In the first our Cannes podcasts, Zeno global CEO Barby Siegel and chief client impact officer Thomas Bunn examine the firm's Clarity 2030 research, which studies CMO attitudes toward reputation, earned media, and AI discoverability. The duo discuss why marketing leaders acknowledge the value of reputation but struggle to embed it earlier in the growth process, or to fund the earned media strategies most likely to build it. The data points to another persistent structural problem: comms holds the broader stakeholder mandate, yet marketing claims more CEO influence on reputation and external positioning by a significant margin. Siegel and Bunn explore what it would take for communications to move from late-stage risk manager to early growth input, and where business acumen fits into that shift.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Earned First podcast at the Cannes Lions 2026 Festival of Creativity. And I'm absolutely delighted to be back here for the second year with our friends at Zeno Group. We're going to be talking about the agency's very interesting Clarity 2030 research. But first, let me introduce our podcast guests, of course, from Zeno Group. Chief Executive Officer, Barby Siegel. Barbie, welcome. Thank you. So happy to be back here,
Arun. And Global Chief Client Impact Officer, Thomas Bunn. Thomas. Thanks for having us. So I hope you are both having a good week. It's still Monday in Cannes, so I don't know when people will listen to this, but we're still relatively early in the week. Before we start talking about the research, I wanted to ask, as always, how's the market looking for Zeno? How are you looking this year? It hasn't been the easiest of periods for the public relations sector. But Zeno always seems to do well regardless. So how are you doing?
Thank you for asking. So this is actually a really interesting time to be talking. We are coming to the end of our fiscal year, the end of June. In fact, while here, I'm working on my end of year remarks. And we have worked hard. It has been a very challenging year, but I am delighted to say that for the end of our fiscal year, we will report growth and double digit margin. So I am... really pleased with that. But of course, measure of an agency is both financial and reputational.
And we made a lot of moves this year, some of which we're going to talk about that I think sets us up very well for this changing world and also to head into fiscal 27 with some real strength and competitive edge. Okay, well, that's really good to hear. It's always good to hear, I think, when agencies are growing, because like you said, this is not the easiest of markets. It's interesting also, I think, because we are seeing growth come from different sources and maybe not the usual places often. And that, I
think, comes to life in Cannes because there are so many CMOs here. And increasingly, we're seeing perhaps reputation issues taking more and more precedence on the CMO agenda in a way that I don't think we would have seen a few years ago. And Zeno has very helpfully. We've researched, I think, around 100 CMOs for your 2030 Clarity research. And there's some fascinating findings that I'd like to talk to both of you about that
look at growth, that look at reputation, look at AI discoverability, and then look at the relationship between the CMO and the CCO. And these are all, I think, kind of the crucial talking points, certainly if you're coming from an earned -first lens like we are. So let's start with one of the key findings that I think is really interesting. And actually, it's a few findings around maybe tension between growth and trust. So 82 % of
CMOs in your study agree that reputational considerations are a bigger factor in marketing and growth decisions than before. But only 13 % say that they're frequently involved in weighing growth opportunity. against reputational risk and then i think more than half about 54 say only sometimes or rarely and almost two -thirds say that reputation and comms considerations have actually slowed marketing
execution so do you think that um reputation is actually being built into growth decisions um or does it come later on when the stakes are already too high And do you think there's work to be done to make reputation almost an input earlier in the process? This research has proven to be so rich. I think we could probably do a podcast episode for each of the findings. I'll just share a few thoughts and turn it over to Thomas. We have been partners on this research.
We began the Clarity 2030 platform about a year ago, and we launched it at Praxis to really look at then how ready communicators were. for 2030 and also the impact of the rising influence of communications. And what we found from that study, which is important context for this study, is that indeed it validated that communications has moved from being a manager of the message to a driver of strategic growth. Fantastic. That is where we want to be. Communications in the
C -suite, across the enterprise, really impacting business. And so the logical next move was to talk, as you said, to CMOs to understand what they understand about the role of communications and reputation, not just as a protection mechanism. The brand is in trouble. we need the reputation experts but really how do we embed reputation at the very beginning of conversations we've
talked for so many years arun about integration and that's great and that's now a given that's not what we're talking about here what we're really talking about is marketers understanding that reputation that reputation is a key driver of business growth and that in fact communications leaders and marketing leaders have an opportunity to co -own growth. Because what Clarity has shown us is that the remits for both communications
leaders and marketers has vastly expanded as pressure intensifies and growth is sought after. But neither one feel quite ready. And we think that has to do with, A, the understanding of each other, and B, the organizational structures to support it. Yeah, and I'll just build on that. I think we were heartened to see how many marketing leaders do think their reputation is way more important than it ever has been before. I think
it was 82 % thought it was, you know, extremely important. But only just half of them. or really are seeing it through the way it is impacted by sales. So for example, they have a very narrow lens of reputation right now. If it hurts my top line sales, it's a reputational issue. They're not looking at reputation, as you said, as a business. input right from the start as communicators we all know we look at the full landscape of stakeholders a very complex map we try and decipher and understand and predict obviously where reputational
problems could arise and impact the business in many different ways but for the marketer it really is through the lens of sales and we saw that and sometimes brand health so the problem is they're not thinking about it right at the start they think about it really near the end once they've seen the sales come in. So this is really the big shift that needs to be made is to help marketers really truly understand that you can build your business strategy around reputation. And in doing so, obviously, you can actually accelerate your growth and also you can protect your brand clearly from all the issues. So that really is that kind of disconnect we're
seeing right now. We're glad to see them much more focused on reputation. They don't even know operationally and organizationally how to truly manage it and how to truly put it at the heart of the work they're doing. And that's, again, where communications... can really step in. And in some ways it's understandable. The world is changing so fast. Responsibilities are expanding. Communications has evolved. in so many ways across the entire organization, that the opportunity to get back together with the marketers and really help them, as Thomas said, understand the potential
and what reputation is, both as a mechanism to protect, but also to proactively grow and promote. The big question as well is who owns growth in an organization, right? Traditionally... marketing kind of on growth and how they're really laser focused on growth. And, you know, communications was focused on, obviously, reputation, perception, managing all of that. So I think now, as Bobby said, this understanding of it's no longer about alignment between the functions. It's about co
-ownership. Everybody owns growth. And not just comms and marketing. Surely the CFO, the CHRO with talent, everybody's involved in the growth equation. But, you know, it can't be just one function really driving it. I guess the question that always follows on from that is how do you make that case to the CMO? I mean, if it is the CMO, but if you're a CCO and you really want to prove that reputation should be an earlier factor in growth decisions, what are the ways
to make that case? I mean, I think there's a data point that, if okay, I want to share that I was... we were so fascinated by sorry i have to refer to my notes according to eco yes you know eco their research um 22 of total market capitalization can be attributed to corporate reputation. That's a powerful data point. 26%, wasn't it? What did I say? 22%. Oh, it's 26%.
That's powerful. And I think there are other ways. We have more opportunity now, as you well know, through data analytics, the intelligence we use, to draw a line between the work that we as communicators do. and growth but even to build on something that thomas said when you're looking at all the stakeholders let's even think about the employees we need to consider employees in the growth equation as well because they of course are your greatest advocates so it is a case to be made but i think education and this
shared understanding and what cfo doesn't want everybody in the in the organization to consider growth as part of their responsibility But understanding, not to interrupt you, that people care about the reputation of a company much more than they ever had. It's not enough just to buy a brand. They want to know where that brand comes from. And I think there is a lot of research that talks about consumer behavior and wanting to feel very aligned to the values of a brand. Those values
come from the reputation. Indeed. Now, there's a... some findings about reputation which i think are really interesting and we are i think most more familiar with surveys that ask ccos about reputation and we perhaps um default to this kind of uh customer review that the the cco is in charge of reputation but the research tells something of a different story um 43 of cmos
only 43 say coms and pr plays a true strategic partner role in shaping reputation on an ongoing basis marketing also reports holding more ceo influence than comms on reputation and and external positioning sixty percent versus fourteen percent yet to be fair fifty seven percent of cmos concede that comms manages a broader stakeholder remit than marketing does so why does the function
With the wider remit, the broader stakeholder spectrum, it seems to have less authority, less CEO access. Is that a credibility problem for comms? Is it just a turf war? Or is it organizational lag? I'm not sure I completely agree. If you look at the recent Wall Street Journal story about CCOs reporting to the CEO. I really do think this is an instance of lack of understanding and, if I may, lack of clarity. Communications
and PR has grown so fast and evolved in ways that we had only hoped for many years ago that I think it hasn't quite caught up to the marketing organization about what true strategic communications can do. And as I said earlier, It has absolutely moved from a position of managing the message, PRing a campaign, to being a driver of strategic growth, because we know that strategic storytelling,
communicating with myriad stakeholders, as Thomas said, It does all add up. It's not just one activity that delivers growth. It's all of these pieces working together. I mean, I do think there's some serious organizational challenges, though. I think, according to McKinsey, in the last five years, the C -suite has grown 50%, right? So that's... A lot more people with a lot more remits, a lot more voices to tell the story. A lot more responsibilities, a lot of confusion around who owns what. So yes, maybe the marketing lead is
in the kind of growth driving position because historically they've moved into that and evolved into that position. But now that is also spread across the organization. So it really is challenging to kind of galvanize and get everyone together. And that's why we were so interested in our research to find that the most important skill for 2030. for marketing leaders was cross -organizational influence. When we did our original Clarity research a few months back, for CCOs, it was creativity and judgment were the top skills, right? So creativity,
not meaning come up with beautiful, creative campaigns, but finding creative solutions to problems. We assumed when we got the research in that, you know, the CMO would have a similar, you know, creativity and human judgment would be the rising skills. It wasn't, it was cross -functional. cross -organizational influence, which just tells us that this CMO is really having to figure out how to pull all the right levers, exert the right influence without added authority across the organization. I think that's where
really that the CISO has an opportunity to really help foster that working relationship in interesting and new ways to make it. better and there are many cmos out there many clients of ours that that understand all this we don't want to make broad generalization but according to the research there is plenty of room for more conversation we're going to be convening a dinner with you later this week bringing ccos and cmos together i mean one of the um Most popular CMOs here is
Todd Kaplan of Kraft Heinz. Last year here at Cannes, he talked about how important it is for marketers to be in lockstep with the communications people. And Kraft Heinz, the work we do for them across the brands, it's very culture forward. when we put our teams together we always talk about being at the intersection of brand and corporate reputation of course it used to be the brand people here the corporate people there our teams even on a brand remit even on a big
creative brand remit our corporate teams are involved from day one just to be sure that all there are all the considerations being taken because i think we have all seen what happens What can go unfortunately wrong when that doesn't happen? Yeah. And I would imagine actually that the CMOs that you work with are probably predisposed or they've been well -educated and they probably understand the relationship with the CCO. at a more sophisticated level perhaps than maybe
some of the respondents to the research do in organizations that are perhaps more siloed um but we have clients who the marketing and communications function resides with one leader yeah we have clients where we are asked to work together and we have clients where it's quite separate and that was a very key impetus for doing this research because there are so many models out there but i would think you can kind of sometimes be the bridge yourselves right i wouldn't yes i would imagine that happens too um we are seeing for
example i think you mentioned the wall street journal piece and i think that reflects how reputation issues are now seen you know are taken far more seriously yes right which is good in the c -suite absolutely everyone wants a piece in a way of reputation um everyone has i think sees how important it is to a company um and issues blow up now in ways that you know you can't imagine you can't predict ceo turnover is higher than ever as well so you know perhaps it's not all that surprising
that Even CMOs think that they should be the ones leading on reputation because it's a bigger issue. And I think we also have to make sure that we see that reputation very broadly. It's not just, let's say, protecting the CEO. That is a piece of it. But if you look at the data, Arun, on earned media as being so important, and we know in the age of AI, earned media is vital, that needs to be a strategic communications function around storytelling. just want to be
sure that when we talk about reputation, it's a very broad definition. It's what happens with the CEO in the C -suite, but it's what happens with storytelling, how we engage with our employees. It's all of that. Yeah, absolutely. One thing I will say, which has surprised me this week, is I've seen a couple of sessions, I think on the fringe agenda, where CMOs are talking about geopolitics. which is not something I would have expected to see. Which is so exciting because
in our research, geopolitical factors, I think, rank the lowest in terms of considerations that CMOs make when they think about reputation. As I said to you before, sales was the first one. There was brands, health, etc. But things like employee, even media and investor relations, all those things were in the single digits. Meanwhile, when you ask CCOs, what's their top? reputation issue issue now it's almost always geopolitics absolutely it's kind of like the reverse isn't it i've thought of it that way reverse you know
it is you know i'm an optimist you've known me long enough but it is an exciting time to do what we do as communicators as marketers but it is also a complex time and to to us let's use all the tools at our disposal and let's make sure that we have that co -ownership between communications and marketing for growth. Absolutely. So let's talk about AI discoverability as a very big topic here in Cannes this week, as you'd
expect. And of course, I think within the comms world, this has been a real driver for consultancies and has also just driven a lot of conversation. The potential resurgence of earned media because of its influence. Not potential. It has resurged. It has resurged. Yes. The resurgence of earned media because of its authority and influence with answer engines and LLMs and so on. Now,
77 % of CMOs in your research say marketing owns AI. and search, AI search, sorry, discoverability today. Only 1 % say comms PR does. But at the same time, 83 % of the same CMOs say earned media is more effective than paid media at shaping how brands show up in AI generated answers. I think it's seven out of 10 say earned media has become more valuable, but... it also ranks below
search optimization and analytics tools in terms of the budgets so again that throws up an interesting you know tension earned media and credibility signals are what ai systems actually reward so shouldn't comms have a bigger claim on that territory and shouldn't marketing be spending more money on it You're passionate about this topic. Take it away. I think you point out the contradictions and the tensions we saw in those findings. I
think the big... piece that we see right now is that the CMO is extremely focused on discovery visibility and visibility of the brand right how they just the brand is the brand showing up in the LLMs the larger issue what is concerning tucked away in that data is less than half are concerned that the AI is misinterpreting their brands so we have this on the ground with our clients right everyone's focused on Am I being found? Am I being found? It's critical to my business, of course, but am I being understood or perceived in the right way? And they're not
paying attention to that. And that's not the reputational issue that is very concerning. So from that perspective, I feel it's not, again, it's not about who owns what. It's about co -ownership. I think there's room for marketing. Again, in terms of, you know, they are traditionally overseeing search to really, you know, be thinking about that and then have comms obviously as a partner to it. We did think that it was pretty staggering, obviously, that thankfully, although CMOs really recognize that earned media is much more effective, clearly, with the LLMs than paid media is at,
you know, boosting discoverability. But the fact they're not willing to invest more in it is just, again, very surprising to us. So, again, the question begs, where does that budget sit? Is it they're not putting the budget because they don't control that? It's just a lot of questions there we need to unpack, to be honest with you. But I think it's interesting just to see again that that reputational piece of AI search is definitely missing. A lot of our clients are down with us and we have those aha moments with them where they're like, oh, wow, there's a whole other part to this I didn't think about. So other work that we do at Zeno with our geo -fluent
product and geo is really help them understand the two sides of this equation. You need to be found. but you need to be understood as well. And that is such a great opportunity for communications and marketing to come together to bridge that gap and to open up new types of conversations. Is there a risk perhaps that the CMO, the marketers are viewing AI discoverability almost as an advertising channel? I think so. And, you know, again, I think comms, we've taken a different approach now with AI. I mean, we speak to our clients,
I talk to, you know. you know business to business communications you know b2c but it's not a b2m business to machine like we treat ai as a stakeholder now right in communications we have comms plans built around how we're going to reach the machines because that's how we see it very much as a stakeholder that could have reputational impact on the brands that we take care of and and champion and i think that's where the markets aren't seeing that way they as you said they're really seeing it as a channel again search so i think it requires
a different mindset um and you know i think that's that was definitely some of those findings there where my head was kind of spinning saying wow they want to own it they but they don't want the reputational impact they they know that to earn media is so important yet they don't want to spend more on media so i think there's a lot there to kind of figure out i think that will be the ongoing conversation but i say to you know our communications clients this is your chance to walk into the ceo's office to talk about geo aeo it's such an important topic and we are the ones who really can influence it in
the most effective way and again it's an opportunity to really kind of rise to the challenge and go to marketing and say let us help you versus fighting about it so again co -ownership again there yeah i mean that finding you mentioned on misrepresentation that that is a very interesting one that the the lack of console the less concern about a brand being misrepresented in these answer because it's not it's not enough to be found what are you finding beneath the surface yeah exactly i mean and and so many reputation issues are
are surfacing and are going to surface via Answer engines now. Probably requires a stronger CMO -CCO partnership. There's a lot of data about that partnership in the study as well. Marketing leaders cite a few barriers to closer collaboration with comms. They tend to be around things like different working speeds, which is a little bit of a surprise to me because I always thought comms were, you know, pretty fast moving. function
um and the media moves quickly uh resource constraints is cited uh mismatched success metrics um so those are cited more often than you know perhaps structural ownership issues which To me, it's
less about, look, of course, we all want to be in the lead, right? We as comms people love that. To me, it's a little less about that and more about just making sure that the communications people are in lockstep with the marketing team from before day one. You know, when we get briefs now, we brief our teams, whether it's a consumer launch or a B2B or healthcare, whatever the case may be. we are beginning to put in reputational
considerations from the start. So, yes, and here at Cannes Lions, we talk about idea creation from the PR agencies, and we've seen many wonderful examples where that works out beautifully. For this big issue that we're dealing with, that's not where I would put all my energy and say we have to be in the lead. Rather, we as communicators want to partner. with the communications leaders and the marketing leaders to close the gap so that we can have better work and better impact
and outcome around growth, because we will all benefit. We will all grow. And that's the case because we I don't want this to devolve into a turf war. That's not what we're talking about. We want to have a strategic conversation about the role of We're talking about reputation, but it really is the role of strategic communications in all its facets to be a growth driver. Because again, the first tranche of research affirmed that we're no longer just managers in the message,
while that's important. Communications, and we have the data to prove it, is a driver of growth. That, I think, is the message that we want to get the marketers to embrace. because we can be helpful. And I wonder if, you know, in a way with communications, you think about like that kind of teenage analogy and you kind of grow really fast and, you know, you're still lanky. Well, that's me anyway, as a teenager, kind of, you know, your body grows faster than, you know, your legs or whatever. And, you know, I think of it, we've certainly got all this influence. We've become so pivotal and important, but I
still think there are things that we need to work on. I think you mentioned the speed thing. My assumption is we have to deal with so many different stakeholders so complex that if we get you know if creative comms comes in sorry marketing with a creative execution and says oh my god is this going to be okay you know we don't think of it to the lens of just consumers the end buyer we're thinking about the employee we're thinking about investors maybe advocacy groups you know all sorts of things so there is an element of like there's only so fast you can move even though we make great progress the
other thing is the metrics and the measurement piece we have some work to do there to help the cmo understand really the reputational value of the work we do on the business so we all know there's a gap there then one you did not mention um which is something that I think our industry is starting to talk about a lot more is business acumen and commercial judgment. I think sometimes... as comms leaders we do have you know a gap to close there i think sometimes we don't speak the same language as the ceo or the cmo the cfo
we sometimes you know in our comms world and i think we do need to recognize that sometimes we need to understand the business better we'll be able to speak about the business better and that would give us even more credibility in those conversations so for me it's all things that we can close the gap on but understandably there's some great clues the research that really a bit of a blueprint that tells us what we need to work on in order to really get to that kind of perfect harmony and partnership with the marketing teams. I think Thomas makes a good point on the balance of all of this. What we are not saying,
it's only the marketers have to change or change their minds or change their perception. It's very much a shared responsibility. And the business acumen cannot underscore that enough. It is not good enough to come to the table, the proverbial table, as a communications person. You must come as a business person first. And when given a brief, the very first question is, what is the business challenge we need to solve? Forget about communications. Forget about the channel. And I think if marketers begin seeing us more in
that light, I think that will actually pave the way for us to get closer to them. Yeah. And I don't know. I've always thought this should be... relatively straightforward to address, you would think. If you're a senior person heading the comms function, you would think business acumen is something you could take for granted. But it did come through, I think, particularly in the qualitative findings in the research. There was comments from some of the respondents about business acumen. And again, not making excuses,
but our business has moved so fast, there are still people that need to catch up. Let's talk about the future. to close um asked where comms pr could add the most value to the cmo agenda over the next three years cmos say becoming a strategic partner earlier in the process again at that perhaps that point about speed they also cite ai search discoverability building a trusted brand narrative and earned influence thought
leadership which is I think those are fairly unsurprising in terms of areas. And several CMOs said, and this again in the qualitative point that you mentioned, a deeper understanding of the business itself. So of those different areas, earlier strategic involvement, AI discoverability, brand narrative, earned influence. Which of those do you think, if we're going to look at 2030, which of them do you think is the most realistic? What is the capability perhaps that you think
comms most needs to build the strongest case for over the next four years? I think the AI scalability piece is connected to narrative and the influence. They're really, for me, they're a little of a cluster that we need to kind of keep moving forward. consistent as quickly as we can. I think we have made great progress with that. Again, a lot of us as comms professionals have seen the opportunity there to kind of really rise and really reiterate the importance of earned media now more than ever before and owned and
quality content. So I do think that's going to continue to be the case. I think the other piece in terms of, you know, what i'm looking at is like how we move the needle more from a operational structural perspective and have that honest conversation as an industry to say no industries as commerce but marketing as well like are we building teams the right way in order to you know meet the moment in this ever -changing reality. I think that's what we need to really think about. The geopolitical conditions aren't going to get any easier, I don't think, anytime soon. Technology is going
to keep accelerating and be more innovations down the road. We're watching AI and watching how AI behaves, but we don't know where it's heading either. So there's so many uncertain pieces to it. So if we can just come closer as a team and really think through how we can be stronger together, I think we can just be much, much more effective. for brands, for companies, you know, inside and out. And I would say, I don't think it can just be one item. I think what Thomas is saying is we need to work on all
of them because they do work in concert. But what I would say is without... the deep business understanding, there is no place to go. You must start with that. You must be seen as a business person informed. That's why we're all here at CAN, to soak it all in, to hear different points of view, and to give the assurance to the marketers, the communicators, the CEO, that we are going to solve real business problems. And we have many tools to use, but let's first understand
the business. Yeah. Okay. Well said. I think the research is very illuminating. I'd really recommend people go through the findings. And I also think that it's quite impressive that you've been able to get a group of marketers to engage. um you know so substantially with questions around ccos and reputation so well done to you and well done to xeno on coming out with this study um i hope you have a great week ahead of you it's been a real pleasure looking
forward to our dinner yeah indeed we will we're going to gather some ccos and cmos and we'll actually try and try and talk this stuff through in person. So that will be fascinating as well. And you can find all of that on the Earn First website and of course on our channels and on Zeno's channels as well. So thank you, Barbie and Thomas. Thanks a lot. Thanks for being here. All right. And a big thank you as well to our production partners at Real Films.
Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...
Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...
Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO...
GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...
Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to...