Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Digital Jung

Digital Jung artwork

Knowing and Not-Knowing

May 13, 202129 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode: We look at the limits of a merely rational approach to life and the need to make place in our lives for mystery. Sources for quotes and more: “In our time, it's the intellect that is making darkness, because we've let it take too big a place...." ~ C.G. Jung from On the Frontiers of Knowledge in 'C.G. Jung Speaking.' “A mercenary of our will to power, the mind is trained to assail in order to plunder rather than to commune in order to love.” ~ Abraham Joshua Heschel in 'Man is Not Alone: A Philosophy of Religion.' Discussion of "instrumentally rational" in The Reenchantment of the World by Morris Berman. “The experiment presupposes a distorted image of [the human being].” ~ Raimon Panikkar in 'A Dwelling Place for Wisdom.' “There is no such thing as a baby.” ~ D.W. Winnicott from The Theory of the Parent-Infant Relationship in 'The International Journal of Psychoanalysis.' “Everything hints at something that transcends it; the detail indicates the whole, the whole, its idea, the idea, its mysterious root...." ~ Abraham Joshua Heschel in 'Man is Not Alone: A Philosophy of Religion.' The Cloud of Unknowing from the 'Classics of Western Spirituality' series. "Understanding is a fearfully binding power, at times a veritable murder of the soul as soon as it flattens out vitally important differences...." ~ C.G. Jung from 'Selected Letters of C.G. Jung, 1909 - 1961.' “Love can survive only if wisdom has an effective voice.” ~ Gregory Bateson from Style, Grace, and Information in Primitive Art from 'The Anthropology of Art.' Music: "Dreaming Days," "Slow Vibing," and "The Return" by Ketsa are licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 Like this podcast? Please consider leaving a review at one of the following sites: Apple Podcasts Spotify Or, if you are able, support the show with a donation at Buy Me a Coffee: Support the show Connect with me: Instagram (@digital.jung) Facebook (facebook.com/jungiananalyst) Bluesky (@digitaljung.bsky.social) Subscribe to the Digital Jung Newsletter For more on living a symbolic life: Please check out my book, Religious but Not Religious: Living a Symbolic Life.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Digital Young, a podcast about living a symbolic life in a technological age.

SPEAKER_01Man cannot stand a meaningless life.

SPEAKER_00I'm Jason Smith, you mean an analyst and author of religious and not religious? Living a symbolic life. And in this episode, we look at the limits of a merely rational approach to life. And the need to make a place in our lives for mystery.

SPEAKER_02It's the human soul. That's the buried treasure.

SPEAKER_00In our time, it's the intellect that is making darkness. Because we've let it take too big a place. Consciousness discriminates, judges, analyzes, and emphasizes the contradictions. It's necessary work up to a point. But analysis kills, and synthesis brings to life.

SPEAKER_00We must find out how to get everything back into connection with everything else. We must resist the vice of intellectualism and get it understood that we cannot only understand. Now I have to admit that I feel a little hesitant in beginning an exploration of this particular quote from Jung.

SPEAKER_00And I'm hesitant because we're living at a time in which such things as truth and fact and knowledge are far too often treated with what can only be called a casual recklessness, especially when they contradict some cherished and virulent ideology. And so to look at a quote in which Jung speaks of resisting the vice of intellectualism feels a little dangerous, something that might too easily be misunderstood or misinterpreted.

SPEAKER_00So let me just state clearly right off the bat to critique a one sided intellectualism does not mean taking the opposite position of anti-intellectualism, nor does a critique of a one sided scientific rationalism mean taking up the opposite position of being anti-science. We cannot and should not deny the great achievements of the scientific method.

SPEAKER_00Simply put, it works. We know, for example, that because of the knowledge and technology that science has generated, global life expectancy has doubled since 1900 and continues to rise. Medical science is constantly improving such that diseases that would have been fatal even twenty or thirty years ago are successfully treated and survived today.

SPEAKER_00There is no question about the importance and the value of science in our lives. That said, we are beings that need more than just long lives. We need meaningful lives. And meaning has a different imperative than intellectual knowing. Meaning seeks communion, and knowledge seeks differentiation.

SPEAKER_00Meaning comes from what connects, joins, and unites. Knowledge comes through the mind's ability and tendency to split things apart. And what I mean by that is that we know something in the sense of being able to identify and categorize it when we recognize how it's different from something else.

SPEAKER_00And this is why Jung says consciousness discriminates, judges, analyzes, and emphasizes the contradictions. And it's an exaggerated emphasis on this splitting and analyzing tendency of the intellect, despite its being, as he says, necessary work up to a point that Jung is critiquing.

SPEAKER_00Analysis involves breaking something complex down into simpler units, cutting it up into smaller bits. What is so successful about the intellect, about the rational mind, that is, its ability to abstract things from the confusing and often messy contexts in which they're embedded, in order to understand them in their particulars, it turns out is also, when taken too far, its very problem.

SPEAKER_00Abraham Joshua Heschel eloquently lays out the issue. He writes that the mind is often like a knife that cuts the world in two, into a thing on the one hand, and a self perceiving that thing on the other. In other words, it divides us, the thinking and perceiving human beings, from the world in which we live, effectively alienating us from that world.

SPEAKER_00And this makes the rational intellect an agent of our drives for power and domination. And so he writes a mercenary of our will to power, the mind is trained to assail in order to plunder rather than to commune in order to love. And this is a perspective that the historian and social critic Morris Berman calls instrumentally rational.

SPEAKER_00And Berman notes that the process of intellectual and scientific knowing takes place through manipulation, that is, through disrupting a particular phenomenon, isolating it in some way from its natural setting, and observing it in the abstract. That is, we come to know something by interfering with it.

SPEAKER_00And the question that interests the observer in this approach is not the question why, such as why are we here, which in its essence is unanswerable, but rather how? As in how does it work, which is answerable. And more than that, it's actionable, right? We can do something with it.

SPEAKER_00We can make use of something for our own purposes. It becomes an instrument that we can use. But notice that it's for our purposes. To the instrumentally rational mind, things are used to serve human ends. And this leads Raymond Panikar to say that the experiment presupposes a distorted image of the human being.

SPEAKER_00And that distorted image is that we are separate from the world in some way, that we are merely the ones doing the observing, performing operations on the passive material of the world, which is then understood as being just so many resources for human consumption, as if we are not also nature, as if we are not also embedded in the world, partaking of a common life with the world.

SPEAKER_00And one way that this manifests in our lives is in what I think of as the productivity fallacy, which is an offshoot of the instrumentally rational mindset. And what the productivity fallacy says is that everything has to be for something, right? Everything has to be useful, everything has to be directed to some practical end.

SPEAKER_00And again, being productive is not in and of itself a bad thing, but an exclusive emphasis on productivity is an incomplete picture of how life really works. The natural process includes decay and decline as well as growth. Right? There's night as well as day, winter as well as summer.

SPEAKER_00To everything there is a season, so the old wisdom teaches. No one can be productive without also sometimes being unproductive. Creative people know that the best and brightest insights can often come after a period of rest, when nothing, so to speak, is happening.

SPEAKER_00We cannot always be the ones working on life, performing operations on life. We must also be able to let life work on us. There are two core issues with a one-sided intellectual rationalism. The first is expressed in Jung's almost shocking statement that analysis kills and synthesis brings to life.

SPEAKER_00I say shocking because Jung's psychology is called analytical psychology. Analysis is literally in the name. And yet here he is calling out analysis as potentially destructive. Analysis kills and synthesis brings to life. And what he means is that cutting things up into smaller pieces serves understanding, but it doesn't necessarily serve life.

SPEAKER_00Dissecting a living body tells you about the parts of that body, but at the cost of its life. Life is not a collection of separate bits and pieces, but a living whole. Knowing all the parts doesn't tell you about the whole because as we know, the whole is always more than the sum of its parts.

SPEAKER_00Everything is embedded in a larger context. The psychoanalyst D. W. Winnicott, for instance, once famously said that there is no such thing as a baby. And what he meant is that there has to be a mother for there to be a baby. And it's the fact of the baby that makes a mother a mother. There's no isolated baby and no isolated mother.

SPEAKER_00There is a mother baby diet. And we could say the same thing about anything else, right? There's no such thing as a tree. The tree is part of a larger ecosystem that includes the soil, the surrounding flora and fauna, the weather, and the presence of human beings, to name just a few of the factors. There's no such thing as an individual.

SPEAKER_00Each of us is born at a particular time and in a particular place. We are affected for good or for ill by family, by culture, by history, by our personal circumstances, and by the current political climate, among other things. Life in its totality does not conform to the structures of rational thought.

SPEAKER_00Thought, for instance, has to understand, say, light as different from dark, just as it has to understand a baby as different from its mother. But a holistic experience of life recognizes that light and dark exist together. We cannot recognize light without contrast to the dark, as any painter who has wrestled with shading and shadows can tell you.

SPEAKER_00Light and dark form an organic whole. For the anthropologist and philosopher Gregory Bateson, the recognition of the systemic nature of things, of the interconnectedness of all things is what constitutes wisdom. And this is just what Jung means when he says we must find out how to get everything back into connection with everything else.

SPEAKER_00But the web of relations in which everything exists is extremely complex. And ultimately, it's beyond our ability to fully discern and understand. It leads us beyond what can be known. Right? To what can't be known. That is to mystery.

SPEAKER_00And here let me turn again to the words of Abraham Joshua Heschel, who says, everything hints at something that transcends it. The detail indicates the whole. The whole its idea. The idea its mysterious root. What appears to be a center is but a point on the periphery of another center.

SPEAKER_00The totality of a thing is actual infinity. And here we come to a place where we discover the importance of balancing knowing with what we might call not knowing, with wisdom, with a recognition of mystery. And here we need a very different way of knowing than just that which the intellect can give us.

SPEAKER_00Bateson suggests that the instrumentally rational mindset needs to be compensated. He uses the term aided by art, religion, and dream. Or to put it another way, the intellect finds balance through the symbolic life. The understanding of mystery is most fully developed in the expressions of religion, particularly through its mystical dimensions.

SPEAKER_00And it's through these expressions that we can gain a better understanding of how to include this level of experience in our picture of life and world. And so here's a passage from The Cloud of Unknowing, a mystical writing from an anonymous Christian monk from around the fourteenth century, that speaks to this different way of knowing.

SPEAKER_00The passage starts with the writer addressing the question of how one should think about God. But now you put me a question and say, How might I think of him in himself? And what is he? And to this I can only answer thus, I have no idea.

SPEAKER_00For with your question you have brought me into that same darkness, into that same cloud of unknowing, where I would you were yourself. For a man may by grace have the fullness of knowledge of all other creatures and their works. Yes, and of the works of God's own self, and he is well able to reflect on them.

SPEAKER_00But no man can think of God himself. Therefore it is my wish to leave everything that I can think of and choose for my love the thing that I cannot think. Because he can certainly be loved, but not thought. He can be taken and held by love, but not by thought.

SPEAKER_00I said earlier that there are two core issues with a one-sided rationalism. The first being that it neglects the interconnectedness of all things. The second is what this passage from the cloud of unknowing identifies. That knowing must be balanced with not knowing. That in the face of the mystery, the best thing that we can do is to let go of our need to know and just be present to the Experience of the mystery.

SPEAKER_00And Jung says essentially the same thing when he states we must get it understood that we cannot only understand. And in one of his letters, Jung makes a warning about understanding. And he says this. He says, Understanding is a fearfully binding power. At times, a veritable murder of the soul.

SPEAKER_00As soon as it flattens out vitally important differences. The core of the individual is a mystery of life which is snuffed out when it is grasped. Too much understanding, it turns out, can only do violence when confronting mystery.

SPEAKER_00And it's not only in the divine realm where we encounter mystery, but in the core of every individual. One of the problems of rational understanding, that is, of analysis, is that it reduces things down to their type or to some kind of classification. It doesn't do so well with the handling of uniqueness, idiosyncrasy, individuality.

SPEAKER_00At the same time that it differentiates one thing from another, it prefers each separated thing to be able to be identified according to its general category. In the passage from the cloud of unknowing, the author names love as an alternative to thought.

SPEAKER_00He can be taken and held by love, he writes, but not by thought. And it's love, really. That's the takeaway for this episode. But we shouldn't make the mistake of thinking in terms of some sentimental idea of love here. Love, the author of The Cloud is saying, is another way of knowing.

SPEAKER_00It's a knowing through not knowing. It's not knowing through the intellect, but through relationship. And this is a kind of knowing that only occurs when there is a sufficient personal investment of ourselves in the act of knowing the other. It is an engagement with that other, be it a person, animal, tree, or god, that doesn't seek to simply identify something, but rather to be able to tune into our experience of and appreciation for that other in their ineffable uniqueness the mystery of life, as Jung says, that they are at their core.

SPEAKER_00But this kind of knowing through not knowing can only happen when we remain conscious of our participation in the interconnectedness of all things. When, so to speak, we take our place in the great dance of life and don't just observe from the sidelines like an intellectual wallflower.

SPEAKER_00And this recognition of our place in the whole we've seen is what Gregory Bateson calls wisdom. And it's essential if we are to establish a right relationship to life and to the world. Love, he says, can survive only if wisdom has an effective voice.

SPEAKER_00Until next time. You'll find information in the show notes for all the sources used in this week's episode, as well as links to connect with me on social media. Let's make this a conversation. If you have any comments or questions about anything you heard in this episode, or that you'd like me to address in a future episode, send them to me on Facebook or Twitter.

SPEAKER_00And finally, if you want a deeper dive into the kind of material explored on this podcast, please check out my book, Religious but not religious: Living a Symbolic Life. Available from Chiron Publications. Thanks for listening. Take good care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Metaphor of the Machine

    Nov 19, 202631 minAudio

    In this episode: We look at the first part of Chapter 2 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'The World of Reality.' We discuss how the imagination that we bring to our perception of life can have either a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. More Than Words

    Nov 5, 202632 minAudio

    In this episode: We look at the second part of Chapter 1 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'What Is Mysticism?' The discussion this week explores different ways of knowing and what it means to have a direct...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Art of Uniting with Reality

    Oct 22, 202626 minAudio

    In this episode: We explore the question of how we know things and why it is necessary to direct our attention to what Jung calls the "higher unity" of which our everyday consciousness is just a part. Listen to Chapters...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Doors of Perception

    Oct 8, 202629 minAudio

    In this episode: I introduce the fifth season of Digital Jung with its special focus on the book Practical Mysticism by Evelyn Underhill. Listen to the preface of Practical Mysticism Here Sources for quotes and more:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Mystic Way

    Sep 24, 202644 minAudio

    In this episode: I discuss the figures of Ahab, Starbuck, and Ishmael as representatives of three possible responses to the encounter with the numinous. I look at the contrast between the Iron Way of Ahab and what I...

    Credit the people on this episode