Recorded days after PRAXIS Asia-Pacific in Singapore, this special Earned First episode - created in partnership with Finn Partners - explores what mattered and what’s next. Arun Sudhaman is joined by Finn Partners' leaders James Brasher and Joyce Liong to break down: moving comms from reactive “crisis saviour” to proactive strategy partner; the in-house/agency handshake on data fluency, business acumen and learning agility; why credibility and empathy become the core currency in an AI-saturated ecosystem (avatars, disclosure, authenticity); and how corporate affairs leaders are reinventing roles, mentoring the next generation, and scaling consultancies without losing culture. If you care about measurement beyond vanity metrics, generational renewal, and building influence with the board, this is your field guide from Singapore’s PRAXIS debut.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello everyone and welcome to the Earned First podcast. My name is Arun Sudham and I'm founding editor at Earned First. And this is actually a special podcast that we're doing in partnership with FinPartners. It's going to be an episode that reviews some of the themes, the lessons and perhaps takeaways from Praxis Asia Pacific, which took place in Singapore on the 14th of October. uh just three or four days ago as we
record this maybe when you listen to this a few more days will have passed it was the international debut for praxis praxis is an event that has been running for 12 very successful years in india and it was a huge privilege for me personally to bring it to singapore the response was kind of overwhelming i wasn't expecting The turnout, the support, and really the level of positive feedback as well. It was very good energy in the room. The venue helped. I think being at
the National Gallery in Singapore certainly kind of, I think, helps elevate some of the conversations. And we covered a lot of ground at Praxis. We started out with a conversation with Dr. Bikki Bangu, who... was president of Rolls -Royce for many years, has apparently just accepted a role at Temasek, by the way, the day after the event. I wasn't allowed to talk about it on stage. He
talked about how communicators can prove their value at the highest levels of organizations, which is always very relevant. And then we moved into a variety of topics across geopolitics. the impact of artificial intelligence, of course, what consultancies are doing to differentiate themselves, the tussle for talent, and indeed the reinvention of corporate affairs function. So there's a lot to discuss. And I'm very happy to be joined today by two people who I believe were there the whole day on Tuesday. So joining
us from Singapore, we have James Brasher, who's the managing partner of Rice Fin Partners. Welcome, James. Thank you. And Joyce Leong, who is Senior Partner at FinPartners Singapore. Welcome, Joyce. Thanks, everyone. Nice to be here. Yeah, it's a pleasure to have you both on. So you were both there the whole day on Tuesday? Yeah, we were there. Diligently preparing. I had a slightly
longer lunch than I should have, but I did get in on time. Okay, fantastic. Yeah, well, it was hard because, I mean, honestly, we were not expecting the turnout. And I think we had something like 180 people in the room at lunch. So it was busy. So it took people a while to kind of conclude. the lunch break which is fine i think sometimes you have to let these things flow but no doubt
you were diligently preparing for today's podcast so let me start by asking you both uh and james i'll start with you if that's okay uh what really stood out for you on tuesday what were the themes that really resonated um and that you think perhaps are worthy of further discussion here now well something that you did share in your intro that i have to say i really felt it was really good was it was this vibe this sort of collaborative spirit if you like in the room that made it very
comfortable um i think for people to share which is exactly what you want um at this sort of event but i thought it was at a level you don't usually see or i don't usually feel um and i think that's thanks in large part to the people who spoke and presented their openness But it just really gave way to some really, I think, quality conversation as well. And you weren't too bad yourself, Arun.
I think the best for a moderator or host, the best thing is to be unnoticed. That's the best compliment that can be paid, right? You just don't want to get in the way. Yeah, but I think it really lends itself to a really... good open session um yeah and i think for me some of the big takeaways would be around well even the theme of communications at the crossroads i think that really nicely sums up the place that we as practitioners
find ourselves in um and as was discussed there's a lot going on a lot of disruption i think as you mentioned also in the intro ai was tackled from lots of different angles um all the disruption is making our jobs harder i think harder than ever um and you know i like that what was discussed helped us better prepare for what's going on now but then it was also looking ahead um and
I loved that there was so much focus on the person, on the human impact of the issue, the things that we were discussing. And that made a big difference for me and I think for a lot of people that attended. Just because that's such an important part of what we do and helping us do better is really taking that into account. So it's not just... always talking about the tools or the
issues it's what about the people in all this really good points i think i you know i'd love to say there's some sort of formula or process you can follow that gets to that atmosphere and energy and candor in the room and but there isn't i think it's just a you know it's it's a sort of alchemy um where you kind of have good speakers They're prepared well. I think there's for many
of the people, you know, we've been doing this for many years. Right. So perhaps we've built up a level of trust amongst us, whether that's with not just the people on stage, but also the people in the crowd. Right. The community. So I think that, you know, that's it's a nice thing to see. But I think it's also a reflection of maturity, industry maturity. And if you do these events, perhaps in places where the industry is less mature, I think sometimes you do get less candor because people are a little bit more
insecure, perhaps a little bit more competitive and less willing to really open up about some of these challenges, which is understandable. But as you said, James, we can only kind of tackle and address these problems by, I think, coming together. So, yeah, it's really nice to hear that. And of course, the human angle, that was really what stood out to me, I think, because if you say to someone, yeah, we had three or four sessions on AI, you know, it's not necessarily
the stuff of which dreams are made. I mean, so often it's, yeah, I mean, it could be just AI, AI, AI, AI, AI, AI. Yeah. you know it was not that at all every single session i noticed came back to the people yeah yeah so it really wasn't about ai as so much as it was about what are people grappling with right what is top of mind for the people in this industry and of course ai is one of the things that is really um changing
you know changing a lot of the processes and products and all of that um Joyce, what stood out for you in terms of the discussions on Tuesday? i think um sort of you know supplementing what james said right i think the people in the room did make the biggest difference right everyone's sort of open to discussion and collaboration um and i think what was really nice for me was that there's a well balance of um both the agency as well as a brand side of the perspective um
which is something you may not always see in a um event you know of this um kind right and i think that lends itself to provide a little bit more of a well -rounded perspective. And it's good, like, you know, from my point of view, because I'm coming from agency, right? Hearing from the brand owners or, you know, that really was a little bit more eye -opening, you know, in that sense. So I really liked that part. And I think the main thread that really stood out
for me was that, you know, the roles, whether you're in agency or in the brand side. It's changing. There are all these challenges coming in. What is it that you need to do in order to make yourself a little bit more ready for the future? Yeah, interesting as well, because I think sometimes there can be a gulf between agency and in -house. I'm not sure if there... Yeah, I wouldn't say
there was evidence of a gulf between agency and in -house on Tuesday. But on certain topics and issues, there's certainly a divide, not in the sense of a confrontational divide, but a gap in thinking and process. In some cases, in -house people are potentially ahead. I think they are much more aware of, for example, the importance of proof and value. because I feel like their
functions are really under a lot of pressure at the moment. Yeah, and I think some of the panelists that sort of alluded to the fact that, you know, there is a place for both to play together and there is a role for each, you know, and how best to navigate the future together. And I think that was really important because, you know, it's really not going to be on one or either side. It is a collaborative effort. Yeah, how
did you see that, James? Because, I mean, I've always thought when it comes to innovation, you know, agencies tend to be a step ahead, which you'd expect. You know, their product -focused businesses, their product is comms, right? So you would kind of expect them to be a little bit ahead of them. in -house people. But you had people from companies like ByteDance, like LinkedIn, very sophisticated in terms of content.
Do you still see evidence that there is kind of a gap between in -house and agency, or do you see it playing out in different ways? I don't really. I mean, I think it depends. It depends a lot on the in -house. the organization and then the agency as well um you know i think what was interesting in one of the sessions uh was uh with meta was where bridget was sharing about how their team evolved um and i think she was
talking about they've brought in a creative uh they've brought in a data analyst uh recent in the last year they've brought in some creative people as well um and you know i i think what what that sort of was saying to me was okay are we on the agency side um are we up to date with someone like meta and their team and i feel that many ways we are but then how is our role going
to change um as time goes on if if more organizations are sort of in housing these these skills or this expertise um but you know i think what she said what she said was great that you know we there's a lot of value from that outside perspective that agencies can still provide um and you know i think it's our job on the agency side to morph and to adapt to the client and the clients and
for us that that can be very different from one client to another um and so yeah i guess making sure that you you can meet their needs um but then also you know in one of the other conversations or maybe in the same conversation um you know it what came out was the importance that we sort of partner with them on the thinking so that
we're not just arms and legs. But, you know, just getting back to what was being shared before about, you know, in -house perspective versus agency, I found it really, it's always so valuable getting the perspective from someone like uh bicky who's he's really who's looking at things or his view is from the top if you like um because even if you are say dealing with business leaders
on a daily basis in in many cases many of us are we're not really are we having conversations with them that are about the place of comms in their world or in their organization or comms people in a broader in the broader scheme of things um So some of the perspective he provided I thought was really useful and helpful. I mean, I can share a bit about what I took away from that session, you know, now. Yes, please. You
know, when he was sort of saying that people sort of look at comms as being the crisis saviour, if you like. Yeah. everything's just going along normally we're not really engaging closely with comms until a crisis pops up and then all of a sudden come running to comms um you know in that reactive setting to help us get out of this problem but he was looking at the need to shift that relationship to being reactive to more proactive um yeah and and talking about how role that the
the comms has a role to play in say business modeling and resilience early on so developing the strategy not just executing it like once the strategy baked um and something that that we often forget and i i know i certainly do um is that we have you know when i say we meaning that the comms the in -house team the agency but we have insights that are across stakeholders
that are the broadest in the organization and and sometimes the deepest depending on on on the group um so our view of the network as he put it and sort of this the stakeholders um is very valuable to the business but it isn't used often enough often enough to say inform business strategy yeah Absolutely. He made that point. It has to be more proactive. It has to be embedded
across different functions. And he challenged comms people to move out of their, I think they're kind of, he didn't say comfort zone, but I'll say comfort zone. He said, I think, you know, they need to move out of just talking to other comms people, for example. They need to be actively talking to other functions, building networks. along those lines because and that's interesting to me because I guess from my perspective you
sometimes think well organizations will handle all of that right they'll make sure that that comms is talking to sales and making sure that kind of sales people understand the insights that comms might have but it doesn't always happen that way the onus is on the comms function to actually step up and do it I think that was the point perhaps he was he was making. And it's a really interesting one, how much he talked about sales as well, which, you know, honestly,
you go to a lot of comms conferences and yes, we talk about measurement, we talk about evaluation. I don't think I've been in a session where someone talked quite as much about, you know, he was talking about how we sell products in different markets. And it's quite, it's a very valuable perspective to have. I think the role of comms going in, if you're entering into a new market in laying the groundwork before you even think about going and trying to sell. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
I think it does go back also to some of the tensions that have been in the conversations about the role of comms in the whole scheme of things. Right. Where if we're just seen as sort of like execution, then there's a big part that's missing. And Then that gets into a different conversation where C -suites or, you know, leaders might go, why is comms relevant? Because ultimately for them, they're looking at what the business outcomes are going to be. How does this help me drive growth in my business? And that's where, you
know, as communicators, we do need to get in to those conversations. And that really also like going back to what James had said, about bringing those insights in to help, you know, sort of influence strategy. also being able to measure the impact of our work beyond just sort of the vanity metrics, you know, it's not just about what we've done, but how does that align with the business goals and where is it helping to drive growth? Yeah, and Bicky made those points
as well. He even, I think, admitted at one point that, you know, yes, when it's tough, comms is... if not the first, one of the first functions to face scrutiny. And I think that's true. We've all seen that. And the only way out of that is to demonstrate value, right? And as you said, it's about value beyond vanity metrics. That was discussed. But it's also about, I think, understanding there's a level of insight that
comms can bring across all these different areas. But is that... you know it requires that kind of more proactive mindset i actually thought as well bikki's um the opening session dovetailed really well with the penultimate session which was with with the apac d where we had the three uh corporate affairs heads we had um sorry four corporate affairs heads uh from kellen over uh heineken halion and air wallex um talking about
the pressure on their functions and how they are reinventing. And whilst I think we had four people on there whose functions are perhaps not quite as pressured as some other companies. So they were relatively, I don't know if I'd use the word secure, but they were at least optimistic. There was still that acknowledgement that there is... there is restructuring and, you know, we
have to always be thinking about how we're changing, how we're demonstrating value. I'm wondering, was there anything in that session perhaps that stood out for you as well? Because I just thought that was an interesting look from, you know, corporate affairs heads at quite different types of companies. Yeah. I think that was one of my favorite sessions and James knows this. that was a session that really stood out for me yeah because i thought it was a very powerful message that they had right that um especially when may
from airwalks actually said you know the job description is the job description it's not the job you know and that really signals how you need to sort of you know think out of the box in terms of what your role is going to be it's not really just strictly comms and traditional sense of work right um you need to look at you know where there's a time with the business um what are the different you know um connections you did have where do you really drive growth and how do you make you know um helps join the
different dots along the line to create that value for the organization yeah yeah yeah a lot of talk about fluency in that session james what did you make no because while the discussion was mostly i guess in the context of corporate affairs because of you know that's then leadership in corporate affairs because that's the roles that sort of each of them have i felt that what they shared is obviously very relevant and applicable outside of that just the value of i think they
were talking about data fluency uh business acumen um and learning agility was something else i remember that was mentioned i mean that's sound advice uh for anyone in any role um coincidentally um it was working with erin i was reporting to erin many years ago oh yeah louis yeah giving me exposure to numbers uh was you know one of those times where my business acumen certainly took a significant step forward um but yeah that's
just a coincidence but that was you know something that was i thought they covered really well Yeah, and they talked about the importance of relationships with the board, which I think was a really well -made point. And also, I thought Rimi Harindran, who's the corporate affairs head at Calanova, she'd said, you know, it's also about this kind of personal evolution of being comfortable letting go a little bit, which is also required these
days. which I found quite an interesting observation because it isn't always you know it isn't always just about you know getting better at all these different things but sometimes it's yeah it's about how you handle and control manage different situations yeah I think I think it was in that panel session it was one of them where just on that in relation to the board that someone said uh you know you've got to look at not just what
your boss needs it's what your boss's boss needs and i thought that was good as well yeah it's a little bit like the circular influence that you need to understand even sort of within the organization and how they all connect together and therefore um what can you do to sort of facilitate those relationships yeah yeah yeah so i pulled up i've actually pulled up the story now so now i can i can give you exact quotes this is one from aaron We are schizophrenic, part strategist,
part influencer, part storyteller. You have to be fluent in policy and ESG data fluent. Yeah, Meilun from Airwallex, practitioners should embrace agility. I would encourage everybody to flex with change. And here's an interesting one I'll put to you both. The importance of generational renewal, because this is something that extends beyond. the corporate affairs function. I think
it was Rimi who said, I would invite communicators to think about how you are building the next gen as leaders, how you're exposing them to all of this. Are we doing enough to bring the next gen to the table? So how would you both respond to that question? What I think about is, and just in relation to something that was discussed at the conference around that, was It was actually in the second session with Barbie where, I mean,
it was a great conversation, I felt, to help us sort of prepare for what's coming. You know, looking at 2030 and asking ourselves, are you ready? I mean, after I think it was Thomas shared the backdrop of the world of 2030, I mean, my response to that question of are you ready was, hell no but um i felt but i was relieved to see in the study that they did uh that uh i wasn't
the only one it looks like the majority of people don't quite feel like we're ready for what's to come in the next five years but something that barbie was talking about because we would you know obviously there's a lot of discussion around ai but you talked about the importance of sort of foundational skills um And just thinking about the next generation, sure, there's all these skills and expertise that we and they, I say we because I'm older than them, but that
we need to work on and continue to develop around AI and adapting to that change. But the importance of things like relationships. um you know soft skills yeah face -to -face meetings and and i'd go further to say basic communication skills um writing you know these these things are so important in our industry in the in any industry
but particularly in ours um and she was quite quick to say that it you know it's not one or the other we need to be doing both and i think for the next generation that yes there there's simply because of the way the world is um i think that there does need to be a lot of emphasis or emphasis put on softer skills as well and and that's i think older people like myself can you know uh can help with that because i guess
my experience is is of a world that was before you know the internet and so you know helping the younger generation develop those equally important softer skills i think is part of the job that we have to do yeah i mean yeah that was encouraging yeah sorry i was gonna say that as well you know that you know the soft skills are important the technical skills are important i think those provide the foundation um but i also think that you know in terms of what you
asked about, you know, are we preparing the next generation of leaders, right? I think mentorship. it's an important thing that needs to be effective as well you know we do a fair bit of that ourselves at finn where we have a mentorship program in place to sort of help you know guide the next level of leaders right and i know some of the speakers at the conference that also talked about this mentorship being pretty important um because it does convey certain experiences you know um
provide additional perspectives that may not necessarily translate as well in like you know training on technical or self -skills per se but does work well in sort of a mentorship environment and i remember because even mentioned about this reverse mentorship yeah where you learn from the next generation as well as you know sort of guide the next generation so it's a it's a two -way street It's all coming back to me now as you discuss these things. I've kind of suppressed
all these memories from being on stage. And now I can remember the point, yes, about reverse mentoring. In fact, that whole session, the 2030, are you ready? The stats were very interesting. So whilst people think they're personally ready, I think a majority, only a minority think their organizations are ready. and then when they're asked what they're ready for uh they feel you
see more confidence in terms of technologies and things like ai but less in terms of areas uh described i guess as foundational skills right strategic understanding and foresight um does that worry either of you at all it is yes for sure because i think it's it's easier to talk about technology It's easier to figure that out, but the soft skills, the communication skills, that doesn't always translate as well. And I
know that for a lot of the younger people joining the workforce now, where they're sort of like digital natives, digital first, they're a lot more comfortable messaging than they are actually having a conversation in person, on the phone. bit of an aversion to pick up the phone to speak to somebody um and and that that could mean then that very important skill gets lost along the way because it's just not enough practice of it yeah i mean it's amazing how often i find
myself saying back in my day but um i yeah i think it's certainly the case um one of the other questions that was sort of rolling around my head just when we were discussing on the day and just discussing this now it's also whether ai is is making us stupider as a species um you know and i'd have to say yes purely based on what we outsource to it a lot of thinking um
yeah creativity and other things as well it's it's sure it's making things faster yes but are we getting dumber as a result of that perhaps um but I'm not sure maybe that's that's not a discussion for today but it's certainly something that I wonder it's it's actually so we looked I looked at it in a newsletter earlier in the year because someone actually had made this same point at another event um that I had been to
about the cognitive atrophy um and there's been you know there's been a couple of studies about this but the results I think are kind of inconclusive so On the one hand, yes, there's some evidence to suggest that if you're outsourcing tasks to AI, you become less good at doing them and that's a challenge. But it does depend to an extent on how much you're outsourcing and how intentional
you are about the kind of things that you're doing. So it's quite a nuanced... But it worries me a lot because I think if you're a writer or if you're writing, it's so tempting to outsource writing. And I really worry that, you know, if you lose the ability to write, then you're kind of, well, at least for me anyway, I would be stuck, I think. So, yeah, I think that is, that's quite a big, that's quite a big concern, I would
say, in terms of... I think it also goes back to a whole discussion where people talk about, yes, AI is great, but there always needs to be a human intelligence instead of it, right? So I think that then lends itself to the, in response to James' question, I would say it depends how intentionally are you structuring the use of AI, what kind of guidelines and policies you have in place that then governs in a way that
you don't lose the important skill sets, but still sort of like the human at center of it. And I think that's a question that actually a lot of the organization had asked as well, or had discussed during the conference. And we ourselves, you know, find ourselves confronting this question, right? Which is why, you know, even at Finn, we've got our own sort of guidelines and policies with the use of AI. We know it's... already here, we know there's no running away from it. So it's not about don't use it. It's more like how can
we best use it without losing what's important to us and still having human intelligence be the one that value adds, that gives it that perspective, that emotive intelligence, the authenticity. So you take something and make it better rather than sort of... being taking the lazy way out and just have it be the same but have someone do it someone else AI do it for you yeah it comes
it reminds me of something that Heidi Ashley said from HSBC I don't think she actually used this quote but but she made a longer point which was that throughout her career she has kind of you know as you'd expect from someone who works in corporate comms on the where she's in financial services, now it's heavily regulated industries. There's a lot of crisis, there's a lot of issues management, and she effectively runs to the fire,
right? That's kind of the skill she's had to develop and hone. And yes, of course, that's important from a crisis perspective, but I think it's important in general, perhaps. It means, you know, rather than taking the easy way out. actually having to confront whatever the challenge might be whether it's making sure that AI isn't you know you're not outsourcing everything to AI or making sure that you are dealing with a
crisis making sure that you're you know weighing up how different governments are responding to different things and making a determination on that rather than trying to please everyone this is a it's not always instinctive but i think it's something that perhaps it's a skill that for communicators becomes more important something else just around ai that it cut across a number of other panel discussions and that really and
it was discussed that it's something that i constantly think about and i'm exaggerating there but it it's we all know that the way we're using it it's helping us to you know generate content efficiency that sort of thing but one of the examples that um it was emma shared was how there's ai driven avatars selling uh over a live stream um in china um and they're based on two real
people and they sold over seven million dollars of products during this live stream which is more than uh any any it's the most they've made ever like more than they've done when they've done themselves in real life um and and what what was talked about and i still grapple with though is that with all that we can do with ai and that we're doing with a generative ai what happens to authenticity credibility trust you
know, these things that we keep telling ourselves are so important, you know, and studies show people feel are important and are so important to our profession and people working in it. But, you know, and I wonder to myself if it is more of a generational thing that, because I care about authenticity and, you know, does it mean that as time goes by that that's going to matter less? um or become less important or are we heading
to a point where there is going to be a backlash against content that's created by ai where people essentially they refuse to consume content that they know is ai generated um i mean i actually don't know the answer so that's why i'm asking the question yeah um So that was the presentation from Emma Smith from Sandpiper. But there was another session with Isabel from the Hoffman
Agency. And they were discussing this exactly, I think, really, you know, in a world of AI content. What is the value of credibility? And I think it was Puneet Singh from ByteDance, which is, of course, the company behind TikTok. who had said, you know, credibility ultimately becomes the most important currency for communicators. It buys belief. It buys you trust. It gets your net promoter scores up. It gets, you know, that's what will persuade people to stand up for you
and defend you. Third parties, independent voices. And I think Elisa Chopard from LinkedIn made the point that, you know, empathy and authenticity become even more important in this. ai driven world so i think that's true i think they do become more important but the question is um how many people will actually listen to that how many brands and corporates because the temptation is always i think more content at scale faster
you know but also does that china example suggest otherwise Yeah, it's a really good question. Did people maybe trust an AI avatar because of the source of that avatar? Is it about the ecosystem? I was going to say, it's also got to do with was this already apparent to the audience? Because
I think one of the key things as well is disclosure, right? Are they aware that there was an avatar they were sort of interacting with and therefore, you know, that's acceptable in that sense? Yeah, really good. It's really good questions. I think there's always, you know, the ecosystem matters as well to an extent. So people, I would imagine,
are maybe more attuned. to this kind of buying on certain ecosystems in certain communities maybe even in certain countries um will that work everywhere will credibility be more important in other places um i guess we'll see but it does raise really interesting questions because yes ai avatars are coming i think we're seeing uh not just for selling but even you know ceo avatars
People were talking about AI influencer movement, right? With a lot of, you know, these AI influencers getting really popular very quickly. Huge followings. People are aware they are AI. And they do follow them with fully aware what they're going in for. Right. Yeah. And what do you think is the formula for an authentic AI influencer? Assuming there is some kind of authenticity there. I think at
the end of the, at the back end of it, right, you know, even if the avatar is AI generated and, you know, content or what they do is driven by AI, there is still some human sort of orchestration behind that. Exactly. That's trusted. That's not. that's not missing. It's not fully automated in a sense, right? So there are still certain directions that's given, certain decisions that are made by the human, which then lends itself
to being able to make sure that that engagement is as authentic as it can be. So there's that to consider as well. I think it is a different area of influence that we do need to consider because of the changes we're seeing in today's landscape. And there are going to be areas we need to navigate there. Like you said, according to the levels of trust, authenticity, how do
we make sure that that isn't lost even when we create those sort of engagement? Yeah, that credibility is there. I suppose the risk is the more we see of AI avatars, there's always that risk that they'll become kind of more and more divorced from humans and humanity. And that's where challenges will come up, right? And let's be honest, right? Not all of them are going to have that same level
of human involvement. There will be pretty nefarious uses as well, no doubt. yeah i think there's been some backlash on that as well where when they didn't monitor it enough and then the influencer the ai influencer was sort of seeing things that were you know a little bit not quite um approved and so that had a huge audience um backlash as
well as from the brands well where you know that's not quite right i was going to very went rogue Yes, exactly. Did they lose their job? Sorry? Did they lose their job? Pretty much. Unplugged. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Well, I think we can close soon. I just wanted to end. This has been a really fascinating discussion, but I actually wanted to end, perhaps appropriately, with the final
conference session about the... kind of the future of consultancies in a way because we didn't talk about that much during the day but we did a little bit at the end um with george kaprayash from yafira and we had lena from mutant and they were just talking about how you know consultancy scale and grow uh in this kind of environment i'm wondering if there were any takeaways from that session that made you perhaps yeah rethink how you're
looking to grow at finn um from memory uh you know i think what they talked about was and was shared really i think drive drove home the role that obviously people play in the success growth development of businesses like ours um and it
it wasn't just in that session i think you know i think but they did talk about and i think you know what they've done in terms of uh say giving people uh a stake in the business and that sort of thing that has really served them well their culture uh alan dean as well and i think that's certainly uh something that and quite recently
actually joyce and i have been discussing is the emphasis that we put in those areas and i think that traditionally or historically i should say both rice and finn partners in singapore have done a really good job with that but you know it's an area that Given all that we've talked about and that was the focus of some of the discussions and conversations at the summit, even more effort,
more resource, more time needs to go into developing people, into training and maybe looking at not the normal and traditional ways of doing that in order to kind of stand out. and be different and i mean not just for the sake of it but so that our people um you know can continue to to to sort of do great things do good work um and
you know keep doing what's needed to for us to keep growing i think yeah that was something that uh and again not just in that session but um from some of the comments that others made as well um that i it was one of the takeaways for me yeah yeah i mean i i know that james we had talked a lot about that as well and how we want to make sure that the culture is always sort of you know preserved and making sure that you know of course you know um the employees
are invested in the future with us as well and i think the whole learning development and making sure that they're also sort of invaded very much in that journey it's kind of important So that it is a joint future that we're creating together and not sort of a solo interpretation of where they should be. Yeah, absolutely. It comes back, I guess, quite neatly to the importance of that kind of collaborative energy, right? Whether that's at the agency or in the conference room.
So long may that continue. I think we are definitely stronger together. so james and joyce thank you so much for your time um and thanks of course for your support and thanks to finn partners for partnering with us on this podcast thanks for being at the event and um paying attention throughout that's really all i ask of people that come so i really appreciate it and um yeah i hope you have a nice weekend thank you it was
Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...
Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...
Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO...
GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...
Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to...