In this episode: I discuss the figures of Ahab, Starbuck, and Ishmael as representatives of three possible responses to the encounter with the numinous. I look at the contrast between the Iron Way of Ahab and what I call Ishmael’s Mystic Way, suggesting that Ishmael's way is a path of self-emptying that makes possible a deeper experience of life. Sources for quotes and more: 'Moby-Dick' by Herman Melville (Chapter 1: Loomings; Chapter 16: The Ship; Chapter 35: The Mast-Head; Chapter 37: Sunset; Chapter 41: Moby Dick; Chapter 49: The Hyena; Chapter, 79: The Prairie; Chapter 82: The Honor and Glory of Whaling; Chapter 104: The Fossil Whale; Chapter 110: Queequeg in His Coffin; Chapter 135: The Chase - Third Day; Epilogue) S4, Ep. 6 - Moby-Dick: An American Myth, pt. 1 S4, Ep. 8: A Collision Course with Life 'Man and His Symbols' by C.G. Jung 'Memories, Dreams, Reflections' by C.G. Jung 'Two Essays on Analytical Psychology' by C.G. Jung in Collected Works vol. 7 S4, Ep. 9: The Gorgon’s Eye 'Aion: Researches into the Phenomenology of the Self' by C.G. Jung in Collected Works vol. 9ii ‘Freud, Goethe, Wagner’ by Thomas Mann 'Mysticism: A Study in the Nature and Development of Man's Spiritual Consciousness' by Evelyn Underhill 'The Soul and Death' by C.G. Jung in Collected Works vol. 8 'A Dwelling Place for Wisdom' by Raimon Panikkar Music: "Dreaming Days," "Slow Vibing," and "The Return" by Ketsa are licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 Like this podcast? Please consider leaving a review: Apple Podcasts Spotify Or, if you are able, support the show with a donation at Buy Me a Coffee: Support the show Connect with me: Instagram (@digital.jung) Facebook (facebook.com/jungiananalyst) Bluesky (@digitaljung.bsky.social) Subscribe to the Digital Jung Newsletter For more on living a symbolic life: Please check out my book, Religious but Not Religious: Living a Symbolic Life.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Digital Yome. A podcast about living a symbolic life in a technological age.
SPEAKER_01Man cannot stand a meaningless life.
SPEAKER_00I'm Jason Smith, Jungian analyst and the host of this show. A show about exploring what it means to live a life of meaning.
SPEAKER_02That's the very treasure.
SPEAKER_00I'm glad you're here. Let's begin the buttons. What I've dared, I've willed. And what I've willed, I'll do. They think me mad, Starbuck does. But I'm demoniac.
SPEAKER_00I am madness maddened. That wild madness that's only calm to comprehend itself. The prophecy was that I should be dismembered, and I lost this leg. I now prophesy that I will dismember my dismemberer. Now then be the prophet and the fulfiller one. That's more than ye, ye great gods ever were.
SPEAKER_00I laugh and hoot at ye, ye cricket players, ye pugilists, ye deaf burks and blinded bendigos. I will not say as schoolboys do to bullies, take someone of your own size, don't pommel me. No, you've knocked me down, and I am up again. But ye have run and hidden. Come forth from behind your cotton bags.
SPEAKER_00I have no long gun to reach ye. Come, Ahab's compliments to ye. Come and see if ye can swerve me. Swerve me. Ye cannot swerve me else ye swerve yourselves. Man has ye there. Swerve me. The path to my fixed purpose is laid with iron rails, whereon my soul is grooved to run.
SPEAKER_00Over unsounded gorges, through the rifled hearts of mountains, under torrents beds unerringly I rush. Knots an obstacle, knots an angle to the Ironway. Earlier this season, I described the figure of Captain Ahab as a symbol of what I called the metastasized will.
SPEAKER_00That was back in episode six, Moby Dick and American Myth Part one. And shortly after that, in episode eight, a collision course with life, I went a little further and stated that this will is not only Ahab's fatal flaw, it is the fatal flaw of modern life as well, and therefore of all of us.
SPEAKER_00We are creatures of the modern world, I said, and we are imbued with the modern spirit. We believe in the power of the will, and we resist any suggestion that we should be beholden to something like fate. Now, this problem of the modern Ahabian will belongs to both our inner individual lives and our collective outer life together.
SPEAKER_00We are confronted with it at every level of our experience, from the loss of personal spiritual meaning to the impending climate catastrophe to the rise of authoritarian political movements and on and on. Anywhere we find the spirit of domination smothering the spirit of love, there dwells the destructive archetype of Ahab and his iron will, calling out in defiance of the gods, swerve me, ye cannot swerve me.
SPEAKER_00The path to my fixed purpose is laid with iron rails whereon my soul is grooved to run, not an obstacle, not an angle to the iron way. Nothing is an obstacle to the iron way. This is really just an amplified form of a saying that we all know very well, right?
SPEAKER_00Where there's a will, there's a way. A saying, by the way, that Carl Jung once called the superstition of modern man. And the cost of such a superstition, he said, is quote a remarkable lack of introspection. Efficiency and rationality, those foot soldiers of the often obstinate will can often be the means by which we deny that there are powers that lie beyond our control.
SPEAKER_00The gods and demons, Jung wrote, have not disappeared at all. They have merely got new names. They keep us on the run with restlessness, vague apprehensions, psychological complications, an insatiable need for pills, alcohol, tobacco, food, and above all, a large array of neuroses.
SPEAKER_00Ahab himself seems to recognize the psychological dangers of his self-proclaimed iron way, right? The very moment that he asserts the dominance of his will, what I've dared I've willed, and what I've willed, I'll do. He acknowledges and even embraces that he is a man possessed by a kind of demonic spirit.
SPEAKER_00They think me mad, Starbuck does, but I'm demoniac. I am madness maddened. Ahab's affliction, it turns out, has gone way beyond the restlessness and vague apprehensions, the psychological complications and neuroses that we just heard described by Jung as the form in which the gods appear today.
SPEAKER_00It's more akin to what Jung elsewhere calls the daimonization or demonization of man and his will, by which he means a state in which all the powers once understood to be transcendent or experienced as spiritual or divine energies operating outside of human control, have been usurped by human beings, so that they are now assumed to be under the command of the ego and its will.
SPEAKER_00This is a dangerous state of hubris in which we, like Ahab, have become our own gods. In the previous episode I suggested that Moby Dick, the great white whale, was a symbol of the divine mystery, an expression of the numinous power of the mysterium tremendum at Fasinans.
SPEAKER_00Viewed through this lens, we can then recognize that Ahab's hatred of Moby Dick is at its heart a hatred of that divine mystery. And so it is that he rails against the gods and mocks them, as we heard in our opening quote. The great offense of the divine mystery, of course, is that it relativizes the power of the individual will, demanding both surrender and an acceptance of the powers of what has been variously called fate, destiny, karma, or providence.
SPEAKER_00Translated into psychological language, we would attribute these powers to the unconscious psyche, or more specifically to Jung's notion of the self. Regardless of the name we give to this power with which we are confronted, regardless of the framework we use to reflect on it, the demands of surrender and acceptance remain the same.
SPEAKER_00Coming to terms with these demands is of central concern to the work of the symbolic life. But this aspect of the work requires us to navigate between two potential dangers despondency on the one hand, and megalomania on the other. Faced with this numinous and relativizing power, we are vulnerable to being overcome by a sense of utter powerlessness, or overtaken by, to use Jung's phrase, a defiant will to power.
SPEAKER_00And to my mind, the first of these dangers, despondency and a sense of powerlessness, is embodied in Starbuck. We saw back in episode nine, The Gorgon's Eye, that even though Starbuck is described as courageous, it is a courage marked by certain limitations, one that ultimately fails in the face of Ahab's uncanny power.
SPEAKER_00Starbuck exhibits, the story tells us, the incompetence of mere unaided virtue. In other words, he may be a good man, but his goodness has no heft to it. It becomes ineffectual when confronted with the vigor and the capriciousness of Ahab's monomania.
SPEAKER_00There are repeated scenes throughout the novel in which Starbucks seems to have an opportunity to stand up to Ahab, to take charge and thereby to change the fate of the Pequod and its crew. Yet every time his resolve buckles, he has no real source of power of his own, on which he might draw to counteract that of Ahab's.
SPEAKER_00Starbucks God, we might imagine, is just an idea of God, and not a real and living force, and confronted with a demoniacal power such as that radiating from Ahab, a mere idea has all the force of a withered leaf in a hurricane. And this mismatch is reflected in one of the last things that we hear Starbuck say in the novel.
SPEAKER_00I misdoubt me, that I disobey my God in obeying him the hymn at the end, of course, referring to Ahab. The other danger, that of megalomania and the defiant will to power, we've already begun to discuss, right? It is, of course, Ahab's ironway.
SPEAKER_00I've already mentioned his state of possession and his exaggerated will, and I could go on piling up example after example. Everything Ahab does, really, is expressed through an inflated grandiosity. He is, as the novel suggests, a mighty pageant creature formed for noble tragedies. One of the words most frequently used to describe Ahab eleven times, by my count, is monomaniac.
SPEAKER_00He has become possessed by his quest for vengeance. It is all he imagines, all he desires, all he strives for. The path to my fixed purpose is laid with iron rails whereon my soul is grooved to run. This is what we call inflation, which is a psyche out of balance.
SPEAKER_00And what such an inflation requires in order to return to a healthy balance, says Jung, is to allow the ego to experience defeat. In fact, not only must one learn to allow it, one must go even further and participate in that defeat. The world of consciousness must now be leveled down in favor of the reality of the unconscious.
SPEAKER_00Jung writes. The ego must be ready to be changed by those powers that dwell beyond the province of the ego. And if we are attentive and sensitive to these powers, we discover something paradoxical. At the same time that we feel the limitation of the ego, which can be and often is a painful experience, to be sure, we also experience an enlargement of the scope of our whole personality.
SPEAKER_00I remember when I was younger, and I would be doing something simple like going to the grocery store on the corner. I would keep my eyes looking directly in front of me and mostly turned down toward the sidewalk. I didn't want to let my eyes wander too much to the right or left or drift upward where I might meet the eyes of another person. I didn't think too hard about this, but even then, I had a vague awareness that I was trying to avoid running into someone, maybe a friend or someone else in the neighborhood that I knew.
SPEAKER_00I had an agenda, which was to get to the store, and I didn't want my fixed purpose derailed by something unexpected, even something as pleasant and welcome as seeing a friend. And I share this as a kind of simple illustration of just what it means to talk about the ego being ready to be changed by powers that dwell beyond the ego.
SPEAKER_00The guy walking with his eyes fixed on the sidewalk is an image of that ego, right? It has its focus and its goal and wants to avoid anything that will get in the way of that goal. And the friend is like something from the unconscious that might suddenly appear and suggest something quite different from the planned goal. In this case, maybe going to a cafe and catching up over a cup of coffee.
SPEAKER_00To follow the new possibility, to participate in the defeat of the ego's agenda may frustrate the goal-oriented mind, but it brings with it the potential for a connection, a connection with a new energy and a new vitality. Ahab, of course, could never allow the defeat of his fixed purpose.
SPEAKER_00But Ishmael can, and it is Ishmael who offers us a third option between the powerlessness of Starbuck and the will to power of Ahab. If Ahab's mode of being is the iron way, Ishmael's is one that we might call the mystic way. Where the iron way leads to a hardening of the psyche and an exaggerated, inflated experience of oneself, the mystic way, goes by the path of self-emptying.
SPEAKER_00And this leads in a very different direction. And right before we start to look at this third way of Ishmael's, I want to look at what I think is a particularly emblematic scene of his mystic sensibility. In this scene, Ishmael is up atop the masthead. His job is to keep a lookout from those heights for any visible signs of a sperm whale in the vicinity, and to call out to the rest of the ship when one appears.
SPEAKER_00It is an important job, right? But as Ishmael notes, in the serene weather of the tropics it is exceedingly pleasant, the masthead. Nay, to a dreamy meditative man. It is delightful. And then a few moments later he makes this confession.
SPEAKER_00Let me make a clean breast of it here, and frankly admit that I kept but sorry guard. With the problem of Of the universe revolving in me? How could I? Being left completely to myself at such a thought engendering altitude, how could I but lightly hold my obligations to observe all whale ships standing orders?
SPEAKER_00Keep your weather eye open and sing out every time. And let me in this place movingly admonish you, ye ship owners of Nantucket. Beware of enlisting in your vigilant fisheries any lad with lean brow and hollow eye given to unseasonable meditativeness, and who offers to ship with the fedun instead of Bowditch in his head.
SPEAKER_00Beware of such an one, I say, your whales must be seen before they can be killed. And this sunken eyed young platonist will tow you ten wakes round the world and never make you one pint of sperm, the richer. When Ahab first appears in the novel, we hear that he stands with his whalebone leg fixed in an auger hole that has been bored into the planks of the ship.
SPEAKER_00And here he stands looking out over the prow. And though Melville doesn't describe this, it doesn't take too much imagination to see that if Ahab were to try to move with his legs set in that hole, it would become a pivot point. And he would turn around and around in place, a perfect image of his monomaniac spirit circling around one thought, one desire, circling in the end around himself.
SPEAKER_00Ishmael, by contrast, is not circling around himself, but rather as he tells us, he has the problem of the universe revolving in him. Ahab has become his own universe, the killing of Moby Dick, his one thought. Ishmael's imagination, on the other hand, soars beyond himself as he ponders the mysteries of the universe and the immortality of the soul, as the reference in the passage we just heard to Plato's Fido suggests.
SPEAKER_00What separates Ishmael's mystic way then, from the iron way of Ahab is the nature of the relationship of each to the divine mystery, symbolized, as I said earlier, by the great white whale. Ishmael and Ahab are both in pursuit of the whale, of that living spirit of the deep.
SPEAKER_00We know the nature of Ahab's pursuit, one of vengeance and domination, but Ishmael's is of a different order. Though he admits that his goal is, as he says, to manhandle this Leviathan, his is a quest of curiosity and wonder and appreciation.
SPEAKER_00What Ishmael is trying to capture is the image of the whale, its meaning and essence, and so he approaches his task from many different angles. At times he acts like a scientist, at other times as a historian, and at others an etymologist, a philosopher, a physiognomist, and a phrenologist. Above all, though, Ishmael is a mythologist, experiencing the whale as a true living symbol that gives to life, in the words of Thomas Mann, self awareness, sanction, consecration.
SPEAKER_00It is through this role of mythologist that Ishmael knows the nobility and dignity of his chosen pursuit. At one point, examining the myths and legends associated with wailing, Ishmael declares When I find so many great demigods and heroes, prophets of all sorts who one way or other have shed distinction upon it, I am transported with the reflection that I myself belong, though but subordinately, to so emblazoned a fraternity.
SPEAKER_00Ishmael's is a symbolic life. He does not pursue the whale to kill it, but that it might bring him alive. For him the whale is a way, a path leading him to a horizon of mystery and meaning. Ishmael's pursuit allows him to participate in what he refers to as the mystic modes of the whale, those secret passages by which the whale travels, but that are only found after sounding to a great depth.
SPEAKER_00This is a mode of pursuit requiring humility, simplicity, and a kind of detachment from preordained goals and ideas. Ishmael, as I read him, is the personification of that participation in the defeat of the ego that I described earlier.
SPEAKER_00His is a path, as I said, of self-empting. This is a motif that runs throughout the novel. We see it, in fact, in Ishmael's very first utterance as the narrator of the story, call me Ishmael. As I noted back at the start of this season in discussing this opening line, it tells us that our narrator is essentially anonymous.
SPEAKER_00His personal identity, that is to say, his ego, his eye, is submerged, and he takes on the character of the outcast, the unknown, the nameless. And in this he embodies a quality common among the mystics, as described by Evelyn Underhill in her masterful study on mysticism, one who regards himself not as an isolated and interesting individual possessing desires and rights, but as a scrap of the cosmos, an ordinary bit of the universal life up on the masthead.
SPEAKER_00With the problem of the universe revolving in him, Ishmael indeed dissolves into a scrap of the cosmos and an ordinary bit of the universal life. In this enchanted mood, he says, thy spirit ebbs away to whence it came, becomes diffused through time and space. There is no life in thee now, he continues, except that rocking life imparted by a gently rolling ship, by her borrowed from the sea, by the sea from the inscrutable tides of God.
SPEAKER_00Ishmael's whole journey is a dying to self. He tells us at the outset that going to sea, quote, is my substitute for pistol and ball. With a philosophical flourish, Cato throws himself upon his sword, I quietly take to the ship. He goes, in his words, as a simple sailor, eschewing all honor and status.
SPEAKER_00And later, this dying to self will become formalized, so to speak, when he realizes that his duty as a simple sailor requires him, when the whale boats are lowered in pursuit of whales that have been sighted nearby, to man one of the oars of one of those boats and, as he says, break his own back, pulling himself back foremost into death's jaws, and recognizing that this is an unalterable law of wailing, he sets about writing his will, with Quiqueg as both his witness and beneficiary.
SPEAKER_00After the ceremony was concluded upon the present occasion, Ishmael says, I felt all the easier. A stone was rolled away from my heart. Giving himself over to death has a liberating effect for Ishmael. Like the mystics, he has achieved, as Evelyn Underhill writes, a complete self-abandonment, a holy indifference to the accidents of life.
SPEAKER_00And with the acceptance of death, he can more freely and fully give himself to life. And this, finally, is the takeaway. The dying to self of the mystics is simply a fundamental imperative of life raised to its highest degree.
SPEAKER_00For life at whatever level it is lived necessarily involves the reality of death. It is a psychological necessity, Jung tells us, to recognize death not just as an undesirable cessation of life, but as a fulfillment of life. To pull back from death is to pull back from life, to refuse to live, to stagnate and cling to what is already past.
SPEAKER_00From the middle of life onward, only that person remains vitally alive who is ready to die with life, Jung declares. If we are to live forward into our lives, to continue the work of becoming and growing, we must be willing to acknowledge where this path we are on is ultimately leading.
SPEAKER_00But more than just that, we must embrace the fact that to grow is to die each day. Each moment of growth is a dying to self, the death of who we were just the moment before. And it is just a step from here to what Underhill calls, quote, the essential mystic act of utter self-surrender.
SPEAKER_00An act that, as she notes, marks the death of selfhood in the interests of a new and deeper life. True life begins. Where clinging to life ends. As the religious philosopher Raymond Panicar teaches, we only live when risking this life over and over.
SPEAKER_00When allowing life to live. You'll find a list of all the sources used in this week's episode in the show notes. And while you're there, be sure to sign up for my newsletter, in which you'll find updates and extras related to the show.
SPEAKER_00And if you enjoyed this episode, please consider supporting the production of this show. You can do so for as little as the cost of a cup of coffee at Buy MeACoffee. Just visit buymeacoffee.com slash digital yum. Or simply hit the support the show link in the show notes. Thanks for your support. Thanks for listening.
SPEAKER_00And take good care. Now here are this week's parting words. There is so much more that could be said about this miracle of a novel. There are so many themes, so many passages, so many symbols and images that I would have loved to have included in this season of the podcast.
SPEAKER_00The depths of Moby Dick seem to me at times as unfathomable as the waters that carry the Pequad on its doomed voyage. Trying to include everything, however, would have been an Ahabian quest, right? An expression of that idea that we heard him speak in today's opening quote What I've dared, I've willed, and what I've willed I'll do.
SPEAKER_00My quest, if you will, was more Ishmaelian, more along the lines of these words that Ishmael speaks. I try all things. I achieve what I can. Dying to self is an essential quality of the creative life.
SPEAKER_00To try to say everything can be so overwhelming that one simply gives up and says nothing at all. In the end, the potential of our grandest visions must be sacrificed for the sake of realizing a few good and hopefully nourishing words. If I could, I would have spent more time on the relationship between Quiqueg and Ishmael.
SPEAKER_00I would have included a look at the chapter titled Quiqueg in His Coffin, in which Quiqueg, convinced he is dying, makes for himself a coffin carved all over with the same images that adorn his tattooed body. And once it is complete, he gets into the coffin prepared to die, and then all of a sudden he rallies, climbing back out of the coffin and returning to life.
SPEAKER_00It's a scene that, of course, hints at Kuiqueg as a kind of Christ figure, right? One who has died and lives again. And that coffin is later put to use as a lifeboy for the Pequad, a perfect symbol for this episode's theme, right? Only through an acceptance of death and dying can life be preserved.
SPEAKER_00And in the end, Quiqueg's coffin is what saves Ishmael's life, as he clings to it, that remnant, so to speak, of Quiqueg himself, while the Pequod and all its crew are carried down into the depths of the sea. And so it is that the novel comes to an end with these words.
SPEAKER_00Boyed up by that coffin, for almost one whole day and night I floated on a soft and dirge like mane. The unharming sharks they glided by as if with padlocks on their mouths, the savage sea hawks sailed with sheathed beaks. On the second day a sail drew near, nearer, and picked me up at last.
SPEAKER_00It was the devious cruising Rachel that in her retracing search after her missing children only found another orphan. Until next time.
In this episode: We look at the first part of Chapter 2 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'The World of Reality.' We discuss how the imagination that we bring to our perception of life can have either a...
In this episode: We look at the second part of Chapter 1 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'What Is Mysticism?' The discussion this week explores different ways of knowing and what it means to have a direct...
In this episode: We explore the question of how we know things and why it is necessary to direct our attention to what Jung calls the "higher unity" of which our everyday consciousness is just a part. Listen to Chapters...
In this episode: I introduce the fifth season of Digital Jung with its special focus on the book Practical Mysticism by Evelyn Underhill. Listen to the preface of Practical Mysticism Here Sources for quotes and more:...
In this episode: I look at the image of the whale as a symbol of both Jung's notion of the Self, as well as the numinous experience of the divine mystery: the mysterium tremendum et fascinans. Sources for quotes and...