Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Earned First

Earned First artwork

Geopolitics, Mastercard & OpenAI's CCO search

Sep 29, 202639 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO search, and why only just over half of CCOs report to the CEO, according to Earned First's PR 2030 research.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to the Earned First podcast. This is Arun Sudhaman, founding editor of Earned First. I'm joined today by my colleague, David Blecken. How are you, David? Very well, thank you. Good. It's good to see you. It's been a holiday, right, in Japan? Silver Week. Silver Week, yeah. It's Golden Week in May and then we have Silver Week in September. So lots of holidays in Japan. Yeah,

indeed. Well, why not? Very good. So we want to talk through a few stories that have attracted our attention in recent weeks and maybe even months. It feels like a lot has happened in the public relations industry, of course. Not too many dull moments, but particularly this year and last year, I do feel like there has been a lot happening. um so let's start with your

newsletter last week where you looked at a sentiment in singapore in opposition to the country's national airline of course singapore airlines i think potentially increasing its investment in air india um on the face of it Seems like a pretty straightforward business story, but it's not

quite from what I understand. No, not at all. No. So there were various factors involved in the story, which it became something quite complicated when it started out just as, you know, a fairly standard discussion about. as you would expect to happen with a listed company. But the issue

has been that Singapore Airlines is, although it's a business, obviously in its own right, it's very tied up with Singapore's national image. So what started off as a rational discussion about business and investments morphed into a sort of nationalistic, an outpouring almost of

emotions on social media. We saw racist slurs being thrown around, directed at people of Indian origin. And all sorts of accusations being raised without any real foundation. Yeah, so it becomes a much more complex situation and actually illustrates a lot of the trends that corporates are grappling

with these days, particularly as they relate to geopolitics. So Singapore Airlines is, it's partially owned by Temasek. I believe. Is that right? Or majority -owned? I'm not entirely sure. And, of course, Temasek is owned by the Singaporean state through the Ministry of Finance. Meanwhile, of course, Air India is India's national airline,

although owned by Tata Group now. undergoing quite a painful rebuild. It needs more money. SIA had bought a minority stake in Air India a few years ago, may have to inject more funds. And all of this adds up to potentially this idea that hard -earned Singaporean tax dollars are

being spent to bail out. an indian airline there's someone of indian origin as well on the singaporean side i believe um is it the sia ceo or the or tamasic it was uh yeah it was um tamasic tamasic ceo right so that's also become a factor in all of this um i thought it was quite extraordinary though the response from singaporean government actually um they came out and uh quite heavily

against the racism that I think was evident in a lot of the online chatter. And I'm not sure it was necessarily the best approach because they also repeated some of the racist statements, which is not always helpful. Tomasek took a long time, not Tomasek SIA. You'll forgive me if I'm conflating the two, but from a corporate perspective,

the response wasn't really quick enough, I think was your assessment. So they did take a little while to respond and to clarify the position of Singapore Airlines, to clarify that it was free to make its own investment decisions. um that it wasn't the government um sort of wasting taxpayers money um so uh there was a period um

when things started to turn ugly online um there was a period of silence um and uh you know a vacuum like that obviously allows people to fill it with their own voices um And, you know, people began to sort of shift the issue towards their own agenda, which, you know, it seems there were two groups. There were people who had legitimate

concerns about a poor investment decision because Singapore Airlines has lost money through its Air India investment. There were people who were legitimately concerned about. you know, about this business that they're proud of losing money. And on the other hand, there was, you know, there was a group of people who were obviously very anti -Indian, if not anti -foreigner generally.

And, you know, they used it as an opportunity to cast a shadow over the Indian community in Singapore. And that's where the government... finally decided it was time to step in and try to get things under control. They promised to unmask the people who had been spreading, you know, rumours and racist insults. It's true that

those insults were repeated and somebody that I spoke to did make the point that that... That tends to worsen the situation when a government representative, you know, obviously he was not meaning it in the same way, but just by repeating those terms, it just continues the, it sort of perpetuates the problem. Yeah. Yeah, no, his heart was in the right place, no doubt. Well,

I guess, depending on your point of view. But it's kind of emblematic of, I think, the challenges that corporates... increasingly find themselves grappling with where you have more nationalism to contend with in different shapes and forms. Maybe you have more protectionism as well. In Singapore specifically, I think this has become more of an election issue. So this was actually raised in Parliament as well by an MP from the

Workers' Party. That helped to, I suppose, stoke. embers in this case, and then I believe the Business Times ran a story as well, which you wouldn't necessarily expect that to happen maybe 10, 20 years ago about a situation like this. So I think it does demonstrate how things have shifted, even in Singapore, which is not necessarily the most freewheeling place, but you can't keep a lid on this kind of stuff. Well, I mean, yes

i mean obviously the world has become more um protectionist generally uh and um you know there's um there is fear of there is you know economic insecurity everywhere including in singapore um and um so yeah it it's possible that it became it was a bigger issue than it would have been uh it became a bigger issue than it would have been a few years ago And yeah, it's easy to turn this sort of thing into an election issue. The

idea that, you know, foreign investments or just generally some vague foreign forces, as they're sometimes referred to, might be taking advantage of hardworking locals. So, I mean, it's likely to, perhaps in a different form, but... you know, we might expect this sort of thing to come up again around the election and, you know, and

it sort of suggests that Singapore has a job to do in reassuring people, perhaps reframing the idea of foreign investment and openness to the rest of the world as a positive thing, something that isn't to be feared. and something that's also necessary for the country to continue to be successful. Yeah, absolutely. Singapore's

so reliant on... Singapore's so reliant, isn't it, really, on foreign business. But definitely it's something that for corporate affairs, communications heads, they need to be increasingly aware of. If you're at an Indian company, for example, I think you probably need to be aware that... these kinds of forces and this kind of sentiment might exist. If you're at a domestic heavyweight, you need to be aware of how your foreign investments

are being assessed, especially if you're, you know, if you're taxpayer funded in any way, probably raises the stakes even more. And it's interesting because I was also in Singapore last week and I was at a couple of events where These kinds of issues were being discussed. The first was the Corporate Affairs Forum run by the PRCA, which was really quite focused on public affairs and geopolitics. And then we ran a roundtable

with Edelman on trust corridors, which specifically was looking at how trusted companies are when they expand beyond their home market and how that is influenced by their country of origin. by the sector, by the kind of protectionist sentiment on the ground in the destination market, by policy friction and so on. It's quite an interesting discussion. In a way, I suppose the Air India

Singapore Airlines story brings a lot of these things to life in terms of demonstrating how geopolitics is becoming a bigger and bigger concern. for corporate affairs heads? I would say it certainly does. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, but the question is whether it will actually deter businesses from investing or from being active in the market.

You know, will businesses actually be put off by sort of hostile voices in the market? And, you know, I think there's optimism that they won't. But I don't know. I don't know what you think. I'm interested to hear your point of view on that. I suspect it's already happening in some markets. I think Singapore in general, though,

because it's such an open and, you know, overall welcoming. for foreign business, and indeed it's a very active foreign investor in different countries around the world. I suspect Singapore is more towards one end of the spectrum. But there are other countries, including Asian countries, where that's not the case, where they have far more protectionist policies, where they have a more, let's say, open political landscape in which...

you know politicians and different political parties can make capital uh out of these kinds of things and that will have an influence on on the policy environment as well right i mean just you know you look at look at a company like tiktok or bite dance for example and the decisions it has made in terms of you know where it's open where it's not open um you look at the i mean you're in japan and uh The relationship between Japan and China is always interesting in this

regard. I feel like we've been talking and writing about this stuff for decades now. You'll remember the bowing lions or whatever it was back in the day. There's always some flare -up, right? And we're at a point now where I don't think relations are that great. No, they're not, right? In fact, we even talked, I think we talked, you may have even written about this. last year, or earlier this year, in fact, about another flare -up in

Japan -China relations and how that's impacting corporates. So I feel like it does have some impact, especially in Japan, you're seeing more protectionism in terms of the new, not so new anymore, but the political leadership. China also is a more insular place now. Do you feel that way from a Japanese perspective? I mean, I think, well, Japan is missing out on Chinese

tourism, certainly because the government has dissuaded people from visiting Japan. The Chinese government has. The Chinese government has quite actively. put people off, even if it hasn't actually banned people outright from visiting. People have had, you know, calls apparently saying that they should rethink their travel plans if they're

planning to go to Japan. So this sort of thing will obviously, you know, this will be felt in Japan, considering how many Chinese tourists. the country has had over the recent years, how big a group of tourists they've been. But in terms of protectionism in Japan, I don't know if I would call it protectionist, but there's certainly the government has sort of instilled a new sense of caution when it comes to letting

people into the country. So it's more an immigration issue. I think it's a bit less to do with... businesses, although there might be some sort of higher hurdles for business in Japan. And some sectors. I think that was one of the interesting points in the Edelman research is it can be very sector dependent. So I know Japan, for example, has a new energy policy, right? And that's being watched quite closely in terms of what that means for foreign investors. So it all adds up. I think

it all adds. a certain amount of risk and complexity to the ease of doing business. And that can add up and that can have an impact, especially in countries that are reliant on international, whether it's international investment coming in or on expanding beyond their home markets. You also wrote earlier this year about all the Chinese brands that are going global over the

last couple of years. and that's i think a really interesting one because um they've kind of you know for the most part they're avoiding the us yeah uh so but they've uh had real success in europe um but uh the us is obviously very difficult uh as a place to do business with if you're chinese if you're a chinese company um but the interesting thing is um that these government policies are quite different to they don't reflect the feeling

of consumers um so yeah uh oh i mean sometimes they do but i think where where chinese companies are concerned um there's a real openness to um chinese products now chinese brands you know they're often seen as um being high quality um product quite desirable products which is it is quite a big change um yeah absolutely even in india where you know, still certain Chinese

products and services are banned effectively. Chinese mobile phones are still, you know, rated quite highly here. And you would have thought by now some of this sentiment would have kind of filtered down to consumers, but it's not really the case. So you do kind of wonder how, yeah, how detached it all is from everyday life. It's an interesting one definitely to keep an eye on, but certainly it's something for public affairs

and comms heads to be aware of. So next, let's talk about MasterCard. Let's talk about an American company. And I don't know if you had been following their global pitch, which has more or less, more or less. reached a resolution over the last few weeks. I think you've certainly followed it more closely than I have. I'm aware of it. But, I

mean, why have they... I mean, what's behind it all? I think, well, as always, there's the stated reasons and then perhaps the kind of maybe some of the... some forces behind the scenes. I think what they have said publicly is, you know, that they're trying to become a different type of company, a technology company, you know, an enabler of different kinds of things. They've

always been leaning, I think, into this payment technology, but now they're kind of saying we're even, we're sort of beyond that, just technology in general. And whether you believe that or not is, I suppose, Up to you, but that was the sort of rationale. I think it's also, though, influenced by, as always with these cases, by the change of personnel on the client side. The CMO, who also heads comms, is a relatively new person,

Jill Kramer, and she succeeded Rajamannar, who was there for 14 years. And so often when you have a new person in that role, they want to leave there in premature on agency relationships. It had been a Ketchum client for a long time, a key Ketchum client, but that's all changed. I think what is really interesting here, though, is that from what I understand, the initial rounds

of the pitch did include the kind of traditional. global pr networks um uh you know in in keeping with um mastercard's uh existing agency roster which is is ketchum and i think also weber shandwick and parts of the world but in the final round it was um according to our reporting anyway it was we communications and allison neither of

whom you would say In a global pitch of this kind of magnitude, you wouldn't necessarily say you would have seen them in the final rounds maybe 10, 15 years ago. And I think that reflects how the market has changed and how the momentum is shifting towards independents and maybe mid -sized players as well. And why? Do you have a sense of why that is? Why it's shifting? I think we've covered... This shift in reasonable

detail, and I'm sure others have as well, but we've looked at the consolidation, at the big networks. Holding groups have not had the best of times in recent years. They've been outgrown by independents. In some cases, they've been out -innovated and out -performed. I think scale... is far less of an advantage as it used to be so you can be a mid -sized network like a wii

which is not present in many of the markets that you know one of the big networks is in but it can still handle a global account these days because of you know you don't need a flag in every market and then of course you look at ketchum which was the incumbent and you know now it's golden ketchum so it's part of it's a very different thing to what it was so again i think all these changes um have added up i think there's been

quite a big exodus of talent from the bigger networks and that has maybe played to the uh to the that has maybe played out to the benefit of you know more more independent or mid -sized more agile players so yeah it's it's quite interesting from that perspective and i think it's a good example maybe of how the market is shifting it's also just really rare though to see a global pr pitch i mean well i was gonna say yeah yeah

it's it's so rare and i i'm always wary of saying this because you know maybe we're just not doing as good a job of reporting them as we once did um but they used to be you know, three or four of these a year at least, where you'd have a big global company, okay, often US headquartered, making a global decision on its PR agency. And that is quite rare now. That is quite rare. And even in this case with MasterCard, it's not clear how this new relationship with We will play out

in, for example, Asia Pacific, where MasterCard has Archetype, and in the Middle East, where We doesn't. even have a presence it operates through affiliate partners um and you you wonder about the clients at mastercard at a local and regional level if they are necessarily on board with this kind of a shift because i think that's one of the biggest reasons in in terms of why we don't see as many global pr pitches because

i think local clients now are much more resistant um to being dictated to by hq right um so there's tension between uh well i'm not sure i'd i'd go that far i'm sure they all get along really well um but there's definitely uh more more empowerment at a local level And I think that has been a

strategy from HQ as well for many of these companies. They've recognized they're more effective when they give their local clients more autonomy. So, yeah, it's a really rare one, but well done to we, I would say, for winning it, because if there is one and you're in it, I mean, you might as well win it. And, yeah, it's got to be a real boost for them. And for them, they haven't had the easiest of times in the U .S. over the last couple of years because, you know, we as a very

tech -focused agency and it hasn't been very easy in terms of technology PR spending. So good luck to them and we will watch MasterCard. I think it will be very interesting to see how it does unfold in terms of different relationships. In general, big brands like Mastercard, we can say they're looking for more flexibility. And also, is it fair to say looking for perhaps a more creative approach than they might be able

to find at a very large network? I think every client will say it once, more flexibility and more creativity. I would be wary of concluding you can't get that from a bigger network. I think maybe you can't get it as often as you used to. And maybe, you know, the strength of networks is not what it once was. We've seen that in Asia,

right? I can remember a time when, you know, you wouldn't get fired basically for hiring the big network. I can recall people used to say that about Ogilvy PR. But, you know, those days have changed. You see so many strong domestic firms. You see all these midsize networks. You see homegrown players from places like Singapore who've built, you know, who've got offices in multiple markets now. So, yeah, I think, I just

think that there's many more options now. And I think clients are far more willing to shop around. And clients, let's segue to our next one. Clients themselves are changing quite a lot. You wrote earlier this year about a Wall Street Journal article, which I thought was a little bit giddy in its depiction of the ascent of CCOs in the C -suite. And I think, what was

it? How publicists conquered the C -suite. Was that the headline? Something like that. Anyway, we have an article that's come out this week from Fortune, really well -researched and investigated piece. I'd recommend everyone reads it. We'll put it in our newsletter as well. And it's looking at OpenAI's protracted search for a CCO, which has been going on now for nine months, which Fortune says is an eternity in comms terms. I'm

inclined to agree. It is quite a long time. But the last line is really something to behold in the Fortune story. I'll read it out here. Quelling fears of human extinction is quite the job description, but it will presumably be a core responsibility for OpenAI's future communications leader if and when the company hires one. It's a very good story because not only does it go into just the nuts and bolts of why OpenAI has been unable

to find the right comms candidate. It also looks at questions about the reporting line of the candidate, which honestly is really good because you don't expect this stuff from like a generalist business magazine. And then it looks at the reputation problems that the AI sector is facing in general, which we've discussed at length and which are becoming, you know, which just seem to get worse every day. Right. In terms of, you know, we've seen. We've all seen these interviews of people who have left the AI companies. We see interviews

of people who are still at the AI companies, and they don't necessarily help either. I mean, Fortune makes the point that this could be, you know, this is probably the biggest comms challenge in the world right now, and also a life -changing amount of money in terms of salary, which no doubt it will be, you know, if OpenAI is going to list and all of that. But yeah, they've been unable to find their candidate. And what really struck me actually was that one of the things they mentioned was because it's been going on

a while, they're now starting to reconsider the reporting line. So maybe the CCO should report to, I think it's Sam, not Sam Altman, but his partner, I think it's Greg Brockman. Or maybe, yeah, he's the president and co -founder. who's the one who's leading the hiring. So I think that was the initial thinking. But then the suggestion also is that the CCO should report to the CMO,

which will come as, yes, not something, especially for those of us that rejoiced when we read the Wall Street Journal article. This will perhaps... maybe pour some cold water on some of that. But I think it's quite a realistic depiction of some of the conversations that are going on inside big companies. So, yeah, what did you make of it all? Yes, well, the Wall Street Journal article

that came out in June, I think it was, it did seem a bit breathless, all about the ascent of the CCO. And it gave some, you know, it did give some examples of where chief communications officers have risen and they're reporting directly to the CEO. And it is, you know, it's true that comms is becoming, it's, you know, seen as more

strategic. But that rise is, you know, it's still unsteady and it's very patchy. I think there's real confusion. In terms of who these people should report to, as we've seen with this OpenAI story, they report to various people. Yeah, sometimes the CMO. I think in some recent research, our

PR 2030 research, we found just over half report to the CEO. um yeah which could be seen as good you know it depends yes exactly it's classic glass half full or half empty i i suspect most people wouldn't see it that positively given it's 2026 and i mean you still have 50 of ccos that don't report to the ceo yeah yeah but um

but i mean in terms of um that that particular story about open ai i mean obviously ai companies uh can function as somebody in the article made the point uh you know open ai can function perfectly well without um a chief communications officer uh it's not going to stop what it's doing uh but um ai companies are especially prone to crises and issues um plus um it's not just about fighting fires but there's just this shadow of negativity

around AI which is it just seems to always be there you know as as you said you know fear of extinction you know it's not a lot of cheery thought so there's a lot for anyone in that role to do and you would imagine that there are lots of people out there who would be up for the challenge so I don't know whether it's a case of OpenAI just not finding someone with the right capabilities?

Or if really people are just too afraid to take on that challenge? I don't know. Yeah, it's hard to say. I think it's probably a combination of both. I mean, the article does point out that the first choice for the role was Jill Hazelbaker, who is a very well -known name in the comms world and is considered one of the top operators. um works at uber um there's a great quote actually

i'm going to try and find it in the story about chill from a from a friend no a source familiar with the search um oh no no those who know her list a few reasons she may have turned it down i love the sourcing here i always love it where it's Someone who knows someone. And as reporters, you always wonder, is that the person themselves? Is it someone else? Anyway, the quote is, Jill

is absolutely fantastic, said another source who has spoken directly with OpenAI about the position and who commented on the likely reasons the company has not been able to hire her. She's very mature. She has an awesome relationship with Dara, the Uber CEO. this is my favorite she makes a fuckload of money also she lives on the east coast and has a family it's really hard to get her because she lives in dc and she's

not going to move all good reasons and um i certainly think given where she's at and probably what she's seen at uber you can maybe understand Maybe not wanting to go back into the absolute hottest furnace around at the moment. The reputation issues facing AI, as you described, a shadow, they're not going to go away. It looks like they're

going to get worse. We have so many questions now about data centers as well. Absolutely. OpenAI wants to list, so that's going to, you know, that just... kind of elevates all of these concerns as a material risk. So you sort of think they need to find someone sooner rather than later, but yeah, they have quite a big team and they seem to be doing, as the article suggests, maybe

a better job. But yeah, it's a good example, I think, of some of the forces we're seeing more broadly across the industry. It's still... i think a bit difficult for the comms function to always effectively demonstrate where it should sit to whom it should report uh the value it brings um i was at a thing last week where someone asked you know is the fact that people still ask the fact that uh tesla doesn't have a comms

head or elon musk doesn't have a comms head is that is that evidence that comms heads are not needed um which you know i think is kind of a ridiculous question but if people are asking it it's not that ridiculous so um so yeah it's an interesting one to watch and i just hope for the reporter's sake um they don't hire someone next week because that's always what you worry about with these kinds of stories as well um

but yeah good story Worth reading. And on that note, I think perhaps we will end this podcast. So what have we got to say? We've got Praxis India. That will have happened by the time this episode comes out this weekend. We've got Praxis Asia Pacific in Singapore in two weeks. So if you're listening and you're in Singapore or you'd like to travel to Singapore. please come to the national gallery on 7th of october we have a

great lineup um and yeah we have lots of research and all the usual stuff on our website um so thanks david for your time today and um thank you big thanks as always to our production partners at earshot media

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Kaizzen’s Vineet Handa on monetisation, Middle East expansion and AI enemies

    Oct 30, 202637 minAudio

    Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jean-Léopold Schuybroek: Four decades of building independent PR

    Oct 13, 202625 minAudio

    Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why corporate affairs pros want change, with GlobeScan's Chris Coulter

    Aug 24, 202636 minAudio

    GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Culture, Cannes & cockroaches with Charlotte Mceleny

    Jul 30, 202647 minAudio

    Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Cannes: Chris Foster on creative shifts, earned momentum and acquisition lessons

    Jul 1, 202628 minAudio

    Earned First's Cannes podcast series concludes with Omnicom PR CEO Chris Foster, who joins Arun Sudhaman for a wide-ranging conversation about creativity, culture, CCOs and consolidation. Foster reflects on what he sees...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode