In this episode: We talk about the value of letting things happen and why Jung felt it was essential for the task of individuation. Sources for quotes and more: 'The Integration of the Personality' by C.G. Jung. 'Tao Te Ching,' Translated by Richard Wilhelm. 'Some keep the Sabbath going to Church' by Emily Dickinson. 'The Spiritual Life' by Evelyn Underhill. 'The Wisdom of Insecurity' by Alan Watts. 'Religious but Not Religious' by Jason E. Smith. 'The Cloud of Unknowing.' 'Lost' by David Wagoner. 'Oceans' by Juan Ramón Jiménez. 'Love in the Void,' a collection of writings by Simone Weil. 'Encounters with the Soul' by Barbara Hannah. 'Visions Seminars' by C.G. Jung Transformation Symbolism in the Mass from 'Collected Works, vol. 11' by C.G. Jung. Music: "Dreaming Days," "Slow Vibing," and "The Return" by Ketsa are licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 Like this podcast? Please consider leaving a review at one of the following sites: Apple Podcasts Spotify Or, if you are able, support the show with a donation at Buy Me a Coffee: Support the show Connect with me: Instagram (@digital.jung) Facebook (facebook.com/jungiananalyst) Bluesky (@digitaljung.bsky.social) Subscribe to the Digital Jung Newsletter For more on living a symbolic life: Please check out my book, Religious but Not Religious: Living a Symbolic Life.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Digital Young, a podcast about living a symbolic life in a technological age.
SPEAKER_01Man cannot stand a meaningless life.
SPEAKER_00I'm Jason Smith, Jungian analyst and author of Religious but not religious, living a symbolic life. And in this episode, we talk about the value of letting things happen. And why Jung felt this was essential to the task of individuation?
SPEAKER_02It's the human soul. That's the buried treasure.
SPEAKER_00The best cannot be told, anyhow. And the second best does not strike home. One must be able to let things happen. I have learned from the East what it means by the phrase wu-wei, namely not doing, letting be, which is quite different from doing nothing. Some Westerners also have known what this not doing means.
SPEAKER_00For instance, Meister Eckhart, who speaks of Zisch Lassen to let oneself be. The best cannot be told. This is the great dilemma of talking about the symbolic life. Ultimately, it can't be explained.
SPEAKER_00It's impossible to convey directly a sense of the experience to be had through the practice of the symbolic life to someone who has not had the experience. Furthermore, there is no surefire method that one can suggest that will lead unerringly to it. All such descriptions, understandings, and techniques, which are the things that Jung refers to in our opening quote as the second best, are unlikely to make any real impact.
SPEAKER_00They do not strike home, he says. And this is because the experience that we're talking about, what we might call the meaningfulness of life, is not something that can be achieved. Right? It's not a thing that we can do. As Jung puts it, one must be able to let things happen.
SPEAKER_00Too much explanation, too much advice tends to reinforce our doing nature, our willing and striving mind already so exaggerated by the productivity mindset that permeates contemporary life. What Jung suggests is the need to develop the capacity for not doing, an idea most fully elaborated in Taoism with its concept of Wu Wei.
SPEAKER_00For Jung, this capacity is crucial for the work of individuation. Individuation means becoming oneself, but it is not a self-conscious creation of oneself, a crafting of one's self image. Rather it is a natural and honest unfolding of who and what one is and should be, and it proceeds in a sense by wu wei, by not doing.
SPEAKER_00Now not doing, as Jung states, is quite different from doing nothing. One way to understand it would be as the art of letting oneself be lived by life. Richard Wilhelm, who we'll talk about more later on in this episode, was a scholar of Chinese and a translator of two of the great classics of Taoism, the Iching and the Tao Te Ching.
SPEAKER_00He gives the following description of Wu Wei. This non action, he writes, is not idleness or inertia, but a total receptiveness to that which wells up out of the metaphysical source in the individual. Elsewhere he states it means allowing the creative forces to work within and through one's own ego without wanting to supplement it by external means.
SPEAKER_00If there is anything that approaches a method to the symbolic life, it begins with this quality of not doing, of letting things happen. I've called it in this podcast a discipline of deep listening. And in the next episode, I'm going to say more about this in connection with the practice of what Jung calls active imagination, but what I want to do here is to try to invoke the spirit of this letting be, by listening deeply to some of the witnesses who have entered this ground of being and have tried to point the way towards it to the rest of us.
SPEAKER_00The very act of stopping and reflecting, says Jung, is a spiritual act. It's through the act of reflection that we become fully human, attuned not only to biological necessity, but open to the numinous and transcendent as well. And so it should be no surprise then that the great masters of this approach to life are the poets, the artists, and the mystics, those who have given themselves to the inner life and allowed it to live in and through them.
SPEAKER_00And in what follows, I'm going to share some poems and quotes from a few of these masters. And in the spirit of letting things happen, I'm going to keep my own comments brief, trying mostly to draw out some of the qualities of this attitude as I see them reflected in these passages. However, I want to leave as much space as I can for the spirit of wisdom that speaks through these examples to have its own resonance in our hearing and to do its own work in our imaginations.
SPEAKER_00The first quality I want to draw attention to has to do with our relationship to time. The symbolic life, whether it's expressed through art, religion, or the work of individuation, requires a deep acquaintance with the present moment, and a suspension of our usual immersion in chronological time. All the spiritual traditions insist that the possibility of depth, of divinity, is present in every moment, if we could only tune our hearts and our minds to it.
SPEAKER_00Emily Dickinson uses the image of the Sabbath, that time of resting from the busyness of life and giving our attention to the depths, to point to this tuning of the heart. She suggests in essence that Sabbath consciousness does not have to be separate from the rest of life. It doesn't have to be compartmentalized to a special time or day or structure. It's available everywhere and always.
SPEAKER_00And this is what she says. Some keep the Sabbath going to church. I keep it staying at home. With a bobbleink for a chorister, and an orchard for a dome. Some keep the Sabbath in surplice. I just wear my wings.
SPEAKER_00And instead of tolling the bell for church, our little sexton sings. God preaches, a noted clergyman, and the sermon is never long. So instead of getting to heaven at last, I'm going all along. Eternity, we are reminded over and over again by the sages of the inner life, is not a very long stretch of time.
SPEAKER_00Eternity, which Dickinson in her poem calls heaven, is a different dimension of time, a deep dive into the present and a release from an anxious focus on the past or concern for the future. As the religious writer Evelyn Underhill notes, expressing something very similar to this poem, the action of those whose lives are given to the spirit has in it something of the leisure of eternity.
SPEAKER_00And she goes on to add, and because of this, they achieve far more than those whose lives are enslaved by the rush and hurry, the unceasing tick, tick of the world. The art of living, writes Alan Watts, consists in being completely sensitive to each moment, in regarding it as utterly new and unique, and having a mind open and wholly receptive.
SPEAKER_00The next quality of this let it be attitude that's helpful to become aware of is a certain kind of passivity. And here we recognize that we are not the primary actors, the agents, but rather the recipients of or the channels through which some other agency works in us. However, as I say in my book, this style of passivity should be understood as qualitatively different from the passivity fostered by our entertainment culture, in which the imagination is barraged by a clutter of images twenty-four hours a day.
SPEAKER_00In this instance, it's important to distinguish between what we might call a dead or passive passivity, in contrast to a living or active passivity. And what is demanded here is a certain quality of attention, where and how we direct our consciousness. In the Christian contemplative tradition, this is expressed through the language of opening oneself to the loving work of God.
SPEAKER_00So for instance, in the fourteenth century mystical text called The Cloud of Unknowing, we hear the following advice. His will is that you should simply gaze at him and leave him to act alone. Your part is to keep the windows and the doors against the inroads of flies and enemies, and if you are willing to do this, all that is required of you is to woo him humbly in prayer, and at once he will help you.
SPEAKER_00A remarkably similar piece of advice, this time coming from a very different tradition, is given in David Wagner's poem Lost, which is based off a Native American teaching story. This was a story that was told to a young person describing what to do when you get lost in the forest. And the poem goes like this.
SPEAKER_00Stand still. The trees ahead and bushes beside you are not lost. Wherever you are is called, here, and you must treat it as a powerful stranger, must ask permission to know it and be known. The forest breathes. Listen. It answers: I have made this place around you.
SPEAKER_00If you leave it, you may come back again, saying, Hear. No two trees are the same to Raven. No two branches are the same to Wren. If what a tree or a bush does is lost on you, you are surely lost. Stand still. The forest knows where you are. You must let it find you.
SPEAKER_00One of the subtlest qualities that belongs to this attitude we've been looking at here is that of silence. Now this means far more than just the sounds that we hear and that we make. The quality of silence includes the quieting of our expectations about how we want things to turn out. It means releasing those habits of mind and of action that prevent us from being open to new possibilities and new outcomes.
SPEAKER_00And it means connecting to the primal depths out of which all things emerge. And we can hear echoes of all of these things in this poem titled Oceans by Juan Raimond Jiménez. I have a feeling that my boat has struck down there in the depths against a great thing.
SPEAKER_00And nothing happens. Nothing. Silence waves. Nothing happens. Or has everything happened? And are we standing now quietly in the new life?
SPEAKER_00The life of the depths that can be encountered in such a silence is beyond explanation, beyond anything that we can rationally understand. And about these depths the mystic Simone Vi writes Everything happens as though by a miraculous favor. Our very senses themselves had been made aware that silence is not the absence of sounds, but something infinitely more real than sounds, and the center of a harmony more perfect than anything which a combination of sounds can produce.
SPEAKER_00These three dimensions that I've indicated so far the quality of time, the stillness or passivity, and the silence are all present in a story that Jung was fond of telling quite often. This is the story of the Rainmaker. In her book on active imagination, Barbara Hanna, one of Jung's early students, writes that Jung encouraged her to repeat this story every time that she gave a talk or a seminar on his psychology.
SPEAKER_00Clearly it was a story that held great meaning for him. The story involves Richard Wilhelm, who I mentioned earlier, the translator of the Iching, and an important colleague of Jung's. It was Wilhelm who told Jung this story of an old Taoist rainmaker, and who apparently was a witness to the events that it relates. And so here is the version of the story as retold by Barbara Hanna.
SPEAKER_00There was a terrible drought in that part of China where Richard Wilhelm was living. After all the ways to bring rain that the people knew had been tried, they decided to send for a rainmaker. This interested Wilhelm very much, and he was careful to be there when the rainmaker arrived. The man came in a covered cart, a small, wisened old man who sniffed the air with evident distaste as he got out of the cart, and asked to be left alone in a small cottage outside the village.
SPEAKER_00Even his meals were to be laid down outside the door. Nothing was heard from him for three days. Then it not only rained, but there was also a big downfall of snow unknown at that time of year. Very much impressed, Wilhelm sought the Rainmaker out and asked him how it was that he could make rain and even snow.
SPEAKER_00The Rainmaker replied, I have not made the snow. I am not responsible for it. Wilhelm insisted that there was a terrible drought until he came, and then after three days, they even had quantities of snow. The old man answered, Oh, I can explain that. You see, I come from a place where the people are in order.
SPEAKER_00They are in Tao. So the weather Is also in order. But directly I got here, I saw the people were out of order and they also infected me. So I remained alone until I was once more in Tao. And then, of course, it snowed.
SPEAKER_00This is a story that tests our credulity. Rationally it makes no sense, and we're justified in being skeptical of the notion that one man could have influence over the weather. At the same time, our own collective experience demonstrates all too forcefully that when many people live out of balance with themselves and with nature, it can have a destructive effect on the weather, as the reality of the climate crisis amply shows.
SPEAKER_00But though this story is apparently a true one, we don't need to take it literally to see the larger point at work in it, and to understand why Jung felt that it was an important one to retell as often as possible. We all have some sense of what it means to live out of harmony with ourselves. And we know the experience, whether we ever registered it fully or not, of how this kind of disharmony can have devastating effects on the many weather patterns of our lives, our relationships, our communities, our own capacity for contentment and creativity and joy.
SPEAKER_00This sense of a felt harmony with oneself and with life, though we can't account for it on a rational level, is nevertheless a real psychological experience. And this experience is attested to in the different traditions with a language specific to each tradition. So Taoism calls it being in Tao Christianity following the will of God.
SPEAKER_00And in Jungian psychology, it's expressed as being in alignment with the unconscious. And speaking of the effect of the Rainmaker, Jung makes this comment. He says, if one thinks psychologically, one is absolutely convinced that things quite naturally take this way. If one has the right attitude, then the right things happen.
SPEAKER_00One doesn't make it right, it is just right. And one feels it has to happen this way. It's just as if one were inside of things. There is something like a deeper current of life, something like the Tao, like a divine or higher order. And we can turn away from it, or we can turn toward it.
SPEAKER_00And this is the key takeaway here. Of course, it's impossible to describe this order or to convey the nature of the experience of what it's like to be in harmony with it. The best, remember, cannot be told. It seems from one point of view like nothing at all, and yet it is everything, as we heard in the poem from Himeneus.
SPEAKER_00Nothing happens or has everything happened? And are we standing now quietly in the new life? And because the experience cannot be told, cannot be given, it must be had first hand. We have looked at some of the indicators that can help us know whether we're on the right path, but the paradox is that the path itself cannot be found until we stop trying so hard to find it.
SPEAKER_00We do not obtain the most precious gifts by going in search of them, writes Simon Vi, but by waiting for them. We cannot discover them by our own powers, and if we set out to seek for them, we will find in their place counterfeits, of which we will be unable to discern the falsity.
SPEAKER_00The good news to all of this is that maybe we don't have to work so hard. Maybe the most important thing that we can do is to not do anything at all, but to let things happen, to allow life and ourselves along with it to unfold without trying to get in the way.
SPEAKER_00It is not I who create myself, Jung once wrote. Rather, I happen to myself. And so it seems it might be the better part of wisdom if we could just learn to let ourselves be.
SPEAKER_00Until next time. You'll find information in the show notes for all the sources used in this week's episode, as well as links to connect with me on social media. Let's make this a conversation. If you have any comments or questions about anything you heard in this episode, or that you'd like me to address in a future episode, send them to me on Facebook or Twitter.
SPEAKER_00And finally, if you want a deeper dive into the kind of material explored on this podcast, please check out my book, Religious but not religious. Living a symbolic life. Available from Chiron Publications. Thanks for listening. Take good care.
In this episode: We look at the first part of Chapter 2 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'The World of Reality.' We discuss how the imagination that we bring to our perception of life can have either a...
In this episode: We look at the second part of Chapter 1 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'What Is Mysticism?' The discussion this week explores different ways of knowing and what it means to have a direct...
In this episode: We explore the question of how we know things and why it is necessary to direct our attention to what Jung calls the "higher unity" of which our everyday consciousness is just a part. Listen to Chapters...
In this episode: I introduce the fifth season of Digital Jung with its special focus on the book Practical Mysticism by Evelyn Underhill. Listen to the preface of Practical Mysticism Here Sources for quotes and more:...
In this episode: I discuss the figures of Ahab, Starbuck, and Ishmael as representatives of three possible responses to the encounter with the numinous. I look at the contrast between the Iron Way of Ahab and what I...