A talk for my fellow PCC faculty and graduate students at our annual retreat this past week. This talk was my attempt to share a perplexity, not a finished theory. What is the source of form in the living world? How do eternal forms participate in our actual experience, and how does our actual experience participate in forms? My title adapts Whitehead: “eternal objects tell no tales as to their ingressions.” Whitehead is an inverted Platonist. He starts with concrete facts of experience, and yet eternal objects remain an essential aspect of his philosophy, because an actual occasion is a limitation and a selection among an infinitude of possibility. The mind doesn’t create eternal objects, but neither do they govern the mind. The agency is not with the forms. The agency is with the organisms, and with the occasions of experience that compose them moment by moment. The whole talk in one sentence: does a tadpole’s tail already contain every tale that will ever be told of it? Stuart Kauffman argues that the future of the evolving biosphere cannot be deduced, even in principle. This is not just about epistemic limits. There are no future facts, only future possibilities. The future is not yet actual and yet it’s real, which is why a philosophy of creative advance needs something like eternal objects. The inherited explanatory hierarchy gives numb and dumb stuff primary explanatory authority. Everything is to be explained by the strange marriage of chance and necessity. Reductive physicalism and intelligent design both assume the same mechanistic universe: the atheist and the classical theist are quarreling over the same image: an omnipotent, external engineer-father and his machine world. Whitehead turns this picture upside down and inside out. Science is becoming the study of organisms, and we can learn from biology how to historicize physics, so that the so-called laws are better understood as widespread habits. Natural philosophy’s task is to explain how nature generates genuinely novel forms without reducing their emergence either to random chance or to the execution of a pre-planned blueprint. The third way is that forms affect facts by becoming lures, not stamps. The embryo is the paradigm case, since it is not an assemblage of parts, but a division from wholeness. Plato’s Timaeus already points this way. The demiurge’s first account is interrupted by the Khôra, and I read that false start as Plato deliberately performing the impossibility of preformation. The demiurge has to persuade, and the cosmos is born as a living creature, so Plato’s universe is ultimately less an artifact than an embryo. But his world-soul remains eternal and complete, a closed circle. Schelling and Whitehead insist that the circle be broken open and become a spiral. Three biologists are my friendly enemies here. Michael Levin is pulling biology upward toward eternity, with a Platonic space of patterns under positive pressure. My worry is that he turns forms into puppeteers. Tim Jackson is pulling biology downward toward pure variation, with no need for eternal objects. My response is that variation and invariance are co-ultimate, like the poles of a magnet. Stu Kauffman is pulling biology forward toward novelty, through exaptation and the adjacent possible. They have left me in a hostage situation, negotiating for the release of two weight-bearing categories: God and eternal objects. I don’t think Darwin is Plato’s undertaker. I think Darwin is inviting Platonism to evolve. Whitehead has three basic kinds of entities: occurrences, recurrences, and endurances. An important fourth kind are the propositions, which I also call allurances: lures for feeling, hybrids of fact and form, felt and aimed at for their interest before they are judged true or false. Even oysters entertain propositions, and a Micronesian stick chart is a proposition you can hold in your hands. My proposal is that Kauffman’s unprestatable possibilities are not new eternal objects but new propositions. Novelty only arrives when history supplies new logical subjects for a proposition to be about. The spiral of fifths shows how invariant form and open evolution go together. The ratio of three to two is a definite potentiality that has no birthday, yet the spiral of fifths doesn’t actually close. The closed circle becomes an open spiral. This is how eternity falls in love with time. Pure genesis without invariant form would be an indefinite flux; pure form without genesis would be determinism. Hold the polarity and you get form in genesis: evolutionary Platonism. God, in this picture, is no longer a designer issuing commands but a lure, the source of emotion rather than locomotion: an eternally evolving embryo, so that cosmogenesis is also the embryogenesis of the divine. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit footnotes2plato.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01I don't know if we have the power, but I have the power, so I will speak up. If Robert McDermott weren't here, he would say that. We're still missing a lot. Yeah, yeah, people are still rolling in. So I'm just going to kind of slow roll into my
SPEAKER_02presentation with a couple
SPEAKER_00of questions because I just want to know how many Platonists and how many Aristotelians are in my audience?
SPEAKER_03Fair question.
SPEAKER_00Or if anyone's really difficult, like Sean. Okay. Is everyone going to be difficult about that question? Good, me too. I couldn't place white men on one side or the other. Are there any nominalists in the room? There's not a single nominalist? We just heard a presentation about William James and how awesome he is.
SPEAKER_00An evolutionary, I think he's an evolutionary plagiarist, which is what I'm going to talk about tonight. You don't think William James is a nominal?
SPEAKER_03Not to the extent that I don't think he believes that ideas for the universes are a weird name.
SPEAKER_01Sure. I think he thinks there's something more.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I guess he, James is just, he emphasizes different sides of these sort of dichotomies. But just, he's so concerned about particulars, and he doesn't want them to be overshadowed by generalities.
SPEAKER_01We need to be in dialogue with nominalism, even if it's wrong.
SPEAKER_00But, uh-oh, my computer went to sleep. Actually, maybe I should plug this thing in, so that that doesn't happen again. I have my plug, one second. People are still arriving, so don't worry.
SPEAKER_03Let me just get my plug. You don't belong.
SPEAKER_03That was Plato a Pythagorean. All the good people.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Plato was a Pythagorean, a Parmenidean, a Heraclidean. Not a Democratean, but... What was it? Was Pythagorean. Was Pythagorean. Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Almost everyone gets to be right in my universe, my pluriverse. Almost everyone. All right. We have power. Should we start? Yes. Is Jake here? No.
SPEAKER_01I love VCC! I love VCC! I love VCC! I love VCR! [music]
SPEAKER_03who needs no introduction. [music]
SPEAKER_03Do you guys know that Matt has published many things on Schelling?
SPEAKER_01I was joking earlier, having seen all of these presentations on Whitehead, and this will be another presentation on Whitehead, I feel a little bit guilty when I just led the charge on Whitehead invasion in the BCC, because it wasn't always this way. Speak up.
SPEAKER_00Alright, well, welcome everyone. I'm so grateful that you're showing up here as your full selves and so impressed by everything you've been sharing and I've learned so much over the last few days. And giving this presentation on some ideas that are difficult is actually way easier because of how much I feel like has been set up for me already.
SPEAKER_00Josh gave a presentation on eternal objects that I'm gonna borrow a little bit from quite explicitly as we'll see. And Ian gave a presentation where He talked about how Whitehead understands consciousness,
SPEAKER_01and Jesse gave a presentation with a very simple diagram of concrescence that only had 74 of the phases listed just as a way in. But no, this is going to be my attempt to share a perplexity that I have.
SPEAKER_00And by the end of our time tonight, I hope you too will be perplexed. I don't have any finished Theory here, I'm just gonna try to invite you into some conversations that I've been having with a couple of my biologist friends who are transforming biology. They're Darwinians, but they're also trying to understand form in a way that goes beyond a kind of crude neo-Darwinian reductionism.
SPEAKER_00What is the source of form in the living world?
SPEAKER_01That's the core inquiry that I'm going to be inviting you into, and maybe you have already found yourself having this inquiry. Many of the ideas that I'll share took form this summer. I was invited to give a talk online for a group called the Agential Biology Institute. And people like Stuart Kaufman, a theoretical biologist,
SPEAKER_01was there, Carl Friston, Alicia Herrera was there, Richard Watson, I don't know if you know these names, but they're doing biology in a
SPEAKER_00really process-oriented way, and in a way that I would call kind of evolutionary plaguenism.
SPEAKER_01There's a, I think, Resurgence of interest in this ancient philosopher and sort of school of thought about how not only the human mind relates to ideas but how ideas shape the universe and how the universe participates in ideas. And that's kind of surprising to me. This is a more recent shift in the philosophy of biology. Michael Levin is another biologist I've been in dialogue with.
SPEAKER_01And I never would have expected, say, even as a graduate student or much less as an undergrad, to see biology take what appears to be a platonic turn. So much so that I actually feel like Michael Levin
SPEAKER_00might be coming a little bit too platonist for me. What?
SPEAKER_01Very surprising.
SPEAKER_00So... My title here, Eternity Tells No Tales, this comes from Whitehead's Process and Reality. It's an adaptation of something he says. He says, eternal objects tell no tales as to their ingressions. And I've just shortened that to Eternity Tells No Tales. Let me quote him. What he says right after that, he says, you cannot know what is red, what red is, merely by thinking of redness.
SPEAKER_00You can only find red things by adventuring amid physical experiences in this actual world. This doctrine is the ultimate ground of empiricism, namely that eternal objects don't know tales as to their ingressions. And immediately after this passage, Whitehead explains another one of his categories, what he calls propositions, which are not just logical propositions that we can verbally articulate. Propositions for him are how we feel possibilities and orient towards possibilities
SPEAKER_00and feel the allure of the possible. But for Whitehead, propositions are the possible tales that might be told about particular actualities and particular experiences. Unlike eternal objects, which are just pure possibilities, propositions can be true or false. Because they refer to something determinate, something actual. Eternal objects in and of themselves refer to nothing and so are not yet true or false.
SPEAKER_00So eternity tells no tales. And one of the things I want to argue about the state of biology today, the study of life, is that what's called the agential turn, or you could call it the platonic turn, I mean there are lots of turns, Occurring. But what I want to argue is that it can't really just be contained in biology. It also is going to bleed into how we understand the rest of the universe, the other ologies.
SPEAKER_00It's going to have to transform the categories by which we understand physics. And so it's moving downward in that sense into physics and also It's going to have to move upward and change how we understand theology, I think. It's going to change physics by, as Darwin did to our understanding of life, historicizing physics. Physics has been, for the modern period, since Newton and Galileo and Descartes,
SPEAKER_00focused on finding eternal
SPEAKER_01laws that don't change. And as Brian So passionately and clearly
SPEAKER_00showed us last night, the best science we have is evolutionary. The whole universe is an evolutionary process. The whole universe is a historical process. So that's one way in which what we know about biology and the living world is bleeding down into physics and changing how we understand so-called laws of physics and just the whole time developmental nature of the universe. But I think it's also It needs to change how we think about theology so that God ceases to be conceived as some kind of impassive
SPEAKER_00and unmoved eternal engineer who designs the world from outside but becomes instead something more like what I'm going to describe as, this is a bit of a paradox, but an eternally evolving embryo. An eternally evolving embryo so that cosmogenesis The development of the physical universe is also seen from another perspective, the embryogenesis of the divine.
SPEAKER_00But like I said, this isn't a finished theory. This is really just a way into... I'm trying to infect you with my perplexity about the nature form and how it participates in facts. In our actual experience. How do eternal forms participate in our actual experience and how does our actual experience participate in forms? Whitehead says that his whole philosophy just casts the ghost of a glimmer of light upon that mystery. And I'm leaning on his glimmer a lot here.
SPEAKER_00As he says, philosophy begins in wonder and after philosophy has done its best, the wonder remains. But maybe the emotion of wonder has been There's been brought to it some elucidation, some sense of the appreciation, a deepening of the appreciation of the mystery. So that's the best that I can hope to do tonight. We're going to talk about external optics.
SPEAKER_01Whitehead's famous for, people who haven't read Whitehead know about at least The footnotes2Plato quote, that all of European philosophy is safely characterized as a series of footnotes
SPEAKER_00to Plato. But they've also heard of misplaced concreteness, right? And so here he's describing what he means by that. The explanatory purpose of philosophy is often misunderstood. Its business is to explain the emergence of the more abstract things from the more concrete things. It is a complete mistake to ask how concrete particular fact can be built up Out of universals. The answer is in no way. The true philosophic question is how can concrete fact exhibit entities abstract
SPEAKER_00from itself and get participated in by its own nature? So I know it's a Platonist, but he's He's an inverted Platonist in the sense that for him, explaining the universe doesn't begin with a heaven of forms, eternal forms, or laws of physics. And then from that beginning, you know, the idea,
SPEAKER_00as if the idea were to explain how the world gets assembled out of those physical laws or how those eternal forms come to be Imitated by the physical world. How those forms might stamp their order upon a merely passive interior world. That's not his project. I'm going to argue that it isn't necessarily Plato's project either. But for Whitehead he's very clear, clearer than Plato often was,
SPEAKER_00Despite what I'll argue when I talk about Timaeus, it's very clear that we start with concrete facts of experience when we're doing philosophy. He's Jamesian in that sense. He's a radical empiricist. Nothing can be left out just because it doesn't fit into our neat-tidy system of abstractions. Always begin with experience and always hold philosophy accountable to experience. But he still is a Platonist in the sense that he wants to ask how, in our experience, we are participating in eternal forms. And what he means by an eternal object or an eternal form is that it's something
SPEAKER_00that recurs across particular experiences, like the color red or the quality of two-ness. We usually think of numbers as quantities, but each number has a quality too.
SPEAKER_01So shapes and colors and numbers, ratios, as we'll see. I'm going to talk about the fifth. And the circle of fifths, or the spiral of fifths, actually, and Jack set me up pretty well for that.
SPEAKER_00And so he's not getting rid of the idea of eternal objects, even though he's a process philosopher who's really focused on experience. And a lot of people come to Whitehead's philosophy expecting it to be all process all the time, and then they stub their toe or bang their head against eternal objects and go, what the heck is this doing here? But it's an essential aspect of his philosophy. Actual occasions of experience were composed of the entirety of the universe. But what is an actual occasion of experience? It's an integration or a synthesis of possibilities,
SPEAKER_00but in synthesizing all those possibilities, which are eternal, something novel, some novel value is achieved that is a limitation and a selection among that infinitude of possibility. Right? And so an actual occasion is nothing else than a limitation of its possibility. Where possibilities are all these eternal objects. So you can't really understand what Whitehead means by an actual occasion of experience unless you also have an appreciation for this other category
SPEAKER_00of the eternal objects. But Whitehead's inverting Plato's tendency, and if we have to remember, Plato wrote dialogues, not doctrines, and all the best reputations of Plato's theory of ideas are also in the dialogues. So what is Plato's position? That's not an easy question to answer. But Plato does seem to have this habit of granting eternal objects or forms preeminent reality.
SPEAKER_00Whereas everything else is a pale imitation of those forms. Did you guys just see a notification? No. Okay, no one shows up for me, great. My brother's in SF right now and lives in the Mission and his apartment is flooding. He's okay. So, for Whitehead, he's inverting Platonism, he's giving preeminence to actual experience and not abstract form.
SPEAKER_00But he's also not, he's not a nominalist by any means, which is to say he doesn't think that universals are just names that human beings come up with to group particular things together. Eternal objects, they have a reality independent of our minds, and in fact our minds function because of that reality in the way that they do. So he's not a nominalist. The mind doesn't create eternal objects. But neither do those eternal objects govern the mind.
SPEAKER_00The mind has a creative role. And the eternal objects are in some way in a co-creative relationship with our minds, with our consciousness, with our thinking activity, while still remaining eternal. So there's a lot, this is the perplexity, right? And importantly, and I'm going to get into why this is so important, you know, the concrete occasions of experience, they have preeminent reality.
SPEAKER_00They achieve novel values with each crescent moment, each pulse of experience is achieving something. A new perspective is being born moment by moment that has never, it's new in the sense that it's never been before. It's once occurring. It's completely and utterly unique in the whole history of the universe. And that's happening everywhere, all the time, in Whitehead's vision. But they cannot be what they are. Their novelty itself is a function of, again, the selection made by each of those occasions of experience from this infinitude
SPEAKER_00of eternal possibilities. But the agency for Whitehead is with the actual occasions of experience and with the living organisms that those actual occasions of experience organize themselves into. The agency for Whitehead is not with the forms. The agency is with the organisms, with the occasions of experience that compose those organisms moment by moment. I'll return to that. That's gonna be important when we start talking about what these other biologists are proposing.
SPEAKER_00All right. So this is the whole talk in one sentence. Does a tadpole's tail already contain every tail that will ever be told of it? So the theoretical biologist, Stu Kaufman, he is arguing that the future of the biosphere, the evolving biosphere, cannot be deduced, even if we had complete knowledge of the present state
SPEAKER_00of everything on the Earth. Down to the subatomic scale. We could not, even in principle, deduce what would happen next. Because evolution is a creative process and there is no pre-statable phase space of options that it's gonna move into like would be the case in some kind of statistical grid of probability. Evolution is breaking into, in Kauffman's sense, new possibilities all the time.
SPEAKER_00New possibilities are coming forth, not just new actualities. And just to be very clear here, when he's denying that there's any predetermined state space or phase space that evolution is moving into and saying the future is not deducible, he's not really talking about our knowledge of the future. He's not saying we can't know the future because of our limited And we don't know all the initial conditions exactly right. It's not just about epistemic limits.
SPEAKER_00He's saying that even in principle, ontologically speaking, there are novelties emerging all the time. Novel functions in the biological world. I'll talk about feathers. And when feathers didn't originally emerge for flight, they emerged for display, for sexual display, and for insulation, and then eventually some feather dinosaurs discovered that they could use them for something else.
SPEAKER_00That was a new creative possibility, Kaufman is saying, that could not have been predicted, even with complete knowledge of The state and trajectory of all the particles that composed the organisms on the earth at that time. And further, even God, from a process perspective, from Whitehead's perspective, doesn't know that feathers might eventually become for flight. So even God is surprised by evolution in this view.
SPEAKER_00So a tadpole's tail and the occasions of experience that compose that tail, which for Whitehead, like the physical tail that we can see and touch is actually a society or historical root of actual occasions that are repeating a similar pattern. But the occasions that compose that enduring society that we call the tail or the tadpole, Those occasions are prehending everything that has ever happened.
SPEAKER_00And so there is a lot of history that's accumulating and allowing a tadpole to be a tadpole. And so the question I'm asking here though is, is its entire future contained in what is achieved by that history? And if it's not contained in that history, in that past, Then where is it? Where is the future? And Whitehead's idea of eternal objects, you might initially think is in stark opposition to a philosophy
SPEAKER_00of creative advance and novelty, but when you start to ask about the ontological status of the future, all of a sudden you realize that you need something like eternal objects. And he even calls it a realm of eternal objects, which I both I resist that terminology but I also get why he says that. The future has a very strange type of reality because it's not yet actual and yet it's real.
SPEAKER_00There are real potentialities that are radiating out moment by moment and every decision that we make changes the constellation. Of those real potentialities in a way that could not have been predicted in advance, right? So this isn't a fixed phase space that's already out there where there's a certain probability for any decision I might make. Every decision I make updates that whole field, changes that field, right? So this is why I said earlier that what we actually experience
SPEAKER_00and the eternal possibilities are in a co-evolving relationship because it's step-by-step The array, the constellation of possibilities is being updated. This is more or less what Stuart Kaufman is saying about the nature of evolution. So there are no future facts. There are only future possibilities. So this is the inherited explanatory hierarchy
SPEAKER_00in the physicalist or materialist conception of the universe. This is what modern science has been schooling us in for the last few centuries, the methods of mechanistic explanation where you reduce Everything to its parts, and you abstract the laws that govern the motion of those parts. That's the picture that we're left with when you do that. The laws of physics explain chemistry, and the laws of chemistry explain biology, and the laws of biology explain psychology.
SPEAKER_00And so, despite really a second scientific revolution over a hundred years ago, this is still a basic story we're being told to this day, right? Matter somehow emerged from a quantum void. We were exploring that mystery a little bit last night. Particles and antiparticles and so on. And then somehow dead matter came to life. And then somehow conscious minds burst forth from life. And the word emergence is often used here.
SPEAKER_00Which is sort of a placeholder, I guess, for a future explanation in many cases in this paradigm. Right? So mind bursts forth from life and then in the standard story, you know, what's the purpose of mind? I guess, you know, conscious beings and conscious human beings in particular are just here to extract the life energies of the earth to enrich billionaires. I guess that's the right. But through the whole story, numb and dumb stuff is being given primary explanatory authority.
SPEAKER_00What's really going on here? It's just a bunch of stuff colliding according to laws of physics. Well, where did those come from? That's an odd thing for physicists to have to deal with. So mechanistic physicalism, it's imagining that all of natural history is just this complicated trajectory through a list of optional moves that are laid out in advance, right,
SPEAKER_00in some sort of a phase space, even with quantum physics. That phase space is a statistical space that in some sense it might be infinite, but it's a kind of infinitude where we can still convince ourselves that it's merely an epistemic limitation, that we just don't know. How the way of function will collapse. Because we're inside the system. But God, who's outside, would know. So, in other words, when a physicist says, but God would know.
SPEAKER_00Like, the God's eye view is so essential to this mechanistic view of physics. Which is why, you know, there's always this strange sort of demiurgic deity hiding underneath the laws of physics. Because This whole pyramid doesn't really get off the ground unless you have some account of where the laws came from, and there's the multiverse, of course, so Stephen Hawking can just say, well, there's infinitely many other universes, and ours just happens to be the one with the fine-tuned parameters to give rise
SPEAKER_00to enough matter to create stars that created the heavier elements that created life that somehow became conscious and so on. That just feels, I mean, You can say creationism is absurd. You know, so there's still this need for God to impose these arbitrary eternal laws that are exquisitely calibrated. So reductive physicalism and intelligent design Both seem to me to assume
SPEAKER_00the same mechanistic universe ultimately. So the atheist and the classical theist are actually quarreling over the same image. This omnipotent external engineer father and his machine world. That's the image in the background of mechanistic materialism just as much as intelligent design. So Whitehead turns this whole picture upside down and inside out.
SPEAKER_00And I've been brooding, as Isabel Spangers would say, over his comment in Science in the Modern World for nearly 20 years now. He says, biology, science is becoming the study of organisms. Biology is the study of the larger organisms, whereas physics is the study of the smaller organisms. This isn't just like a new conceptual frame. I think it's like, it feels like more like removing the picture from the frame
SPEAKER_00and turning it upside down. It's a totally new picture where what we think of as the material, physical, inorganic world is actually a subset of a much wider process which is ultimately alive and ultimately divine. And that what materialistic physics had told us Was this unfathomably large empty space is actually, it's organic through and through in the sense
SPEAKER_00that there is no such thing as empty space for white men. There is only creative advance. There is only ultimately creativity. So when we imagine empty space, as Brian was trying to show us, Last night, it's actually the quantum void. It's seething with energy and generativity. And I don't want to equate, you know, the quantum void or the quantum vacuum to divine life, by any means.
SPEAKER_00But there's a way in which the new physics is making it very difficult to maintain a mechanistic view of the universe, where matter is dead. And so Whitehead's point here in saying everything is alive and everything is organic, he's not trying to say that electrons are little animals scavenging for their next meal or something. But at the same time, when you think about the nature of energy, they don't call it a particle zoo for nothing. This isn't dead matter anymore.
SPEAKER_00It's all active relationships and resonances and vibrations that are non-local. What he was really, his whole point in this statement though about science becoming a study of organisms is that, you know, biology, our study of life can't be, we shouldn't imagine that physics has the final word. That this old kind of physics that's focused on eternal laws has the final word.
SPEAKER_00As if organisms were to be subject to the more fundamental laws of the dead. Those laws are, as Robert Rosen, another theoretical biologist, would say, the laws of physics are not generic enough to account for life. And that life, or you could say self-organization, as Brian was describing it last night, is more generic, more fundamental, than dead matter. And that actually what we think of as dead matter is very often,
SPEAKER_00on the surface of this planet, something excreted by life. It's what's left over. Trash. But that, you know, the planet has, over billions of years, often figured out ways of bringing back into the metabolic activity that sustains further life. So Whitehead was daring to imagine here that physics might have something to learn from the life sciences.
SPEAKER_00And so as I said earlier, what I'm proposing here is that we learn from biology how to historicize physics. To see the physical world as also being a product of an evolutionary process. And so the regularities that physics discovers, the laws, so-called, Might be better understood as widespread habits. These are stable roots of inheritance, highly repetitive forms of behavior that produce enduring societies.
SPEAKER_00Why don't we talk about the electromagnetic society? Uh, which was, you know, what we were looking at, uh, the cosmic microwave background radiation. We're all bathed by that form of social order in white-headed sense. And he's using society beyond just human groups to talk about groups of anything, uh, at all scales. We're in the electromagnetic society as far out as we can see. We're bathed in the order that was achieved, uh, tens of billions of years ago.
SPEAKER_00And then there are, within that, other forms of societies that get nested. You know, we exist inside of a galaxy. It's this other form of social order. An environment of stable behavior that allows for complexity to emerge within it. And stars. And then second generation stars with planets, rocky planets, and so on. These are societies or environments that achieve a form of order that's dependent on all the other orders that they're nested within. And all the way down to our own physical bodies composed of cells.
SPEAKER_00Whitehead talks about all of these layers of the environment sheltering within a stream of entirely living occasions of experience in our brain. There's order upon order upon order, with lots of chaos in between, sheltering a stream of experience that we call I, our self-consciousness. But that self-consciousness is entirely dependent on everything else going on around it. All the way out to the divine life. So, all of that is the achievement of evolutionary becoming.
SPEAKER_00None of that is eternal. A hydrogen atom will last a long time if you leave it alone. It's not eternal. It emerged at a certain point in the history of the universe. Electrons emerged at a certain point in the history of the universe. Stars, galaxies, obviously. Everything on this planet emerged in the course of history. And importantly also, contrary to classical physics, nature is not a bloodless dance of numbers. You can't just reduce it to mathematics, as powerful as mathematics are, as eternal objects.
SPEAKER_00Nature is full-blooded, right, let's say. Real facts are happening. And so the largest circle there is the divine life, but... That's not to say that God is someone outside of the process, the whitehead. If you ask, well, where is God? Not up there. God exists inside of each moment of our experience. And so God is radically distributed in this vision. And so really to get this right, I would need to have like, you know,
SPEAKER_00the yin symbol has the little dots on each side. Like there needs to be a little divine life dot inside of the physical and the biological and the psychical organisms. So, as I understand it, natural philosophy's task is to explain how nature generates genuinely novel organic forms without reducing their emergence either to random chance or to the execution
SPEAKER_00of a pre-planned blueprint. So, as Jacques Bonneau, a French biologist of the 20th century would say, Nature is just chance and necessity, right? That's all you need. You need chance, which is just an explanation of novelty that is reducing it to the result of an accumulation of accidents that are sifted by a process of natural selection in the biological world. And then you have those laws
SPEAKER_00that are determining the statistical patterns, at least, that all chance accidents must obey. Even if you can't know where an individual particle will be, in aggregate, the laws of statistics allow you to make very precise predictions about how all those individual things will behave, right? So this is, this animation is an example of how that works.
SPEAKER_00But there's another way here. Where the forms, or what would be called eternal laws in classical physics, they do affect facts, but they affect facts by becoming lures. They're not stamps that are forcing a certain pattern upon the world. And it is the living organisms that are creatively deciding moment by moment how
SPEAKER_00to be affected by those forms. The forms aren't determining what happens. The creative decisions of organisms determine what happens, but those creative decisions are informed by the constellations of possibilities that are more or less desirable. And the desirability of a constellation depends on the perspective of the organism that's prehending them, but it also depends upon the definite structure that those constellations take. It's not just made up by the organism.
SPEAKER_00So there's a structure to this problem of eternal objects. It's not determining what happens. It's luring organisms, coaxing them in the direction of what would be most valuable in the next moment. And so really what we're exploring here is not just the mystery of form, but also final causality. So there's formal causality, Where do the shapes of things come from?
SPEAKER_00And final causality, which is, well, what are they for? Where are they aiming at? And thinking about formal and final causality, it's been a, you know, the more I thought about preparing for this presentation, it's followed me from the beginning of my interest in philosophy, when I learned about how physics is rooted in just this understanding of efficient causes, pushes from behind. And then I thought about my own experience, and it's like, well, Obviously, lots of things are constraining what I can do next, but I also feel a sense of agency. Where does that come from?
SPEAKER_00And, you know, as someone with a philosophical inclination, I don't pretend to be consistent, but I at least try to be consistent and to think that a universe totally determined by efficient causes somehow left room for me and you and, like, all the things that we like to do as human beings and we hold each other accountable for our actions, you know? We expect one another to behave in certain ways because we assume we're free. And somehow that stands in sharp contradiction with what physics is telling me
SPEAKER_00the ultimate nature of reality is like. So I couldn't really handle that. And so I'm thinking, how do formal and final causality fit into this cosmology that I've inherited? How do we, again, How can nature be understood to generate genuinely novel forms without reducing their emergence, either to random chance or to the execution of a preformed blueprint? And these first two answers, right, chance and law, they belong together.
SPEAKER_00As the balls fall, each one's bouncing unpredictably, but each one is unpredictable. Again, from our perspective, it's an epistemic limitation. But together, in aggregate, they settle into the same curve every single time. And any statistical judgment, and all of physics is based on statistics now, since the 19th century, any statistical judgment is going to presuppose a settled ground and a defined population of comparable instances
SPEAKER_00over which frequencies can be taken. Which means that the outcomes are going to be drawn from a pre-given set of potentials, of probabilities. And so in classical physicalism or mechanistic physics, everything is, every future is deducible or calculable according to some statistical frequency. And Whitehead goes deep into this question of what is the ground of a statistical judgment? It can't just be another statistical judgment.
SPEAKER_00Statistics only work when we assume the environment remains the same for every instance that follows. We don't live in a universe Where the environment is going to remain the same. We live in an evolving universe. And yet statistics work really well. Not only at the quantum level, but, I don't know why I always go to this example, it's really morbid, but, you know, like 10 to 15 people are going to jump off of the Golden Gate Bridge. On average every year. But which 10 to 15 people is not yet determined?
SPEAKER_00Sorry, that's not. They put a net down there, so most of these people get caught
SPEAKER_03by the net.
SPEAKER_00And surfers bring them in. A whale at once, did you hear this story? So, this third way though is saying that, I'm trying to say that forms affect facts by becoming lures, right? Not stamps in that crude sense of the two-world Platonism. Or the hylomorphism where the form is stamped on the passive matter. Or in the sense of the statistical probability where all of the options are calculable in advance.
SPEAKER_00And the embryo here is the paradigm case of what I'm trying to describe. And Raymond Rieh is really great at getting to the core of this point. The embryo, it's not an assemblage of parts. It's a division from wholeness. You have a zygote. It divides. It divides again, again, again. And Rie would refer to what he calls a theme guiding this process
SPEAKER_00of differentiation, which is something like a proposition, I'm going to suggest, in Whitehead's sense. So this theme in Rie's sense is it's soliciting development rather than dictating it. And so it functions in that sense as a lure rather than a law. So, okay, now we're really going to dive in. What follows from here, it's part philosophy of biology, it's part speculative cosmology, and it's partly autobiography because this is,
SPEAKER_00I'm sharing conversations that I'm currently in that are, again, perplexing me. Maybe you guys can help me out of my perplexity or... Maybe you'll be upset that now you're really confused and thought I was gonna come up here and teach you something. And also in Brian Swim's sense, this is auto-cosmology, right? Because these are ideas I care about, not just academically merely, but I'm, like many of you, weird enough to care about metaphysics.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, as Whitehead would say, it takes an especially Unordinary mind to care about metaphysics in the sense that you want to analyze the obvious. That's what metaphysics is provided. It's an analysis of the obvious, the things that everybody takes for granted, but for some reason I just can't get past. You want me to believe this and this? The universe is statistically at least determined, and yet I as an individual am free?
SPEAKER_00And any other contradictions that I think we inherit in our cosmology? So this is auto-cosmological in that sense. It's a story about the cosmos, a likely story in Plato's sense. But it's told from within that cosmos by me, by one of its own co-creating creatures. So I'm gonna talk a little bit about Plato's Timaeus.
SPEAKER_00Over 20 years ago now, I guess I made my blog after Whitehead's clip about all of European philosophy being safely characterized as a series of footnotes to Plato. But the Plato that I feel continually nourished by is not the one who supposedly split reality into these two separate worlds, right? A perfect eternal realm forms up in heaven in the mind of God, perhaps, and then an effective world of becoming that's condemned to mere imitation.
SPEAKER_00That's not the Plato that I find so instructive and that has been so formative for me. This is the pre-formationist There's a reading of Plato that can support this view of a two-world setup and a pre-formationism where in some sense the divine had a blueprint, perfect blueprint, and then imposed that blueprint upon the passive material
SPEAKER_00of the world. There's a reading of the Timaeus that would give one that Perspective on what's going on here. And that's, that reading has been very influential. The image of God as an engineer, we fixed all the laws and initial conditions in advance, and then let the clockwork run, right? But Plato's texts are, they're dialogues, right? And they're as pluripotent as it can get. They're multi-valent, they reward many interpretations.
SPEAKER_00Nothing is on the surface. And the dialogue to Maus, I think both can be blamed for seeding these later pre-formationist theories, as I'm calling them, which include, again, intelligent design just as much as mechanistic materialism. But I think the dialogue Timaeus also seeds what used to be called a sort of epigenetic view. Say, in like the time of Kant, in the second half of the 18th century, the biologists were Debating with one another whether life emerges
SPEAKER_00in this pre-formationist way or this epigenetic way. The epigenesis thought life is just emerging spontaneously all the time whereas the pre-formationist thought that every egg or every sperm contains inside of it a smaller life form and inside of that a smaller one, smaller one, smaller one. And life is just a series of Russian dolls that all the beings who will ever exist were created at the beginning by God and it's just a matter of You know, inflating them as you go. And so, it's neither one of these views is strictly speaking correct.
SPEAKER_00We know nowadays because life isn't, there's not just spontaneous generation all the time. There is a lineage. But we also know that when, you know, an ovum and a sperm meet and you have a zygote that this is a new creation, right? This wasn't a series of Russian dolls. But nor did it just spontaneously arise from nowhere. But I think this other view
SPEAKER_00of Plato as developing an evolutionary account of the origins of the universe. I think he's justified, and Whitehead has this reading, he compares the Timaeus to Newton's Scolium and says that actually Plato's Timaeus is less in conflict with our modern understanding of the universe as an evolutionary process where new forms of order are coming into what from one perspective is the chaos
SPEAKER_00before it through a kind of persuasive The persuasion of that new form of order. It was persuasive enough that the universe, which had been wandering and kind of chaotic, was allured to take that form, rather than thinking of it as just the imposition of laws. And so the Timaeus opens with this line, one, two, three, but where is the fourth?
SPEAKER_00It is said that the fourth has fallen ill. And, you know, John Salas has written a great book, Chorology. We'll talk about the Chora. Well, the Chora's right there on the screen. Chorology, trying to examine what is meant by the missing fourth, who has fallen ill. And my friend Danielle Lane, who I was in a dialogue with recently about Plato, And participatory Platonism as we were calling it.
SPEAKER_00She was just sort of hypothesizing that maybe this fourth interlocutor was a woman who was menstruating. Just couldn't be present for this philosophical discussion. Maybe so. But whether it was a menstruating woman or just someone who had fallen ill and was sick, the point I think that Plato's making is that we're embodied preachers, we get ill. We get sick. You might also think of Carl Jung and his idea
SPEAKER_00of the Fourth as the shadow of all these Western Trinitarian ways of thinking. Jung would identify with the feminine, or materiality, darkness, chaos, evil even, right? And so I think there's a lot going on here with this first line. Of Timaeus, that there's this missing fourth. But these are the basic characters, Nus, Ananke, and Korra in the dialogue.
SPEAKER_00Nus is the divine mind, the divine intellect that's contemplating the eternal forms as its model for the cosmos. Ananke is usually translated as necessity, but it's not like our modern sense of Determinism, it's more like the errancy of chance and contingency. And then Quora is this dark and difficult idea, Plato says, that we can only access through kind of bastard reasoning.
SPEAKER_00Almost like a dreamlike state of mind because Quora you could say is like the form of formlessness. It's the mediatrix. What form requires to take on death, to exist as a body, it's the place where form can ingress.
SPEAKER_00And Plato uses a lot of feminine metaphors for Korra. It's the wet nurse of the coming, he says. And it's always kind of, it's a fugitive from formalization. Its motion can't be calculated, it can't be conceptually captured. The Korra, she's everything that the noose leaves out. It's the generative womb, right? Shellingwood would later call this the dark ground.
SPEAKER_00And so, like I said, there is this image in this style of a demiurge designing the world according to this perfect blueprint of forms, you know, a craftsman god who fashions the cosmos as a kind of copy or imitation of the perfect forms. But the demiurge is not actually the main character of this dialogue. As John Salas shows in his book, Chorology, this first account of the astronomer Timaeus trying to explain how the universe was made that begins with the Demiurge,
SPEAKER_00creating a copy of the universe based on the forms, it's interrupted. Timaeus has to start over because he encounters the Korah and realizes, okay, wait, this won't work, let's start over. And this false start, it's not accidental that Plato put this in the dialogue. It's not a matter of just like, Oh, ran out of paper. I have to just continue with this story. I can't, you know. It's not compositional clumsiness. There's a point to this failed attempt to explain the universe.
SPEAKER_00And I would say that what Plato is doing here is deliberately performing the impossibility of preformation. Deliberately performing the impossibility of this idea of the intellect molding the world from a perfect blueprint. This Korah, the Korah interrupts that process and humbles the theorists attempt to explain everything. So Plato starts again, he says, okay, all we can do is, the best we can do is a likely story.
SPEAKER_00And rather than seeing the intellect commanding matter or the Korah, or also called the receptacle, to conform to its plan and its demands, Now the description is that the Demiurge has to persuade and cooperate with contingency and with the Quora to make, you could say, chaosmos out of chaos, if not perfect cosmos, perfect order. And so Whitehead would later say, the creation of the world, said Plato,
SPEAKER_00is the victory of persuasion over force. So the cosmos then isn't just the replication, it's not just Replicated as a flawless copy of an archetype. It's born as a living creature, Plato says. Out of the marriage of Nus and Korah is the soul of the world. The universe is brought forth as a living animal. And living animals have histories. They grow. And so this act of creation requires eternity to mix and mingle with time.
SPEAKER_00And both time and eternity are changed as a result. So, these are these two world images again, right? The manufactured machine and the gestating organism. And the whole history of cosmology has been haunted by these two world images.
SPEAKER_00Machines are assembled from already determinate parts in accordance with some kind of externally imposed plan. Whereas organisms unfold themselves through an imminent activity where the parts produce themselves for the sake of an evolving whole. And with organisms, the future of their life can't be predicted in advance. So the manufactured machine, that world image, can in principle be totally explained from the outside.
SPEAKER_00Whereas the second world image of the gestating organism, I think it invites us into a world without an outside. And that changes the very nature of so-called explanation. We can still do science. Clearly statistics work. But we need to be humble enough to not think that we could have a complete explanation as a result of our Mathematical formulas. So the universe is a living animal, according to Plato.
SPEAKER_00It has soul. It has mind. So Plato's universe ultimately is less an artifact than an embryo. But there's a problem. Plato's world soul is And in that sense, his universe is a kind of, his cosmos is a kind of closed circle.
SPEAKER_00And what I love about philosophers like Schelling and Whitehead, whether or not Hegel fits into this, I'm not sure. But we can, we'll talk about that, I'm sure. I mean, Sean and I were talking about that last semester when we taught Hegel. Shelling and Whitehead insist that the circle be broken open and that it become a spiral.
SPEAKER_00And they push against this reading of this pre-formationist, as I'm calling it, reading of Plato. But their point is not to abolish Platonism, but to free it from the fantasy that eternity has already scripted the whole history of the coming. That everything is already determined in advance by some set of laws or some set of Perfect ideas or some design, right? So Plato's world soul, it's posited by him in his dialogues, or at least he has Timaeus posited, that it's eternal and complete,
SPEAKER_00and this risks closure. The universe is just this closed circle, a moving image of eternity, that if you squint, it starts to look a lot like the deterministic clockwork of Newton and Laplace. And Shelley and Whitehead, and process philosophy more generally, are affirming An ongoing cosmogenesis and a sense of the perpetual incompletion of the universe. So the closed circle becomes an open spiral for them.
SPEAKER_00And the Divine, for both Schelling and Whitehead and I think Teilhard as well in many ways, the Divine is no longer kind of frozen bud on an eternal rose bush. The Divine is not the perfect closure of the cosmic circle represented by that. The Divine instead is a lure amidst this creative unrest that keeps Many blossoms blooming.
SPEAKER_00And so it's a radically distributed sense of the divine. And a form of an understanding of divine creativity that is democratic. Wynette says we live, we find ourselves in a buzzing world amid a democracy of fellow creatures. And each creature is self-creating in the sense that The divine is involved in each creature's ongoing self-creation by providing a lure.
SPEAKER_00So what's the role of God in Whitehead's cosmology? It's to provide what he calls the initial aim that helps lure the subjective aim of each individual creature toward what would be best in the next moment. But each creature decides for itself. It's just that God's providing a A sense of, a hint of what would be best. Whitehead says, God holds up a mirror to each creature to reflect back to it its own greatness and its own beauty while leaving the creatures free to decide what to become next.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so now these are the conversations that I've been having with three biologists who have perspectives on the nature and the status of form. And they're friendly enemies in the sense that we're involved in a sparring match, but we really learn a lot from each other. I would learn a lot from them. So the first one is Michael Levin, a developmental biologist at Tufts University.
SPEAKER_00And I am absolutely amazed and astonished by his empirical research, which I'll go into in more depth in a moment. And I'm shocked that he's been drawn into Metaphysics and Speculative Philosophy, which he really wants to be able to ground and test empirically in his lab, many labs now that are working with him. But a few years ago at CIS we hosted the Ian McGilchrist Conference,
SPEAKER_00I think some of you were there, and Mike was invited to present, and he took the opportunity to write an extremely speculative paper about how His empirical findings are suggesting to him that you cannot understand form and the emergence of novel forms in the living world
SPEAKER_00without imagining a realm, a platonic space, as he calls it, that's under positive pressure, that's pushing not just forms and patterns, Into the world of our embodied experience. But agency, like there are minds hanging out in this platonic space. And when a new mutation occurs in the physical world, it's almost like he's imagining, as I am able to understand him,
SPEAKER_00that that creates a portal for these minds and these agencies that hang out in platonic space to enter into our world. So, Levin is, Mike Levin is pulling upward on biology, toward eternity is one way to look at it. And he's claiming that biological form and organismic agency are ingressing from this platonic space beyond space-time, the physical world, and he thinks that this space is again under positive pressure.
SPEAKER_00And so my worry with what Mike is saying here is that he's basically turning these platonic patterns, these forms, into puppeteers in a way. So all the agency is with what I would think of as abstractions. He's taking all the agency away from organisms, I think. So then there's my good friend Tim Jackson. He was an evolutionary biologist. He was in Melbourne, Australia. And Jack and I got to hang out with him in China at the Whitehead Conference.
SPEAKER_00We had a lot of fun. And for a biologist, and not just for a biologist, I mean, just Tim is extremely well-read in philosophy. Very respectful of the questions that philosophers ask and ponder. And he recognizes how relevant and important metaphysics is for doing If not doing science, then at least saying anything about what the science means, you're immediately doing philosophy. And he really understands that, and he's been a wonderful Dialogue partner for me,
SPEAKER_00as has Mike Levin, because I haven't
SPEAKER_01formally studied science. What I've learned is not from turning out in labs, but from reading books and from
SPEAKER_00talking to these guys and some gals who devoted their life to the study of And Tim's specialty is toxinology, or what he calls chemical ecology. He studies toxin-bearing organisms, including those that actually need to get the molecules to make their toxins from other organisms. So they kind of steal them.
SPEAKER_00And he's really interested in the way that, you know, we used to think only humans use tools. No. All organisms are tool users. And so many venomous animals, they actually have to get the molecules from some other organism to get their own venom that they use for their own survival. That's an example of tool use, right? So he's done all this amazing research. He loves snakes in particular, and he's gone on lots of walks when we were in Asia and Singapore and China looking for snakes.
SPEAKER_00The problem was we wouldn't shut up. We were debating philosophy, and so then all the snakes got chased away. But anyways, Tim's position is that we don't need these eternal objects. He is an OG Darwinian, not a Neo-Darwinian mechanistic reductionist and the genes, you know, boot up the organism, which is just a new kind of pre-formationism if you're a genetic determinist like that. He's not that kind of Darwinist. The Neo-Darwinians he thinks sort of this badly distorted Darwin.
SPEAKER_00He was actually a bit more of a romantic. Who actually thought that Lamarck was correct about acquired characteristics, which became the boogeyman in the 20th century. So Darwin is way cooler than you might think. And Tim has really helped me avoid caricaturing Darwin. Darwin's got problems, of course. Don't we all? But Tim has helped me rediscover
SPEAKER_00The Romantic Darwin, you might say, which is a great book by Robert Richards. The Romantic Conception of Life, where he goes into how Darwin has this romantic side. But Tim's view is we don't need eternal objects. Instead of the invariance of these eternal forms, Tim thinks we can explain everything just by beginning with pure variation. Just pure variation and then selection, those variations that tend to persist,
SPEAKER_00it's a tautology, will persist. So why do the forms that we see all around us exist? Well, it's because they survived in the past. And gradually, over millions of years, because of the conditions that operate as a kind of So there's a history that every moment inherits that constrains variation. And each moment, new constraints are arising that shape the next variation.
SPEAKER_00And so he just thinks, well, we need variation and selection. You don't need a category in your metaphysics of eternal objects or invariance. That's basically what eternal objects would mean. So for him, there are no timeless forms. Variation comes first, and what we think of as invariant is actually just the stability which has emerged and been selected for.
SPEAKER_01And some stabilities in this universe, like hydrogen atoms, or like the laws of electromagnetism, they're already stable, they're not going to change any kind of stuff. But they did once emerge as a result of this creative variation. Now, like I said earlier, I totally agree that all of these invariant forms of order Emerged historically.
SPEAKER_00I don't think eternal objects, though, can be understood as emerging historically, and I don't think we can do without them, because they help us understand the future, like I said earlier, and because I think Mike Levin is actually on to something, that there is this structured realm of possibility, constellations of potentialities, that we're Always orienting ourselves by as we make decisions moment by moment and as the cells in my body make decisions moment by moment.
SPEAKER_00I just don't think that those potentialities are making the decisions. So that's where I differ from Lebanon. And then finally, there's Stuart Kaufman. He's the senior here.
SPEAKER_01Brilliant guy who's really at the forefront of theoretical biology in the last several decades.
SPEAKER_00If Levin is, in a way, pulling biology upwards towards eternity and Tim Jackson is pulling biology downward towards open genesis or pure variation, I would say Stu Kaufman is pulling biology forward towards novelty, towards this unpre-stateable creative process of evolution. He'll describe organisms drawing on Kant as Kantian Holes, as he calls them. Kant was the first to develop this idea of self-organization to differentiate
SPEAKER_00the world of physics and mechanism from life. And Kant famously said, there will never be a Newton of the grass blade. By which he meant, there will never be a mechanistic explanation of life.
SPEAKER_01Many mechanistic reductionists would say, a few decades later we got Darwin, who is the Newton of the Grass Blade,
SPEAKER_00but that's really misunderstand Kant's point. Darwin's theory is about speciation, not the origin of life. It's a theory of phylogenesis and how life diversifies. If you read the last page of Origin of Species, you know, he says, in the beginning, life was breathed into one organism. And in the 6th edition he has Spy God. And then Natural Selection can explain Endless Forms Most Beautiful. So Darwin's not actually explaining ontogenesis or the origin of life.
SPEAKER_00And so he's not the Newton of the grass plague, because that's really what Kant was saying. So these Kantian holes, Stuart Kaufman thinks life is really important, and he thinks it's so important that we're going to have to change our understanding of physics before we can understand it. And he'll talk about closure of constraints, which I don't really have enough time. I could have given a whole talk on this issue. An organism, the parts that compose an organism, as Kant would describe them,
SPEAKER_00the parts produce themselves for the sake of a whole. What is that wholeness? As biochemistry has advanced, and Stu Kaufman has played a major role here, there's an understanding of what he calls autocatalytic sets, Chemicals that get involved in these circular chains of causality whereby each chemical produces the ingredients required to sustain a self-perpetuating reaction and you get all these auto-catalytic sets
SPEAKER_00in these complex chains of self-organization and life is able to maintain itself through the closure of the constraints that those reactions give rise to. Then of course, Organisms are always mutating, encountering all situations in the environment. And so that closure is continually being broken. And so if I had more time, I'd go into the paradoxes here around how if you define life as a closure of constraints, you're kind of missing what's essential to life, which is how it adapts to perturbations and
SPEAKER_01disturbances that break that closure. But anyway,
SPEAKER_00What's brilliant about Stu Kaufman's work is he's showing with mathematical rigor that these mutations, and not just mutations that are random, but exaptations, which have to do with already evolved traits becoming useful in a new way. That's what an exaptation is. So like the feather example
SPEAKER_01I gave earlier.
SPEAKER_00Stu Kaufman likes to use the example of our heartbeat. The heart has a function. Maybe it has several functions. Cognitive. It's not just a pump. If it even is a pump, that's all another conversation. The heart makes sounds, though, Stu Kaufman would like to say. Right? Do they have a function right now? I mean, they let doctors hear how it's doing. I guess that's a function. But the point is, that sound could eventually become really essential
SPEAKER_00for our survival in ways that we can't even imagine right now. He also likes to talk about technology as an extension of this evolutionary process. Like, how many uses does a screwdriver have? I mean, you can use it to unscrew things or screw things in, but you could use it to pick a lock maybe, you could use it as a weapon. The uses that you could put a screwdriver to can't be stated in advance. It could always be repurposed. So that's what exaptation is about.
SPEAKER_00And so, I've learned so much from all three of these biologists and from Whitehead as well, but they've left me in a bit of a hostage situation, as I like to refer to it, because I find myself in a situation where I need to negotiate for the release of two weight-bearing speculative categories that really matter for me when I try to make sense of my experience and This creative cosmos. And those two categories are God and eternal objects.
SPEAKER_00None of these guys are exactly atheists, but
SPEAKER_01nor are they comfortable with Whitehead's God.
SPEAKER_00And Tim doesn't want eternal objects. Stu Kaufman is saying that organisms are giving rise to new possibilities in their evolution, whereas Whitehead is saying there are no new eternal objects. So how do I square that with what they're saying? So let me say a bit more about Mike Levin and what he's doing.
SPEAKER_00He, in his empirical work, he didn't discover bioelectricity, but he has pushed our understanding of bioelectricity further than I think anyone before him. We usually think of our Our brains as having a special kind of cellular organization called neurons that are capable of cognition. But it turns out that the sodium potassium pumps that drive the action potentials
SPEAKER_00of our neurons are in every single one of our cells throughout our entire body. And that there are electrical patterns flowing through all of our tissue that have cognitive functions. In Mike Levin's terms. And he has found ways to alter the patterns that are active in the normal morphogenesis and ontogenesis of organisms. And so you're seeing a picture of a frog here. It has an eyeball growing on its tail.
SPEAKER_00And it works. It can see with it. And his lab will use, they first used voltage-sensitive fluorescent dye to see the voltage gradients, the electrical patterns in certain tissues. And they could see that before the normalized developed, the voltages were different. And they could actually see the sort of face of the frog in the voltage patterns. Before the cell is differentiated enough to give rise to this new kind of tissue
SPEAKER_00to make the eyeballs. So they then, at that phase of development, they injected certain cells with a messenger RNA that encodes an ion channel protein that changes how the sodium and potassium pumps work, and recreated that pattern that they had seen when the eyes usually develop, and they got an eye. There's no genetic change in this organism.
SPEAKER_00Same genes, totally new anatomy. They can do the same thing with flatworms. They can give flatworms two heads. Interestingly, another experiment that Islam has done is they train flatworms on a maze to find food. And flatworms are extremely regenerative. You can cut off its head and it will grow a new head back in a week. They train some flatworms to run a maze, cut their heads off where their brains are, And it still remembered how to run the maze when it grew back.
SPEAKER_00Where is the memory stored? So, DNA is necessary, of course, but it's not sufficient. The genome is not specifying coordinate by coordinate where all the cells end up in a developing organism. Cells are not just passive packs of molecules that are being steered around by genetic programs. Cells communicate with each other, they coordinate, they remember, they repair, they pursue physiological and anatomical goals, Levin says.
SPEAKER_00In other words, cells are conscious agents. And so Levin's word for this is that they are agential materials. Evolution's not just working on selfish genes, as Richard Dawkins used to say. The organism is not passively selected by changes in the environment. We're composed of a community of intelligent agents that can actively, proactively, respond to their environments.
SPEAKER_00Xenobots and Anthrobots, you know, Anthrobots will take a scrape from Throat tissue of a few cells that have never, they didn't evolve to exist independently, but he puts them in a petri dish and they start to self-assemble into these new forms of life that discover new functional organizations. And his question is, how are they discovering these novel forms that aren't in their ancestral inheritance?
SPEAKER_00And so this is the positive pressure of the platonic space, in his view, providing new sources of agency. So what I love about Levin's work is the way that he's reminding us, we all know that we're made of cells, but he's reminding us that there's a collective intelligence working itself out here. He also has this idea of the cognitive light cone,
SPEAKER_00where there's a kind of nesting of aliens. So the cognitive light cone is the range of states and agent consents, remember, anticipate, act upon. It's the extent of its agency, you could say. And evolution expands these light cones by binding formerly independent cells into larger cells. Right? Each of us began, though, as a single cell, as a zygote, even Descartes.
SPEAKER_00So Josh brought up the combination problem earlier. This is Mike's way of thinking about the combination problem. How do these larger cells emerge? Well, cells can do this kind of Vulcan mind meld. They share gap junctions and they can share voltages across their membranes and give rise through that sharing to these higher level patterns that they're participating and creating with each other. Sometimes I play with the metaphor that our bodies are like
SPEAKER_00the monotheistic religion of ourselves. Like their biological metabolic activity is a kind of ritual performance that actually generates ourselves. Because, you know, very often when you're deeply immersed in a ritual practice, your rational mind doesn't know why you're doing it. I don't think the cells exactly know why they're worshiping. But through that ritual activity, you know, the hemoglobin pumping through my veins and the cells
SPEAKER_00of all my tissues just doing their thing, they're enraptured by something. They're lured towards something. I hope, so long as I'm alive, they're keeping the worship going, right? I don't know if you guys like that metaphor, but sometimes I
SPEAKER_01think of it that way.
SPEAKER_00Right, so even Descartes, And the reflective abstraction exemplified in his dualistic philosophy. Doesn't matter whatever he was thinking about the separation of mind from body conceptually, he also began as a fertilized egg in his mother's womb. And what's being suggested here by this vision is that our own conscious imaginative creativity exists on a spectrum With the unconscious formative powers that are already active in embryo genesis.
SPEAKER_00So when the embryo that we were is taking form, there's a certain participation and cognitive activity, a participation in form, that we experience consciously in our own imaginations. As we imagine novel forms, novel possibilities. There's a continuum there. And, you know, we often get into these conversations
SPEAKER_00about if human beings are unique, what's special about us, maybe we're too anthropocentric. This cognitive light cone idea is one of the implications is that human beings seem capable of extending concern and their imaginations across centuries. And across the entire planet. And even into the indefinite future and the indefinite past. That may be a unique achievement of this collaborative effort
SPEAKER_00between these many nested layers of cellular intelligence. So of course, as I've been saying, I part company with Levin. Because I don't think that he uses the cloud metaphor that organisms are like thin clients, where the real agency and the processing and the source of the form is in the data center.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, if you have like a Chromebook or something, there's not actually any major chip and processing going on in the machine. If you just connect with the internet, the processing is going on at the data center. And so he calls organisms, our bodies, or just the thin clients, just the Chromebook and the information processing and the agency beaming in from platonic space. And he borrows Whitehead's term ingress to describe this, which is not what Whitehead meant.
SPEAKER_00And he doesn't claim that he understands Whitehead, but he borrows this term. And I worry that this could easily become a new kind of reductionism. I agree with him that there are these real constellations of physically irreducible forms, but these patterns, these forms, are not puppeteers. They don't have any agency. Organisms have agency. And this seems to me like it is at risk of becoming a new kind of reductionism.
SPEAKER_00The philosopher Graham Harmon has these useful terms, undermining and overmining, for two different kinds of reductionism. Genetic reductionism is undermining the agency of organisms. Levin's Platonism in the two-world sense, the bad sense, seems to me to be overmining organisms by reducing their agency, if not to genetic information, then to photonic forms. And I'm trying to find a third way here.
SPEAKER_00So then Stu Kaufman, just basic introduction to his approach of the adjacent possible. He certainly would reject the idea of a platonic space as some kind of pre-stated catalog of every function that evolution will ever discover. Again, his point about exaptation is that evolving organisms are not browsing a prefix menu, right?
SPEAKER_00Go through their process of development and as they evolve, life is creating adjacent possibilities with each of these ex-saptations, discovering new functions that could not have been predicted in advance. In every novel function, it's not really occupying one more point in a fixed phase space. Its emergence is changing what can happen next, which is what's being illustrated in this animation.
SPEAKER_00And this isn't, again, just a fact about the limits of our knowledge. These are ontologically new possibilities, right? So if you think about in physics, in mechanics, a double pendulum is unpredictable. Its motions are unpredictable to us. But its phase space, the possible states, is fixed in advance. And so its unpredictability is merely an epistemological limitation on us as observers. Ontologically speaking, it's completely deterministic.
SPEAKER_00When Kaufman refers to the un-pre-stateability of the future evolution of the biosphere, it's not just epistemically un-pre-stateable. I've said this a few times. So again, the example of feathers, it seems like they first evolved for insulation, then they became relevant for display, and then in the right context, the right socio-historical context, including specific morphologies,
SPEAKER_00the quality of gravity, the nature of the atmosphere being thick enough for flight to be possible, certain forms of muscular coordination, behavior, and ecological opportunities, and so on. Only then could feathers, could organisms discover that feathers might become for flight. So flight becomes a relevant lure in that case. So in a sense the forms themselves do not contain the tail of what they might someday be for.
SPEAKER_00The form of the feather does not tell you whether it will be used for insulation or display or for flight. It makes possible all of those functions, but it doesn't determine them. So then Tim Jackson would say that, as I mentioned earlier, there are no fixed forms, variation is primary. And my response to Tim, and we haven't finished arguing about this,
SPEAKER_00but my response is that I don't think we need to choose variation first or invariance first. I think these are co-ultimate in some sense. I don't know how one could even understand what is meant by pure variation without the reference point of invariance by which to compare it to. Um, and so I feel like Whitehead, as a mathematician, who also wants to understand evolution, um, grasps that co-ultimacy.
SPEAKER_00And, like, why is it, it's impossible for me to think about the ultimate nature of reality. Without something like eternal objects or forms. Because even if you say only actual entities are real, you're already claiming to know what it would mean for something to be unreal by indication. And what is it? What does it mean to be unreal? Or to not exist? And so you're always going to end up with this actual possible polarity.
SPEAKER_00I like to use the analogy of a magnet. It's like trying to get rid of eternal objects is like trying to get rid of the negative pole of a magnet. So you break it off and then you discover you just have a smaller magnet. The polarity always reappears. You just end up again with a smaller magnet or you smuggle in the idea of eternal objects or possibility while explicitly denying it. You're still making use of it covertly. So why not just Do it out in the open.
SPEAKER_00That's my idea. Because I think if variation is to grow anything significant and beautiful and functional, it needs seeds of invariance, but not only seeds of invariance, seeds that grow toward the sun. The good, in Plato's sense.
SPEAKER_00In other words, these invariant eternal objects, they're not just dead static forms in Whitehead's view. They're imbued with a divine valuation that tilts them towards beauty. Whitehead says that the eternal objects are a graded And that God's valuation of the realm of possibility or eternal objects gives them a certain intensive relevance, he says, to each moment of our experience.
SPEAKER_00Certain possibilities are made relevant to our actual situation. Why are they relevant and not just a chaos of disordered possibilities, right? He says, well, we need a divine function to explain that. And that's God's role in his scheme, is to order possibility so that it functions as a desirable direction for actuality to move in. So, I don't think that we have to have Darwin and Plato competing with one another. I don't think Darwin is Plato's undertaker.
SPEAKER_00I think that Darwin, though, is inviting Platonism to evolve. So Whitehead has these three categories of entity. We've heard a few presentations about this. Actual occasions, eternal objects, and societies, or for short, occurrences, recurrences, and endurances. And as I've been emphasizing for Whitehead, the agency lies in the occurrences and the actual occasions.
SPEAKER_00These are momentary drops of experience. They're the only entities that act Right? And they are feeling the past, physically prehending the past, and even, say, conceptually prehending possibilities for the future. Recurrences, or eternal objects, are these repeatable forms of definiteness, like a shade, redness. A ratio, like the fifth, 3 to 2.
SPEAKER_00I should say what the fifth exemplifies is the ratio of 3 to 2, which is an eternal object. And then endurances, or what you call societies, which are these lineages, inheriting and reenacting certain forms. So everything that has emerged in the course of historical time, electrons, atoms, cells, institutions, the level of human society. And so for white light, these are three distinguishable factors in one creative advance. They're not separate realms.
SPEAKER_00Depend on one another for their coherence. So, to understand what an actual occasion is, you need to make reference to eternal objects. To understand what a society is, you need to make reference to eternal objects and actual occasions, and so on. But where's the fourth? We'll get to that in a moment. Repeating this phrase from Whitehead, eternal objects tell no tales as to their aggressions. Eternal objects are anonymous in that sense. They're just pure potentials for definiteness. There's no record in an eternal object of where or when or how it will ingress.
SPEAKER_00And so they're real, but they're not actual. They're real, but they're not yet actual, right? So what is the future like? It's a constellation of eternal objects that are real, but they're not yet actual. They're not yet facts, because there are no future facts. So it's a special kind of reality. Actual occasions, on the other hand, are they have biographies. They inherit the past, they entertain the possible, and they decide which forms to ingress.
SPEAKER_00And so the tale, the story that tales are for balancing, say, can be told only once one or more related mammals Began to use their tails to help them leap through branches. That tail was not pre-existent in eternity. That function was not pre-existent in eternity. That tail's new function is not chosen from a menu, right?
SPEAKER_00It's felt, though, as an adjacent lure within these constellations of possibilities whose relevance, again, is continually co-evolving with actuality. Whitehead says some enigmatic things about this co-evolution that I wish he would have put in his published work. It only shows up in the students' lecture notes from his time at Harvard.
SPEAKER_00This is from his time when he first got there in 1924. He says that He hasn't even invented or coined the term eternal objects yet, so he says ideas. He says, the realm of ideas itself alters in its reference to the particular occasions as they flow by. So not only are these otherwise eternal objects said to be altered via their aggression into actual occasions, Whitehead suggests that,
SPEAKER_00I quote, the light of realization or actualization casts the shadow of truth Back upon the realm of eternal objects, thus enriching it. In this way, each fact of realization takes its place as an eternal truth. Since, as the eternal is now for us, the total nature of the past belongs to it. So once something occurs, it gains what he calls objective immortality, becomes part of the eternal past.
SPEAKER_00And so eternity in that sense is growing, moment by moment. Because of the truths, the facts, realized in the present. Where's the fourth? Well, there's a fourth kind in Whitehead's scheme. Propositions, which are the lures for feeling. And I've called these allurances, right? So you have occurrences, recurrences, endurances, and allurances. That's all you need to know. Those are the four ingredients to make a universe, the Whitehead.
SPEAKER_00These are the propositions. Whitehead says a proposition is a tale that perhaps might be told about particular actualities. Every proposition has logical subjects, which it's indicating these are other actualities, say these feathers. Every proposition also has a predicate, which is a pattern of eternal objects. These feathers are for gliding. So a proposition in that sense is a hybrid of fact,
SPEAKER_00actual entities or actual occasions that are indicated as logical subjects. It's a hybrid of facts and forms. These patterns, these predicative patterns, we'll say. What that set of actualities might be. And so a proposition is a hybrid of fact and form. It exists in between. It's an impure potential, he says. And importantly, a proposition for Whitehead is not limited to what logicians mean by a proposition. It's felt first for its interest, its aesthetic interest,
SPEAKER_00before we consider whether we want to judge it true or false, as a logician might. And he clarifies, no verbal statement is the adequate expression of a proposition. Isabel Stengers, a contemporary Whiteheadian, would say, Just to remind us of what's implied in Whitehead's theory. All life experiences and feels propositions. Even oysters entertain propositions, in the sense that they have these hybrid feelings that is a feeling of a contrast
SPEAKER_00between what is and what might be. That's basic to life, to the experience of all organisms for Whitehead, is an experience of propositions. It's not just something that you get with language. Or you could say, in some sense, it's how language goes all the way down, just not what we usually think of as human language. This is where I'm drawing on Josh. As I get towards the end here, I couldn't help but add another slide. Just to give you a sense for how broad wide its category of propositions were,
SPEAKER_00you could even say proposals, you know, a better word that doesn't have a logical connotation. I mean, there's a logical proposition that Guayne is very concerned with, but you lose the aesthetic importance if you have the logical connotation. So, proposal. This map that the Micronesian peoples used to Know where islands are and where new land might be, right?
SPEAKER_00The sticks are actual currents supposed to represent and indicate actual currents and the shells indicate actual islands. Those are the logical subjects of this proposition. And then the predicative patterns are these places where there might be new land that hasn't yet been discovered. So here's a proposition you can hold in your hands that these navigators articulated
SPEAKER_00that help them find new lands. So propositions help guide us into possible futures. A tale that might be told about the sea Felt as a lure before any voyage judges it true or false. So my proposal here, to bring this to a climax,
SPEAKER_00is that what Stuart Kaufman is calling these new possibilities that are unprestatable, that the biosphere is evolving into, they're not new eternal objects in Whitehead sense, they're not new invariant possibilities, they're new propositions. In Whitehead's sense. Because, again, for Whitehead, there are no new eternal objects. Novelty only arrives when history supplies new logical subjects for a proposition to be about.
SPEAKER_00And their primary role, Whitehead says, is to pave the way along which the world advances into novelty. When a proposition has been not just entertained, but ingressed and made real in the sense that an occasion of experience has decided whether it's true or false, error becomes possible. You could be wrong. You know, these explorers, you know, sailing across the Pacific might have thought that those currents indicated
SPEAKER_00a possible island and there's no island there. Whoops. So Whitehead says, error is the mark of the higher organisms and is the schoolmaster by whose agency there is upward evolution. For example, the evolutionary use of intelligence is that it enables the individual to profit by error without being slaughtered by it. We can model before we take action, right? That's the function of propositions for Whitehead. And so this is a re-description.
SPEAKER_00Of what Kaufman is proposing using Whitehead's metaphysics. It's not the only way to interpret what Stu Kaufman is saying, but I think it's one way that I have found of allowing me to maintain some understanding of internal objects being uncreated. You don't need new internal objects to understand these unprecedented possibilities because they're actually propositions.
SPEAKER_00So again, just in connection to Mike Levin, who's doing amazing work, allowing us to understand cellular collective intelligence, and he may win a Nobel Prize for his work as it will become relevant, as it is accepted, you could say, into regenerative medicine, because we might be able to regrow limbs, we might be able to cure cancer, as a result of his understanding of bioelectric patterning. But I think the metaphysics here is granting agency to patterns,
SPEAKER_00making patterns puppeteers, when I think the organisms are the agents. The patterns aren't deciding anything. Okay. One last example here to help connect with the earlier Discussion of Plato and the closed circle and how we can have invariant form and open evolution at the same time.
SPEAKER_00This is the circle of fifths. Oh, I need to plug in the sound. Sorry. Okay. [music] So what you're hearing fits as Jack was explaining to us.
SPEAKER_01You pluck a string and it vibrates at a certain rate. And then you halve the string and it vibrates twice as fast.
SPEAKER_00And we hear that two to one relation as the same node, only it's higher, right? That's an octave. And if you shorten the string to two thirds of its length instead, so it vibrates three times for every two on each side of your finger, That three to two relation, that ratio, is heard as two different notes that fit together in a kind of sweet way. And musicians call that the perfect fifth. So there's this ratio, three to two. It's precise.
SPEAKER_00It is exact. It's a definite potentiality that has no birthday, I would say. It requires It doesn't have a natal chakra. It wasn't born at a certain moment in history. It's a ratio. It's an eternal object. A relationship that allows us to hear a perfect fifth. And it's exemplified by the perfect fifth. It's not identical to the perfect fifth, though. The perfect fifth is the actualization of a ratio that requires a whole bunch
SPEAKER_00of historical and social context, instruments, Reference pitches, culturally inherited tuning systems. And so the mathematical relation of three to two, it's not an efficient cause, it's not a material cause. Maybe it's a formal cause, maybe it's involved in final causes in some sense, but it's not determining the fifth, but it's conditioning it in some sense.
SPEAKER_00And the thing is, what we just heard, I'll play it again. Oops. What do I see now? [music]
SPEAKER_00That spiral of fits doesn't actually close. And modern tuning systems like on a piano, they actually have to have the keys slightly out of tune to get the spiral To close and have a wholeness of an octave, that's a fudge. So for this perfect ratio to enter into space and time, physical existence so that we can actually hear it, there's a slight imperfection.
SPEAKER_00The closed circle becomes an open spiral. And so this seems to me to be a great example of how eternity Falls in love with time, you could say. And it's allowing us to help to maintain this polarity between variance and invariance, between actuality and eternality, because I think pure genesis or creativity without invariant form would just be an indefinite flux, a kind of chaos.
SPEAKER_00Whereas pure form Without a sense of Genesis or creativity or openness would just be determinism, right? But if we can hold the polarity right, you get form in Genesis, evolutionary Platonism, right? And you can think of this more like a spiral. It's open and there's a little bit of imperfection. There's a crack in everything, right?
SPEAKER_00And that's how the light gets through. And so God in this picture is no longer a designer issuing commands, but a lure. And yes, Whitehead's God is a kind of prime mover, but not an efficient cause. It's more like as if God were the source of motion. It's more like God is the source of emotion rather than locomotion. God's not pushing things around. It's the ideal vision of beauty.
SPEAKER_00That God provides by valuing possibility and ordering it in a certain way that moves us emotionally to seek to realize it. These collaborative acts of socio-historical evolution. So this is a vision beyond the ancient view of a finished closed universe. Beyond the modern view of a mechanistic universe.
SPEAKER_00It's an idea of the universe is unfinished. A cosmogenesis, not just a cosmos. Maybe even a chaos-mogenesis. And this requires, I think, overcoming innocence, the sense of a guaranteed happy ending, overcoming this desire for power that drives the mechanistic modern worldview, and returning to a sense of responsible participation. Because when it says, the good of the universe cannot lie in indefinite postponement, the day of judgment is an important notion,
SPEAKER_00but that day is always with us. Our task is to render the day of judgment a success now. So in conclusion, eternity tells no tales. But we do. And this divine cosmos conceived us, but what it may become through us has not yet been born. So we have a role in creating the future, and we have a role in co-creating even the divine, because in this vision,
SPEAKER_00inspired by a certain Whiteheadian reading of Plato, The universe is God's body, yes, but that body is also growing and striving to ever richer forms of interrelationship. And as I said, it's a process of embryogenesis. And so to the extent that we can lean into that process of participation to strive to live in love and artistically an expression of ever richer beauty,
SPEAKER_00we're enriching The divine. And as Whitehead would say, God's power is the worship that God inspires. And so, you know, God's only hands are our hands. There's no rescue mission coming. It's up to us, but we have help. Which is to say that we're not just pushed from behind by the way of history.
SPEAKER_00There is a An ordered realm of possibility that is beckoning us and calling us because of the way it is being in Whitehead's terms divinely envisaged. So that's my attempt to make sense of contemporary theoretical biology from a metaphysical point of view in a way that I hope you can resonate with as a human being trying to live a good life.
SPEAKER_00But thanks for your indulgence and attention. Jack.
SPEAKER_03Bad choice. I love that bad, thank you so much. And in an effort to steal students from you, I'm gonna take you down. Oh, okay. Well, I don't think Kant came up with the idea of Kantian Holtz, Aristotle, Phil, Laos, Galen, Aristoxinus, Lacanus. Lao Tzu, others have had that idea before, though, but that's okay. Three to two...
SPEAKER_00Well, just the term self-organization, I guess, he coined it, but he was obviously going out of rich history. True.
SPEAKER_03Very true. Three to two and two to three have very different feels to that. So, I mean, I think we can make a distinction between the morphe, the concrete instantiation, of the form, and then the idos, which is the idea of three to two. So the morphate would be the fifth itself as like a herd integral, but you can also have the reciprocal, which has a different feel.
SPEAKER_03And then you have the essence, I think, which is what the eternal object is, which is like ingressible into a number of different contexts, which sound very different from each other. That was one thing I wanted to say. One other thing I wanted to say. Why does Plato's have to be a closed circle? I mean, I think that the Salus reading you were giving
SPEAKER_03Leads to the idea that, first of all, matter is recalcitrant and doesn't stop being recalcitrant or resistant. But also, that's not, like, in the Timaeus, it's a fun kind of dramatic thing where, like, as Hollis showed, like, God loves order and blah, blah. And then later it's like, oh shit, the order is, like, not coming out and, like, we have to rivet things and there's all this, like, reworking and, like, by the end, like, It's not, there's no finishing and it remains that way.
SPEAKER_03And that gets to the point of Eros, which Salas is really, like, draws forth as, you know, you don't eliminate Eros and that's why philosophy still exists and, like, we don't close the circle. And I think he knew that the circle fits, doesn't come back and, like, there isn't a closure at the end. And that's why philosophy is, it's the last word.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, all true. I want to have the most open evolutionary processional reading of Thomas
SPEAKER_00and Platonism as I can, but I don't ever get any hints in Plato that the forms themselves are in any way affected by it.
SPEAKER_03But they aren't for Whitehead either, and you defended it for Whitehead.
SPEAKER_00Well, but the truth, what happens in the present casts a shadow of truth back upon the realm and enriches it. And the consequent nature of God, which I didn't speak about much, is continually growing with the creative advance of the universe, incorporating all of these unprestatable events, as Kauffman would say. And I don't think there's anything equivalent to a consequent nature in Plato.
SPEAKER_03Why not? I think there could be. I don't think there's anything closing at all.
SPEAKER_00Well, I don't want to disagree with you.
SPEAKER_03We have a passage that says that it closes it off. Matt, that was brilliant and beautiful and typically generous. And I think your argument or your response to the three biologists is compelling. And personally, I'm totally with you with the Whiteheadian ontology. And it makes perfect sense from an imminent frame, like from our perspective,
SPEAKER_03where I find myself resisting is with, to me it feels like a dogmatic plane, like there are no future facts. To me that's either a tautology, obviously there's no future facts by definition, or, or end, it's ignoring a whole set of Experiences such as those maybe from Sri Aurobindo or St. Augustine or a whole tradition who have a different experience of God or the Divine
SPEAKER_03and open up a different metaphysics and a different theology. So like when you say God is, I would feel more comfortable with Whitehead's God or the way Whitehead thinks of the Divine. But to me it's an incoherent theology and rather clunky. And to conclude, I think a theology or a true metaphysic that would be more consistent with the non-dual ontology that is worked out
SPEAKER_03so beautifully and that you use in your response to these dead ends in biology, would be more in the direction of a true integral non-dual panentheism. It can make room for a different experience and conception of the Divine, which is not merely one actual occasion beside other actual occasions.
SPEAKER_00Yes, thank you, Sean. I think, you know, Fichte says the kind of philosophy one adopts depends on the kind of person one is, one's character, one's temperament, and I might just be sort of a Jamesian. William James, his sense that the cosmos is unfinished, and we were hearing earlier from Caroline, And I think it's possible that the future of the Sri Aurobindo Intuits
SPEAKER_00or the Tehran Intuits
SPEAKER_01will be actualized. And I think there's a lot that suggests that we're headed in that direction. I don't think it's decided yet.
SPEAKER_00And I think, for me, it's important that it isn't decided yet so that we have some, there's some drama, we have agency in realizing that.
SPEAKER_03I agree, again, that's a false binary. Either it's decided or not. This is my suggestion. There's another third way.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03It's consistent with your ontology.
SPEAKER_02I'm open to that. Yeah. To be continued.
SPEAKER_03You have many hands, so give me your next two. Look at all that.
SPEAKER_00Candace. And then we'll come, we'll switch sides after. Candace?
SPEAKER_03Candace. Okay, I have two quick ones, I hope. One is, so it's becoming, I'm going to call this the new biology, but clear that subjective aim seems like it's getting easier and easier to see, right? But the word feeling seems like it's really got to be redone. I mean, it seems like it seems very, I get what my head's saying, but I feel like in terms of what we're now trying to describe, that word seems clunky when you're talking about a single-cell organism,
SPEAKER_03and you're talking about satisfaction. I mean, I feel like those words could use some work as we really get into this biology, and I'll begin to see how this might be happening. So I just want to say that.
SPEAKER_02Do you have some suggestions?
SPEAKER_03I'm not happy. No, I'll stay fine. I'll talk to you tomorrow morning or breakfast. I guess I was thinking that, that I think those words were possibly very useful almost for their shock value at the time when we had came up with them. But I feel like now I would love to see them more nuanced.
SPEAKER_00Is the neologism like preemption better or worse?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I feel like just need to keep working on it as we go. Because we're getting more open to the concept. It's just how to think of it in a way that goes all the way up and down. And then the second quick thing I guess goes back to Jack's This question of whether eternal objects, when you say that the world of time and space casts a reflection on eternity, but then eternal objects are unchanged.
SPEAKER_03If you could just clarify that a little bit.
SPEAKER_00Well, the ratio of three to two doesn't change when a fifth is played.
SPEAKER_03Right. But then what does it mean when you say that a reflection is passed on eternity?
SPEAKER_00The shadow of truth is cast because everything that is actualized in the present becomes objectively immortal. Which, in other words, it becomes part of eternity from our perspective in the next moment. So the shadow of truth What becomes true after it's actualized as a new fact is then is part of what we consider it's now eternal. It's happened. It can't be undone. And it casts a shadow of truth in the sense that now this realm of possibilities has
SPEAKER_00a new relevance to the next moment because of what just happened prior to it.
SPEAKER_03Thank you. Also two quick ones. I'm always trying to avoid the fallacy of the illusion of one-to-one correspondence, but in Levin's experiment, you know, he put potential gradient of some sort over tadpole and eye crew. In electrical engineering, another word for voltage is potential. Is there any link between Voltage and then potential in the terms of new potential possibilities.
SPEAKER_03You also talked about the double pendulum and you said that it's, although it's chaotic it can be determined because if you look at the phase space there's a strange attractor etc etc. Kastner differentiates between the quantum realm and the classical realm. In terms of uncertainty, saying that in the quantum realm, uncertainty is ontological, whereas in the classical realm, uncertainty is epistemic. However, I've worked a lot in labs. I've never made a single measurement that didn't have uncertainty,
SPEAKER_03and it's really hard to differentiate You know, what's epistemic and what's ontological, because whether it's, you know, something related to thermal fluctuations in the pendulum that make it just a little bit off, or the way I measure it, you'll never get a measurement without uncertainty.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, let me... There's a philosopher of science at Cambridge, I believe, Hasek Chang, who talks about the ways that Theoretical physicists come up with explanations for like, you know, why water boils and what temperature boils at. And then engineers go out and have to actually apply the theory and discover, well, does water really boil at 100 degrees Celsius?
SPEAKER_00There's a lot of things that have to be exactly right about the conditions for that to be true. The slightest little imperfection in the pan or imbalance of like how the flame touches it or
SPEAKER_01You know, the temperature of the air around it, what altitude you're at, like all these other factors are gonna change that. And the theoretical business is just doing math. We're acting all that out. And so, when it comes to measurement, the practicalities of measurement often confound the theoretical models that we're trying to test.
SPEAKER_00Such that there's always a range of error that we have to account for. In terms of Potentiality, I think kinetic and potential energy is a bit different.
SPEAKER_01In most models of energy, the potential energy would be a certain set of states that are pre-stated, that
SPEAKER_00in the dynamic movement of an object, it could fall into one of these states according to different probabilities. That's different than, I think, what Whitehead means by, and what Coughlin means by, unprestateable, in that it is,
SPEAKER_01yeah, it's ontologically unprestateable. But I appreciate how you're pointing out how difficult it can be to determine, in practice, the difference between these things.
SPEAKER_02You have Jay, but give me, go. We're back. All right, okay. So I made a list of seven persons I disagreed with. I have two questions where I want to ask you to elaborate a little bit. I would love to talk to you about the places where various folks here on the faculty and in the community would want to differ in some way that you phrase things. But I don't want to do that now. I think that was brilliant.
SPEAKER_02And I want to draw out a couple of things that I was left wondering about. So I'll give you two of them and you can have a go at either of them or move on. The first is, unless the Michael Levin point about the agential power of the new platonic biological phase space realm, whatever, one way to think about what he's Or one way to think about sort of precursors
SPEAKER_02to that would be like the kind of Bergsonian theory of consciousness as a sort
SPEAKER_01of the brain as a filter or like there's all these sort of like esoteric ideas that people got really excited about when radios were developed and a sense of like the organism
SPEAKER_02as the receptor of something else. There's still a kind of communicative agency and I just wanted to get your take on that. Yeah, so the agencies and the interface... Yeah, so the idea that what is happening in the organism is that it's being brought into a kind of resonance capacity to transmit something that is not solely located within the organism, but is being
SPEAKER_00picked up and communicated by it. Yeah, totally. I think in some sense you could think of What I'm describing as organismic agency is the capacity of the organism to tune into this textured
SPEAKER_01Constellation of possibilities. So we're tuning into the field as it were.
SPEAKER_02But on that account you could also have agency. What I'm trying to suggest is that that way of looking at things sees agency as more widely distributed so that whereas Whitehead's eternal objects are non-agential but lures, there could be a kind of agency that is say both in that
SPEAKER_01I'm happy to speculate about angelic organisms that are not physical in the way we're usually used to imagining physical and Whitehead would allow for there to be organisms that have a very attenuated or even vanishingly
SPEAKER_00The existing physical pole, you know, they're still emphasizing the mental pole that we can't even really detect them physically.
SPEAKER_02Right, so something non-detectable by a non-fire... I would just call those subtle orientations. Those are subtle orientations.
SPEAKER_01I figured that's what you would say, but I just wanted to get that, draw that out. Which, if that's what Levin is suggesting, If we want to go in an occult direction or do anthropology or demonology, that's a different conversation. I'm doing metaphysics with this distinction.
SPEAKER_02And then the other one, quickly, and you can decide how to do it if you want to move on, is what do you mean exactly by eternal? Because I feel like we haven't gotten that defined, and I think some of the confusion when people are asking about its change, etc. So can you just give
SPEAKER_00sense of what you mean?
SPEAKER_01Is it abstract?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's abstract from any particular occurrence of it or ingression of it in an actual occasion. So yeah, it's abstract. But there's nothing concrete that's not participating in those eternal objects. But it is, yeah, it's abstract.
SPEAKER_02Last question, is it like the infinite space of come-possibles?
SPEAKER_00No, because there can be contradictory, there are many contradictory objects that can't simultaneously ingress in the same occasion. So they're not just come-possible. That's why there's no truth or falsehood in the realm of emotional objects yet. Thanks. Alright, survive that.
SPEAKER_01Okay, Martin, and then we'll go to this team.
SPEAKER_03Thanks, Matt. I really enjoyed you highlighting the irony that Michael Levin may be perhaps unnecessarily leaning too hard towards the Platonic. And I'm trying to figure out just how far he's willing to go and just how far you want to pull him back. And that eye example on the tail I think provides like a very acute opportunity to interrogate that question. So the application of the electric fields to the cells of the tail I think
SPEAKER_03on a conventional biological analysis would say something like the part of the genome that expresses All the combinatorialness of creating an eye was activated in the cells in the tail. And so you could still make the argument that the data, if you will, is in the nucleotide sequences, right? But interestingly enough today, you could hypothetically generate that organism with the cells in the tail absent the sequences in nucleotides that make the eye, right?
SPEAKER_03Knockout or deletions through mutations. And then Levin could apply those fields to that part of the tail, right? And it'd be fascinating to see if that produced an I. And so then you have this, like, opportunity where, well, then where's that information coming from? And I think you had mentioned something about, so if there's a mutation, that that's an opportunity for these competing possibilities, right, coming down to actuality.
SPEAKER_03Which is really fascinating. If Levin could show that in that experiment, which is designable, that's pretty cool.
SPEAKER_01He's devising ingenious experiments to test
SPEAKER_00the extent to which certain novel behaviors and forms can be explained genetically
SPEAKER_01through what's been inherited from prior selection versus what seems like a free lunch in the sense that...
SPEAKER_03So my question to you is that when you said something like DNA is necessary, you kind of floated that. That example, exactly. That example would say DNA is not necessary, if Levin could show that. So I'm curious where you are there.
SPEAKER_01Well, I, as someone who takes science, you know, science is not a fair tale, Whitehead says, right? Metaphysics is really important for how we interpret science, but like, I am very interested in the empirical data.
SPEAKER_00Like, that's what I, that's what I'm initially drawn to Levin's work for. I didn't expect him to become a Platonist in this way. This is relatively new over the last few years that he feels that he has enough empirical justification to make these claims.
SPEAKER_01And we'll see if he can back it up. Maybe he can. And I'll come back next year and give you a different presentation. Thanks. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Can we... Can we have that table back there and then power is back.
SPEAKER_02Thanks Matt, that was really great. I've actually never read Whitehead throughout my time on TCC. And I was hoping for this presentation, I wouldn't have to, but it's seemingly so, and I will. I think I have a few questions. We'll see how we get there. How I started off my thought with your own question was what are some ways that organisms are lured by the forms. And then Mike Levin says that there's like an aggressive positive pressure
SPEAKER_02which he kind of reverses the top, like reverses. A pressure that opens it up, opens up the possibility of evolution, as I interpret it. And then there's Tim, who is quite the opposite. There's the variation that will lead to the structure and the form. And obviously there's so much context that we had these conversations left out, but I see why you posited like this to
SPEAKER_02They did seem either or, right? That's how I'm inferring it. And Michaels is kind of like a, I was wondering if that's like an entropic process that he's just saying it's by chance. My question was if it's the tension between the laws of nature and chance,
SPEAKER_02that is the lure, but then you say the lure is an unrest. You give the really good metaphor of the ritual and the devotion, which kind of brought me into the idea of, okay, well, in our own day-to-day lives, we have these structures that we go by, whether they be ethical, moral, like our responsibilities to ourselves, our families, our society. At times we are aware of that, but then most of the time it is unconscious.
SPEAKER_02It becomes a habit of doing that. And then all of a sudden something happens in our lives where we're just like, we're led to a new possibility. Or this moment of realization of why we're doing it, which is kind of the whole of our history kind of being recapitulated through the understanding of Possibility and opportunity opening it up to us, if that makes sense.
SPEAKER_02My first question kind of finishes off with, Yeah, and you wrote, Novelty arrives when history supplies new logical subjects for a composition to be brought about, which is, I took it as, one, awareness of the history and then the consciousness of that. So, how would Whitehead... How would Whitehead see the way
SPEAKER_02that Thomas Kuhn presents the structures of time, revolutions and paradigms? Because it seems to be right there, but it's not super... Explicit and listed. That's the first question. And the second one is, I'm sure you're very familiar with Varela and Maturana with autopoiesis. And there's theories are quite secular,
SPEAKER_02but it is a very emergent complexity kind of reorienting itself to its environment and with itself. But it is secular, so how do you kind of bridge that gap there? Sorry, there's a lot happening. Okay, it's good
SPEAKER_03to come up and I don't know if you're going to have mic service.
SPEAKER_01Well, I can just... Yeah, I'll just keep going with that. Okay, so paradigm shifts in the sense. Often when normal science is happening, all the facts or most of the facts are expected. They fit the existing paradigm. And then at some point, unexpected facts begin to accumulate and it can't be explained in the existing paradigm. But when scientific revolutions happen,
SPEAKER_01it's usually not just because there's novel facts that don't fit the model. You know, Brian's not here, so I hate to pick on the Big Bang without coming to the bench. But there's a lot of evidence that is, in Karl Popper's sense, kind of falsifying the model. But the model has ways of adjusting its free parameters to just incorporate that, you know, by changing how the dials between, what was the rate of inflation at this moment in the history of the universe. I think you can account for the new data that seems to conflict with the old version
SPEAKER_01of the model. So, but like when Copernicus draws on some ancient, you know, Bear Green and Greek astronomers who had already calculated that the earth was round and that the sun might be at the center, why didn't the paradigm shift, you know, 1500 years earlier? That knowledge, those propositions were there. And so it's like the social and historical and cultural conditions weren't ready
SPEAKER_01for that to be widely adopted. And so for a new idea to take root, the conditions have to be right. Of a novel form, novel in the sense that it hasn't existed in history yet, or new theory, for it to gain widespread acceptance for a proposition to propagate through society and compel someone to say, oh yeah, that's true. A lot of conditions have to be right.
SPEAKER_01And then in terms of aquasis, what I can say there is that it's a brilliant account building on this idea of self-organization, that organisms are self-producing on aquatic. But it doesn't really account, and it makes life really distinct and irreducible to physics. But even at the end of his life, in my favorite paper that he wrote with Andreas Weber, who's still alive, great biologist, philosopher of biology, it's called Life After Kant.
SPEAKER_01They articulate how autopoiesis gives rise to this center of concern. They use Whitehead's term subject pole. In living organisms that are autopoetic that differentiates them from neutral physics and chemistry. For Whitehead, physics and chemistry is also the study of organisms. To make autopoiesis unique to the biological world I think is a missed opportunity and it leaves you with this really hard problem of the origin of life, basically.
SPEAKER_01How did neutral physics and chemistry ever give rise to an autopilotic cell? It kind of, that great theorization of life ends up blocking a lot of the pathways towards explaining the convergence of life. And then also Donna Haraway says, nothing makes itself. So she has this term, simpoasis, to emphasize the relationality. And Varel is a Buddhist, and I think this idea of dependent for origination is his oncology, more or less,
SPEAKER_01and I think is brilliant for understanding the physical world, the biological world, and the psycho-spiritual world, too. But I also think it's compatible with Whitehead's understanding of the divine's relationship to creativity. And Whitehead's ontology is fully Buddhist in the sense of being relational, dependent horizon on all occasions of experience.
SPEAKER_01Whether, like, why we need God is, if we do, Whitehead's God, I think is just a matter of whether or not we think evolution is about something. Is it going somewhere? Is there a purpose trying to realize itself? You don't get that from Varela's view, other than like we should all love one another, which might be enough. That might be enough.
SPEAKER_03So do you want to take a moment to pop the mics back or just keep going a little bit louder maybe? Okay. All right, a little bit louder.
SPEAKER_01You don't even need a mic anymore. That was an incredible and stimulating presentation. The quick things that I would raise to be either address now or as we move into the future is, I'm not sure if I agree with you that Barry is evolutionary Platonist, so I'd love to think with you more on this, because I've heard Thomas Barry say that he's more interested in forms
SPEAKER_01as insendent rather than transcendent. So he's in evolutionary areas that's going on? Yeah, probably. I mean, that's maybe where I'd land. He's the first neoplatonist. I would like to say Aristotle's the first neoplatonist. Interesting. Okay, I want to think with you about this more. The other aspect that is related is that how would you see what you presented related to Rupert Sheldrake? I was fortunate to study with Rupert in the 90s. I believe it's accurate to say that he felt that morphogenesis was related not
SPEAKER_01to eternal or transcendent forms, but to feelings. So how would you see that as fitting in? I spoke to Rupert. I heard not long ago about this and he's very excited about Mike Levin's work and he's very interested in Whitehead. But basically I think morphic fields and morphic resonance has more to do with the inheritance of habits from the past and less to do with Feeling possibilities in the future. It's not that it is in conflict with Whitehead's view
SPEAKER_01of how novel possibilities can ingress, but it's just more about the past and how we inherit Yeah, it's a whole book called The Presence of the Past. Presence of the Past, yeah. So it's more about, in Whitehead's terms, the physical pull and how we inherit what's been actualized and how memory propagates through The cosmos, the living world, and the whole cosmos. And it just, I think it has less to say, and Gruber admits this, it has less to say about the future.
SPEAKER_01And so every theory is focused on a certain set of phenomenon, and that's what morphic resonance is about. I think it's a powerful theory that's testable. And Rupert has collected a lot of evidence that suggests that something like that is going on. And he and Mike Levin are friends. I know we're still recording, but Levin is more open to saying that what he's doing is similar
SPEAKER_01to what Rupert is doing, but they've had to be cautious because what Levin is doing is different. It's not identical. And Levin wants to be and is taken seriously as a scientist in a way that unfortunately for sociological reasons, Rupert has been kind of pushed to the outside and the margins despite the fact that his work is pretty solid. Thank you. Kate and then Josh.
SPEAKER_03Hi. Thanks, Matt. I had a basic Whitehead question, but I was wondering if you could comment on the linguistic choice of eternal objects. And I thought it was really interesting you mentioned, was it ideas originally? And just how that informs your understanding of what you've just presented, like that linguistic choice?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, sometimes objects can sound bad, like you're objectifying. It sounds dead or something. But for white, an object is just a potential that only exists in relationship to actual occasions, which are subjects. And so... Earlier in his philosophical development in the early 1920s when he was more doing philosophy of science he would talk about objects and events
SPEAKER_01and that nature is a network of events And the reason he wanted to refer to objects being ingressed in those events is that there's no other way for him to understand science. Science requires recurrent forms that we can recognize across events, mathematical forms, ratios.
SPEAKER_01But, you know, I recognize you as Kate, not because your physical body hasn't changed at the microscopic level dramatically from day to day, but because there's some recurrent pattern that continues to repeat across the many events and occasions that it composed your life. And so he just calls that an object, and an eternal object. He's always held in polarity with, you could say, actual subjects.
SPEAKER_01So actual subjects are apprehending internal objects. Neither of them exist in the penalty of the other. And he's repurposing this subject-object language But he means something very different than, say, what in a Cartesian context we would mean by the two words subject to object or mind and extension have really, mind and matters, they have nothing to do with each other. They could exist independently of one another. As separate substances, that's not how white is thinking about subjects and objects.
SPEAKER_01What is a subject in one moment, once it achieves satisfaction, it perishes and becomes a superject, but from the next occasion's perspective, who inherits that superject, that perished subject, is now objective data that it receives and then grows into its new subjectivity. So that's subject-object and why that sense is very different. So it doesn't, you know, it was really hard for me to accept eternal objects and I got hung up on the terminology and a lot of people who even think he might be
SPEAKER_01onto something or like it's a terrible word choice. But I'm less sure, I don't know, it seems like a fair way of naming what he's trying to get at. Josh and then Josh.
SPEAKER_02I hope the southern get into the weeds too much. We're not in the weeds yet? We have to use language like realm and space and all that kind of stuff to try to hang our intellectual hats on something. And obviously, as you're well aware, there's this debate for decades in the Whitehead literature
SPEAKER_02about whether or not Whitehead's God has to contain, so to speak, all eternal objects within God's nature. Now, my own feeling is that There can't be a realm or a space. This is just an intuition. I mean, this is a question I'm grappling with now too. Is there can't be a realm or space because that attributes
SPEAKER_02a spatiotemporal substance ontology to things that are outside space and time. Because it's actual occasions that make space, time within the extensive continuum. So, you know, you mentioned God being radically distributed in all actual occasions. So, you think that perhaps eternal objects are also sort of radically distributed,
SPEAKER_02kind of like God. You know, would that be something like how it might be possible for actuality, potentiality, creativity, To all be mutually implicated without separate realms. So would infinite possibility also be radically distributed within everything including say ourselves as well as God?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so. Whitehead says that every concrescence, every actual occasion of experience is a selection among infinite possibility. But even in making that selection, he has this idea of negative apprehension, that all of the other infinite possibilities that haven't been selected are still in a sense Being prehended, just in negation. And so all possibilities are always present to us. We just decide
SPEAKER_01to emphasize some finite complex arrangement of those possibilities and to imbue that arrangement, that pattern, With emotion and with aesthetic value so as to achieve something novel, a new arrangement of possibility that's never been achieved before. And that produces something new that changes God in the sense that it changes
SPEAKER_01the relevance of the realm of eternal objects for the next iteration, for the next concrescence. And so that's It's not compatible with the idea of a separate world, and it's not compatible with the idea of a God that exists impassively and isn't responsive, doesn't feel what decisions that we make.
SPEAKER_01Because we're not just feeling the divine lure that's eternal, That's the primordial nature of God. God's also feeling a consequent nature, what we do with that lore, how we decide to actualize in light of that lore. And so there's this call and response relationship. And that's how I think of the radical distribution. Of the divine, in that sense, that each of us is contributing to the divine nature in each one,
SPEAKER_01being inspired by and contributing back to it.
SPEAKER_02Mind-blowing.
SPEAKER_01Good. I'm here to do, I'm a mind-blower, a professional mind-blower. I wanted you all to share my perplexity. That's awesome. Maybe it's working. Josh. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Thanks so much, Matt. I think you covered this partly with Jake, but to bring it back to agency for a bit. If agency is not ingressed from the eternal objects, then I guess my question is what makes freedom or agency metaphysically possible? And so I think when I heard the exchange with Jake, I think you mentioned that freedom or agency consists at least in part
SPEAKER_03in this attunement to the lore. So that makes sense, but then I think part of what is happening there is, as you mentioned in your talk, this moment of a decision on the part of an occasion to move to that attunement. But then what makes me able to decide to do that in a way that's my decision and not something caused by something else?
SPEAKER_01I mean, ultimately for Whitehead, God, but he says God is an accident of creativity. And so what makes God decide to value the eternal object in a certain way? Whitehead says it's like the ultimate irrationality. It's the first superject of creativity. But subsequently to God's initial valuation and ordering of the realm of possibility, for all finite occasions that then responds to that initial ordering,
SPEAKER_01God is necessary. The structure of God's evaluation is necessary. But without determining, All of the finite decisions that we make moment by moment because God's just providing an initial ideal and what gets realized can't live up to that ideal because we're finite. But when we ask, can you explain how my freedom is possible? What makes me free? Nothing makes you free. I can't do better than just pointing you back to your own experience moment
SPEAKER_01by moment of feeling like You're making a decision. And then you feel guilty that you didn't make the right decision. Hasty point. Chloe?
SPEAKER_03So I had two things that came up for me that are in very different realms of how I walk through the world. Say it, say it loud. Yeah. This is going to be interesting because it's like Two very different realms that I walked in the world came up when we were talking about a run back to Levin. And Martin kind of touched on some of the one part where it was talking about the expression of this And so part of my background is molecular biology
SPEAKER_03and genetics. And so that whole part was like, well, like when you were talking, I'm like, if you take the DNA away, like, no, you're not going to have expression of the eye because that is literally the code that is telling you to make an eye. So if you don't have that, you go, oh, I was having a moment. Oh, and I'm still having a moment with it. But there's this. Yeah, thank you. Everything next to each other in this moment together. And it's this one world that I live in that is, like, from 20 years ago in my life that was my whole life.
SPEAKER_03But there was a layer within that that was just, like, coming forward. And I'm going to have this, like, everything I'm about to say does not have question. Content that feels like it wants to come out, so I'm sharing. But this notion of within every single cell in my body, it is the exact same DNA. And what though it is.
SPEAKER_01Unless there's mutations, but yeah. Transposons. Wow. More or less.
SPEAKER_03I think a lot of times a misconception for those who don't understand this level of molecular biology, that it's like my eye and my liver, the cells are not It's not different DNA. It's the same DNA and it's different expression. And I think what was coming forward for me in that layer was this notion of in the development of a child. It's chemical gradients that are essentially dictating where limb formation is going
SPEAKER_03to happen and where the elongation of the spine is going to happen. Again, dot, dot, dot.
SPEAKER_01Chemical gradients, geometry.
SPEAKER_03Geometry, location, and environmental factors. So there's this element of how a cell will go on to develop depends on The environment it's in and the chemicals that are surrounding it and the signals that it's getting. It's very external and forming internal that then allows for the development to act. That's one bubble of thought. Again, there's nothing other than just like that feeling of this external that is allowing for it to develop in some way.
SPEAKER_03Close that box. Totally different world. A thousand percent. West African spirituality came forward too. There are deities that, this is the other part, it's like other languages for me, so bringing it to English. Incorporar, essentially these deities, they incorporate.
SPEAKER_03So your body becomes a vessel for these spirits to move through you from this other realm. And in that moment, you are the expression of their existence.
SPEAKER_01Like possession?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, like possession. But I hesitate with that world because of the colonial, demonic aspect that comes with it. There's a lot of unpacking there. But that was, yeah, anyways. They're leaven in that aspect. Just both of those came through.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, what that brings up is just the way that sometimes what Levin calls free lunches are all these factors in the environment called free lunches. A free lunch, like a metaphor for something that didn't need to evolve and get selected for, but that nonetheless provides an enabling constraint for life to come forward, just something in the environment. Like, I mean, at the origin of life, without The free launch of the bilipid membrane that just spontaneously forms
SPEAKER_01a sphere to minimize free energy. Just a more efficient way of distributing the energy. These lipids form spheres. That didn't need to evolve by natural selection in the way that Darwin understood. That's a free launch. Order for free. That biology can exploit and that restoration can make use of. And there are so many examples of that in nature. And then in terms of these West African practices of incorporation,
SPEAKER_01like I was saying with Jake, If Levin wants to go in the direction of that type of spiritual ecology, then we're talking about subtle organisms that don't necessarily have physical bodies that take up space in the way that we're used to and that our physical eyes can see, as usually. And that's a different conversation for me. What I've been talking about Eternal objects or these abstract patterns
SPEAKER_01and actual occasions and propositions. This is like the most, this is metaphysics, the most general language that we can comprehend just to get a sense for like what are the categories required to even think about anything. Whether it's a spiritual being or a physical organism. I haven't heard Levin yet talk about angels or souls that are disembodied and somehow coming into contact with bodies.
SPEAKER_01I'd put on a different hat for that. Not that I'd leave the metaphysics out, but I would just be engaged in a different kind of conversation. I could give a different presentation about that. With Neil's presentation about Egyptian temple Practices and statues in the way that they would create and worship statues not to produce souls in the statues through certain magical techniques, but to turn the statues into a vessel to receive a soul.
SPEAKER_01And if we were to look at what's going on with artificial intelligence nowadays, I don't think that a semiconductor is going to somehow, when you get enough data in there, More training data or more powerful gyps, all of a sudden that's going to produce consciousness or become a soul. But I do wonder seriously about whether you might not be creating a kind of vessel for subtle beings to incarnate into.
SPEAKER_01That's a different kind of conversation. If he's already talking about agential material cell in this abstract space. Well, the agential materials are like the cells and then there are the agential patterns. Sorry, the agential patterns. Once you've made them agential, you're kind of talking about something about
SPEAKER_02If you go from just conceptual description to the actual historical cosmos, then maybe talking about beings.
SPEAKER_01Matt, can I ask this? At some point I'm just going to sit down at the table.
SPEAKER_03So either take one more question and then we can conclude it or we conclude it now and keep talking.
SPEAKER_00One more question.
SPEAKER_03There you are. So from one perspective, you're pointing to the organization of all of the epigenetic and physical factors, right, as a free lunch. But couldn't that be, could you look at the mirror the other direction and say that invoking God for those explanations is like a banquet that's for free?
SPEAKER_03Philosophically.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's just a question of what is... No, I mean, do you see my question? Sure, yeah. Well, let me just explain that when you talk about, like, minimizing Gibbs free energy for, you know, a biopic membrane, mycel, so much. That's an account, more or less mechanistic account. But I agree with the free lunch. But I'm just asking, why does energy want to minimize and be efficient? Why does it work that way? And I think saying God does it, or that that's a divine rule.
SPEAKER_01That's metaphysics, that's not physics. But if you ask why, you're going to get a metaphysical answer. And if you don't ask why, then you're not going to know It just seems to me that if someone
SPEAKER_03responds to their organizational principle and result in structure with, well, let's just reduce it to a larger status. And then we say of that, well, cool. You're importing a lot of free lunch there, so you can have that explanation on both things. It strikes me that if I just turn in the other direction, I think I can just as easily point through a lot of things as possibilities that make possible that actuality.
SPEAKER_03What's the other grounding other than a free lunch there?
SPEAKER_01Well, it's like either historically achieved through a selection process or something that is, I mean, I don't think Levin is thinking of the physical world as an evolutionary process yet, as far as I can tell. I found out the principles of plant physics that biology makes use of. I mean, lots of biologists say that. That's not it. But my question is none of the lunches are free. They've been paid for through generation upon generation of striving occasions
SPEAKER_01of experience, trying to ingress alluring patterns that then can be built on by the next generation and complexified. Right. But I think they're implying this. Thank you.
SPEAKER_03Sequentialness. There's always an unaccounted for states there. But I think when science comes up, it's very comfortable to just say, for whatever reason, well, yeah. It's physics. But look at all this you're smuggling in the background. But I think that happens in philosophy quite a bit. But philosophy makes it explicit. Science does not. And so it creates an asymmetry for that conversation. Yeah, that's a good point.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, everyone.
SPEAKER_03I was like, oh, that was weird. That was great. Yeah. We need to, the three of us, get together and talk about eternal objects. Yeah. That's great. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Man, you know, if there was enough people interested in, um, the convergence of drugs and...
One of the important ideas that Tim and I discussed last night was his threefold differentiation of the inquired (natural science), the speculative (metaphysics), and the prosaic (everyday experience). I agree with him...
Moderator: Andrew M. DavisPanelists: Matthew David Segall, Sherry D. Kling, and Thomas Jay Oord Welcome and introductions ANDREW DAVIS: Welcome, everybody. Good to see you all. We’re late in Beer Camp, and it looks like...
Participants. Dan Koch, moderator; Myron Penner; Sarah Lane Ritchie; Matthew David Segall. See https://theologybeer.camp/2026speakers for bios. Transcript: Dan: If you’re going to be making some meaning you’ve got to be...
I was originally supposed to be in dialogue with Tim Miller of Our Evolving God, but he had to take care of a loved one and so missed this year’s Theology Beer Camp in Kansas City. He prepared some remarks that were...
My conversation with Jason Hoskins, a molecular geneticist and systems biologist at the National Cancer Institute, explored the convergence between contemporary systems biology and process-relational philosophy. Jason...