Moderator: Andrew M. DavisPanelists: Matthew David Segall, Sherry D. Kling, and Thomas Jay Oord Welcome and introductions ANDREW DAVIS: Welcome, everybody. Good to see you all. We’re late in Beer Camp, and it looks like we still have some energy out there. I see a few smiles. This is great. This is the Upside Down, and you saw Vecna over here. I also thought he’d be taller. My name is Andrew Davis, and this session is titled “Transitioning with Whitehead” - and, importantly, “Personal Perspectives.” By a show of hands, how many of you are somewhat familiar with Whitehead? Okay. And for how many of you is this really a new name? A few. Excellent - a nice mix. Our goal today is not really to ask what Whitehead thought and then argue about whether it’s true. We like to do that. Today, we’re going to assume it’s true and ask: What difference does it make? How might we name those differences at individual and collective levels? We’re using the language of “transitioning with Whitehead” because we’re going to focus on five transitions. These are transitions in our ideas, in the sense of being ideological. Ideas inform and transform the way we think and interact with the world. Ideas are important. One of my favorite Whitehead quotes is, “Ideas won’t keep. Something must be done about them.” But I would say - and I hope you guys agree - that these transitions are also existential and spiritual. They involve the nature of our existence and experience, and our attitudinal disposition toward the whole of what is. There are any number of transitions we could name in Whitehead’s universe. Some of these are lifted from the final chapter of my book, Whitehead’s Universe. We’re just going to look at five. I’ll name them quickly, introduce our guests, and then we’ll get into their different perspectives and angles. Let’s try to end with some time for questions, too. I’d love to hear what’s on your minds and how these transitions are fitting with you. The five transitions are: from exception to exemplification; from being to becoming; from mechanism to organism; from force to persuasion; and from passivity to creativity. There’s a certain flow here: from who we are, to what reality is and what its nature and character are like, to what sort of cosmos this is, to the nature of power and how it operates, and to the nature of our participation in the present and the future. To my immediate right is Matt Segall, professor at the California Institute of Integral Studies. Matt has a beautiful way of articulating the scientific, metaphysical, and philosophical connections of this material. To his right is Sherry Kling, our colleague at the Center for Process Studies, now leading the Templeton-funded Modern Meaning Project. She’s an expert in Whitehead and Jung, emphasizing spirituality and transformation - another important angle on these transitions. And, of course, Tom Oord, who needs no introduction. He’s going to give us insight into the open and relational theological side of these transitions, if any - because we also have to ask what these transitions mean for how we think about the reality of God. From exception to exemplification ANDREW DAVIS: Let’s jump into the first transition: from exception to exemplification. This raises the question of whether human beings are just anomalies in the universe, or whether there’s a deep connection we have with this universe and what that might mean. Matt, maybe we can start with you. From a scientific and philosophical perspective, how is the notion that we’re not an exception supported? Where are the challenges? Perhaps bring in your own work and how this transition has been central to it. MATT SEGALL: Thanks, Andrew. When I was in my young teens, I was experimenting with atheism and reading people like Richard Dawkins and Stephen Hawking. The basic idea in their picture of the universe is that there’s this whole physical process that’s more or less blind and dumb, and there are laws of physics that get imported from somewhere - that’s a strange element in this otherwise mechanistic view of the universe, where particles are just colliding. After billions of years of collisions, somehow human consciousness emerges as something added on at the end. The human being is a kind of exception to what the rest of the universe is doing. As a young teen, accepting that vision felt heroic to me. It allowed me to feel smarter than all the dumb religious people who thought we were special and that God uniquely cared about our species. Eventually, as I grew a little older and learned more about the science - the more recent physics and biology, all the alternatives, how much quantum physicists fight with each other, and how much biologists disagree with each other - I realized science was way more open than I had understood from reading the bestsellers by the New Atheists. I realized that this idea of human beings being exceptional was problematic. I learned about the ecological catastrophe. Human exceptionalism is a big problem in terms of how we relate to the rest of the community of life on the planet. It was around that point, when I entered graduate school, that I discovered Whitehead. All of a sudden, this problem of human exceptionalism became something I could resolve through Whitehead’s notion of exemplification. The human being and human consciousness are not an exception to what the rest of the universe is doing, but an amplification of what has always been at least nascent or pregnant. When the universe was just a cloud of hydrogen, somehow human consciousness was already there in germ. That’s not to say that, rather than our being at the edge of an otherwise mechanistic process, now the whole of evolution is heading toward the human. I wouldn’t quite put it that way. It’s rather that we are an expression and exemplification of what the universe has always been doing. We could say, in a kind of Teilhardian way, that the universe personalizes. Human persons are an expression of the deepest dynamics of cosmogenesis. We’re not random accidents; we’re the full flowering of what was seeded already at the origin of everything. ANDREW DAVIS: That’s beautiful. It’s part of what he calls a radical empiricism. He’s coming from William James, who taught at Harvard before him, and saying that if we start anywhere other than human experience when trying to discern the nature and character of things, we’re starting in the wrong spot. There’s a lot that can be said for that. Thanks, Matt - a great opener. Sherry, it seems to me that holding this notion that we’re exceptions to the universe would be detrimental to the spiritual life. From your perspective - and speak personally, too - what’s involved spiritually when we make that transition? What transformative capacities are embedded within it? SHERRY KLING: I think there’s so much. First of all, if we think of ourselves as exceptions to the rest of nature, that effectively means we’re orphans. We’ve orphaned ourselves from the family of life. But if we’re an exemplification - and I’m thinking of where Whitehead says our bodies lie in the field of nature - then we’re embedded within the natural world. We are what life is doing, perhaps in a particular way. If we see ourselves as embedded rather than orphaned, everything is kin to us. Everything in the natural world is our family. We’re connected, and we can greet it. I say hello to every lizard and every squirrel when I’m walking around outside. Yesterday, when I came out of the restroom, there was a moth underneath the fountain. I put out my hand so I could get it, and it climbed into my hand. I walked outside and opened my hand, and it sat on my finger for a little while, doing this little thing like, “I need to clean up a little before I take off.” Then it went on its way. I was just like, “I love you.” We expand our family, our connection, and our belonging when we see ourselves as exemplifications. We can also see ourselves as having a kind of dignity. What we do contributes to the life of t… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit footnotes2plato.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Okay, well welcome everybody. Good to see you all. We're late in beer camp and it looks like we have some energy out there. I see a few smiles. This is great. This is the upside down. If you saw Vecna over here, I also thought he'd be taller. Not as scary as the actual Vecna. My name is Andrew Davis and this session today is titled Transitioning with Whitehead and importantly, Personal Perspectives. So just by show of hand, how many of you are somewhat familiar with Whitehead?
SPEAKER_02Okay, how many of you, this is really a new name? Okay, a few. Excellent. Nice mix. Our goal today is not really to ask what Whitehead thought and then argue about whether it's true.
SPEAKER_01We like to
SPEAKER_02do that. It's more going to be about... We assume it's true. It's more going to be about what differences make and how might we name those differences at individual and also collective levels. There might be a number of ways to do that. The reason we use the language of transitioning with Whitehead is because we're going to focus on five transitions. They're transitions in our ideas, in the sense of being ideological, right? And ideas inform and transform the way in which we think and interact with the world.
SPEAKER_02Ideas are important. One of my favorite Whitehead quotes, ideas won't keep, something must be done about them, right? But I would say, and I hope you guys might agree, that they're also... Existential and spiritual in the sense that they involve the nature of our existence and our experience and our kind of attitudinal disposition towards the whole of what is. So there's any number of transitions, arguably, that we could name in Whitehead's Universe. In fact, some of these are lifted from the final chapter of my book, Whitehead's Universe.
SPEAKER_02We're just going to look at five. So I'll name the five quickly. I'll introduce our guests here and then we'll get into the different perspectives and angles they have on these issues. Let's try to end with some time for questions too. I'd love to open it up to everybody just to see what's on your mind and how these transitions are fitting with you. But just by way of naming the transitions first, from exception to exemplification, from being to becoming, from mechanism to organism,
SPEAKER_02From force to persuasion, and from passivity to creativity. There's a certain flow here, right? A movement from who we are to what is reality, what's its nature and character like, to what sort of cosmos this is, to the nature of power and how it operates, and to the nature of our participation in the present and indeed the future. So I have with me Matt Siegel to my immediate right. Professor at the California Institute of Integral Studies.
SPEAKER_02Matt has a beautiful way of articulating the scientific and indeed the metaphysical, philosophical connections of this material. To his right, Sherry Kling, our colleague at the Center for Process Studies, leading now the Templeton-funded Modern Meaning Project, which is fantastic. An expert in Whitehead and Jung, but also emphasizing spirituality and transformation. Another important angle, I think, on these transitions. And of course, Tom Ward, who needs no introduction, who's going to be giving us insight on the open and relational,
SPEAKER_02the theological side of these transitions, if any, right? Because we also have to ask, well, what do these mean for what we think about the reality of God? So let's jump in then to the first transition. From exception to exemplification. And this whole question as to whether human beings are just anomalous, anomalies in the universe, or whether or not there's a deep connection we have to this universe and what that might mean. And Matt, maybe we can just start with you here because I'd be curious to hear from
SPEAKER_02the scientific philosophical perspective, how is this notion that we're Not an exception, supported? Where are the challenges? And maybe bring in your own work and how this transition from exception to exemplification has been central.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, thanks, Andrew. You know, when I was in my young teens, I was experimenting with atheism and was reading people like Richard Dawkins and Stephen Hawking and, you know, the basic idea in terms of what human beings are and human consciousness is and their picture of the universe is that, you know, there's this whole physical process that's more or less blind and dumb and there are laws of physics that get imported from somewhere.
SPEAKER_03That's a little bit of a strange element in this otherwise mechanistic view of the universe where particles are just colliding and after billions of years of collisions, somehow human consciousness emerges and something kind of added at the end. And so the human being is a kind of exception to what the rest of the universe is doing. And that as a young teen was accepting that vision felt like heroic to me because it allowed me to feel smarter than all the dumb religious people who think
SPEAKER_03that we're special and that God uniquely cares about our species. And eventually, though, as I grew a little bit older and I learned more about all the science and the physics and biology that's been done more recently and all the alternatives and how much quantum physicists fight with each other and how much biologists disagree with each other and that science was way more open than I realized, just reading the bestsellers by the new atheists and whatnot, I realized that I...
SPEAKER_03This idea of human beings being exceptional was problematic. And then, of course, I learned about the ecological crisis. And human exceptionalism is a big problem in terms of how we relate to the rest of the community of life on the planet. And it was around that point when I entered grad school that I discovered Whitehead. And all of a sudden, this idea of human beings being exceptional became... A problem I could resolve through Whitehead's notion of exemplification, that actually the human being and human consciousness is not an exception to what the rest of the universe is doing,
SPEAKER_03but an amplification of what's always been at least nascent or pregnant. When the universe was just a cloud of hydrogen, somehow human consciousness was pregnant or in germ already. And that's not to say, you know, Rather than us being at the edge of an otherwise mechanistic process, now somehow the whole of evolution is heading towards the human. I wouldn't quite put it that way. It's rather just that we are an expression of an exemplification of what
SPEAKER_03the universe has always been doing and that we could say in a kind of Teilhardian way that the universe personalizes. Like human persons are an expression of the deepest dynamics of cosmogenesis. So we're not Random accidents were actually the full flowering of what was seeded already at the origin of everything. That's beautiful.
SPEAKER_02And it's part of what Whitehead calls a radical empiricism, right? He's coming from William James, who taught at Harvard before him, and saying, if we start anywhere other than human experience when trying to pierce what the nature and character of things is like, we're starting in the wrong spot. There's a lot that can be said for that. So thanks, Matt. Great opener. Sure, it seems to me that if we think about the spiritual life, if we hold this notion that we're exceptions to the universe,
SPEAKER_02that seems to be detrimental to the spiritual life. So what, in your perspective, and speak personally if you will too, what's involved spiritually when we make that transition? What sort of transformative capacities are embedded within?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think there's so much. I mean, first of all, I think if we have to think of ourselves as exceptions to the rest of nature, that is, in effect, means that we're orphans. We've just orphaned ourselves from the family of life. But if we're an exemplification, then, you know, and I'm just thinking, too, where Whitehead says our bodies lie in the field of nature. And so we are embedded within the natural world. We are just what life is doing, but maybe in a particular way.
SPEAKER_01And so if we see ourselves not as orphaned, but as embedded, then everything is kin to us. Everything in the natural world is our family, and we are connected. And we can greet, I mean, I say hello to every, like, lizard and every squirrel, you know, as I'm walking around outside. And I'm looking, you know, like there was a moth, and I came out of the restroom yesterday, there was a moth underneath the fountain.
SPEAKER_01The fountain, and I put my hand so I could get it, and it was like in my hand, and I walked outside, and I opened my hand, and it sat on my finger for a little bit, was kind of doing this little, like, I need to clean up a little before I take off. And then it went on its way, you know, and I was just like, I love you, you know. So we just expand our family. We expand our connection. We expand our belonging when we see ourselves as exemplifications. And also, we then can see ourselves maybe as having a kind of a dignity that what we
SPEAKER_01Is not only contributing to the life of the world and the life of God, but that we can reflect on that, maybe is part of our unique role, allows us to recognize what we are doing and how we are contributing. So yeah, I think it just can make our whole spiritual life come alive in a new way to see ourselves as an exemplification, as embedded, and not as an exception.
SPEAKER_02I love the statement of the body being a field of nature. In one of my chapters, I say the body's geography. It's just as natural as trees, rivers, and rain. And if you were to take that seriously, doesn't that mean that experience in some sense pervades nature, right? If not, we run into a host of philosophical problems. We don't necessarily have to go there yet. But spiritually, one of my favorite statements Whitehead makes, just because, again, I'm a Whitehead nerd, he says, to know that our experience, dim and fragmentary as it is, yet sounds... The utmost depths of reality, right?
SPEAKER_02So what is ultimate is intimate, right? And you want to find that intimacy in the midst of your experience. That to me has been spiritually very, very significant.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Tom, if we come to the theological side, I would be curious to hear, you know, personally, but also theoretically, what does this mean for thinking about God or human uniqueness as well? I mean, part of the Claim of Imago Dei is a certain drawing us out from nature, making us, at least in some interpretations, an exception. Is this a challenge to that? I'm curious to hear your thoughts.
SPEAKER_00I think it is. Let me begin by saying, Andrew quotes Whitehead really well. I'm going to quote the Bible.
SPEAKER_02I won't say St. Louis. Why have you appreciated the Bible? He did. Part four of my book. The Gospel of Al.
SPEAKER_00I think the first Bible verse I ever learned is probably one many of you know, for God so loved the world. Another one I learned said, Beloved, let us love one another, for love is from God, and everyone who loves is born of God and knows God. The one that doesn't love doesn't know God, for God is love. First and second commandment, love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength. And actually, one of the Bible verses for the last 20 years has kind of been, you know, I come from a tradition, they say, what's your personal verse?
SPEAKER_00This has been my personal verse for the last 20 years. Ephesians 5.1, imitate God as dearly beloved children and live a life of love as Christ loved us. Love is at the core of how I want to live my life and how I think about God. And I know there are some passages of scripture that don't support the love themes, but I think the majority do point toward a God of love. Now, next to the Bible in Christian history, the most influential theologian is Augustine.
SPEAKER_00And if you want to know what he has to say about love, look at his book, Teaching Christianity. And here's what he says. Love is a craving or a desire. It takes two forms. Love is fruity or uti. Love either enjoys or uses. And then he says, well, what does this mean for God? Well, he thinks to himself, well, God would only want the highest good, the thing of most value, and that's God's self. So God must only enjoy God's self, which is another way to say God only loves God's self.
SPEAKER_00And then he says, yeah, but what about use? Does God use us? Well, I guess we're going to have to say God uses us, but not in the same way as we use things, because God has no needs. So the most formative theologian in the Christian tradition takes God so loved the world and replaces it with God really just loves God's self. And loving our neighbors is actually not loving our neighbors for their sake. It's to love God through your neighbors. That seems so at odds with the Bible I was taught and still read.
SPEAKER_00Why would it go that route? Well, Augustine wants a God who is an exception, not an exemplification. Whitehead wants a God who is outside time, who is not affected by anything whatsoever. He said Whitehead. Oops. Augustine. Thank you for correcting me. Augustine wants a God. Who's outside of time, who's unaffected, who's unchanging, who only loves God's self.
SPEAKER_00That is the formal Christian tradition coming through Augustine. And in that case, God is an exception to everything we know is loving. An exception to the vast majority of scripture says about a God of love. Whitehead comes along and says, we're not invoking God as an exception to the categories of existence to save them from collapsing on itself. Rather, God is the chief exemplification of existence, which spins out as saying God is in time.
SPEAKER_00God is relational. God changes in some respects. God not only loves God's self, but God loves you and me. That is a beautiful thing and far more scriptural than what Augustine and many in the tradition have said. That's God as an exemplification of the categories of existence rather than an exception to them.
SPEAKER_02It is great. And it's a distinction, we might say, between a natural and supernatural framing of God, too. Because historically, if God supernaturally establishes the ultimate conditions of being and becoming, but is not bound by them, that's a supernatural framing. But if God's not metaphysically connected to the world, somehow that's a problem. After all, what bridge do you cross experientially to go from one side to the next? Or must you just be quiet, a hush of apophatic silence? So to say that there is a metaphysical bridge connecting what is here and what is there, as it were,
SPEAKER_02although it's always present, there is a bridge that we can traverse experientially, rationally, to God as the chief embodiment of those ultimate principles of being and becoming. One quick follow-up, and I wonder if you can try to do it in one sentence each. What do you say, and then we'll move on to the second transition, what do you say to the critic who says, Saying human beings are an exemplification seems like a demotion of them. And I'm rather keen to preserve the uniqueness of human beings. Is there a tension there? Could we still be unique if we exemplify the nature and character of, well, nature?
SPEAKER_03I think we can still consider ourselves the imago dei, but also microcosmoi, which is to say mirrors of the cosmos. And our unique role, there was a semicolon there, our unique role... Is to mirror the cosmos, like to celebrate the creation. That's what makes us unique. So we're both unique and universal in that relationship to the whole cosmos.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would say there is a unique role that I think we can preserve in that Imago Dei sense, in that sense of being the face of God in the world. And so that there is great dignity in being human. And I just want to mention, too, you know, I... I kind of have become, I kind of bristle now a little bit when people want to say, oh, the more than human world, the more than human world. I prefer to say the other than human world. Because I think, yeah, we want to acknowledge that it's not just non-humans versus humans.
SPEAKER_01But I also don't want to just say, I want to demote humans so much that everything else is more than. I just want to say other
SPEAKER_00than human.
SPEAKER_01This is my personal point.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm with them. My one sense would be something like, yes, humans are unique in some ways, but I'm much more interested in lifting the status, the intrinsic status of non-human creatures than trying to make a big gap between humans and the rest of everybody else.
SPEAKER_02Great. Excellent. Well, we'll transition now to the The second transition. So that was from exception to exemplification. I mean, whole books could be written on that topic and have been. Thanks for your comments. And the second transition is from being to becoming. And so at the heart of a Whiteheadian vision is this notion that reality is verb-like before it's noun-like, that becoming is more fundamental than being. And this seems to be a transition that would have some important and pragmatic outcomes as we think about our lives, as we think about our ideas.
SPEAKER_02So Sherry, maybe we can start with you on this one. How important is this notion that we're unfinished? I mean, if we're not confined to, say, the noun-like fixations of the past and the future is open, what does that mean spiritually? And maybe give a personal example if you can.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it means a great deal, especially for those of us who have suffered any kind of trauma or adverse childhood experiences or have been stuck in conditions that have not caused flourishing in our lives. If we were beings that were fully determined, there wouldn't be much hope for change or for positive change. But if we are becoming, yes, and I want to say that yes, there is real pressure from the past.
SPEAKER_01Whitehead wouldn't deny that. The past does put pressure on the next moment. It is much easier to just repeat the past. And I think that's what complexes are all about. Because the complex makes us react to life from an image based on the past. But if we are becomeings, if we're always in the process of becoming, and new possibilities in every moment come from God, as Whitehead says, and process theologians say, then there's always hope for positive change.
SPEAKER_01There's always movement. There's always possibility. It may be minuscule. Maybe within our current finite conditions, the next step toward positive change is minuscule, but it's there. And that is very hopeful to me.
SPEAKER_02Beautiful. Matt, if we think about this metaphysically or scientifically, haven't we suffered in the modern world under a dominant vision of substance and matter, really, that what is fundamental is dead, vacuous matter? But that all changed with the advance of the science as Whitehead paid attention to that. And how would you frame this transition from being to becoming in light of those advances?
SPEAKER_03Well, scientifically, I think the role of possibility, which when you talk about What makes becoming rather than being important metaphysically, it's that all of a sudden possibilities are just as relevant as actualities. And with the quantum revolution, and even before the quantum revolution in the 19th century with thermodynamics, there was a realization that we can't actually predict where every atom is. We can't know where it is right now, and we can't predict where all the atoms will be at any T plus 500 or whatever.
SPEAKER_03We need statistics to do science. So rather than fully reductionistic science where you can literally be certain where every particle is, there was a shift in the 19th century through the study of thermodynamics towards statistical reasoning about nature. And then quantum physics is just building on that and recognizing that on some interpretations, even in principle, if we were to know all the initial conditions, we still couldn't predict How the wave function so-called is going to collapse. Now, I think in terms of Whitehead, he's a process philosopher, obviously.
SPEAKER_03He titles his magnum opus, Process and Reality. But in that book, it's not just that reality is composed of these becomeings or actual occasions of experience and that no thinker thinks twice, he will say. We're different in each moment. There are actual occasions. But there are also eternal objects. And so he's just as much a thinker of Permanence and eternity, the primordial nature of God is out of time. And the primordial nature of God knows everything that there is to know about possibilities.
SPEAKER_03What God doesn't know is about actualities. God doesn't know how the actual future will unfold. And so I think Heraclitus and Parmenides in the ancient Greek world are holding it down for Becoming and being, flux and form, you might say. I think Whitehead's like Plato, who's kind of already in the ancient world synthesizing these two great visions of being, you know, Parmenides just says being is, and Heraclitus says everything flows.
SPEAKER_03Plato's synthesizing that and then Timaeus and saying, and in other dialogues like the Sophist, becoming is also a kind of being. Whitehead's also doing something similar. So he's a process philosopher, But he's not just getting rid of eternity, right? So it's becoming with being, or being with becoming.
SPEAKER_02And that addition of possibility as a reality, not just actuality, seems important for Sherry's comment too. Because the power of the past is, if they're only actualities with efficient causation, all the past was doing was determining the present. You know, you can see how we just endlessly repeat, but possibilities allow the past or the present to be different and chart a new path of transformation seems very significant. Well, maybe we can come back to that, but Tom, let's come to you on this becoming in God. I mean, isn't this, let me, you threw that to me on stage earlier.
SPEAKER_02Isn't this a contradiction? I mean, Matt just talked about the eternity of God. How can God be eternal in becoming and why does God need to become?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, key. Let me start by answering that by saying I'm attempting an audacious task. I'm writing a three-volume systematic theology of love. The last probably great or influential systematic theology from a progressive perspective, and lots of really good progressive books in theology, but like a systematic theology, is probably Paul Tillich's books written 60 to 70 years ago. Tillich in those books reacts against the kind of God I imagined as a kid.
SPEAKER_00You know, I thought God was up there somewhere in the clouds as a particular bodied individual who might occasionally come down and talk to Moses, but never with me, and needed to have a Holy Spirit, whatever that was, send that out there. But God in God's self was this being out there who might intervene from time to time. And Tillich rightly came down hard on that view. He says, God's not like that. God is everywhere. And he comes up with this language, God is being itself or the ground of being.
SPEAKER_00And it has the advantage of us thinking God is omnipresent right down to the smallest to the largest. That was the great advantage. There's a huge disadvantage. Being, for Tillich, doesn't have the kind of dynamism that becoming suggests. And it's really hard to imagine a lover who is, in all respects, unchanging, unmoved, unaffected. And yet, in essence, that's the kind of God Tillich wants to give us with this being itself.
SPEAKER_00This is what, in academic terms, is called ontotheology, theology based upon a being of God. Now, I like the living God of the Bible. And I don't think it makes much sense to say God is truly a lover, giving and receiving moment by moment, if God is unchanging being itself. So that's where Whitehead comes to the rescue. Because he's got a God whose experience changes moment by moment.
SPEAKER_00A becoming God. Not that God wasn't God in the past and is now becoming God, but God's experience moves and changes moment by moment. God even learns new information, which is what Matt says. And this dynamic, relational, living God has a nature that's unchanging. But experience that changes moment by moment. So instead of the ontotheology of the God of being itself,
SPEAKER_00I decided to invent a new word because I like inventing words. I went back to my Greek studies and the Greek for becoming is genomai. So geno theology is a A theology of a becoming God. Not a God who didn't used to be God and now is, but a God who's always been God throughout all eternity, but learns, changes, experiences moment by moment in a dynamic, living way.
SPEAKER_02I wonder if, you know, a synonym for becoming, Matt, just a brief comment from each of you about the significance of time here. Philosophically or scientifically, Spirituality, the temporal dimension that takes time, right? And then obviously, theologically, I mean, this is all very controversial, but maybe just a quick comment on the relevance of becoming to time.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Time is, we usually think, what clocks are trying to measure. But just because it's 342 on the clock doesn't mean that the clock is causing it to be that time, and actually the clock itself is aging, and so... We have all these ways that clocks calendars to try to measure time, but we don't actually get at time as we live through it. And I think what Whitehead's vision of becoming is pointing to is not some measurable quantity.
SPEAKER_03That is in physics equations as t, but rather the growth that we experience as human beings, the growth that we witness in the vegetal world and the animal world, it's a creative process that seems to intensify experience as it goes. And so bringing Whitehead's vision of becoming to bear on how physics usually thinks
SPEAKER_03about time, I think, really breaks us free of the clutches of a kind of mechanism, which we'll get to in the next proposition, by allowing us to see that time, concretely speaking, is a process of growth. It's not just something quantifiable.
SPEAKER_02Time is a process of growth that seems really relevant to the spiritual side of things.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and it's interesting for me because I'm thinking in two different ways. There is that sense that, you know, again, there's that hopefulness that the next moment can be different from this current moment. You know, one of the things that, I mean, there's suicide in my family, and And there's been times when I've considered and been close. And it's because I've thought to myself, my life is never going to change. This pain is never going to get better. But if there's that sense that there's a flow and that in that next moment there's always that possibility, that is hopeful.
SPEAKER_01At the same time, I want to think about the now, the power of now, that God the I am is the now. And not future tripping, as William Paul Young likes to say. But there's that sense, there's almost a spaciousness in the now where the spirit is, where I'm thinking of that moment in experience. In concrescence, Whitehead's word for that becoming, that moment of solitariness where the decision is made of what
SPEAKER_01that moment will actualize almost seems to me like that pregnant pause of the spirit of the now where that possibility is just all present and we can then respond in a way that's not just about the past but respond and it'd be in that flow of Of the now toward the next. To me, it's both. But both are really important.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Yeah, and I just say, you know, the idea that God is... In time or moving through time, there's lots of ways to talk about it. I mean, we get, at least I do, I'm guessing you guys do as well, I get criticism all the time. Oh, your God is bound by time. And I always say, well, your God is stuck outside of time. But the way to kind of bring the two insights together to say God's experience is moving through time,
SPEAKER_00but God's nature or essence is timeless. And then we can have the best of both worlds.
SPEAKER_02And there's always a tension in the classical tradition about how God can really know a world if God is fully outside time. After all, the world is the time-bound flux of existence. Excellent. From being to the coming. All right, the next transition is from mechanism to organism. Matt mentioned Whitehead's book Process and Reality. But Whitehead, in fact, didn't call his philosophy process philosophy. What he called it was a philosophy of organism.
SPEAKER_02And so, Matt, let's come to you first. Why? And what in the sciences was suggesting a kind of organic turn for Whitehead? Why did philosophy need to keep up in that regard?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, one of my favorite lines from, I think, Science in the Modern World, where Whitehead says science is becoming the study of organisms. Physics studies the smaller organisms, and biology studies, he said, the larger, I would say the midsize, because astrophysics studies the really big organisms. And what he's intuiting there is that Already in the early 20th century, there was a whole, it was called the organicist movement in biology. Whitehead had an influence on it and was influenced by it. And then general systems theory, Ludwig von Bertolanfi develops this approach to studying the whole of nature as
SPEAKER_03a series of nested self-organizing systems. And complex system science then comes out of that. In the later 20th century, the Santa Fe Institute is known for continuing the study of complexity. And I'm not reading... What there is, whether you're talking about atomic elements, or stars and galaxies, or cells, or multicellular organisms, or whole ecosystems, or whole economies, what there is, finally, are self-organizing systems. Organisms, in other words.
SPEAKER_03Now, there are different approaches to studying organisms that consider, like, autopoesis is a Greek term, Francisco Varela, Alberto Materano, some Chilean Theoretical biologists developed this. Has anyone heard of this term before, autopoiesis? Okay. It just means self-making. And so they think organisms are self-making systems. Autopoesis. More recently, Whiteheadian feminist philosopher science Donna Haraway criticized this view
SPEAKER_03and said, no, no, organisms are sympoetic, not autopoetic. She says, nothing makes itself. Why? Because everything is in relationship with everything else. And so mechanism to organism, if you think organisms are just autopoetic, Kind of closed systems. They even have this term, Matron and Varela, operational closure, to describe what an autopoetic system or organism is like. You might get the wrong idea. You might lose the relational element that's present in Whitehead that Haraway's bringing forward with sympoesis.
SPEAKER_03And so it could be what we really want. We want to break open this idea of organismic closure. So maybe it's more like mechanism to orgasm would be my alternative orgasmic philosophy.
SPEAKER_01LAUGHTER
SPEAKER_03Organic realism, which was great, you know, Whitehead, but to orgasmic realism. He must have gotten that joke at Harvard. If I was a student, I'd be like, you know, Whitehead,
SPEAKER_02one couple letters missing here. Thank you, man. That was beautiful. I like the notion of self-making in relation. Sherry, I think... Isn't there a personal self-making aspect to the spiritual side, but don't we falter to the extent that we only restrict it to the self, I wonder? The relational component seems really important here.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, you know, I was talking in my workshop about dreams that, you know, I asked the question, who's on our team? You know, when we deconstruct religion or walk away from From organizations and systems, we can feel really alone and like we're isolated and is it all up to me? But I'm asking, who's on your team? Well, if we have a relational reality and a relational God, God's on our team. And Jung talked about a relational psyche.
SPEAKER_01Where the psyche is always in contact with an autonomous objective other, the collective unconscious, and there's always that confrontation, so the self is never being developed alone. The psyche is always in this compensatory relationship with the unconscious that's always bringing something new to the discussion. And I just think about that difference between mechanism and organism. You know, a machine has parts. Parts are all hard.
SPEAKER_01You think about parts of a car or parts of gears in a machine. They can only be what they are at the beginning. They never change. They're just in a mode. They do one thing. They do one thing only. But if life is an organism and connected to everything, it's like I'm thinking of the The systems of tree roots and the mother tree and the fungi and that, you know, there's always new things coming into the system. There's always new things coming into the psyche from the unconscious.
SPEAKER_01There's always new possibilities coming from God. I mean, I don't want to sound like a broken record, but again, what is the more hopeful image? If we're just machine parts playing a role that never changes, moving from one thing to the next, then our future is foreclosed. But if we are part of a living system where new information is coming, we are part of a flow, then there's so much more aliveness there,
SPEAKER_01so much more vitality, so much more zest, so much more orgasm.
SPEAKER_00Why not?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, orgasm's ass is October's ass. Tom, Teilhard, Charles Kingsley, a number of others said God creates self-creators. Yeah. So it's a form of creation, but it's markedly different from a typical kind of creation.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_02How would you frame that? What are some of the issues involved?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think the way I frame it is to first of all celebrate that in the last few hundred years, I think there's been a shift in theology, generally speaking, toward recognizing the agency of the human. We'll call it freedom, we'll call it free will, that humans have some kind of role. And you get someone even like Alvin Plantinga, who comes from a reformed Calvinist perspective, who gives a free will defense. He believes in real libertarian free will. I think that's a really big plus,
SPEAKER_00especially when we're talking about questions like the problem of evil, like why didn't God stop this? Well, the quick answer is, well, they were using their freedom and God doesn't want to override freedom. But it's a choice on their part, usually, when they think of God. But I think one of the things that Whitehead does in this shift to organism is think about agency all the way down. And so that helps us not only give a better answer to the problem of evil, especially what we call natural evil, like, well, why didn't God stop the pandemic? Well, maybe the viruses and the pandemic have some agency, too,
SPEAKER_00that even God can't control, because as I see it, God's an uncontrolling lover of everyone and everything. So the shift from thinking about the world as a machine, in which you and I are just cogs in the machine, kind of was breaking down, so we've got some agency. What Whitehead does is take that all the way to the bottom and say, it's agency all the way down. And that agency relates, as Sherry is saying, in real organismic ways. And that's why God can love, really love the whole wide world.
SPEAKER_00From cells, or actually my favorite line is, from quarks to quinoa to queers to quasars. You say quinoa? Quinoa. I need a Q in there. Sorry. Tom's getting hungry.
SPEAKER_01I just want to add one more thought to that too, that I think this idea that moving from mechanism to organism also changes the way we can think about prayer. Because if the world is a machine, or say a computer system where their software has been already coded, then we have to pray to the one that's doing the coding. We have to pray to the one that made the machine, that then plead that they act upon the machine that they created, or recode the software that they wrote.
SPEAKER_01But if we're part of an organism that is all alive with free, with agents that have agency, what if our prayers actually go horizontal as well as vertical? What if we can actually affect, I can pray for Matt and actually pray to the cells in his body or for the natural world? What if I can actually... Influence the aims that all of the world that's in this system want to actualize
SPEAKER_01and maybe persuade. So maybe we all have that power. And maybe prayer is more like that.
SPEAKER_02Pray horizontally.
SPEAKER_01Beautiful. That's why prayer for me is not requesting, it's listening.
SPEAKER_00Pray horizontally also works with orgasm. LAUGHTER
SPEAKER_03There is a photo out of Matt Tom, I want to show you. Moving right along. Earlier, just one more thing on the mechanism to organism piece. I said earlier that this mechanistic vision of the universe is particles banging into each other, but where do these laws of physics come from? The one thing that scientific materialism, reductionistic physicalism, and intelligent design actually share is The mechanistic picture of the universe, right?
SPEAKER_03Whether it's a coercing God or the absent God that left his laws behind. Like, where did these laws come from? So, moving to organism is moving to a completely different vision, not only of nature, but of the divine. It's not coercive.
SPEAKER_02All right, well, before we move on to the next one, let me come back a little bit. Because, man, look at the unbelievable success of AI. Look at all that's being accomplished. Isn't this somehow evidence that a sort of mechanistic, algorithmic, computational picture is more correct rather than less? If you only recently wrote a book on the topic. Give us just a minute or two on an AI connection with this transition. Obviously, it's going to be hard to do, but I trust it.
SPEAKER_03The book, which I wish was here, but was late getting delivered, Remembering the Human Microcosm in the Age of Mechanized Intelligence. As a pan-experientialist, I get often asked, well, you must think AI is conscious, right? And it's just not that simple. The superconductors with logic gates and electrons flowing through them according to digitized codes that might have been learned through this really fascinating neural network machine learning process, it's a stack.
SPEAKER_03It's one of the most amazing technological achievements, but there's no meaning being Realized in those transistors. There's certainly no consciousness being realized in those transistors. Even from a Whiteheadian point of view, we could say that the electrons might be these pulses of emotion, but Whitehead would distinguish between the physical purposes that are being realized by those electrons and the propositional feelings. Sorry, I'm getting into Whiteheadese here,
SPEAKER_03but consciousness for Whitehead is not what pervades the universe. He distinguishes consciousness and experience, And we can acknowledge the experience of the silicon atoms and the electrons without claiming that somehow consciousness is being achieved, because for Whitehead, consciousness requires billions of years of cellular collaboration to give rise to our physiology and our nervous systems, to channel experience from our environment into, he says, the interstices of the brain.
SPEAKER_03And as we learned from Shailene, Our hearts also have neurons. Our guts have neurons. All of our organs are participating in the realization of what we call consciousness. But I see no reason to think AI as it currently exists in its current form would be conscious, even as a pan-experentialist.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I just wanted to bring that up because this is another... The success of AI risks... A recourse back to a certain style of mechanistic thinking, right, and raises all sorts of new debates. Remembering the Human Microcosm is a great, great book, less than 100 pages, and believe me, Matt can do more than that. Excellent, thank you guys. So, from mechanism to organism. Okay, the next one is one of my favorites, and we're going to let Tom lead with this one. It's from Force to Persuasion. So, light had remained one of the most voracious critics of power In the modern world,
SPEAKER_02and theological power at that. I often say, or I suggest, we can put him alongside the other masters of suspicion, Nietzsche, Marx, Freud, albeit without holding to their ultimately atheistic conclusions. So, what does this transition mean theologically? What are we giving up, and what are we gaining? And Cornell praised Whitehead and then said, oh, there's other things I don't like about it. Maybe he meant that a God without omnipotent power is not enough.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02To liberate communities of suffering. I'm curious to hear your take on that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's definitely, I want to address that. I said there's been movement in the last few hundred years in theology toward more recognition that at least humans have free will. And part of that has meant that there's been a decline in what we call theological determinism. The idea that God controls absolutely everything. Nine people out of ten that I talk to think that that view ends up portraying God as a real jerk because of all the bad... You know, now that I'm not at holiness anymore, I can say a real dick.
SPEAKER_00Anyway, I don't cuss well because I'm from the holiness tradition. Anyway... But what has happened is free will theists who rightly talk about freedom, and some of them even stretch it down to the smaller agents of reality, still want to hold on to a God who could force, but just chooses to use persuasion most of the time.
SPEAKER_00You know, the really important stuff, God makes sure by force that that happens. But the rest of the stuff, God's persuading. Well, the problem, there's lots of problems with that. One of them is, okay, so that means that God really cares only about a few things that are super important to make sure they get done, but not other things. So the problem of evil rears its ugly head once again. If you have a God, however, who simply can't, Control anyone or anything.
SPEAKER_00Can't force anyone, and by anyone I mean more than just humans, down to the smallest level. Can't be the sole cause of any event. Then you've got a way to solve the biggest question atheists, agnostics, and most people who believe in God ask, and that is the problem of evil. God simply can't rescue single-handedly. God requires our cooperation. Now, I'm a liberationist.
SPEAKER_00I believe God wants to see the liberation of oppressed people. But oftentimes when I present this model of God to Cornel West and other folks, they say, ugh, like what happened to God the liberator? I'm hoping that God is going to liberate us from our oppression. And I like that idea too. But when I'm being real snarky, I say to Cornell, how's that working out for
SPEAKER_01you?
SPEAKER_00That God's asleep at the switch for thousands and thousands of years. Okay, maybe some instances people seem to gain their freedom, but in lots of other instances, not so much. What if God is a God of liberation? God is always working for the liberation of all oppressed people, but God requires our cooperation. There is a persuasive rather than force element here.
SPEAKER_00God is an active agent, just not a controlling agent. That's at least one way to interpret Whitehead's view on persuasion and force.
SPEAKER_02Great, that's great, Tom. Sure, in thinking about spirituality, transformation, the domain of psychology, I mean, can transformation ever be forced? Yeah. Think of it in a therapy setting or think of it in a theological setting. I mean, it seems like there has to be freedom here. There has to be the ability to persuade and agency and freedom come into that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's, you know, I think that we can resist transformation. We can be stubborn. And life will, I think, ratchet up the pressure of As time goes by, because life is about change and transformation. And I have a song that I wrote called Crack in the Door because I was thinking about how those times There were times when I really wanted something to change
SPEAKER_01in my life, like a behavior pattern that I had, and I really wanted it to change. So there's this idea that if I say, if I pray, I'm willing to let this go, that that's a step toward healing. And sometimes I wasn't even willing to say that. But I could say, I am willing to be willing. And to me, that just was enough of a crack in the door to let God come through. That's how the chorus says.
SPEAKER_01So there is that, I have to be willing to open that door. Jung said that when we don't work with our unconscious material that's coming to us from the subconscious, it comes to us as illness or fate. And so I do have to be willing and then can move with the help that comes. But I also want to mention here kind of another side, and it goes along with the question of Liberation and communities,
SPEAKER_01but also thinking, again, of individuals and trauma, individuals experiencing abuse and horrible situations. And there's a beautiful book called The Proverbs of Ashes by Rita Nakashima Brock and Rebecca Parker. And they're talking about the atonement and their rejection of this idea of abusive father He sends his son to be killed in order to save the world and heal
SPEAKER_01the world. And so they're coming at that from their own perspective. And each one was sharing very personal experiences around abusive situations. And Rebecca Parker's story had to do with really horrific abuse she experienced at the hands of a neighbor at like five years old. And she said that in the midst of the worst of that, she had She had this absolutely clear sense that God was in the corner of the room.
SPEAKER_01That the light, she could see God's light in the corner of the room. And she said, I knew that if this neighbor could have turned and seen that light, there is no way he could have done what he did. So she could feel God in that space, trying desperately to get this man's attention. And he wouldn't look. And so again, that goes back to that idea of there's that agency. And in a way, maybe that's not enough.
SPEAKER_01In a way, that doesn't feel like enough for someone who's been in the midst of an experience like that. But at the same time, there's that companioning. There's always that presence. And I come back to Jesus on the cross. He wasn't rescued from that cross. But God was with him. He felt abandoned. According to the narrative. But that presence, I believe that presence never left him.
SPEAKER_01And that's, you know, that is comforting to at least to some degree that that presence is always there and trying, trying to get the world to change.
SPEAKER_00I love what you said. It reminded me of one of my favorite stories of an argument I had with one of my former theological colleagues. I was laying out the vision that we're laying out here of a God who never controls and can't control others. And he looked at me and said, you know, Tom, your God is just doing the best he can. And I looked at him and I said, your God could be doing a whole lot better but choosing not to.
SPEAKER_00And if I have to choose between a God who's trying but can't control or a God who could have fixed it but letting it happen, I'd rather go with a God who's trying but can't control.
SPEAKER_02And I would add, and that will come to you, there's a difference between a God who's trying but can't control and a God who's trying but can't control but also suffers with. Yeah, that's true. And I think Whitehead's beautiful line, God is the great companion, the fellow sufferer who understands. It's one thing if God doesn't have the kind of power to stop evil. It's another if God, attended to that, suffers with the world. That means God's a part of the victimhood of existence. Part of creation is a risk for God to...
SPEAKER_01Feeling all of it.
SPEAKER_02Sorry, we're leaving Matt out. Go ahead and jump in. Persuasion is not just theological or spiritual.
SPEAKER_03I might need to stay theological now, not do the science thing. Let's take off the science hat. I mean, okay. Distrust all those in whom the urge to punish is strong. Who said that? Nietzsche. Thus spoke Zarathustra. Nietzsche's an atheist. He doesn't believe in that god. Whose urge to punish is strong. Maybe it shouldn't even be force versus persuasion.
SPEAKER_03It should be punishment versus persuasion. Because if God could control, we'd never disobey.
SPEAKER_00We'd always behave.
SPEAKER_03We wouldn't have been created in such a way that we wouldn't naturally do what God wants us to do. And so Nietzsche doesn't believe in the punishing God. I don't believe in the punishing God either. So I'm with Nietzsche on that one. Distrust all those in whom the urge to punish is strong. And so instead of imagining a God who could control us but doesn't and lets us do all this bad stuff, this persuasive vision, not only is it inspiring because it helps resolve the problem of evil,
SPEAKER_03we don't have to blame God for all the bad stuff that happens, but I think it also indicates that the world is persuading God. And that while God may envision all the beauty that's possible, God is nonetheless surprised by what the world decides to actualize. And that surprise isn't just, it's not horror. It's a celebration and an embrace. And so that's how the world and each of us can contribute back to the divine nature. We're actually helping to enrich God's appreciation of what could be
SPEAKER_03by actualizing things that are surprising and delightful to the divine.
SPEAKER_02Beautiful guys. Just a quick shout out to Plato. Is he in the room? He might be. All we need is the idea of Plato. Whitehead says fantasically that Plato makes one of the most important intellectual discoveries in the entire history of religion, namely that the divine element is a persuasive agency and not a coercive agency. Just want to represent that. And of course, The next step is to say that intellectual intuition took on flesh in the feet
SPEAKER_02of Christ, who was an expression in life of a divine persuasion. Even later in life, he points to Gandhi and Lord Irwin and the risk of millions dying under war and strife and says that here is a flicker and flash of divine persuasion. It's a bit of Galilee showing up in Gandhi.
SPEAKER_00Oh, wow. Thanks.
SPEAKER_02So think about persuasion. This is no mere transition. It can have a huge effect. Okay, transition five. Our last one, and then we'll hopefully have some time to open it up for whatever kind of questions have come up for you. From passivity to creativity. So Whitehead is one of among a few, Berkson, Nikolai Bridaev, a few others showing perhaps that give creativity perspective. A cosmological and indeed metaphysical meaning.
SPEAKER_02But instead of going to Matt, which would be easy on that, I want to go with Sherry first and ask, what role does creativity have in spiritual transformation? We're often given a prescribed sort of way of, say, meditating or praying or some sort of method or practice, but where does the space of creativity lie in that?
SPEAKER_01I think it's part of inspiration. You know, when we dream, when we imagine, when we think of a better life or imagine something in our lives that shifts or relationships, I mean, there's, well, and it Actually, I'm really thinking now about just the way that the arts, the creative expression, can be part of our healing and how important those expressive arts are to our healing and growth and spiritual lives,
SPEAKER_01that when we can become sort of a conduit for that flow of creativity, And how much that can help us come to terms with our own lives and see where our life wants to take us. I remember there's a beautiful book by Parker Palmer called Let Your Life Speak. And where he says, don't tell your life what you want to do with it. Let your life tell you what it wants to do with you. Something like that. And so I worked in the software industry for many years,
SPEAKER_01and I think I was downsized out of a job about seven times in 15 years. And so it got to be where I was like the one that my colleagues, when we had another layoff, they'd come to me when we'd talk about it, and I would say, Don't just look for the same thing that you've been doing. Listen for where your life might be leading you. What conversation did you have that shimmered for you? What dream did you have that opened up a thought? And there was a woman,
SPEAKER_01I think her name was Barbara Sher, who wrote a lot of books about Career and stuff like that. And she tells this story about this woman who came to her for career guidance. And she worked with a lot of people, was always able to help them find their new thing. What excited them work-wise? What was their vocation, their calling? And this woman came to her and they talked for like an hour and got nowhere. Nothing was coming out of this woman that would be some next step for her.
SPEAKER_01And Barbara Sher was like, all right, I guess I just have to give up and think that I just can't help you. And they were like walking out the door and the woman was picking up her things and Barbara noticed she had a book and on the cover of a book was like a gorilla book. And she's like, wait, what's the deal with this book? And they're like, oh, I love gorillas. I'm so interested in gorillas. And she's like, wait a second, sit back down. And they start talking. And anyway, the woman ended up, she looked for, how can I,
SPEAKER_01she got involved with the Friends of the Zoo organization where she lived. But it got to where she was part of then, where part of the group that was nursing gorilla babies that were orphaned or something. And became a caretaker of gorillas in the zoo. I mean, this one little thing just came from this awareness of this was her love. She had fallen in love with this part of life.
SPEAKER_01And then they talked about, how can you find the next step there? So it's that creative flow that when we get in alignment with that, it can open up so much.
SPEAKER_02Beautiful, Sharon. Matt, what are we meaning when we speak of creativity? And not just in the Whiteheadian sense, right? We don't have to go there necessarily, but in the scientific sense. Some might say that we're simply anthropomorphizing nature to say it has creativity. Isn't that just a human concept? Or does it go deeper?
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I mean, that might be one of Whitehead's most radical moves is taking this idea that we usually consider to be psychological. It's what human artists or scientists engage in, creativity as something unique to the human genius or something. But in saying that the whole of the cosmos is a creative process, he's really decentering the human in a way and allowing us to recognize The ways in which the evolutionary process that, again,
SPEAKER_03goes back to, you know, clouds of plasma and the first atoms and stars and galaxies, none of this could have been foreseen in advance. Like, if you could imagine Stephen Hawking floating out in space observing the first cloud of hydrogen, even with his galaxy brain, he couldn't have seen galaxies coming, right? Because something creative occurred that transformed the very nature Of hydrogen, right, to allow that new form of organization to emerge.
SPEAKER_03And so if we go to the theological side of things and think, what kind of a god does this imply? It means that, as Catherine Keller put it, in Face of the Deep, creation is... Nobody really likes committees, but, you know, loosen up your idea of what a committee is. It's creation by committee, in a sense. It's a co-creative effort. And God creates with... Creatures, because in Whitehead's vision, God is also a creature of creativity. Maybe the first creature, the primary creature that all subsequent creatures are in a call and response with,
SPEAKER_03but nonetheless, God can only co-create. God lets there be plants and animals and human beings and stars and galaxies.
SPEAKER_02I poke at Hawking just because you brought him up in one place in the book. The quote in Brief History of Time, philosophy is dead, he says, and is not kept up with physics. To which I playfully say, philosophy retorting, Stephen Hawking is dead and should have read more Whitehead. Tom, let's come to you. Not just on whether God's creative, because I think we're assuming that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But if you think about the whole theological tradition, this isn't an attempt to baldly state what's true in the most common language. There's a creative dimension here. Omnipotence. Geno-theology. Did I say it right? Geno. Geno. This is creativity.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Is it not? Yes, it is. Yes. Yeah, in fact, I suspect most people in this room, if you've been around progressive circles, you've heard people talk about co-creating with God. We're co-creators. And Whitehead and Process. Affirm that 100%. And as Matt said, that co-creating is not just with humans. It goes down to the smallest units. But there's one more element. I think this co-creating is everlasting.
SPEAKER_00Whitehead is known for rejecting the notion that God once existed all alone and then decided to create something from absolute nothingness. What if this co-creating in various complexities has had no beginning? It would require a whole new doctrine of creation, and I've offered one. In which I think God is the ever creator. That God is always creating alongside creatures God previously created
SPEAKER_00and there was no beginning to that everlasting process. That helps to overcome a whole bunch of problems in terms of thinking about creating and problem of evil, etc. But one of the best things about it, and I think even if you don't end up going with that route, one of the best things about being a co-creator with God, if the future is open, hasn't been determined, If our co-creating helps create what happens next, it's not all on God,
SPEAKER_00it's not all on us, together we co-create, that means you actually matter. Not just kind of matter, not like what God decided to let you do a little. God, I hate this thing. So many theologians, sorry, Matt, this might sound like I'm dissing you, but I'm not. So many theologians say, well, God's allowing you to participate in the work as if God could just do it all alone.
SPEAKER_00What if God actually requires creaturely participation for love to win, for the kingdom of God to be established in its fullness? The Whiteheadian vision puts that kind of significance into your life and my life and a rabbit's life and everybody's life. And I think that's pretty powerful.
SPEAKER_02We have about 10 minutes for questions. Before we thank our panelists here, I think we're, we up here, that is, are curious about how some of these transitions might sit with you. Now, there's far more than just five, obviously. I have to point out to ten at the end of my book. There's more than ten. But I think these five are suggestive of certain important moves, again, ideologically, existentially, spiritually. That we think are important. And so we're curious to see where it lands for you. Any questions for any of the panelists or comments on the transitions?
SPEAKER_02Yes, sir.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I actually have many questions, but I'll try to see if
SPEAKER_02I can. And I'll try to repeat the question up here since we are reporting. Oh, good. So, you know, we have this idea that, well, if God could act
SPEAKER_00and get rid of evil but doesn't, that's a problem. But then on the flip side, it seems that if we have a God that isn't powerful enough to do things, that seems like a problem to at least most people's religious sensibility.
SPEAKER_02And so I wonder if there's a third option here, which I think maybe Matt alluded to a little bit, but like there's times Maybe I could punish my child, but I decide not to. There's this sermon actually, not a philosophical piece, where Kierkegaard says God is like a mountain where someone comes up and wants to pass through the mountain and what really needs to be changed They shouldn't want to pass anyway. And so the mountain, of course, says nothing. It doesn't act. And then eventually after 5 years, 10 years, 50 years, however long it takes, finally the will of the person is changed and
SPEAKER_00they turn back, right? And so I'll put it back. I wonder if the third option might be something like, say, Simon Bay, who said, how does
SPEAKER_02God create? By making God's self small, because if God's infinite, there's no space for the other, so that creation is sort of a self-mortification and yielding God. And what would be lovely about this is that we don't have a different God in Genesis 1 where power is abusive and explodes outward, but in the Gospels, God is weak and humble for 30-some-odd years and then kicks ass and takes danger. But we need the same God all the way through so that even in Genesis 1, there's a kind of self-mortification where God could exude power but chooses not.
SPEAKER_02Well, I'm not going to repeat all that, but Tom, Master, any comment? There's a downside to either here. Coercion, go ahead.
SPEAKER_01Well, I was just going to say there are process thinkers like Thomas Hosinski who does have more of that sense of voluntary kenosis. My own perspective is more like that where I want to say that in order for there to still be a world, God has to give up power. The moment if God were to take all that power back, I really believe the world would disappear because the world needs these kinds
SPEAKER_01of boundaries and things in order to be embodied. And so there has to be that space. So that's a little bit more my preference. I think it is an option, and there are other process thinkers who do articulate that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Sherry's right. That's an option. It's not one I like, but it's an option on the table. Here is a dramatic response to you, all right? I wrote a little book called God Can't, which takes the view that God simply can't stop evil, which yours is more like God usually doesn't or allows sort of it. And I got this letter from this woman who had been sexually molested by her brother as a child. And she said that she had this dream while, well, dream,
SPEAKER_00she had this vision while she was being molested that Jesus showed up next to her. And she said for a couple of days she felt really comforted that God suffers with her, was present in the moment. And then she thought, hold on a second, if Jesus could have stopped this, why didn't he stop it? And she said, I walked away from God. God's got the ability to stop my rape and chooses not to, and I'm not down for believing in God. So the voluntary self-limitation has that sort of problem in my way of thinking.
SPEAKER_00I prefer to look the abuse victim in the eye and say God couldn't have stopped what happened to you rather than God allowed it for the time being.
SPEAKER_02And God couldn't have stopped it not because of the lack in God, but just because of who and what God is. Namely, love, which takes lots of priority. Uncontrolling love. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Sorry, man. Well, there's something about love that Whitehead says it operates patiently, slowly, quietly in the background. It doesn't contend force for force. It's not wielding the thunder and so on. But nonetheless, and this is just a loose analogy, it's a little bit like the weakest force in nature, gravity. Which is tremendously creative if you just give it enough time and space. And so it may be that this really weak seeming human being who was crucified on the cross lost.
SPEAKER_03But that event, that deed seems to slowly and quietly have been changing the world. And I agree with Ilya Delio this morning, who says, like, this is, the impact of this event is just barely beginning to be felt in human hearts as an evolutionary transformation. So, be patient, I guess, is what I'm saying. Yeah, go ahead. So, as I'm sitting and thinking through a lot of these things, like,
SPEAKER_03I'm wondering, when we come back to the problem of evil and just the horrible things that do happen in the world as a result of some aspect of this world that is not contained in God, the things that are harming people, the violences in the world, and then our agency in responding to those things and the necessities Does that then,
SPEAKER_03I guess what's your vision of how that works as with God being like needing humanity in order to be able to address something that God cannot address in God's self, but that needs to be addressed outside of God's self. And then the role of like, The human containing both of those worlds and the possibility of love,
SPEAKER_03but also the possibility of violence is like a necessary component of humanity or of creation or of, I don't know, the material world that is like an expression of God that does not contain a certain aspect of God. Like, do you see what I'm getting at? Is it like a negative space of, like a vacuum of, you know, this absence of God that then needs to be filled with some other sort of presence
SPEAKER_03that God cannot act with? Like, am I making any sense of where I'm going with that? What do you think, guys?
SPEAKER_01God in a position to need something outside of God's self to address something that God can't touch.
SPEAKER_00Does that make sense? You guys want to start?
SPEAKER_03Well, I'll just say if I'm Following that, you know, we have the freedom. Human history is just a series of horrific events, and then the next generation seeks revenge for what happened to the prior, and it's a cycle of revenge, basically. But what we have, maybe this is the Imago Dei, we have the ability, the freedom to forgive. And if we were to forgive, which God can't force us to do, but if we were to choose to forgive, maybe we could start to short-circuit some of these cycles.
SPEAKER_03But that's on us, right? And whether or not, I mean, I think God is working to help persuade us to make that decision in various ways, but it can't be forced on us. And whether or not that's a lack in God or just the nature of God, and, you know, Love and forgiveness can only be a free decision on our part. Like, it wouldn't actually be forgiveness if we had to do it. That would be coercion again. So, I don't know if that's touching on your question at all, but that's what came to mind.
SPEAKER_01I just feel like if
SPEAKER_03we were restrained in the way that God is restrained, like if we became more God-like, would we be less able to address injustice? Hmm. In other words, we can't use force if we're more like God.
SPEAKER_02Oftentimes,
SPEAKER_00when people ask the problem of evil, we focus on God's power, which is crucial here. There's another element that I think is also crucial, and a difference between you and God, that won't change no matter how godly you become, is that you have a localized body, and you can reach out and touch the guy behind you on the shoulder, and in doing so, open up new possibilities and delimit other possibilities. So as localized creatures with bodies, we have certain agency and capacities that God doesn't have. God can do things we can't do because God's only present.
SPEAKER_00So I like to think that God is present everywhere. There's no place that God isn't. So there's no vacuum ever. The question is whether or not God's presence there is going to be attuned to and cooperated with. And when people do evil, I think they're not cooperating with the presence of God. They're not that God has disappeared somehow momentarily. And so that means for us to be more and more godly is not to become omnipresent. It's to try to make our choices align with the ways of love.
SPEAKER_02I would only say there's the old adage that we are the hands and feet of God, right? So if God can't coerce, we can. And there's some situations which require us to act coercively. And that might be a response to a persuasive lure to do so. There's just war theories, which, you know, it's a painful tradition, but there's all sorts of situations we could think of where coercive power is required in order to prevent evil or preserve.
SPEAKER_01Stopping a child from running into the street is a great example.
SPEAKER_02If someone running into your house, you know, trying to take you and your children, God persuades, so please don't do that. No, you're going to, you know. I don't advocate violence, but there's some times when coercion is required. It doesn't mean, you know, that God, well, it's complicated, and it's an interesting way of phrasing it. Okay, let's get to one more question, just for sake of time, just since my eyes saw it first to the back here.
SPEAKER_00Hello, um, as somebody, I'm a big, like, more I would say a lot in the contemplative school of Christian thinking, and a big Merton head more than a whitehead head. LAUGHTER I guess, as some of you grew up very evangelical, so I've got to where everything to you is permitted, what are you doing for God in a very manipulative way,
SPEAKER_02and getting away from that in the contemplative tradition has been very helpful for that in being in God and presence. Great. Is becoming a threat to contemplative thought?
SPEAKER_02Would that be one way to put it?
SPEAKER_00It's a little
SPEAKER_03simplistic, for sure. Okay, well, sure. Because you can't rest in the being of God. You're on the move. The whole universe is going somewhere, and you don't want to get left behind. But I don't like the dichotomization of being and becoming. That's what I was trying to talk about, the way that, at least in Whitehead's Process Philosophy, it's not all process all the time, actually. In order to even recognize that change is occurring, you're already presupposing something that doesn't,
SPEAKER_03by which the change is relative to that which is permanent. That's in Whitehead too. So it's more a polarity than a dichotomy. And there's a way in which contemplative forms of contemplative practice could be understood as a mode of becoming. But it's an inward intensification in a way that doesn't need to be taking you out of the place of rest, but is actually allowing you to deepen ever more into it.
SPEAKER_03So we don't need to dichotomize them.
SPEAKER_01And also, the idea of resting in God doesn't have to be seen as static. It's not a static resting. The eternal now is a now, is a now, is a now, is a now, is a now. It's not a static thing. So, like, the eternal now is like you are flowing with the flow.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and maybe one other angle. The doing things for God. I mean, when I was younger, that was, if you don't do these things, God is going to be pissed. And you're going to be punished. But we don't have a punishing God. So that sort of takes that right out there. And we have a God who always loves no matter what, even if you do the worst thing possible. God's always going to love you by in the next moment promoting your well-being and calling you to promote well-being. So maybe some of the negative baggage of doing stuff for God gets taken out by this of love.
SPEAKER_02We do need to conclude. We can grab a beer, continue the conversation. Healthy in thanking the panelists today.
A talk for my fellow PCC faculty and graduate students at our annual retreat this past week. This talk was my attempt to share a perplexity, not a finished theory. What is the source of form in the living world? How do...
One of the important ideas that Tim and I discussed last night was his threefold differentiation of the inquired (natural science), the speculative (metaphysics), and the prosaic (everyday experience). I agree with him...
Participants. Dan Koch, moderator; Myron Penner; Sarah Lane Ritchie; Matthew David Segall. See https://theologybeer.camp/2026speakers for bios. Transcript: Dan: If you’re going to be making some meaning you’ve got to be...
I was originally supposed to be in dialogue with Tim Miller of Our Evolving God, but he had to take care of a loved one and so missed this year’s Theology Beer Camp in Kansas City. He prepared some remarks that were...
My conversation with Jason Hoskins, a molecular geneticist and systems biologist at the National Cancer Institute, explored the convergence between contemporary systems biology and process-relational philosophy. Jason...