheless, I think that gives you a glimpse of what might be meant by the astral realm. The kind of work Goethe is doing, delicate empiricism is what Goethe called it, observing the metamorphic quality of plant growth. The metamorphic quality of animal growth, embryology, and perceiving organisms not just in space, anatomically, but in time as rhythmic processes of development. That's a form of what Steiner would call etheric perception.

SPEAKER_01Steiner's inviting us into these deeper modes of perception. Of deeper layers of reality beyond just the mineral, he would call it, or the physical world that we see with our eyes and touch with our hands. He thinks by cultivating attention and thinking and feeling and willing, we can go deeper than that. I obviously can't verify everything that he claims about the spiritual research he does in these other realms, but I think what Garta is doing is certainly worth paying attention to and taking seriously.

SPEAKER_01And I think given my own experiences in the so-called astral realm, through psychedelics and other exceptional states, there's a there there. And I think there's a new form of research that can be done and peer review that's needed to explore these spaces beyond just the physical sense world. And so what's required for the buy-in here is that the human being

SPEAKER_01in our normal modes of perception is just the beginning. We can actually cultivate higher modes of perception

SPEAKER_00to see deeper into reality.

SPEAKER_01That's what Steiner is proposing.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's interesting in a way because it's like, I think when a lot of people hear it, it, you know, it, it does sound really out there and all these things, but it's, it's weird because it's like, I think people are, are quite on board, broadly speaking with, um, evolution. And in some ways it's like, well, it's sort of just proposing a sort of psychological evolution. Um, I'm going to get

SPEAKER_01a glass of water real fast. I can still hear you continue. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Where it's difficult because it's like we sort of look at the fossil record and all these things and we can sort of get a rough map of this trajectory of biological evolution. But it seems like, at least to our knowledge, it seems like the sort of consciousness that we have as human beings seems to be,

SPEAKER_00from what we can tell, it seems to be reasonably new. And so... I get people having a hesitancy, and I don't even think that hesitancy with these sorts of topics is wrong. Because I think it's easy to see... Like I said, I have a background in both conspiracy theorism and the New Age movement as well that I've since come out of, and it's pretty easy in those circles to find what can happen if people just sort

SPEAKER_00of go... Just sort of willy-nilly charging ahead without any sort of mental or sometimes even physical caution. You can end up in bad places and you can end up because you don't really have something like a scientific method where people are hopefully sort of able to corroborate and check each other's work and push back on each other's ideas.

SPEAKER_00You can end up with this sort of runaway effect, I think, where people can get really carried away with some ideas that end up not really tracking reality very well. But at the same time, it's like, even though I now have, you know, I still will use the label for myself, skeptic, I've been pretty vocal about my criticisms. Of a lot of behaviors I see in skepticism, same as I'm an atheist and I criticize atheist stuff all the time.

SPEAKER_00But at the same time, there's this sort of experiential level to things where having had some of these first person experiences, sort of like what you're talking about, whether it's psychedelics or these other states, I've had some of these things. And I've seen, I've first-person experienced things that are really difficult for me to... It's tough because it's not difficult to generate an explanation.

SPEAKER_00And I mentioned sort of UFOs, abductions. I would include... Some religious people might take offense at this. That's not my intention. But I would include miracles under this,

SPEAKER_01this sort of like...

SPEAKER_00Umbrella of what they call, those of us in the biz call, I'm not in the biz, I don't get paid for this shit, but call high strangeness, which is sort of this umbrella term for just things that are recounted by human beings as experiences that are just completely outside sort of the bailiwick of the mundane or however you want to talk about. And so I bring sort of this skeptical eye to it, but I cannot escape.

SPEAKER_00And I wish I could, to be clear, because I'm sure I've got some skeptic people out there being like, but it's like, I kind of wish I could have that very dismissive attitude because it would make my internal life easier in a way. And I wonder if that's not going on to a degree with some skeptics. I'm not trying to psychologize my fellow skeptics necessarily, but something's going on sometimes. So it's like, I'll give a first person example to put some meat on the bone, so to speak.

SPEAKER_00You mentioned DMT. I've had experience with that a couple times. And I will keep... And this is a good example because I didn't... I didn't do what they would call like blasting off. I didn't... I wasn't gone. You know what I mean? I wasn't out there with the machine elves or, you know, as, you know, Terrence McKenna said. I was outside and... Um, as I detail out my, but whatever, we're here.

SPEAKER_00Fuck it. We ball. Um, so I inhaled and, um, onset was very quick. It's collapsed back. Um, I happened to be sitting right in front of a tree, big Oak tree, huge. And I collapsed back and smack my head or anything, but I collapsed back and I land with my head at the base of the tree. And I'm looking straight up the trunk of the tree and through to the top. And it wasn't enough where I left.

SPEAKER_00So I was still there. I'm still consciously in my body and everything. But as the onset happens, suddenly, it's like everything just goes shifts slightly.

SPEAKER_01And I can literally see

SPEAKER_00Every leaf on that tree through all of the other ones. And not only can I see visually, I can see every leaf on that tree. I can see every vein. I can see every little just detail, just unimaginable detail of every single leaf. And it was the craziest experience because it's like I've only ever seen something like that I've never seen anything honestly like that, but if you see sometimes a 3D model of something where it's sort of translucent,

SPEAKER_00I've maybe seen something similar like that, but the amount of detail and how vivid it was was just so incredibly compelling. As someone who still has a skeptical mentality, it's like Can I generate a story about how my brain would have produced that experience? Of course. Yes. But more and more, it's like I can hold that.

SPEAKER_00It's like I said earlier. How I approach these things with people will very much sort of depend on... How assertive they are with their conclusions. So on the one front, if I just recounted that story and someone very assertively was like, Oh, well, you smoked the DMT and suddenly your pineal gland cracked open and now you were given this altered awareness and what you saw with each of those leaves was actually,

SPEAKER_00you were really seeing exactly what the leaves look like. That's a pretty strong statement. And I would be like, well, I don't know. Maybe we temper that a bit. There are other explanations. But I feel similarly in the other direction where if I tell that story, And then your sort of typical skeptical response would be like, Oh, well, you know, you did the thing. And then it was just your brains just making things up. And it doesn't mean anything. It's like, fuck off, dude. Like, because there's, it's not about either side.

SPEAKER_00No, me knowing that either side is wrong, but it like misses the fucking point. You know what I mean? Yeah. And I feel that way so much increasingly, whether it comes to spirituality or religion. You know, I've been having conversations with a lot of theists lately. I just had a conversation with Matt Whiteley, which was awesome. And I'm just finding so much more accord with like this particular sort of type of person who just isn't

SPEAKER_00They're not dogmatic in either direction, but they're also not in this sort of like mealy-moused middle road either. These are people that, whether they're Christian or, you know, anything else, the commonality is they're This is going to sound so cringe, but it's like they're alive. They're invested, if we're talking about faith. They're invested in their faith. Their faith is not about... Because what I got into conversing with Matt about...

SPEAKER_00Was sort of this modern apologetics that's very popular online, you know, your William Lane Craigs and things like this, where there's all these attempts to sort of create these logical arguments about, you know, why it's perfectly reasonable and logical to believe that God exists. And I don't want to go so far as to say that there's never a time for that. But I end up feeling, and then in the flip side, in response to that, you have the very new atheist, no, that's stupid, and you're an idiot, and, you know, this back and forth.

SPEAKER_00And I just, in all these conversations, and it's just this pattern emerging for me that almost no matter what I talk about, I come away with a similar thing because I've got interest in all these areas. So, you know, we might be talking about theory of mind, or we might be talking about spirituality, or we might be talking about UFOs, abductions. We might be talking about miracles or high strangeness or all these things. And more and more, I feel like the common pattern I see Is there's always people on either side

SPEAKER_00that are insistent on engaging with these topics in a really brutally like literalist sense, where it's like, no, this is true. Like, this is how reality works. And that sort of, um, Assertion, this sort of very in the religious context, like viewing the question of God purely through this sort of propositional lens where it's all about like having the right opinion about the existence of God. Yeah, not that these are always mutually exclusive,

SPEAKER_00but it seems to be very little about experiencing God. Right, exactly. And that strong sort of propositional framing. And once again, this is not where I think that the response is necessarily wrong. And that's where, like I've said, I still do hold some space for new atheist style rhetoric. Because when someone makes some really crazy strong proposition, then I think it is appropriate to be like for someone and it's just sort of natural to come back and want to check that and

SPEAKER_01be like, all right, you know, maybe, you know, maybe it doesn't work that way.

SPEAKER_00But the problem, easily, I think, to point out on the case of, say, something like New Atheism and Christianity, is it really, to me, it really impoverishes the conversation because it strips away everything out of it that isn't this very propositional type of thing. And I feel like there's something that... Very likely can happen with things like anthroposophy.

SPEAKER_00Particularly because he was involved with the sciences where there will be things, like he said, that... And that's the thing, though. That's not unique, I don't think, to any of these. Like, just because the person made some... You know, put forward some ideas that we've since turned out to find out weren't accurate. That doesn't mean that we should discount everything the person said. Like, look back at... Look at some of the stuff... For fuck's sake. Look at a lot of the stuff that... Newton was into. Like, we hold him in this,

SPEAKER_00and not saying that we shouldn't, we hold him in this incredibly high regard for this thing that he did, that he contributed. But Newton was into some very wacky stuff.

SPEAKER_01Galileo was still a practicing astrologer as well.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And so the idea that we're just gonna, like, oh, well, I like what this guy said, or, you know, granted, there's something that those guys... Put forward that we still utilize today. I just don't, I don't like this dismissiveness that I see so often that can be set up in both directions, you know? So when it comes to anthroposophy, Whitehead and things like this, sure, you might get people that I would say maybe lean a bit too hard on that stuff.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But something I really have become passionate about is trying to encourage everyone, not only Not only on, say, the believer side of things, to maybe temper that a bit, but also to my fellow skeptics and stuff, to be a bit more pragmatic about this stuff and to realize that when we're engaging and we're contacting people who are interested in these kind of ideas,

SPEAKER_01whether they be religious people, spiritual, all these kind of things,

SPEAKER_00like I said towards the beginning, that if we really do care about coming to a fuller and a A richer understanding of the world and our place in it. We're not accomplishing anything by only, only engaging with topics in the narrow band where we feel like we can win. If that makes sense.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. No, I, I love all of that. And, you know, personally, if your religion is reducible to a set of propositions that you believe in, you're doing it wrong. Religion is, from my point of view, about one's disposition. Religion is about transformation, the transformation of character. We've got science and logic for propositions,

SPEAKER_01for refining our sense of what's true and factual of the observable world. You know, we've got A long list of fallacies to help us avoid poor propositional forms of logic. In religion, belief is, to my mind, beside the point. Religion is a form of life that involves ritual, it involves self-sacrifice, it involves

SPEAKER_01A sense of community, and it involves a sort of striving to be a better person, transformation of character. If you're getting hung up on making sure everybody ascends to the Ten Commandments or some creed that you have to say it the right way, that's not actually what it's about.

SPEAKER_01And so there's a lot of confusion. I mean, these debates, does God exist? Or not? To frame that as a scientific hypothesis, and it's like Richard Dawkins' God Hypothesis book, right? It's like, no, God's not a hypothesis. But the problem is that these fundamentalist religious people, like the William Lane Craigs of the world,

SPEAKER_01Or treating God like some kind of hypothesis that there's rational reasons for believing in. And like you were saying, there may be some rational reasons, but God is something you experience. God's not an idea that you believe in or not, at least from my point of view. If someone were to ask me, do you believe in God, I'd be a little bit Hesitant to even answer. I mean, there's this great video of Carl Jung being asked this question as an old man.

SPEAKER_01Do you believe in God? And he's like, oh, well, difficult to say. I don't believe. I know. And of course, you know, he's well known for being interested in Gnosticism and alchemy and astrology. But what does he mean? I know. It's this more or less mystical attitude that's It's relating to the divine as something you experience, not something you believe in as a proposition.

SPEAKER_01And so it's just so beside the point to me, you know, in these logical debates and like who's got evidence for what. If I were to ask to like, what do I mean by God, you know, The best way I've come to answer that question is that God is the most obvious, mundane fact about human existence, coexistence. And unless you can recognize God as that,

SPEAKER_01I have the sneaking suspicion you might be worshiping an idol. Like, God's not hiding from us. This isn't a trick. This isn't like, oh, only the people that happen to be born in the right community and believe the right creed get into heaven and everyone else is going to burn hell forever because God is, like, really picky about who gets into heaven. No, I don't think you're missing something here. If God is love, like, everyone's invited to the party, there's nothing hidden about this.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I don't know how that lands for you.

SPEAKER_00No, it does. It lands well. I was talking to another friend last night and he was asking me what were the big problems that led me away from believing in God and the divine hiddenness. Question was one that always, I think, really bothered me a lot because I'd been taught that, you know, God was a real chatty Cathy at some point back in the day, apparently.

SPEAKER_00And then they had their little narratives about, I mean, Honestly, no, I'm not going to apologize for speaking dismissively about because I really don't think much of the sort of belief that I came up with, you know, where it was like, well, why was God so willing

SPEAKER_01and able apparently to

SPEAKER_00and sort of definitionally God can do whatever he wants. So nothing changed in terms of God's ability. To speak directly to, you know, his creation to, you know, clear things right up. He has that ability. But then after he has a kid, he just goes on hiatus and then, you know, like he's just missing an action apparently. And so, you know, that was something that bothered me so much because I wanted to, I wanted to experience God. Um, And I never did.

SPEAKER_00I never experienced anything that led me to think that the sort of God I was raised to believe in was in any way real. I never saw anything along those lines. And it wasn't, ironically, and, you know, like I said, I'm still fine. But part of me calling myself an atheist, too, is just sort of the result of where I live. Because... You don't believe in that God. No, I'm believing that guy. Yeah. Which it's like, I think there is a, it is legitimate to say that like, yes,

SPEAKER_00every person, every person has a different, you know, somewhat different sort of way that they conceptualize this idea of God. But at the same time, I'm not trying to be sort of pedantic about it. So it's like, I'm an American, in America, when someone says, do you believe in God? They're asking in that sort of propositional sense. And my answer is no, I don't believe in this, you know. And I'm curious your thought on this, because it's like...

SPEAKER_00And I'm frankly at the point, too, where there's probably some people that listen to me talk at this point and actually think that I sound like some sort of theist, and I don't even really care. But this sort of apophatic idea, and it's an idea that's not unique to Christianity. I know people are probably tired of me saying it. I'm not a Taoist either, but... Another word that I used to hate and I find myself using more here of late is resonate.

SPEAKER_00The line from the Tao Te Ching of the Tao which can be spoken is not the eternal Tao has always just nailed me in between the eyes. Something about it every time that I hear it. And it reminds me very much of apophatic sort of traditions within Christianity of this idea of saying like, yeah, we can, we can sort of talk loosely about God, but we can't, we can't say anything about him, it, they, however you choose to, she, however you choose to think about it.

SPEAKER_00We can't actually like contain it in language. And I think that marries nicely also with sort of what we're talking about of, you know, we have this sort of placeholder, we have this term for God, but it isn't something that is or really by its nature can be cashed out in human language. You see it also, I think, in certain phrases which sound incredibly, you know, a bit kitschy, but I think it does hit at something like God doesn't exist.

SPEAKER_00I forget who said it, but it's like God doesn't exist. He insists. This idea of once you try to nail it down, it's not there. And that goes so against the rational... It not only goes against the rational mind of, say, the new atheist type or someone who's much more along those lines, it also flies in the face of Sort of theistic personalism of this very,

SPEAKER_00you know, God is this character, is this sort of separate being that isn't, you know, he might be technically everywhere, but there's some degree of separation between God and ourselves. It also flies in the face of that. So how do you feel about sort of the apathetic way of engaging with the idea? Do you think it leaves something to be desired? Or do you think that It's pretty close to a good way to look at God, like a good rule of thumb to really not say anything specific about it.

SPEAKER_01I think negative theology helps us avoid idolatry. And, you know, when Moses asks, you know, God, like, what's your name? When he's on Mount Sinai in front of the burning bush and God says, I am that I am. To me, that's indicating that divine existence has to do with the thatness of reality, not the whatness of reality. What I mean is, God's not the sort of thing that you could ask a what is it question about.

SPEAKER_01Because when we ask what is it, we're talking about some finite thing within the universe. And God is that... The fact that there is anything at all begins to point at what can't be pointed at. And, you know, language is very interesting in the sense that it can be self-referential. It's not just for designating things in the world. We give names to the things that we can share attention around or whatever,

SPEAKER_01or we can give a name to abstract concepts and then share attention about that. We can also refer to language itself. How the hell do we do that? I mean, this is related to the mystery of self-consciousness. And I think when we use words like God to avoid idolatry and thinking we're talking about a what and remind ourselves that, no, no, this is a that. And there are other traditions, like Buddhism has this understanding of Buddha nature as the Tathagatagarbha,

SPEAKER_01which is translated often as suchness. The very nature of things is Buddhahood. The very nature of existence is divine. There's reality and then there's this God that created reality. If you're a negative theologian and a mystic in that sense, God isn't separate from what is. And so it brings you into,

SPEAKER_01I think, a deeper relationship that's more mysterious, that you're never quite sure how to talk about, but for people that have had that experience, and that's the key, it's rooted in an experience that's ineffable. For those who have had that experience, and even to call it experience that you have turns it into a what, so we have to be careful here. For those who have touched this mystery, there's a way of orienting around it that generates community, but that isn't rooted in a A sort of conformity to a proposition.

SPEAKER_01It's instead rooted in the recognition that propositions are futile and that it ain't about belief, but it's about touching your source and seeing how that transfigures your whole life and brings you into a new kind of community that's not oriented around control or how I might By associating with the right people, get ahead in the world, or it's not even just about like safety or belonging,

SPEAKER_01but it's just about like a recognition, a mutual recognition that like you can wink at each other and know that you don't know. But that it, even with that lack of certainty in a propositional sense about what this means, there's I guess I don't want to just reduce it to emotion in the psychological sense because it's really about love. There's a way in which knowing that you can't know this in

SPEAKER_01a propositional way opens you to a form of relationship with others who know that they can't know it that's rooted in this outpouring of compassion and love and just dwelling in the mystery together. And Christianity has its way of referring to that mystical Christianity, Buddhism has its way of referring to that. And so there's a way in which this emptiness in the Buddhist sense Or this kenosis in the Greek Christian sense,

SPEAKER_01kenosis meaning self-emptying, like God is not something you can point to, it's not the subject of a proposition, but rather the very capacity we have to propose, like that we can be speaking animals that are capable of this kind of self-reflective consciousness. That we can even ask a question like, why is there something rather than nothing? It's like always a pointing at the ineffable and generating this mystical experience.

SPEAKER_01And if that mystical experience is at the core of our cultural life together, I think it generates a different, it just generates a different field, way of being together. It's not combative and competitive and rooted in a kind of lack or sense of fear of not having enough or getting enough because it totally reshapes your whole sense of life and death. You're not afraid of death anymore when you've touched this suchness

SPEAKER_01that all these negative theologians and mystics are pointing to. And so it's really important that people be invited into this experience. And I think when you relate to God as the almighty, all-powerful father figure who's really stern, and if you don't obey, you're going to be punished for all eternity, that just closes you off to being able to relate to the ultimate in a curious way

SPEAKER_01that opens you instead of closes you down. Um, and so this is, yeah, it's essential. And it was at the core of Christianity for a thousand years or more, you know, it's only in this modern fundamentalist reactionary move where it's like, Oh no, no, we got to defend religion from science by being better at propositional logic than they are. It's like, first of all, you're going to lose that battle. And second of all, you're totally missing the point.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. It shows up in a lot. It's, it's funny because it's like when I was coming up, um, For the sort of, um, for the sort of questions that you see apologetics dealing with all the time, uh, we didn't, we weren't really too concerned with all that, but the place that very apologetic style stuff would show up in our community was for like creationism, um, in terms of trying to combat evolution. And it's a very similar sort of thing. Um, I mentioned that when I talked to the other Matt, um, I think it was Rhett.

SPEAKER_00I think it was Rhett McLaughlin, um, who was on Alex O'Connor not too long ago, the same Rhett from the whole, uh, that, uh, what is it? Morning something or other with Rhett and Link. People might've seen their show. Um, they were both were sort of, uh, former evangelicals, I believe, but, um, how Rhett said it was that apologetics was essentially, um, Christianity taking the bait from the enlightenment. Um, yeah, which I, I thought was a really good way to put it. And, you know, I didn't know,

SPEAKER_00and this is just like a little bit of a glimpse behind the curtain, like, I don't think most, at least within the circles and the type of Christian fundamentalism that I came up in, they don't know that sort of fundamentalist, like, at least the form that we're talking about of this sort of literalist fundamentalism, They think that they're holding this sort of preservational role like that. This is the good old time religion and that this is the way that it always was and that they're protecting that. Like it was literally I'm 41 now and I've been out of been out of the faith

SPEAKER_00for pushing 20 years now. It was literally within the last year or so that I learned that the whole way that I grew up was a pretty new phenomenon. And not only that, but that as Christian theology goes, that the theology I was raised in is essentially incoherent garbage. And, you know, I think that's part of it. You know, I had such a horrible experience with Christianity and sort of the Christian God

SPEAKER_00by extension that, you know, I just don't know as it will ever be a place that I would be comfortable

SPEAKER_01with again. And also...

SPEAKER_00When it comes to spirituality and stuff, I'm sort of fine in broad strokes with Christianity now, like certain forms of it, definitely. But I don't think that I don't personally think there's anything really super special about it. But it does bother me a bit because like, I think I went through so much pain and anguish by viewing sort of God in the way that I was taught to. And Part of what I've, I think, wanted to do in having conversations with, well,

SPEAKER_00I think this conversation with you falls under this category as well, where, you know, even though it might not be for me at this point in my life, whether it be spirituality in general or, you know, maybe even certain forms of Christianity, I do believe that they can be such a great source of meaning making for people. And I feel like there's probably a lot of people out there like me that came from my sort of background that just completely just cut themselves off entirely spiritually

SPEAKER_00because spirituality for them was sort of coterminous with abuse. And I think that's necessary. If you're in sort of an abusive relationship, you need to get out. And that's where, too, when it comes to new atheism, things like that. If I see someone who's in sort of a new atheist phase or something like that, I don't... Like I said, I still categorize myself as an atheist. But I don't look at that person and be like, oh, no, don't do that.

SPEAKER_00Don't read Dawkins. Don't read any of these guys. Because I do believe that If you've had God set up for you as this very brutal sort of dictator-like force, And we can say it in the frame of a critique. I think I've even heard some Christians say it, and I think there's a nugget of truth to it, where it's like the new atheist mentality. It's like, well, you guys are really, really angry at a God that you supposedly don't believe in. Exactly. Which I think some Christians say that smugly, like,

SPEAKER_00trying to imply that, oh, the atheists still believe in God and they just are hating him now. Which I think that's too uncharitable. I don't think that's the case. I think there's just a psychological explanation of when you've had this character drilled into you for years of God being this angry judge, it just lives rent-free in your head. And then I can't speak for other former fundamentalists, but I know for me,

SPEAKER_00something I had to come to accept was the fact that My lashing out and my hatred at the concept of God in a lot of ways was, and this is really personal, but maybe it'll help somebody. My lashing out was because it was much easier for me to hate God than it was for me to hate my parents. Yeah. I can continue to project onto God all of these sort of negative features,

SPEAKER_00but the fact is when I look at it, the people primarily, and trust me, there was a huge laundry list of other people that frankly fucked with me all the time in retrospect in terms of like what now I would be fine calling spiritual abuse. But sort of ground zero for that was my parents. And what's even harder is that it wasn't done as an act of conscious abuse. It was done under the guise of a misguided sort of love.

SPEAKER_01Mm hmm.

SPEAKER_00And that can be something that is really, really difficult to emotionally navigate. And so I think a lot of the vitriol that many of us atheists have, as you said, it's a religious wound and it may seem strange to people from the outside. And don't get me wrong, too. When you are confronting Christian nationalism or trying to brute force creationism into schools, There's things that,

SPEAKER_00or dealing with a group like Westboro Baptist or something, there's things that happen under the auspices of Christianity, broadly speaking, that are absolutely worthy of indignation and need to be met with, like I said, you know, met on the field with great rhetorical force. I don't think that opening myself up more sort of precludes me from engaging in those things, but Whether it's something like what we're talking about today or any of the other people I've talked to about similar topics,

SPEAKER_00I think there's great value in realizing that if you want to, you don't have to, but even if you maintain the title of atheist, you might not ever be consciously religious or anything like that, but there's no Whatever this thing is that we're talking about, and that's where it gets tough when we're talking about spirituality, whatever this is, this way of embracing life, this way of,

SPEAKER_00once again, using language that I want to kick my own ass for, because I still have that new atheist streak in me, but open your fucking heart to other people. And I think that that's maybe some of what we're talking about, where it's like, I think that I was lied to in being told that God or spirituality was this thing out there to which I needed to appeal.

SPEAKER_00And if there is such a thing as God, I think it is like you said, it is something that can just be found, but it's not let me go find it. It's you just sort of dropping a wall and not finding anything, but just letting it fucking be. Yeah. And I don't know. I don't really know what to do with that.

SPEAKER_00So now you're my spiritual advisor. What do I do with that?

SPEAKER_01Well, you have conversations like this that are trying to approach this subject differently and exemplify, I think, a more mature way of relating to life and the mystery, again, that there is something rather than nothing. And I think that for me, religion is, and that's such a vague word, I mean,

SPEAKER_01Personally, it's Buddhism and Christianity that have just spoken to me and helped me make sense of life. Not just as traditions, because I think it's more than just sort of like a cultural milieu and thousands of years old... A long lineage of deep practitioners and monks and thinkers

SPEAKER_01who have formed these traditions, but it's more than just that human sort of cultural inheritance. Like, I've had these experiences of what I'm comfortable with, admittedly some embarrassment, calling spiritual beings Buddha, which I don't mean just like Siddhartha Gautama, like this historical figure, but actually like A being that's present always, ever, ever present. And Christ, a being that's present. And that Buddha and Christ, they inspired these traditions.

SPEAKER_01And human beings have been trying to figure out, like, what do they want us to do? And we've got very confused about that. But, I mean, you could talk about this in a less, I don't know, highfalutin, woo-woo sense as just, like, aspects of human nature. Not just any aspects, but, like, the The aspirational aspects of human nature. These beings are ways that we might be, and we maybe, yeah,

SPEAKER_01we just imaginatively project them as teachers that are loving and kind and compassionate and insightful and wise and are so loving in fact that they sacrifice themselves to try to reveal something to us that couldn't have been revealed in any other way. And like, what is that mystery? Buddhism makes a lot more sense to me, like as a philosophical mind.

SPEAKER_01It's a little bit, I mean, it's often described as more scientific. It's just mind science, you know, which is a bit of a colonial re-packaging.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01What Buddhism actually is, but Christianity is, I think, yeah, admittedly uniquely bizarre. Like, why this first century Jew in Palestine who's, you know, delivered to Pontius Pilate, the, you know, Roman sort of guy in charge of Palestine at that time, and By the Jews and like so his own people are like this guy needs to be dealt with

SPEAKER_01and Pontius Pilate like sort of reluctantly is like all right I guess well we can crucify this dude but so he gets crucified and then he's put in a tomb and then three days later the tomb is empty and you know Saul falls off his horse because he has a vision of Christ and becomes Paul and finally like What the hell happened? Why did this religion just erupt out of the desert and a few centuries later topples

SPEAKER_01the Roman Empire? I mean, the Roman Emperor had to rebrand itself in light of this new tradition, this new movement. And it starts with mostly being women-led and people meeting in their homes and forming this new kind of community. It's uniquely bizarre. And I don't myself know how to make sense of it, but I have, again, had the experiences where this being becomes so

SPEAKER_01undeniably present and real and reorients my entire sense of what's meaningful in life and what's valuable and what I am to do as a human being. And I can't just turn away from that. I also, as a rational person who Takes the scientific method again very seriously and is interested in the history of science and the history of philosophy and wants to be epistemically sound in my own, in the propositions that I affirm.

SPEAKER_00Like I often don't know how to

SPEAKER_01talk about this stuff. I appreciate and really enjoy when I'm invited to talk about it, but I don't go around talking about it just like without being asked because it's kind of, It's a lot. And if people don't want to have that conversation or they may have assumptions about what it means to talk about Christ.

SPEAKER_00Well, you would have to, you know, and I, I, I'm sorry to keep referencing the conversation with Matt, but it was a similar thing with him. Cause like, I, I find so much accord, uh, with Matt Whiteley as well. And, you know, he didn't go into real details, but, you know, we're just talking about this experience thing. And that's, that's something that for me, I can't escape. Like, I've not had experiences that led me that were sort of personified, like you said, with, you know, you've had a with Buddha and Jesus. I've never had anything that was sort of attached to any particular way of thinking

SPEAKER_00in terms of experiences. But as I said, and to be clear too, not just with psychedelics, I've had some strange experiences as well. And it's one of those things where it's just like, For people who are cynical or people who want to be like, oh, well, that was this or that. It's like, you can say whatever you want about it. I'm not even saying anything about it. You know what I mean? So where some people would be, and this is something that sort

SPEAKER_01of is the miracle discourse is sort of going

SPEAKER_00crazy now. You know, and there's a lot of people that are like, well, look at all the, once again, this is very propositional thing. It's like, look at this evidence. And not only does this Prove that the miracle is true, but then this proves that Catholicism specifically is true. And I'm just like, you know, what are we even doing? But on the flip side, though, like I listened to your story, and I talked to these other people, and this is the other thing, too. This is where I think it is where it's really important, even if you are an atheist, to have these conversations with people,

SPEAKER_00because it's so easy when you're not actually talking to people. To just sort of otherize people and be like, ah, well, they're just delusional or they're crazy or yada, yada, yada. But to engage someone in conversation and realize like what's happening here of like, this person cares about pretty much the same stuff I care about. But this person's recounting that they have had this experience and they might not even really know what to do with it. But for them to deny their own experience, they would have to lie.

SPEAKER_00And there's a certain amount of bravery. Does that mean that there aren't people out there that make shit up? Of course, that's going to happen. But this is my thing that I keep coming back to in all these topics, like I said. Yeah, we can do the skeptical thing. If we want to find examples of people that are lying and faking, yeah, we can find examples of that. But if we're going to be, whether it's skeptics or atheists or anything,

SPEAKER_00if we're going to be intellectually honest people, we need to wrap our heads around the fact that every day in the world, there are people having whatever words you want to put on it, numinous experiences, strange experiences, whatever, I don't really care, whatever you want to call it. Experiences that are experienced as being, Really significantly outside the mundane. People have these sorts of experiences all the time, and not only does it happen,

SPEAKER_00but they can cause a seismic shift in people's psychology, often in good ways. As human beings, this is something that is happening to us, and we have to address it. And we have to accept that it's happening. And I think that the only explanation in the past for me, and I think that for many of these other people, and once again, we need to be honest in seeing the people that are claiming

SPEAKER_00to have these experiences, What are they actually recounting with the experience? Because once again, I think we do that thing where we knee jerk people in the face as skeptics, where someone might say, oh, I had this incredible experience and I saw Christ. Oftentimes we then will immediately jump to acting like the person is saying, oh, well, this is how I know everything in the Bible is true or that, you know what I mean? Which is fine if the person says that.

SPEAKER_00But I think that we often are projecting. And that we would be... Even if you want to talk about sort of from a science standpoint, it's not scientific to immediately just sort of brute force, just project your own thinking onto any given phenomenon. That doesn't mean that you don't look for inference to the best explanation. But... So that is what I think is the fear is for a lot of people from,

SPEAKER_00you know, my side of the fence with skepticism and such is I think there's this fear that if we open ourselves to there being possibly something more like suddenly we're going to lose access to being able to care about science and being able to care about all these other things.

SPEAKER_01I think you're the right kind of skeptic Ishmael because you're skeptical of your own skepticism. Um, And you're not just interested in winning debates, but in surveying human experience, my impression of you, and really getting a sense for why people believe what they believe or orient in the way that they do. And I have different...

SPEAKER_01Modes or moods maybe that I enter into. I mean, sometimes I love the propositional games and I want to do speculative philosophy and work out the categories that most adequately explain the nature of experience and reality and everything. And that can be valuable. I think it helps us Build a structure of understanding that can be applied across various scientific disciplines, and it can even inform our theology.

SPEAKER_01And theology is something I value too, like reflection, rigorous philosophical and logical, experientially grounded reflection on God. What we mean by that term and I think that can be a tremendously valuable exercise but it has to remain rooted in experience and it has to remain humble and not think that God is the type of thing that again could be the subject of a logical proof

SPEAKER_01but more so you know we are animals haunted by logos language and we seek explanations we seek Not just to describe our experience, but through the articulation of sound propositions to explain what's going on here. And that's a collective endeavor, and we should pursue it. But I think it's when we lose touch with the

SPEAKER_01silence which precedes speech, and when we lose touch with That mystery of the recursive nature of language and the difference again between the what and the that, then that's when the pursuit of the true propositions, like the true proposition to rule them all or whatever, that's when we get lost down that dead end. Instead of recognizing language as a...

SPEAKER_01So it's, yeah, it's like a means of expression. And, you know, I think of like the angels who are, you know, in the tradition, Islamic and Christian and Jewish traditions are said to just out of their own nature to sort of orbit the Godhead and as a choir just... Lost in worship and love of the divine.

SPEAKER_01As language users, language is our way of expressing that divine love. And it's not like we're trying to prove the existence of God. I think when we're really doing theology well, we're expressing the nature of God. It's not that we're not trying to prove it. We're almost like, Recognizing that the fact that we are language-possessed animals is already, what more proof could you ask for that there's so many more going on here?

SPEAKER_01And just expressing that fact. That's how I relate to theology and the propositional, at least. I value logic, obviously, as an academic philosopher, but I see it as a moment In the divine life, in a mode of divine expression, and there's also poetry and painting and dance and all these other ways of, you could say, if you want,

SPEAKER_01proving the existence of God just through the expression of that love rather than the attempt to defeat someone in an argument.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I've come back to this sort of like poetic idea of, you know, I'm always reminded of, and it makes me laugh because when I was in fundamentalism, if anyone ever said, you know, well, what is faith? People would very just sort of snappily regurgitate Hebrews 11.1 of, you know, faith is a substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen. And they would give it as this very sort of smug response. And I remember eventually getting to the point where I was like,

SPEAKER_00you know, that doesn't really mean anything, you know, in a more sort of a, you know, and these were literalists, by the way. So it's like, in a more literal sense, it's kind of gobbledygook. It doesn't really mean anything. But if you engage with that verse poetically, it's teasing something out that I think is really beautiful, where... It is poetry, I think. It's not meant to make sense in this way because the substance of something hoped for, well, that doesn't sound right at all.

SPEAKER_00The evidence of something not seen. But sort of how you're speaking about with language, that's a good example, I think, of using language in this way. Because what is poetry? Poetry is this way of using language that it causes this effect, I think,

SPEAKER_01that's That's more than the sum of its parts,

SPEAKER_00you know, where you're putting, yeah, you're putting words and I write a bit of poetry myself. Oddly though, you know, that's another interesting example because it's like when I first started writing, I was just planning on writing about critical thinking and all this kind of stuff. I, you know, and I even joke sometimes because I write a decent bit of poetry now and occasionally somebody asked me, oh, who are your, you know, who, what poetry do you read? And I always go like, I don't read that crap. I do read a little bit, but it's like poetry was never much of an interest of mine.

SPEAKER_00But once I started writing otherwise, all of a sudden I started waking up, you know, because I struggle with insomnia a bit. Like if you sat me right down right now and said, write me a poem, I would really not be able to do it. It would kind of be shit. Most of my poetry happens in the middle of the night when I'm half asleep. And then I read it the next day and I'm like, huh. So there's something there of this sort of liminal, I know that gets used all the time now, like this liminal space.

SPEAKER_00And I think that that's, whether you want to call it spiritual or whatever, there's the fact that someone who's on the neuroscience thing can have a mechanistic explanation. To me, that's not sort of disproving of what it is like to write poetry and to therefore hopefully be able to evoke Very particular, hopefully, feelings in people that are maybe, like I said, more than the sum of their parts.

SPEAKER_00The explanation for why I'm able to do that, it's just enriching of the whole thing, but it doesn't eliminate what it's like to do it. And I think that there's, for me, a lesson there in applying that same idea towards spirituality, where like, It doesn't mean that you have to stop looking for mechanistic explanations, but the thing I always use is like, if you talk about the love that you have for your partner or your family or something like this,

SPEAKER_00obviously someone who's more sort of reductionist or maybe even not, but they want to come in and say like, okay, so... What's going on in hormone cascade when you're having that feeling of love? You've got, you know, oxytocin is coming and, you know, these different hormones and things. None of that's wrong. But to say, oh, the love that you have for your partner is just oxytocin, brah, is such a... just an incredibly impoverished way of looking at the idea.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, it's just... Yeah, maybe there's that correlation, but it's still not answering the question of why oxytocin makes you feel that way. Freud used to dismiss mystical feeling as just the desire to crawl back into the womb. Okay, well... What is the womb? You dream about a flower and Freud's like, you're just dreaming of the vagina. It's like, okay, what is a vagina?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's sort of

SPEAKER_00a can kick.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. You're kicking the can down the road. It's like, yeah, we all come out of vaginas into this world. And that's why Christians worship Mother Mary. Great. Thanks, Freud. You're right. It's just like a slight tilt in your vision and all of a sudden you see that like the most biological supposed explanations are actually quite profound.

SPEAKER_01I mean people come out of other people and every human being was Conceived through an act of love. It might have been a fleeting act of love, but, you know, I mean, I guess in some cases there are rapes that lead to pregnancies. So, you know, there's a lot of evil to account for in this world. And I think the Odyssey, there's not really, as far as I can know, any good scientific arguments against the most robust forms of theology.

SPEAKER_01The strongest... Evidence against the existence of a loving God I think is evil and just the fact that babies get cancer and all the other terrible things that happen. I think there are ways of responding to that issue of why there's so much suffering in the world. Still though, relating to the biological facts of our everyday existence, That we die, the nature of pregnancy and birth.

SPEAKER_01I mean, you can't just look at these facts and not have spiritual feelings begin to rush through you, I think. And I mean, when you look at these phenomena, birth and death, biological facts, right? But not just as biological facts, but like feel them from the inside out. And relate to the birth of your own child or the death of a loved one and to just be

SPEAKER_01in that relationship to these phenomena. Again, mundane facts of our animal existence and yet portals into the infinite at the same time. If you just quiet your conceptual mind that wants to say, well, we can explain that and the genes

SPEAKER_00and the hormones and the blah, blah,

SPEAKER_01blah. No, just be with it. And feel it as a human being who you don't know where the fuck you came from or where you're going. Like we're all watching this mystery. And then, yeah, bring in the science, but as a way of relating to the mystery. I think that's a different way we can do this whole science and spirituality thing. That's not woo, because we got to deal with the facts. It's not all about you getting your secret fantasies fulfilled.

SPEAKER_01It's not a create your own reality rollercoaster ride. That's not the nature of human existence. But nor is it just this meaningless machine. It's just as much child abuse to tell a kid in a Baptist community, you're going to hell, you four-year-old. You're sinful. You better shape up. It's just as much child abuse to say that as it is to say, This is a dead, dumb universe, and the only meaning you're going to find here is what you win for yourself

SPEAKER_01in competition with everybody else who's fighting for a place on this earth. That's also child abuse, as far as I'm concerned. You're front-loading this mystery way too much to tell the child either of those stories, I think.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think I'm inclined to agree at this point, because having been that guy... I think... I'll say it about me. I suspect it applies to other atheists and skeptics and things. I think that we get caught in this thing where we're like, well, no, the universe is cold and dead and lifeless. And here I stand on the clifftop, a proud, unyielding atheist who has no need of God.

SPEAKER_00I think a lot of we atheists are getting every bit as much sort of narrative satisfaction out of our, quite frankly, fucking delusions of rugged individualism that the religious person is getting from their faith. And it goes back to that thing, like we sort of started talking about, about, you know, these things occurring within narrative. It's still a narrative. You know, like it's true on the one point on the one side where if you have someone who's really staunch religious being like,

SPEAKER_00no, you know, the purpose of reality is to bring glory to God. And this is how you do that. And if you don't do it this way, then you're doing it wrong. Like, yeah, we're within our rights to push back against that. But it's every bit as much of a worldview to say, nope, it's dead and meaningless. It's like just because it doesn't have that kind of meaning that maybe we were taught that it has. It also doesn't mean that there is some other kind of meaning, but when you say the universe is cold and dead and meaningless, you are making a positive assertion.

SPEAKER_01You're telling a story. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I think the problem with many of us on the atheist side of things is we've deluded ourselves into telling ourselves that we aren't telling ourselves a story. And I think there's this sort of, it's an understandable progression. But I think it's this natural path of literalism that happens where we start out, maybe we're just sort of fed a bill of goods, a religious bill of goods, and we kick away from that and we say, oh, well, no, I don't want to do that. I want to value reason.

SPEAKER_00You know, I want to, you know, reason is how I want to navigate the world. I think which is, which can be really good and healthy and fine, particularly if you're coming out of a high control religion, taking the reins back, so to speak, and be like, no, I, I'm, you know, it comes home to me. I'm going to figure the world out. I think that can be a good thing. And I think reason is important, but I, I feel like I always see this drift that happened to me. And I feel like I see it happen in a lot of my fellow atheists where this drift happens, where it goes from, I am a man who values reason.

SPEAKER_00To then saying, well, I'm a man who values reason, so that means I'm a reasonable man. And then after that, and that seems pretty innocuous. You're like, well, what else is a reasonable man but a man that values reason? Okay, fair enough. But then the next step after that is, well, seeing as I'm a reasonable man, all of my conclusions were arrived at by a reasonable man, and therefore my conclusions are reasonable.

SPEAKER_00And now we have a fucking problem.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Because we have lost the sauce. And now we're viewing ourselves as we end up in this delusional place where we think, I care about reason, I care about facts, and therefore my views on the world are sort of like coterminous with facts. And that's bullshit. That is absolute bullshit. It doesn't mean you're wrong about everything, but you, if you're talking about sort of epistemically, you are, to me at least, you are now in a state of epistemic delusion because you've come

SPEAKER_00to believe something about yourself that isn't fucking true.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I mean, this point about story and myth is really important, and maybe we, I think we should end on this because I'm getting hungry. Yeah. I am an animal, a rational animal, but still an

SPEAKER_00animal nonetheless.

SPEAKER_01So just psychologically speaking, for the sake of our own self-esteem to not just be depressed to get out of bed in the morning, we need to have a narrative about who we are. Which is kind of what you're speaking to. And sometimes we get a little carried away at the narrative, like, well, I'm a reasonable man, so I wouldn't believe in bullshit. Therefore, everything I say is rooted in logic and facts. But beyond that, let's be scientific for a minute and look at the anthropological evidence

SPEAKER_01and cognitive psychology and developmental psychology and understand that to become rational, there's a debate.

SPEAKER_00Uh-oh. Got the freeze. You froze up.

SPEAKER_01I'm not sure if you can hear me, Matt.

SPEAKER_00Oh, no, we lost him. Well, I will... I guess we'll go ahead and end it there. I know he said he needed to go eat. I'll reach out to him here on DMs here in a minute.

SPEAKER_01Oh. Oops.

SPEAKER_00Let me invite him back real quick. I feel weird. Hey. There you are. He's back. Lost you there for a second.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, I don't know exactly where I got cut off, but I think just to say psychologically, anthropologically, developmentally, historically, story and narrative consciousness, like mythic consciousness, precedes scientific and rational consciousness. And in a way that scientific rational consciousness actually depends upon the cognitive achievement of like a kind of narrative identity. And so if you just think you can get rid of myth and narrative and keep the reason

SPEAKER_01and the science, you're actually sawing off the branch that you're perched on. I mean, study like the developmental and cognitive psychologist Merlin Donald's work on how homo sapiens actually move through a kind of episodic consciousness through a narrative consciousness and then only gradually developed in the midst of those earlier more vestigial forms of consciousness,

SPEAKER_01a kind of theoretical reflective capacity. Yeah. And we're at risk. I mean, part of the reason we're in a meaning crisis right now and we've got this untethered technoscientific juggernaut that's just rampaging around the world, the earth, destroying everything is because we've severed the theoretical mind from its embodied, emotive, narrative, and mythic

SPEAKER_01context that actually roots it In our animal and earthly existence, story has a biological function for our species, right? And we're pretending like we could do without it. So even if we're going to be scientific about this and look at our own anthropological development, it's so important to remember that there is no escape from myth. The most damaging and destructive myth on the planet right now is the myth of mythlessness.

SPEAKER_01That we might somehow bootstrap ourselves into a pure rationality.

SPEAKER_00The assumption that that's worth wanting as well is a big assumption. We can draw to a close here. I think it's a really active sort of thing because I'm realizing even in myself, as open as I am in having these conversations, when we talk about You know, myth and these different things. It's almost like I've been, uh, I can't, maybe indoctrinated would be the word. I don't know. Um, I feel like so much of modern culture, um,

SPEAKER_00it's like, it tries to teach us to hate that part of ourselves to have like a guilt. You know what I mean? Um, particularly for people on the sort of skepticism side of things of like, You know, if we open up ourselves to some of these experiences, if we start to think in these sort of ways, it's been almost, I think, sort of villainized, you know? And we also, I think, don't,

SPEAKER_00you know, I say this in a purely metaphorical sense, but it's like, you know, if we sort of lost our way from God, we also have no tools as to how to get back, even if we wanted to.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So, and, you know, I'm, I'm hoping that, you know, we're all sort of navigating in our own ways and, you know, we, we approach things differently, but I'm, I'm hoping that conversations like this, um, you know, move the needle for someone where they are able to re-approach these things. And, and as a result, just have a more fulfilled and richer existence, you know?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, no, thank you for convening this conversation, Ishmael. And I'm glad that you, you know, like in Melville's Moby Dick, you survived the well of your Baptist upbringing and lived it by the tail. Because I think that type of experience, you know this from the inside out. And I think in speaking your mind and hosting these conversations, you can help other people find their way out.

SPEAKER_01Not just into angry atheism, but into a way of relating to this mystery of being human that invites more curiosity and openness and care and love into the world. I think that's More than certainty about what happens after we die or anything is how we show up here while we're alive for each other and with each other and just to start a different kind of conversation.

SPEAKER_01So, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Well, thank you so much for doing this and thank you to everybody who's, everyone who's joined us. Obviously, if you're here from my side of the fence and you're not subscribed to Matt, go ahead and fix that now. Also, if you came in partway through and you've enjoyed this here in a bit, this will post to both Spotify and then probably tomorrow it will also post to YouTube under my podcast Wunderlost, W-O-N-D-E-R-L-O-S-T.

SPEAKER_00And yes, thank you so much to you, Matt, again, for talking to me again. I thoroughly enjoyed the first time. This has been amazing as well. Maybe next time, if we do another one, we can talk about Gerda.

SPEAKER_01Goethe, yeah, for sure. I always love to talk to a fellow Aquarian. Not going to let me live.

SPEAKER_00You said it in the beginning. You were like, huh, so Aquarius? I was like, damn it.

SPEAKER_01Good times. Talk to you soon.

SPEAKER_00Thanks so much. Goodbye. Have a good night, everyone.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Eternity Tells No Tales

    Nov 20, 20262 hr 56 minAudio

    A talk for my fellow PCC faculty and graduate students at our annual retreat this past week. This talk was my attempt to share a perplexity, not a finished theory. What is the source of form in the living world? How do...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Platonic Space, Organic Agency, and Creative Evolution

    Oct 20, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    One of the important ideas that Tim and I discussed last night was his threefold differentiation of the inquired (natural science), the speculative (metaphysics), and the prosaic (everyday experience). I agree with him...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Transitioning With Whitehead

    Oct 10, 20261 hr 22 minAudio

    Moderator: Andrew M. DavisPanelists: Matthew David Segall, Sherry D. Kling, and Thomas Jay Oord Welcome and introductions ANDREW DAVIS: Welcome, everybody. Good to see you all. We’re late in Beer Camp, and it looks like...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Wisdom Famine: The Science of Meaning Making in a Disenchanted World

    Oct 10, 20261 hr 17 minAudio

    Participants. Dan Koch, moderator; Myron Penner; Sarah Lane Ritchie; Matthew David Segall. See https://theologybeer.camp/2026speakers for bios. Transcript: Dan: If you’re going to be making some meaning you’ve got to be...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Evolving God

    Oct 9, 202628 minAudio

    I was originally supposed to be in dialogue with Tim Miller of Our Evolving God, but he had to take care of a loved one and so missed this year’s Theology Beer Camp in Kansas City. He prepared some remarks that were...

    Credit the people on this episode