Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Earned First

Earned First artwork

Cannes: Burson's Craig Buchholz on the PR Grand Prix, the CCO's rise and more

Jul 1, 202626 minAudio

Craig Buchholz, US CEO of Burson, joins Earned First at Cannes Lions 2026 the day after the agency's Kit Kat Heist campaign won the PR Lions Grand Prix. He discusses what made it work: a crisis reframed as cultural opportunity, bravery as a prerequisite for award-winning ideas, and the "culture up" philosophy that sits at the heart of Burson's earned-first approach. The conversation also covered the CCO's evolving role in the C-suite: from brand protector to enterprise growth advisor, and the degree to which that elevation turns on individual relationships as much as institutional structure. Buchholz, a former CCO at both General Motors and Procter & Gamble, also addresses what it takes to keep a seat at the table once it's secured, the growing presence of investors and private equity at Cannes, and what it signals about where the communications industry is heading.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to Earned First at Cannes. It's Thursday. The end of the week is in sight. But more importantly, I'm delighted to be joined today by the Burson US CEO, Craig Buchholz. Craig, welcome. Thank you. Pleasure to be here. How's your week been? It took a wonderful turn last night. It's been wonderful so far, but really an amazing night last night for us, obviously. Absolutely. Burson winning the PR Lions Grand Prix. for the Kit Kat Heist campaign. How are you feeling? Feeling

very, very good about that. We were pretty proud of it coming in. We thought it brought together a lot of the elements we talk about in terms of what makes an earned first creative idea work. And I think that for now becomes the poster child and the aspiration of what great work looks like. It's relatively unusual to see a crisis campaign. do really well at Cannes. What do you think this campaign got right? I think from the beginning, the frame was perhaps this isn't a crisis, right?

So it is in the most traditional sense where there was a theft and whatnot. But at the end of the day, the frame turned to how do you turn it on its head? And we thought about it less as a crisis, which... It was, but more as an opportunity really to integrate this notion of what we call culture up, where a brand really looks to intersect with culture. And then it kind of took off from there. It required an element of bravery, I would imagine. Is that something

that you're seeing more of on the client side? You, of course, worked client side for many years. do you think that companies are more willing to take these kinds of risks given how important it is to be part of culture? Yeah, I think that's one of the prerequisites to do this is bravery. I mean, the work that you see winning here. One of the through lines really is a brave stance on something. Because that's what sets it apart. Especially if you're going to talk about standing on stage at Cannes. It needs to be something

that is different. And oftentimes curiosity and bravery are things that will pull the campaign into a different stratosphere. Were there any other trends in particular that you've seen emerging from the work this week, whether it's in PR or other categories that you think are perhaps setting the agenda for what we can expect to see in the kind of comms world? You know, there are some things that I saw and some things that I thought we would see more of in some of the winning work. And the answer is the same for both of them,

which is where data and insights actually feed a brief or feed a campaign. Because the tools that we have in our industry are unlike anything we've ever had before. Certainly that's true for Burson, but I think that's true broadly across the industry. So I thought we might see a bit more on where we had ideas and campaigns that were data led. There were a couple of those for sure. But I think next year and in years ensuing, we're going to see even more of that where we

really arrest the power of these tools and use that to do. amazing work. Yeah, it's a very good point. Of course, Burson has a huge tech stack now, quite a developed offering, which includes predictive analytics and a lot of data insight products. Do you think maybe that stuff is just harder to translate to some of the bolder ideas you see at Cannes? I don't know that it's harder

to translate. I think when telling the story of how the work one, we probably have to incorporate that part of it a little bit more overtly. Because it's not to say that a lot of the winning work wasn't fueled by that, but it sort of doesn't come through in how you tell where the work became the winning work. And I think that at the end of the day, because of these tools, the work is going to get more precise and more impactful. Like you talked about the predictive analytics. We also have all of these synthetic AI focus

groups where you can... be more confident, and actually be more brave because of that confidence, because of the tools. And I think that's just going to create this transformation of the work. Just to digress slightly, I'm always a little interested in these synthetic AI audiences. How reliable are you finding them? Are clients willing to trust them? Yeah. Oh, yeah. Our clients are trusting them for sure. We have a very high degree of confidence on this. Our team is among the brightest in the industry. And of course, these AI synthetic focus groups are... built on millions

or billions of artifacts right so the confidence level that we bring to that is very high and the benefit of it is that you can parse it much more specifically than you can in something in the field that would take two days or three weeks. We can do it in two hours with a high degree of specificity and a high degree of confidence. And that continues to prove out. So we bring it to a client with full disclosure that it's an AI focus group. They are confident in our

confidence. And so far, what we're seeing on the other side is validation of the synthetic AI focus groups. At what point do you decide, actually, we need a human -focused group rather than an AI one? But I think this is the fundamental question of the relationship between the human and AI. And one of the things that WPP recently came out with was our trust principles. And we talk about consumers as people. We talk about AI as augmenting, not replacing. I think that's going to be the really important balance to get right. And that's the one thing I'm excited to

be seeing a lot this week is I haven't heard a lot of the doom and gloom of is AI going to replace what we do. Mark Pritchard, I'm sure you know, had the talk the other night about robots can't build brands. So it's about where in the spectrum does the human come in? And I think the human always comes in. So I think at the end of the day, depending upon the campaign, depending upon the crisis, depending upon what you're trying to solve for, there is a judgment

that comes in where you say, okay, the synthetic AI focus group took us this far. Let's go one more step and validate that. But the gap between what the human groups will tell us and what the synthetic groups tell us is very, very narrow. So that confidence is there, which is – they're very reliable tools. Yeah, it's very interesting. But I totally agree with you. I have noticed this week at Cannes the AI discussion has been very human -led. Yeah. And I think that's reassuring.

The other thing, of course, is the emergence perhaps of the CCO. Yeah. at CAN. This has not always been their natural domain. This has been an event that has traditionally been dominated by CMOs. You moderated a CCO panel with Adweek yesterday, which by all accounts was a very interesting conversation. How are you seeing it as someone, of course, who's worked on the CCO side for many years? Why do you think CCOs are becoming more

integral to CAN? A couple of reasons. We've always been here. Yeah, true. But I think the recognition of the work and creating more specific space for the work has opened that door. I also think, we talked about this in the panel yesterday, I think we're actually in the second cycle of a CCO evolution. We went from... protectors of the brand. And I think the remit was protect us. I think the remit now is help us grow. And

when you have a CEO, a CFO, anyone in the C -suite that looks at the work and says, this can actually be part of our growth strategy, it completely changes how you're perceived and where you can come into the conversation. So I think we went from protect us to counsel us to now be a... true strategic advisor to us and help us think about how we execute or contribute to this growth strategy. When I was the CCO at General Motors, Mary Barra had a very specific remit for anyone

who was her direct report, which is, yes, you run your function, but your primary role is to be an enterprise leader. Help us think about the strategy of the company, how and where we grow, where we make supply chain decisions, where we make new product introduction decisions. the chief communications officer is in the room for that. That is a different role than existed five years ago. Yeah, and yet it sounds so obvious, right? It does, yeah. Given what we know about communications and corporate affairs and its

understanding of different stakeholders, what do you think the barriers have been to comms people being elevated into that position? I think the profession itself has matured significantly. And I think at the end of the day, A communications leader needs to be a business leader. And we've moved, I think, from a world where we do communications for communication's sake to we do communications as an enterprise growth driver. That difference

has really changed the way the profession is hiring, recruiting, even back to the university level. You see some of the curriculum now is much more focused on the business of the work. than it is about just the craft. And I think you need both of those to be successful. Yeah, it's a very encouraging point, I think, for the comm sector as a whole. The other thing, of course, I wanted to ask you about if we're talking about CCOs is, you know, maybe a slightly more tactical

point, but I was at a Page discussion. I think it was yesterday. I don't know. All the days blur into one. It's one long day here. At this point. And they found, they do their kind of navigator benchmarking study, and they found that 51 % of CCOs now are reporting to the CEO. That still strikes me as a little too low. I wonder how you feel about that. I think it is too low, but I think we're heading in the right direction. I think there's sort of this overall transformation of how is the C -suite? put together.

I mean, I think you see really interesting models out there. The thing that matters more than reporting to the CEO is the relationship that you have with the CEO. So we get really hung up on structure, but what matters is an operating model. Do you have the license to go into the CEO, the CFO, regardless of your reporting structure and influence decisions? Are you called on as a counselor? It's interesting, GM as an example. When I was

there, the CCO reported to the CEO, but the CMO did not. The CMO actually reported to a president. So that was like technically one level down. That has since changed. So Lynn, who came in behind me, is now the CMCO. They've combined it into one role. So we're seeing a lot of that as well. So I think it's great that 51 % report to the CEO. It would be great if it was 100. I think there's some hand -wringing there that is better used in terms of defining the value

proposition of the work that we do and making sure that you have the license to go in and influence. Hand -wringing, God forbid. Never heard of it. How much of it is down to individuals versus institutions? Because that's another thing that sometimes you can see emerging when we look at the data. There was a Wall Street Journal article recently, for example, about the emergence of the CCO. And sometimes it seems like it's down to the power of a specific individual rather

than an institutional decision to elevate the CCO. What do you think about that? I think that's largely true. I mean, I think relationships and behaviors drive a lot of things. When I came into the role at Procter & Gamble, when I came into Procter & Gamble, They had eliminated the CCO role because they had actually a failed CCO succession. This is years ago. And part of my remit was self -imposed to get into there as

a VP, establish the value proposition, reestablish the CCO role, which is what we did. And then Damon Jones went and took it into the stratosphere. So I think part of that is... the individual relationships, the institutional fortitude for what the role can be. But as with most things, it comes down to behavior and relationships. So if we perhaps agree that the CCO has now got

the fabled seat at the table, which again is something I think the industry can get a little bit too hung up on. I agree. But how do they keep it? Yeah. I think it's... Really understanding the role is a business advisor. You are a business leader who brings communications as a discipline into the growth strategy of an organization. If you look at it the other way and get back to a world where we're doing communications for

communication's sake, I think we're going to lose that seat. And I actually say we have gone from having a seat at the table to actually working the door. because there's a lot that comes to communications first. And I think that's a very powerful position for us to be in. Well, exactly. I mean, I think, you know, comms people are the first to see so many of these signals emerging about corporates and, of course, see so many of these issues emerging. Not something that has always been recognized internally, but I'm

glad to see it is. Now, of course, I think... The emergence of the CCO will not have gone unnoticed by other types of agencies and other players. And of course, we're seeing the influence of earned being increasingly recognized in the AI era. How confident are you that the comm sector, the public relations sector, will be able to kind of deliver on that promise? I'm hearing ad agencies are now setting up earned practices

as well. How do you see that particular tension? Look, I think there's always going to be tension and opportunity. And I think that the focus that we bring to this is what is in the best interest of our client and who is in the best position to drive a strategy. You're probably familiar with the fact that WPP is really moving to a one company model where we are able to take the best of talent across all of their traditional operating companies and say, we need some of this, we need some of that, two of those, one

of those. I think that's the world that we have to be focused on versus the turf of this is mine, that is yours, because that is more about the company and the individual and less about the client. Our mission as WPP is to be the trusted growth partner for our clients. And that's the only way to do that. I mean, it's a disruptive time. Yeah. Hasn't it been for a while? It has been, but I do feel the last 12 months, I've

seen more change in the agency world than perhaps in the last 12 years. And it suddenly seems to have just fast -forwarded. We've seen so much. We've seen a lot of consolidation, obviously at WPP, a lot of change as well. But also that's kind of playing out here in Cannes. And this is, you know, you're coming to Cannes this year. I think the last time you came was before COVID. That's right. Yeah. What are the changes you're seeing here? You know, in terms of the work,

one of the real changes that I'm seeing is the recognition of how to. intersect culture. So there was conversations in the day around brands wanting to interrupt culture. That is no longer a successful... Sounds like fun. It's no longer a successful strategy. But that's an evolution. So now we're talking about intersecting culture. We talked about culture up where you, instead of brand down, we find that intersection with culture. I mean, this is Kit Kat. And we pull

culture up into the brand. I think that's just a fundamental reframe on how we think about the work. But the other thing, too, to your point on consolidation and what's happened over the past 12 months, I started on the agency side. And then I was on the client side for 25 years. And now I'm thrilled to be back. back on the agency side. I do think this is a pendulum. So when I started in this industry, it was totally around. consolidation. Everything wanted to be

a one -stop shop. We have it for you. We can do it for you. And that evolved into the birth of specialty and boutique agencies. All of a sudden, you wanted somebody who just did healthcare. You wanted somebody who just did technology. I think that pendulum is now going back to, because of the tools that we have, because of the operating model, we do need everything in one bucket, if you will. Invite me back in 10 years and we might be talking about the disaggregation. Well, I mean, there's a lot of specialist agencies out there now. Even right now, that would probably

disagree with you, right? So I do wonder if sometimes multiple things can be true. Absolutely. And it gets back to what is best for the client, right? And how is the agency engaging? with the client? What is the brief? What is the growth strategy, et cetera? But yes, two things can absolutely be true. But I think the disruption that you're referencing does remind me of 20 years ago when we were going through sort of a similar cycle. It's always useful, I think,

to have that context because sometimes we can all be guilty, I think, of assuming that something is new. Right. And it isn't always. And that introduces hand -wringing again. The hand -wringing, the navel -gazing. Yes, exactly. Sometimes it seems endless. What's your advice for brands that want to be part of culture, that want to do a Kit Kat? Yeah. You know, because we see a lot of companies getting it wrong. Yeah, I think the worst brief in the world right now would be go do a Kit Kat because that wasn't

really how it started. I think it's understanding where the opportunity is, having a deep recognition of... your authentic space and place in culture in a moment. I think the brands that get it wrong are the ones that wake up and say, I want to do a Kit Kat or I want to, you know, sort of do this thing, but not actually, they think about it from the brand perspective and not from the culture perspective. That's where we find ourselves counseling clients. And that's where we find

ourselves getting it right. It's like, hold on. Where is the starting point from a cultural perspective? Where is your authentic space in that? Where is the intersection of those two things? And then we can have a conversation about putting the brief together. We oftentimes, you know, when I was on the client side and we do it now on the agency side, I love to take a brief and then not just reply to the brief, but actually... hone it with the client and say, perhaps what you really are asking for is this. Perhaps what

you really need is this. Let's be very clear so that we get it right and then we're on stage next year again. One of the things, to that point perhaps, but one of the things I think I liked about the Kit Kat work is that it didn't seem like there was an overt sales objective in mind. And of course, it's a crisis campaign. it just seemed like it was focused on solving a specific issue. How comfortable are corporates with that?

Because I sometimes think when it comes to being a part of culture, you kind of have to maybe deprioritize the commercial, the short -term commercial imperative. How important do you think that is? I think it's a balance of interest. So I think the Kit Kat thing is a great example of a problem to be solved. P &G is phenomenal at this. When I was at P &G, I hired us. They're one of our clients. One of their famous things is identifying the work to be done and the problem

to be solved for the consumer across any one of their brands. There's always some sort of attention. There's always some sort of problem to be solved. If you think about it from that perspective, the commercials generally flow from that. The value flows from that because you're creating space for the brand to be relevant in the consumer's life. That is the right frame versus how do you go out there and get 3 % more share. Right, exactly. But you still see it. I go on Reddit. I'm on all the running groups.

And every now and then you'll see a really obvious kind of sales play by a brand. And I still find it quite surprising that we're seeing that. What's so interesting is it is surprising, but it creates more space for the work that we do, which is an earned first reality. And I think one of the moderators on stage said this last night. In a world where there is such a deep and growing distaste for that overt... It creates much more

space for this earned first world and earned first creative, which is kind of the sandbox that we like to play in. So I think that's the juxtaposition. And that's what you're seeing in the work. That's what you're seeing in the winning work. Thanks for saying earned first so much. It was definitely not briefed. I need one of your hats. Excellent. Yeah, we need to figure out how to merchandise these. So yeah, final reflections perhaps. On the shifts you're seeing at Cannes, we were just talking about how there's more investors here on the Quazette.

There's more money around. Is that a sign of Cannes perhaps becoming almost like a Davos in the sun? I would much rather be in Davos right now. It's so hot here. No, I do think there is – I actually like the idea of having investors, private equity, people who can sort of – understand the value of what we do. I think that is a huge validator of the work that we're doing, but also

the future that this industry represents. Because investors, private equity, they're not here looking at today's valuation. They're out there looking at what is this going to be worth in three, five, 10 years. And if they're interested, that means that this industry is about to skyrocket. Do you think they're looking at I know it's maybe a bit reductive, but are they looking at technology? Are they looking at companies as tech companies? Because that seems to be where so much investment

is flowing. I mean, look, that would be an interesting valuation because that's a good way to look at it. But I think the truth is we are more of a tech. oriented industry than we ever were. And I think we're just at the beginning of that. I think that's what's interesting to them is if you look at the tools that we have, like our Decipher, like our predictive analytics, like our synthetic AI focus groups, you name it. RepCap is our tool to value reputation. These are things

we've never had before and we're just getting started. So I think it's very realistic for them to say, how is tech going to fuel this industry? over the next cycle yeah um and that to me is an extraordinarily exciting place to be yeah and it's something that everyone in the comms sector should be mindful of i think because this isn't always a sector that's been very tech fluent yeah right no but if you're thinking about it and if you're thinking about what way where the money is going You know, technology is a big

part of that. Absolutely. And that's where the investments, you know, at the holding company, at the individual operating company, that's what we're looking to invest in. Our WPP open platform is, in my opinion, I can say this having been on the client side, now the agency side, far and away the best in the industry. We're continuing to invest in that. That is going to be the tip of the spear for how we get these award -winning campaigns done. All right, Craig, thank you so much for your time. Thank you. And have a good rest of the week. I will do. Safe travels. Big thank you to you. Big thank you to Burson. And

of course, a big thank you to our production partners at Real Films. Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Kaizzen’s Vineet Handa on monetisation, Middle East expansion and AI enemies

    Oct 30, 202637 minAudio

    Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jean-Léopold Schuybroek: Four decades of building independent PR

    Oct 13, 202625 minAudio

    Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Geopolitics, Mastercard & OpenAI's CCO search

    Sep 29, 202639 minAudio

    Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why corporate affairs pros want change, with GlobeScan's Chris Coulter

    Aug 24, 202636 minAudio

    GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Culture, Cannes & cockroaches with Charlotte Mceleny

    Jul 30, 202647 minAudio

    Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to...

    Credit the people on this episode