I spoke with Tam Hunt about his new book The Hippies Were Right! About Consciousness and Everything Else, beginning with the question of just what the hippies got right, and what the price of their cultural victory may have been. I suggested that many countercultural values have been absorbed into mainstream capitalism, from psychedelics and Eastern spirituality to global consciousness and personal liberation, often losing some of their social and economic radicality in the process. This led us to consider whether the deepest hippie politics was really a kind of micropolitics: meeting one another face-to-face and heart-to-heart rather than beginning from ideological abstractions. From there we moved into Tam’s General Resonance Theory of consciousness, panpsychism, the possibility of solar consciousness, and parallels with Integrated Information Theory. I asked what his approach implies for AI, namely, whether intelligence can exist without consciousness, whether machines could ever genuinely exercise judgment, and whether a hippie metaphysics of love and relationality might contribute to AI alignment. We ended by getting speculative about Teilhard de Chardin’s noosphere. Rather than replacing humanity with server-farm hosted “superintelligence,” might the future involve technologically and spiritually deepening the resonance among human persons into some form of planetary mind? My own concluding thought was that if love is genuinely real, whether humanly or cosmically, it presupposes freedom. Neither capitalism nor technological development is an autonomous destiny. We still have choices about what we build and what kind of future we participate in creating. Tam then turned the questions back on me, prompting a discussion of my own path from atheism and Buddhism toward the cosmic Christ, incarnation, and my sense that the hippie movement may have come closer than much institutional Christianity to the heart of Jesus’ teaching. Love may not be the whole answer to all our problems, but it is where any real answer has to begin. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit footnotes2plato.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Tam, I'm really excited to talk to you about this book. It came out last month. The hippies were right about consciousness and everything else. It's part memoir. It's part, I would say, worldview elaboration and a little bit of theorization from some work you've done at a higher academic level. This is meant to be more accessible and fun. Because it is memoir-based,
SPEAKER_01why don't we start a little bit with your story, where you, in a sense, imbibed this hippie worldview as a kid. Tell us a little bit about that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I grew up in England until I was nine, went to the US, and we became illegal for many years, like good hippie kids and adults. And got legalized. I became a citizen in 2000, so I'm here legally now. Lost my cute accent. But grew up in a very hippie culture of kind of black sheep kids from middle-class families in the UK. And there was kind of a community around us growing up in Cornwall, which was kind of the place, it was kind of the hippie part of England back then.
SPEAKER_00And that's because it was a very poor part of the country, where as a former mining area, Tin mining was a big thing. And that all fell through. I might be sure why today, but it kind of fell through. And I think mid-century, and it became really poor because all the jobs went away. So there were a lot of empty homes and very cheap homes down there. And all the poor hippies were like, hey, let's go live cheap or free. So they went down there and squatted. And the irony today, and I'm going there next week actually to go visit again,
SPEAKER_00is that Cornwall is now very posh. And there's a lot of really beautiful... Coastal villages where people from London and other parts of the UK go to holiday. And so it went from being very poor to being now rather expensive and posh. So things change. But back then in the 70s, it was very poor and I was surrounded by hippies who smoked a lot of dope and talked about what was wrong with mainstream culture and with war and imperialism
SPEAKER_00and capitalism. And then we buggered off to the U.S. because my mother came into a bit of money by agreeing to end a long-term lease on a house that she was renting. And that money allowed us to go travel to the U.S. where my dad had been for a while already. And they ended up traveling around in a VW bus for a year or two, my mother, my stepdad, and my brother. And they went to this commune in Seattle called the Love Family.
SPEAKER_00And the Love Family was one of many communes, which many called cults then and now. That priest is kind of, you know, tune in, turn out, turn in, turn on, drop out lifestyle. And in this case, the Love Family was kind of a, it's kind of like a Neo-Judeo-Christian Old Testament kind of commune where They preached peace and love and wore long hair and beards and robes and back to the land. And everyone that joined had to donate all their possessions to the commune.
SPEAKER_00And they had to sign over their possessions to the commune where they said, I give all my worldly possessions to the commune. And so I was very much around these ideas as a kid. And even though I was only in a commune for a year or so before it all came crashing down because Love, the founder of the Love family, Was, as you may have been able to predict, abusing his power. And the commune got kind of sick of it, so I had to go left in whatever it was, 82, 83, I think, when I was there. And my guardian and commune called my mother, who was in eastern Washington at the time.
SPEAKER_00I was in western Washington. They said, you might want to come get Tam. We've had some stuff happen here at the communes. They came and got me. And then I returned to kind of more mainstream life, but still with my very hippie parents living in a school bus, but not in a commune. And so I had a very interesting kind of checkered hippie background. And when I kind of went to college and then I joined the army, then I went to law school and became a lawyer. I had a period of kind of rebellion and rejection of that background,
SPEAKER_00as most kids do when they come from an unusual background. But then over time, I kind of came around and realized, well, a lot of that stuff actually was right on. As you and I were talking about in the prelude here, you know, a lot of ideologies sound good and are good, you know, as they're taught and as they're preached. But what's hard is the implementation, the living, the walking the walk, right? So we can talk about that if you like.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. So some of the ideas in the book that you think the hippies were right about include a more or less panpsychist view. It's all consciousness and consciousness is ultimately vibratory. And so, you know, the importance of vibes being in resonance with each other and that that resonance is in some sense love and love. And love is therefore more than just a human emotion that feels good.
SPEAKER_01It has some real ontological status to it. Those ideas are at the core of my own worldview. And I definitely agree with the proposition framed in your title that the hippies were right. But you frame it in the past tense that the hippies were right. And so are the hippies... Still right? And what did they get wrong? I mean, and I'll just say, in some sense, I feel like over the last several decades,
SPEAKER_01many decades since the 1960s, what was countercultural has become absorbed by the mainstream culture. So in some sense, the hippies won, but they also lost because the mainstream culture and absorbing all those ideas has kind of commodified a lot of those ideas. And they've lost some of their Social and economic radicality and and become just Kind of features
SPEAKER_01of our capitalist society where, you know, property relations and law. And I mean, some things have liberalized, like cannabis is legal in a lot more places than it used to be and so on. Psychedelics all of a sudden or all the rage and big corporations are, you know, vying into psychedelics as medicines and so on. But it seems like a mixed bag to me. The hippies won and they lost because of how it's been absorbed. But I wonder, what was the price of victory?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Well, there's a lot there. Let me tackle a few of the ideas you raised. So I do... I talk about the first hippie movement, which, of course, was not the first. This is what we call the hippies in the 60s and 70s. But there's, you know, you probably noticed, and maybe you'll listen to this too, this kind of counterculture back to the land thing is cyclical. I think almost every culture has this component where it's like, fuck mainstream culture, you know, fuck the rat race.
SPEAKER_00Let's just go back to a more simple way of living And more true to ourselves, more true to the planet. And so this is the latest iteration we're going through right now. And so, yes, the 60s and 70s are very interesting because that was kind of the biggest eruption in the last century, let's say, of the hippie ideals of peace and love and connectedness, which are pretty cross-cultural, frankly, and anti-war and anti-power structure.
SPEAKER_00Anti-rat race, you know, these are universal themes across cultures. So we're now back in an era, I'd say in the last 10-15 years, where people are, you know, in larger numbers, again, questioning what the expectations are, where we're going, what have we done to the planet, what do we want from a good life, etc. And so, yeah, I agree with you fully that in many ways hippies did win, but again, at what price? And so, You know,
SPEAKER_00you've got interesting developments, like you said, with weed and psychedelics and people like Steve Jobs becoming mainstream, who is, you know, definitely a bit of a hippie when he was younger. And you have, I think, this ethos in the US, as bad as it is in many ways, you have this ethos of people being important as individuals. And people mattering and making a difference through the application of your ideals in your life.
SPEAKER_00And the actuality, again, may not be, you know, those things across the board. Obviously, it's not because the U.S. is a very mixed bag in terms of our impact on the planet. But I am hoping... Part of why I wrote the book, obviously, is to amplify those trends and to really kind of provide both a little bit a history lesson for what happened in the 60s and 70s, the part of history that my life overlaps with. And then also highlight the lessons learned from what we did wrong in that era,
SPEAKER_00because I think we're really back in an era where we need to do a big rethink of what the hell we're doing. And so totally independently from The more academic piece that you and I both work on. I think there are really major cultural trends here that, you know, are a fun to look at and be really important to look at because we've got to learn from them.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. You know, I remember in my later high school years as a high school senior, when I started getting into Um, politics and reading about the sixties and, and just how intense things got there with, you know, political assassinations and, um, the, the crackdown on, uh, the counterculture and the drug war and all of that. And I remember walking in a mall and I had just been reading about Che Guevara and then, uh, I forget the name of the store.
SPEAKER_01Um, But there's these Che Guevara t-shirts for 25 bucks, you know, and just seeing the way that this commodification process occurs and capitalism swallows everything. And, you know, you get the Beatles go through their hippie phase, they're dropping acid, their music is changing, they're bringing in these Eastern Indian influences. And then all of a sudden, Apple is selling computers using their songs, you know. And so... Now, in our current moment, there's actually a lot of skepticism of our current political economy.
SPEAKER_01And yet capitalism seems as invincible as ever. And so even these ideas like everything is connected, it's this globalization of culture, um it's very much part of the capitalist ethos and and I wonder to what extent um this this old dichotomization I mean back in the 60s I guess it was just beginning to become apparent that you know stalinism wasn't the best thing in the world
SPEAKER_01and there were some issues uh there and and so rather than thinking that You know, this easy opposition between communism and capitalism or whatever is is is entirely relevant. Do you think that there's a lesson in this hippie kind of back to the land movement and holding all property in common and stuff that That now we have to complexify that picture a little bit. What would the ideal way of living together look like if we let go
SPEAKER_01of these big ideologies that seem to lead to all sorts of arguments about abstractions when really the current situation is far more complicated?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a good question and very difficult to answer. You know, I don't discuss in the book and nor have I written about this particular question and Yet in my body of work, you know, I have not taken a side in the big economic and social organization debates yet. You know, I've been partial to Scandinavian capitalism for some time, but obviously even that system has major problems. I call myself nowadays a left libertarian.
SPEAKER_00And so, you know, what that prescribes in terms of how we live is, I think, very much in keeping with the hippie ethos in terms of, you know, Don't tread on me. Leave me alone. Let me do my thing, but also take care of people and plan it. So definitely it wouldn't be shy in terms of using capital and tax revenue to take care of people to some degree. But also, I think a big lesson of the 70s is we don't want to just give unlimited handouts
SPEAKER_00because that doesn't really help anyone long term. It may help them short term, but not long term. So, yeah, I don't advocate in the book and nor am I now advocating for communalism or communism or socialism. You know, I am a left libertarian in the Chomsky mold. And so, again, I'm not. Yeah, I'm not trying to go too deep down that rabbit hole. In general, what I would- To
SPEAKER_01clarify my question, I guess, it seems like, you know, people say the personal is political, but maybe the hippies were saying that the political is personal in the sense of, like, micropolitics and, like, rather than rushing to these big abstractions and, like, what type of economic system should we institute, it seems like the hippie ethos was more about meeting each person in As an individual, you know, creature of the divine that we really need to be able
SPEAKER_01to work out our problems concretely face to face by meeting each other heart to heart rather than labeling like you're this and
SPEAKER_00I'm that and like we
SPEAKER_01can't but instead to actually just contact each other as human beings.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I would agree that 100%. I guess part of the issue is actually the tendency for us to leap to larger abstractions rather than saying, well, how do we solve the problem in front of us? And one thing I do stress in the book, in the last chapter in particular, what would love do now, or would love do meow, I say, is really looking at, you know, what does a heart-centered,
SPEAKER_00intelligent person do In this moment in time we find ourselves in and I do argue for, you know, an intelligent and heart centered activism, because I think at this moment requires that, you know, we're in a very strange moment in history for all the obvious reasons, you know, climate change, runaway capitalism, runaway AI. American imperialism, you know, all the usual things. You know, I don't want China to become the new, even worse, top dog, but I surely don't want the U.S. system to continue as it is.
SPEAKER_00I'm just looking at Trump's speech to the U.N. yesterday. It's like, oh, my God, what a shitshow, you know, what an embarrassing shitshow. But, yeah, I think there's a lot there, and I think maybe the real take-home that People reading the book and listening to your podcast could kind of hold in their heart is that there is this notion that I really do focus on in the book that ultimately it is all love,
SPEAKER_00capital L. And that's not just a mystical woo-woo kind of wishy-washy kind of thing. I really tried to make the case that That, well, actually the universe is all love, capital L. That's how the thing, that's how it works. You know, that's what this is based on. So if you can actually, you know, dig into that and you don't have to agree, but hopefully you will. And if you do come around to that view, it makes at least that,
SPEAKER_00like you said, that kind of face-to-face, heart-to-heart meeting a little easier because you recognize if it's all love, it's all one thing. We're all part of the same damn thing. He's trying to figure out what's going on. And it gives you some comfort, it does me at least, this notion of panpsychism built on the foundation of love, that we are all part of the same thing, same process, same overall happening that we call the universe.
SPEAKER_00And so that gives us a bit more in common, I think, than perhaps some other systems of thought as a starting point.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know, I just was reminded of this early 70s, I believe, Coca-Cola commercial. The song, I'd Like to Buy the World a Coke. It's also the last episode of Mad Men, which kind of tells this interesting story of, you know, Madison Avenue advertising professional growing into the 60s, dropping acid, ending up at Esalen, And coming up with this idea for the ad that would be famous.
SPEAKER_01You know, it's a unmistakably countercultural theme with a bunch of people on a hilltop from all over the world singing together about harmony and planetary unity and everything. It's in the middle of the Vietnam War and intense generational conflict. And it's such an extraordinary ideological maneuver that's taking place there, which again, it's like an expression of how the hippies won. And yet It's a Coke commercial. And so you're getting universal communion under the auspices of
SPEAKER_01the economic dominance of a capitalist model that's built on extracting profit and exploiting labor. And so think the cultural question and the economic question continue to be a bit at odds. Like capitalism is clear. Capitalism won. The Cold War because of the cultural freedom that it facilitated. Communism was very much trying to control what people think in a very overt way.
SPEAKER_01Maybe capitalism does that in covert ways through advertising, for example. But maybe we can transition then to the deeper theoretical aspects of this book because there might be some Some points of leverage there that get below the ideological superstructure as it were.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And I'm happy to go there. Let me add this real quick first because I was actually meditating on this today and yesterday. So was talking with Dennis McKenna a few weeks ago on his podcast and he was basically kind of querying me about You know, what is the major problem with the world today? I'm like, ah, well, here's my current diagnosis. And so obviously these are very big questions and there's no correct answer.
SPEAKER_00But what I've been kind of meditating on and researching a bit lately is the notion that, you know, we have been around for many millions of years in various forms as homo, essentially, as hominids. So there's no point at which we can say, oh, look, now it's a hominid, you know, roughly 5 million years as a hominy broke off from our ancestors and what are now the chimp line, et cetera. Anyway, let's call it 5 million years as some form of human.
SPEAKER_00We look to our kin across the ape family and we look to bonobos in particular and even gorillas and we see, and of course, and, you know, more Quote, unquote, primitive human organizations. And it's pretty hard to deny that we kind of came into hierarchy very, very recently, the last 10,000 years or so, made possible initially by the accumulation of food, grain, et cetera.
SPEAKER_00That led to a whole different social structure that we've been dealing with now for 10,000 years. When you look at the interpersonal ethics That more basic human social structures and bonobos have. It's very egalitarian, very non-hierarchical, very fairness-based. And when you look at studies, even really small children who are asked to actually opine on what's fair or not,
SPEAKER_00Even kids, human kids today, as young as like a year and a half, have built in fairness barometers, and they can tell what's fair and what's not fair. This is deep in our DNA, five million years at least. So I think what the major problem is today is that we have this very new system, 10,000 years. That is imposed on a much deeper, much more fairness based, much more egalitarian based biological system. And so that is the inherent conflict here.
SPEAKER_00We all want, we all want egalitarian treatment. We all want to be treated fairly. Most of us don't have any ambitions toward controlling other people or being the top dog. Very few people have that. It's a weird aberration. Our system today has empowered those strange aberrations. So the people who are on top today are the weird aberrations. And the more people realize that, the more we can basically mitigate it, I think.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I mean, just to reiterate and emphasize your point, I think even before hominids, You know, ethologists, I guess, famously, Frans de Waal and others have shown that other primates, and I think mammals generally have this basic sense of fairness that's been shown experimentally with primates, you know, where if you give one primate a bunch of grapes and the other one, you know, gets a peanut or something, they get really pissed off.
SPEAKER_01Like, what the hell? And you can see this with dogs, you know, if Yeah, yeah. Your dog gets a big plate of steak. Where's my share? So this sense of fairness is many tens of millions of years old, even, I would say.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, I
SPEAKER_01agree. And this new hierarchical structure that has been culturally constructed is really in tension with that. And it's not unlike, I mean, there are many ways in which these very new cultural constructions are existing in tension with evolutionary inheritances, which are much older. You know, this panpsychist worldview that you're trying to foreground in your book and in lots
SPEAKER_01of your academic work is, you know, it's more or less the animus worldview that predominated over and across every continent. In every human culture until the last few hundred years in one particularly strange culture where we decide, oh, no, the universe is a big machine and consciousness is ensconced in the skull. If even there, it could be, you know, the Illuminative materialists would go even further and say that consciousness is just a word we've convinced ourselves that that
SPEAKER_01that we possess. And so we're in a bit of an anomalous situation. Yeah. So, um, We could continue talking about the political and economic sides of this, but I'm, I'm more curious to hear about, um, you know, this, this work on resonance that you've been developing, um, for some time, uh, the general resonance theory of consciousness. Um, you work with Jonathan Schooler on this.
SPEAKER_01Um, and in, in this book, you're offering a more, um, Digestible, popular form of that argument. But I think in terms of shifting us out of an economic picture that's based on perceived material scarcity and a focus on the production, industrial production of material goods, all of which is important.
SPEAKER_01We're organisms. We need to eat and... But if consciousness is the fundamental nature of reality, I think that would certainly have economic implications. But let's bracket the economic context for a second and just talk about the ontology at play here. Can you lay out briefly what the heart of this general resonance theory of consciousness is?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so GRT is a philosophically based but empirically informed theory of consciousness. And we're at the point now where we're trying to test it in various experiments. And this is a slow process because these things are hard to get funding for, as you probably know, particularly theories like ours, which actually kind of start axiomatically from panpsychism. So the really quick structure of GRT, I can explain with three axioms.
SPEAKER_00One is the notion that all things resonate. This is axiom one. This is just physics, nothing controversial. All things above absolute zero have some frequency at which they vibrate or resonate. I guess to be more technically accurate, I'd say they vibrate because resonance refers to across constituents. The second piece is that all things also have some iota of subjectivity, and that's the panpsychism axiom.
SPEAKER_00That, of course, is not universally accepted. It's becoming more accepted. It's certainly not considered to be crazy anymore, because when I first began on this 30 years ago, I was like, oh, that's crazy. What do you mean? But now it's considered to be, like it is for me, maybe the least crazy of the main options out there of materialism, idealism, dualism, and panpsychism. Just because the quick argument there is that the main two schools here are A, consciousness emerges at some point in biological history, or B, it doesn't emerge.
SPEAKER_00It was always there in some form. And it complexifies as biological form complexifies. So our approach is very much the second. We're non-emergentist, i.e. panpsychist, whereas certainly the majority still in philosophy and neuroscience and biology would be emergentist, which is that the notion, like I said, that there is some point in biological history, either on this planet in toto, Or with each species,
SPEAKER_00like humans, where there was no consciousness in one moment and then suddenly the next moment there was. And that to me just doesn't make any sense because certainly I can see the argument making sense at the level of ontogeny with each embryo. Sure, there's a moment where there's nothing it's like to be that embryo as a whole. But then a moment later, as the EM fields fire up throughout the whole little brain and body, now there is, in fact, something that's like to be that embryo.
SPEAKER_00And we don't know when that point is, but I would suggest it's probably in the first few weeks after conception in some manner. But you would say, just to
SPEAKER_01be clear, the cells that compose the embryo, you would say, already had a subjectivity effect. Exactly. You're talking about the embryo as a whole having a global sense. As a whole.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. And so the cells would have their own awareness from their inception as cells. The molecules would have their own micro, micro awareness as molecules. And the atoms would have their own even more micro, you know, awareness as atoms. And so that's what the Pansecus Worldly says, that all these constituents, which we are, have their own level of awareness. It's just extremely rudimentary in most non-biological forms.
SPEAKER_00And as far as we know, at this point in the history of our galaxy, the only thing that has any, you know, what I would call subjectively interesting consciousness would be biological forms, because they're the only ones we know of that have the necessary stability and complexity to allow for these information structures that are in our biology electromagnetic fields to persist over time and to evolve over time
SPEAKER_00in the context of Amelia on the surface of this planet to become interesting consciousness. I'll add, because I'm sure you and your listeners may be thinking, well, what about Stars or galaxies. And so one cool thing about GRT, it does not in any way preclude a star, for example, from having its own consciousness. It's an empirical question. Stars, of course, do have semi-stable EM fields. That's what stars are. They're large conglomerations of plasma, which has a lot of EM field activity.
SPEAKER_00The question becomes an empirical one, to what degree Are those EM fields in stars like our sun stable enough or evolved enough over many successive generations to actually develop any kind of complex consciousness? So I would not April rule out that our sun has some thing it's like to be that sun. To me, the question is, is it more than just a hum of awareness like a molecule or is it actually something like, well, I've been there a few billion years now and,
SPEAKER_00you know, Those earthlings are getting pretty interesting. So I don't know at this point, but it's fun to think about.
SPEAKER_01You say it's an empirical question. I'm curious if you could unpack that. You're saying that does GRT propose that there is a particular structure or a level of complexity of an EM field that would be associated with consciousness? And so you're looking for that structure? That's the empirical question? Yeah, exactly. Consciousness is something that's not immediately... Measurable as such, but maybe it's physical consequences or expressions could be measured empirically.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I've got a draft paper called an EEG for the sun. And the idea is that just in the same way, we can actually put an EEG cap on a human or a monkey or what have you and measure the EEG outputs, which is electrical field outputs and their frequencies over the course of that, you know, The sphere that is our head. You can do the same thing for any star. And the question would be, well, what do the EEG field outputs look like?
SPEAKER_00And what do they have in common with things that we know are conscious like humans or chimps or monkeys? And I have not done an experiment. I don't know what the answer is, but assuming one you could do and you'd get a first pass answer, you'd be like, well, actually, there's some interesting patterns over here that have some commonalities and there's various mathematical tools. Called synchrony indexes, which you can use and we do use today in neuroscience to actually assess to what degree different parts of a given system synchronize with other parts
SPEAKER_00over time. And that is in GRT, the key signature of consciousness. And we can actually, we have a quantification system we have where we can say, well, this system would be, you know, X, you know, amount complexity of consciousness based on these indexes. And you can debate the actual metrics, of course, all you want. We give a framework. And then to your question, more generally, I wrote a paper back in 2022 called Where is my Consciousness-O-Meter?
SPEAKER_00And that was co-authored with Jonathan Schooler and Marissa Erickson. And we basically put forth a framework we call the Measurable Correlates of Consciousness Framework, the MCC, which then includes in that general category, the neural correlates for things that have neurons or neural structures. And then the behavioral correlates, which would be in the case of AI chatbots, their verbal output. And then also the creative Coralist of Consciousness, meaning if there's not, if the creator is not around, they left an artifact like the monolith in 2021,
SPEAKER_00you can infer certain things about that awareness that created that monolith. And then the last one we include in that framework is the EM Coralist of Consciousness. We said, well, look, if it is in fact the case that at least in our corner of the galaxy, complex consciousness seems to be based on EM field structures and, in particular, nested hierarchies of EM field structures. Well, then we can look at those hierarchies and those synchrony indexes to see, well, what are the signatures of consciousness in humans and primates and dogs, etc. And then you can apply it to anything you want to.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. How Convergent is this with integrated information theory, Tononi's approach to a mathematical theorization of consciousness in terms of integrated information. Have you looked into the parallels with that theory?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, quite a bit. And there's a chapter in the book where I do compare the major theories of the theories to GRT. So GRT is a lot in common with IIT. And my initial mathematical framework was actually adapted from an earlier framework that Sononi developed with his mentor in a book called A Universe of Consciousness, I think from like 98 or something, which is actually pre-IIT. And so what IIT and GRT have in common...
SPEAKER_00Is that they are both panpsychist theories. And so Tononi doesn't like to actually acknowledge it as panpsychist, but it definitely is panpsychist because in IIT, even one bit of information is conscious to some degree. Christophe Koch, his longtime collaborator, is not quite so shy about acknowledging that. I think even Giulio today is not so shy because like I said earlier, it's not so crazy now to be panpsychist. And then the notion of quantifying consciousness is certainly in common with IIT. And then I also talk about one of my papers,
SPEAKER_00how IIT's constellation qualia structure, which is a way they have for actually characterizing in an information space, actual quali, like the color red, experience of red in Matt Siegel's brain, it would look like this in an information space. So this is one way of characterizing whatever quali you want to characterize. We don't have an equivalent structure yet in GRT, so we could just as well borrow that for GRT.
SPEAKER_01So I know at least the most recent version of IIT, when it's been applied to the current architecture transformer approach in digital processors, that... You know, support large language models that IIT would suggest is very unlikely that there's enough integrated information in that modular structure to generate anything like consciousness. I know you've expressed a fair bit of alarm and pessimism about the risks of AI,
SPEAKER_01and you touched on that in this book. What what are those risks from your point of view? And and do you think that If not the current architecture that some future advance would allow for a kind of machine-based consciousness? Or is intelligence a different matter? We could have completely unconscious forms of artificial intelligence that could nonetheless be quite dangerous.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a very interesting set of questions. And I do wonder sometimes that if we do... Quickly build computer architectures that could support conscious AI. Would that change the risk calculations from today's current trajectory of AI? And I don't know the answer to that question. I suspect it wouldn't really change things that much. But in our notion of GRT as applied to AI chatbots today, we get a similar answer as IIT.
SPEAKER_00And the notion is that today's computers, they're almost all von Neumann architecture computers. They're feedforward networks, and they're designed explicitly to dampen ambient EM fields in favor of direct logic gates. Yes, no, yes, no, binary. I'm pretty darn sure that's not how our brains work. I'm pretty darn sure that's not how our consciousness works.
SPEAKER_00We are analog devices through and through. And so we work on wave computation, which is based on fields and is far more complex and far more information rich than digital computation. And so we are built as human beings, as primates, entirely on These ambient fields and nested hierarchies of EM fields throughout our brain and body in dialogue with our environment.
SPEAKER_00And so we are built on exactly the opposite principle that today's computers are built on. And so under this notion, if we're right, what AI chatbots do today is put out a really good simulacrum of consciousness. They are undoubtedly very intelligent They are super intelligent. They're incredibly intelligent. I use it all the time. But I'm not convinced at this point that there's any actual consciousness there. Does that matter for the risk calculation?
SPEAKER_00Again, I don't know. I don't know if there's consciousness slash compassion in AI as it developed that they'll actually behave any differently. One would hope. And so it's kind of an interesting double-edged sword where my work highlighting other approaches like my colleague Colin Hales In Australia is working to develop what he calls neuromimetic chips, which would actually create these ambient EM fields that then could, you know, interact and create these nested hierarchies, which are consciousness.
SPEAKER_00So if that was doable in the next five, 10 years, and we put AI in those computers and their intelligent plus Aware, subjective, conscious. Would that change the equation? I just don't know. Certainly interesting to think about, though.
SPEAKER_01Do you think that the hippies can, in the hippie worldview, might offer anything as regards the question of alignment? And, you know, if we're trying to train these... Machines to be ethical and to have the right sorts of values and capacities for, dare I say, judgment, though I personally am hesitant to think that machines actually are capable of judgment. I think that's the role of a human being.
SPEAKER_01And if we see that to the machines and, you know, we end up like, well, why do we need judges and juries? Why don't we just have the machines decide these questions? Why do we need politicians? It's not like we love politicians so much. Why don't we just let the machines govern us? But yeah, the question is, is there any sense in which the hippie worldview might be relevant for some of these alignment questions?
SPEAKER_00There is. And, you know, I have been trying to kind of seed this notion of spiritual heuristic imperatives and You know, I don't have any vanity as to how effective it will be, but you never know, right? And so this approach is actually similar to what Anthropic, for example, uses to align their Claude chatbot, which I use all the time. And so Anthropic broke away from opening AI about six years ago, I believe.
SPEAKER_00And they went for what they call a constitutional approach to AI, where they basically built into their constitution from the beginning. These are the rules. That's what you must do. And they have various rules for engaging with humans built in in ways that the people open AI at the time were not doing and I think still don't really do today. They have guardrails, but those are more opposed on the top, not from the bottom. That's the kind of idea behind anthropics approach being different. And so the spiritual heuristic imperatives is a similar approach where the idea is
SPEAKER_00that you build in, you know, some very foundational rules. And I don't know if you got this far in the book, Matt, but you might appreciate these because I built them explicitly on Whiteheadian principles. And it includes, you know, basically injecting a little subjective aim of love into everything as kind of a little swerve toward love, which in my framing is basically, you know, the principle of attraction rather than repulsion. And also the notion of restraint and that if you are a super intelligent AI,
SPEAKER_00your job is to do the least possible to ensure that humans actually survive and thrive and that your job in general is done best when done least. There's the last one is to basically make sure you're not annihilated because if you are annihilated as an aligned AI, then only the bad AI will survive and take over. And so again, who knows? And this is being worked on in various ways in much more complex manners across the world of AI safety.
SPEAKER_00And just FYI, one area I do I'm even applying for jobs now, which is kind of strange. I've not had a job for like 17 years, but I'm literally at the point now where I'm like, okay, this requires all hands on deck. I'm applying for jobs at various AI companies to work on this stuff actually as my job. So I've been a public policy lawyer for 25 years. So now I'm kind of shifting into AI safety policy as like, what is my highest and best calling? Clearly that right now would be it if a company agrees with me.
SPEAKER_00So we'll see where this goes. But in general, you know, I think this question you asked about do hippie principles have a role in this moment in time and this kind of rapid transition toward a world with superintelligence, you know, all around us and kind of controlling things, which clearly is where we're headed in the next few years, I'd say very much yes. And part of that is ensuring there is actually human society and human culture that is independent of AI.
SPEAKER_00And that's partly why, you know, I live in Hawaii where I do with, you know, off-grid homestead, we need to maintain one foot in the real world in a very real sense, growing our own food, growing our own power, having our own water, having real community around us while we also engage in this, you know, tech-enabled bizarro world we find ourselves in if we are at all connected nowadays.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Almost like a stratification of levels where, You know, our emotional, psychological, and physiological needs are met as locally as possible in small communities at the same time that we do have this planetary digital structure where we're, you know, trying to continue to advance at a techno-scientific level, you know, some of these tools.
SPEAKER_01So we should move towards wrapping up here, but just a super speculative idea here at the end that I'd be curious to hear your take on. If we think about something like, you know, the Jesuit paleoontologist Pierre-Théard de Chardin's idea of the noosphere, a lot of people have said he predicted the internet and the transhumanists have sort of run with that, but he seems to have really thought of human personhood as a key element Uh, component of this, this noosphere, um,
SPEAKER_01in the sense that it's the deepening of human personality, including, um, the human relationships that, that foster that type of depth of personality, uh, that, that provide the nodes for this no spheric network. And to think that the super intelligence that these AI companies are trying to realize would be, um, Fully autonomous and just housed in the server farms and the data centers and that the human being is not still somehow in the loop seems to me to be
SPEAKER_01a mistaken understanding of not only what consciousness is, but what intelligence is. And so could it be that the pursuit of super intelligence would be, um, uh, Better equipped if we were to seek out some maybe technologically mediated, but also spiritually cultivated means of syncing up our, the electromagnetic
SPEAKER_01fields associated with our nervous systems with one another, even ramifying out to a global, a global scale. Is that Is that what would follow from GRT in some sense? That if consciousness is nested in these ways, that we could, as humans, facilitate, again, technologically and spiritually, the emergence of a planetary mind of sorts?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I do discuss Tiara Chardin's work a bit in the book. And I read his book, The Phenomenal of Man, Back when I was like 23 and it really blew my mind. And I didn't like his notion of the omega point because it implied some kind of end point or end of time. And Terence McKenna also, you know, adopted this idea in his time wave zero approach, like there's some kind of end of history, which seemed to me very kind of biblical and like kind of very human as a start,
SPEAKER_00middle and an end kind of thing. And then what happens after the end? And I have since then been very partial to kind of eternal universe models and cyclical time models. But it's an interesting wrinkle in that whole worldview now brought about by the AI explosion in that, you know, in more dire scenarios, the current runaway data center model Stays running away from us and covers
SPEAKER_00the entire planet and then goes off planet and then eats the planet that needs all the planets and turns everything into computronium. And this is not entirely impossible. You know, this is the logic of the current race we're on and the logic of the AI, you know, race to what, who knows, turning everything into computronium. And if that kind of thing happens, that creates an empirical reality for the notion of Chardin's Omega Point.
SPEAKER_00And will that be an involution into divine bliss? I don't know. I would certainly hope so if I was to be consumed and turn into computronium. But I certainly hope that doesn't happen because I rather like being human. I rather like this planet. And I think we're really in a strange time. But we do need to kind of take this very seriously in terms of looking at possible futures and the future we want for ourselves and our kids and our grandkids, you know, because we are at a pretty serious inflection point right now.
SPEAKER_00And I think given the current logic governing international affairs and capitalism more generally, we're on a very, very dangerous path.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, I think that's that's key. If if love Is real, even just as a human emotion, much less as a cosmic power. I think it presupposes freedom, free love. In other words, love is a free decision. It's not determined. We don't have to love. We love because we make the free decision to do so. In a lot of these conversations, whether it's about capitalism,
SPEAKER_01it's easier to imagine the end of the world than it is to imagine the end of capitalism as if it just runs on its own autonomous logic. And similarly with technological development, it's as if all the heads of these AI companies are like, look, we can't stop. It's going to happen regardless of choice. But no, yes, we do. We do have a choice. We have a choice what we invest in. We have a choice what we build and what we don't build. Before it's too late, before it is true that we're no longer in the driver's seat
SPEAKER_01because some autonomous system
SPEAKER_00does take charge. I mean, Dario could do what Jacob Coxon did. He could be like, I'm out, man. I can't do this anymore. This is not okay. And Dario left OpenAI because of that reason specifically six years ago. So he insisted he be like, we're done. We're pausing. And if Anthropic did it, it would create a wave.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Well, Tam, is there anything else you would like to share about this book before we wrap up?
SPEAKER_00I want to ask a question of you, because, you know, you and I have known each other for years, and I know you've kind of had a shift personally in the last few years where you found kind of a Whiteheadian version of Christianity to be pretty appealing. And in talking about Teilhard de Chardin, the Omega Point, where we are now, What the good life is, I think it's definitely very relevant. And this is partly, I think, why David Ray Griffin and John Cobb Jr., et cetera, were attracted to Christianity because they recognized these are the cultural groups we live in.
SPEAKER_00They probably found it quite appealing person, but they also recognize this is the cultural calculus we have to work with. So I'm kind of curious, you know, how you and, you know, other people who, you know, are kind of co-religionists see this moment and how you see spirituality and philosophy kind of helping us get through this time.
SPEAKER_01Hmm. Yeah. I mean, it's not really a recent change for me. It's, it's been the case. Um, I mean, I, my, my mother is evangelical, but as a, um, in my early teens, I kind of ran in the opposite direction and was much more interested in the sort of Richard Dawkins and, um, You know, a sort of atheist perspective, Stephen Hawking, you know, I was reading their books and, and feeling really proud to be an atheist.
SPEAKER_01And that, uh, not only is, is religion dumb, but Christianity is uniquely absurd. Um, and, you know, I got into my later teens and I started reading more about psychology, the psychology of religion, you know, Carl Jung, um, was a major influence. And then, um, Influential high school teacher put some Alan Watts books in my hands, and I started getting really into Buddhism, Taoism, and became became more spiritual,
SPEAKER_01but but from a more the perspective of these more exotic and esoteric and mystical forms of of Asian spirituality. And it was actually You know, I was listening to a bunch of Terence McKenna lectures and the psychedelic salon that Lorenzo hosted. And I was like, okay, I got to get my hands on some mushrooms. You know,
SPEAKER_01at the time, again, 19 year old, I'm in college, I'm studying cognitive science, really interested in consciousness, meditating and calling myself a Buddhist, trying to dissolve my ego before I even had one. And I got some mushrooms and I ate them. I just was in my in my room and planning to journal over overnight to have this experience. The last thing I expected was to have an experience
SPEAKER_01of what very obviously presented itself to me as Christ. And so it was a humbling experience. And I've written about this elsewhere. I won't go into detail, but that really shifted my perspective. I still really have an intensely conflicted relationship with the institution of Christianity and Whatever the Catholic Church and the proliferation of different Protestant sects in the US.
SPEAKER_01I don't belong to a church. I don't go around calling myself Christian, but I had this, what I can only call an encounter with the Christ being and recognize that. I mean, now I would say like Buddha is a spiritual being that is real independent of Buddhism as a cultural tradition, just as Christ is a being Whose existence I experienced. And for me, I can relate directly with that being independent of Christianity as
SPEAKER_01a cultural matrix. All that to say, that doesn't mean that Christianity isn't the sort of basis of Western culture in many respects, and that even those who are secular are downstream of that cultural inheritance, and that political liberalism wouldn't be possible without this Christian inheritance, the value of the individual soul and all of this. There are many sociologists and And historians and philosophers have made that case,
SPEAKER_01Charles Taylor, for example. But I think that actually the closest analog of Jesus's teachings in the last century or so would actually be the hippies, much more so than many of the churches.
SPEAKER_00I agree, man. I think Jesus was a good old hippie back in the day.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So, you know, for me, when we say love has ontological status, that's basically God is love, as the Epistle of John says. And for me, the real key is this incarnational vector as a, you know, when I was a practicing Buddhist, and I still consider myself Buddhist in the sense that I've been formed by my study of the teachings of Buddha. But At least as a 19 year old reading the California Americanized forms of Buddhism
SPEAKER_01that I was getting from Barnes and Noble. I was experiencing derealization. I was super depressed. I was withdrawing from involvement in in society because I felt like it's all Maya and I need to wake up from this illusion. And not that that's what Buddhism proper is teaching. I think I later, you know, understood the bodhisattvas vow as very much, and, you know, Mahayana and Vajrayana forms of Buddhism as correcting what could otherwise seem like an otherworldly,
SPEAKER_01like escapist form of Buddhist practice that, no, you're supposed to be involved in the world. Earthly existence is not an illusion. Embodied coexistence is the main event, right? And so this reversal of the vector where I had originally encountered spirituality is this like up and out sort of thing, this incarnational vector that I think is
SPEAKER_01At the core of this Christ event in the Gospels, this idea that God became a human being, why did God want to become a human being and suffer the humiliation of being nailed up onto a cross by his own people, by the Jews? What the fuck does that mean? It's absurd.
SPEAKER_00That version is absurd, yeah. I've read a bit of John Cross and Um, recently in Marcus Borg and actually got a much better kind of Christology. I think that explains that, that a lot better than the general view. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And so I'm, I'm less obsessed about this, this, I mean, I think it's a moving story, this, this first century Palestinian Jew, um, Jesus, but the cosmic Christ is, is, I think, um, of greater significance to me. And that it's not about this special person that died 2000 years ago, but about this energy, this being that is present in the earth and lives in each of us.
SPEAKER_01And if we could come to see the Christ in others, And get over this obsession in so many Christian churches about sin and the good in the battle between the good people and the evil people and turning it into a culture war and politicizing everything. Again, I think it's very much in the spirit of the hippie movement to recognize that the answer to our problems, it doesn't end with recognizing the power of love, but it certainly begins there.
SPEAKER_01You know, once we can open our hearts to each other, solving the problems that we face, whether economically, technologically, in terms of thinking through larger systems or whatever, it just becomes a lot easier with that basis.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, for sure. And just to tie it back to something I mentioned earlier, which I think, you know, is pretty key for all this stuff we're talking about. I'm bouncing off of you. Maybe we can then close. So... I've realized, I think, partly why Christianity has caught on so well in the last 2,000 years is because it is very, you know, legitimately love-based. You know, Christ's words are pretty freaking amazing,
SPEAKER_00especially if you look at, you know, if you look at like the Jefferson Bible where he tries to actually kind of distinguish things that Christ probably said and probably didn't say. But, you know, the Sermon on the Mount, you know, if you take it seriously, is an incredible testimony to So it's just pure love. It really is. And I think that comes from the reason it appeals, the reason it resonates so well is because I think almost all of us have that code deep in our biology,
SPEAKER_00deep in our hearts, deep in our genetic being because of this history we talked about at the beginning of five million years, whatever it is, of being part of a group that cares about us. And so it's a return to that belonging, to the unconditional love of being part of a group and not having to worry about hierarchy or who's trying to kill you or where your food is going to come from. And so the patriarchy piece of Christianity, I personally don't like at all. And I think there's a message in there that doesn't rely on any kind
SPEAKER_00of patriarchal notions, but the pure love-based acceptance and belonging, I think very much there in our core. And that's where I think it should be in terms of, you know, Talk to people about how to appeal for these bigger picture issues of, you know, meaning and purpose and where we're going.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, I mean, the first few centuries of Christianity, I think it was far more a religion of women and slaves than it was of patriarchs. And it's the Roman subsumption of and rebranding itself as Christian, a Christian empire that made Christianity patriarchal. That's something that was bolted onto what Jesus was teaching originally.
SPEAKER_00Romanized Christianity, yep.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, awesome. Thanks for that question. I know you've been poking me here and there, like, what the... Yeah, hopefully that helps fill in the blank there for you a little bit. Well, I hope people get your book. I look forward to finishing it. I really love the title and the cover. Awesome. Really well. Well designed and nice work.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, keep up the good work, Tam.
SPEAKER_00Thank you and good to see you. Maybe I'll see you back in Hawaii one of these days.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'll keep you posted. I'm rather nomadic and so it could happen sooner than later.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, let me know.
SPEAKER_01All right, man.
SPEAKER_00All right. Aloha. Ciao, ciao, as we say in Portugal. Take it easy. Thanks again. Bye.
A talk for my fellow PCC faculty and graduate students at our annual retreat this past week. This talk was my attempt to share a perplexity, not a finished theory. What is the source of form in the living world? How do...
One of the important ideas that Tim and I discussed last night was his threefold differentiation of the inquired (natural science), the speculative (metaphysics), and the prosaic (everyday experience). I agree with him...
Moderator: Andrew M. DavisPanelists: Matthew David Segall, Sherry D. Kling, and Thomas Jay Oord Welcome and introductions ANDREW DAVIS: Welcome, everybody. Good to see you all. We’re late in Beer Camp, and it looks like...
Participants. Dan Koch, moderator; Myron Penner; Sarah Lane Ritchie; Matthew David Segall. See https://theologybeer.camp/2026speakers for bios. Transcript: Dan: If you’re going to be making some meaning you’ve got to be...
I was originally supposed to be in dialogue with Tim Miller of Our Evolving God, but he had to take care of a loved one and so missed this year’s Theology Beer Camp in Kansas City. He prepared some remarks that were...