In this episode of the Earned First podcast, Gil Bashe, chair of health and purpose at Finn Partners, argues that healthcare’s most urgent crisis is no longer innovation or access, but institutional credibility. Speaking during a visit to India, Bashe draws on his new book, Healing the Sick Care System: Why People Matter, to explain how healthcare systems have become optimised for process, compliance, and risk management - often at the expense of patient belief and human connection. The conversation explores increasing scepticism towards healthcare institutions is, how health influencers are filling a trust vacuum left by institutions, and why misinformation has become a symptom of credibility failure. Bashe also addresses the depth of public anger directed at insurers, the global legitimacy gap between institutions and community voices, and what healthcare communicators must unlearn in a low-trust environment.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Earned First podcast. My name is Arun Sudarman. I'm founding editor at Earned First, and I'm very lucky to be joined today by Gil Bash, who's the author of Healing the Sick Care System, Why People Matter. Gil is also chair of health and purpose at Finn Partners, advises healthcare organizations globally. Finn, of course, is... a U .S.-headquartered firm, but is increasingly active across Asia Pacific,
now expanding into the Middle East. And Gil is with us here in India today, visiting Hyderabad. Gil, welcome. How's your trip going so far? first of all thank you very much for the gracious welcome and uh i'd like to believe that my major focus of course is on finn partners and its mission and also i've authored a book so i'll just flip your intro for a second the visit is going extremely well for for many different reasons one as you know we're um and you've been a long supporter and i thank you we're we're a major presence
in india with offices throughout the country and representing of course many of the world's great life science companies here in India. There's an increased interest in this market for many good reasons. India has an incredible policy infrastructure. supported nationally and regionally. Hyderabad has really become a mega center for technology. It's India's high -tech city. And as you drive around, and I'm sure you have, you've
been here before, you really see the influence of multinational companies on this city. establishing their headquarters. Companies like Novartis, which have about 9 ,000 employees in India, they're not just focused on India, they're focused on actually supporting Novartis around the world. And this is just one example of many of the world's great life science companies that have come to the city and to India. So it's a great visit. I get a chance to hear moment by moment. incredible
accolades about our work with SPHE Finn in this market. And as someone who's very passionate about this work, it's always very reassuring when people pull you aside and are raving about your colleagues. There's nothing sweeter to hear, my friends. So it's been a great visit, a busy visit. And yes, the book here in the city has been a surprising hit of how word has... reached um people here in the industry i'm getting direct
messages from people also there's been a major feature about the book in the um in the city's newspaper so um i i don't think there's disguise on when i leave my uh my room so i can get something i don't think it's that popular but it's touching people's hearts here and that i'm grateful for so thank you it's it's great to hear that and and we will talk about fin partners a little bit later on. But let's talk about the book first. You were kind enough to share some excerpts with
me, which I'd read. And of course, the focus, to some extent, is on the US healthcare system. But the themes, I feel, are universal. And one of those themes is that healthcare institutions command enormous authority, but they are challenged. by declining public confidence in them. And I think that's a global theme. And so I wanted to start there. Why do you think healthcare is
struggling to sustain that institutional credibility despite such an important life -saving role? Yeah, it's a number of reasons. I wish I could say it's this one reason and we'll fix it. Let me just say everyone in the health system, no matter what element you represent, whether you're a government payer or a private payer or a physician or a physician specialist or a nurse or pharmacist or a technical staff in the health system, whether
you're involved in product innovation or patient advocacy or policy, everybody wants the system to deliver for the people it seeks to serve, in theory. What happens is that in between the desire and the application of health, we've become a process -driven system that's transactional. How much does it cost? How much do you get paid? How much is it reimbursed? Who pays for the reimbursement? And so that middle part actually has disrupted the historic relationship between the healer
and those people who are seeking to be healed. And that disruption has become so vast that people feel separated from the the system itself so when you look at a doctor in in this city and i met with quite a few they are when i say to an orthopedic surgeon what's your specialty in orthopedic surgery somebody might say hip or rotator cuff or knee And so as medicines become
more specialized, doctors suddenly channel their ambition, not to you, aren't in the person, but your rotator cuff. And the relationship becomes about the it within you rather than the whole you. And that's not why people got into medicine when they they first entered into the field. It was actually they were. probably pretty passionate about healing people over time when they have to justify the cost and their time and their continuing medical education suddenly they become
less interested in why they got into medicine and surviving medicine that's on the professional side on the consumer side we realize that our voices actually are minimized our experience how many people go into the doctor you might do it one of your colleagues might do it and and come in with some online printouts whether it's open ai or google whatever the case might be and you go into the doctor to ask some questions and you have sheets of paper in front of you
and they immediately look not at you But if the sheets of paper and they gear themselves emotionally, ready to argue back, you know, don't believe Dr. Google, believe me. I've even in the book, I cite one instance where a doctor said to my face, as I'm with a patient who happened to be my daughter, is my daughter. The doctor said, who are you going to believe me? Who are you going to believe, me or a patient? That little vignette is in the book. And try to think about. my daughter's experience in the room. She was
the patient. The doctor is saying, I don't believe you. I believe only me. Medicine is a relationship. And the book's global theme, and thank you for mentioning that, the global theme is essentially we've got to rebuild a health system that remembers our humanity. And you and I come from the precious discipline of communication. i mean you're you're an ambassador for our discipline and i thank you for that but try to imagine that the system
stops communicating with i don't say to with the people it seeks to serve we start to feel marginalized and that's what's happened globally more and more it's happening now interestingly and i compliment um the minister of of um of information technology who i met with twice while i've been here he said to his audience we have to build in this country india we have to build
a system that is compassionate and caring considers access and deals with not only those who are prosperous but those who are struggling to rise to prosperity for a leader to say that distinctly represents a certain sense of self -awareness of what is the responsibility of the system. So it ties back to the original question of how's my visit going? And I would say I am inspired
by the mindfulness of the state government of India here in this state and in others, a chance to hear from them directly. Indeed, I think. sometimes there is a greater focus on health equity in perhaps in countries where there's more balance across all the different actors in this equation. But it's interesting also that
you mentioned the importance of believing, of belief. And you write about that as well. And it seems to me that often the institutions we talk about you know, whether it's payers or whether it's health care systems, have been optimized more for compliance, for efficiency, for risk management, rather than patient belief. And again, this is not an easy question, but how do we shift that so that we reach a situation where patient
belief perhaps is taken as seriously as these other factors? Yes. So historically, in a pre information curated era who chose physicians and other health professionals by their IQ. My father -in -law, who I mentioned in the book, he passed three years ago, but he graduated from medical school at 21. He was a genius. You know, what we categorize as a genius. He had three
medical specialties and board certified in three aspects of medicine. I mean, he was really that passionate about it. But one of his great superpowers was almost complete retention of information. And so if we look at some of the great physicians of the fifties and sixties and seventies and eighties, they not only had great clinical skill, they had great memorization of data. They were walking open AI human machines that made them.
Now, if they could combine that with humanity, a sense of personality, a sense of retaining their passion for patient care, they became medical superstars. They had the whole package, right? They had the skill and they had the connection to the people they were trying to help. And that's what made them rise to the top of the system. Now into the information age and suddenly and specialization, new innovation that drives clinicians
to say, I no longer just deal with orthopedic surgery in general. I only do hip replacement or I don't, I'm not a gastroenterologist. I focus on upper GI disorders or I'm not a neurologist. I only focus on. on on particular illnesses and so as medicine moved to the specialization it started to separate more and more from its humanity and so the the prospect is is that none of our
pieces of the health system actually share a common metric if you think about it um these have a different metric than the government the government has a different metric than insurance companies insurance companies different metric than health innovators, biopharmaceutical companies. They don't share an economic system. They're not aware of the supply chain of costs. And they're measured by their stakeholders differently. They have to share a common metric in order to feel
part of an overarching care community. And that is us, right? They have to look at their impact on us. you are to the human being side of this the easier it is to say what's my impact on that person's life and so the the the panacea from all this was we have to rebuild a system that in fact remembers why it was created for the sake of humanity instead of for the sake of you
know what's the shareholder value for this quarter and how many billions did we make in profit that's an outcome of great work it's not the goal of the work the goal of the work is to focus people if we focus on people in theory we do that very well money should follow consistently i mean right will be valued so i look at this you've been covering my sector of health communications for for decades and i thank you for that the when i entered it's hard for me to say it four
decades ago the whole thing was The focus of news was inventing medicines that created a life -saving difference, that kept people alive, that overcame heart disease, that sought to push back cancer, extend life, survival, push on survival, to take people who had mental health concerns and make their lives better. And that's how we drove the news initially, because it was real.
And now we talk statistically, how many patients are impacted, what's the cost, all that. That's important, but it's not the dominant factor. I think the dominant factor is care about you. And we've got to get back to that. Absolutely. The backdrop, as we've mentioned here, is not just declining confidence in healthcare systems, but in institutions in general, I think. whether
it's government, whether it's corporations. And one thing that you often hear is that more transparency is required to reverse that trend. Is that enough? No, it's not enough. I do believe in transparency, timeliness to build trust. I do believe in that. I think when you're transparent and you're timely about that, you're not forced into transparency and you should build trust. One of the aspects I believe, and I indirectly covered in the book,
I do highlight certain people I've encountered that buck the system, not intentionally. Their behavior is unique to their belief system and personality as leaders. And as a result of that, you trust them most certainly. You believe in them. You know, I cite people like, you know, you've probably encountered either personally or in the news, people like, well, Roy Vagelos of Merck, who automated ivermectin, the drug,
to overcome river blindness. That was the scourge of many nations. Now it's almost eradicated around the world because of Dr. Vagelos' decision. Or Ken Frazier, who made some very bold decisions during his tenure at Merck. I cite them. I cite some. incredible doctors. I have the privilege of speaking to world -class doctors and working with them who will take a call from a patient late at night. And they don't even know the person,
but they know the person is worried and they make the time. They're passionate about helping people get better. And I cite those by name. Now, those that I felt fell short of the mark. I don't mention by name and I don't mention their institution. I mentioned the instance to just create the dichotomy. I think we have to applaud those people, those leaders that are putting themselves out there. Let me talk about our profession for a second, communication and thought leadership. What is thought leadership? It's not visibility
and it's not just amplification of voice. It's influence. And we sometimes think thought leadership is about projection of self. It's really about saying, I respect that person. And as a result of that, I attribute what they're doing to their enterprise as well. And so a lot of senior leaders of our health industry seek to project news about the company. The company is the star. But let's
face it, you cover... who cover, let's say, agencies or companies that have communications departments. But actually, don't you think the candor, transparency, engagement, connection to the market of the leadership is what makes you feel an affinity for the company or its ability to navigate a difficult circumstance? It's not what the company does, it's what its
leaderships commit. the company will do so i kind of try to channel that in the book there's some two things consistent in the book that have i think um framed my infant there's belief in great communication one is collaboration when people are willing to work with people across the aisle and the other is communication in my introduction i cite the story if you remember of apollo 13. The spacecraft that almost didn't
come back home was on its way to the moon. The mission shifted to sort of say after an explosion inside the capsule, how do we get these people home alive? Oxygen system was depleting. Power was depleting. Navigation was depleting. They had to retreat from the ship into the capsule that would bring them back to Earth. What wasn't destroyed was the communication system. Without that communication system, they would have died in space, tragically, horrifically. On Earth,
what made it work? They brought a batch of people from different disciplines who knew the capsule well into a room, and they had to collaborate. And so the combination of communication and collaboration brought three heroic, brave astronauts safely home again. I seek to sort of say we need to apply that to the health system right now. We can communicate with each other and we can choose
to collaborate with each other. Payers and doctors have to learn to collaborate. Payers or doctors often cite the fact that they spend two hours a day arguing with payers about prior authorization and they feel burnt out about it. Two hours a day. We know we have to help that person. What's the game plan? We have to collaborate. We have to share responsibility for that person, not just the economics around the person. So I do
touch on that, and I believe that deeply. And it's probably one of the reasons why, since you've been watching FinPartners, you've risen to be one of the great communications agencies in the world today. Our behavior sets the client up. for success are you surprised by the depth of rage um that exists now you you talked about prior authorization that seems to be um you know
and especially a triggering phrase these days um particularly in the us we've seen protests we've even seen you know quite tragic situations unfolding The murder of Brian Thompson, the United Healthcare CEO. It indicates a depth of rage towards insurance companies. And I wonder if, is it as simple as collaboration and empathy
to solve, you know, a level of anger that seems beyond anything we've seen before? So I do write about that in the book and I've written about that situation privately at the request of magazines. When, first of all, murder is murder. There's no justification for murder, period. But when we examine the situation itself and we realize that the murderer, Luigi, developed sort of a
fan club. And he's raised a million dollars on crowdsourcing for his legal defense. It's not a question of how many or the magnitude of people that are sympathetic toward him. It's that there are people who are sympathetic toward him. And so insurance companies have to step back and say, whether we're doing the right thing or not, we're painted by the same brush right now. And we have to rethink our relationship. with what
they term beneficiaries, but they're customers. Customers are angry at them or upset or frustrated or frightened. Now, part of it is I get letters from my insurance company. I won't mention them, but I think I understand the English language relatively well. And I certainly understand health relatively well if I don't understand the English language. I cannot make heads or tails of these letters at times. I don't know if they were written by a lawyer who didn't take English 101 or someone
just whipped them out or they have their poor use of prompts in OpenAI and they've been written by a large language model that's gone amok. But I get letters such as my daughter who has a rare disease. We get letters a year and a half after a medical procedure asking us to explain to the insurance company why a neurologist was present during a surgery and to provide the medical documentation.
Certainly, my daughter, who is under anesthesia, doesn't know that there was a neurologist available. And I do not have medical records. Probably, it's better directed to the provider than me. the letter is certainly directed to me as the policyholder and i say to myself gee if um if that was nordstrom writing to me a clothing store in the united states asking me to explain why the bow ties i wear have been defective for a
segment of society i would say don't you think you should dress this to nordstrom's instead of me the person who bought the bow tie it's run amok and i think insurance companies have to sort of say we need to train everybody on customer service. We need to train that when people call us who are dealing with life concerns, they're anxious and we're making them more anxious. And our job is not to do that. And if we want to do prior authorization, the best medical practice,
we need to have a better explanation of what we're doing in terms of managing care rather than delaying. delaying care. So I do think there's a huge need for internal communications. I think there's a need for external communications. I think there's a need to set down goals of what the relationship should be like between the company and the people it serves, its customers. And so the book sort of examined those situations from the point of view, how do we emotionally feel about this? Now, as an agency, We sometimes
look at tools or tactics, but I think that I have the highest regard for my colleagues here. And I mentioned being here in India with SPG Finn. When I hear the sensitivity that they deploy in terms of the holistic relationship between the company and the people it seeks to serve, I feel inspired and reassured. Same with the United States. They're thinking not just about representing the company's interests, but representing
the company's connection to the people it serves. And that includes shareholders, by the way. That includes policymakers. That includes insurance companies. But it includes patients and caregivers, not as an afterthought, but as a primary initiative. And that's what we need more of in our industry. We're a little off course right now. And the book acknowledges that. And I get letters and calls and DMs on LinkedIn from people. thanking me um thanking me for putting it straight actually
someone wrote a big review on amazon that uh i don't let anybody off the hook but they also say that's true i don't um and if people know me i don't let myself off the hook even but so right i leave everyone hopeful that we can we can we can do something about this pretty darn quickly and that's my experience also It's not a broken system. It's a system that needs more self -awareness. So Gil, one other thing I wanted
to ask you about, and your responses now, some of the things you've said, they kind of, to me, indicate that the level of skepticism that we're seeing isn't just a matter of ignorance, but in a way it's kind of behavior that people are learning. And if you take that as the context, the rise of health influences is something that we're seeing every day. Their influence grows.
Are they filling an information gap or are they exploiting a trust gap? Both. It's not one or the other. They are people like, let's say, Matthew Zachary. who actually endorsed this book. I saw it for its true intent. He was the creator of the organization Stupid Cancer when he was diagnosed with brain cancer during his college years. And he's been on the cover of Newsweek. He's certainly
a major influencer. He has a great book coming out, actually, I guess, not spoiler alert, but preview alert. But I had a chance to read the manuscript. It's great. It's absolutely... it's a it's a well -needed book his rise in popularity is because people do want champions out there so we call them influencers i think he's a he's a champion for patient voice the patient needs more equity in the conversation and and people like him and others are going to do that so the
rise of influencers are because we feel we need advocates who have clout So that's needed because the system is starting to marginalize the patient more and more. And it's actually elevating the system. We need balance. And I think influencers like that create balance. I don't think it's a question of lack of distrust or lack of belief in the system. I think people hold innovation in very high regard. I think they want the connection
between the innovation and what does it mean for me? Why should I care to be clearer in language that speaks to their needs? And that's why influencers are rising. So I think that we have a number of people out there who I look forward to seeing, I look forward to hearing from. And I think that when I speak to my daughter, for instance, about her health journey, I learn. I feel inspired. I also feel worried and sad at times. But that's
the range of human emotions that influences bring out in us. So I think it's needed. But I don't think it's out of distrust. I think it's because we've long neglected the voice of the consumer, of the patient. Indeed, yes. Influences, I guess, feel more human, more accessible. more in line with people's experiences. In this part of the world, one observation is that community voices sometimes carry more legitimacy than formal systems, institutions. But the risk, of course, is that
they're not operating to the same standards. How much does it worry you that influences may legitimize misinformation? Well, it's a very big concern. And certainly, when we look at AI, when we think that AI is infallible, actually 71 % of medical information curated is inaccurate. And often the consumer may or may not have that knowledge. So obviously, health professionals
play a very critical role in not dismissing that information, but in clarifying it. And I think that's very important. But influencers like a Matthew Zachary who've lived through the experience actually are experts. They're experts in their journey. You can't discount their journey. And so it helps us. If you were to buy a house or a car or a washing machine, you might speak to someone who bought that model, bought in that
neighborhood. It's the same thing with a patient. They've kind of had to buy in. without the desire. Nobody wants to be in a hospital, but they had to buy into the experience. And their sharing that experience helps us create context. And that's why they're so important. I would say, I just want to point out something. I write about Dr. Mike Rosenblatt, who was Merck's first chief medical officer in the book. I have great regard for Mike. He went on to be chief medical officer
flagship. He's now a consultant. He serves on many boards. He was born in a displaced persons camp. And his parents came to the United States as refugees, as immigrants. And that experience, that childhood experience, has colored his perspective of what it is to be a doctor, to be a healer. He's very accessible. He talks about how his daughter almost died in childbirth. He realizes with all his might and connections, he's vulnerable.
He's human. That's the essence of all this. Whether you're the CEO of one of the world's largest health companies, pharmaceutical companies, or whether you're a doctor in rural India, it doesn't make a difference. We're human. We're finite. We're on a journey. We have to remember that humanity to humanity connection. in order to do effective work. When companies view themselves as universes rather than as conduits to healing,
they get a little off course. We've got to get everything back on course of saying, hey, why do I exist? I exist to serve. I exist to serve people who have needs. Or indeed, whether you're a healthcare communicator, how do you hold on to that humanity? as you build finn partners for example across asia pacific across the middle east well first of all culture is critical i i give a big tip of the hat to peter finn who established finn partners on the basis of seven
values that are um are critical to our operating nature and the decision -making process and peter cares deeply about that and he's representative he's a model for those values and um and he's a role model for all of us he's a mentor So that's one. You have to do it by culture. Now, often having been, as you know, in the big holding companies myself and being a CEO of one of the holding companies, bigger enterprises for some time, what happens is as leaders, we get very
much into reporting and reporting and making sure the balance sheet is accurate and our lives center around the balance sheet as opposed to. the role of health communication in protecting and saving people's lives peter is very mission oriented now if you look at if you said why are you doing finn partners for instance he'd say well i want to create a global community that has a heart and a conscience that could serve major everywhere a heart and a conscience he's he didn't say i want to create a a global communications
company that has x amount in revenue that's an outcome he knows that You have to have leadership that's clear of why the enterprise exists. And does the enterprise make a difference in the world? You know, I'm very passionate about what I do, but I'm also very passionate about where I do it from. And so we bring aboard people like Aman and Shivani Gupta, who lead SPAG Finn in India and now are looking toward the Middle East.
There's a cultural harmony that exists that makes us exponentially stronger. And I've listened to recently, I attended a seminar on selling your agency, what matters. Very impressive presentation. What matters is the balance sheet, free cash flow, opportunities for growth and revenue. I listened to all this and I pinged Peter afterward and I said, you should see this tape. It's interesting. Peter talks about what's his priority. It's culture. It's about sharing values. It's about how they
treat their people. It's about a sense of helping people grow. It's about how do they serve their communities. It's a different mindset. And you would say, hey, how can that work? Well, guess what? We're not experiencing layoffs. We don't have turnover of staff. We don't have turnover of clients. What's wrong with our model? It's a pretty darn good model. And I think people feel inspired because they feel whether you're
in travel or education, whether you're dealing with consumer marketing goods, whether you're dealing with technology, regardless, or health, regardless. we seek to impact the world in positive ways. And I think that really speaks to the generation that's entering into our field right now. I think that generation that will lead us forward isn't really thinking about how big we are. I think they're thinking about how good we are to the world. And at a time of sustained consolidation,
I suspect these lessons could not be more topical. Gil, you have been... a wonderful guest on the podcast i i thank you for your time i know you must have you must have a busy schedule in hyderabad today i have an exciting schedule today i returned to bioasia 2026 the 23rd gathering of the world community here of in asia to talk about the biosciences and again it's a privilege to see i did not know
it it was a privilege to see finn partners amongst the sponsors of this great gathering and again i thank my colleagues in this market for making that possible thank you so much gil and safe travels thank you my friend thank you so much same to you
Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...
Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...
Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO...
GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...
Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to...