Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Digital Jung

Digital Jung artwork

When the Soul Retreats

May 11, 202330 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode: I look at one of the more difficult experiences of the symbolic life, an experience best known by its religious name: the "dark night of the soul." Sources for quotes and more: 'Selected Letters' by C.G. Jung 'Concerning the Inner Life' by Evelyn Underhill Concerning Rebirth in 'Collected Works, vol. 9i' by C.G. Jung 'Ego and Archetype' by Edward Edinger 'The Masks of God: Creative Mythology' by Joseph Campbell The Romance of Tristan and Iseult, retold by Joseph Bédier (translated by Hilaire Belloc) Luke 17:33, NKJV Tao Te Ching, translated by Man-Ho Kwok, Martin Palmer, and Jay Ramsay 'Mysticism' by Evelyn Underhill The Psychology of the Transference in 'Collected Works, vol. 16' by C.G. Jung 'The Life of Prayer' by Baron Friedrich von Hügel 'Alchemy: An Introduction to the Symbolism and the Psychology' by Marie-Louise von Franz Music: "Dreaming Days," "Slow Vibing," and "The Return" by Ketsa are licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 Like this podcast? Please consider leaving a review at one of the following sites: Apple Podcasts Spotify or support the show with a donation at Buy Me a Coffee: Support the show Connect with me: Instagram (@digital.jung) Facebook (facebook.com/jungiananalyst) Bluesky (@digitaljung.bsky.social) Subscribe to the Digital Jung Newsletter For more on living a symbolic life: Please check out my book, Religious but Not Religious: Living a Symbolic Life.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Digital Young, a podcast about living a symbolic life in a technological age.

SPEAKER_01Man cannot stand a meaningless life.

SPEAKER_00I'm Jason Smith, Jungian analyst, and your host for this show. And in this episode, I look at one of the more difficult experiences of the symbolic life. An experience best known by its religious name The Dark Knight of the Soul.

SPEAKER_02That's the very treasure.

SPEAKER_00Dear colleague, in the confrontation with the unconscious, there are indeed a considerable number of arid patches to be worked through. They cannot be circumvented. At such a time, it is a good thing to have some occupation which has the character of an opus divinum, something like a careful shaping of images, such as many patients paint or carve in wood or stone.

SPEAKER_00These primitive methods have the great advantage that the unconscious continues to work on these patterns, is enthralled and transformed by them. One of the most distressing experiences of the inner life is a phenomenon that is often referred to as spiritual dryness.

SPEAKER_00This is an acutely painful time in which all the richness and meaning that one has experienced in connection with their spiritual practice seems to suddenly disappear, together with the motivation to continue in that practice. These are times as the religious writer Evelyn Underhill explains, speaking from the perspective of the Christian tradition, when all your interest and sense of reality evaporate, when the language of religion becomes meaningless, and you are quite unable, in any real sense, to pray.

SPEAKER_00And it is probably in the Christian tradition where we find this phenomenon of spiritual dryness most clearly articulated, and its qualities, effects, and what it demands of the individual most fully elaborated. Even a person who has little to no interest in anything religious is likely to know and understand the phrase the dark night of the soul, a phrase which describes a particularly profound instance of spiritual dryness, and one which comes from the writings of the Christian mystic, Saint John of the Cross.

SPEAKER_00And it's not uncommon today to find this Christian imagery of the dark night of the soul being used in popular discussions of other traditions to help illustrate their own understanding of and encounter with this difficult spiritual territory. That said, it's not just a Christian experience, but a universal human one.

SPEAKER_00And as such, it's important not only to have some awareness of its existence, of the fact of it, but to be able to recognize the different contours of this inner situation in order that we can understand the meaning of certain kinds of psychological experiences that can and will happen in the practice of the symbolic life, and to navigate our way through them.

SPEAKER_00In the opening quote, we heard Jung speak of the arid patches that are encountered when one is actively engaged in the work of individuation, what he calls the confrontation with the unconscious. In this kind of close attention to one's inner life, Jung suggests, it's impossible to avoid going through many such patches. And the quote comes from a letter written in response to a colleague who presumably was going through one of these difficult times and had reached out to Jung for advice.

SPEAKER_00We don't have the first part of their correspondence, so we don't have a description of how this arid patch manifested itself in this particular case. And Jung doesn't give us any details. However, we can find hints in Jung's other writings that give us some indication of what was likely involved in this experience of psychological drought.

SPEAKER_00In an essay titled Concerning Rebirth, Jung speaks of something called an abaisement du niveau mental. This is a phrase that he borrows from a French psychologist of the time named Pierre Jannet, with whom he had studied at the very beginning of his career. The phrase can be translated as a lowering of the mental level, and it refers to a kind of slackening of consciousness, a deterioration of the capacity for a directed application of one's will.

SPEAKER_00This is felt subjectively, writes Jung, as listlessness, moroseness, and depression. And he goes on to say one no longer has any wish or courage to face the tasks of the day. Jung compares this experience to one described in many indigenous and shamanic traditions as loss of soul. And this can be a helpful image for getting a better understanding of what an abaisement du niveau mental really feels like at the subtlest level of one's subjective experience.

SPEAKER_00Loss of soul points to both a loss of vitality, a sudden lack of some animating or motivating force in one's life, as well as a quality of no longer feeling like oneself, a sense of feeling disconnected from one's familiar experience of being. It's an experience of absence, right? Of something missing, of being emptied out, drained, held at a distance from the rest of life.

SPEAKER_00Now so far, all that's been described probably sounds indistinguishable from what we normally call depression. And to a certain extent, that's true. At the same time, however, the ideas I've looked at up to this point spiritual dryness, dark night of the soul, loss of soul, and even a basement du Niveau mental, expressed as they are through images, all have a resonance to them that extends our imagination of what potentially is at work in depression.

SPEAKER_00That is, they change our perspective from thinking solely in terms of symptoms to imagining through symbols. And this is a crucial change for it opens up the possibility of discovering meaning, even in the midst of what may seem at the time unbearable. When we think in terms of symptoms, all we find is something intensely disagreeable that must be eliminated as soon as possible so that we can return to normal, to a previous state of existence.

SPEAKER_00As Edward Edinger notes, symptoms are disturbing states of mind which we are unable to control and which are essentially meaningless. That is, contain no value or significance. Symptoms are what we have left when we have lost a sense of the symbolic. For its part, though the symbolic imagination doesn't necessarily relieve us of the intensely disagreeable, it can suggest a way through and beyond such experiences.

SPEAKER_00It orients us in a different direction, so to speak, for it casts our gaze not backwards to what we have been, but forwards to what we may become, if we learn how to meet and even participate with the psychological forces bearing down on us. A sensitivity for the symbolic, in other words, can help us to persevere even when the night grows dark.

SPEAKER_00Now I'm not suggesting that any of this is easy. The symbolic life, as I've said before, is not a path of denial, nor is it a path to the avoidance of suffering. So long as we are human beings living human lives, we are sure to meet with suffering at some point. What human beings do seem to be able to deny and avoid, strangely enough, is the possibility of the experience of meaning in the events of our lives, including and especially suffering.

SPEAKER_00To engage the symbolic imagination is to lean into the meaningfulness of experience, which means at the same time leaning into the experience itself, accepting it, reflecting on it, and growing through it. And of course, that's the great problem, isn't it? We have understandably a natural resistance to pain and don't want to accept it, let alone allow for it to have some positive meaning for our lives.

SPEAKER_00At the same time, though, we have no choice but to accept it. Now this doesn't mean falling into a state of passive resignation and giving everything up for lost. What it does mean is recognizing that pain, whether it comes in the form of illness or injury or some kind of spiritual or psychological distress, pain throws us back, as it were, into the arms of life, or as the old religious language would have it, on the mercy of God.

SPEAKER_00For here we come upon a situation that cannot be solved by an act of will. Of course, there are things we can do. We can and should seek medical or psychotherapeutic interventions when necessary, for instance. But we seek these kinds of support because we have come to the limits of our own power. We need something outside or beyond ourselves to assist us, and at times to carry us.

SPEAKER_00And when I say that we're thrown back into the arms of life, I mean that regardless of whatever interventions we apply to our situation, they themselves are still dependent on the natural processes of the body or the psyche in order to be effective. We may apply a caste in the case of a broken bone, but it's not the caste that heals, right?

SPEAKER_00It's the body that knits the bone back together. It's nature herself that does the work of healing. Often the part that is left to us to perform is to submit not only to whatever treatment we may receive, but to the workings of nature as well. And it's the recognition of this task of submission and our conscious participation in it that set up the conditions by which we are ready to discern the emergence of meaning in our ordeals.

SPEAKER_00There's a scene in the well-known medieval romance of Tristan and Isolt, which gives a symbolic depiction of this experience of giving over to life in the face of great affliction. A central image in this scene is that which Joseph Campbell calls the rudderless boat, the vessel in which the hero is carried, in Campbell's words, on the bosom of those cosmic powers by which the movements of the heavens and all things on earth are controlled.

SPEAKER_00However, it's only because of direst necessity that the hero Tristan turns to those powers at all. And the whole scene begins when a knight known as the Moorholt, acting on behalf of the King of Ireland, is sent to demand a terrible tribute that includes three hundred youths and three hundred maidens from the King of Cornwall, King Mark, Tristan's lord and uncle.

SPEAKER_00None of King Mark's barons will take up the defence of Cornwall because the Moorholt is a giant, and no one has ever been able to overcome him. Tristan alone, the youngest of them all, agrees to take up the battle. The fight between the two warriors is fierce. In the end Tristan is able to kill the Moorholt, leaving a splinter from his sword in the giant's head.

SPEAKER_00But he does not escape without his own injuries, and upon returning from the battle he faints in his uncle's arms because of his wounds. And the story continues. But over in Tintagel, Tristan languished, for there trickled a poisonous blood from his wound.

SPEAKER_00The doctors found that the Moorholt had thrust into him a poisoned barb, and as their potions and their theriac could never heal him, they left him in God's hands. So hateful a stench came from his wound that all his dearest friends fled him, all save King Mark, Gorvanal, and Dinus of Leiden. They always could stay near his couch because their love overcame their abhorrence.

SPEAKER_00At last Tristan had himself carried into a hut apart on the shore, and lying facing the sea, he awaited death. He thought, Have you thus abandoned me, King Mark? Me who saved the honor of your land? No. I know, fair uncle, that you would give your life for mine. But what avails your tenderness?

SPEAKER_00I must die. Yet it is good to see the sun, and my heart is still high. I would like to try the sea that brings all chances. I would have the sea bear me far off alone, to what land no matter, so that it heal me of my wound, and perchance someday I will once more serve you, fair uncle, as your harper, your huntsman, and your liege.

SPEAKER_00He begged so long that King Mark accepted his desire. He bore him into a boat with neither sail nor oar, and Tristan wished that his harp only should be placed beside him. For sails he could not lift, nor oar ply, nor sword wield. And as a seaman on some long voyage casts to the sea a beloved companion dead, so Gorvanal pushed out to sea that boat where his dear son lay, and the sea drew him away.

SPEAKER_00There is a paradox at the heart of any inner work that goes at all deep. The first encounter with the wider personality, the more comprehensive life to which such work can lead us comes as a wounding, a weakening, a diminishment of the self. The path to new life, it seems, goes through the valley of death.

SPEAKER_00This is a spiritual truth that has been understood for millennia. Whoever seeks to save his life will lose it, says Jesus in the Gospel of Luke. And whoever loses his life will preserve it. Use up all you are, says the Tao to Qing, and then you can be made new.

SPEAKER_00This, then, is one of the meanings that a time of spiritual dryness heralds. Expressed in religious language, we might say that body and soul are being prepared for a greater share of the life of the spirit. They are being used up in order to be made new, emptied in order to become full. As Evelyn Underhill puts it, psychologically then, the dark night of the soul is due to the double fact of the exalted.

SPEAKER_00Exhaustion of an old state and the growth towards a new state of consciousness. It is a growing pain in the organic process of the self's attainment of the absolute. Jung expresses the same dynamic from the viewpoint of psychology. He writes there are moments in human life when a new page is turned.

SPEAKER_00New interests and tendencies appear which have hitherto received no attention. During the incubation period of such a change, we can often observe a loss of conscious energy. The new development has drawn off the energy it needs from consciousness. One of the examples that he gives as an illustration of this process is the empty stillness which precedes creative work.

SPEAKER_00In the practice of the symbolic life, it is inevitable that we will experience times of discouragement, often very acute discouragement. There are indeed a considerable number of arid patches to be worked through, teaches Jung. They cannot be circumvented. During such times it is helpful to remember that spiritual dryness signals new life, that the withdrawal of psychic energy prepares the way for a new creativity.

SPEAKER_00It's tempting, however, to want to rush ahead to that new land of promise, forgetting that there is still an ocean to cross in a boat with no sail and no oars. We cannot forgo the dark night if we wish to really experience the dawn. And if there is one key takeaway to all of this, I think that is it.

SPEAKER_00During times of spiritual dryness we are constrained to wait, to endure, to submit. In this way we may perhaps learn to relinquish a too great reliance on our own will, and thereby make ourselves susceptible to a deeper will. Such trials, declares Baron von Hugel, an influential lay theologian writing in the early twentieth century, such trials are sent us for the purpose of deoccupying us with our smaller selves, an idea completely in keeping with Jung's own psychological insights.

SPEAKER_00In the meantime, it is necessary that we learn the art of waiting. I say waiting, though it might be better thought of as not interfering. As Marie Louise von Franz states, one cannot force a process of growth. It is foolish to storm at a little oak tree, telling it to grow more quickly.

SPEAKER_00To this end, both Jung and Von Hugel counsel that it is valuable to have some other occupation to engage with during times when the soul has gone into retreat. This advice is meant not as a distraction from difficulty, not as a means of simply killing time or fending off boredom. Rather, it is for the sake of allowing ourselves to loosen the grip that we try to keep on the management of our life and our psychological growth, turning it over instead to the work of the new life, transforming us from within, that hidden work unfolding in a place too deep for words.

SPEAKER_00I'll be back in just a minute with this week's parting words. You'll find a list of all the sources used in this week's episode in the show notes. You'll also find links to connect with me on social media, as well as for my book, Religious But Not Religious, Living a Symbolic Life, available from Chiron Publications.

SPEAKER_00If you enjoyed this episode, please consider supporting the production of this show. You can do so for as little as the cost of a cup of coffee at Buy MeACoffee. You'll even find some extras for this show posted there from time to time. Just hit the support the show link in the show notes. Thank you very much. Now here are this week's Parting Words.

SPEAKER_00We are used to thinking in terms of action, right? Of doing. Times of spiritual dryness confront us with the limits of our power to act. Teach us, in fact, that there is a value beyond action, beyond productivity. They remind us, however painfully, that life is not just material for us to work on, but an abiding reality to which we belong.

SPEAKER_00The effect of the dark night of the soul, says Evelyn Underhill, is this. The self, she says, loses the power to do, and learns to surrender its will to the operation of a larger life that it may be.

SPEAKER_00Until next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Metaphor of the Machine

    Nov 19, 202631 minAudio

    In this episode: We look at the first part of Chapter 2 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'The World of Reality.' We discuss how the imagination that we bring to our perception of life can have either a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. More Than Words

    Nov 5, 202632 minAudio

    In this episode: We look at the second part of Chapter 1 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'What Is Mysticism?' The discussion this week explores different ways of knowing and what it means to have a direct...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Art of Uniting with Reality

    Oct 22, 202626 minAudio

    In this episode: We explore the question of how we know things and why it is necessary to direct our attention to what Jung calls the "higher unity" of which our everyday consciousness is just a part. Listen to Chapters...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Doors of Perception

    Oct 8, 202629 minAudio

    In this episode: I introduce the fifth season of Digital Jung with its special focus on the book Practical Mysticism by Evelyn Underhill. Listen to the preface of Practical Mysticism Here Sources for quotes and more:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Mystic Way

    Sep 24, 202644 minAudio

    In this episode: I discuss the figures of Ahab, Starbuck, and Ishmael as representatives of three possible responses to the encounter with the numinous. I look at the contrast between the Iron Way of Ahab and what I...

    Credit the people on this episode