Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

Oct 21, 202635 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and again, their answer was education. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Mark Boonshoft, associate professor of history at Virginia Military Institute, where he directs the constitutional history program, and author of Aristocratic Education and the Making of the American Republic. They look at why the founding generation worried so much about schooling: Benjamin Rush’s call to turn students into “republican machines,” fears about young Americans studying abroad, and a national university that the first six presidents wanted and never got. Boonshoft also takes up the harder side of the story. Jefferson and Madison built the University of Virginia while the state’s common schools went without. The founders’ “aristocracy of merit” often kept power with the same people who held it before. And free Black communities who invested in schools saw their voting rights cut anyway. New York dropped the property requirement for white voters in 1821 and raised it for Black voters. Finally, what cadets at VMI learn from constitutional history: that citizens drive constitutional change, and that the Constitution is something built and kept up, not just read. As Boonshoft puts it, you can’t defer the maintenance on the republic.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

announcerWelcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackley and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.

announcerSmith Center for the Constitution and James Madison's Montpelier.

Katie Crawford-LackeyHello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey with James Madison's Montpelier. The ratification of the U.S. Constitution in 1788 established a framework for government. But a framework alone could not make self-government work. Americans still had to figure out what it meant to participate in this new political system and what citizens needed to know and do to sustain it.

Katie Crawford-LackeyThose questions quickly became connected to education. In the early republic, Americans debated not only what kind of government they wanted, but also what kind of citizen that government required and who should have the opportunity to become that citizen. Education, in other words, was a part of a much larger question about the survival of the republic. They had to ask themselves what should people in this new republic learn?

Katie Crawford-LackeyWho should be taught? And how could Americans with very different ideas and interests learn to participate in a system that depended on disagreement as well as cooperation? And that's where we're picking up today's conversation with Dr. Mark Boonschaft, an associate professor of history at Virginia Military Institute, where he directs the Institute's constitutional history program. A historian of early America, the American Revolution, and Constitutional History, he is the author of Aristocratic Education and the Making of the American Republic.

Katie Crawford-LackeySo welcome, Mark. This is a subject you know so much about. So very happy that you could join us.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftThanks for having me. I'm very excited to be on the show.

Katie Crawford-LackeyNow, as we get right into this, so once the Constitution is ratified, what did it actually take in practice to make this document work, to basically make it a government that functioned?

Dr. Mark BoonshoftYeah, it's a great, great starting question. And I know you want me to get to education, but I want to start with like a little bit bigger, which is to remind listeners that a document on paper is just a document on paper. And there's a lot to be sorted out after the constitution goes into effect. Some of that is the really obvious stuff. You've got to figure out how to hold elections for the, you know, the first Congress and for the presidency. You know, once that happens, you've got to set up cabinet departments and all of that kind of thing. But there's also getting people to buy in to the whole idea of being under a new constitution that, unlike the Articles of Confederation, puts a premium on kind of national attachment over state attachment.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftUm, the historian John Murren famously called the Constitution a roof without walls. Um, like, right, like they built the overarching edifice, but then you had to like put the pillars up so that the thing wouldn't collapse. So there's just a lot of things that are up in the air. And one of those things is when you go from subjecthood to citizenship as the basis for political allegiance, and you go from sovereignty resting in a monarch to sovereignty resting in the people, that puts a lot of pressure on the people.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftLike the, and you know, the famous quip that's probably overused, but is you know, Ben Franklin walking out of the Constitutional Convention, you know, what kind of government did you make? And republic if you can keep it. And right, when they're thinking about how do you actually keep a republic, their answer is education. In a really simplistic way, educated critical thinkers are not actually useful in certain kinds of governments. Totalitarian governments now, that means you're gonna question it. In certain monarchical societies, it was thought of as kind of a problem to have a population that was like a little too self-actualizing, too smart.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftBut in the United States, the thinking becomes: well, if everything rests with the people, so much is going to turn on elections, who they vote for, so much is going to turn on what's being publicly said in the press, what's being said in state houses and Congress, and how people are interpreting those things, that it would behoove the country to uh ensure that the people who have just been empowered as sovereigns have the wherewithal and have the skills and attributes to actually do the things you need to do to govern yourselves. Read, write, talk, comprehend, and so forth.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftSo, from a very idealistic perspective, this is sort of why Americans were obsessed with education in the 1780s, 1790s, and going forward and why it remains, I think, partly such an important part of our understandings of citizenship and voting and so forth.

Katie Crawford-LackeyYou mentioned several things just now that really made me think about this whole time period in a new light. The fact that, of course, this government needs buy-in. You know, yes, there was states ratifying it, but that does not mean that by and large, every single person was in favor. So the idea of the government being legitimate through buy-in from the people. And then this idea of people in the United States at that time went from, you know, before the Constitution, before the American Revolution, understanding themselves as subjects, subjects of the British Crown, to all of a sudden being citizens of a whole new country.

Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd that obviously does not just happen like bam, right after the Constitution is either drafted or ratified. That is an ongoing process. And so when we look at this time period, especially talking about the 1790s, as you referenced, so the years after the ratification, what specifically did American society believe a citizen needed to learn in order to participate in and sustain a democracy?

Dr. Mark BoonshoftIt's an interesting question. And I think one answer is the classic historian's answer, which is it's pretty complicated. Um, there's a lot of debate. And so on the one hand, right, there is actually an element of believing that the American Revolution, I mean, some people have argued it's like the last act of the Enlightenment or something like this. People in the United States in the 1780s and the 1790s are looking abroad and seeing advances, and and at home, but seeing advances in science, advances in literature, history, writing, and so on and so forth.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAnd so at some level, they don't have to recreate or reinvent the wheel. At some level, they're looking around and they're saying, like, you know, the Romans had a good idea about this, right, Ethan? And and maybe we should talk about the Romans and we should learn, you know, learn the classics, Latin and Greek, and so forth. What they call natural philosophy, but science, um, that this is an era of that, and that, you know, that's something that's important. When they they think about politics, I mean, James Madison thinks about politics as kinetic, right? That all the all the imagery, all the metaphors are physics, science kind of uh stuff.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAnd so this is not not happening in Europe. In fact, it's still remains, they're kind of actually self-conscious about how much of it's happening in Europe and not happening here. And so there's an element of, well, we know what good education is. And so for some people's point of view, it's just get it, expand it, right? Make it, make it more accessible, perhaps. Um, and that's that's one way of thinking about it. Another way of thinking about it is that you have to focus on particular skill sets and particular subjects that would be especially useful in a republic or a democracy.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftSo, right, you should learn American history, right? This is um many of your listeners may know the work of uh historian Michael Haddam, right? Like, this is an era of like expansion, expanded, expanded, expanded obsession with history and creating American history, like creating a version of American history that's not entirely just British history until 1776, um, that there is a deeper past. Um, and so that might need to be in uh in schools. Um, history of republics, right? Because um they're not, they don't tend to last very long.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAnd so cautionary tales are potentially useful. So, right, Roman history, Greek history, this kind of thing would be perhaps front of mind. Oratory, this is the age of oratory. My colleague Carolyn Eastman teaches at Virginia Commonwealth University. She's written tremendous stuff on just like the expansion of oratory, the importance of oratory, how much of a draw it was for people to go go see orators. And, you know, that is going to be useful in a governmental system that's based on persuasion. All that being said, there's a question of who should have this, right? How widespread should it be?

Dr. Mark BoonshoftWhat interests does it serve, and how widespread should this actually be? Or is there actually a point at which it becomes maybe a different kind of problem?

Katie Crawford-LackeyI think it's so interesting when we talk about citizenship and education. You know, you reference James Madison, and I think he is a fascinating retirement because he is somebody, obviously, that earlier in his political career, he is thinking very deeply about government, about what it means to be part of a government, how to sustain it. That's in part why we have the US Constitution as it is today. But then we see him later, after he retires from his second term as president, thinking about education and access to education, which is still pretty restricted at that point, at least at the university level.

Katie Crawford-LackeyHe is so devoted to it that he helps. Jefferson found the University of Virginia. Madison becomes first president or rector of that. In terms of what Madison's thinking, as well as some of his contemporaries, how important was formal education in preparing Americans for self-government? What did that education actually look like? Because again, Madison is so interested in and very dedicated to seeing informed citizens.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftYeah, this is a really, really good question. There's a famous essay written in, I can't actually remember, 1787, 1788 by Benjamin Rush, where he said schools need to be there to turn Americans into Republican machines, which is at some level, you're like, okay, you know, civic education. I mean, I guess what are we doing with civic education other than making Republican machines? On another level, machines is a kind of weird analogy for people. But I think what that gets at is there's a sense that the institutions you create are as essential as anything.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftThe extra-constitutional institutions and schools are chief among them. And part of that is because there's a worry about the wrong kind of education. To give you one example that doesn't make it sound so nefarious is Americans are actually really worried about study abroad. Nowadays we're like, oh, go abroad, right? This is the best thing you can do to become a worldly good citizen. The fear of study abroad in this period is like rampant. If American kids can't get an education in the United States and they go to France or England or wherever, they're going to get swept up in all this monarchical excess. And even if they're learning the right things, they're learning at the wrong place and from the wrong people.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAnd like that could be a problem. And so there's another example of how this kind of plays out, which is the first six presidents all wanted to create a national university. One of the kind of kookiest ideas for how to staff this was to just import the entire faculty from the University of Geneva. Um, because it saves you from having to find homegrown talent and all of this, and you know these people know what they're doing. But, you know, is that going to create a kind of American set of schools, set of institutions? And so what institutions you create and what they teach, that is fundamental, both because the ability to control what people are learning and also to make sure it's happening in the context in which these people live, right?

Dr. Mark BoonshoftThese kids are gonna grow up and live. Um, so my colleague at VMI, Zach Dybel, who's a friend of Montpelier, is finishing up a book on contests over knowledge in the revolutionary period. And like one of the things he's arguing is that at the sort of tail end of the British Empire's reign in North America, they're very worried about people learning the wrong things, right? That they are so far from England that they're actually learning this kind of vernacular American knowledge, and that is actually contributing to the tensions within the empire. And so you can kind of look at this and be like, oh, so like the Americans are like freeing up knowledge, and that is resulting in a revolution.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftBut what he points out is that then a lot of the founders run the same playbook, right? They want to curtail vernacular learning, and part of the impulse for institution building is if there is not legislative control or elite control through boards of trustees of colleges and academies and other types of schools, that people are just gonna get, they're just gonna learn wherever they can. And sometimes that means you're gonna learn from the wrong kinds of people and you're gonna learn the wrong kinds of things, and maybe they're gonna be a little too rowdy and so on and so forth. And so at one level, the impulse to build institutions is one that is part and parcel of wanting to build a constitution, wanting to build a Congress, wanting to build all of the structures that you need for Republican government.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftOn the other hand, it's also certain ways to limit kind of some autonomy about what one can learn and curtail who gets to decide what kind of knowledge is useful, right? Like that's useful knowledge is a very common phrase at the time. You define useful for me, I'll wait. Um they couldn't be, and there's debates about that. And so there is there's also a politics of um building institutions. And so you you brought up Jefferson and Madison and UVA in uh 1817, 1819, and into the 1820s when that's all taking place.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftWell, UVA is, as the great historian Andrew O'Shaughnessy has pointed out, one of the more forward-thinking types of institutions of higher education ever devised for its time in terms of faculty governance, in terms of curriculum, in terms of its sense of where religion did and really did not belong in the curriculum. It's also an institution that gets created with a limited set of resources that the state of Virginia had at the time, and in certain ways comes at the expense of building a public school system at the lower level, because Jefferson and others have to kind of make a choice about where to devote resources in a country that has fought a revolution, then fought the war of 1812, and is not exactly like flush and taxing is not exactly easy.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftSo you make a choice. And in from their point of view, all right, we make sure that the would-be leaders of the republic are getting an American kind of education. And Jefferson is, you know, and you can read Andrew O'Shaughnessy's book, it goes into excruciatingly beautiful detail of like how much Jefferson is thinking about this. But that also means that the ordinary people of Virginia, and ordinary people in this case would really be white boys, are not gonna get the kind of access they would have if they had devoted the same amount of resources to building what they called at the time common schools, but what we would think of as sort of like public elementary, public middle schools.

Katie Crawford-LackeyWell, Mark, you brought this up, and so I have to ask. So this national university, what can you tell us about that briefly?

Dr. Mark BoonshoftThere's another, I'm just gonna keep recommending books because I've got all these great colleagues who are writing all this great stuff. Uh George Oberly, who works at George Mason University, wrote a book called Creating an Informed Citizenry, and it starts with the debates over the national university. But it's this idea that like it's almost like a graduate school for would-be politicians. And I think at its best, it's thought of in the context of a much broader system of education that would be very like kind of what Jefferson envisioned in 1779, which is a sort of pyramidal kind of system, right? Free common schools at the bottom level to all boys, talented kids drawn from those would be able to rise through the ranks first to academies, sort of like high schools, to it's not a perfect analogy, but basically like high schools.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftThen, you know, the talented ones would rise again to what became UVA, University of Virginia, and then eventually you'd go to the national university. And so some of that access would be dependent on one's ability to pay, right? Like you could get in, but can you afford it? But there would also be sort of scholarship opportunities. And the idea was, as Jefferson put it, again, in one of these kind of things that cuts both ways, you'd rake from the rubbish the best. So it's not exactly the most uh positive view of his fellow Americans writ large, the rubbish, but the impulse to sort of find the diamonds and the rough, as it were, is one that takes very seriously like the idea of all people being created equal.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftIf all people are created equal, then talent is evenly distributed throughout the ranks of society. And so you're not going to reliably find the most qualified, the most meritorious, et cetera, if you just pull from the people who are already have the resources to get an advanced education. Um, and so a national university would then kind of be the top of that pyramid, a place for people from across the country who would be, would be leaders from across the country to come together, um, forge some sort of understanding, have some sort of common experience, um, and uh and and learn uh you know the skills of statesmanship and so forth.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftBut of course, you know, this is it didn't happen because it's highly contested, it seems like, to certain people, extreme federal overreach, um, even beyond the more famous examples, right? Like if you think about the Bank of the United States as something where where states' rights people were like, this is a kind of cabal of the federal government to like concentrate power and create like an elite. And that's like maybe an outcome that could happen from a bank, whereas that's the entire purpose of a national university. So it's a tough sell and it never happens.

Katie Crawford-LackeyWell, and based on what you're talking about, there's clearly, at least among the founders and this early leaders of the nation, that there's a certain type of person or there's an ideal citizen, at least as defined late 1700s, early 1800s. What does that look like? Who should be part of the citizenry that's participating in government?

Dr. Mark BoonshoftOkay, there's a cynical answer and there's a not cynical answer, right? The non-cynical answer is the most honorable, the smartest, the most disinterested and virtuous, that's who should rise, the most meritorious. Then the cynical answer is they get to define what counts as merit, and they get to define they being the people who are setting education policy to the extent it exists at a legislative level, or the people who are building schools through voluntary subscriptions and stuff, what we would think of as private schools, but these are at the time state chartered but privately funded.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAnd so the cynical answer is um the same people who were in charge before, but now you're just gonna launder their privilege through something that looks like merit, and so you can lay claim to uh some like deservingness or something. Right. So it's still gonna be white guys, it's still gonna be primarily people from sort of the middling sort and oh, and it's going to be people who just by definition, whose parents value that their kid get an advanced education at at some level, which is a self-selecting group.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAnd so in that sense, it's not all that different. Like the who is not all that different from what it might have been before. The how is is kind of what's changing, right? So if you're looking at Virginia in the 1760s, right, why are certain people gonna have power and certain people aren't? Well, certain people have wealth, certain people have standing, wealth translates to voting power, influence, where you sit in church, all this kind of stuff. Well, that's all kind of sounds a little too hereditary, a little too backward, a little too monarchical.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAnd so merit becomes the word of the day. So you hear people on all sides of the political spectrum, you'll hear Jefferson and you'll hear the Hamiltons of the world talking about the same thing. And you've got to create an aristocracy of merit, right? The idea that a situation in which you create some sort of equal opportunity, the best rise through those pathways of equal opportunity, and then the most meritorious are the ones who get to get the higher education and then get to have a claim on political power. But if you define academic merit through your mastery of Greek, if you define merit generally as having risen through the ranks of an education system that is not actually that equal, you have not really done all that much to equalize opportunity and to create those pathways and to change who's going to be in power.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftMoreover, you have not elevated people whose skill set actually necessarily corresponds to what ordinary voters want. So, I mean, I think it's great if our politicians can quote Cicero. I can't. It's lovely if there are good writers and good orators. It's also really helpful if they know how much gas costs and the regular things you have to deal with in life. And so the criticism of the education system that is created such as it is, system is probably way too strong of a word, is that it doesn't equalize opportunity, but it elevated the importance of academic merit to one's claims on power.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftThe result of which is it makes it even harder to argue against and oppose certain people when they're standing for office, but those people are gonna hold office and they're gonna be even further removed from the day-to-day concerns of most Americans. So there is a kind of bottom-up kind of opposition to this notion that representatives should be not representative of constituents, right? And that the the And the assumption of an aristocracy of merit is actually that the people who hold power are fundamentally not representative of their constituents.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftThey are they are the outliers. And that is a fundamental contradiction in American political life to this day, right? If the citizens rule, then should we just do election by law? Should we just pull everybody's name out of a bingo wheel? That'll get you a much more representative sample of America in the legislature. Um but we have not chosen to do that because we think that maybe we should be careful about who we pick. Um but there are downfalls of being careful about who we pick.

Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd this idea of self government that was really important, obviously, in establishing what is the United States that obviously requires citizens to participate. Which inevitably means that people are going to disagree. So, how did these early Americans learn how to disagree with each other without undermining the entire system that they're trying to build?

Dr. Mark BoonshoftI'm not sure that they did. Americans were deeply divided in partisan terms over politics, over various other social and economic issues. And sometimes that came to blows more often than we like, we like to remember. But you could I've to I teach a class uh that's just the early republic, but it's just through violence. It's like we don't actually And you can do that. You can cover 15 weeks of a college semester just talking about how Americans failed to settle disagreements peacefully and just took to clubs, sticks, guns, cannon, and arson.

Katie Crawford-LackeyThat sounds like another book.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftYeah, there's probably one in there, right? Yeah. Um but I mean, I think like at an ideal level, that's what this emphasis on education was supposed to create. The ability to kind of disagree rationally and productively and peacefully, and that like that is the essence of democracy. I think in practice, and it's not just because of education, but there are plenty of Americans who don't feel like the government the Constitution creates or their state, for example, is doing all that great of a job of representing what they believe. And if you don't feel represented in the institutions that are meant to enact the will of the people, then they have no legitimacy at all.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftIt doesn't matter if the people in the Senate are having rational debates, if you think there's no one in the Senate or no one in the House, or no one in your state legislature that actually represents your interests, right? That's kind of immaterial at that point. Like the government is failing to do what it a government by the people claims to be doing. So you can see that in the various agrarian rebellions. Like, I mean, before the Constitution, Jays' Rebellion, but yeah, after the Whiskey Rebellion, Frieza's rebellion, you can kind of go down the line this way. You can also look at Americans' inability sometimes to actually like live up to some of these ideals.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftIn your last question, you asked kind of like who's the ideal citizen, right? And I and I kind of was like, well, it's still going to be like a kind of a relatively elite white guy. That doesn't mean that there weren't people who still took them at their word, right? Took the founders at their word and said, okay, if education's the pathway, then let's focus on that. And that's what free black communities throughout the, especially in the North, do in the 1780s and 1790s, and certainly into the end of Madison's life when gradual abolition kind of comes due, and basically you have almost no enslaved people in the North, but you have large free black communities.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAnd so they're taking that wager. They are black communities and abolitionist societies are building schools left and right. I would venture, I mean, there's no real way to quantify this, but I would venture that per capita black Americans are spending more to create schools. They're also getting less state support for their schools, right? Where many states will develop school systems, but the funding will only go to white schools or something like that. So they're trying to take that wager, right? Trying to say, we're gonna do what you political leaders claim is the path to good citizenship. We're gonna take that at face value. And then often what happens is they lose their political rights the more they do this.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftUh so I think of examples in New York State is a good example where in 1821 the state rewrites its constitution and they take away the property qualifications that would have disenfranchised many white men, and basically every white, adult white man in New York can vote after that point. They raise the property qualifications on black communities. How do they justify it? Well, they say we can get rid of property qualifications because the population is now educated, right? We have built a public school system, it is reaching pretty much every white New Yorker, and we can now trust that the citizenry is an informed citizenry.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAt the same time, they say, uh, but black people have shown no kind of capacity to learn and to be improved through education. And so therefore, that justifies um increase in the property qualification. They probably have it exactly backwards. In fact, the school system that they build in New York is first tested out. It's called Lancasterian schools. They're a dumpster fire, but they all think this is the wave of the future. They're tested out. And first, the sort of proof of concept is the New York free school for black children in New York City. And then that's imported to every common school system in the state.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftSo, right, by their own lights, it's a bunch of hooey. In other places, you'll see so black voting rights will get taken away sometimes, often for political reasons, right? Black people vote the way they want to vote, and then it swings in a local election or something like that. This this happens in a couple of states. And so then those states restrict the vote from black people just for voting the way they think. That's not violent, but that's also not really agreeing in a peaceful and productive way. That's not respecting the ideals that they claim to value.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftUm, I'm not trying to give like a totally negative take on this, but I think there is a lot to suggest that if we're looking for a model of a group of people who can disagree productively and in good faith, that the early Republic folks they're not always going to be the most inspirational. And that, you know, continues through the Civil War. If you read books by Joanne Freeman, she has a book on congressional violence and the road to civil war and just how disagreement just breaks down fundamentally. Um and congressmen are just beating the crap out of each other.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAnd it's the the analogy is less Rome and more like the Philadelphia Flyers of the 1970s. Um, and uh it's a hockey game. It's uh you need enforcers and so forth.

Katie Crawford-LackeyWell, as we conclude our conversation today, I want to bring this discussion up to the present. So you, Mark, teach constitutional and American history at Virginia Military Institute. Where many of your students are preparing for military andor public service in some capacity. So, what does studying the constitution and history, constitutional history, kind of the broad arc of it all? What does that teach future leaders about their responsibilities, both as citizens as well as those who are really directly involved in, again, this public service?

Dr. Mark BoonshoftGreat, great question. And I think it's not the only school in the country that has a kind of constitutional learning requirement. We are, but very deliberately here, it's constitutional history. And that is to say it's not constitutional law. It's not just great documents, right? Where we're sort of telling us the story of how the American constitution emerged and developed and changed over time. And so that has a few knock-on effects that I think are very useful for our students, 65% of whom commission into the armed forces and so will be an officer at least for a few years.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftUm, many more of whom go on to careers in public service, um, whether it's kind of three-letter agencies or the like. One is that citizens matter. So, right, that that the citizenship is active, that constitutional change is something affected by people, not just immovable forces of history that you can't see. So, you know, I think a cynical view of the American constitution, constitution right now is that the amendment process is really hard. And that is true. The amendment process is super hard, and there have been thousands of failed amendments and 27 successful ones, and most of them are just in bursts after wars or something like that.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftUm, but the constitution, how what it means, how it is uh functions in practice, has changed tremendously over time. Who can really claim full use of the rights it guarantees and the privileges it guarantees, right, has changed over time through social movements, through politics, like great run-of-the-mill politics, sometimes persuasion, sometimes threats of force, unfortunately. And in those moments, that tends to backfire, right? And so, like, hopefully, what they learn from this course and what Americans generally can learn from thinking about how the constitution has developed over time is that if you're dissatisfied with how something's working, the constitution is actually kind of flexible so long as you can persuade enough Americans, and hopefully you do that the right way, to come around to your way of thinking.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftAnd that doesn't always mean an amendment, right? That could mean getting Congress to put its money where its mouth is, right? If you think about the Civil Rights Movement, what it actually results in in 1964 is the Civil Rights Act, and in 1965 the Voting Rights Act, which are laws meant to enforce the 14th and 15th Amendments of the Constitution. They are those amendments contain, you know, 14th guarantees equal citizenship to all Americans. The 15th guarantees that the right of to vote won't be taken away on account of race, color, or uh previous condition of servitude. They have enforcement clauses, the fifth clause of the 14th Amendment and the second clause of the 15th Amendment.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftSay Congress shall have the power to enforce this by appropriate legislation. They hadn't written the appropriate legislation for a long time. That's why we have Jim Crow for a long time, right? Congress is just not doing it. Well, comes, you know, you gotta get a strong enough movement that can sway enough Americans politically in the vote in the ballot box, but also in kind of cultural world, the larger social world in which everybody in which Americans live, and you get those laws passed and you get those provisions of the Constitution to be enforced, maybe not in full, but better than they had been before.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftThat's the story of how voting rights expand. That's the story of how we get something resembling equal civil rights in in the United States. It's not just a story about what the you can't begin and end with the text, even of the amendments, right? You have to you have to be able to understand what people are doing to make that kind of thing happen. And hopefully that kind of empowers people, makes people feel like they can they can make change. Um, the other piece about of constitutional history as opposed to constitutional law or or something else is where we started, which is that we think of a constitution as just a text, and the founders didn't.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftThey thought of it as constitutions is similar to construction. It's an edifice, it's an it's something that has to be built and maintained in in like a literal sense, right? Um you gotta you you can't defer the maintenance on the republic. And that means extra institutions that are not demanded by the constitution or that aren't even governmental can matter just as much. And so I may have been a little bit cynical about how schools function in the early republic in terms of actually realizing the ideals that the founding generation had about the role of education in a republic as a kind of extra-constitutional institution.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftBut if you're a VMI and you don't believe in that, like you're in the wrong place. Because, right, the entire purpose of this institution is creating citizen soldiers to serve American democracy and do lives of service. I'm I'm mangling the mission statement, and I please forgive me any uh any alums who are listening. But uh we exist to bolster the republic. Newspapers exist to bolster the republic, other colleges, K through 12 education system, non-governmental organizations, civil society organizations, Elks Lodges in the early republic.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftIt was Mason Lodges and debating societies. And um, I mean, there's a society for everything in the early republic. Uh society is stop bell ringing in your town because it's annoying. All of that is democratic. That's all democratic practice. That all builds, in theory, uh, the wherewithal to know how to make change, to talk with your neighbors, to do the things that I said early Americanists are not always great at, but they are sometimes in their own narrower spheres. Uh, all of that comes through if you think about the constitution historically. So you're telling the stories, even something that seems kind of silly, like the story of temperance and prohibition, and then the repeal of prohibition.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftWhere does prohibition come from? It's not just the social movement, it's civil society organizations, it's Americans joining together, it's doing democracy, it's building the American Temperance Union at the national level and building all these auxiliary societies at the local level, and then turning that energy, and in that story, women have a really, really important role to play, turning that energy into constitutional change and you get a damn amendment passed. And then, you know, people just keep drinking. And so, right, you know, you can change the constitution by um bootlegging uh and and uh you know, partying in a speakeasy, I guess.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftBut you know, the the point here is that if you're not so wedded to the text and you you want to understand, like you ask the question, not just what does it say, but why does it say it and how did it happen, you get a very different view of how constitut how the American Constitution works, how it's developed over time, and what role ordinary citizens have to play in its maintenance and evolution.

Katie Crawford-LackeyWell, that really resonates. This idea that it is active democracy and participation in it is an ongoing process. And that's something that we're all a part of. So thank you so much, Dr. Mark Boonschaft, for being with me today and for recording this episode. I think it's really important that we understand the kind of this arc of education, especially as we continue this democratic experiment today. So great to have you.

Dr. Mark BoonshoftThanks for having me, and thanks for everything you and your colleagues do at Montpelier to preserve history and teach the story of the Constitution.

Katie Crawford-LackeyYes. And this podcast is one piece of that. So thank you also to our listeners for subscribing. I hope you'll share the show with family and friends and tune in again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. You Compromise on Politics, Not on Principles

    Sep 9, 202634 minAudio

    We know James Madison the thinker. The architect of the Constitution. The author of the Bill of Rights. But Madison was also a working politician - and a very good one. Dr. Matthew Goetz, senior historian at the White...

    Credit the people on this episode