Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Earned First

Holding groups, CMOs & Cannes with Charlotte Mceleny

May 20, 202640 minVideo
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Charlotte Mceleny has seen the PR and marketing industry from both sides, through 15 years as a journalist, then inside a holding group at MediaMonks. In this conversation, she and Arun Sudhaman work through what's actually happening to the holding group model, why PR keeps failing the measurement test, what the CMO role is becoming under CFO pressure, and whether Cannes still means what it once did.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

0:00Welcome to the Earned First podcast. My name is Arun Sudhaman, founding editor at Earned First. And joining us today, we have got Charlotte Mceleny, who is currently a freelance journalist and comms pro. But many of you will know her as a experienced marketing media journalist, spent several years with The Drum. in singapore including as asia

0:30pacific publisher uh before that was with a company called haymarket uh charlotte welcome to the podcast thanks for having me i'm excited yeah we're excited too we are keen to hear what you're up to these days you left the drum i don't know when you left the drum was it last year sorry not the drum you left media monks last year I went into the PR world, yeah, about four or five years ago after like 15 years as a journalist.

1:02Yeah, loved it. Yeah, I've been on both sides now. That's always a fun perspective. And yeah, I think it's been an interesting time to kind of not only kind of be on the PR side, but also be in at an agency after kind of covering the industry for a long time. So in relation to our discussion today, I think I've got a few different. sort of facets of perspectives on this um as we kind of dig into PR and comms and the agency world and kind of what's happening um because

1:33yeah we there's been so much change over the last few years so yeah I love this industry I love covering it loving it being in it it's uh been a bit of a ride yeah no I'm really hopeful that you have um a different perspective i think you you must do i always wonder right when and you would know this when you're outside and you're writing about these companies and you kind of think is this is this really what's happening you know you don't always know for sure and now

2:05when there is so much change going on i've never seen anything like it the last 12 months certainly from a you know in terms of the public relations firms at least but then part of me is kind of wondering how dramatic is it internally so we'll get to that um we'll start with holding groups i think because that seems like the best place to start there seems to be so much going on um in terms of how they're changing and evolving some would say that the holding group era is

2:37is perhaps I don't know if ending is too strong a word. You had spent a few years with MediaMonks, which of course positioned itself as the, you know, the kind of challenger, the disruptor to the traditional holding group landscape. Certainly from the public relations perspective, I would say the amount of changes I've never seen. And it does call into question whether holding groups are the best vehicle for public relations firms. But how do you see it from your perspective?

3:09Yeah, I think the model's been challenged for years, hence the likes of your Monks, your Stagwells, all of these guys kind of cropping up and offering alternatives. But I think in the last couple of years with the emergence of AI and kind of all of these huge shifts that we're all feeling ourselves, I think it's kind of accelerated some of those conversations that were already happening. PR particularly has been interesting because I think the role that PR plays within those holding groups has, we were kind of joking before we

3:41said on the, some PR arms of these holding groups literally sit in other buildings and are kind of kept physically at a distance. So that whether PR has ever been integrated into that model at all is like a legitimate question here. It feels like with the WPP stuff. it feels like the easy route to kind of sort of break off that chunk um it's because it's been less integrated so i think then it it it places a big question back

4:12on i think the holding groups of like whether that integration has really um happened um but i think for me it's an interesting conversation because you've also got in parallel this conversation with ai of kind of pr having a bit of a resurgence of value you know with like the role that the journalism and kind of create you know content plays in geo and things like that there is kind of an opportunity again to integrate it better and i think you know rise the conversation of pi into the pr into the boardroom so there's

4:45i think personally i have this conflict with this holding group conversation because it's like okay on the one hand has it been integrated is this an obvious way to break it up on the other hand is this a total missed opportunity to have a really interesting sort of strategic um integration with marketing and pr i think maybe both things are true um but it yeah for me it i think i do i i mean i'm a i think maybe it's the journalist in me but i'm always kind of looking at the optimistic side and it's like that was that's such an opportunity for pr to

5:16have this moment i kind of want to see better integrated pr with marketing um yeah most journalists i've come across are a little bit more negative than that but i like it i like it very interesting observations the I think it is an opportunity, actually, for public relations, for the reasons you've pointed out, that upstream shift towards the boardroom, towards areas where perhaps public

5:47relations can demonstrate more strategic importance is clear. And you're right, you do wonder why the holding groups are less interested in that. But when you look at what they're investing in, and what they're betting on it does seem to be media buying it does seem to be e -commerce conversion technology in general ai is there anything there that makes you think otherwise and and what does that mean for perhaps you know all the creatives

6:19and the consultants that these holding groups have spent decades accumulating yeah we saw so publicist has acquired live ramp so that that's like maybe a good kind of parallel on this it's like you know you see one holding group trying to sell off its pr arm and what you know create some cash from that and then the other side you see kind of these data companies being snapped up by another holding group and ultimately the the the reason you would buy these data companies

6:49is is part of this bet on ai right like you don't have an ai you don't have good skin in the game if you don't have the data that underpins the ai right and the quality of that So you can understand the strategic bet that they're making there. And then we're also saying that AI is kind of fueling this resurgence in value for PR. So again, there's another interesting sort of battle there. But I think the challenge that PR has always had that the media and e -commerce side doesn't

7:20have is this measurement conversation. And one of the things that I think that's interesting with the holding groups and how they're kind of developing is. And again, in WPP's kind of announcements that it's making and how it's going to kind of refresh itself, this kind of move towards outcomes model. the way that that would work is your client would say this is how we want to grow this is the sales we want to make and you would underpin your entire agency model around that versus charging for time and you

7:51know assets and things like that and so it's a complete shift in the way that the agency would be structured how you would pay staff would then have to be against these goals of around growth and sales and things like that so it's it's a big structural undertaking at like a very basic level and I don't think any of the agencies have yet got a big scaled case for how that would work but I think they're working on it and then it's like if you think about how does PR fit within that when the conversation around PR has

8:24always been quite challenged against measurement particularly if you're equating it to sales I think that's when it becomes very difficult for that that value you know we're anecdotally saying the case for PR moving upstream is because there's more value on journalism how it sort of fits in but yet with that still conversation isn't moving into and therefore that makes a sale and so I think for me that's where this is becoming disconnected for PR it's a measurement conversation yeah really good point difficult to measure difficult

8:55to value effectively in a holding group context in fact in many contexts and difficult to scale as well I would imagine right so at least with these you know, data and AI plays, I think they're much easier for a holding group to then kind of replicate that globally. If you look at what Publicis has been able to do, for example. And that seems to be where the opportunity lies. But surely that has an implication, not just for PR, perhaps, you know, for the creative agencies as well. Do you think perhaps they're imperiled

9:30as well by the way the holding group model is evolving? Yeah, I think there's sort of two parts to that because I think agencies have always, on the creative side, have always had a kind of dual job. strategic part it's the finding something that is the differentiator it's the strategic you know white space it's it's kind of finding something surprising that makes you stopped in your track tracks on social or tv or whatever the context of it is and then there's also literally creating the assets of creative

10:02to fit into those slots so ai is helping that part that's the second part of the model where it's kind of right reducing the cost and the the human need um from a resourcing point of view for that and um that's very much like that's not a new thing agencies have been kind of figuring out how to to do that for a long time and you've got lots of startups in that space trying to kind of come into there and answer that challenge um and ultimately that's filling a need as well

10:32because if you think about all the different platforms that we've got from social and audio tv um it is quite the complicated job to create all of those assets in different languages like we're in APAC and so there's a need for technology to do that really otherwise existing as a brand in that context is too expensive but the I think the interesting thing is like where does this leave the strategic role of creative and how do you price on that now and then that goes into

11:05the an interesting conversation which for me is a a journalist and someone who's interested in kind of content is well we've potentially got a lot of ai slop and you know if who's who's kind of dictating what good is who like for me the the just you know it goes to quite a deep level of trust and you know fact checking but then also on the other side it's like who how how does ai find surprising things you know i grew up in the 90s where tv ads were the for

11:38me like the golden era tv ads um and some of them were bonkers like they just didn't make sense and it was kind of art in a weird way it allowed kind of creatives to be completely insane in those days um whether those worked or not is another question and obviously we're kind of better at optimizing making marketing work these days that's the measurement conversation but um there's still a space for kind of weirdness and pricing and an ai doesn't do that it kind

12:09of is going towards an average or it's you know it's trained on yeah averages and commonality and things like that so i think the big question that's unanswered in the industry is that layer of strategic creativity and and kind of surprise and pr does tend to sit in in that arena in in a lot of respects because pr isn't you know it's it's finding that space to kind of create a new narrative and um and so i think there is there

12:39is this world where we will be able to articulate that value and charge for it probably better than we are now but we're in a bit of a messy middle point i think particularly because and because of ai so um but again ever the optimist this is for me it's an opportunity well there's a lot of opportunity i think i mean it's well put you could you can argue that for independence um independent firms, for example, this presents a huge opportunity. Of course, I think they're

13:10all grappling with a lot of challenges, unfortunately, at the moment in terms of economic situations and political volatility and so forth. And that shift to outcomes -based pricing, which I think WPP outlined at its AGM, very interesting. You know, you do wonder how it's going to work. given not only how difficult that will be, but also WPP's own cash position and the debt they have.

13:42Looking at the holding group landscape overall, what do you think of how Publicis has been able to kind of outstrip really all of its competitors if you look at what's been happening? Are we kind of moving to a situation where... you know we have publicists and and then there's the rest a little bit for sure i mean the gap that they have from a literal financial like value is an

14:14unbelievable gap now um gonna be hard i think for the others to recover in any short amount of time um but one thing i always think about with this is and you know we've seen ipg and omnicom merge as well you've kind of everyone is we've got less and less options at that kind of scaled level. And I kind of think if I was what those holding groups might consider a kind of tier two or tier three client, still well

14:44in the millions and millions of spend, right, I would not be feeling very important. So I wonder if this then creates an opportunity for your Habas or your Stagwell or Monks, you know, these players who have a bit more scale than an independent independent and can make those sorts of very important very scaled you know large amounts of cash kind of clients feel a bit more important than if they were in a kind of bigger structure but at the same time your publicist you know

15:14those guys that this this kind of growth and the scale that they've got means they've probably got good prices and things like that and everything is becoming increasingly driven by a conversation with procurement and finance so there's there's multiple layers and it depends i think on what clients really want from that relationship with an agency but um yes there might be a kind of need for publicists and those guys but i don't again i'm just such an optimist where's the opportunity but yeah for me you know if i was if i was kind

15:45of one of the smaller agencies i would kind of be looking at that you know become client centric and make those clients you know the most important clients you can you can get and i think there's kind of growth to be had there um i think that's sort of super interesting actually yeah absolutely i guess the question probably that persists is always Is that best accomplished within a publicly held structure? But that's quite a big question.

16:17Don't let Omnicom hear you refer to it as a merger, by the way. It's a takeover or an acquisition or however you want to frame it. It's not a merger of equals. And just on your point on procurement, let's talk about that briefly, because how do you see that impacting the CFO role? The fact that so many of the conversations now do seem to be so financially focused in terms of how

16:48these buying decisions get made. Do you see that changing the CMO role at all? Yeah, 100%. I've spent the last couple of months through different projects speaking with CMOs a lot about the challenges that they're facing and kind of the gaps of their skills and things that they're kind of trying to find out. And one of the big themes that keeps coming up is, I guess, improving their ability to talk to their CFOs and to procurement at a

17:21level where they're talking their language and they can articulate, I guess, the value of the work that they're doing and things like that. But one of the skills gaps that comes up, AI is obviously. a big topic but um the second one is kind of being able to talk at board level about um the the financial side of things because i guess that's it's coming to them as a pressure um but it's but it's also i guess everything's changing so much um you know this move to outcomes is driven by that sort of structural change i

17:53guess the agencies are responding to that um that need from um you know they're pushing that down onto their agencies which sort of shows that that need um but yeah in the conversations that i've been having it it's it's it's a gap um cmos need sort of help and support understanding how to do that better um because they've got a difficult role though you know they're managing so many things and they also have to talk at a level of a cfo at the same time so it's a complicated role these days It's fascinating, actually, because

18:25that's always been, as you would probably know, it's been the perennial bugbear in the comms world. If you talk to CCOs, corporate comms heads, it's always about how do we demonstrate our value in terms that the boardroom can understand, but not dumb it down to something like AVEs. CMOs have had an easier ride in this regard because

18:57they're able to connect their work more easily, perhaps, to sales or to conversion. But it sounds like it's not necessarily the case. Even CMOs are facing increasing pressure to demonstrate their commercial viability. companies in general are viewing the CMO role? Yeah, I think the job

19:28tenure thing is another kind of evergreen topic as well, right? Because I think the average tenure of a CMO is like two years or something crazy and it's not really long enough to see it. Get in, win a can line and get out. I think that's the cycle. Yeah, and I think that sort of speaks to a lot of the challenges that the industry is having because if your average cmo tenure is sort of two years within that you're then expecting results within you know i mean and

20:01also back to the the point that we won't dig into too heavily but most of these sort of large -scale companies are publicly traded so you have to um you know respond you know report on a quarterly basis and so you've kind of they're in this churn of quarter by quarter proving something that we know through looking at effectiveness studies and you know things like that that that's not really how things work at that kind of brand and and kind of longer term level and so i think

20:34it yeah i think the challenge that cmos have is that they're i'm going to reference a walk um way of looking at this they call it the twin pace principle so they they kind of say that marketers have to work at these two levels you've got this kind of long -term brand building part and then you have this like quarter by quarter performance delivery side so cmos kind of live a bit of a split personality they've got this long -term creative brand got to think at that level because if you drop that people will forget you in a year's time and you'll kind of lose

21:06your your share of market But then we've still got to deliver quarter by quarter on a sales and performance point of view. So I think it's challenging living in both of those worlds and then being able to speak on both of those worlds to a CFO to explain that dual impact. For some brands, maybe that's easier because of what you say and how you sell it. But yeah, it's a difficult, I think, headspace to be in. I don't envy CMOs. They have a lot of pressure. and add in the fact

21:38that they now have to be technical experts with with ai and things like that so yeah absolutely they have to demonstrate mastery and demonstrate what they're doing to automate their functions um which can't be easy and we can't forget all of the external factors now the the economic environment we're seeing play out in in you know different ways but there's definitely i think an overall push to eliminate roles and eliminate functions uh yeah i'm seeing i saw diageo for

22:09just as one example is i think getting rid of kind of the whole regional layer of um functions including marketing and comms and i think the north american marketing head is the first first significant casualty and i can't imagine they're the only company that's looking at this and we've seen this pendulum swing um wildly in different ways but we it does feel like we're in a moment now where there's more pressure to remove some of these layers um which going on since since

22:43kind of covered I think yeah I think the difference in this it is cyclical right we particularly if you're I'm based in Singapore where you usually have it's it's very tangible that swing between the regional power and the local power because singapore is such a regional hub so you do have these periods of time in singapore where suddenly the job those big jobs go and you can you can see those people kind of leave both a kind of brand side level and an agency side um but at

23:14this time it feels different because i think it's been happening since covid and the pendulum kind of hasn't swung back so that regional layer hasn't been put back in we're in kind of year six of that happening was usually that that might have resurfaced again i think um one of the other i mean and then it's being echoed at agencies i think um densu has been talking out there about that that kind of shift from removing the regional layer they've done it through rounds of i think restructures and things like that but they're still talking about that as a as a kind of structure

23:46for them it's like putting more power in the markets and that's completely driven by the brands requiring that um so yeah i think yeah it is it is cyclical but i do feel like we've been in this version of the cycle for quite quite a long time yeah and i'm not really sure if anyone really knows when that might come that regional layer will be important again maybe you know a bit like yeah i mean surely it's going to come back again but um yeah i don't know maybe maybe not maybe it's structural this time you know

24:17at some point things change it does feel like things you know are everything is kind of up for grabs at the moment i would never have if you told me 12 months ago that you know all these agencies were going to be merging and some would be up for sale and um you know i would not have predicted it so you you can ask the question it could be structural this time whether it's the right decision i'm not sure right i think these regional layers often do a lot i know certainly in many comms functions they are invaluable um

24:52But they're difficult to justify at times like this. Yeah, it's like that regional layer usually, particularly from a comms perspective, would be where you would have your senior advisory around important subjects that would mitigate risk and uncertainty and, you know, really important cushioning layers for challenging times. So I think the other thing that's kind of a little hard to see the logic in is we're in this time that feels so unpredictable. so kind of fragile

25:23and crazy. And yet most companies have kind of removed that senior layer of comfort. They could be kind of exposing themselves to risk in some sense. So I think that's what kind of feels a little bit unpredictable about the industry as well. To your point, I'm not sure where it's going to go because the logic that you would normally apply to some of this. doesn't quite sort of seem there. No. Some of the decisions seem a little bit knee -jerk, perhaps. Yeah.

25:54And you're right. I mean, even just in terms, if you think of the reporting lines, if you go from, you know, having local markets report into a regional head, and look, I know there's a lot of, well, I think there's probably a lot of fat out there that can be trimmed. I'm sure, you know, there's good reasons for that. you can't have all the local markets reporting into the US or wherever. I mean, that just seems so unwieldy. So it does raise some interesting questions.

26:27I think Dentsu is a really interesting case, perhaps a unique one. I'm curious to hear your thoughts. There was a lot of talk that they were selling their international operations, although I saw there was a recent interview with the Dentsu CEO and campaign where... He pointed out it was never confirmed that they were actually up for sale. But they have, you know, they've got quite a challenging set of conditions in terms of their

26:57numbers, in terms of their global network. And for them, you would think they need more, they actually need more senior talent outside the country, whether it's in regions or local markets. So I wonder how you see that playing out. i think it's interesting isn't it it's one of the things i think it always comes back to for me with this conversation is yeah i think they probably do need more senior talent particularly to kind

27:27of give the you know or create the trust with clients and potential clients that you know they're being sort of serviced outside of japan and things like that i think you know clients want to be serviced at that level locally so that they you know got um the talent that sort of corresponds with that um but then the question is are our clients really willing to pay for that there's sort of this chicken and egg on that yeah and i think this is and that's ultimately i think the place where the big holding companies are

27:58at we've had this kind of race to the bottom a little bit on on some of the costs from clients um And then the pushback is that you need talent here, you need talent there. And I think we're in a bit of a challenging moment where perhaps a tough question needs to be pushed back on CMOs. And then that goes back to the CFO conversation again, because I think a lot of CMOs probably know that they need to be at least keeping the budgets and keeping these agencies alive and

28:30don't want to see headcounts being reduced on their accounts and things like that. the ask from the cfo is is you know xyz so i think there's it goes back to this need for sort of literacy and empowering the cmo to have that conversation um but we have been i think economic situations have pushed it into that point but yeah so i think holding groups are in a bit of a difficult situation because i do think we need you need solid talent coming through to to kind of help

29:00that regeneration for some of these guys but it's like who's paying for that um but actually i've been i talked to a few recruiter friends recently in in singapore and there are a few more senior roles coming into holding groups and and things like that so i think there's there's been obviously a big big shed of talent yeah it's not like suddenly that suddenly they're going to be recruiting hundreds of roles um to make up for what they've shared um but i think they're now in a point where understanding what

29:32strategic roles they need to put back in place to kind of build that up. I mean, if those redundancy rounds, all of those things that the holding groups have been making were genuinely strategic, the point of it is to sort of strip back, remove the fact to your point earlier, but then look at like, okay, what talent do we need to move in the direction that we need to move into? Again, that may be optimistic of me, but from the conversations we've been having with some recruiters, it does

30:02sound like some of those roles are starting to be put back into the market. That's good to hear. That's good to hear. Positive? Yes, positive, even though, I mean, I do wonder, though, about the whole model when Omnicom is, I think, committed now to 1 .5 billion in savings, cost savings from the interpublic acquisition. But, yeah, anyway. Anyway, let's talk about Cannes. Yes.

30:33Because that's always the industry's. Yeah, while we're talking about ROI, let's talk about Cannes. The industry's always the favorite topic. Do you think there will be more pressure this year? Do you think there's going to be fewer CMOs? Or will they find a way, as always, to make it out there? There is a big challenge from an APAC point of view on it, which is that it's more expensive to literally travel at the moment.

31:04So like flight prices are insane. So I do think that will probably unfortunately impact some of that. But I'm a big believer in people getting together in the industry and Cannes is like the absolute gold standard of that. I want it to be the global event that it deserves to be. So it does need representation from APAC. It needs representation from South America and whatever. But when you go as someone who works in APAC, it's very evident that you're in the minority,

31:37like truly in the minority. I mean, there is some good attempts at doing APAC content from... from Lion's group generally, Walk are pretty good at trying to put stuff on and then outside of, there's usually some sort of fringe events and some of the other publications and stuff that do some bits and bobs. But it would be good to see more APAC representation. But it's, this year particularly, I think it's going to really harm it. It's too expensive. I'm not sure, and

32:09it's become very American actually. I went two years ago. And had had a gap before that. And it was very American. Everyone talks about how the Crozet has been taken over by kind of tech companies. But for me, it was the American accent. Yeah. 100%. I mean, my first can was 2009, I think. Which is always interesting because that was the financial crisis. And I think it was

32:40only about 50%. attendance that year. It was a really crazy year. It also rained a lot. But even then, if you look at the change between then and now, that's 17 years ago. Yeah, I know. It's really a long time. If you look at the comm sector, for example, the Americans didn't really turn up until 2013. The PR lines started in 2009. But the American agencies didn't really commit

33:12to it for three or four years. And yeah, definitely you see much bigger American influence. And you see that playing out, I think, in the conversations as well, in what people are talking about, which I think is a little bit of a shame, actually, because like you said, it should be representative. It should reflect the breadth and depth of the industry. One other thing I really noticed was the Chinese presence, which dropped off for obvious

33:45reasons during COVID, has not really recovered. No, they used to have China Day. Like there was a specific day that, and I remember, I think it had like Tencent or Alibaba sponsorship or something like that for a long time. Yeah, I remember all that. Yeah, that hasn't really come back. It's just pockets of sort of sessions. And I don't know what that's driven by, if that's driven by like less APAC attendees, so therefore less, you know, because I don't think it's, you know, from, I know Lions put in a good effort

34:18into attempting to kind of address that balance. So I don't know. Oh, they've done, yeah. They've done a huge amount of work on diversity. You know, you have to say they've really made significant efforts to diversify CAM, because again, going back. 10 years, you know, it was a very homogenous place, like the industry. And that's changed a lot. You have Inkwell Beach, you know, you have a lot of, they invest a lot, I think, in

34:50just taking people from underrepresented groups to Cannes. But it's quite difficult, I think, with Asia, because you're talking about industry leaders from this part of the world who are maybe not necessarily seeing the value, certainly not. from China. There is an interesting session I saw happening with, I think it's Xu Ting from Singapore, who's leading a discussion on, I think, something to do with Chinese branding, which looks quite good. But yeah, it's kind of one

35:21-off sessions as opposed to a whole day. But we'll see. We'll see how it goes. Yeah, I think, yeah, I'm a big, I'm a big, there will always be a question of like, I think. Does this drive ROI for us? And it is difficult to do that when you're spending more from Asia and it literally costs more to go there and there's less content. So it is tricky. Much easier, I think, to justify

35:51if you're coming from London or even the US. But yeah, I'm a big fan of moving the industry forward through getting together and figuring stuff out. um you know i absolutely hope that we can kind of figure that out and i actually think um spikes coming back this year as the kind of sister event to it kind of properly and i think the feedback from that was good um so i kind of see and i think asia just took a little

36:22bit of time post -covered to come back from events even locally so i i think interestingly it's just this delayed reaction and not being helped by situations that we're in now um yeah and the flights are just a mess as well right because no one is to get to to france from asia you know it's hard to to avoid the middle east yeah yeah i did see a stat the other day and this maybe

36:53comes back to this sort of cfo conversation again i think it's like i'm gonna i did write it down because this is a good stat um so highly creative award -winning campaigns eg online but can be you know any award -winning campaign deliver a 51 increase on roi um so there is is that from walk as well that might be from the lions group yes excellent david tiltman will be so happy with this podcast we've discussed we talked about

37:23brand versus performance and we talked about effectiveness this is a yeah you should get you should be He'll be very happy. There we go. Well, and you guys have awards too. This is just bigging up the case for awards. But, you know, the point of awards, when you don't feel like it's, you know, too much of a commercial machine, is that we get together and we decide what good is. And when juries, I think, take that seriously, which, you know, can lines, obviously, the jury is very

37:53serious there. But, you know, other awards shows when the jury is... taking things very seriously i think it's like a very important part of our industry because it's you know we get together what do we stand for what do we think is good what are we putting on a pedestal it's very important preach i totally agree i think i i had to i was speaking at an awards thing in in tokyo last week the proi awards and they asked me to say a few words about why awards matter and then again you can get so jaded and cynical about

38:25it all Especially when you've seen how awards work and you know how much money they can generate and you see all the category bloat and all of that. But from a commerce perspective as well, I think there's so much negative coverage of PR. And awards is really one of the best ways to demonstrate how much good work the PR world does. And in particular, work that improves societies and helps. organizations build stronger relationships with you know all stakeholder groups that i don't

38:57think that happens without award show mechanisms no the process of writing an awards entry as difficult as it can be sometimes is a very i think the process itself is is kind of important for for people to go through um but yeah to your point there's category bloat there are bad players where it's pay for play like there's reasons why awards generally have gotten that that sort of cynical view but but when they're done well you know i think they're important all right

39:30well we'll leave you on that positive note i think um which yeah indeed so thank you so much charlotte uh for joining the show today and yeah i'm very hopeful we'll get you on again in the in the not too distant future anytime when you need some positivity We always need it. We always need it. Thank you so much. And a big shout out to our producers at Earshot Media.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Kaizzen’s Vineet Handa on monetisation, Middle East expansion and AI enemies

    Oct 30, 202637 minAudio

    Vineet Handa, founder and CEO of Kaizzen, joins the Earned First podcast to discuss one of the more unusual independent agency stories in India. Founded in 2008, the firm sold a majority stake to Maven Corporate...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jean-Léopold Schuybroek: Four decades of building independent PR

    Oct 13, 202625 minAudio

    Jean-Leopold Schuybroek, chair of PROI’s International Development Group, joins the Earned First podcast to reflect on four decades in the consultancy business. The Interel founder and former ICCO chair has spent 20...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Geopolitics, Mastercard & OpenAI's CCO search

    Sep 29, 202639 minAudio

    Earned First's David Blecken and Arun Sudhaman look at the backlash over Singapore Airlines' stake in Air India, Chinese brands going global, and Mastercard's global PR pitch. They also discuss OpenAI's nine-month CCO...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why corporate affairs pros want change, with GlobeScan's Chris Coulter

    Aug 24, 202636 minAudio

    GlobeScan CEO Chris Coulter joins the Earned First podcast to break down findings from the latest Oxford-GlobeScan Global Corporate Affairs Survey. Now in its seventh edition, the study draws on nearly 300 senior...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Culture, Cannes & cockroaches with Charlotte Mceleny

    Jul 30, 202647 minAudio

    Charlotte Mceleny returns to discuss Cannes Lions 2026: the creator economy's growing dominance, the industry's fixation on "culture," and renewed momentum behind CCOs and organisational trust. The conversation turns to...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode