Culture, Cannes & cockroaches with Charlotte Mceleny
47 minAudio
Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to GEO and AI search's parallels with early SEO, before closing on the Gen Z-led political movements reshaping communications across Asia.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Earned First podcast. My name is Arun Sudhaman. I'm the founding editor of Earned First. I'm very happy to be joined again today by Charlotte Mceleny, freelance journalist. Charlotte, how are you? I'm good. Glad to be back. Thanks for having me back. It's always nice to be welcome back. Can't have done a terrible job last time. You did an amazing job last time, as I think you're probably aware. We're kind of entering, I guess we're getting towards the
dog days of summer. Yeah. Where typically, you know, we are looking for stories, but I don't know if that still exists anymore because it feels like there's a lot happening regardless of time of year. Yeah. In today's crazy world. It just doesn't get quiet in this summer period. In trade journalism, the only time it kind of gets quiet is like the Christmas period, I think.
It's the only time it still happens, but it did used to happen over the summer and it just, you'd have Cannes and then you'd have this like quiet period for maybe four to six weeks. That's kind of summer holiday, kids on holiday phase. And it just, yeah, it doesn't happen anymore. Yeah, you mentioned the C word. So let's talk about Cannes. Let's get into it. I mean, it's been a month now. It's been more than a month. And it's interesting because I think we may have
somewhat different perspectives because you were not there and I was there. And I sometimes feel like you can get a better view of Cannes if you don't go, oddly enough, because you're so focused on your kind of little... niche um or area of operations during the week and there's so much going on in can now i mean that was my biggest takeaway this year other than um the heat which
was you know oppressive and punishing my biggest takeaway was just how expanded it has become even in a year when i think numbers were not quite as healthy as perhaps the Cannes Lions organizers would have hoped for. I think entry numbers were down and attendance probably followed a similar trend. But even with those caveats,
it was still massively busy. But just this expansion, this proliferation. of the program beyond the Palais into just ever more villas and, and, you know, I feel like the geography of it, the geography, it's almost like it's kind of colonizing neighboring towns now. That's crazy. It is crazy. So many people I spoke to this year didn't even stay
in Cannes because of the pricing and, you know, availability. of accommodation um and there is there is some talk afoot that that they may look to move can um and and also move the time of year to uh to try and avoid the heat and also make it a bit more manageable but you know who knows because one of the things i think driving um that expansion though uh which i think is we should talk about perhaps first and foremost
um was just how many creators are on the Quazette now. Of course, there's a new category in the Cannes Lions that awards creator -focused work. But it's creators everywhere. I first noticed it, I think it might have been last year or two years ago when I went to one of the Spotify events and I ended up, you know, it was in one of these villas where you have to get a car. And I ended up in a car with five people who were all extremely
young, young Americans. And, you know, we started, of course, we started talking to each other and it became very clear very quickly that we really didn't have much in common. And that's really the first time that had happened to me in Cannes, where there was kind of, there wasn't really a sort of shared lingua franca. between us which is not necessarily a bad thing um but it really brought it home to me that the complexion of the festival is changing and that has only accelerated
uh to the point that this year i think you know creators were not only everywhere in can but you know on many stages at many events and increasingly increasingly dominating the work as well Yeah, I was trying to think when I last went, I think it was two years ago. And it did feel like it was starting to happen then, particularly where you saw the media companies that are kind of
creator adjacent, they would bring them as talent. And you've always had companies bring talent to kind of prove the conversations that they're kind of talking about. but it felt it did feel from afar at least that that's changed from oh this is our creator talent to there's a structural level of the creator ecosystem that kind of has to be here almost like it's like you've got your agencies you've got your tech platforms you know it's like and then there's the creators um my
favorite piece of writing that i think again from afar wasn't there that i i read and just really really enjoyed that helped me kind of unpick that because i think you're on linkedin and you see a lot of people talking about some of this and sometimes it's a bit cynical because it's that whole you know is can dying is creativity gone kind of thing and so it's very difficult to read some of that without that eye roll and being like it's a bit cynical but Eugene Healy was my favourite kind of person to take this
on because he's also sat on both sides he was an agency strategist and now he's kind of become a creator so it's like he could balance those two things and the kind of agency strategist part of him did respect the fact that you know the shame of can changing is in not really bringing the young people of the industry in to kind of teach them about the the craft and the award wins and things like that like that's what kind
of can and it's you know the thing that we bemoan as having gone as being excellent and some agencies do still have really rigorous competitions around kind of young talent and things like that so it's not good that's not completely dead but I think that he talked a little bit about that and how that's a bit of a challenge we need to kind of keep bringing the young talent into these things um but the flip side of his piece was about the kind of gentrification element that the creators kind of brought um which i quite liked um and just showing that this sort of creator
industry had become so developed and matured that this was the kind of signaling of that um that it was you know not only that it had matured but that had therefore got the attention of the c -suite and the businesses and the cmos and kind of all of that stuff um and particularly one piece of content that he talked about that i i really thought was quite important in this conversation was um it was the creator effectiveness playbook that was by system one and i think he
had um he had some some involvement in it And they were basically looking at creator work and their kind of key takeaway was this idea that engagement rates have zero correlation to remembering a brand. So it was this real challenge of like how we think about creator work, how we think about anything related to sort of earned media in that sense when it comes to sort of creators and the measurement of engagement rates or attention being not the key measurement. It's we've got to think about how brands stick in your memory.
which I just thought was really interesting because it it brings creator into this space of okay how does it sit next to other channels and how does it kind of intertwine how does it become an ecosystem and it's not just like this sort of you know we we pay some influences and we get some hits and and there it goes so there was this really interesting conversation alongside the just the presence of the creators but it was this kind of growing up of creators um or at least that's what i i kind of saw from the outside maybe that wasn't as it's easy for me
to say again like you said that kind of umbrella view of like reading everything afterwards um maybe on the ground it didn't feel like that was the topic but um i think that would be the interesting lesson of like now that can's done this is i think potentially where this conversation goes um and i think it's particularly interesting for for comes pr people because it kind of comes back into that whole conversation of you know we really have to understand where the measurement of our work fits into the wider picture of kind
of building a brand and um and kind of business metrics um yeah i don't know if you saw it was like a conversation on the ground or is that is that something that's just kind of been pulled out afterwards no i think that is part of it certainly the conversation around metrics um and around being able to prove return on investment. But then in the comms world, that's always a conversation. So I think they are maybe a little more, I don't want to say comfortable with that,
but they're a little more used to it, maybe resigned to it compared to people on the marketing side of the equation. I think there's a couple of things specifically on creators, well, more than a couple of things. And you've referenced some of them already. But the first is I think there's, you know, it kind of reflects to an extent a democratization of creativity at its best, let's say, which is not necessarily a bad thing, I
feel. And, you know, when we're talking about, especially when we're talking about, we have to talk about culture, another C word. Because that was, along with AI, I'd probably say it was the two most talked about topics during the week. You know, you couldn't move without someone talking about how important culture is. And I don't want to sound cynical after what you just said, but we've seen so many words lose all meaning.
thanks to their overuse and, you know, thanks to their kind of, the way they're becoming incorporated into marketing jargon. And I do fear that will happen with culture. But creators, and, you know, Eugene Healy mentioned this as well in his piece, creators are a really visible part of that shift towards culture. They're seen as being... however you describe them as immersed in culture or intermediaries
or in some cases gatekeepers or facilitators enablers um and of course that you know that shift from uh institution to individual um which i know you you have um talked about is you know kind of exemplifies this i feel so i think that the creator Well, like with anything in Cannes, it wasn't about one particular thing. It was
sort of multifaceted. You know, I heard some people saying that they were moving away from creators. So I even kind of heard about a creator backlash in Cannes. So it's like, you know, it really is. It's a fully 360 view of creators. I think in this part of the world, though. I don't think we're seeing so much of a backlash because I do think, you know, brands here are still getting to grips with just the whole notion
of letting go of their messaging and, you know, it requires to really become adept, I think, at creator marketing and also to kind of deploy creators in service of broader cultural goals. I think you have to let go and lose a certain measure of control, which I think maybe is something that for companies in this part of the world is still something they're getting used to. There
was actually a quote in that, Eugene, he did a sub stack on his take away from Cannes. And there was a quote that I really loved where he basically said. i think it was like creators are not the future of marketing but he was saying they're the best example of what the future of marketing will look like and then he referenced some attributes so it's like decentralized always on and then built from the bottom up through kind of culture and it was like they're what wider marketing should sort of start to look at so i think that that kind of gets to your
point right of it it's like they sort of represent a bigger thing for us practitioners um that things are changing um and yeah and i think it's just like and specifically for kind of comms and pr people it's how trust we always think about trust in these kind of institutions and that's kind of shifting into kind of networks and individuals and it's becoming a lot more personal like the big takeaway from the edelman edelman trust barometer this year was the sort of insularity of people and how we look to to others so i think we've
got to kind of rethink how trust is moving between people between institutions and different things and i think um i think i think that's really making businesses look up and and kind of think everything that we've been doing is potentially changing and and i'm not sure how to understand it and maybe creators at the moment is the shortcut but actually our whole kind of marketing mix and our approach to marketing kind of has to change i don't know it's interesting that the edelman trust barometer i think doesn't measure
creators yet um but it does measure you know maybe maybe proxies um that it measures i think you know people like me which i think is maybe a proxy i don't know if you could argue creators are not necessarily especially now um certain types of creators anyway although one thing that's really clear is that the the even within creators there's so many um uh shades and stripes and types yeah um from you know the nano influencer
all the way to you know the the mr beasts and so on um yeah so that that in itself is is something that i think probably corporates are grappling with and then in this part of the world i do think that shift from institution to individual will be a more difficult uh pill to digest i think because um oh this is this region is complicated anyway yeah exactly adding this onto it you know
it is yeah but it's this is a more you know in many societies in asia it is more it can be a bit more conservative and a bit more um traditional um but of course it's interesting that we talk about creators and we sometimes make the mistake And I'm sure a lot of businesses do this as well, right, is looking at them as a replacement for media channels. And we think of them in the same way when they're not really. No, they serve different
purposes. I think this is part of the kind of growing up of the approach to it or the necessary kind of growing up around the approach. I also think this is I think one of the topics we're going to kind of dive into is. it comes people kind of growing their influence in the C -suite. And I think business is kind of grappling with this role and how does it replace this? How does that relate to traditional comms and PR? How does it relate to my investor relations? How
does it relate to this and this kind of shift? I think all of these changes is kind of making the role of the comms person quite intrinsic to kind of future strategy, which is obviously great for our practitioners in theory. But I think it's born from some of this kind of trend towards all these shifts coming together at once. It's a lot for businesses to figure out. Indeed, and just the preeminence of trust amidst all
of this. Because I think if we're talking about Cannes in particular, so I will say I'd never seen more marketers talk about trust as I did this year. and reputation. So these have suddenly become, you know, important issues for marketers. And geopolitics. I saw and heard marketers talking about geopolitics, which is not something I would
have seen five years ago. So these issues have become, you know, clearly on the marketing agenda. You know, we know they're on the C -suite agenda. And so by implication, it should reinforce the case for comms leaders, CCOs to be, or however you put it, taken more seriously, at the top table. There's so many phrases you can use. But
just more instrumental, more valuable, seen as drivers of value rather than just as centers of cost. Just before Cannes, there was the article in the Wall Street Journal, which wasn't necessarily helpfully headlined. I think it was publicists are storming the C -suite, something along those lines, which I don't think anyone really likes the term publicist. But the article itself was
very much about how commerce people are now taken more seriously. I had my reservations about that article. I thought it was somewhat narrow in its scope. I didn't think, you know, like many of these articles, it was focused on certain cases in particular. I don't know, maybe I'm sounding a bit churlish about it. But it's, you know, you could see the response on LinkedIn from the comms world. It was like... their prayers
had been answered i kind of to see how many people had you know were reposting it and you know all of the preach and all of this it's interesting because it's been a topic we know it's been a topic for a long time i think because we're in that world and it's just i think when you see it kind of hit more of a industry or mainstream than our you know your needs i think there's something quite validating in that um i mean the overall stat that i pulled from that i think
it was like i don't know they only looked i think fortune 500 companies or something i think in the stats but it was like nearly half of the ccos directly reported into the ceo or something in whatever sort of stat they'd chosen which i thought was interesting that's right so i think that was one of my other reservations with that article which is that it it's it built heavily on the corn ferry study yes which, well, I would just say there are other studies available out
there. And I would encourage anyone who really wants to get a good understanding of this area to read Korn Ferry, to read Globescan, to read Page. And that's just to name three. There are several others. There's the Deloitte one that's just come out in the last month, I think, which I think is very good as well. but yes you're right it's validating and there was definitely a feeling in can you know we did a number of events with ccos it was a feeling that they their
time had had maybe arrived um in a way that it hadn't before certainly in from a can perspective they would take it more seriously you know adweek had a big session on ccos i know i'm sure at least part of that is commercially driven but um again it is validating and it is nice to hear that ccos are important and are drivers of strategic value um and and that for me was also one of the the more interesting threads to emerge from
from can this year i think it's it's all progress in the right direction let's say i think there will be many many challenges facing cco still to come again it comes down to the trust thing doesn't it I think that just feels like the theme to me because I think it's and particularly for I think the other validating part of this is you know that's been such a strategic pillar of what comms and PR professionals have talked about for so long that I think it's not only am I viewed as more important within my peers
but the sort of strategic foundation by which I do everything is now you know more important as well so I think there's like a few parts of this that you kind of go I've been saying, you know, it's that like, I told you. Yeah, I've been saying this. My worldview, my worldview is finally being taken seriously. Yeah. But the risk, of course, is always that it won't just be taken seriously. It will be taken. I mean, that is, I think that is something we can't ignore. I feel we've seen it before. The tension between
comms, marketing. and and sometimes other functions and you know I think sometimes in the trades we can all get a little bit reductive about this stuff and you know we're looking for tension we're looking for these these battles it's it's good copy it's good headlines it's not always doesn't always reflect the reality I think sometimes these things this is how they have to happen ultimately you you would know this I'm sure having worked on both sides of the fence Yeah, well, one thing I think I did pick up from the Wall
Street Journal piece, Katie's piece, was she used an example in there of Hinge. And it was the elevation of one of the marketers there. And she made sure that in her job title, it was marketing and comms. And it was kind of just sort of explain how important comms was. But the flip side of that is that that person holds both. Right. So instead of either or, actually, the reality of that is that. you know as a brand they've gone these two things are important together so i think yeah to your point sometimes we can
pit these things against each other but actually the reality of most day -to -day in businesses is that both of those things play alongside each other should play alongside each other as kind of pals alongside other parts of business as well of course yeah yeah and I mean, you have hybrid functions, of course. Sometimes you have comms reporting into marketing as well. I mean, you very rarely, if not never, have marketing reporting into comms. But sometimes when I talk
to comms people about this, it's just very simple. It's very pragmatic. They're not interested in fighting battles that they can't win. And they've got to focus their time on energy, on more realistic. endeavors and you can't blame them for that no i don't think then that brings us to another topic i know we wanted to talk about so it's the question i have is is you know ai search a battle that pr can win so this is the next
battleground that is the next battleground yeah well i'm curious to hear your thoughts definitely on this From what I hear, obviously, when it became clear that if it really is clear, I still hear people saying it's not that clear. But let's assume that it's clearer that geo AI platforms are more influenced by earned media and maybe
owned media and definitely not by paid media. So then, according to that. which by now is like, you know, this is sort of accepted wisdom, I think. Then, you know, presumably that makes the comms function even more important, you know, helps them attribute their work. But it's very, you know, it's somewhat reminiscent of the whole SEO debate. And you would know better than most people what happened there. I recall comms people,
you know, similar kind of. of sentiment you know this is this is our time because seo is driven so much by editorial results but actually it was it didn't happen it didn't play out in that way not the way that they expected it to no because it got technical and you could game the system and then it became i mean it's interesting because it's almost the I think, again, it's like this redemption hug for PR people and this concept
of trust because actually SEO became something really not trustworthy, right? It's like if you do this trick, you do this trick, you do this trick, you can say, you know, game the system. Very much not about editorial. It's quite the opposite. And I remember being a young journalist like 15 years ago and we used to hate it. We'd occasionally get these. um kind of seo agencies popping up and being like oh you wrote about our client can you give us a link here and i'd be like absolutely not and you know they'll be really trying to get you oh my god haven't they
learned journalists don't do that um yeah crazy and it just would be like a huge bugbear of ours and we would almost like blacklist certain companies if it happened more than once because it would be like they've done it again um yeah but yeah these sort of tricks and tricks and whatnot um but yeah i think that with the the wisdom we seem to have at the moment and i do think there's still a black box element to this um is that it's really taking third party signals um not
necessarily your own home page but that i think it still does take some home page stuff depending on what it is and whatnot but it's not the press release it's like it has to come from coverage of the press release and that's the wisdom that we have so in theory that gives a much more strategic strength to PR and comms but there are still technical elements to this and particularly in kind of the measurement of this and how it relates
to other parts so I'm such a boring hedger of these opinions but like we said before it's the kind of working together on this. um and i do think it is the two working together i i mean maybe you can have someone slightly take the lead but you're not going to be able to do geo properly just singularly as pr or just you know as because there's all sorts of other elements that you would want to be you know you would also want to be understanding if that has contributed
to website traffic uplift and other elements and has it increased other brand metrics and elements that you were kind of looking at what how does it relate to different things so these these conversations do not exist in a vacuum um but you could arguably have pr kind of taking the lead on the strategic element of this or you know having arguing for a bit more budget is probably where this is probably at least in the short short term going yeah and you can i mean you can make the case i think you can make
a reasonable case that pr people and would would understand the earned media aspects of this better than anyone. But having said all that, and this is purely anecdotal, my conversations with comms people in -house suggest that marketing is taking a keen interest in GEO and in several cases that I've heard about are taking the lead. And that...
i don't know if i wouldn't say it alarms me nothing really alarms me anymore but um it does feel maybe like it's a missed opportunity um but then the other thing of course that i also find is sometimes i find that comms people in -house are still not as up to date on on some of these trends as um as they should be uh and i think that's a big challenge too That's their own missed opportunity, isn't it? Because if you've got
a kind of digitally savvy, well, if your digital marketer is no doubt well up on this. So you're kind of inherently against someone who, as a personality, is just probably quite embedded in all of this. So as a comms person, you have to really, I mean, there's a lot of technical, impressive comms people out there. But they are, everyone I've met that fits into that personality is owning GEO. Like, you know, they already are.
But maybe they're a sort of rarer breed than your kind of general digital marketers who are kind of all over this anyway. The one thing that kind of comes to me is you're talking about like the lessons from SEO, but it also reminds me of the kind of social media turf war that we had as well, right? Like social media came up. You can forget it. yeah and and the answer to that has kind of ended up being a bit of both or it depends you know paid has obviously gone in the paid camp and is in the earned camp and
it's then you've also obviously got your social specialists in between community managers it's kind of it became so big that that it's kind of split between different elements but that was a conversation at the beginning of social as well you know the pr agencies were taking there but everyone had their kind of different perspective on it so i i feel like to say it's another deja vu to me i i actually do think social was a missed opportunity for the comms world not in the sense that they could own it or take
it over or any of these things but i don't think they made as much of that opportunity as they could have It was slow. It was slow. It was digitizing the industry. It was an industry that wasn't especially digital at that point, 15, almost coming up to 20 years ago now. Realizing how long we've been doing this. Yeah, I know. But, you know, I still come across some firms that
are still not especially digital. And you kind of knew that would happen. You knew some firms would get there quicker. But I don't think any of us thought 20 years later we'd still be talking about it, especially certain types of work, I suppose. Well, I don't think the PR and comms world really convinced us on the strategic side of the social argument. I think it was like, OK, you can do X, Y, Z or execute on that. But
I think like if you look at what's happening with GEO, I do think that the jumping on it is faster because. the the that strategic angle on trust again that our sort of common thread here um is so strong and so obvious that i think that that's like that it's it's very clear but also i do think beyond comms people are making a better go at that um but that the trust theme could have been the strategic argument for social as well right because it's like if we understand you know trust from a media and comms and you
know this this this angle we can apply that to again the other theme of today which is this kind of switch from institutional trust into kind of net trust in networks or individuals and it's almost like that trend which started with social and is now kind of completely scaled and kind of gone wild with AI is finally dawning on slash you know there's that redemption arc again for PR people it's you know They can own
that trust conversation. But they could have owned that 15, 20 years ago as well. But now's the time. I think so. Now's the time. There's no time like now. I do think probably one thing we should say about social is I'm not sure anyone anticipated how quickly it would move away from, you know, earned peer -to -peer communication. to being dominated by the platforms um and you
know the impact of algorithms and and paid uh and that shift you i mean you recall the whole facebook zero thing when that happened it did kind of move away a little bit from perhaps what people envisaged yeah um to be fair but if we're talking more broadly i guess about this shift from institutions to individuals and about the corresponding importance of culture then i guess
we have to talk about the big political story of the moment in asia which is here in india the the rise of the cjp the cockroach junta party i hate cockroaches so much um it just it bothers me even saying their name that's how I mean, I live in Singapore. Yeah, I know. They're around. Yeah, I remember I moved into, when we moved to Singapore 20 years ago, we moved into a flat
and we, I remember the first day we went into the kitchen and it was just, there was just cockroaches everywhere. So this is kind of like one of my recurring nightmares. But anyway, I mean, it's just been. It's been really interesting. It's been fascinating to watch it unfold here because you're kind of aware, I think just having lived here now for three years, you're aware of the context. You can't divorce it from the, you can't
divorce any of these movements, I think, from their context. You're aware of that. But yeah, from a comms perspective, I think it's really interesting because it does reflect, you know, on a very basic level, if we're talking about culture, it's a really good example of how individuals are different from institutions. Because for an individual, politics is part of their culture, perhaps. But for an institution, it always feels like a bit of a leap for them. I mean, some of
them can be political in different ways, but it's a more formal and sort of intentional. And particularly for young people. Because it's so born of Gen Z this, right? I think, yeah, I think that kind of, you know, being born in and among social media, I think that, you know, you're not as reliant on the institutions that we were reliant is in mainstream media or, you know, other things. I think there's an empowerment for Gen Z and, or want to, to sort of translate
it on it. So there's this sort of comms element of it, not just the, you know, the the reasons they're angry the reasons that they are sort of taking to this but it's like the the way in which they communicate that being through memes through through all of these elements is is so vastly different to how you or I might have done it when we were you know yeah um it's sort of fascinating but even even how institutions would
you know they just you know they wouldn't engage in these kinds of And so you can understand why this kind of movement becomes so popular, because it feels utterly authentic. The communications, and even calling it communications, feels a little bit detached, feels almost too formal. But the way they, you know, it started as a viral meme
account, as a joke. um it is is utterly immersed in gen z digital culture you know it's very pure from that perspective yeah have you ever looked at the labour party in the uk's instagram account um i haven't actually no tell me because they really specifically the labour party not um like the the number 10 or um either kirsten or andy
burnham so they all have like the different parts of their social media accounts but specifically the labor party they do lots of mean content lots and every time they post it there's always tons of people underneath going can you just fix the country and stop doing memes to your point it's like it really has to be born from a place of authenticity i think the labor part of your audience yeah doing this kind of meme -y meme -like and sort of anti -farage content
which you know some people find funny and you know gets engagement and it's not terrible content but it's just there's an element of that doesn't feel authentic to me because it's coming from the official Labour Party account that just gets pulled apart every time so yeah I think the the genesis of of that is so important like you know what it yeah the backstory the the authenticity because you can't really mimic it. No, you can't. But we're seeing this type of thing happen in
different places around the world. We're seeing these Gen Z political movements. Certainly in Asia, we've seen Bangladesh, we've seen Nepal, we've seen Sri Lanka, I think Kenya in Africa. And then, of course, you could probably make the case that Zoran Mamdani's election in New York owed much to this. it's kind of Gen Z groundswell in politics. And I mean, at the very least, I think a lot of people should be revisiting their
assumptions about, about younger people. Yeah. And in British politics, which I guess just sort of the flip side to the Labour Party argument I'm making is, I guess you've seen the success of Zach Polanski and the Green Party. They're incredibly good at getting him. into that kind of podcasty you know like space and and kind of giving his thoughts and it feels a little bit more from the heart um and you know particularly
for that section of kind of young british people i think that's kind of similar to mamdani i think there's a playbook i think there that that's starting to kind of surface um guy as well isn't it i think he's advising The same person, the same strategist who advised Mamdani is now crossed the pond and is advising the Greens. But yeah,
that's an interesting point as well, though. The authenticity takes different shapes. I mean, when Donald Trump won the election the second time, you know, there's so many think pieces about why he succeeded. One thing that kind of came back again and again was that his approach was quite authentic to who he is, much as it kind of pains us to hear this. He went on a lot of podcasts and was himself. And ultimately that
proved quite persuasive. I don't think we're definitely not seeing that yet with the CJP. I think for them, going on interviews is not necessarily especially authentic. They're like the next iteration almost, I feel. I don't know how to describe it, but you do get the sense that they feel that just dealing, definitely dealing with mainstream media is not worth their time. Yeah. Even use forms of it like a podcast
or whatever. But I also think that's probably because podcasts in this part of the world are just not as, I don't think they're, you know, they're also kind of co -opted. The biggest podcast in India, for example, I think he had Prime Minister Modi on for a three -hour conversation where he never challenged any of his claims. So the trust again is not there. Yes, we're back to it. Back, sorry. Yeah, but it's a really interesting
thing. definitely recommend people follow the cjp because even for corporates and brands and you know they all talk about we've how many conferences have we been to on gen z marketing um you this is where what's happening this is you know you can't find better case studies this guy as well abigit dipike from cjp i mean of course i would love to get him to come and speak to people at praxis or whatever i think he's probably got um bigger fish to fry right now But he is a comms
student. He was doing his master's or certainly a postgraduate degree in comms at Boston University. His mastery. Your point where it's intentional, isn't it? Even if it seems unintentional, there's kind of intention in the authenticity. There is a lesson in there. It's not just completely a kind of random. Yeah. No, correct. Interesting lessons, I think, for corporates, but also I
am not surprised. Some people here are surprised that corporates haven't got involved. They haven't said anything, you know, no messages of support, or at least, you know, at times like this, we should all come together. You know, nothing. There's been nothing at all. I'm not surprised in the slightest by this. Because I lived through Hong Kong and I had no expectations of brands. Are you at all surprised? I'm curious to get another view. I guess I am a little bit. But
then also not because I think it's a very APAC thing to not or Asia thing to not get involved. Whereas I think if this was happening in the UK or America, you'd have like. McDonald's in the chat the brands just aren't as as worried about especially if you can play with the fun of it there's like in other in other markets I think there's because there is a bit of silliness to it that I think even if you don't want to
kind of come out being really explicitly kind of political there's there's a part of that that you could could ride on um but i think that there's a hesitancy in a lot of apac markets to do that um in singapore sometimes you you see it with when it's slightly jovial um but if it's serious i don't you wouldn't really get get much going on um yeah i can't expect to hear because i mean and this is one of the you know one of the issues
we we actually wrote about it in our last newsletter but the you know that nexus between state power and um corporates is uh you know it's one of the things that the cjp is taking aim at so could get uncomfortable um but yeah it's it's fascinating to watch brings us back i think quite neatly to our point on you know that trust is is becoming more crucial that shift from institutions to
individuals is a big part of that But yeah, we've covered a lot of ground. I think I better let you go. I'm sure you have other things to do with your day. I feel like we could keep talking about culture and creators. I could talk about trust all day long, to be honest, though. But we have to stop at some point, if only for the listeners' sanity. If they're still listening. Charlotte, thank you so much, as always, for your time. I thought this was really... Yeah, it was just fun to discuss some of these topics.
So have a really good week. Yeah, thank you for having me again.
Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...
Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...
Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO...
GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...
Earned First's Cannes podcast series concludes with Omnicom PR CEO Chris Foster, who joins Arun Sudhaman for a wide-ranging conversation about creativity, culture, CCOs and consolidation. Foster reflects on what he sees...