We know James Madison the thinker. The architect of the Constitution. The author of the Bill of Rights. But Madison was also a working politician - and a very good one. Dr. Matthew Goetz, senior historian at the White House Historical Association, joins Katie Crawford-Lackey to look at the side of Madison we tend to skip. With Jefferson, he built the country's first political party and its first partisan newspaper - then wrote attacks on the Washington administration under a pen name and admitted he found the work grating. Goetz also makes the case for Madison's most overlooked chapter: the War of 1812. The first wartime president in American history never passed a sedition law, never arrested a newspaper editor, and never considered postponing the election. You compromise on politics, he believed. Not on principles. Along the way: a weasel, a mole, and a set of measurements sent to Paris. A deathbed offer Madison turned down. And why the messiest parts of American politics may be exactly what makes the system work.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
announcerWelcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackley and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
announcerSmith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
Katie Crawford-LackeyHello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey with James Madison's Montpelier. There's a version of James Madison that we know particularly well. He's this constitutional thinker, the author of the Bill of Rights, and one of the central figures of America's founding. But Madison is also a politician, and looking at that side of his career gives us a different picture. He's deeply engaged in partisan politics, he's building political alliances, negotiating, compromising.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd he had to navigate the gap between political ideals and political realities. So in looking at Madison in practice rather than simply as a political thinker, we can tell a great deal about how he's understanding and building constitutional government. And to explore this side of Madison, I am joined from afar by Dr. Matthew Goetz, who is the senior historian and the Maryland Sexton Chair in White House History at the White House Historical Association.
Katie Crawford-LackeyMatthew earned his PhD in American history from George Washington University and has taught at George Washington, Georgetown, and the United States Military Academy at West Point. His scholarship has appeared in White House History Quarterly and Washington History Magazine, among other publications. Matthew, thank you for joining us all the way from Washington, D.C., calling in. And I am here in the studio at Montpelier. So it's great to have you virtually join us.
Dr. Matthew GoetzThank you. I'm really excited to be here.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd a lot of your research focuses on James Madison. So, you know, at Montpelier, which you visited, Matthew, we talk about Madison a lot in context to the Constitution and to the Bill of Rights and obviously his presidency. But if we expand our focus beyond this, what else do we discover about Madison? Or phrase differently, what do we discover about him when we look beyond those achievements that we so often focus on?
Dr. Matthew GoetzEven with all of those accomplishments that you just listed, the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, the presidency, James Madison is still one of the least remembered of the founders compared to Washington, Jefferson, Adams. He gets very little historical or public recognition or attention. I think part of that reason lies with just his temperament. He was not a very naturally gifted public speaker. He was very tiny, both in uh height and weight. In fact, one of his colleagues said that he was no bigger than half a bar of soap.
Dr. Matthew GoetzHe was very shy in big group settings, which is tough for a politician. He could be painfully shy to the point where he could come across as rude or cold. He was very humble. He was often fine being in a supportive role of people like Washington or Jefferson, or at least making them think that they were in the lead when he, in fact, subtly nudged them in the direction that he wanted. He was very good at that. And he was not a very snazzy dresser. He wore the same plain black suit every single day. There's a really funny quote from one of his contemporaries who said that with his plain black clothes and with his dour disposition, Madison looked like a country schoolmaster in mourning for one of his pupils who he had whipped to death.
Dr. Matthew GoetzSo, in other words, he doesn't fit our modern mold of what we think of as a great historical figure or political leader. But I think a larger part of why he's forgotten, somewhat or overlooked compared to the other founders, comes down to the way that we typically teach or discuss the American Revolution. We often describe it as a staged production, a story where you have clear lead characters at certain times. Each founding father takes turns with their sort of moment in the sun before they pass the baton to the next founder who becomes the main character, and so on and so forth.
Dr. Matthew GoetzTypically, stories of the revolution start with John Adams in Boston. He's there for the Boston Massacre and Tea Party. Then in the summer of 1776, Jefferson takes the lead briefly when he drafts the Declaration of Independence. Then George Washington becomes the main character, he leads the American Army to victory during the war. And then only very briefly does James Madison become the main character. In the summer of 1787, he seemingly comes out of nowhere to draft the Constitution. And then he very quickly recedes into the background.
Dr. Matthew GoetzAnd George Washington re-emerges as the main character during his presidency. That way of teaching the revolution is perhaps inevitable since we need to have a way to teach it in a sort of simple story that people can understand with the focus on individuals. But it has an unintended consequence of giving people like Madison short shrift when he only really has one moment in the sun with the Constitution. And that's unfortunate because if you look at Madison's entire career beyond just the Constitution, you realize that he's actually one of, if not the most important figures in early America.
Dr. Matthew GoetzWashington is often called the indispensable figure in the revolution, without whom it would have failed. But I think you could arguably give that title to James Madison as well. He's there for the entire story, often in leading roles. So he's at the Virginia Assembly in 1776, the same assembly that then writes to the Continental Congress, urging them to declare independence. He then serves in that Continental Congress during some of the bleakest but most crucial years of the Revolutionary War, and he's recognized as being one of the leaders in that Congress.
Dr. Matthew GoetzEven during Washington's presidency, Washington often gets a lot of credit for establishing the early government framework through his precedence. But it's actually Madison who's in Congress during this first Congress under the Constitution. He's the recognized leader of Congress. And it's him who actually ushers in all these laws that helps create the framework of the government. He passes the first Ten Amendments, the Bill of Rights. He passes a bill that creates the departments of the Treasury, State, and War, basically the framework for the modern executive branch, and he negotiates the bill that creates DC as the early capital.
Dr. Matthew GoetzSo he's so crucial in this early time period, and yet he's so often overlooked. But more than simply being there for the entire revolution and being in the leading role, Madison is indispensable because he, arguably more than any other founder, was able to take the high-minded ideals of the revolution, ideas like liberty, self-government, religious freedom. And he's able to then turn those ideals into reality, without which the revolution would have failed. He, you know, all the high-minded ideals in the world mean very little if they're not codified into law effectively, else they prove effervescent and fake with time.
Dr. Matthew GoetzAnd it's Madison more than any other founder who's able to do this. He was an excellent politician, far more so than the other founders. And I don't mean that as an insult, actually as a compliment. He was a great politician. He excelled at the nitty-gritty politics, the sometimes ugly, unsavory aspect of politics that we often look down upon today in our own hyperpartisan times, but without which none of the achievements of the revolutionary era would have been possible.
Katie Crawford-LackeyWhat an astute observation in terms of how we tell the stories of the founding, the history of it all, that there's this kind of central character that we look to who's the main focus of that story. And I like how you kind of explained it as, you know, there's this one main character, John Adams, and then Thomas Jefferson emerges and so forth. Madison, what a great description of him, his clothing. And I don't think that uh image will ever leave my mind as this like schoolmaster.
Katie Crawford-LackeyBut that does matter when you're kind of in these circles that he's navigating. Beyond this kind of intellectual prowess, again, you know, you noted he emerges as kind of this leading figure, very short period of time, 1787 for the Constitutional Convention, which is behind closed doors, though. So it's kind of still a small group of people that are seeing him in that capacity. You know, we we know that he's this intellectual thinker, but beyond that, and and you kind of noted this already, what is he bringing to this role of politician?
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd, you know, he's you said he's navigating this kind of nitty-grittiness of politics. How is he doing that, particularly being so introverted and quiet?
Dr. Matthew GoetzSo he definitely, as you've said and as you notice on this podcast previously in previous episodes, he's definitely a philosopher and an intellectual, right? He's very comfortable in those circles. He's often paired with Jefferson in discussions of the revolution, which makes sense. They were both allies, they both agreed on a lot of political issues and outlooks. But it's actually Jefferson, more than Madison, who earned the reputation of a philosopher. He's very commonly described by his contemporaries, both his allies and critics, as being sort of having his head in the clouds.
Dr. Matthew GoetzIt's actually Madison who his contemporaries recognize as far more grounded, a more practical politician, still engaged in Lostini philosophy for sure, but was more concerned than Jefferson with what was actually practical. If you look at the correspondence between Jefferson and Madison, there's so many instances where Jefferson will suggest some new idea that he has based on his reason and his philosophical thinking. And then it's Madison who has to write back and very gently will bring him back down to earth. Say, oh, that's a great idea, Jefferson, but I don't know if that's really practical or do you really think that's a good idea?
Dr. Matthew GoetzSo he's sort of grounding Jefferson in these philosophical debates. But part of what made Jefferson and Madison such effective allies is that Madison was able to put these ideals that they shared into practice. There's a really good story that's symbolic of this relationship, where Jefferson is in France serving as the U.S. foreign minister there. And while he's there, he's engaged in a debate with a few French scientists who have this theory that's very widespread in Europe at this time amongst intellectual circles. And the theory is that because of the climate of North America, animals and humans living there tend to degenerate.
Dr. Matthew GoetzThey say if you compare the size of animals and humans in North America to Europe, they're all smaller. So it must be something with the climate that degenerates them. Jefferson wanted to refute this idea, so he enlists the help of Madison, who's still in the United States at this time. Jefferson writes to Madison and asks him to take measurements of various animals from North America and send the measurements to him so he can use them as evidence in this debate. And so Madison actually goes out, gets his hands on a weasel and a mole, and he takes the measurements of these animals head to toe, all detailed measurements, and then he sends them back in a letter to Jefferson.
Dr. Matthew GoetzThere's so much symbolism in that story there of Madison and Jefferson together engaging in this very intellectual debate, but it's Madison who's actually getting his hands dirty, literally in this case. And you can say the same with politics. Not to say that Madison didn't engage in philosophical or intellectual thinking of his own. He certainly did, but his superpower was blending those ideals with practical politics and codifying them into law.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd Matthew, can you talk about Madison being involved in partisan politics? How is he, I guess, participating in that? Not just, you know, he's not on the sidelines. Again, I think we tend to see Jefferson as the one who's kind of blazing the trail in terms of politics. But as you noted, Madison is doing a lot of the groundwork. So when we think about especially the Constitution as an example of principled political thought, how is Madison getting in the weeds with that and putting that into practice?
Dr. Matthew GoetzMadison is deeply involved in partisan politics. You're absolutely right. And he's a very effective party politician. He, with Jefferson, founds the first political party in the U.S., the very confusedly named by today's standards Democratic-Republican Party. It's opposed to George Washington's policies as president. With Jefferson, he founds the first partisan newspaper, a partisan media organization in the country, the National Gazette newspaper. And then Madison recruits its first editor, a friend that he knew from college. Madison also drafts several articles and essays himself, always under a pseudonym, but these articles attack the George Washington administration for policies that he disagrees with, very partisan articles.
Dr. Matthew GoetzIt's worth noting that Madison didn't enjoy being a partisan warrior. He actually found it somewhat unsavory. While he's writing these articles criticizing President Washington, he writes a letter to Jefferson and he says, I have forced myself into the task. I can truly say that I find it the most grating one I have ever experienced. So he doesn't enjoy this. He also doesn't, as a rule, he doesn't like political parties. He's opposed to them in theory, like the other founders. He thinks they're potentially fostering disunity and that they can be abused by foreign powers that want to meddle in American politics.
Dr. Matthew GoetzSo he doesn't like political parties in theory. But he quickly realizes, far quicker than the other founders, that political parties may be necessary evils in a republic like the United States. They can be very effective at keeping voters engaged, educating them, marshalling support for to pass legislation that you support or marshalling public support against legislation that you oppose. His support for political parties also stemmed from his understanding that politics in a representative government meant more than just a bunch of elite politicians behind closed doors wheeling and dealing.
Dr. Matthew GoetzThat happened. There was a time and place for that, like at the Constitutional Convention. But if you were a politician who held your nose up at the public masses and you didn't engage with them, you were doomed to failure, according to Madison. But if you found a way to marshal the public support, even through political parties or partisan tactics, you would find success. But for Madison, it's important to note that political parties were a means to an end. They weren't the end in and of itself. Success to him was enacting policies that you agreed with, not just electing your party or your people.
Dr. Matthew GoetzAnd in your question, you mentioned the Constitution specifically, and how can we square the partisan politics that Madison practiced with the principal political thought of the Constitution? But it's worth noting that the Constitution was a product of hard-nosed politics, including the kind that Madison excelled at. Even getting to the convention and convincing every state to send delegates to the Constitutional Convention required immense politicking, very skilled politicking by Madison and a few others. He had to convince various important figures around the country to attend the Constitutional Convention, including Washington, who didn't want to.
Dr. Matthew GoetzHe was happy being in retirement. He didn't want to come out of retirement to go to the convention. But Madison realized that without Washington there, any sort of constitution that they came to an agreement with would risk not being ratified by the public. So Madison worked very hard to subtly encourage Washington to attend, and he had to use a lot of clever political tricks to get him there, including finally appealing to Washington's sense of history and the importance of his reputation. It's also worth noting that the constitution that they did come to an agreement with at the convention was a work of political compromise.
Dr. Matthew GoetzIt's only in hindsight that we think of it as this sort of divine document that came down from on high. It's actually a work of hard-nosed politics and compromise.
Katie Crawford-LackeyWhat a, I think, fascinating and nuanced way of looking at Madison, the founding, and I think it's almost a commentary on America Today, too, where theory, Madison's thinking, you know, party politics maybe not be the best, but in reality, this is a way where things are going to get done. As you said, it's a means to an end, but not the end itself. And it's, I think, an example of his practical nature. Again, kind of this theme that we've been talking about today, where Madison is again an intellectual.
Katie Crawford-LackeyHe has these ideals, but at the same time, he's a very practical person, practical politician, perhaps more so than some of his contemporaries. And then, of course, this piece of engaging with the public, acknowledging perhaps there's a time and a place for this more confidential, kind of behind closed doors policy making. But the engagement with the public being key. I don't think it needs to be one or the other. I don't think Madison was one or the other.
Katie Crawford-LackeyI think you've just demonstrated he's both. He's both, you know, this intellectual with ideals, but he's also very much somebody who is a politician. And I think compromise, and this is something your research focuses on, is a part of what he's trying to achieve as well. And can you talk about if there's a difference between compromise as Madison is understanding it and the way we tend to use that word today?
Dr. Matthew GoetzWell, in some ways it it's similar in that Madison understood that politics is the art of the possible, as they say. Or to use another phrase, never let perfect be the enemy of good. Madison believed in this principle, and so according to that, compromise was really important to him. Political compromise did not come easily to Madison or nationally to him. He had to struggle to embrace this. Even the Constitution, he initially disagreed with. After months of negotiations, the constitution that the convention agreed upon, Madison thought was inadequate.
Dr. Matthew GoetzHe said it creates far too weak of a central government. Many of the propositions that Madison puts forward are rejected. There's a historian named Forrest MacDonald who calculated that Madison put forward 71 different proposals at the convention, and he lost 40 of them. So over half of his ideas were rejected. So Madison is initially dejected. But he quickly realizes that it's far better, for all its flaws, it's a far better government than the previous governing system known as the Articles of Confederation, which he sees as being far too weak.
Dr. Matthew GoetzIt's part of the reason why there's so much chaos and what he sees as mob rule in the United States in the 1780s. So to Madison, he recognizes the Constitution isn't perfect, but it's a step in the right direction. Maybe a half step, but that's still better than no step at all. And so not only does he come to agree with it, but he then endorses it and publicly supports it and of course writes the Federalist papers to encourage Americans to ratify it. Another example of where politics, yes, it's all about behind closed doors and negotiations, but then you've got to marshal public support for it.
Dr. Matthew GoetzWithout Madison writing the Federalist papers, Americans may not have ratified it, right? He also engages in debates in Virginia, his home state, over the ratification. So he not only comes to terms with it and says, okay, this is an acceptable compromise, but he also then actively campaigns for it. But with Madison, when you're discussing compromise, it's important to note that to Madison, you compromise on politics, not on principles. There are some things to Madison that you can't compromise over. And you see that very clearly when you look at his leadership as president during the War of 1812.
Dr. Matthew GoetzIt's unfortunate that the War of 1812 is one of these forgotten conflicts in American history. And even when you do discuss the War of 1812 or when you do hear about it, Madison very rarely factors in as any sort of leading character, which is ironic considering he's president during the time. But maybe the only time you hear him discussing it is the embarrassing episode when the British burn the White House and he has to flee. But it's a shame because his leadership during the War of 1812 is actually one of the sort of unsung aspects of his legacy, I think. One of the things he does is that during the entire war, he's the first wartime president in American history.
Dr. Matthew GoetzAnd he never endorses or passes any sort of anti-sedition legislation, even though many of his advisors are urging him to do this. They are pointing to actions of many Americans that are at best borderline treasonous, if not fully treasonous. A lot of Americans are still trading with the British during the war, or they're selling food and equipment to the British military. You have the famous Hartford Convention where a bunch of Federalists, the opposition party, meet in Hartford, Connecticut, and they debate having New England secede from the United States because of their opposition to the war.
Dr. Matthew GoetzBut Madison never gives in to this pressure. He never orders any arrests for sedition. He never harasses or arrests any newspaper editors for criticizing the war effort. There's no internments during the war like there would be in subsequent American wars. Nor did he suspend the 1812 election. I think this is a very important point. This is the first wartime presidential election in American history. Now we take it for granted that we hold elections during war. We did so during the Civil War, during World War II. But this is the first time, and Madison never seems to even briefly consider the idea that they would suspend the election because of the war.
Dr. Matthew GoetzI think that's a testament to this idea that you compromise on politics, not on principles. To Madison, the War of 1812 was a fight for liberty against what he saw as a tyrannical monarchy in the shape of the British. And so for the government to then infringe on civil liberties in the name of national security would have been to compromise the very principles that he saw the United States as fighting for.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd what an important precedent Madison is setting in that moment, the War of 1812. You know, he's leading by example, and the fact that these are rights and civil liberties, he's keeping intact. And as you said, it's not even a consideration to suspend the election or the Sedition Acts. Is a real testament, especially as America is in unchartered waters. It's still trying to essentially prove itself legitimate in the eyes of the world.
Katie Crawford-LackeySo that is really an important chapter in American history and Madison's history that deserves more attention. That distinction, so, and when we think about Madison in all these different capacities, you look at his career. He's pragmatic, he's got this party politician in him as well, but he's willing to compromise. So, you know, you were kind of describing Madison in context of the War of 1812 and what that says about him. As we look at him in this broader context of his whole life, his whole career, what can we understand about how he envisions and then is putting into practice constitutional government?
Dr. Matthew GoetzMadison understood that in a constitutional government, politics is incredibly messy, even ugly, but that's okay. It's inevitable. That's how it's always been in every single republic throughout history. That's how it always will be. There's a great book released recently by historian Dennis Rasmussen called Fears of a Setting Sun, where he looks at how every founding father became incredibly disillusioned by the time that they passed away. They all seemed to be incredibly fearful that the United States' experiment at self-government had failed, and they went to their graves basically incredibly pessimistic about the future of the country.
Dr. Matthew GoetzEvery founder, except for Madison, Rasmussen points out that Madison maintained optimism even well into his later years. He always maintained a confidence that the United States would overcome its problems. He certainly had his anxieties about the United States and its future, but he never lost this sort of optimistic view of the country's future. And part of that explanation is that Madison was less sentimental than the other founders, more clear-eyed perhaps about human nature. He famously says in the Federalist Papers: if men were angels, no government would be necessary.
Dr. Matthew GoetzSo he recognizes the fact that in a government of men, politics is going to be messy. And that politics would be ugly, but that doesn't mean that politics and government couldn't still produce good, noble results. There's a great story from Madison's later life that shows this sort of lack of sentimentality and more uh sort of real politic view of the world that Madison had. He fell he falls ill in June of 1836. His doctors recognize that he was not long for this world. And so they offer to keep him alive artificially with stimulants until July 4th so that he can pass away on the same day as Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, and James Monroe.
Dr. Matthew GoetzIn fact, the only ex-president at that point who hadn't died on July 4th was George Washington. So his doctors say, hey, wouldn't you like to be part of this category? Think of the symbolism. You know, we can keep you alive until July 4th, or we can try. But Mazdin refuses. He doesn't want to dull his faculties in his final days. So he refuses these stimulants. And in fact, he dies on June 28th, a few days before July 4th. I think that's a great story to sort of acknowledge that he's a little different than the other founders, right? He cares less about symbolism and sentimentality.
Dr. Matthew GoetzHe's more uh clear-eyed about human nature.
Katie Crawford-LackeyWe had Dennis Rasmussen on our previous seasons who talked about his scholarship in that book. And it was very eye-opening to hear about not just what these great men achieved, but then what they're thinking in the aftermath and what maybe regrets they had or things they they wish would have gone better. And it is kind of a testament to Madison that he has this very realistic perception of life and government. And I don't think that that's something that ended when his presidential term ended, when he decided to retire.
Katie Crawford-LackeyHe came back to Montpelier. So, what does Madison's later political career, but also his retirement, reveal that we might not see in the conventional founding narrative? You know, how is he continuing to shape or engage with American political life even after he's out of public office?
Dr. Matthew GoetzHe has a very long retirement. His presidency ends in 1817, but he lives until 1836. So he has almost two full decades of retirement. But during that time, he still engages with politics and current affairs. He stays up to date, he still maintains a correspondence about these kind of things. And if you look at his correspondence from his retirement, you can see that the issues he focuses on reveal some of his anxieties for the country. I mentioned earlier that he, of course, he maintains a very optimistic stance on the long-term future of the United States, but he does see some signs of worry that he thinks Americans need to address.
Dr. Matthew GoetzAnd for him, in his retirement at least, he focuses more on two issues that particularly worry him. And the first is slavery. Of course, Madison is a slaveholder himself. He's surrounded by slaves his entire life and Montpelier. As a young politician and as president, I think it's safe to say he tries his best to basically ignore the issue of slavery. He understands how divisive and potentially explosive it is. He sees it as sort of a distraction from other issues that he needs to focus on as a politician. But from his retirement, he allows himself to think a little bit more about it.
Dr. Matthew GoetzAnd he ultimately came to the conclusion that slavery presented a conundrum, both for himself and for the United States. On the one hand, he knows that slavery is wrong, but he thinks there's no way to peacefully end it without risking economic ruin, political upheaval, and maybe even violence. And so it left him a bit paralyzed. He didn't end up freeing any of his own slaves, though he did end up endorsing publicly the so-called colonization movement, which is the idea that we can free slaves if we then send freed blacks to Africa, the quote-unquote back to Africa idea.
Dr. Matthew GoetzSo in his dilemma on slavery, you can see this sort of conundrum facing the entire early US regarding slavery, and not only Madison's individual shortcomings, but also the shortcomings of his entire revolutionary generation. The other issue that he focuses on in retirement is education, particularly the problem of how do you have a republic where the people govern themselves if the people were not informed or educated. So he lives long enough, well into the Jacksonian era, he sees the expansion of voting to large groups of the population that don't have property or land.
Dr. Matthew GoetzBut then he worries what happens when you have these voters who don't have an education. There's a great quote from Madison where he says, a popular government without popular information or the means of acquiring it is but a prologue to a farce or a tragedy, or perhaps both. So he worries about the United States without a good public education system. So from his retirement, he helps Jefferson found the University of Virginia. Then he serves as one of its trustees, and eventually he serves as its president. With Jefferson, he hires faculty for the school. He designs the curriculum, and he even with Jefferson picks reading lists for students.
Dr. Matthew GoetzI love the idea of Jefferson and Madison together picking the books and pamphlets that they want their students to read to understand political philosophy and politics. I think what two better people to pick a reading list for to understand politics? So those are the two issues in his retirement. And you can see the two things that do worry him about the future of the United States.
Katie Crawford-LackeyYou know, Madison being the oldest of his siblings, he's going to inherit this very large plantation. And there's at the time about a hundred enslaved people here. So it's very much a part of his personal reality, as you noted, as well as this political reality. And, you know, towards the end of his life, as you were describing, you know, he can't even physically move about. His manservant and slave man named Paul Jennings is physically carrying him around, shaving him, feeding him, all of this.
Katie Crawford-LackeySo just a very tangible example of he's so reliant upon the institution of slavery in a personal capacity. And this point about education, I think, is an enduring one to one that today we ask these same questions and have these same concerns. And from what you've taught us today, Matthew, we gather that Madison is a man that was deeply committed to principle. But he also understood politics as a process of negotiation, of coalition building, conflict, all of that.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAs we look at him from, you know, today, from the present, what would you say, as an expert on Madison and his life, is his most enduring legacy?
Dr. Matthew GoetzOf course, there's many specific achievements you can point to, none more so important than the Constitution. He's often referred to as the father of the Constitution. But the historian Richard Brookheiser has an excellent biography of James Madison, where he says that we should call Madison the father of politics, meaning he helped create our very political system and our way of doing politics. I think that's his perhaps greatest legacy. Madison showed how politicians can use politics, sometimes even less savory aspects of politics, such as partisan media or hard-nosed negotiations, to achieve noble ends.
Dr. Matthew GoetzIt's very easy to criticize our current political system as dysfunctional, and of course it definitely has become more and more dysfunctional. But if we look at the last 250 years over the long time span, it's actually remarkable to chronicle all of the amazing achievements that American politics has produced, sometimes through the exact kind of hard-nosed politics that Madison practiced and using the same methods and procedures that he helps create. You don't even need to look any further than the issue we just discussed, slavery. One of Madison's failures in his own life, you could say. But slavery was abolished 30 years after Madison's death via the Thirteenth Amendment.
Dr. Matthew GoetzThe amendment process, of course, being one, a mechanism created by Madison. And if you know the process of how the Thirteenth Amendment became law, or if you've seen the film Lincoln, which is basically about this idea, about this process, you'll know that it took some less savory political scheming and politicking, but it was put towards more noble ends. So to answer your question about what is his ultimate legacy, I say that Madison stands as a reminder of the greatness that government can achieve when those in power adhere to the principles displayed by him. Hard nose politics, put towards lofty goals, mixed with a willingness to compromise under the belief that impartial progress is still progress.
Katie Crawford-LackeyWell, this conversation has been really enlightening, at least for me, Matthew. It reminds me that constitutional government hasn't been in the past and isn't today simply about having the right ideas or even designing the right institutions. It's really about human nature. And in your words, it's messy. It's the messy work of politics, of compromising, about listening to each other, about having different ideas, but to what you said earlier. It's not about changing your principles.
Katie Crawford-LackeyYes, politics is one thing, but sticking to your principles is another. So, Matthew, thank you for helping us see Madison as a little bit different, a different light than we typically look at him. Not just about this great thinker or architect of the system that we have today, but somebody who is deeply entrenched in defining what that process, the political process, looks like. That's been very insightful.
Dr. Matthew GoetzWell, thank you. It was my pleasure.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd hopefully we'll get to welcome you back to Montpelier sometime soon.
Dr. Matthew GoetzPlease, yes.
Katie Crawford-LackeyWell, thank you to all of our listeners for tuning in. Please share the show with family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...