In this episode: With help from some of the symbols in the story of Parzival, I discuss the surprising importance of vulnerability in the process of psychological growth. Sources for quotes and more: "Only through our feebleness and incapacity are we linked up with the unconscious..." ~ C.G. Jung from 'The Tavistock Lectures,' Collected Works, vol. 18. Jacob and the Angel from Genesis 32:25 - 29, Sefaria.org The Man Watching by Rainer Maria Rilke (Robert Bly translation) "There's a crack in everything, that's how the light gets in." ~ Leonard Cohen from 'Anthem.' "Give your unconscious a chance to analyze yourself..." ~ C.G. Jung from 'Jung on Active Imagination,' p. 164. Parzival by Wolfram von Eschenbach (Helen M. Mustard & Charles E. Passage translation). Music: "Dreaming Days," "Slow Vibing," and "The Return" by Ketsa are licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 Like this podcast? Please consider leaving a review at one of the following sites: Apple Podcasts Spotify Or, if you are able, support the show with a donation at Buy Me a Coffee: Support the show Connect with me: Instagram (@digital.jung) Facebook (facebook.com/jungiananalyst) Bluesky (@digitaljung.bsky.social) Subscribe to the Digital Jung Newsletter For more on living a symbolic life: Please check out my book, Religious but Not Religious: Living a Symbolic Life.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Digital View, a podcast about living a symbolic life in a technological page.
SPEAKER_01Man cannot stand a meaningless life.
SPEAKER_00I'm Jason Smith, Jungian analyst and author of religious but not religious, living a psychological life. And in this episode, we discussed a surprisingly important vulnerability in the process of psychological.
SPEAKER_02It's the human soul. That's the buried treasure.
SPEAKER_00Only through our feebleness and incapacities are we linked up with the unconscious, with the lower world of the instincts, and with our fellow beings. Our virtues only enable us to be independent. There we do not need anybody. There we are kings. But in our inferiority, we are linked up with mankind as well as with the world of our instincts.
SPEAKER_00My principle is, for heaven's sake, do not be perfect, but by all means try to be complete. So as I was reflecting on last week's episode, I found that I couldn't shake this feeling that there was something incomplete about it.
SPEAKER_00Last week I was speaking about the biblical story of Jacob wrestling with the angel. And in discussing that story I I focused on the issue of struggle, struggling or striving with God, wrestling with wisdom, and living the questions instead of seeking for answers. And all of these I suggested were qualities involved in the living of what Jung called a religious outlook on life.
SPEAKER_00But there are more facets to this story, and I think it's important for us to look a little deeper and to fill out the picture a little more. Now it's true that Jacob is the one who struggles with God, and it's said in the story that he prevails. But the truth is, if he prevails, he doesn't do so by conquering and overcoming the angel.
SPEAKER_00If anything, Jacob's victory is to endure and survive the struggle. He's grateful for the remarkable fact that, as he says, my life has been preserved. And he's not unaffected by the whole encounter. While they're wrestling, the angel dislocates his hip, and when he eventually walks away from the encounter, he does so with a limp.
SPEAKER_00But it's this wounding I want to suggest that constitutes Jacob's victory. He grows because of it. Jacob, the trickster who stole from his brother first his birthright and then their father's blessing, who now faces the possible consequences of that theft in the form of his brother's wrath, grows by being humbled.
SPEAKER_00His wound changes and softens him. And then when his brother Esau approaches, Jacob bows low to the ground seven times. And in response Esau runs to him and hugs him, and the two brothers are reconciled. There's a wonderful poem called The Man Watching.
SPEAKER_00And in it the poet Rilke makes an allusion to this story of Jacob. And his description of the effect on the Jacobs of the world, of their encounters with their angels, is powerful and incisive. And he says this he says, Winning does not tempt that man. This is how he grows. By being defeated decisively by constantly greater beings.
SPEAKER_00This is how he grows. By being defeated decisively by constantly greater beings. This is the dynamic that Jung is pointing to in that quote with which I led off this episode. And this is a quote that comes from a series of talks that Jung gave in 1935, collectively known as the Tavistock Lectures.
SPEAKER_00And in the quote he says that it's through our feebleness and incapacity that we're linked up with the unconscious, with the lower world of instincts, and with our fellow beings. In other words, he's saying that it's through our human frailty, through our wounds, through our not quite put together parts of ourselves, that a meaningful connection can take place both with other people and with our own depths.
SPEAKER_00Our virtues, he says, only enable us to be independent. That's a very interesting way to phrase things. Our virtues, that is our strengths, only enable us to be independent. Strengths and independence, Jung seems to be suggesting, are in themselves inadequate for a fully lived human life. When we live out of our virtues and our independence, we do not need anybody, he says.
SPEAKER_00But our inferiority, as he calls it, links us with mankind as well as with the world of our instincts. In effect, what Jung is saying here is that in our strength there is a hidden weakness. And in our weakness there is a secret strength. So how are we to understand this?
SPEAKER_00What is the strength in our weakness? The growth that comes through defeat. Well the key point here is that it's only when we discover the limits of our powers, of our will, our reason and understanding, our sense of mastery over our lives. It's only when we find the limits of these that something new and creative can emerge.
SPEAKER_00It's when we discover the limits of our ability to affect the course of life that we become open to being affected by life. Instead of changing the circumstances surrounding us, we are changed by them. It's at this moment when what we know fails, what we don't know emerges to fill the gap.
SPEAKER_00Or to use Jung's language, through our feebleness and incapacity, we are linked up with the unconscious. And this is when we're receptive to an illuminating dream or a helpful intuition or a creative idea. In the words of the immortal Leonard Cohen, there's a crack in everything.
SPEAKER_00That's how the light gets through. And this has important implications for the practice of the symbolic life. For in that work, it's essential that we learn how to submit to the initiative of the symbol. And this means learning to receive our psychological images from our dreams, our waking fantasies, and our creative imagination, to receive them humbly, with openness and curiosity.
SPEAKER_00It means not imposing our perspective, our agenda, or our fixed ideas upon such symbols. To work with symbolic material in our psychological and spiritual lives is not a matter of interpreting it according to what we already know and think. It's not about analyzing our unconscious, as Jung says when he's speaking about his technique of active imagination.
SPEAKER_00Rather, it is to give your unconscious a chance to analyze yourself. And so the move here is one from invulnerability to vulnerability. We need to allow cracks to form in our psychological armor if we want to let in the light of self-awareness, compassion, and meaning.
SPEAKER_00This is a theme that is powerfully presented in the story of Parzival, one of King Arthur's knights, in his search for the Grail. And so here's a retelling of an episode from that tale, in which Parzival makes the first of two visits to the Grail Castle.
SPEAKER_00Leaving behind his new bride, Parzival set off in search of Lady Adventure. Feeling troubled at being thus separated from his love, he becomes lost in thought and drops the reins of his horse. The horse pulled the dragging reins over fallen trees and through marshy land, for no one's hand guided it.
SPEAKER_00In this way, and without knowing it, Parzival arrives at the outskirts of the Castle of the Grail. On the lake near the castle he sees an old fisherman. This is none other than the well-known wounded fisher king, the king of the Grail Castle. Now the king's wound, so the story relates, was received in part because in his youthful pursuits, he failed to embody the appropriate spirit of humility.
SPEAKER_00Unbeknownst to Parceval, he has the power to heal this king and to free the kingdom from the sorrow and barrenness that pervade it. Parceval is made the honored guest at a great banquet, and a ritual of great sorrow and solemnity is presented before him, culminating in the appearance of the grail, which is described as the fruit of blessedness.
SPEAKER_00And according to the story, Parzival did not fail to notice the richness and the great wonder, but for courtesy's sake, he refrained from questions. Not asking any questions, it turns out, is a catastrophic error. The next morning, Parzival finds the castle deserted, and when he rides off in search of the others, the castle disappears altogether.
SPEAKER_00At this point, the story declares, grief may arouse him now, but it is a thing he has not been accustomed to, nor did he much long for it. And it continues, his adventures begin now in earnest.
SPEAKER_00Parzal's great failure is a failure of empathy. He's enthralled by the sights of the Grail Castle, but he fails to ask a pivotal question. He's been taught by his mentor that it's not proper for a knight to ask questions, and so instead of following his spontaneous curiosity and concern, he chooses instead to preserve a kind of unmoved attitude, the persona of the impassive and invulnerable knight.
SPEAKER_00And the question that Parzival fails to ask is a deceptively simple one. What is it that troubles you? And one of the things that happens to people when they go through an experience of grief for the first time, after they've lost someone close to them and struggled through the long, dark valley of grieving, is that they emerge with a new awareness of others' pain.
SPEAKER_00Many experience remorse when they reflect on their lack of understanding before having gone through their own experience of loss, of the depth of suffering that others have endured, and of their lack of adequate compassion toward it. Like Percival, they realize that they did not know enough at the time to ask the critical question. What is it that troubles you?
SPEAKER_00We do not know what we do not know. And this is the kind of knowledge that can only be gained by going through the experience. We grow by the defeats that life hands us. Of course, this kind of change in perspective isn't only the result of painful experiences.
SPEAKER_00There are also life-changing experiences that are joyous occasions. Having a baby, for instance. But either way, these kinds of experiences not only change us, they change the world in which we live. They are truly transformative. Whether such experiences are joyful or sorrowful, we are initiated by them and by life into a new state of consciousness.
SPEAKER_00We become different people. Life events like birth and death are those that break open the heart, such that we are no longer able to stay isolated in our own private consciousness. Now we live in an awareness that what happens to the other affects and involves us too. We become vulnerable, and another name for vulnerability is nothing other than love.
SPEAKER_00But that is a subject for another time. In the Parsival story, it's in part his initial defeat and failure at the Grail Castle that prepares him for his ultimate success. His failure begins a process by which his personality is tempered, softened, and opened.
SPEAKER_00From this point on Parzival learns from others, he grows in humility, he learns to let himself be affected by life, vulnerable to both its joys and its sorrows, and eventually he finds his way back to the castle. And in the words of the story, he learns the right balance of knowing when to grieve and when to abstain from grief.
SPEAKER_00And this time he will succeed in asking the healing question. This softening, this growing through humility and vulnerability are important not only in our openness to others, but in our openness to our own psyches. If we are too identified with a particular self image, we're in danger of ignoring other vital aspects of our personality and our potential.
SPEAKER_00We may develop part of ourselves, but leave other parts undeveloped. One aspect of the symbolic life is that it opens us to the fullness of the life that wants to live in us. The individuation process, said Jung, is to become what you are. But that might mean that we have to let go of who we think we should be, or who we have been told we're supposed to be.
SPEAKER_00And that can be felt as a kind of defeat for the old outworn ideal. So what's the takeaway from all of this? Well, I can think of no better one than Jung's own from the quote with which we started. For heaven's sake, do not be perfect.
SPEAKER_00But by all means, try to be complete. Until next time. You'll find information in the show notes for all the sources used in this week's episode, as well as links to connect with me on social media.
SPEAKER_00Let's make this a conversation. If you have questions about anything you've heard in the episode or that you'd like me to address in a future episode, send them to me on Facebook or Twitter using the hashtag digital yoga. And finally, if you want a deeper dive into the kind of material explored in this podcast, please check out my book, Religious but not religious.
SPEAKER_00Living a symbolic life. Available now for the publication. Thanks for listening.
In this episode: We look at the first part of Chapter 2 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'The World of Reality.' We discuss how the imagination that we bring to our perception of life can have either a...
In this episode: We look at the second part of Chapter 1 of Evelyn Underhill’s Practical Mysticism: 'What Is Mysticism?' The discussion this week explores different ways of knowing and what it means to have a direct...
In this episode: We explore the question of how we know things and why it is necessary to direct our attention to what Jung calls the "higher unity" of which our everyday consciousness is just a part. Listen to Chapters...
In this episode: I introduce the fifth season of Digital Jung with its special focus on the book Practical Mysticism by Evelyn Underhill. Listen to the preface of Practical Mysticism Here Sources for quotes and more:...
In this episode: I discuss the figures of Ahab, Starbuck, and Ishmael as representatives of three possible responses to the encounter with the numinous. I look at the contrast between the Iron Way of Ahab and what I...