Aman Gupta on the next era of influencer marketing
34 minAudio
Arun Sudhaman speaks with Aman Gupta, managing partner of SPAG Finn Partners, about the evolution of influencer marketing in regulated sectors - and why credibility, compliance and subject expertise now matter more than reach. Presented in partnership with Finn Partners, the conversation explores how structured scoring models can help brands identify credible voices, counter misinformation, and turn influencer investment into measurable impact.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Earn First podcast. This is Arun Sudhaman, founding editor of Earn First, and I'm very happy to be joined today by the CEO of SPAG FinPartners, Mr. Aman Gupta. Aman, welcome. No, thank you, Arun. Thanks for having me and very excited to have this conversation with you. This is the second in the two -part podcast series that FinPartners is sponsoring around Praxis
Asia Pacific, which of course took place, feels like another lifetime, but was only, I think, three weeks ago now. Yes. Many themes emerged from the event. We discussed some of them with your colleague James Brasher from Rice Fin a couple of weeks ago. But I think for this episode, Aman, you in particular wanted to talk about the changing nature of influence, the rise of influencers. and creators. I think there was
plenty of attention afforded to that topic at Praxis, particularly in terms of the challenges it poses to traditional communications functions. But let me start by kind of getting your views on how you see the whole influencer landscape changing, particularly in terms of healthcare and technology. So Arun, thanks for bringing this topic up. Let's sort of look at healthcare
and technology, the two things which kind of are so interwoven in our lives. The biggest factor which matters there is the trust and credibility. At SPHFN, we have been talking about the trust as a core factor when you're doing the messaging. through credible messengers since the time we launched as PAG in 2014. And this whole idea of how do you ensure that we work with the right set of individuals who have both the credibility
and have a subject matter expertise to really take that content, take that data, take that story to the larger audience is the core to anything which we are doing. So on the one side, we are seeing a lot of content creators coming up across the ecosystem. You have nano, micro, macro, whatever we may be calling it. And they usually are defined by the number of followers. That's the kind of
the basic thumb rule which people look into. However, is that really what works in this sector? The answer is no. What we really need to look at is are these people have their subject matter expertise to act as a credible voice on that subject? Are they transparent in the way they are engaging with their own audiences? Are they within the regulatory and compliance ecosystem? of the geography in which they are operating and so and so forth so that was kind of one of
the core thoughts which we had and based on that in the recent few weeks back we launched influence which is our proprietary tool uh with with which we can work with our clients and the larger players in the health and technology ecosystem to ensure that we work with I would say content creators who have all the necessary five steps of the five elements which we think really make them the best suited to be the voice for a brand,
voice for a topic, or voice for a particular theme. And those five metrics are signal, compliance, overlap, relevance, and engagement. Yes. So that's what we call is kind of a score. It's like, it's a kind of a thing for us, what we call is the score, which we will try to bring in. And if you just go a little deeper dive, right? So if you look at what we call is a signal quality,
it's about that content creators, authenticity, consistency, and the richness of the content. So that's one part of it. The second, as we look at from a compliance and authority is that is the person disclosing uh you know who is uh funding or sponsoring those posts and do they have the relevant qualifications and the regulatory ecosystem to talk on that subject do their audience overlap
with the audience of the brand or the topic which we are doing? Because we do not want somebody who is talking to an audience which is completely away from the audience which brand would like to talk to. And is the narrative or the relevance of the content aligned with what the campaign objectives are? And finally, it's not just about saying how many likes you get, but is it really initiating a conversation? Is it really bringing in a meaningful and thoughtful replies, which
is the part which for us makes the most important thing? It's not saying, oh, I have a million likes on the topic and the conversation is having about something very different from the topic that you would like to do. I think these are the elements which become very critical in both health, technology and anything which I would say has a high involvement with the consumer. I guess it's particularly relevant in healthcare because it's a regulated industry. Different countries have different regulations. For a pharma
company, I imagine it's quite important to ensure that they're finding influencers who aren't breaking rules. But do you find perhaps that there's almost like an inverse? The more popular a healthcare influencer is, maybe the less likely they are to be adhering to regulations and rules. Is that potentially a challenge? Okay, so I think what's
happened is that I think the influencers have understood the need for them to be more compliant. So while what you're saying may be true in the past, the whole landscape is changing. And when we say healthcare influencers, it's not a one homogeneous group. A healthcare influencer could be somebody who is a fitness expert, he could be somebody who is a medical professional, and you can't sort of put them in the same bucket.
You know, if I'm talking about say, for example, one of the biggest health conversation nowadays is about obesity. Now, obesity can have a conversation which is related to your lifestyle element, you know, from a fitness to your nutrition. Now, that's something which a nutritionist or fitness expert could talk about. But if you would like to talk about the pharmacotherapeutics of it, then those are not the people who can speak on that particular subject. That's where you need.
an expert, a certified medical practitioner who understands the science, who understands the compliance, who also understands that you can't go and sell. What you are doing is you're educating and asking the person to take a more informed decision. And based on the data, based on the person's condition, then the... The healthcare professionals are the best people to advise what would be the right treatment which they should
probably go with. Yeah. And do you think the clients are, in general, sophisticated enough? Because, you know, there's always that temptation, I suppose, to just select. the influencer with the biggest reach the biggest audience you know the biggest name uh it's very tempting right for if you're in control of those budgets exactly
and i think that has been the kind of the core thinking right now you know whenever in the past we had talked to the clients their ask would be uh give us the you know what's the follower ecosystem and when we say follow they're just looking for the numbers there is no qualitative methodology which used to be asked for so if the person has a background which to some extent could be classified as health and second is if the person is popular those are the two factors
which I am comfortable with I'm going to put the budgets behind it but what we realized was and we used to sort of you know go along that path along with the clients right so we were not sort of cautioning that thinking and but what we realized was that in couple of campaigns the impact was not coming in so while we were spending the money working with those influencers but if we are looking for a behavioral change if that is something which is kind of one of
our main impact where we asking the person let's say for you know so if you're working say in a diabetes ecosystem and you would like the person to go and do a regular check for diabetes right so every morning i will go and do my check is that happening the answer was no despite the fact that if you just look at from the simple metrics from a million followers you had five percent of people who liked the post there was a conversation but those conversation will be
if it's a celebrity about the celebrities social life it will be about celebrities recent doings and nothing to do with the topic and I think that's where the the need for influence came in that as a specialist healthcare marketing communication agency it's our responsibility to bring something which could act as a filters which can act as a tool for both the sides to say is this really the right person so it's not
about the the size only it's also about expertise uh credibility uh the trust which that person could bring in also the fact that the person is then providing the right kind of an education and sensitization to the audiences yeah I guess the the metrics as well are really important from an outcomes perspective too right as you just mentioned you know you can have a lot of impressions and a lot of likes but it's potentially
not um generating the actual outcomes you want if it's you know specific tests or um over to awareness around a particular issue um do you see that being linked more now to influencer investment uh more specific i think so i think so because so let's look into who has the budgets for influencer uh if it is coming from a communication department then the uh the metrics largely still
remains from a communication perspective which is your likes and engagement and conversations but in our ecosystem we're largely dealing with the marketing uh folks right for marketing folks they are sort of saying what can this dollar investment give it to me in return so therefore it has to have uh certain outcomes which could be linked to what our core objectives are and therefore influencer is not a standalone thinking it's not a campaign which sort of works in its
own silo and is standalone it is a part of the larger digital and social campaigns which we are running so therefore the idea would be that from there if we are doing this campaign it has to have a call to action which takes a person on a particular journey to know more on that topic uh to do a more deeper dive about the uh the subject which we are talking and get further information to take the right informed decisions
so it's not just like a one step it's part of a journey this is one of the steps an overarching journey to make people more informed so that they can really change their lives and you know have more healthier uh options or you know have better diagnosis uh talk to the doctors about you know what the new innovations can really help them in a particular condition which they may be suffering with and on the technology side i i imagine you don't have the same regulatory
pressure perhaps But it's just as important, no doubt, to be working with, you know, to have the same kind of lens, I guess, in terms of credibility and compliance. Are there different factors around compliance when we're talking about tech sector clients? Well, it's not as, and again, technology is such a broad ecosystem now. It's not, you know, you can't sort of say, okay, technology in one way. It depends on what part of the technology
are we kind of. are talking about so for example if we're talking about technology from a b2b space you know where we're saying a particular technology could play a very critical role in changing a particular industry and its operations it can make it much more efficient or it could sort of really change the way the systems are working in that particular case you would need a credible voices who has seen the technology
at work. So for example if it's a big cloud service provider with a particular new technology or tool which could help say a gaming company to become more efficient or it's sort of saying I can ensure that your data is stored much more safely. Now, that is where you would need somebody who is an expert in that space. And if it is about security, it's about, say, you need a cybersecurity
who has used the product or who has that kind of technical expertise to chime in and say, yes, I think this is where the newer technology can really help. But if you're just bringing a social influencer who is speaking about, say, consumer electronics, and just because it's because of electronic has a huge uh reach that may not kind of work in this case so it depends on who you're kind of talking to and within the consumer electronic
again then it depends on which consumer electronic am i talking about because they're so often and then extending into say the variables part from you know where health and technology comes together how do you get the right people to sort of say this is really the the variable which could give you the data which you can be sure of and take your decision based on it. So we have to sort of look at technology and start to segment it to look at who the audiences are. And within that space, do we have the right credible voice?
It cannot just happen that a technology influencer can talk about each and everything under the sun. Yeah. That makes plenty of sense. Let's talk about... um influences themselves for a moment um because I think it's always quite interesting the the trends in this area um any patterns in terms of where they are living and where they are moving to for example are we still talking about I I know of course it's market and sector
dependent but uh in terms of the main channel drivers are we still talking about Instagram tick tock I imagine LinkedIn is important from a B2B perspective. Are you seeing any specific changes in terms of channels? Well, I think the video content is becoming more and more popular and we can see that kind of getting embedded across all the social channels. So yes, YouTube
Shorts, IG Reels, TikTok. so that's really where the video content is becoming more popular because more engaging uh that's part one uh linkedin is becoming a much more bigger uh play uh come you know in in the system especially in health and technology where you are looking at a kind of a b2b conversation it's also more expensive compared to you know doing uh things on a meta
or in a google ecosystem uh but much more targeted so linkedin is something which we are seeing more clients asking to explore uh but just because of the budgets there's a little bit of uh let's say uh it's more experimental right now to see what can be done in this space uh but yes it's gaining more kind of a popularity uh and despite everything, we're still seeing, you know, X having its own space. I was in conversation with a few
clients a couple of weeks back, and it was kind of a learning for me. And we were discussing the role of X in the health side, and they said that's something which... a lot of scientific conversations happen. So if you look at scientific publications, they are very active on eggs and they keep on putting a more peer reviewed publications. So for the medical and the scientific community, they do look at eggs for that kind of content and that kind of an engagement. also conversations which happen on x if there's a conference happening
so that's much more quicker way for them to know what conversations which are happening get to be part of that conversation so you know so x has you know not completely lost you just need to aware to use it uh yeah because it's sort of it's happening there very it's a very interesting point because i think in the media world x has lost a lot of its luster certainly as a driver of traffic for media organizations. But the numbers
are still pretty strong in terms of users. And as you mentioned, it's also quite market dependent, right? So you hear a lot about brands coming off X, although I think many have returned. And outside America, or let's say the further... you know the further you go from the from western markets i do think there seems to be less concern about x which is um kind of an interesting phenomenon
that's true that's true so it's not as uh negative as you might find it happening in the the us or some part of europe what about these other networks and channels are they becoming important some of them are more local language but presumably you're also looking at um wechat uh you look at line uh in north asia and cow cow yeah then
there's the video the video one in china sorry the name escapes me the short video one yeah yeah yeah but um it is important um i would say more It is very critical, not just important, because when you get into a specific market, you need to be aware and work with the local channels because they are much more popular. So if I am in Korea or if I'm in Japan, I do need to work with Line and Kakao. I can't sort of work with an IG or a meta ecosystem because
they may not be as... big or popular. And also then the language matters, right? Because if you have to create content, then you have to create content in the local languages, work with the local influencers. And the question which you asked in terms of the direction, how the influencers are, the number of influencers are increasing. So you see more and more content creators coming in from areas which otherwise were not there. So we have seen more say doctors
coming out as a content creators and we have doctors who have a pretty large reach and they are seniors say an orthopedic surgeon there may be people who are endocrinologists and they are taking time to use social media as a vehicle to talk to their audiences educate them use that as a platform for people to sort of have a better understanding of health and science so We are seeing that happening, which I think is a good
trend because you need more people who have that expertise, which people can trust for the kind of content because they will always ensure that they are not going against the local guidelines or against the ethical part of things. Yeah, absolutely. They've taken an oath, which you can't always say that about some of the wellness influences out there. I mean, some of the stuff I've seen, you know, products, various remedies
that have been endorsed. I won't even call them products. But, you know, it's not far off kind of quackery, I guess. So the more medical doctors, surely that's a better, an encouraging trend. Exactly. And that is where it kind of starts to move into the whole space of... the misinformation and rumors and disinformation, because that's a very thin line. And that's where the social conversation starts to become important, especially
in, as you said, health and tech sector, because people might just take what's coming up on an Instagram as the truth. So for them to get access to the right people becomes very, very kind of critical, because if you just go and start looking for and we see people around they just take anything which comes on their uh id you know things that that's where it is and everybody wants to then uh use it you know so because health is becoming
important people wants to be well they wants to have more healthier life and then we need to believe everything which is coming on the social media and therefore it's responsibility of the brands uh to take a more uh visionary and forward looking thinking is not just for businesses, but having a broader responsibility to ensure that there is a more ethical storytelling, more trustworthy content, which is available in social and digital ecosystem. And people can
then sort of go to them and get the right information. Yeah, it makes sense in a way, because, you know, I think in Asia, especially, medical information hasn't always been as accessible as it could be. And sometimes you do get a kind of a, you know, the doctor knows best attitude, which I guess when you have influences, you know, that it sort of provides a very appealing route for
people to find out more information. you know in places where they already are and you know such digestible forms but you're right the the potential for misinformation is very high exactly and you know especially when you have and i remember when at spag we worked with who during the covet time and for us this was this whole idea of how
do you listen in and have a response mechanism for all the misinformation and rumors which were floating around in the early days of COVID across Southeast Asia. And having a robust mechanism was what WHO had tasked us to do. And based on that, this whole science of infodemology came up, which is how the misinformation can really change the way people think. And we've been seeing that happening. Because while science is Sometimes
you have to also understand the emotions of the people. So you have to mix the science with how the people think and what their emotions are to tell the right story. Yeah, these are good insights, right? If this is the kind of stuff that people are looking for, then that's a very useful insight for a healthcare company. When it comes to the influencers themselves, how do you think they feel, though? you know, being scored. I've always wondered this. I mean, I
know you're not going to make these scores public, but they may well find out that they have a score and it's impacting their earning potential. Do you ever think that there was potential backlash from that? Well, they can be. They could be. If somebody feels that just because of a certain score, which they have scored low on a particular brand, they may feel a little resentful about it. But I think as an organization, our role,
and I think that's the role of an influencer, is that by core meaning you're an influencer, you're influencing people. in their thinking in their behavior in the way they may act so from all expect of being an ethical influence you should be speaking on the topic which you are expert on and in a way that gives you a better uh play field that this is an area where I score higher so therefore this is a space which I can then monetize much more bigger number instead
of spreading myself So it's a way of perspective. For us, this is something which could help and strengthen an influencer to go and talk to a brand saying, because of this score, I am more better suited for you to work along with it. So there is a perspective which they can even work along with us saying, give us a score. And I'm sure at some point of time, they will be very keen to sort of make this course more public so that the brands know who they should be working with. It's a bit like scoring agencies. But do
you find that influences in general? Because, you know, now there's so many. I mean, it's crazy how the whole landscape. Presumably there's quite a lot of competition for marketing budgets, I would think. Do you find that influencers are more willing nowadays to kind of work with brands, give up a measure of control? Or is it still
less controllable than you might like? I think it's a... it's moving towards where the influencers are more willing to co -curate content with the brand and not just becoming saying this is what it is because they do realize that if they have a better story which is more engaging it's good for their own audiences right so they are but it's a work in progress you still have influencers
or influencer ecosystem who believe that this is where i billing belongs so this is my platform this is how i am perceived by the people so therefore you have to build your brand into my persona and not let's look into kind of a co -curation part of it but i think because of what you said the the brands are looking at the choices uh the choices are much more higher in numbers today uh compared to what we could have seen maybe
even a year and a half too back So they do have a sort of saying, if you are not, then we could look for another option. So I think the whole idea is that what's the whole purpose? The purpose is to make the audiences more informed, give them the kind of information which will then make them to take the right decisions. So that really is where the conversation is. And does
it benefit both? brand and the influencer if they work together. Yeah. And then lastly, how do you see regulatory regimes keeping up? Do you think, and I know it differs on a country by country basis in Asia, but are lawmakers able to keep up with this kind of proliferation of healthcare information on all these different channels and the risks involved? I think that
really is a very critical question right now. But you will sort of see a very differentiated economies of markets. In certain markets, the policymakers are taking note that they need to have compliance and regulations which are specific for our social channels and not a one broad marketing regulation. where there's an ambiguity of how
do you take this into a social channel because what they've not been able to differentiate between the different media ecosystem which exists right now you have a marketing regulations which are taking media as a one homogeneous ecosystem now that doesn't work so from my because from my advertising to my pr to my social media to an influence to my own channels each has a very different way the brands work with them so having
a one universal guideline creates more ambiguity and i think that's where some of the markets we are seeing are trying to find a more uh how to say they're trying to sort of give more uh predictable and more clarity on how it needs to be done uh but there are still places which are great and ambiguous in nature. So that's something which is still, I believe, will take a little bit more time. And you do sort of find places where situations where despite thinking
you are within the regulatory ecosystem, you might be pulled up for something. So, you know, that's where partners like us come in that, you know, we sort of ensure that we have taken enough. kind of a layers to sort of come out with something which would meet all the forensic and the regulatory uh needs of that particular market yeah it's very interesting to think you need actual specific guidelines and criteria for some of these social
creator channels right compared to mass media compared to other kinds of information okay last question do you have a favorite healthcare influencer Actually, no, right now. I don't. That's a diplomatic answer. I don't. Because as I said, for me, as someone who comes more from a pharma and the medtech side, I would like to really have somebody
who is able to do justice of talking more from serious health issues. per se and not from a wellness and nutrition side. So that group is still evolving. And that's underserved at the moment? That's very much understaffed, very much underserved. And I'm hoping that as SPHU Finn, we are able to make that group a little bit more
bigger and available. So we are collaborating with the SCPs. to bring them outside of their chambers to become the voice. That's one of the areas which we're currently working on. Yeah, there's quite a preponderance, I guess, in areas like wellness, nutrition, and mental health. Very active areas. But I think it's a really good point in terms of pharma and medtech. Yeah,
probably less well -served. So we'll watch that space closely. Aman, thanks so much for your time. Really enjoyed this conversation with you. And I'm sure we'll have you on the podcast again. Always. Thank you. Thank you, Arun. Pleasure.
Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...
Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...
Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO...
GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...
Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to...