Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

The Man Behind "We the People": Recovering James Wilson

Jul 29, 202637 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The three most famous words in American government - We the People - were written by a founder most Americans have never heard of. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey sits down with author and journalist Jesse Wegman to recover the story of James Wilson: a Scottish immigrant who arrived in 1765, signed both the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, drafted the Constitution's opening words, and sat on the first Supreme Court - then vanished almost entirely from national memory. Wegman's new book, The Lost Founder: James Wilson and the Forgotten Fight for a People's Constitution, is the first full-length biography of Wilson in more than seventy years. Wilson was the convention's fiercest advocate for popular sovereignty. He pushed for proportional representation, one-person, one-vote, and the direct election of the president - positions bold enough to unsettle many of his peers. We owe to him not only We the People but the Necessary and Proper Clause and the Supremacy Clause, the architecture of a strong national government. His 1768 essay on parliamentary authority reached Thomas Jefferson's desk and echoes in the Declaration itself. His end was as dramatic as his rise. A ruinous addiction to land speculation left Wilson holding four million acres he could not pay for. He was jailed twice for debt - the only Supreme Court justice ever imprisoned - and died in 1798 in the back room of a North Carolina tavern, delirious and destitute, with no funeral and scarcely a mention. Wegman explains why Wilson's ideas about equality and self-government still matter, and what we lose when the stories we tell about the founding get too simple.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

announcerWelcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.

announcerSmith Center for the Constitution and James Madison's Montpelier.

Katie Crawford-LackeyHello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, with James Madison's Montpelier. When we think about the founding of the United States, we often return to familiar figures like George Washington and Thomas Jefferson. And when we talk about the U.S. Constitution, James Madison is top of mind. But the founding generation was much larger, filled with individuals whose ideas and contributions helped shape the nations.

Katie Crawford-LackeyOne of those figures is James Wilson, a Scottish immigrant who arrived in America in 1765. He became a leading voice in the movement for independence. He was a signer of the Declaration of Independence, one of the most influential delegates at the Constitutional Convention, and one of the first justices appointed to the Supreme Court. Yet, despite his remarkable record, Wilson remains largely unknown today.

Katie Crawford-LackeyHis story, however, offers an important window into the baits that shaped the Constitution over democracy and liberty. And today we're exploring the life and legacy of James Wilson with Mr. Jesse Wegman, author of a new book, The Lost Founder. James Wilson and the Forgotten Fight for a People's Constitution. It is the first full-length biography of James Wilson in more than 70 years.

Katie Crawford-LackeyMr. Wegman is a senior fellow in the Office of the President at the Brennan Center for Justice, where he works on issues related to democracy reform and constitutional governance. Previously, he served on the New York Times editorial board from 2013 to 2025, writing extensively on law, politics, the Supreme Court, and democracy. His work was part of a Times package that won the Pulitzer Prize for Public Service in 2018.

Katie Crawford-LackeyMr. Jesse Wegman, it's a real honor to welcome you to Consider the Constitution.

Jesse WegmanThank you so much for having me.

Katie Crawford-LackeyI have to say, in reading your book, I was really excited to learn about Wilson because obviously, being at James Madison's Mop Pillier, we focus a lot on James Madison and his role in the convention. So before we delve into that aspect of Wilson's life, what should we know about him for us who are not familiar with James Wilson? Who is he? What brought him to America? How did he become so central to the founding of the United States?

Jesse WegmanYeah, well, I was excited to learn about James Wilson too, because I had not known of him, despite having gone to college and law school and writing about the courts and the law for a major national newspaper for many years. So I was kind of surprised. I thought, how could somebody who, as you described in your introduction, is so central to the founding of the country and so central to the ideas that undergird the American Republic be so forgotten? And that was really what drew me to tell this story is that he was both so influential and yet completely erased from American history.

Jesse WegmanI think most people I've spoken to in the last seven or eight years that I've been working on this project have never heard of him. So Wilson, as you said, was a Scottish immigrant. He was raised, he was born in the lowlands of Scotland, so outside of Edinburgh, and raised in a poor farming family. He was expected to enter the ministry by his parents, who were devout Presbyterians, but very, very soon in his educational life, he decided that was not for him. He ended up training at St. Andrews University, which was just down the road from his house.

Jesse WegmanHe ended up taking classes at the University of Glasgow, and in the process became this incredibly well-educated and also democratically spirited person to a degree that I think none of the other founders achieved. He ends up, like a lot of ambitious young men of that era, taking a boat across the Atlantic in 1765, landing in New York Harbor right as the American Revolution is starting to, you know, bubble up. This is the Year of the Stamp Act crisis, and in the years to follow, we would just have more and more incursions by the Great Britain, and the colonists were getting more and more antsy about independence.

Jesse WegmanSo Wilson is really just there from the beginning. He writes this essay that I talk about in the book, and we can get into that makes the most robust legal case to date for the independence of the colonies from Britain. He signs the Declaration of Independence, he signs the Constitution, he sits on the first Supreme Court. He's by far the greatest lawyer in the land. I think that's a general acclamation. George Washington hires him to tutor his own nephew, Bushrod, and he becomes a very wealthy and well-established figure of uh the Philadelphia elite over his years in America.

Jesse WegmanAnd the reason that he's lost we can talk about, but it has to do with his addiction to land speculation, which was something that he got into very early upon his arrival in America and never could free himself from. So it's both a remarkable story and a tragic one. And it was very appealing to me in terms of thinking about the founding of the country and how much we don't know about the people who built this country.

Katie Crawford-LackeyI mean, his story sounds really remarkable from his beginnings to where he ended up, at least what he participated in in terms of the political future of the United States. What role specifically did he play in independence, fighting for independence, and how important was he to that struggle?

Jesse WegmanAs I say, Wilson signed the Declaration of Independence. He's one of only six founders to have signed both of our foundational documents. But what's so interesting about him and the Declaration of Independence is that Wilson was a proponent of this idea of popular sovereignty, the notion that the people themselves are the ultimate authority in government, and that they may change their government when they are unhappy with it, whenever and however they please. This is something he came back to again and again and again throughout his life. It is the essence of this essay that he wrote that I mentioned.

Jesse WegmanThis is it's an essay with a long and unwieldy title, but the basic argument that he was making was parliament has no authority at all over the colonies. Not a bit. All the other people at the time are making the argument that, well, parliament has some authority, but not total authority. We they can't tax us, that you know, certain types of taxes are okay, but other types aren't, right? Everyone's doing a very funny dance about what is the nature of the relationship between the colonies and Britain. Wilson comes out and he writes this essay in 1768. He's only 26 years old at the time.

Jesse WegmanAnd he says, in an extremely carefully argued 11,000-word essay, Parliament has no authority at all over the colonies. And in the course of writing this essay, he puts some words on paper at the beginning of it that I'm just gonna read to you a very short portion of that are quite, let's say, they have powerful echoes. This is what he says early in that essay about Parliament's authority. All men are, by nature, equal and free. No one has a right to any authority over another without his consent. All lawful government is founded on the consent of those who are subject to it.

Jesse WegmanSuch consent was given with a view to ensure and to increase the happiness of the governed above what they can enjoy in an independent and unconnected state of nature. You may hear the echo of those words in a document written two years later, which was the Declaration of Independence. Thomas Jefferson, we know, was influenced by Wilson's essay, which actually was not published until 1774. I said he wrote it in 1768. It was so bold and so kind of ahead of its time then that he was advised strongly to put it away.

Jesse WegmanHis mentor said, James, you're a young man, don't ruin your career with this maybe overly ambitious argument so early in your life. And so he hid it in a drawer for six years. He pulled it out and got it published in 1774. Thomas Jefferson and many other people see the essay. It really transforms the whole debate in the colonies about what is the nature of American independence. And when Jefferson is drafting the Declaration two years later in the spring of 1776, we know he has the essay on his desk because he's cut out whole portions of it and pasted them into his commonplace book, where he keeps the quotes that matter to him.

Jesse WegmanNow, obviously, we know Jefferson was drawing on lots of sources for the Declaration. He was trying to pull together the energy of the moment, the prevailing wisdom of the colonies at the time, but we know that Wilson may have influenced him, at least in those most famous lines of the Declaration that we know today. We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal. Wilson was so central to the creation of those lines because Wilson believed more than any of his peers that the people themselves were the ultimate source of power in government and they could change that government whenever they wanted.

Jesse WegmanThat's exactly what the Declaration was doing.

Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd I think about those lines and how much they shape who we are today, what defines us. And it gives us a little bit of insight into Wilson's political philosophy. Can you expand on that and talk about what he believed in and how he was bringing that to government?

Jesse WegmanWilson wanted people to be more directly involved in the choosing of their representatives than any of the other founders, to a degree that I think made a lot of the other founders kind of uneasy and in some cases even scared. And what's interesting about this is for all of Wilson's commitment to popular sovereignty, all of his commitment to self-rule and public participation in government, political equality, you know, the idea that all of us are equal, these were all Wilsonian ideals that I think the other founders just didn't adhere to, or maybe a portion of them they liked, but not the whole thing.

Jesse WegmanWilson himself really struggles to win over the hearts of the very people that he's speaking on behalf of. So I was just talking about how his words were influential in the writing of the Declaration of Independence and how much he himself is committed to this ideal of popular sovereignty. But he's doing things, his behavior during those years is being interpreted in ways that are not very flattering for him. And it gets him into a lot of trouble. So around that time that you asked about with the writing and the signing of the Declaration of Independence, Wilson is a central player in Pennsylvania's ultimate decision to sign on to the Declaration.

Jesse WegmanHe's a delegate to Congress from Pennsylvania at the time. He actually delays Pennsylvania's vote on independence. And there's a good reason for this. I have a whole chapter on it in the book explaining what the sort of political maneuverings are at the time. But in the public eye, Wilson was seen as someone who was a hesitant, avoidant of independence, maybe even a secret loyalist. He's not a person to be trusted. On top of this, he's a wealthy lawyer. He's becoming part of Eastern Pennsylvania's elite.

Jesse WegmanSo a lot of the more radical revolutionaries are not happy with him, and they get very upset when they see that he's delaying this vote. It turns out that his delay is actually what makes it possible for Pennsylvania to vote in favor of independence and therefore bring the country along and get to the declaration itself. But at the time, he gets in all kinds of trouble for it. This happens again and again throughout the 1770s, where Wilson gets himself in trouble with the very people that he's speaking on behalf of. So while his theory of government is as well conceived and as thoroughly framed as any of the people at the founding of the country, he really it's funny how I think this is part of what leads to his ultimate erasure.

Jesse WegmanHe did not have the affection of the people in the way that, say, a Washington or a Benjamin Franklin did. And I think that ended up haunting him for the rest of his life.

Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd his beliefs on what, you know, freedom, democracy, what that should look like translates not just into the Declaration of Independence, but also beyond that, into the U.S. Constitution. What role does he play in that? And you know, how does his story fit into the 1787 Constitutional Convention?

Jesse WegmanSo Wilson is uh chosen as a delegate from Pennsylvania to the Constitutional Convention in 1787. I think there's almost no question that he should be one, right? He is by then easily the best lawyer in the country, one of the wealthiest. He's clearly the most educated of all of them. He and Madison are probably vying for the top spot. But he wants to come to this convention because he is insistent that he wants to build a country on the principles that he believes in, right? The Articles of Confederation, the first draft of the Constitution, were failing miserably at this point.

Jesse WegmanAnd they're failing for reasons that are pretty clear to everybody, but no more so than Wilson, who sees in the insistence of state equality that is embedded in the Articles of Confederation the ills that bedevil the country, right? This is the ultimate problem he sees. And the problem is that with the states being treated as equal partners in governance, the people themselves get treated very unequally. So he says at one point, what sense is it to treat 40,000 people in one state the same as 10,000 people in another state?

Jesse WegmanHe says this may be the effect of magic, not reason. In his mind, the ultimate goal of government is to treat all people as equal, give people equal political power no matter where they live, and that that is going to be the principle on which you build a functioning government and a government that actually can serve its population. So he gets to the convention and he's so insistent that that is the principle they need to build the new country on. And he fights for this for the first two months of the convention while they're all fighting over what is Congress going to look like, how are states going to be represented, how are people going to be represented.

Jesse WegmanWilson, more than anyone else at the convention, is fighting for what we call proportional representation, one person, one vote. The idea that you don't get extra power or less power just because of where you happen to live. And so something like the Senate, right, which many of the delegates at the convention want to be based on state equality, that every state gets the same number of senators, no matter their size, he finds this an abomination. He's so mad about it. He says this would be, if you do that, he says this will be a fundamental and a perpetual error that will end in disease, convulsions, and ultimately death itself.

Jesse WegmanYou know, he he does not mince words about how much he sees the threat of treating states as equals as opposed to people as equals. And so that's something he fights for throughout that summer of 1787. Obviously, we know because we live in this world, that he lost that fight. The other founders lost that fight too. The founders who were in favor of proportional representation, including James Madison, lost that fight. But he won many others and was really essential to the shaping of the country that we live in today.

Jesse WegmanSo the primary purpose that drove him forward, both through his whole life, but especially through that summer of 1787, which takes up the center of my book, is this idea of popular sovereignty, powerful national government based on the people?

Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd you referenced that Madison and Wilson are kind of these heavy intellectuals in the room. And we do hear some of this language coming from Madison about representation of the people to an extent. What was that relationship between Wilson and Madison like? And were they aligned on their thinking on what the United States should look like in the form of this constitution?

Jesse WegmanIn some ways they were, yes. Wilson and Madison were working hand in hand through a lot of the summer. They were very much aligned on the question of proportional representation. So he and Madison together are fighting for counting people as the fundamental unit of the building block of governance, shall we say. Where they diverged, Wilson was very much in favor of popular rule, as I said. He wanted people to be directly involved in choosing their lawmakers and choosing their leaders. Madison, I think, was a little more skeptical of direct popular involvement in government.

Jesse WegmanHe wanted more baffles, right, between the successive filtrations, as he calls it, to kind of translate some of the people's maybe less considered views into something that was more manageable and stable on a national government level. What's so interesting about this is that, you know, how I was saying earlier that Wilson did things or said things that got him into trouble with the people that he was promoting? You know, the pinnacle of this was that in 1779, this is eight years before the Constitutional Convention, Wilson's house is actually attacked by a large mob of militiamen who are armed and who are angry.

Jesse WegmanThey are upset about price gouging in Philadelphia. This is during the Revolutionary War. Uh, people are actually suffering, you know, they they can't get the necessities of life, bread and sugar and molasses, things like that. And they want there to be price controls. The government does not succeed in instituting those. And so they go after the elites of the city, right? They see them as the symbol of the all the inequality that they're suffering from. Wilson is obviously among that group, and his house is targeted.

Jesse WegmanHe barricades himself inside his house with two dozen of his friends, and this mob of up to 200 people marches toward his house, fighting breaks out, there's gunfire, seven people are killed. It is the most shocking riot of the revolutionary era. It becomes known as the Fort Wilson riot. Wilson himself barely escapes with his life and disappears from the city for several days before he's even able to come back. But what's shocking about that to me is that, you know, a man who experienced that kind of violence, firsthand violence, at the hands of a mob, you would think he more than anyone else might say, Oh, I think maybe I oversold my ideas on popular sovereignty.

Jesse WegmanMaybe the people shouldn't have as much access to power as I thought they should, right? Wilson would be, I think we would all forgive him for coming around and saying I might have been wrong. Instead, eight years later, he joins the Constitutional Convention and he doubles down on popular rule. He says, No, I absolutely think the people need to have that power. A majority of the people need to decide all the important questions. A majority should always, you know, win over minorities in government, right? That was his fundamental approach because that was the only way, majority rule was the only way you treat everybody as equal.

Jesse WegmanYou use any other system of counting votes or counting people, and you're going to treat some people as worth more than others. It's just, that's math. So to Wilson, it all fit together. And I think what was so shocking to me was that Madison didn't experience that kind of attack, and yet Madison had this sort of skepticism of popular rule. Wilson was attacked, and yet he was no less committed to it for that. So he spends that whole summer, as I say, arguing on behalf of people voting directly for their senators, voting directly for the president.

Jesse WegmanThat was how I discovered him in the first place, was that he called for direct election of the president, right? He didn't think it should go through some complicated system like an electoral college. He wanted direct election and proportional representation in the House. At every single step, he was fighting in favor of this government that was more based on people and more based on equality than any of his peers.

Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd you kind of alluded to this, but are there key kind of constitutional ideas or provisions that we can attribute to James Wilson that became included in the U.S. Constitution? And then are there key things that weren't included that he really fought for?

Jesse WegmanYeah. I'll tell you the three that immediately come to mind that are there that are because of Wilson. The first and the most explicit expression of his belief in popular sovereignty is the opening words of the Constitution. We the people. He put those words there. He did it actually during a break in the session in the middle of the summer. There's a 10-day break where everybody goes home because they've been arguing for two months over the, you know, just the shape of Congress and they still have the rest of the government to build, but it was such a fraught debate that it took them that long.

Jesse WegmanEveryone's angry at each other, they're tired, they're hungry, they're hot. They all take a breather. Wilson stays. He does not take a break for the entire summer. He and four other delegates form what's called the Committee of Detail. And in that committee, they pull together the first draft of the Constitution. So among his many other accomplishments, Wilson is the drafter. He writes the first draft of the Constitution. And in that draft, he starts putting things that were not necessarily debated in full on the convention floor. We the people, he puts in there specifically to invoke that ideal of popular sovereignty that the people are the foundation of government.

Jesse WegmanHe puts it there to link the Declaration of Independence to the Constitution. He sees the declaration as being foundational to, even supreme over the Constitution, which is a funny thing to hear today, right? Because the Declaration, we understand the Declaration for its soaring words of equality, right? But it's not a legal document, right? It's a statement of separation from Great Britain. It's a list of grievances against the king, you know, and parliament. It's not a legal, a binding legal charter the way that the Constitution is.

Jesse WegmanBut Wilson saw them as inextricably linked. He said, we have to have that spirit of the declaration at the beginning of the Constitution. So he puts the words, we the people, at the beginning of the Constitution to ensure that nobody is mistaking the states or the federal government or any other body of government as being the primary mover here. Another, there are two clauses that I just want to call your attention to. One of them is the necessary and proper clause. That's another addition that Wilson makes. This is a clause that is in Article I, which outlines Congress's powers.

Jesse WegmanCongress has a list of enumerated powers in Article I, right? And that's, you know, some delegates would have been happy to limit Congress to only those powers that are enumerated, such as, you know, the ones we know, the big ones, right? Being able to tax or make war or coin money, right? The jobs that a Congress should be able to do. But what the necessary and proper clause does is it gives Congress additional unenumerated powers to carry into effect all of those powers that it is given, you know, explicitly.

Jesse WegmanAnd that has the effect of expanding Congress's authority dramatically. It's a huge gift to the federal government. It really makes the federal government far more powerful than I think a lot of the people at the time wanted. And Wilson definitely gets in lots of fights over this because he sees a powerful central government as the solution to America's ills, right? America is about to collapse in the mid-1780s. They call this the Constitutional Convention is essentially an emergency resuscitation meeting.

Jesse WegmanAnd Wilson is insistent on these two principles that I've been mentioning: this idea of popular sovereignty, but this also this idea of a strong national government. And so necessary and proper clause. And then another one which is connected to that is the supremacy clause. The supremacy clause ensures that the federal government will always be supreme over the states. In a conflict between federal law and state law, federal law wins. Wilson did that too, and he did it again to make sure that you had this powerful central government that would make sure there was certain laws were uniform across the land and that there would be a stability and a consistency to our constitutional structure.

Jesse WegmanSo those three are the ones that I think are the easiest to flag. You said what didn't get in, the one that I'll mention is the one that I touched on a few minutes ago, which is the election of the president. Wilson comes out at the very beginning of the convention and he says, why is this even a debate? We should be electing the president by a popular vote. The people should be choosing the president directly. And that was a shocking thing for me to see because I thought, you know, I think we all, as people growing up in America and learning, you know, American history and taking our civics classes, I think the understanding was the framers were people who did not want people to be as directly involved in government.

Jesse WegmanAnd so the idea that there was one of these founders who was not only there in the room, but one of the central players in the room saying, no, the people should be directly involved. They should be choosing their president directly. That was a shock to me. Wilson loses that fight. Very few people join along with him. Although I will say James Madison comes around to agree with him in the middle of the summer. Madison speaks up in late July and says, I agree that a popular election would be the fittest way to choose a leader. He says it's not going to happen on account, he says, I'm a score of the Negroes.

Jesse WegmanAnd what he means is the southern states, the slave states, would not agree to have a popular vote because that would reduce their influence in the federal government because they had so many people in their states who were obviously enslaved and had no voting rights or any other rights to speak of. So that ended up being one of the decisive factors in killing the Wilson's push for a national popular vote. In the end, ironically, Wilson is the one who first proposes a system that looks very much like what we have today, which is the Electoral College.

Jesse WegmanHe comes up with it the day after his push for a direct popular vote is rejected. And it takes four more months, but at the end of the summer, the delegates settle on a system that looks almost exactly like what Wilson proposed and what we still use today, the Electoral College.

Katie Crawford-LackeyWilson's contributions, there are so many, and I didn't quite realize, one, who he was, but really how much he did for the founding of this country through many different key chapters. And your book I appreciated because it does break down these different periods where he is influential and what he is bringing to the table. You talked a little bit about his status during the 1770s through the 90s. Is he well known among his peers?

Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd if so, you know, why do we lose sight of him throughout history? Why has he become such a forgotten figure when, I mean, you talk about his contributions to the Declaration? And I mean, we the people, why do we not hear about this man?

Jesse WegmanIt's a good reminder of how much our stories are kind of baked in and that we've gotten used to telling the ones that we tell and not necessarily asking whether we're missing some. My discovery of him personally was I had that same feeling is how could I not know somebody who is so central to the nation's founding and whose ideas were so visionary? I think that's what's exciting to me about Wilson is that he could see the future of the country that we now live in so much more clearly than any of his peers. He saw a future more democratic, more egalitarian, more inclusive America with a clarity that none of the others did.

Jesse WegmanAnd I think that's exciting for me just because I realized, oh, these ideas were there at the beginning. You know, it's not like something that just, you know, came out of obviously there were centuries of struggle to get closer to that ideal, and many people have fought and died for those ideals. But Wilson was right there at the beginning articulating them, which is so amazing. The main reason that lost is in the lost founder in my title is because of his land speculation. So Wilson, soon after arriving in America, starts getting involved in the buying and selling of land, flipping land for profit, essentially.

Jesse WegmanThis is not an uncommon, uh, you know, it's a side hustle for a lot of the founders. George Washington does it. A lot of them are involved in it. Uh, it's just something when you have money that you do. Things haven't changed that much. But Wilson gets involved in it to a degree and with a kind of veracity that none of the other founders do. He's he's reckless in a way that I think shocks many of them. And he starts getting involved in ventures that are far beyond his capacity. So by the later years of his life, the late 1780s and into the 1790s, this is a time, by the way, when he is not only drafting the Constitution, but he's being appointed to the first Supreme Court by George Washington.

Jesse WegmanHe owns four million acres of land. Four million acres is a lot of land. And, you know, he's obviously, in order to own that much land, he's highly overleveraged. And it's what eventually brings him down. So when the economy goes south in the 1790s, the mid-1790s, Wilson's creditors come calling. He can't pay, he gets thrown in debtor's prison. Not once, but twice. Uh so Wilson is to date the only Supreme Court justice who has seen the inside of a jail cell.

Jesse WegmanHe gets thrown in jail in Philadelphia, and then a year later in uh New Jersey. And after that second jailing, he writes his son Bird. He says, Get me out of here, he bails him out, and then he goes on the run. And he escapes to coastal North Carolina, to a town where one of his fellow justices, James Iredell, lives, Edenton, it's called, and he hides in Edenton in a tavern, in the back room on the second floor of this tavern in Edenton for almost a year, avoiding his creditors, avoiding the authorities.

Jesse WegmanAnd that's where he dies in 1798, the summer of 1798, he has a sitting justice of the Supreme Court, basically in rags, delirious, destitute, and dying of malaria. So it's really a shocking and pathetic end to a life that had been so filled with glory and triumph in the years leading up to that. And all the more so because, you know, you asked, what was his reputation? In the earlier years, before that end, he was, I've mentioned, the most respected lawyer in America.

Jesse WegmanYou know, George Washington writes a letter to a friend in Virginia after the Constitutional Convention pushing for the ratification of the Constitution in Virginia, and he says Wilson was as able, candid, and honest a member as any in the convention. You know, it's ironic that he uses the word honest, right? Because honesty became a real problem for Wilson in the 1790s as he's kind of doing all kinds of funny business with money to try to keep his land empire growing and stable. But Washington, I mentioned earlier, had hired Wilson to tutor in the law, tutor his nephew Bushrod in the law.

Jesse WegmanUm Bushrod would eventually actually succeed Wilson on the court. He would take his seat after Wilson died and spend more than 30 years there. But it was just a measure of how much people respected Wilson that Washington would hire him of all people. Wilson gives a series of law lectures in the early 1790s at what is now the University of Pennsylvania. And everyone attended, right? Washington Adams, all the top leaders of the federal government, all the top leaders of the Pennsylvania government, everyone who was anyone was there. They all saw Wilson as the pinnacle of legal thought and analysis in the country.

Jesse WegmanSo his death in that kind of back room of the tavern is all the more shocking and upsetting. And yet by then, everyone was so sick of him. You know, he didn't have that sort of respect anymore. People were kind of relieved that he was gone. And so there's no state funeral, there's no obituary, there's almost no public mention of his death at all. And that is the primary reason for the loss of the lost founder. It's why we still don't know him today.

Katie Crawford-LackeyWell, Jesse, in reading your book and in trying to capture his life and the important parts of his life, obviously there's so much more to talk about. But as we conclude our discussion today, I want to ask you you kind of rediscovered, air quotes, if you will, James Wilson and his contribution to the founding and early years of the United States. In your opinion, why is he such an important figure for understanding our constitutional debates today in the 21st century?

Katie Crawford-LackeyWhat is his relevance?

Jesse WegmanYeah, I'd like to I'd love to just credit the people who have been aware of Wilson all along. It's a small group, but it's a mighty group. And it includes, first and foremost, William Ewald, who's a professor of law and philosophy at the University of Pennsylvania, and who has been writing about the history of Wilson's thought and his worldview for decades now, but so many others, John McKyle and Bill Trainer at Georgetown, and John Ganapp at Stanford, and Elamarr at Yale. Even the recently departed Gordon Wood, the Dean of American Historians, I think, understood and wrote about Wilson as being a really key figure in the American founding, you know, long before most other people were making that lane.

Jesse WegmanSo there are historians who've really been doing, I think, great work on Wilson, and I'm just helping to translate his life to a broader audience. I think what I find so important about Wilson for us today is, you know, he was tapping into ideas that are just as important to us today as they were then. These aren't ideas that faded away with time. You know, his emphasis on political equality has been with us from the start, and it has shaped so much of what America has become.

Jesse WegmanSo in the elimination of property qualifications to vote, say, in the elimination of slavery, in the expansion of the vote to women, half the population of the country, right, who couldn't vote when the country was founded, in the passage of the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act, in the reduction of the voting age to 18 with the 26th Amendment, all of these things, as you watch this progression, you see this expansion of democracy, this expansion of equality and inclusiveness that Wilson was anticipating 250 years ago.

Jesse WegmanAnd that to me is exciting because I feel like when ideas have that kind of purchase and that kind of persistence and longevity, it means they are deeply rooted in our souls. They are deeply a part of who we are as humans. And we know that people want to be treated equally, they want to have a say, an equal say in how they are governed. And Wilson, I think, embodied that from the start better than any other founder, despite his many contradictions, despite his complexities, despite his personal failings. But I do think that when we are talking today about a country that truly represents everybody and where everybody is equal, which is a, I think, in some ways, frighteningly, I think that's become a more live debate than I thought it was even just a few years ago, with a lot more people than I thought are, don't seem to be very much in favor of that sort of a government.

Jesse WegmanIt's all the more important, I think, to have someone like Wilson to look back to and to say the country was founded in an important part on these principles. These principles were there. They are part of the lifeblood, they're part of the civic poetry of this country, and they've been erased, I think, over time because the kinds of stories that we tell get a little overly simplified. They promote certain ideas over others. And I think that is a misrepresentation of our founding, and it doesn't serve us well in the present and looking forward into the future.

Katie Crawford-LackeyWell, Mr. Jesse Wegman, thank you so much for joining us on Consider the Constitution. And thank you for this wonderful book, The Lost Founder, James Wilson and the Forgotten Fight for a People's Constitution. It's a really fascinating read. I hope this conversation serves as a bit of a teaser so folks will go and learn more about what Wilson contributed. Um, again, we talk so much about Madison and his role, but it's really fascinating to hear how his thought process was influenced by Wilson.

Katie Crawford-LackeySo thank you so much for sharing with us today.

Jesse WegmanThank you. It's been a pleasure to talk to you.

Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd thank you to all of our listeners. Please subscribe and share the show with family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode