In this episode: We look at the first part of Chapter 2 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'The World of Reality.' We discuss how the imagination that we bring to our perception of life can have either a damaging or a life-giving effect depending on its capacity to meet and receive the fullness of experience. Listen to individual chapters of Practical Mysticism here Sources for quotes and more: 'Practical Mysticism: A Little Book for Normal People' by Evelyn Underhill 'The Psychology of the Child Archetype' by C.G. Jung in Collected Works vol. 9i 'Symbols and the Interpretation of Dreams' by C.G. Jung in Collected Works vol. 18 S1, Ep. 9: Technology and the Soul 'Religious but Not Religious' by Jason E. Smith Healing, poem by D.H. Lawrence 'A Dwelling Place for Wisdom' by Raimon Panikkar 'On the Relation of Analytical Psychology to Poetry' by C.G. Jung in Collected Works vol. 15 Tao Te Ching (Stephen Mitchell translation) Music: "Dreaming Days," "Slow Vibing," and "The Return" by Ketsa are licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 Like this podcast? Please consider leaving a review: Apple Podcasts Spotify Or, if you are able, support the show with a donation at Buy Me a Coffee: Support the show Connect with me: Instagram (@digital.jung) Facebook (facebook.com/jungiananalyst) Bluesky (@digitaljung.bsky.social) Subscribe to the Digital Jung Newsletter For more on living a symbolic life: Please check out my book, Religious but Not Religious: Living a Symbolic Life.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Digital Yoma, a podcast about living a symbolic life in a technological age.
SPEAKER_01Man cannot stand a meaningless life.
SPEAKER_00I'm Jason Smith, Jungian analyst and the host of this show. A show about exploring what it means to live a life of meaning.
SPEAKER_02It's the human soul. That's the buried treasure.
SPEAKER_00I'm glad you're here. Let's begin. If the doors of perception were cleansed, said Blake, everything would appear to man as it is: Infinite.
SPEAKER_00But the doors of perception are hung with the cobwebs of thought, prejudice, cowardice, sloth. Eternity is with us, inviting our contemplation perpetually. But we are too frightened, lazy, and suspicious to respond, too arrogant to still our thought, and let divine sensation have its way.
SPEAKER_00Evelyn Underhill. Our opening quote returns to that famous line from Blake that, as we saw back in Episode One of this season, The Doors of Perception, formed the epigraph for the book we're exploring this season Evelyn Underhill's Practical Mysticism. But here, Underhill reminds us that our doors of perception are not cleansed.
SPEAKER_00They are, as she puts it, hung with the cobwebs of thought. And so, of course, we do not see things as they are. Our perceptions are colored, even obscured by the clutter of our minds. And so before we can begin to recognize the truth that, as Shakespeare taught us, there are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in our philosophy, we first need to deal with that mental clutter.
SPEAKER_00In fact, we first need to see that it is indeed clutter, because we are in the habit of mistaking our preferences and prejudices for clarity and objectivity. And this is a central theme of chapter two, titled The World of Reality, the first part of which I'll be talking about in today's episode.
SPEAKER_00And in this chapter, Underhill starts off by returning to the idea that she pointed out in chapter one, that the world we experience is but a concept of the world, that it is filtered through the labels we give to things and not an experience of the things as they are in themselves. She reminds us that under normal conditions we live, quote, in a world of imagination rather than a world of facts, that the universe in which we live and at which we look is but a construction which the mind has made from some few amongst the wealth of materials at its disposal.
SPEAKER_00Because we use, as she says, just a small sampling of the wealth of materials at our disposal, our image of life and the world is necessarily fragmentary. And the fragments that we choose for our image of reality are generally those that we find most congenial to our disposition and preference. It is an image determined by our current and untransformed state of consciousness, which, says Underhill, perpetually imposes its own convention and checks the free representation of life.
SPEAKER_00Jung's warning about how we approach archetypal images as they appear in religious and mythological symbols is a relevant warning to invoke here. He writes Whatever explanation or interpretation does to an archetypal image, we do to our own souls as well, with corresponding results for our own well being.
SPEAKER_00The archetype, let us never forget this, is a psychic organ present in all of us. A bad explanation means a correspondingly bad attitude to this organ which may thus be injured. But the ultimate sufferer is the bad interpreter himself. If our understanding of an archetypal image is inadequate, it does damage to the soul because it is not just an idea, but a fundamental part of our being.
SPEAKER_00An archetype, as Jung says elsewhere, is a piece of life. And so how much more consequential for our well-being, for our soul, are our explanations, our understandings, our attitudes toward life. Our clouded and therefore limited perceptions can only result in inadequate explanations, which, if we follow Jung's idea, can cause injury both to reality and to ourselves.
SPEAKER_00And this is exactly what Underhill is driving at here. To illustrate the fragmentary and incomplete quality of our perceptions, Underhill uses the image of a tapestry. On the front side is the neat representation of a scene from life, while on the other side are the many short ends, the clumsy joins and patches, that is, all the pieces that were hidden or left out in the creation of the image on the front.
SPEAKER_00In driving home her analogy, she writes as a tapestry picture, however various and full of meaning, is ultimately reducible to little squares, so the world of common sense is ultimately reducible to a series of static elements conditioned by the machinery of the brain. Subtle curves, swift movement, delegate gradation, that machinery cannot represent.
SPEAKER_00It leaves them out. One of the things that I find fascinating about this last quote is that even though Underhill is writing these words in nineteen fourteen, using the tapestry image as an illustration of how the habitual state of consciousness operates, she is inadvertently echoing into the future, so to speak, a perfect description of the difference between digital and analog technology, something that is powerfully relevant to us today.
SPEAKER_00And to me, this suggests that this tension that she's describing between the little squares or static elements and the subtle curves or delicate gradation in our perception of things may in fact be an age-old and even inborn aspect of human experience, an archetypal situation, one that we continue to meet in new and updated forms, though always the same problem at its core.
SPEAKER_00Now, digital technology wouldn't make its appearance for another twenty years or so after Underhill's book, and it wouldn't start to become the dominant force that it is now for another thirty years or so after that, as it became more a part of our everyday lives with the rise of personal computing. Still, Underhill's early twentieth century words are an uncannily accurate description of a twenty-first century experience.
SPEAKER_00And just as the image of the tapestry can help us understand how our usual state of consciousness functions, so the digital analog divide, taken as both image and fact, also has implications for our understanding and experience of our own consciousness. Put in very simple terms, the difference between analog and digital is this.
SPEAKER_00Analog signals have a continuous quality to them. Well, digital signals are discrete. For analog, there is a smooth flow from one value to the next. Well, digital jumps from one value to the next. This means that there is a loss of information when something is converted from analog to digital.
SPEAKER_00Analog, in other words, has the quality described in that previous quote from Underhill. Subtle curves, swift movement, delicate gradation that machinery cannot represent. It leaves them out. Just replace the word machinery with digital, and the picture is complete. Digital technology has advantages, of course.
SPEAKER_00It's what allows me to share this episode of the podcast with you, for instance, and allows you to listen to it. A podcast, by the way, called, of course, Digital Jung, a name which, as I said back in the very first season in Episode 9, Technology and the Soul, quote, is meant as both an acknowledgement of the fact that the digital age in which we are living is a reality that we cannot ignore or avoid, and at the same time, a recognition that it presents potential difficulties and even dangers for the living of the symbolic life.
SPEAKER_00Digital technology has a robustness to it that analog does not have. It's easier to reproduce without any real degradation over time. And this is very helpful for the task of operating upon information. But in the end, the operation of discrete bits of information that do not degrade over time is not how life works, right?
SPEAKER_00It's how a machine works. And there's a reason that Underhill uses the phrase the machinery of the brain when talking about how human beings perceive life. The problem of the relationship of the human to the machine was an acute one at the turning point between the mid-19th and early twentieth centuries, as what was known as the Second Industrial Revolution rolled on, and it was a problem that would explode with the onset of the First World War, which, as we've seen, was the very moment when this book we are looking at was published.
SPEAKER_00And so, while all of this talk about tapestries and digital technologies is for the purpose of illustrating the way we commonly perceive the world, the way we perceive the world matters. How we look at the world, at the cosmos, at what it means to be a human being, are not just idle and indifferent ideas.
SPEAKER_00They have real world consequences for how we treat the world, how we relate to the cosmos, and how we enact our humanity. Our technologies, whether it is the relatively simple loom on which the tapestry is woven, or the complexity of a computer operating on the digital information with which it is fed, our technologies are not just tools, but rather they have a tendency to become metaphors for how we think about our own human nature.
SPEAKER_00This is a point that I make in my book Religious but not religious. There I write Technology has become the preferred metaphor for human life in this current age. For example, we conceive of the body as a machine and we think of the mind as a kind of computer. In our everyday language we speak of experiences as being hardwired in our neural connections, or we say that we got our wires crossed when there is a communication failure.
SPEAKER_00However, I go on to say, when technology is the central metaphor, and the machine is our guiding image, beings become things. Nature becomes a repository of resources for human consumption, and people are measured primarily in terms of efficiency and productivity, human resources, whose value is essentially an economic one.
SPEAKER_00Of course, there is something in us that rebels at such an idea, whether we do so consciously or not. D. H. Lawrence perfectly articulates this deep human response in his poem Healing, which I will take a moment right now to read. I am not a mechanism, an assembly of various sections.
SPEAKER_00And it is not because the mechanism is working wrongly that I am ill. I am ill because of wounds to the soul, to the deep emotional self, and the wounds to the soul take a long, long time. Only time can help, and patience, and a certain difficult repentance, long, difficult repentance, realization of life's mistake, and the freeing oneself from the endless repetition of the mistake, which mankind at large has chosen to sanctify.
SPEAKER_00In his book, A Dwelling Place for Wisdom, Raymond Panicar discusses how we have become alienated from the life process because we no longer approach it with a holistic attitude, a sense that we participate in reality, touching all of reality, as he puts it, but have turned ourselves into severed subjects that observe a separate and objectified version of reality.
SPEAKER_00We are too occupied, he declares, by the analysis of the various parts into which we have dissected reality. This is the endless repetition of the mistake that mankind at large has chosen to sanctify, that Lawrence names in his poem. The activity of the mind that we call thought has been reduced to analytic thought, the kind of thought that has dissected reality and as a consequence bisected the human being into a mind and a body, each separate from the other.
SPEAKER_00At the beginning of chapter two, Underhill suggests that the first step towards opening to even the possibility of another perception or level of reality is to begin to feel a sense of dissatisfaction with the vision of the world as we conventionally regard it. Feeling our way into the experience of being a bisected human being, a severed subject living in a mechanistic world shaped by analytic thought, divorced from what we might call an embodied knowing, may perhaps inspire such dissatisfaction.
SPEAKER_00That, it seems to me, is the sensibility that resonates throughout D. H. Lawrence's poem. I am not a mechanism, an assembly of various sections, and it is not because the mechanism is working wrongly that I am ill. I am ill because of wounds to the soul, to the deep emotional self.
SPEAKER_00And as uncomfortable as it is to feel that dissatisfaction, a quality of existence that Buddhism calls dukkha, it is important. It's important because it allows us to feel a hunger. For more, to long for that more, and therefore be open to receiving that more. The model for this longing, says Underhill, is the artist.
SPEAKER_00In the second half of the chapter, which we'll look at next time, she elaborates on this, describing the artist as a figure who marks, quote, a point of departure for our exploration of the contemplative life. At this point in the chapter, she turns to the poet Keats as an exemplar of that dissatisfaction with the world as described by analytic thought, quoting him crying out, Oh, for a life of sensations rather than thoughts.
SPEAKER_00And depending on one's temperament, she notes, these are words that will be heard as quote, either an invitation to the higher laziness or one of the most profound aspirations of the soul. Underhill herself is clearly in the second camp of hearers. About this cry of Keats, she writes, he felt, as all the poets have felt with him, that another lovelier world, tinted with unimaginable wonders, alive with ultimate music, awaited those who could free themselves from the fetters of the mind, lay down the shuttle and the weaver's comb, and reach out beyond the conceptual image to the intuitive contact with the thing.
SPEAKER_00For Jung, this ability to reach out beyond the surface of life in order to make contact with a fuller and more real world is the secret of great art, he says. Jung, of course, describes this process in the terms of his psychology, using that idea of the archetypal image that I mentioned earlier in this episode, and which, as I noted, is nothing other than a piece of life.
SPEAKER_00In describing the effect of the artist's recovery of the archetypal image, Jung, using words closely echoing those that we just heard from Underhill, says this. By giving the archetypal image shape, the artist translates it into the language of the present and so makes it possible for us to find our way back to the deepest springs of life.
SPEAKER_00I'll be back in just a moment with this week's parting words. You'll find a list of all the sources used in this week's episode in the show notes. And while you're there, be sure to sign up for my newsletter, in which you'll find updates and extras related to the show.
SPEAKER_00And if you enjoyed this episode, please consider supporting the production of this show. You can do so for as little as the cost of a cup of coffee at Buy Me a Coffee. Just visit buymeacoffee.com slash digital yum. Or simply hit the Support the Show link in the show notes. Thanks for your support. Thanks for listening and take good care.
SPEAKER_00Now here are this week's parting words. Eternity is with us, inviting our contemplation perpetually, writes Evelyn Underhill, as we heard in our opening quote. But we are too frightened, lazy and suspicious to respond, too arrogant to still our thought, and let divine sensation have its way.
SPEAKER_00What then is to be done? What is needed? Well, according to Underhill, what is needed is, in a word, work. It needs industry and good will if we would make that transition, she writes. For the process involves a veritable spring cleaning of the soul, a turning out and rearrangement of our mental furniture, a wide opening of closed windows, that the notes of the wild birds beyond our garden may come to us fully charged with wonder and freshness.
SPEAKER_00However, we should be careful not to interpret what she is saying here in terms of something to add to the endless to-do list of our everyday lives. As will become clear as we move forward with this book, Underhill is not advocating bringing to the life of the soul the restlessness and busyness with which we normally fill our days.
SPEAKER_00We will come closer to the meaning of her words by understanding them through these words from the Tao to Ching. Do you have the patience to wait till your mud settles and the water is clear? Those who can do this, Underhill assures us, will find that life is transformed in such a way that they discover this world to be a world of morning glory, where every tit mouse is a celestial messenger, and every thrusting bud is charged with the full significance of life.
In this episode: We look at the second part of Chapter 1 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'What Is Mysticism?' The discussion this week explores different ways of knowing and what it means to have a direct...
In this episode: We explore the question of how we know things and why it is necessary to direct our attention to what Jung calls the "higher unity" of which our everyday consciousness is just a part. Listen to Chapters...
In this episode: I introduce the fifth season of Digital Jung with its special focus on the book Practical Mysticism by Evelyn Underhill. Listen to the preface of Practical Mysticism Here Sources for quotes and more:...
In this episode: I discuss the figures of Ahab, Starbuck, and Ishmael as representatives of three possible responses to the encounter with the numinous. I look at the contrast between the Iron Way of Ahab and what I...
In this episode: I look at the image of the whale as a symbol of both Jung's notion of the Self, as well as the numinous experience of the divine mystery: the mysterium tremendum et fascinans. Sources for quotes and...