The Hoffman Agency’s Isabelle Demaude joins Arun Sudhaman to explore why credibility has emerged as a crucial factor in the AI era. Drawing on her PRAXIS Asia-Pacific panel, Demaude discusses how generative AI challenges authorship and trust, why earned media may be regaining influence, and how cultural intelligence is becoming essential for communicators navigating complex, multi-market realities. The conversation also tackles the tension between corporate conviction and caution in an era of polarization, and what humans still do better than machines: listening, reading the room, and earning belief through empathy and context.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Earned First podcast. This is Arun Sudarman, founding editor of Earned First, and I'm really happy to be joined today by Isabel Demord from the Hoffman Agency. Isabel, welcome to the podcast. Thank you very much, Arun. It's great to be here. So we are going to talk about your session at Praxis Asia Pacific earlier this week. So it took place... Three days ago, although
by the time people hear this, it may well have been around a week. Yeah. But it was a fascinating discussion, like many of the sessions at Praxis. You were focusing specifically on credibility as PR's new superpower. And you had a very interesting panel, I thought, as well. You had Elisa Chopard. from LinkedIn, head of communications for Asia
and Japan. You had Stephanie Yu, Asia Pacific communications leader at Lenovo. And you had Puneet Singh, who's the head of communications for Asia Pacific at ByteDance. And I wonder if perhaps you could get us underway perhaps by just giving us a little context into just the sort of idea behind the panel itself and what you were looking to uncover uh well i think that's
a great question and i think what it boiled down to for us at the beginning was a discussion around what does it mean to be credible in today's landscape um there was a story that inspired me personally a good it must be about six months nine months old now um but i don't know if you'll remember that A few months ago when AI content was really starting to reach that inflection point and everyone seemed to be using an AI tool in their content
creation, there was a saga that seemed to spark on LinkedIn called the M -Witch Hunt, for lack of a better term. I don't know if you know about this, but I've asked on LinkedIn quite a lot. I think it's still ongoing. I feel like it's still ongoing. I think it might be. I don't think everyone's up in arms about it as much anymore, but definitely it's a thing and I'm still really conscious about it. For people who aren't aware that it had a name, because I didn't know that it was called an em dash, but the em dash is the hyphens longer cousin. Yeah, I love it. I
like to think it's good grammar and creates lovely, beautiful content, but I come from a copywriting and editorial background, so of course I think this. However... the other people who also really like grammar or the other thing that also really likes grammatical accuracy is ai and so the m dash was considered a hallmark of whether someone had generated their content on social media using generative ai tools or not and we started seeing
a spark of outrage in people's comment sections when they had identified em dashes in people's content saying you didn't write this this isn't your voice a robot an algorithm has developed this content for you etc and i mean we can go into grammatical pedantry as much as we want but i don't think that that's the point of this um of this example i think the point is that We have gotten to a stage where we are praising AI for its efficiency, its productivity, what
it's going to be able to do for the communications industry in terms of being able to move us towards a more strategic direction, where our counsel deserves to be at the board and at the table, etc. But communications very often boils down to what people are reading and absorbing about our opinions and our convictions. And if people can't believe that... you wrote something or that you actually stand behind a conviction then suddenly it's not the information that's being brought into question it's the authorship and
whether they can believe in you as an individual when you're leaning on ai tools to write those opinions for you um so i think the exploration that we had during the panel was is this where we've come to as a society now where leaning on an AI tool is going to completely erode trust or is there a way to balance the fact that the landscape is changing and it's changing very, very quickly, but still hold on to the core of
what PR is all about, which is creating trust, creating reputation and creating influence. So that was really the exploration that we were trying to undertake. It's a really interesting question. How did your panel respond to that, first of all? Did you find any particular dissent, perhaps, around this idea that credibility is in question because people are concerned about
authorship, they are concerned about AI slop, perhaps they're concerned about em dashes? What were the responses like? I think... the general consensus was people agreed that they had that that this was coming into question that people's credibility was being shaken by the fact that ai isn't the mix without naming names um one of the panelists identified a very large consulting firm recently who had to refund a very large
portion of a project that they did for a government agency of memory serves. And the refund came about because it became very, very apparent that they had developed this huge report on the back of AI. And it's completely shaken the faith in the brand. And I thought that that was very interesting that we're getting actually very large. starting to circle around this, that people are really scrutinizing, did you do this, yes or no? So I think the panel was on board in terms of, yes,
this is definitely an issue. This is definitely a question that's coming up at a much larger frequency these days. But I think that... The line that really spoke to me, and I think that captures the general sentiment that I think not only the panel shared, but it felt like the general room shared, was that the basis of what makes us credible has not changed. Because in order to be credible, you need to have a stance. You
need to have conviction. You need people to trust what it is that you're saying. AI is a tool. And if you misuse the tool and people start scrutinizing you, well, so be it, but it's a tool. It shouldn't be what is forming the basis of what makes you credible, yes or no. And I thought that that was a really good place to kind of springboard from in terms of the rest of the conversation. You also asked, as I recall, the panelists, whether
Earned is making a comeback. Yes. There's at least two ways of looking at that particular question, I suppose. The first, of course, is that if credibility becomes more important, then presumably that goes hand in hand with earning it, because it's hard to buy credibility and it's hard to pay for it. It's something I think that has to be earned in a way. And of course, in terms of classic public relations, it's something you rely on. um whether it's kind of advocacy
at scale or whether it's through third -party endorsement but of course the second thing which is maybe more of a a newer phenomenon is is the rise of geo and the impact that authoritative media sources is having on llm search which which would seem to indicate that earned is making a comeback something we've heard really all year as a kind of potential saviour for the public relations industry, if apparently it needs saving.
But you didn't get, I didn't think there was really consensus around this question, right? There was some disagreement. No, there was not. Yeah, so what did you make of that? Take us through that, perhaps. Well, we had both ends of the spectrum on the panel, where... One of the panellists in particular was very adamant that earned is not making a comeback, that the media landscape and the way that we consume insights and information is already so fragmented these days that probably
people are not going to make that swing back to earned and that they're just going to continue finding new ways of consuming information that's not necessarily, at least not in the traditionalist sense, the way that you would look at earned media. i would still argue um because this particular panelist she was speaking about the importance of community value um and community voices and i would i would argue that that is a form of end um yeah yeah so i i believe that that is
a form form of end um personally because you don't shape community voices and community interpretations without having really merited that space in their minds. So I believe that that does fit into that remit. But if we put that to one side, I think one of the other panelists thought that actually we might be getting to that inflection point where Earned hasn't made its dramatic come back
to victory as of yet, but that it's probably on the horizon because the more that people, again, kind of going back to what I was saying earlier, the more that people do start to question authorship and whether something is true judgment, truly intentional and represents what someone thinks. If it's on an owned platform, if it's something that you pushed out into the world, whether there's no, way of really fact checking
it or, or verifying just how much or how little it really truly represents you. And I would even say it even because I know there are things like AI detection tools now. And even that I would say is not representative of whether it's someone's opinion or not. Because you If I speak, if I give a personal anecdote, I post a lot on LinkedIn and I am very open about the fact that I use ChatGPT as basically my LinkedIn editor. And
so I suspect that if you put my posts through an AI detection tool, it would come up as relatively high. But that also wouldn't surprise me because the way that I work with ChatGPT is I speak into it all my. All my stories, my observations, my anecdotes, my half -formed thoughts, the calls to action that I think I want people to take away from this. And basically, because I tend to be very flowery with my words, I say, okay, take all of this and turn it into something that is structured and legible for a LinkedIn community.
Because it's not going to be, you can't capture every single word that I would normally put in a sentence otherwise. I need someone to rein me in. And so I use ChatGPT to do that. I would 100 % stand behind every single post that I have ever written. That is every opinion that I've had, every stance that I've got, every conviction that I've got, that is 100 % me. But if you're just looking at it from a tool perspective, you wouldn't necessarily think that. So that was a very long tangent, but coming back to the other
panellists who thought that earned is at the inflection point, essentially the point that he was trying to make was when we don't know what to trust anymore, earned media we know there's been some rigor that's gone behind being able to secure that spot and so if you have managed to get that all glorious opportunity in whatever publication or or new media outlet that there may be out there if you've managed to do that
and you've done it it's done so in an earned way then you've earned your stripes And people should be able to lean into that as at least one credible, trustworthy source in a world that is otherwise inundated with stuff that you don't know where you sit. Yeah. It's interesting as well because there's so much nuance to this, this whole conversation. Because, yes, you could say that earned becomes more important thanks to the influence of LLMs, thanks to the... um
influence of more authoritative media but it will look different in different markets in different contexts potentially in different sectors as well and it's not going to be i think a simple approach necessarily in fact it may well be more complicated from a from a kind of geographic perspective do you think that um There are questions around how that nuance is going to play out to
help brands land credibly in different markets. I mean, I presume that's something you see every day in Asia anyway. Yeah, every single day. So something, I don't know whether you know this about me, Arun, because I know we've known each other for a long time now, but I'm currently studying a, for all intents and purposes, a master's in cultural intelligence, which is exactly this topic. And it's looking at... Thank you. It's how you bridge perspectives and divides from
people who come from significantly different backgrounds. So it's not necessarily, I think culture sometimes is a misnomer because we think when we say culture, we immediately think to national identities or ethnic identities. But you can have a lot of different things that shape culture. It could be your organizational culture. It could be religious beliefs. It could even be things like your sexuality and what different types of communities that you belong to. And
every single one of these things adds a layer to someone's identity that you have to bridge. I think nations and the... unwritten societal rules that we have are one of the big ones to bridge. But really, when you are trying to connect with anyone and trying to share a message, then you are having to read the room and read the cues that they're giving you and adapt your message accordingly. But if I boil it down to something that is a bit more simplistic, I remember working
with a client and their organization. um was headquartered in the us um was having some difficulties in one of the local markets um here in asia pacific and there was a lot of talk that they were going to have to shut down operations in this particular market and that came with a lot of anger from local users now the local agency on ground was essentially urging this company if you want to
make amends with your user base and you want to have them on side, then you need to go out there and you need to create an apology. You need to have an apology. And the US firm was saying, well, we can't apologize because otherwise we're liable. The legal team is going to come in, et cetera. And we haven't done anything wrong. Whereas my team was trying to say, well, culturally speaking, it's not about liability. It's not about whether you've done anything right or wrong. in our culture we apologize first and follow
up with all the the facts and and the the realities of the situation later but you apologize first otherwise you you burn the bridge um unfortunately in this particular case the organization did not take heed and did not listen to the local council and lo and behold the the backlash was quite significant so they lost a lot of faith and a lot of credibility in the region because they weren't willing to, I don't know whether it's that they weren't willing to bridge that
cultural divide or whether they genuinely felt like their hands were tied. Maybe it was more the latter than the former, but the point being that that lack of nuance led to a significant downturn for the organisation in Asia Pacific. That was a real shame because otherwise they had a very loyal fan base here and people who really supported the brand. When that collision happens, you know, I think we're used to seeing
global winning. Not to reduce this to a binary, but we're used to seeing perhaps global prevail. We're also used to seeing the lawyers prevail. Presumably, if corporates and brands do want to be credible in the markets and communities that they serve, they need to become more culturally intelligent. Do you see evidence that that's happening? Was there anything on the panel that perhaps encouraged you in that belief? I wonder
if what I'm about to say is politically correct. We won't know until you say it. There you go. I would say, so what I've been living in Asia Pacific now, in total, I've been living in Asia almost 10 years. And I am married into an Asian household. And I would say that I don't think I truly understood what it meant to be culturally intelligent until I was more exposed to this side of the world. And it seems to be like breathing
in Asia that you would take a moment to consider what is the perspective of someone who comes from a different background to myself. I'm not necessarily saying that therefore Asia gets it right all the time. Not at all. But I do think that there is that pause and that moment of consideration of do I need to be approaching this differently? And I didn't necessarily see that as much when I was based back in the UK. I don't think this was anything malicious or intentional by no means.
But I don't think that that curiosity necessarily is abundant in every interaction that I was in. So when you say, do I see change on the horizon? I would say that Asia Pacific, in my view, has always been pretty strong in this area. There's room for improvement. There's room for growth. And I especially think as we see. Asian economies increasingly growing and becoming the leading
global economies. I think someone mentioned it during the event at some point that we're looking at in the next, was it five to 10 years, something like that, like seven of Asia's economies being in the top 10 global economies worldwide. I'm sure someone said four of the top five. And four of the top five, you're absolutely right. But I think they expanded it to seven of the top 10. I mean, it's here. So the more that we see Asian organizations going out of Asia and looking
at their global trajectory, the more that we may start to see the reverse effect of having to really bridge a culture that is very, very significantly different to yours. particularly the geopolitical landscape that we're in right now, does not lend itself very well to a very culturally intelligent world because everything is so polarised right now, because everything is gravitating towards nationalism and protecting
your own, which is understandable because there are lots and lots of things that are happening that are beyond people's control. At the same time, I would say that... maybe I'm speaking selfishly here, but cultural intelligence for me is one of the most important skill sets that anyone could be acquiring right now from a communication standpoint, because no matter what we do, no matter how much we resist globalization, the supply chain is already there. Like our supply
chains are so diversified. We are so interconnected as a society, as humanity. That we cannot possibly escape the need to interact with people who are very different to us. So I truly think that that's going to be the mark of incredible communicators and incredible leadership in the years to come and the very soon to come years, I would say. So my follow up to that would be you had three
very interesting brands on the panel, right? You have ByteDance, who are well known for being the company behind TikTok. a company that has been in the headlines for, let's say, cultural and political reasons in recent times. It is, of course, a Chinese company. It's banned where I live in India. It's banned where I used to live in Hong Kong as well, which I always think is quite amusing. Maybe I'll eventually live somewhere where TikTok is legal. you have linkedin
i'd love to see you doing tick tock videos aroon that would be very entertaining hey you never know man you never know i don't know exactly so please enlighten me um no i think i'm quite glad that uh that i don't i don't necessarily have to have to interact on another platform just for now you have linkedin you had linkedin uh of course who which is you know has become the the kind of premier B2B social network. And
then you have Lenovo, which once upon a time was a Chinese company, is now very global. Of course, it bought IBM's PC business, wasn't it, many years ago. And so it's kind of melded into really quite a unique company, I think, in terms of its geographic profile. Did you get a sense from any of them that they... are grappling with these questions around cultural legitimacy and intelligence, and it's changing how they think
about credibility in different markets. I didn't get a particularly intense sense from any of the panelists at that time. it was something that they were heavily considering of course there are certain organizations among them that have had to face this at least in the past um and looking at that cultural legitimacy what i would say that the panelists brought to the
table was the sense of i guess because all of them have been in the region for a very long time and understand the region very well um that they were very quick to the mark in terms of you cannot possibly treat asia pacific as one region you can't um it is so diverse so fragmented um that even having spent extensive time in any given market does not therefore preclude that you are an expert in said market and really that
you should be taking the time to lean into people who are truly experts who are truly local and are going to be able to give you that perspective that otherwise you would not be able to get. So I think there was a real candidness about how complex it is to do communications in Asia Pacific and how carefully you may have to tread if you truly want to make impact here. That was
the resounding sentiment that I got from the panel. Yeah. Yeah, and that's an important consideration as well, right? Just take care because that's also not something that always happens, I think. There is often, you know, there's a rush, there's a haste. And in this new AI -dominated world, we can produce so much content. And I often wonder the more we produce, is it being accompanied
by the same level of care always? That equation can become a little lopsided, which is not ideal. You asked what PR superpower will be in the next decade. What will humans do better than machines? Was there anything that we will do better than machines? Well, I think the idea of doubling down on our humanity was... what everyone seemed
to agree on um so two of the panelists in particular they seem to be it's funny because they were the ones that had the most um opposing views at several points and yet on this last point what is going to be pr superpower they both unanimously agreed that it's the fact that we're able to listen um and i think one of the panelists captured it very beautifully this ability to discern the thing is ai can give you reams and reams and reams of content. It's a fantastic brainstorming
partner. It's fantastic at creating content to fill the void and to fill the spaces, particularly if your brain is feeling tired and fried and you can't think, how do I put something together and I need to put it together quickly. And we have seen people fall on the wrong side of this as well already. AI cannot tell you what is ultimately going to be the right course of action for you because it cannot read the room at least not in its current guise it cannot read the room
it cannot be there with you noticing the subtle cues that we're getting from tone from body language from just understanding the person and their background etc it can't do that and so being that mediator between okay i've got all this content and all these ideas that it's thrown my way But what is the golden thread here and what actually makes sense? If any of this makes sense, maybe it doesn't. Maybe it needs more reiterations, a lot more refinement. Maybe it
needs an extra insight or piece of strategic counsel that it was completely lacking and that turns the whole thing on its head, et cetera. AI is not going to be able to capture that. It can't. And so that's where I think. not just as an industry of communications professionals, but as a society in general, when we're thinking about the skills that future generations are going to need, then that for me is the one that stands out on top. It's how much do you understand
your fellow human? How curious are you about them? And are you going to be the one that helps to bridge the gap? Or are you going to be the one that turns a blind eye and just pushes content out? I think the people who have that moment to think will be infinitely higher up the chain than those who just take it and push. I can't forget the relationship aspect of public relations.
Yes, AI tools are very good at many things. but how good are they at building maintaining protecting and enhancing human relationships um which is kind of what you had you had alluded to that um several points in your last response right you know understanding context the history of a relationship why people react how they do and perhaps even the impact of uh of culture as well
um so yes i do think that that That relationship aspect sometimes gets forgotten. It's funny, isn't it? Because it really is the foundation of everything that we do in PR. Yeah, it's so quick to forget. But the way that tooling has moved in PR, and this isn't an excuse, it shouldn't be an excuse, but the way that tooling has moved is, say, you now have databases where journalists' email contacts, details, et cetera, are listed.
and sure that makes a distribution far easier but yeah then scale the step of did you actually read what the journalist writes like do you know what they care about yeah yeah do you understand their kind of yeah how they how they work what makes them tick yeah it's it's interesting isn't it it's kind of we you know in this sort of arms race towards content distribution at scale, content
production. It's very easy to forget that human aspect. So I'm glad to hear the panelists did reinforce this idea of humanity, and I'm hopeful that that bodes well. And then just finally to close, you did ask about cancel culture. I did. And about companies. Yeah, you just threw that one in at the end. I think they thought they were home. I did give them a heads up, I will say in my defense. I gave them a heads up. And
they were good sports and decided to come along for the ride. But it was by far the prickliest question that I could have asked. So are companies still willing to take a stance in today's polarized environment where... people get cancelled at the drop of a hat and there's so much backlash it seems against well wokeism for one thing um purpose for another esg perhaps in certain places i find all of this painful because i i'm taking
over the uh diversity and culture group um in the prca the industry trade body um well at least they still have a diversity and culture they do they do we held firm um but it is it's it's quite a It's quite a scary landscape out there at the moment in terms of just holding true to things that you think are important values. Because all of these values suddenly have become political topics where you either stand on one side of the argument or you stand on the other side of the argument and apparently there's nothing in
the middle. And I personally disagree with that, but I do think the panelists were very real. I would have said slightly pessimistic in terms of how corporates can respond in this environment, which is if you choose to take a stance as a corporate, you have to accept the fact that you are going to bear some sort of repercussion. And so the question that you need to be asking yourself is, is the repercussion worth it? I
personally, if I add my own opinion in though, while I entirely agree with what they're saying, and I do see a lot of corporates now trying to dilute their stances to make it more palatable, I don't necessarily think that that means you therefore have no opinion or no conviction. I think this boils back down to, it's not necessarily about the conviction that you have so much as how you say it. And that is ultimately the hallmark
of a good communicator and a good, well, yeah, just a good spokesperson is if they're able to navigate that fine line between, I have a belief, but I'm also thinking about how the audience is going to receive that belief. And how can I influence them to at least be open -minded and hear me out, not necessarily to change their minds, but to. make it something that is acceptable to them, that they can digest, that they can walk away and at least feel like they had a thought
that was provoked. I think that that is the ultimate challenge as we move into the coming years in PR. How can you make sure that you still stand for something and that you don't all sound the same? Because if AI is good at one thing, it's great at replicating structures and vocabulary. And so what you tend to find with AI generated content is that it all starts to merge and blend after a certain period of time. And you can start
to sense whether something is really grounding this piece of content or whether it's a bit of fluff to get you through tough times. So the way that I look at it is corporates don't need to be either 100 % or nothing. I would say you're able to find the status quo and deviate from the status quo, even call it 10 degrees, 15 degrees. That would be enough to show that you stand out from the crowd and to show that you have something
in you that you want to share, but without completely alienating an entire audience. I would say one thing that I think of here is. a conversation that I had with Lou Hoffman last time he was in town in Asia Pacific. And this is a belief he's held for a long time, but I truly buy into this as well. It is better that 70 % of the world loves you and 30 % of the world hates you than 90 % of the world thinks that you are fine, inoffensive.
Because if you are inoffensive... It also means that you are meaningless. People don't mind whether you come or you go. And if we're trying to work with organizations who are looking to build their brand and build their influence among whatever stakeholders they find important to them, you don't want to just be one of many. You want to be the one that stands out and the one that is appealing to them. There's one final, I can think
of a quote by a lady that I really like, her name's Juliana Chan, and she is very, very well linked in in Singapore. But she also used the magnet theory of you have to attract, if you're going to attract, then you have to repel. So I think it's a similar concept. Yeah, exactly. Either you stand for something or you fall for nothing, I think. But it's interesting what you said about the, you know, moving 10 degrees,
15 degrees. My initial, my immediate response was, you know, that's just not going to be far enough for lots of people. And that, you know, then that creates another problem. Perhaps. But I think it's better than what people are doing or what I see a lot of people doing right now, which is to just stay at zero. Because zero is safe. Zero means that you're not going to have anyone coming with their cancelled pitchforks and saying you did it wrong because what have
they got to hold against you? So even 10 degrees, 15 degrees can feel like a brave step for... particularly i'm talking particularly from a corporate perspective um when you looking at individuals or maybe you want to take even more of a bold stance to make yourself stand out oh yeah sure that is that's different when you're not necessarily being held against a bottom line and profitability and and commercials um that
you're not looking after an organization that employs thousands and thousands of people right 10 degrees can feel like a lot. Yeah, absolutely. Well, there's plenty here to be hopeful about. So thank you for that. Thank you. I'm glad you felt so. Yeah, I did. I really enjoyed the discussion and I really felt that it kind of reflected, I think, an industry that is getting to grips
with some of these questions. Much more than perhaps 12 months ago, or even six months ago, when I think there has been a lot more angst. Of course, a lot of the angst is deserved and we shouldn't shy away from it. But I'm relatively reassured that we are thinking about these questions and coming up with pretty good responses and
models for how to behave and how to respond. So thank you for that. Thank you very much for moderating the session on Tuesday. And it's been a pleasure having you on the podcast. Thank you very much, Arun. It's been a lot of fun.
Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...
Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...
Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO...
GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...
Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to...