Arun Sudhaman sits down in Dubai with The Romans’ MENA lead, Joe Lipscombe, to explore why the Middle East risks becoming a “margin outpost” - and how it can instead become a true centre of creative gravity. They discuss the indie invasion of the Gulf, why clients are “crying out” for bigger, braver ideas, the impact of localisation and the rise of Saudi Arabia, and what it really takes to be culture-first in fragmented markets like the UAE and across MENA.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Earned First podcast. This is Arun Sudharman, founding editor at Earned First. I'm very happy to be joined today in Dubai by Joe Lipscomb, who's the partner and head of MENA at The Romans. Welcome, Joe. Thanks, buddy. Good to be here. Thanks for having me. How are you doing today? Good. I'm good. What is the time here? We're recording this at 9 .30, Dubai. I'm sleep training six -month -olds, so I'm just
getting so much more done in my mornings, starting hours before. Yeah, I remember. I remember that period. Actually, I don't remember. I've completely blocked it out, but it's fun times, no doubt. So you've been with the Romans now for almost two years, is that right? Yeah, we did the sort of official, I suppose, relaunch of the Romans here on February 1, 2024. So we're about to hit
the Christmas holidays. So yeah, we're coming up in just under two years. Right, excellent. And of course, you were with Ogilvy for several years before that. And you were a journalist for a number of years before that. um you've been in the gulf for how long now i've been working in the region well i came out during the arab spring journalist so and i remember watching
the way the way i date this is i remember being in a hotel watching the tennis at wimbledon uh for the during the 2012 london olympics so that was my first year out here it was was uh summer 2012. oh wow okay so um Yeah, it's quite a while now. You've seen a lot, no doubt. We'll talk about some of the changes. So let's talk about the overall Middle East PR market to start off with, because there's a lot of interest in the
Middle East. It's been a tough year globally for the comms sector. I think it's probably safe to say. But the Middle East has been quite a positive story, something of a beacon of growth. So it feels like a market that is in reasonably good shape. But I've noticed in some of your LinkedIn posts and some of the other interviews you've done that this notion that perhaps the
market needs shaking up. Do you feel that that's something that you believe? Yeah. I think most industries can do with at least a portion of people. thinking about what would this look like if we shook it up at all times. What I think is the challenge I find with the Middle East is, you just said there, there's a positive story, but that story always seems to hinge on financial growth. And you and I go back a long way. I don't
come from a business background. Our focus, obviously, is on expanding and growing in the region. The whole point of that is so that we can do the best work, where we can develop the best work and develop the best people. That's what we care about. So for me, a success story can't be financial alone. I think we're growing as a market still. Like you say, there's a lot of interest, but it can have an impact on the quality of the work,
right? I mean, not a week goes by when there's not an international agency that expands here or something that opens up here. It's great when you look at it that way. It's a lot of opportunity for people, a lot of opportunity for young talent, a lot of opportunity for people, good talents to come in and lead things and try things for themselves. But it does mean I think there needs to be a much more direct focus on what we're producing. You know, there needs to be a lot
more conversation around the quality of the work that we produce and the work that comes out of the region from a PR perspective, right? Because I think that creatively the region has really grown and really established itself on the global level in recent years. I think that's fair to say. But on a PR perspective, we're not there, you know, and there are a number of reasons for that. And so when I talk about the success story, you talk about... from a from a growth perspective and financial perspective i think that's fantastic that for me just creates the platform that gives us the opportunity to experiment a little bit
to attract different types of talent to try new things you know there's there's great homegrown brands that are coming up here that want to try new things that we're seeing a bit of a resurgence from the media as well and the new platforms new digital platforms appearing where they're they're really putting a huge on high -quality editorial and art direction. We did have a lull. So the financial situation and the growth and
the interest and the population growth in the region is great. It's just creating the foundations. I think now what we need is we need brands and we need agencies and we need talent to use that, right? Because we're emerging markets, as you know, right? You've worked in plenty of them. You know them probably better than I do. it almost feels like okay growth is the only thing that matters right yeah right i worked in a global network for nearly a decade like the region is fantastic they love it because it brings in dollars they don't want the most innovative people here
they're not bothered about like the brands really like so long as that's growing the margin cool like we'll have the innovators and the big speakers like they'll be they'll sit in new york right they'll sit So we need to capture that, right? We need the big voices and the big names here. We need people to see the region as like a beacon of creativity, like a heart of good work, experimentation, and not just like an outpost for margin. That's
the crucial thing. So that's what I say I think it could do with shaking up, yeah. Yeah, I couldn't agree with you more. From a creative perspective, certainly in terms of the PR work, it is seen as perhaps a little bit conservative in terms of the work that's produced, perhaps the risks that are being taken. The Romans, of course, has a reputation for being quite a risk -taking
consultancy, for being quite disruptive. from a creative perspective how do you get that to work in this region because it's not always that easy as just opening your doors and and suddenly you're able to produce breakthrough work you've got to i presume persuade clients um one at a time i thought that i thought that and a lot of the feedback when we were talking about establishing
the romance here from within the market was that from our peers was that honestly aaron it hasn't been the case the like clients are crying out for it i thought we'd spend maybe 18 provocation looks different to everyone right the idea was never that we would take a campaign that works well in london and like bring it here and say hey it works like just take it that was never the intention and so I spent a long time with the founder and CEO, Joe McKay Sinclair, talking about what is the agency going to look like here.
It's not going to be a diluted version. It's not going to be a copy paste. We wanted to build something from scratch. We wanted to lean on the principles of what the Romans is, right? Best work, best people. It's disruptive earned, but it needs to be, you know, when you start something new and it may move and grow in new directions that the other markets don't. And same for the other markets around the world that we've expanded into. So we're lucky we have a great base. We have a great foundation. We have a great culture. And when I say culture, I mean
in terms of like how we approach the work, right? Like how we all see what the work should be and should feel like and how brief should be approached and how brands should be talking. The provocation, the social issues, the challenges here that we want to address for the communities, for the population, they exist. They're just different. So when you talk about being a bit disruptive, taking risks, I think it's just about reading the room and knowing the language, you know, knowing the nuance and meeting people where they
are. And that's a bit of a cliche. Once you're on the ground and you know what's happening, it's crazy to do that. I think from a brand perspective, from a client perspective, particularly the comms people, I just think they're sick and tired of doing the PR bit for their colleagues. I think those days are gone. And when I speak to them, and obviously I spent the first six months of the romance just having conversations, really. I was expecting kind of what you said there. I was expecting a big sell from my end. But it wasn't really like that. It was more like we've
kind of been waiting for this, you know. And so what I think is agencies, they're not, I think because maybe, I just think there's a bit of a disconnect. I don't think they're coming with big, ownable ideas. I don't think they're conceptualizing. I don't think they're bringing work to their clients because they assume that there's going to be no risk. They assume there's going to be no appetite. They assume there's a big day -to -day to be done. the rules out the door and off you go. But on the contrary, I found that they're
sort of saying, well, we want to lead big ideas, right? The future of creativity, I think lives within PR because I think we understand influence best. We understand social best. We understand culture best. We understand storytelling best. We're very rapid. We move quickly. We can get things done on a shoestring. Like it's kind of perfect. So you just need some agencies. I wouldn't say brave enough. I think that's a bit unfair, but you just need some agencies that are going to commit to that idea. And it's not all agencies, right? I mean, you know, platform, you know it.
Comms is so vast. Like there are agencies and consultancies that are there to direct on, you know, national mandates and like, they'll never kind of touch upon what we do and vice versa. But in our space, you know, I think disruptive, culture -first comms are like creative and work. Clients are just sitting there being like, just tell me how. That's what we've found. That's what we've found. Do you think this is related at all to, you know, increasing localization as well? And I guess, you know, it's a young
region. So we do have this kind of new generation coming through. But the comm sector in this part of the world has been quite expat dominated for a long time. Do you think that that is changing and maybe that's driving? this perhaps greater comfort with connecting with culture and tackling some of these social issues that perhaps were considered, I don't know, out of bounds a decade ago? That's a great question. I mean, the answer
to that varies massively depending on the flag, right? I mean, if you look at Saudi Arabia, they are aggressively sort of reeling back on on global you know consultancies and international talent that big talent drive seems to have plateaued really quickly right there's a huge emphasis on solidization and trying to grow and establish good local saudi talent um and i think they'll get there you know i think that you've got a
hungry young population that wants to do exciting things um if you look at the emirates a bit different right you your what you want is you want more local talent to be interested in the sector and sort of fly the flag for the sector but we have we do you know we have great ones but just the population balance is so extreme right whereas
in Saudi it's not quite like that but if you look at the rest of the region I mean the best talent it comes out of like the northern parts of the region you know out of the lebanon that's where the really good talent is i think and they help with localization but that i think that's why you see you know what you do tend to see is the big globally recognized or award -winning pieces of work tend to stem out of egypt and lebanon you know places like this where that talent is representing a population that they've
grown up in right yeah through the struggles and they've been to the schools and they've had the jobs and they've listened and consumed the music and the film and the arts and all these kind of things. So they know the brands and they know the insights and all those kind of things. That's harder to do in a place like the Gulf, right? As you say, it's exceptionally expat heavy where it feels like, I get back to that first question, right? It feels like a lot of the onus is on how do we use global expertise to help
grow? whereas uh from a sort of cultural and community perspective in those other meaner markets you know the local talent can drive the work because it makes more sense to do that so that's why i think you'll always see two different types of work but uh saudi is a really interesting one right you want to keep eyes on that because of big emphasis on sanitization and and the you know government mandate to to really increase saudi talent there and i think they are excited about our sector you know i think they're excited
about the craft they're excited about it's the role that it plays you know for vision 2030 and uh and nation branding and all these kind of things so let's let's see i don't think we're we're not quite there enough you know where i think we can talk about it but let's see yeah that's a really good point i think that that you need you need those countries with that kind of critical mass right in terms of youth um talent that can come into the industry and and be a part of it in a way that connects culture authentically
uh and i suspect in the uae that's a much bigger challenge just because of that population imbalance do you ever do you envisage perhaps a a time in the uae where consultancies are um less reliant on expat talent or is it always going to be this kind of equation here i cannot answer that question i hope so if you look at the brands here that are like emirati driven yeah they're some of
the most impactful in the market right i can name a handful of of emirati leaders in the marketing sector that have you know flying the flag for the emirates flying the flag for the region getting global recognition you know the great thing about the emirates aaron's like they just they make things happen You know, they've got such a can -do attitude. No idea is too big. That is, you know, we go back to your first question about
risk and bravery. That is so important in our sector, right? And so when you come face to face with Emiratis, young or more established, they've got a real, like, can -do, like, let's make it happen sort of attitude. I think if you blend that with global creative talent. Then you start to see really, really exciting work, right? When you give the exposure of global creative talent
to that entrepreneurial, do the impossible, drive things forward, something that's never been seen before, culture of the Emirates, then you get great work. And there are a great bunch of examples, right? strong local talent. So I'd love, I'd like to hope that what I'd love, I mean, really ideally what you'd love to see, you'd love to see the Emirati population sort of penetrate the agency landscape a little bit more. That would be awesome, right? That would be awesome.
And there are a couple that are sort of built, built locally that do good exciting things. But that critical mass you talk about, I can't answer that question, but that would be great. I'd love to see. So you mentioned How there's so many PR firms flocking to the Middle East. I can think of so many over the past two years that have opened up here. I mean, most of the global networks are here already, but it's kind of that tier below, I think, where we've seen a lot of expansion.
Of course, the Romans is one of them as well. How easy or difficult will it be for them? to flourish here because presumably they're all coming here in the in the belief that um they will be successful yeah yeah well firstly i think it is an indie era and i'm all here for it you know the the big multinationals brought the big legacy networks with them and they've sort of
sat comfortably ever since you know for decades really embedded in the major multinational companies, big, you know, FMCG companies and the auto companies and all this kind of stuff. But I think now the market has shown that it's, it really gets the industry and it gets, it knows how to use agencies a little bit better and it wants to create good work without the fuss and it wants to create good work with people that are passionate and can move quickly. And that is. That's really
exciting, right? That's, I think, why we've been able to flourish so early. That's a really good thing. The question about, like, you know, will they flourish? I think everyone, it's a very tough market to operate in. It's a very tough market to operate in. You need to be cash backed. That is very important. It's expensive to start here. It's expensive to establish yourself. You know, payment terms vary here in the region. uh you know there's so many different there's
so many different business cultures people talk about like the great diversity of the region and that is something that is so exciting about it but that comes with like a lot of business a lot of varied business cultures right they do things in different ways i'm a very still like who you know some businesses is done you know almost exclusively through whatsapp some is done exclusively through procurement portals some is done in the modulus right some is done over coffee so you have to have good exposure to all of those things you can't just sort of appear and position yourself and like and expect
business to come to you um you've really got a you've really got a hustle uh and you've got to get in in with people and you've got to have expertise you've got to have really good i think financial expertise you know legal expertise um just to understand how them how the region operates because it's not that that's gonna it's not that that's a that's a hindrance to growing your business but it's very time consuming and i think that that's what people don't understand you know you come into the market and there's a there's a lot to be done to just establish
your business you know and get yourself in a good place um so that's that's one of the biggest challenges you know i don't know if you saw it but uh and nick walsh a former colleague of mine good friend of mine you've been at wpp for for decades he you know came through geometry and was running vml for a while you know he recently just just left wpp started a company called migrate which is literally designed to bring the best global indie agencies into the region help scale
them you know take care of that that difficult sort of establishing sex sort of sort of section you know introduce them to key people get them you know all compliant he's built that agency specifically like that company specifically for that because he knows that that's a major challenge and people appear here like kind of like the old gold Rush right in California like they appear with the with their briefcases and a hat and they're like right like where's the gold it just doesn't it's just not the way the region is anymore it's competitive it's established it has standards
and um if you're not prepared and you don't have that that that knowledge or that insight, you're going to struggle. Yeah, that's a very interesting point. You had also mentioned the importance of being part of culture here, I guess being culture first. How does that actually happen in this part of the world? Because like you said, there's multiple cultures. And then there are
firms that maybe are not always staffed with people that have grown up here. So how much of a challenge is that for firms? And for brands, actually. It's the best kind of challenge. It's the best kind of challenge. I love that. Because if you take the UAE as an example, culturally, it's so diverse that something might land in Satwa. that won't even make its way down Shagside Road, let alone, you know, nationwide, right?
You see great campaigns in certain parts of the world that are like nationwide hits. That's just impossible here. You know, it's almost like neighborhood by neighborhood. And so the fun thing is, it's kind of weird. You know, I spent almost a decade with Ogilvy. The first six months with the Romans here, where we didn't have an office, we're just working around the city. I learned more about... the place i live in those six months that i had in the previous 10 years seeing where people are like where they eat what they do what they
talk about you've got to be really active and you've got to get around and you've got to see people right in the flesh because everyone here is like they're consuming their news from different places their algorithms are completely different they live like different you know different digital lives and and because we don't have the sort of traditional like city center that cross you know that sort of cross -cultural you know sort of accidental cultural uh sort of collisions don't happen as much so you've got to be quite
you're gonna be quite you've got to have quite a lot of intent when you go out and see what's happening there and get into the neighborhoods and get into the communities and figure out like what makes them tick and and who's there and those shift by the year right as you would have seen over the years those shift by the year as well so that for me is just it's just an extra fun challenge right like we we Started working with a brand. I don't know if I can mention that just yet, but it's a, you know, it's kind of like a, it's a, it's an international brand, but they operate like it's a, it's a very consumer,
like a very broad consumer brand. And the strategies are neighborhood by neighborhood, right? They're not like nation. They are neighborhood by neighborhood. Like in this neighborhood, what are we going to do? How do we turn up? And how do we speak to people? And who are those people? And what do they eat? and where do they hang out right where do they work and you travel like a mile and a half and it's a whole new strategy right it's a whole new plan it's a whole new playbook so that cultural challenge to me is is fascinating i don't think many people get it i don't think
many people have done it well um and that is not a criticism it's a very tricky place to do it but i really feel like yeah we overuse this terminology of like culture first and you know being our culture or moving at the speed of cultural you know whatever whatever stuff we come out with in this industry um but it's doable and i think that's why you're seeing that like now you're seeing like the rise of saudi culture right they've got an opportunity to to showcase
who they are to the world right like their eyes the eyes of the world are on saudi and you know there are varied filters on on what those eyes see and and how they perceive that nation but what's true is There's a young population there that is seeing their moment to display their Saudi to the world from an arts perspective, a music perspective, a film and a drama and a food and a business and innovation perspective. And I think now brands are on that. And I think
that agencies are on that. And you see more and more work come through that is driven from Saudi culture. you can see the impact of like of being culture first you can see the impact that has because you've you've almost sort of communicated a completely different type of saudi to the world in the last two three years even right driven by young creative people women like it's just small it's just small things right nuance of language nuance of of of clothing and fashion
like these these things for me like these are points that are culture first right good campaigns good exposure um to people and artists when maybe traditionally other parts of the world assume that like you know all women in saudi are fully fully veiled head to toe right and then suddenly you see like a campaign where you've got like a young artist or a boxer or whatever and uh you know what and what i love about them as well is like how they blend like global global trends
and global brands right so you've got this like south like the saudi green you know like infiltrates like global brands and products and like they create like fresh things like a super saudi i really like that like there's not there's a lot of pride in that that you don't see you certainly wouldn't see it in the west right like if you made like a union jack pair of adidas poppers i think like you know that would be really political um whereas well i think now it might be quite popular these days who knows yeah yeah take that
one for free um but you know that you see that like that's all like saudi cultural touch and national pride like blend into global brands and uh and sectors and activities and sports and arts and things it they really love it you know it's a really fun way to express you know saudi pride and saudi culture so yeah that cultural That's a minefield, but it's a really fun challenge. I love that challenge. I love putting that to the team and trying to figure out what that is and what that looks like because it is so different in the goal than it is anywhere else. Yeah, I
was at the Athar festival at the awards ceremony and they show a lot of the work that wins. And it was quite eye -opening actually to see because it's all Saudi work and it is really very much driven, like you said, by this kind of new spirit of empowerment. But it's interesting. When I talk to consultancies about the Gulf, especially newer firms here, they're really only talking about the UAE and Saudi Arabia. Yeah. What about the rest of the region? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, back
to that first point, right? People want what is the perceived gold rush. It makes perfect sense to aim for the financial hubs. But from a talent perspective... Our whole thing, right? At The Romans, the thing that's most important to us is best people, best work. Those are the two things. Nothing's more important than that. Like we get that right and like revenue follows. And yeah, we grow in the business and growth is very important, but it is a secondary conversation for us. And that helps us work with the best clients. It helps us attract the best talent and it helps us do work that no one else is doing.
And that's all we want as an agency. We're not much more complex than that. So when you talk about best work, talk about best talent, to your point, they're out there in the region. And having run MENA from a strat and creative perspective for a decade, all the best campaigns, all the best work, all the best responses and receptions to the work we were doing were in other parts of the region. So I love being out there. I think there needs to be more of an onus on that. Obviously,
when you look at the Gulf, you're talking about small populations. or small economies like it i i understand that um but the the heart of the of the region you know it's it's it's very widespread and i'd love more people you know focus on that i'd love to see more emphasis on you know like on egypt and on lebanon and uh and on yeah i
agree Good to start seeing stories come back out of Syria. I mean, you know, it's a very, like, I mean, look, we're not going to start talking geopolitics, right? But it's a complex region. It's a complex region. And there's a lot of, there's a lot of trauma here. There's a lot of conflict. There's a lot of hurt. There's a lot of pain. But at the heart of it all are just, like, I think the historical context of the region is just so fascinating. Like what this place has given the world over thousands of years is just unrivaled. That talent, that
story, that thirst for knowledge and academia and innovation. Universities were born here. That still lives richly here. I'd love to see that just get a little bit more exposure. A little bit more exposure. I totally agree with that. I would love to see that too. I think that's a good note on which to end because I think it would be... very nice to see more stories coming out of different countries in this part of the
world. And homegrown stories as well, right? They don't always have to be driven by firms from other parts of the world. But that would be, you know, I think a really interesting sign of the kind of evolution that we've talked about today. So Joe, thank you so much. You're welcome, buddy. And look, I just want to say congrats on what you're doing. You know, I love the work.
The Earnfest platform is brilliant. And, you know, we need it. We're a super competitive industry with a lot of good stories. And I just, yeah, I really appreciate what you're doing, man. Keep it up. Thank you. Much appreciated. This region's keeping me busy. There's a lot of news, it seems, at the moment. So, yeah, long may that continue as well. Yeah, exactly. Thanks very much. Yeah, no problem, mate. Thanks a ton.
Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...
Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...
Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO...
GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...
Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to...