Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Digital Jung

Digital Jung artwork

Symbols of the Mystery

Sep 17, 202638 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode: I look at the image of the whale as a symbol of both Jung's notion of the Self, as well as the numinous experience of the divine mystery: the mysterium tremendum et fascinans. Sources for quotes and more: 'Moby-Dick' by Herman Melville (Etymology; Extracts; Chapter 32: Cetology; Chapter 36: The Quarter-Deck; Chapter 41: Moby Dick; Chapter 42: The Whiteness of the Whale; Chapter 55: Monstrous Pictures of Whales; Chapter 85: The Fountain; Chapter 86: The Tail; Chapter 104: The Fossil Whale; Chapter 105: Does the Whale’s Magnitude Diminish? - Will He Perish?) 'Melville’s Moby-Dick: A Jungian Commentary' by Edward Edinger S4, Ep. 2: Outcasts of the Spirit 'Psychology and Alchemy' by C.G. Jung in Collected Works, vol. 12 'Two Essays on Analytical Psychology' by C.G. Jung, in Collected Works, vol. 7 'Religious but Not Religious' by Jason Smith 'Aion: Researches into the Phenomenology of the Self' by C.G. Jung in Collected Works, vol. 9ii Psalm 139: 6-9, Book of Common Prayer, 1979 Exodus 33:18-23, NRSV Hebrews 10:31, NRSV Isaiah 55:8, NRSV 'The Idea of the Holy' by Rudolf Otto S1, Ep. 22: The Idea of the Holy S1, Ep. 23: Approaching the Numinous 'Anatomy of the Psyche' by Edward Edinger 'Psychology and Religion' by C.G. Jung in Collected Works, vol. 11 Symbols in an Individual Analysis from 'Man and His Symbols' by Jolande Jacobi The Holy Longing, poem by Johann Wolfgang von Goethe 'Psychology and Literature' by C.G. Jung in Collected Works, vol. 15 Music: "Dreaming Days," "Slow Vibing," and "The Return" by Ketsa are licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 Like this podcast? Please consider leaving a review: Apple Podcasts Spotify Or, if you are able, support the show with a donation at Buy Me a Coffee: Support the show Connect with me: Instagram (@digital.jung) Facebook (facebook.com/jungiananalyst) Bluesky (@digitaljung.bsky.social) Subscribe to the Digital Jung Newsletter For more on living a symbolic life: Please check out my book, Religious but Not Religious: Living a Symbolic Life.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Digital Yome, a podcast about living a symbolic life in a technological age.

SPEAKER_01Man cannot stand a meaningless life.

SPEAKER_00I'm Jason Smith, Jungian analyst and the host of this show. A show about exploring what it means to live a life of meaning.

SPEAKER_02It's the human soul. That's the buried treasure.

SPEAKER_00I'm glad you're here. Let's begin with the buttons. O the rare old whale, mid storm and gale, in his ocean home will be A giant in might, where might is right, and king of the boundless sea.

SPEAKER_00As we approach the end of this fourth season of Digital Jung, with its special focus on the novel Moby Dick, there is one important symbol that we have yet to explore with the depth that it deserves. And that is the symbol of the whale. One of the striking things that one finds when reading Moby Dick is that the action of the plot itself, the story of Ishmael aboard the Pequod and of Captain Ahab's quest to kill the white whale, forms a relatively small percentage of the whole novel.

SPEAKER_00So much of the book is an examination from every conceivable perspective and regarding every conceivable aspect of the whale. In fact, the original title of the novel, when it was first published in London in 1851, was simply the whale. And that phrase is retained in the official title of the novel as it comes down to us today. The full title of the book is Moby Dick or The Whale.

SPEAKER_00In thinking about how to approach this central symbol of the novel, however, we are immediately confronted with a problem. Edward Edinger, in his book Melville's Moby Dick, a Jungian Commentary, lays out the challenge of this task that we've set for ourselves here. He writes The problem is that the whale has too many meanings.

SPEAKER_00Melville has gone to great trouble to provide an almost boundless network of associations to amplify the image of the whale. The whale and its multitude of meanings becomes a Cretan labyrinth wherein one is almost sure to lose oneself. Or as Melville puts it in the chapter titled The Fossil Whale, from his mighty bulk the whale affords a most congenial theme whereon to enlarge, amplify, and generally expatiate, would you?

SPEAKER_00You could not compress him. And rather than risk getting lost in the labyrinth of the endless amplifications and associations that fill virtually every page of this novel, I'm going to pick up on a couple of hints that are scattered here and there that suggest one understanding and experience of the whale symbol that, to my mind, at least, holds particular relevance for the symbolic life.

SPEAKER_00And the first of these hints comes at the very beginning of the novel. Now back in episode two of this season, Outcasts of the Spirit, I referred to the first sentence of the novel, Call Me Ishmael as one of the most familiar openings in all of literature. And of course that's true, but if we want to be technically correct, that is not the actual opening of the novel.

SPEAKER_00Right before the first chapter and its famous opening line, there is a section titled Extracts, and this section is full of quotes taken from a wide variety of sources that in one way or another make reference to whales or whaling. In fact, the little verse that I used for the opening quote of this episode, which comes from a poem called Whale Song, or The King of the Southern Sea, is the very last entry of this section of the novel.

SPEAKER_00But the real start of the book is earlier even than that. Melville leads off his novel with a section he calls etymology. In this section, he gives us what appear to be a couple of derivations of the word whale that presumably were current at the time he was writing. And the first of these reads in part, This animal is named from roundness or rolling.

SPEAKER_00The suggestion of roundness here is very appealing from a Jungian perspective, because it brings to mind the circle, which is a shape that is generally understood from the Jungian point of view as an image of wholeness, and therefore is a kind of hieroglyphic, so to speak, of the archetype of the self, which is the name we give to the wholeness of the personality.

SPEAKER_00And Jung, in fact, often uses the image of the circle to describe this archetype as when he says, quote, the self is not only the center, but also the whole circumference, which embraces both conscious and unconscious. It is the center of this totality just as the ego is the center of consciousness. And if we take a moment and think about what it means that the self is the center of the totality of conscious and unconscious, we can see that it is describing an experience that is ultimately unknowable.

SPEAKER_00Though we can have some relationship to it through our conscious mind, much and how much, frankly, we just don't know, much transcends our consciousness. The self is and always will be in some measure unconscious. And so what we're dealing with here is something that we could say is both imminent and transcendent, in the sense that it is both present to our everyday conscious experience, while at the same time exceeding and eluding our conscious awareness.

SPEAKER_00And my allusion to religious terminology here, immanence and transcendence, well, it's deliberate. About the archetype of the self, Jung once wrote, It might equally well be called the God within us. He speaks often of the self as a god image in the psyche, which, as I point out in my book Religious but not religious, might be better understood as a god experience, for an image is not just a picture, but an experience that touches the whole person, one's thoughts, feelings, sensations, and intuitions.

SPEAKER_00Symbols of the self, Jung asserts, frequently appear as religious mythologiums, though, its symbols range from the highest to the lowest. And so just to boil down what I'm saying here and make it clear, I am suggesting that the image of the whale in this book is just such a symbol of the self.

SPEAKER_00There are many, many passages in the novel, more of those hints I mentioned earlier, in which we can sense this quality of the God image or God experience in Melville's descriptions of Moby Dick and of the whale in general. For instance, we read that one of the stories that passed among the sailors of the Pequad was the unearthly conceit that Moby Dick was ubiquitous, that he had actually been encountered in opposite latitudes at one and the same instant of time.

SPEAKER_00And this belief leads on to another, as Ishmael in his role as narrator reports, it cannot be much matter of surprise that some whalemen should go still further in their superstitions, declaring Mobyd not only ubiquitous, but immortal. Immortality and ubiquity, of course, are divine attributes.

SPEAKER_00Where can I go then from your spirit? asks the Psalmist. Where can I flee from your presence? If I climb up to heaven you are there, if I make the grave my bed, you are there also. If I take the wings of the morning and dwell in the uttermost parts of the sea, even there your hand will lead me and your right hand hold me fast. It is with a feeling of dread that the sailors of the Pequad essentially ask these same questions of Moby Dick.

SPEAKER_00For Ishmael, however, it's not just Moby Dick that is worthy of divine attribution, but the whale itself in all its various incarnations. I account him no common shallow being, he states, in describing what he calls, the great inherent dignity and sublimity of the sperm whale. He is both ponderous and profound, says Ishmael.

SPEAKER_00He is, we might say, a kind of cosmic mystery, right? The great Leviathan is the one creature in the world which must remain unpainted to the last, we are told. His is an unwritten life, Ishmael declares. The living whale in his full majesty and significance is only to be seen at sea in unfathomable waters.

SPEAKER_00So the whale evokes the experience of the unknowable, the ineffable, the transcendent, and this is finally and fully brought home in chapter eighty six, the tale. After several chapters in which the anatomy of the whale has been looked at from every angle, Ishmael in the end declares that he is at a loss to express what he has seen and experienced.

SPEAKER_00The more do I deplore my inability to express it, he says. And then he makes this conclusion. Dissect him how I may, then I but go skin deep. I know him not and never will. But if I know not even the tail of this whale, how understand his head?

SPEAKER_00Much more how comprehend his face when face he has none. Thou shalt see my back parts, my tail, he seems to say, but my face shall not be seen. And there can be no more explicit indication that the whale is a symbol of the great divine mystery than that last sentence.

SPEAKER_00Thou shalt see my backparts, but my face shall not be seen. These are the very words that God speaks to Moses in the book of Exodus. And so here I want to read the full passage from Exodus so we can really hear the resonance in those sentences I just read from the novel. And so here then is the dialogue that passes between Moses and God.

SPEAKER_00Moses said to the Lord, please show me your glory. And he said, I will make all my goodness pass before you, and will proclaim before you the name the Lord, and I will be gracious to whom I will be gracious, and will show mercy on whom I will show mercy. But he said, You cannot see my face, for no one shall see me and live.

SPEAKER_00And the Lord continued, See, there is a place by me where you shall stand on the rock, and while my glory passes by, I will put you in a cleft of the rock, and I will cover you with my hand until I have passed by. Then I will take away my hand, and you shall see my back, but my face shall not be seen.

SPEAKER_00It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God, we read elsewhere in the Bible. Moses asks to see God's glory, but he is told that it cannot be shown to him directly, it must remain veiled, at least in part, because no one shall see me and live. And you see, this is one of the reasons why the whale is such an apt symbol of the divine, because like the experience of God, it is something that provokes both awe and fear.

SPEAKER_00In the novel, the fearful aspect of the whale is described mainly as it shows forth in the specific instance of Moby Dick himself. He invokes a natural terror, says Ishmael, not because of his enormous size, nor even because of his quote remarkable hue, of which Ishmael actually has quite a bit to say, but because he possesses an unexampled intelligent malignity.

SPEAKER_00He is not merely a dumb beast, a mass of unconscious instinct just doing what instinct does. No. Moby Dick is an intelligence whose ends seem deliberately set against human ends and desires. For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, says the Lord, as we read in the book of Isaiah.

SPEAKER_00Moby Dick's actions, of course, could simply be ascribed to the instinct of self preservation, but that is not at all how the characters in the novel experience him. For the crew, the lore that grew up around the many reports of encounters with the white whale, quote, invested Moby Dick with new terrors unborrowed from anything that visibly appears.

SPEAKER_00There is something unspeakable and otherworldly about him. And for Ishmael, this quality is reflected above all in that remarkable hue that I mentioned a moment ago, the unsettling whiteness of Mobi Dick. Aside from those more obvious considerations touching Moby Dick, says Ishmael, which could not but occasionally awaken in any man's soul some alarm, there was another thought, or rather vague, nameless horror concerning him, which at times by its intensity completely overpowered all the rest.

SPEAKER_00And yet so mystical and well nigh ineffable was it that I almost despair of putting it in a comprehensible form. It was the whiteness of the whale that above all things appalled me. Ishmael goes on to describe that whiteness as the intensifying agent in things the most appalling to mankind, and he speculates as to why this should be so.

SPEAKER_00Is it that by its indefiniteness, he asks, it shadows forth the heartless voids and immensities of the universe, and thus stabs us from behind with the thought of annihilation when beholding the white depths of the Milky Way. The heartless voids and immensities of the universe. Ishmael's question.

SPEAKER_00Here reverberates with the power of what the theologian Rudolf Otto termed the mysterium tremendum et fascinans, the fearful and fascinating mystery of the cosmos. In the face of this mystery, says Otto, the individual feels submerged and overwhelmed by their own nothingness, in contrast to that which is supreme above all creatures.

SPEAKER_00And compare that to the statement we just heard from Ishmael. It shadows forth the heartless voids and immensities of the universe and thus stabs us from behind with the thought of annihilation. The individual feels submerged and overwhelmed by their own nothingness in contrast to that which is supreme and above all creatures. The mysterium tremendum, then, is the overpowering experience of God.

SPEAKER_00It is an experience of the sublime, of a scope of existence that so outstrips the merely human scale by which we judge our lives that it can feel annihilating. This is the experience that lies behind the feeling of the numinous, a word that was also coined by Otto, and which became such an important idea for Jung.

SPEAKER_00And I've spoken about Otto and the idea of the numinous on this podcast before, and if you want to go into it in more depth, you can check out episodes twenty-two and twenty-three from season one, the idea of the holy and approaching the numinous. But what I want to emphasize here is that overpowering and annihilating quality of the numinous, of the mysterium tremendum.

SPEAKER_00Understood psychologically, it reflects the radical decentering of the ego that accompanies the experience of the self. As Edward Edinger puts it in his book Anatomy of the Psyche, encounter with the unconscious is almost by definition a wounding and defeat. Encounter with the unconscious is almost by definition a wounding and defeat.

SPEAKER_00Right? But why? Why? Why should this be so? As I have said repeatedly on this podcast, we really don't understand the experience of the unconscious. We don't understand that it is, as Edinger plainly states, an encounter. It is an encounter with an agency operating within our experience, but outside of our conscious control.

SPEAKER_00It is something that happens to us, and it is something that happens through us, resulting in real-world repercussions for our immediate environment and for our relationships. The archetypal energies of the psyche possess an autonomy that is unsettling to our fantasies of mastery and self-control.

SPEAKER_00And it is these energies that express themselves in symbolic form. And these symbols, Jung asserts, are quote, not the product of conscious cogitation and speculation, but are motivated from sources outside consciousness and possibly even outside man. The living symbol reminds us that our lives are embedded in a cosmic mystery and are somehow intimately involved with that mystery.

SPEAKER_00And this ultimately is the takeaway here. Symbols are not just fanciful pictures. They are not simply products of human creativity. They are living realities that act upon us. They are expressions of energies and dynamics that move below the surface of consciousness outside of our willing and wanting ego, beyond the reach of our controlling and calculating mind, sometimes peaceful, sometimes powerful, always hidden in the depths, until they suddenly breach the surface of our awareness like the great whale, the king of the boundless sea.

SPEAKER_00And how we respond to this life of the depths will have reverberations that echo through all areas of our lives. It is a profoundly humbling experience that asks us to surrender any image of ourselves as self-made or self-reliant centers of action. But as Jung writes, nowadays most people are afraid of surrendering to such experiences, and their fear proves the existence of a holy dread of the numinous.

SPEAKER_00This is an idea that there is a living agency outside consciousness and possibly even outside man. This is an idea that generally we don't like. We don't like the idea that we are not the captain, so to speak, of our own ship. We don't like the idea that there may be forces in the depths that are more powerful than our conscious will. Many of you listening to this may feel a lot of resistance to this idea.

SPEAKER_00You may be inclined to reject it outright, to fight against it, to say with Ahab, that inscrutable thing is chiefly what I hate. For my money, Ahab is the supreme image of the spirit of this age in which we find ourselves. Ahab's way is the iron way. He will not be swerved from his purposes, he will not be subject to anything but the dictates of his own will.

SPEAKER_00And in the next episode, which will be the last one of this series and of this season, we will be looking at the contrast between Ahab's iron way and what I call the mystic way of Ishmael. Ishmael, though not unaffected by the terrors inspired by the life of the depths, does not, like Ahab, seek to master it or even to destroy it, but rather to know it, to come into a vital and vitalizing relationship with it.

SPEAKER_00But this, as I said, means surrender. It means a willingness to turn and face the experience of the mysterium tremendum et fascinans. It means meeting life with all its beauties and all its terrors, not as a nemesis, but as a crucible for transformation.

SPEAKER_00Choosing to take up this path, as we'll talk about in the next episode, involves a kind of dying process, a dying to self. And we should be careful of holding any romantic notions about what transformation means. There is a reason we feel resistance toward it. As Yolanda Yacobi in her contribution to the book Man and His Symbols writes, every transformation demands as its precondition the ending of a world, the collapse of an old philosophy of life.

SPEAKER_00The collapse of the old life is necessary in order to make room for the new life to come. This, of course, is not without its fearful aspect. But as the great German writer Goethe reminds us, there really is no escape from this troubling experience. Everything depends on whether we enter into it consciously or not, willingly or not he writes.

SPEAKER_00And so long as you haven't experienced this to die and so to grow, you are only a troubled guest on a dark earth. I'll be back in just a moment with this week's parting words.

SPEAKER_00You'll find a list of all the sources used in this week's episode in the show notes. And while you're there, be sure to sign up for my newsletter, in which you'll find updates and extras related to the show. And if you enjoyed this episode, please consider supporting the production of this show. You can do so for as little as the cost of a cup of coffee at Buy Me a Coffee.

SPEAKER_00Just visit buymeacoffee.com slash digital yum. Or simply hit the support the show link in the show notes. Thanks for your support. Thanks for listening. And take good care. Now here are this week's parting words. Symbols point us to the numinous, to the ineffable, to the hidden life that moves below the surface of life.

SPEAKER_00Symbols point us to a reality that transcends the merely personal. They point to that which, like the great whale as described by Melville, comes floundering down upon us from the headwaters of the eternities. They are, as we heard earlier from Jung, motivated from sources outside consciousness, and possibly even outside man.

SPEAKER_00And I'll close here with another quote from Jung that addresses this same idea, though here he raises it as a question about the nature of the human psyche. What if there were a living agency? He writes, beyond our everyday human world, something even more purposeful than electrons.

SPEAKER_00Do we delude ourselves in thinking that we possess and control our own psyches? And is what science calls the psyche not just a question mark, arbitrarily confined within the skull, but rather a door that opens upon the human world, from a world beyond, allowing unknown and mysterious powers to act upon man and carry him on the wings of the night to a more than personal destiny.

SPEAKER_00Until next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Metaphor of the Machine

    Nov 19, 202631 minAudio

    In this episode: We look at the first part of Chapter 2 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'The World of Reality.' We discuss how the imagination that we bring to our perception of life can have either a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. More Than Words

    Nov 5, 202632 minAudio

    In this episode: We look at the second part of Chapter 1 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'What Is Mysticism?' The discussion this week explores different ways of knowing and what it means to have a direct...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Art of Uniting with Reality

    Oct 22, 202626 minAudio

    In this episode: We explore the question of how we know things and why it is necessary to direct our attention to what Jung calls the "higher unity" of which our everyday consciousness is just a part. Listen to Chapters...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Doors of Perception

    Oct 8, 202629 minAudio

    In this episode: I introduce the fifth season of Digital Jung with its special focus on the book Practical Mysticism by Evelyn Underhill. Listen to the preface of Practical Mysticism Here Sources for quotes and more:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Mystic Way

    Sep 24, 202644 minAudio

    In this episode: I discuss the figures of Ahab, Starbuck, and Ishmael as representatives of three possible responses to the encounter with the numinous. I look at the contrast between the Iron Way of Ahab and what I...

    Credit the people on this episode