Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Earned First

Earned First artwork

Carolyn Devanayagam on how Asia's brands navigate the America First era

Sep 18, 202534 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode Arun Sudhaman is joined by Carolyn Devanayagam, head of Weber Advisory for Asia-Pacific and managing director, Singapore at Weber Shandwick. They discuss how geopolitical shifts - from tariff regimes to political rhetoric - are reshaping corporate communications, forcing CEOs and comms teams to take public positions and manage complex stakeholder demands. Devanayagam argues this environment is simultaneously a risk and an opportunity for Asian brands: those that combine operational strength with cultural humility and purpose can own a seat at the global table. The conversation closes with a practical look at talent: diversified hiring, advisory groups across policy/AI/government, and the balance of tech fluency with human listening and judgement.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to the Earned First podcast. This is Arun Sudharman, founding editor at Earned First. I'm very happy to be joined today by Carolyn Devanayagam, who's the head of Weber Advisory for Asia Pacific and managing director of Singapore at Weber Shandwick. Carolyn, welcome to the podcast. Thank you, Arun. It's always a pleasure and great to see you. And once again, congratulations on Earned First. Just such a remarkable feat. And yeah, looking forward to our conversation today.

Well, thank you very much. It's a real pleasure to have you on the show today. And in particular, because you want to talk about or we want to talk about a topic that I think is really crucial at the moment. So a few weeks ago, I wrote a newsletter about how geopolitics had become the top priority. for corporate affairs leaders and this was a little bit of a surprise in a way not if you're looking at the recent history of

the communications world i think we're all aware of how geopolitics has emerged as such an important trend but if you were to go back say 10 to 15 years for example and i'm aware you've been at weber now for two decades carolyn geopolitics hasn't always been such a big driver in terms of the boardroom, in terms of the communications agenda. So how surprising is it for you that it's now the number one priority amongst corporate affairs leaders? I mean, Aaron, to your point,

right, I don't think it's a shock just for you. I think it's for all of us. And, you know, honestly speaking, and having done corporate throughout my career, and you said now for almost two decades, it feels like it just... came upon us and and obviously you know the last couple of years it has just been the most intense and you know where we basically couldn't differentiate as we were

basically counseling and taking clients through the strategic comms initiatives was basically the impact of what geopolitics had on their business and how basically they had to stand up and shore up communications -wise. So for me, it is definitely something that we are We can't deny it's happening all around us. And it's also why, you know, Weber Advisory has come in to bear the impact of the

need to balance the geopolitical, you know. on the outside and then also to understand where clients want to be from a brand and reputation wise and then to merge it at that intersection of basically business and we call it culture but obviously culture here is all encompassing and geopolitics plays a huge part of what that means as it shapes up the external environment across all dimensions. So one of the studies

that I cited in that newsletter was from Weber Advisory. And it looked at how the America first environment in terms of policies, in terms of rhetoric is impacting American brands worldwide. And I think it's quite important to look at this because, you know, in this comms world, still largely driven to a significant extent. by US -based multinationals. And while US brands are

viewed as often as transcending their country's politics, the study from Weber Advisory finds that US policies are undermining brand America on the global stage, particularly thanks to tariff hikes, which are prompting a loss of faith in US trade and investment partnerships. That's an interesting finding. I don't think it would surprise too many people. But what does that mean for Asian brands? Because there seems to

be a lot of interest in terms of how these shifts will impact domestic homegrown players who are perhaps looking to expand beyond their home markets. Absolutely. Like you said, we look at it in a way as an opportunity. It's not that they are not impacted by the tariffs and what is obviously going on geopolitically and what it means to basically do business with America. However, as you would have seen, Asian brands are stepping

up onto the global stage and that too with confidence. uh they have showed up um and with leadership that is really a driving force in bringing innovation um cultural relevance and you know truly a new way of thinking to the table so what we are seeing is um an opportunity for these brands um in this um you know, in this era where there is some level of pessimism to truly, you know, own the seat at the table and to also shape, not just

participate in the future of global commerce. And, you know, having... the opportunity to represent some of the world's largest Asian brands out of APAC as well as globally, we are definitely seeing and feeling that impact. And it's a good place to be in, we feel, for those big Asian conglomerates. Do you feel that they are ready for perhaps the kind of scrutiny that companies...

So -called foreign brands, when they expand into international markets, often there's a level of interest, perhaps in their supply chains, in their labor practices, in their environmental standards, that they may not attract in their home markets. Has that changed at all, do you think, in recent years, their preparation for these kinds of questions that are sometimes a little uncomfortable? Absolutely. I think, to be fair, Aaron, it happens for some Asian brands

more than others, the scrutiny. That said, we have definitely seen a growing respect as well as, you know, confidence as these brands take to the global stage. It is not without any sort of, you know, obviously a necessary business. uh concerns that you know i would say that any other brands would face but what we are definitely

seeing is there is a change in the tide we are definitely seeing less of what we would have probably seen even pre -covered um and with a growing up and a sort of assurance that asian brands are bringing to the table and they are basically really offering solutions and innovation which is very tailored uh very culturally resonant uh bringing in a lot of that operational might agility um and in in really fast growing um complex

markets and we do feel that um they are also being able to marry um you know the asian roots and the way they do business uh with you know with local practices um abroad and in that you know they are basically anchoring a lot of the asian might um in in in markets by bringing in those capabilities keeping on to that identity while also you know learning to be more um you know uh you know culturally relevant um you know

overseas and i think that is something that i feel um asian brands definitely have is the ability to very quickly adapt understand learn and you know more than anything they listen um it is not just about you know um you know just going um with force and and with might that isn't without consideration and that is what we are feeling and i think and seeing and it is representative of just how strong some of the major brands are in B2B and in B2C. Like I said, Arun, there is

obviously with any brand, to be fair, but definitely, you know, so as you pointed out with Asian brands, some level of concern, pessimism. And obviously, you know, depending on where geopolitically some of the relationships lie, there is still obviously those concerns that do arise. But we are definitely seeing that, you know, taper off when it comes to the might and the operational excellence they are bringing to the table. Right. Yeah. And I think it's important you mentioned how crucial

it is for them to listen. And I think that's something that perhaps they understand quite well in terms of their, like you said, like their own cultural underpinnings. Do you see a difference in the way that Asian brands present themselves, the way they go to market, and perhaps how their unique cultures can be used to build trust? Absolutely. In fact, as we are helping brands and a lot of

Asian brands, as I mentioned, grow. It is remarkable to see that, you know, as they look for agility and as they look for scale, they are definitely putting a lot of purpose at the center of it. And I think that is fundamentally an Asian value that, you know, we can't separate from the culture, but it's a beautiful part of. about being asian and about being an asian brand and i do think that is a huge differentiator because definitely

i mean the cause and and the might of doing business and the need to be profitable is very much front and center but in order for them to do it with impact um and to definitely leave um a sense of purpose and what they're doing is definitely coming through there is one to um also um carry forward a culture a culture that is unique to asia and you're seeing that right in some of the strongest parts of um of of the world um of the following of asian culture now whether

it's k -pop anime um to design thinking that you're getting um from this part of the world you're seeing that come through most so but i what i've i feel you know between the one to grow and scale and have a presence and own it and be an equal at the table is also a sense of humility. As they learn, they evolve. And like I said, that comes also with listening. They're okay to pause, reflect. understand and

really take in what the market and the landscape gives versus just pushing. And I think there is a lot of very good balancing in the act and the way they do that. And that's a huge differentiator for me, the place that it comes from. And I want to just recognize that for me, as I view it, it comes from a place of humility as well. That's a really important point. One of the common criticisms

of American brands, not always, but sometimes, is that they are overly dictated from head office. Strategies are made for the world as a whole. It's underpinned a very successful model. But these days you could argue that it's perhaps causing more challenges in different markets,

which have different priorities, different expectations, and so forth. And what it often calls for is perhaps local leaders, local insight, local empowerment, rather than a one -size -fits -all policy. So just reversing that question, towards asian brands do you think are they ready to let go um in the same way or do you still see that as a challenge i mean aaron i would take it as there is there

is a certain level of um benefit having a more centralized um way of of running in operations there's definitely efficiency there's consistency um it's easier to manage especially in crisis however i hear you Excuse me. What we are definitely seeing is the need to strike a balance. You know, I don't think it's a matter today of decentralization versus decentralization. We have to find some

level of equilibrium that brings the benefit of both. And some brands are doing it better than others. I've experienced with Asian and with global... brands that are basically the headquartered out of Europe or the United States that have gone through, you know, the, you know, the extremes of being Truly centralized. And like I said, bearing the benefits of that, but also the challenges. And then, you know, completely

decentralizing and leaving it all to the markets to decide. And also, you know, realizing what that brings to, you know, to in good and in bad, you know, operational, especially when it comes to consistency and efficiency. And so we have definitely, you know, worked with clients to see how we can manage it, you know, in a more, you know, like I said, with some level of equilibrium.

And I think Asian brands, as I see it and feel it and have experienced it, they're beginning to learn. uh how to do that without looming i think a lot of times it's about losing the essence of the brand and what they stand for and um and a part of that would be to ensure that you know how you place yourself in um any foreign market still you know basically there's a lot of um of the culture and the and the and the um brand that still basically, you know, is kept and resonates

with local, you know, external, let alone internal audiences. And we are seeing a lot of that take place. And we, in fact, are helping a lot of our global Asian brands who are, you know, obviously mighty global brands that have, you know. presence across the world ensure the cultural peace is managed and through, you know, especially as they go through change. And, you know, you can't help going through change today in this volatile

environment. And sometimes, you know, it's done, you know. you know, for whether there are right sizings involved or whether there's a need to expand, et cetera. But at the core of it, how to keep the culture peace and to make sure that basically is extremely a lift and adjustable as brands basically evolve and do business. And like I said, you know, a couple of years ago, most of that work would have been done probably by just U .S. and European headquarters. But

now you're seeing. Asian brands who have gone abroad are really taking that path seriously to ensure the success of the business. It's great to hear. It's probably worth perhaps digressing a little bit here because not all Asian brands are created equal, first of all. And secondly, Asia is a very big place. So when we're talking about Asian brands, are you perhaps referring to specific markets? the companies from Japan

and from Korea that have made waves globally. But are you seeing emergence of brands from other countries? I'm curious to hear your thoughts on that because we've heard a lot about Chinese companies going global, for example. But I guess it's quite an interesting environment right now. Absolutely. And we work with a few and it's definitely the North Asian brands of Japan and Korea. They've

done that too for a very, very long time. And I think with a lot more, you know, I would say calmer and easier, you know, geopolitical, you know. considerations in comparison to obviously China, for example. That said, we are seeing a huge amount of Chinese brands who have gone global. We're also working with Indian brands

who have made global stage, as well as brands coming through in Southeast Asia and even, of course, Australia. I mean, there are a pool of brands, and I would say North Asia tends to dominate the landscape, and that's what you typically are familiar with and you see, especially because a lot of them also have a very strong B2C presence. But I do not want to dismiss what we are seeing,

especially coming out of India, as well as even in, like I said, Southeast Asia. and um and you know it also really depends on the um industry our own um and and and and and how they basically um have have played some of them have been across uh the globe for many many years and you know with the with the with the surgeons and the and the passion now for a lot of newer and and and more uh evolving brands that you know it's almost like there's there's a second coming and some

have basically just held global global states so I think, you know, to summarize, I think there has always been a dominance in North Asia, and that includes China, but I'm definitely experiencing and we are definitely seeing the rest of Asia coming to ban that too very nicely. That's great to see. So one of the other considerations in the Weber Advisory Report, just to refer to that

again for a moment, is that brands, I think it's specified American brands, should avoid politics, which seems like great advice. But I suspect it's more difficult in practice than in theory. So how do you handle that kind of an equation? Because presumably it's a similar consideration for, I would say, not just American brands right

now. I think for all brands at this time where there's so much heightened complexity and sensitivity, it would seem to make sense to maybe be more cautious about political statements or being involved in politics at all. But it's hard, right? Questions about supply chain can raise political considerations. First of all, is it a realistic

goal to just avoid politics altogether in today's day and age? It is extremely hard. And we experience it across the board, you know, with clients. And it's not limited to just American brands. You know, brands are expected, especially today with the power and the voice of the employee. um they expect to um have their leadership um take a position the brand they work for take

a position um you know uh there is a lot around boycotts and um the the issue of you know not participating pulling out of a certain location due to various um you know geopolitically um charged um situation um you know uh you know we saw that happen even during covid um as well as you know obviously the wars over the last couple of years um in various locations around the world has also put a lot of pressure on brands

um to take a position because the employees demanded and then once it's and then it's just then you realize it's not just limited to the employee um people who buy from the brands, whether it's a B2B brand or a B2C brand, today expect a certain sense of responsibility that comes on them basically procuring from the brand and obviously in the way the brand handles certain situations. And

so, like you said, it's really hard to play an independent role from the situation. absolutely the position is to not get involved obviously no one is going to condone or support anything that's against, you know, human rights, humanitarian situations, etc. And the stance is always to promote goodwill, to do the right thing by all human kind, as well as to operate in the most ethical and transparent and the best way possible.

And so, you know, that's also going back to the purpose, right? And to ensuring the brand basically keeps its integrity throughout. But it's hard. It's hard. We see a lot of brands struggling with that day in, day out, especially if they have a presence in locations or in quadrants of verticals that are highly conflicted or basically...

it's a difficult place to be. And I do admire leadership today in terms of just how they've had to step up. And I think it also goes back to, you know, we also put out, you know, a lot around CEOs and their roles and their evolving roles. It has definitely gone beyond, you know, the expectation of just making decisions in the boardroom. There's a huge responsibility being put on them to exercise a great amount of impact

outside the boardroom today and that too to impact um you know at times um um politically charged um situations so i really i don't have a simple um yes or no the the the the council that we continuously give clients is obviously doing right and to ensure that the brand's integrity is always managed as well as you know ensuring the people that they serve always you know captured for in the right way. But it's a very, very hard

place to be in now, given, like you said, you know, geopolitical needs are strife. I mean, you have to have a certain position. And even if you want to keep the most neutral line, and we're not wanting to veer away from that. Yeah, it does seem like, you know, almost sometimes it seems like a no win. situation. But I definitely don't envy corporates and indeed CEOs having

to try and walk that tightrope. But like you said, they have to balance competing demands, including their employees who more often than not these days are looking for a certain stance sometimes or reassurance even. Of course, if we look over at America, we see significant retreat in terms of areas like purpose and ESG and even

diversity and inclusion and we see companies who are far more reticent about taking on these issues than they were you know three or four years ago there's a significant backlash has that impacted companies in this part of the world at all whether that's multinationals or Asian companies Slightly. I wouldn't say there was no impact at all. Slightly. But at the same time, I would say it hasn't stopped. it continues uh

the asian brands are definitely forging ahead the multinationals are definitely considering and doing what is what is expected and going um you know by by the the the countries they operate in and where possible doing more um there is obviously and this is going back to that earlier question um or i should say topic around you know, the headquarters setting, setting the mandate and needing to follow and how you basically balance

that in especially in much more centralized. operational structures, we are definitely seeing some clients who've come to us to basically bring those realities to the table, but also not wanting to stop or basically regress from all the investment and the efforts and just the lives that have been impacted and changed as a result of some of these great initiatives that have been done over the last year. As I recall, I'm speaking to you, Arun, a couple of years ago, just on,

you know, where we were in Asia and where we should be. And, you know, we've come a long way. That was a few years ago. And I think where where we are basically seeing, you know. the feedback around, you know, what should we do is, you know, at the same time, it's like we don't want to lose momentum and basically regress. So just how do we manage the reality of what is going on over in the US and the expectation around that? And how do we basically keep forging ahead?

But, you know, obviously putting the right, you know. boundaries as well as respect back for the headquarters as they continue to do what's right by this side of the globe. Yeah, it's another really tricky situation, right? Because you sort of think we're thousands of miles away. There isn't this right wing backlash. You know, there seems to be much broader consensus in Asian markets about things like climate change and societal

progress and so forth for now at least and hopefully for the future too but you can't ignore you know you can't ignore the world's biggest economy you can't ignore where so many of these companies come from so it's a it's a it's a very difficult balancing act again so maybe my final question then is you're looking for and you're looking for people all the time in terms of talent, right, that can handle these kinds of questions and

that can counsel clients on these issues. And I'm curious to know how easy or difficult is it to find the kind of talent that is able to weigh all of these different considerations, first of all, and if not, what kind of skills should perhaps younger people be looking to develop? if they hope to thrive in this kind of environment? Oh, that's a question I feel we can spend hours on. And it's also really, really what you call

this challenging question in the era of AI, where you feel you actually have a tool who's going to be able to do all of that for you. I have to say, Arun, I don't think you're going to find a solve in a single person, which is why we're also diversifying how we hire. We are not finding a single individual who's going to be able to charge through all of it. We're finding people who've got obviously the experience. And obviously you're aware that that's one of the reasons why we put together the group of advisors globally

that cut across a diversified range of capabilities that is... you know, the council is basically, you know, ranging from strategies that cover media, AI, financial comms and government business, because, you know, today it's going to have to be and we're bringing independent thinking to the table, aside from what we already have in the organization. And as we look even at our own advisory and as we capture, you know, what we want to do and take forward for clients, it's

not just about recasting current roles, but it's really looking about how you know our our talent is able to basically bolster uh for this reality out there aside from doing the day -to -day and and a very critical role that they all play in making sure that we are you know ultimately still earned first and bringing the power of um you know true communications to the table. And so as we do that, we also realize clients are just not expecting us to solve at the comms function. But like we said, the intersection has now evolved.

And so we do need to bring in talent that basically are quite diversified and it's not basically a one true fits all. And so, you know, we are working with a much more robust and diversified pool as such that, you know, do not come. from traditional communications backgrounds but really people who have had experience whether like i said in government um you know in the field in ngos um you know in in um you know leading consumer groups activists etc to bring that um to bring a much more holistic uh thinking and in terms

of the younger generation you know i mean having a great um you know influx of talent coming to the firm all the time. You're seeing a lot of them who are just so savvy with the tools today. And, you know, what basically, you know, I feel every day every day i'm learning a new tech tool while for them it's it's it's it's innate it's it's you know right at the at the uh at the edge of their fingertips so um where they basically

can i think can can benefit from the fact that they've got that They're hardwired in tech. They know that. But they can't be over -reliant. There needs to still be that pause, the reflect, the listen. Let's not forget the listening. And using some of those human capabilities that technology cannot replace. And then bringing in your own critical thinking that is still going to be driven by emotions. by uh feelings by personality because

that is the differentiation that you know we have against a tech platform and no matter how advanced a tech platform is to feel um you know understand even love, there is a certain element of human behavior that it cannot replicate. And I think that is where the younger generation needs to balance the human instinct, given how hardwired they are in tech. And we do feel that sometimes that doesn't come through first and

foremost. They are so tech savvy. They're so quick to respond with a hardwired tech first. um you know um mode that um and sometimes you're like no listen hold on you know learn to understand learn to feel learn to experience put yourself in the person's shoes those some some basic fundamentals sometimes can be missing and so i would say the balance and again it's all about today it's all about balance it's all about equilibrium and you can't over index in one versus the other

um and so yeah so that is that is something that you know uh we we keep reminding them, you know, and just to be aware, to read, get deep into the culture, the understanding of the external world and versus relying, you know, 110 % on the tech capabilities that is basically at the edge of their fingertips. Yeah, culture and humanity, I think, probably increasingly important in a

more tech -driven world. And I think... That's a great note on which to end. Carolyn, thank you so much for your time and your insight today. Good luck with the balancing act and with finding that equilibrium. But I'm glad to see that, you know, some of these questions are receiving the kind of level of consideration that they deserve. Thank you. Thank you, Aaron. Always a pleasure. And yeah, I'm looking forward to the next conversation. Take care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Kaizzen’s Vineet Handa on monetisation, Middle East expansion and AI enemies

    Oct 30, 202637 minAudio

    Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jean-Léopold Schuybroek: Four decades of building independent PR

    Oct 13, 202625 minAudio

    Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Geopolitics, Mastercard & OpenAI's CCO search

    Sep 29, 202639 minAudio

    Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why corporate affairs pros want change, with GlobeScan's Chris Coulter

    Aug 24, 202636 minAudio

    GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Culture, Cannes & cockroaches with Charlotte Mceleny

    Jul 30, 202647 minAudio

    Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode