When estimating durations, people tend to drift toward one of two dangerous extremes: padding the schedule because they have been burned before, or promising unrealistic performance because they believe they can push through anything. In this episode, Jason explains why both "sandbaggers" and "superhumans" can damage flow, planning reliability, and the people doing the work. Jason explores how experience should be questioned, how past observations and feedback loops shape judgment, and why historical data can help teams establish more realistic durations. The goal is not to eliminate expert opinion, but to find the middle ground where teams can keep promises without unnecessary padding or overburdening crews. What you'll learn in this episode: How sandbaggers can add unnecessary padding based on past negative experiences. Why superhuman commitments can overburden crews and disrupt successor trades. How experience becomes more reliable when observations and feedback loops are accurate. Why historical reference data can improve duration planning. How to find realistic commitments without hedging or asking people to overperform. Are your durations based on what the work truly requires or on fear at one extreme and overconfidence at the other? If you like the Elevate Construction podcast, please subscribe for free and you'll never miss an episode. And if you really like the Elevate Construction podcast, I'd appreciate you telling a friend (Maybe even two 馃槉). Also, here are links to our YouTube Channels: 路 Jason Schroeder YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC4xpRYvrW5Op5Ckxs4vDGDg 路 LeanTakt YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/leanTakt 路 LeanSuper YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCzQDevqQP19L4LePuqma3Fg/featured 路 LeanSurvey YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC-Ztn3okFhyB_3p5nmMKnsw
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey there everybody, welcome out to podcast number 1729. I got a cool one that I've never heard before that, well, I mean I kind of understood the concept but it blew my mind when I heard it and it came from Kevin Rice, Sandbaggers and Superman. If you're interested in this, please stay with us. Welcome everybody, I hope you're doing well and staying safe out there. This is a cool topic, and by the way, you can turn this into a gender
-inclusive title, Sandbaggers and Superhumans, whatever, however you want to do it. I'm just giving it to you the way I first heard it. Oh, by the way, how is this useful versus, I always want to say, how is this useful versus just being some kind of weird rant by Jason. In fact, I remember giving a talk one time and asking somebody how it was and the lady was like, well, there's Jason ranting again. So I'm always trying to make sure there's a purpose. Here's the purpose.
We've got to be watching out for this human behavior and checking, oh my gosh, this is going to be such a good podcast, checking it with a couple of different things. And Sandbaggers will be too cautious and put fluff in their schedules. They will under-promise and try and over -deliver. Superhumans will be like, fuck it, we ball, let's go and not be realistic about how long something takes.
Now, so this isn't just some random rant. I want you to know that in the new book, Elevating the Construction Mind, and I just want everybody to know that's the only book where I had AI gather everything. Every other book, I've written 10 books by myself without AI help. Then 20 more where I wrote the content, but AI helped me edit the content. And this is the first book ever where AI literally aggregated it all for my review
based on trying to get research together. So the idea was, I did load my manuscript, so the lean concepts and the things that I had a complaint with when it comes to human behavior all into this book and asked it to research and find studies that would accentuate the content, meaning really bring the content to life. And there was one chapter that was talking about experts and the observation and experience, meaning
experience being a benefit to people in construction. And in the book and the research shows that experience is a great thing, meaning that it can be wildly beneficial, especially when your subconscious mind is processing so much data in the background and while you sleep and during breaks. And for people who have a lot of experience, they can literally just look at a
situation and tell what's going on. Now, they say where this goes wrong is where you don't question the experience. And here were the two things that needed to be questioned. One is, did the expert who's observing something have continuous exposure to the right observations that brought about the experience? And two, was the feedback loop providing the meaning for those observations accurate? So in the studies that were found, it
was very clear that it is very effective to rely on the observations of experts under those conditions as long as they were checked. So there is a lot to save for experience as long as it's under those conditions. And that's good because we have a lot of people in construction that we rely on
based off of their experience to make critical decisions. And we have to check our experts and their observations, especially when they're dictating durations. Like if we don't have historical data and we're asking a foreman how long something will be taken, the questioning and the quality of the observations and the feedback loops does come into play. And when you're starting to observe a person, you're not trying to profile them to pigeonhole
them or discount them or anything like that. But there are two types that are in the extreme of what we want. The sandbaggers are the ones that have been hurt, so their observations of the past are ones of pain. And if the feedback loop didn't attribute it to bad systems and they just think it's the way construction is, they're going to pad their activities and it's going to affect the pull plan and everything that we do with short interval scheduling.
For the superheroes, superhumans, these are the folks that are like, oh there's a mountain, you want me to climb it? Like I'm gonna I'm gonna die climbing this mountain. And that's dangerous because that could overburden people. And the other trade, the successor trades may not be done and we're relying, now we're blaming humans because we're pinning it all on humans and we actually don't have the right amount of buffer and that will not allow flow. So either one hurts flow.
So the key for us to, in this point, to get away from sandbaggers and superheroes or superhumans is to actually begin to rely more on historical accurate, and this goes for data as well, it's so funny, the same thing for humans, it goes for data as well, accurate historical reference classes. And try and get as much data as we possibly can, but if it is still a human opinion, basically say it like this,
what is the duration if this actually is a job that keeps its promises? Where you don't have to hedge your bets but we're also not asking you to kill yourself. Like what, like Frank, like here was something that got me into this habit. Kate taught me the other day, if I'm talking to somebody and starting to get tipped over, I could say this, could you please say this to me as if you were
on my team? And you can, and by the way, I just want you to know all of these suggestions are like easier said than done. I very rarely remember all of this stuff when I need it. I very often, once I mess something up, remember and then revert to the good behavior. So I'm just saying when, if you ever remember this is a good trick. Okay, what is your duration if you, this project and the other trade partners actually keep their commitments and you feel like you are
in the of a reliable team but also not overburdening yourself and your crew, meaning that we're not asking you too much. And try and get to the middle solution outside of the realm of sandbaggers and superheroes. Anyway, I had never heard that before. Take it for what it's worth. I hope you've enjoyed this podcast. On we go.
Avoiding the hardest problem rarely makes it disappear; it usually gives it more time to grow. In this episode, Jason explains why one of the best ways to improve projects, leadership, and even your own peace of mind is...
You do not need authority over the entire project to start leading. In this episode, Jason shares a story from his own career to explain why the most effective way to lead from below is not to wait for permission,...
A three-week pull may look like Lean planning, but Jason argues that it can leave teams focused on what is directly in front of them instead of preparing the entire phase properly. In this episode, he explains why...
A great meeting should do more than share updates it should expose what is off track and help the team solve it. In this episode, Jason breaks down the purpose and flow of the Level 10 Meeting from the Entrepreneurial...
Going to bid is not just about sending drawings to trade partners and waiting for numbers to come back. In this episode, Jason breaks down the planning, estimating, scoping, and documentation that need to happen before...