The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Rosemarie Zagarri, professor of history at George Mason University and author of Revolutionary Backlash: Women and Politics in the Early American Republic and The Politics of Size: Representation in the United States, 1776-1850. They trace the shift from subjects of a king to citizens of a republic, and how each state wrote its own answer to who could vote, who could hold office and who belonged. Zagarri shows how much politics happened outside the ballot box. Women boycotted British goods, wore homespun and drank herbal tea in protest. Some formed their own Daughters of Liberty. In New Jersey, women and free Black people who owned enough property could vote from 1776 until 1807, when the legislature took that right away. And she untangles the three-fifths compromise, and why counting people instead of places was a radical idea at the time. Finally, what the founding era tells us today. Voting is essential. But citizenship has always been bigger than the ballot: petitioning, protesting, writing and speaking out. As Zagarri puts it, that’s how change happens.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
announcerWelcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lack and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
announcerSmith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
Katie Crawford-LackeyHello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, with James Madison's Montpelier. When the Constitution was drafted in 1787, it began with three words that would come to carry enormous weight. We the people. But who did Americans in the late 18th century understand the people to be? And what did it mean to participate in the political life of this new nation? Those questions were far from settled.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAmericans were moving from life as subjects of a monarchy to citizens of a republic. And while women, enslaved people, and many others who could not vote or hold office still found ways to engage in political life, there were some who did have these new freedoms established in the Constitution. So today we're exploring how Americans in the early republic understood citizenship, political participation, and belonging, and how those ideas evolved.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd joining us today in the studio at Montpelier is Dr. Rosemarie Zagari, a professor of history at George Mason University. Her work focuses on the history of women, politics, and citizenship in the early United States. She is the author of several books, including Revolutionary Backlash, Women and the Politics in the Early American Republic, and The Politics of Size, Representation in the United States from 1776 to 1850.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd her scholarship explores how women and other Americans shaped and were shaped by the political culture of the early Republic. So what a wonderful guest to have with us today. So welcome, Rosie. Oh, I'm so happy to be here, and thanks for having me. Now, the Constitution, as I noted, begins with some very powerful words. Many of us know this. We the people. Now, rewind the clock. Late 1700s. So right as the Constitution is being drafted and ratified, what do Americans in this newly formed nation understand that phrase to actually mean?
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriI think there's many ways to go at this, but I think the most direct way is to understand the shift from the Articles of Confederation to the U.S. Constitution. And the Articles of Confederation, which were written during the American Revolution, coming out of Americans' experience with Great Britain, put a primacy on the autonomy of each of the states. And in the Articles of Confederation, which were in operation from the time of independence through 1789, the basis of government was the states.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriAnd what it meant was that each state elected a certain number of representatives to Congress, but each state got only one vote in Congress. The state legislatures were the ones who voted for the members that were sent to the Congress. And so ordinary people did not have a direct say in any level of government at the national level during the revolution and immediately after, not until the U.S. Constitution.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSo, in one very important sense, we the people refers to the shift from the Articles of Confederation form of government to the Constitution where the people and the states are the basis of government, not just the states. And so that is one level of it. At another level, I think which is very important, in the revolutionary period, we have a shift from a monarchical form of government to a republican form of government. And what I mean by that is that during the colonial period, each colony had its own legislature.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriEligible white males in those colonies elected the lower houses of their colonial assemblies, but the colonists had no representation in parliament. But what joined all the colonists was their allegiance to the king. The king, the monarch of England, had given each of the colonies their charters, and the colonies really regarded themselves as separate from one another, not really having much to do with one another except that they were all on the North American continent.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriTheir allegiance was to the crown, their dealings were with London, with the king's ministers, with the representatives that they had who unofficially lobbied parliament for them, with their merchants, with other people in England. And remember, travel over land was very difficult at this time, so it was much easier to travel overseas and to know what's going on in England. So the connection with England rather than with the other colonies was very strong. Each of the colonies had slightly different forms of government.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThey were settled by different peoples at different times for different purposes. And so there's a very strong tradition of state autonomy at this time. So again, that's one reason why in the Articles of Confederation, the states rather than the people were represented. But what this also means is that when you shift from a monarchical to republican form of government, you shift from having the king or the crown as the protector and guardian of the subjects to the people as the basis of government.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSo in a Republican, and I mean small R, Republican form of government, it's a government based on the consent of the governed. And it usually means that some group of people, and that phrase is very loaded, who are the people who get to do the electing of the representatives, but some group of the people elect representatives to the legislative assemblies. And so we the people means that this is a Republican form of government in which the people have a direct say at some level in the governing of their national government, not just their state governments.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd one of the things I hadn't fully understood or appreciated until familiarizing myself with your work is what a shift in mindset that would have been for people in America, particularly these framers who are drafting the U.S. Constitution. They're growing up in a world where they understood themselves as subjects to the British Crown. And I am wondering if you can talk more about how that concept of citizenship moving, as you said, from the crown being the protector to the people being the foundation and leading this government.
Katie Crawford-LackeyHow did that evolve after the ratification of the Constitution?
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriWell, I'd first like to say that actually the concept of citizenship starts to evolve in the states during and after the revolution and with the writing of the first state constitutions. And one of the things that's important to recognize is that people became citizens of their states, but they were also citizens now of the United States of America. So this opened up just a huge array of questions. Who was a citizen? How did you belong?
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriWhat rights adhered to being a citizen? And today we think about citizenship mostly in terms of voting and holding public office. And at this time, citizenship was a broader category, and we need to contrast that with the idea of being a subject of the crown. Everybody who was born in Britain or the colonies was a subject. And privileges and rights were endowed by birth, like if you were an aristocrat, or by wealth if you were wealthy, and they were unequally divided among the people.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriCitizenship was a more leveling kind of concept. Everyone was equal before the law. But the Americans then opened up another can of worms because they had to decide exactly what it meant to be a citizen. And in the period after and during and after the revolution, different states made different choices about who could vote, what qualifications you had to have for voting, who could hold public office, what religious qualifications were required.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSome states still had establishments of religion. So the states varied really widely. And so one of the important things to understand is that from becoming a subject to a citizen, Americans were having to redefine what it meant to be a member of the polity, who belonged. And I want to emphasize that this was a very fluid and evolving notion that you can't just say, oh, this is what it meant, because it varied from state to state.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriIt varied immensely even over the course of a few years from the time of the revolution to the ratification of the Constitution. You get the first U.S. naturalization law in 1790. And so that's the first time that we have a law that says that foreigners can be made citizens of the United States, and you had to be free and white, okay, which is an interesting qualification. But even that was very different from state to state.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThere still were other requirements in different states for naturalization before that. And so it's it's a very complicated process.
Katie Crawford-LackeyI love how you describe that. As you said, it's evolving. And as you noted, when we think about political participation in this period, primarily in terms of voting and holding office, you know, that's kind of where our mind goes. But it's so much more than that, as you said. So when you think about your own research on women in the early republic, it's shown that women were politically engaged in many ways, including through petitions, political organizing, print culture.
Katie Crawford-LackeySo as we understand this today, what this looked like in this early period, how should we broaden that understanding of what it meant to participate in political life in the new nation?
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSo I think it's really important to understand that both in England and America in the 18th century, there was an understanding of the people as a political force. And, you know, in England in particular, most men could not vote as well as women. In the colonies, it varied from colony to colony, but in many colonies there were substantial portions of white men who could not vote. And yet that didn't mean that they felt disenfranchised because they could use different kinds of political methods to voice their concerns and their ideas and their grievances to their legislatures.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSo this meant that there was a lot of political protests, there was a lot of organizing at the local level, there was a lot of specifying, there was a lot of transmission of ideas through pamphlets and newspapers, and there was a lot of just oral talking people to one another. And what happens in the period that say, you know, years after 1763, after the French and Indian War, to the time of the revolution is as resistance to British policies grows, American political leaders, male political leaders, realize that in order to be most effective in making their case against Britain, they had no representatives in Parliament.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThey couldn't vote for representatives to Parliament. They were far away, so they couldn't organize outside somebody's house and mob their house. But what they could do is use the economic tools at their disposal to organize boycotts. And they knew that boycotts against British merchants would be a way of applying economic leverage that might be effective in making their concerns known. They did, Americans did send petitions to the Crown and to Parliament.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThey did especial grievances, but they knew that they had to put teeth in what they were saying. And they knew that these boycotts to be effective needed the participation of both nonvoters and voters, women as well as men, and women especially, because women were often the primary consumers of the family. And so what you see happening in the period of the 1760s and 1770s is this revolutionary movement actually opens up new opportunities for women to participate in politics in new ways.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSo some women, some elite women, like a woman I've written about, Merciotis Warren, actually start writing pamphlets and satirical plays and poems expressing their grievances against Great Britain and lambasting Great Britain for their policies. But an even larger number of women start participating in these boycotts. In other words, they don't buy British goods. They're joining with their fellow colonists and not purchasing goods from Great Britain. And this is so important because the colonies purchased 40% of all the goods that were exported from England.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriAnd so if political leaders could get women on board to not buy their goods from Britain, then they could more effectively make their point. It would be a more successful boycott. And what kind of things did women especially like to buy? Well, cloth of all sorts, linen, wool, fine wools, tea was very important, all sorts of china and silver and mirrors and lace and buttons, feathers.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSo it was really important that women buy in to this protest movement. And what's really important is that we know this was happening because we see essays printed in newspapers, we see appeals and broadsides to women, where white male political leaders are saying we need the support of women to make this a success. They actually reach out to women and empower them to join this political movement. And women respond.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriAnd we know that in some towns and cities, women got together and they actually formed their own groups that were analogous to the male Sons of Liberty. They call themselves the Daughters of Liberty. And some of them wrote their own petitions and signed their own agreements not to purchase British goods. This is especially the case in a place called Edenton, North Carolina, where you have a wonderful petition from women joining in the boycott. But some of the women agreed to make what we call homespun.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriInstead of purchasing British textiles or goods imported on British ships, they made their own cloth. And this was not the case anymore. More and more goods were being purchased rather than made at home. So making homespun and wearing homespun cloth, which is often of much lesser quality than what you could buy from Britain, was a sign of patriotism. So women actually wore their political views on their bodies. They actually started growing their own tea and drank herbal tea instead of tea imported on British ships.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThe tea, I should note, is usually from China, but it's imported on British ships. And so the British are not able to sell their tea to Americans when women especially aren't buying it. And so they're finding all sorts of ways to feel involved in the success of this protest movement. And I will say this changed women's idea of themselves. They started to feel that they had a political contribution to make, that they had a political role to play, that even though they couldn't vote or hold public office, that they were important to this protest movement.
Katie Crawford-LackeyI love learning about how people, particularly women in this case, even though they didn't have the same political power as maybe men did, they're still leveraging their place in society to have a say. And I want to return to one thread that we touched on earlier, specifically regarding women and voting rights in the revolutionary era. So, for example, in New Jersey, some women voted for a period after independence only to lose that right in the early 19th century.
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd that's not the only case where this has happened. So, can you tell us what's going on there? Like how are women in this state able to vote and why is that being taken away? What does that landscape look like?
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriOkay, I mean, this is a wonderful story that I think more people should know about. And there's a wonderful website at the Museum of the American Revolution that uh has a big exhibit on this, complete with primary sources. So in 1776, the Second Continental Congress asks all the people in the states to write their first state constitutions. And in these new state constitutions, uh people in the states have to decide who can vote. Okay, this is part of defining what it means to live in a republic.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriAnd um some of the states lower the property qualifications for voting. Now I want to point out at this time, voting is not considered a right. It's considered a privilege of property. And in England and in all the colonies, you had to own a certain amount of property to vote. So voting is not yet considered a right, but in the New Jersey state constitution, it is said that inhabitants who own a certain amount of property are allowed to vote.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriAnd they use that what we would call gender-neutral language called inhabitants. Okay. What happens in New Jersey is very interesting because in 1790 and in 1797, the New Jersey legislature actually passes laws describing voters and who could vote in more specific terms, and they refer to voters as he and she. So we know that there's no ambiguity in using what we would call the gender neutral term of inhabitants.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThey are deliberately enfranchising women, and women are voting in New Jersey. But which women? Okay, because of the laws of coverture at this time, which meant that once a woman married, she did not own her own property. The only women who were enfranchised by the New Jersey law were widows who owned a certain amount of property and unmarried women who owned a certain amount. So it wasn't a huge number of women, but was it was enough women to attract attention. But I should also point out that as I said before, voting is considered a privilege, and a privilege is something that can be given and taken away.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSo the legislature had given women this privilege of voting, along with free blacks, I should say, who met the property qualification. Well, as you can imagine, this was extremely controversial at the time. There was all this debate, and we know this debate in the newspapers, from pamphlets, back and forth about whether women should be voting, whether women who voted were manly women, how women who were voting would soon be putting on their breeches and going to Congress.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThere was just a huge public debate about the merits of women voting. And I should say that women in other colonies were aware of this. Abigail Adams knew about women voting in New Jersey, and she says, ah, if I could vote, I would too. So this was an experiment, and it's a fascinating experiment because what does it do? It takes that revolutionary principle of no taxation without representation and applies it to people regardless of gender or race.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSo it says any inhabitant, black or white, male or female, who pays taxes or has a certain amount of wealth in New Jersey is allowed to vote. So it's a really consistent application of that revolutionary principle. So what's going on here though is, as I mentioned before, Americans kind of opened up a can of worms when they became a republic or 13 republics. And they had to decide who belonged and what rights were attached to citizenship.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriAnd so New Jersey pursued this avenue. It was so controversial that in 1807, the New Jersey legislature voted to retract that right to take away the vote from women and free blacks, and they allowed only free white males, very specific, free white males to vote. Now, what's interesting here too is that new states coming into the Union and other states that were just rewriting their constitutions started to adopt the same gender and race qualifier.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriWhereas before they could afford to be vague and say Freeman. Or freeholder or taxpayer. Now, more and more, they were putting gender and race qualifiers on the franchise, free white men.
Katie Crawford-LackeyThis is, I think, a really good example of how, as you noted earlier, this is an evolving concept. And state by state, we're seeing this applied differently over time. And thinking about the constitution and some of the compromises that were made during its drafting, I want to talk about representation and slavery, including the three-fifths clause and the system of apportionment. So, how did questions of political representation intersect race and slavery?
Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd what does that reveal about tensions built into this new constitutional system?
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriOkay. So when you get to the Federal Convention in Philadelphia in 1787, Madison proposes a new system of government for the United States. And this government, instead of just being built on the states, is going to be based on the people and the states. And he wants people, and that's a vague term that has to be defined, to have a more direct stake in this new government. Now, what's important to understand is the difference between apportionment and voting.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriOr apportionment and the franchise. The Constitution, the US Constitution, punted on the question of voting. They left it up to each state to decide who could vote and what the qualifications were. That's why you could have women voting in New Jersey from 1776 to 1807. But the question of apportionment is the question of how people would be represented in the lower house of Congress, the House of Representatives.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriAnd so the people, however the states decided, the group of electors would elect their representatives to Congress. The Senate would be appointed by the state legislature. So we're talking about the lower house of Congress, the House of Representatives. But the question is, what should be represented or whom should be represented? In the colonial period and in Great Britain, the tendency was that the practice was to represent communities.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSo in the colonial period, in Virginia, for example, each county, regardless of the number of people in that county, received the same number of representatives. In South Carolina, you had things called parishes, and each parish received the same number of representatives. Americans looked to Great Britain and they saw the extreme abuse of this problem because you had what were called rotten boroughs. You had places being represented that had no people, but they still got to send a representative to parliament.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriWhat was happening in the colonies is that you started to get vastly disproportionate numbers of people in these different towns or counties or parishes. So a county on the east coast of Massachusetts might have, you know, 10,000 people, whereas an interior county might have 2,000 people, but they would each get the same number of representatives. So one of the ideas coming out of the revolutionary ferment of this debate over equality and rights is the idea of equal representation, that the same number of people should get the same number of votes.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThat seems so obvious to us today. It seems so obvious that we take it for granted. We call it one person, one vote. But that was just emerging first in the state constitutions and then in the U.S. Constitution. So it's very important to recognize how radical this idea was for the time. And so what this means is that when the framers of the Constitution were thinking about how to structure representation in Congress, they had to think about not only who could vote, which they punted to the states, but who was represented and how many people.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThey ultimately decided that there would be one representative for every 30,000 people in the states. So that meant that states with more people would get more representatives. Again, we find that to be, of course, that's the democratic principle. This was a new idea at the time, this idea of proportional representation or representation based on population. What you have in the Senate with equal representation of states is that older concept of equal representation of communities of people.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriAlong with that, which people do you count? Which people do you count? Now, in a lot of the state constitutions, you had a wide variety, but some state constitutions only counted taxable inhabitants. Some counted all inhabitants, but others counted those paying taxes. So you had a variety of practices in the states. But what the U.S. Constitution did after much debate and angst was decided that all inhabitants should be counted and that three-fifths of other persons, which was just a circumlocution to refer to slaves, should be counted, and Indians not paying taxes should not be counted.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriSo that was their decision. All inhabitants, so that actually includes women and children. Men, women, and children were counted when deciding how many representatives each state should get. In a sense, you could say women were virtually represented, even though they couldn't vote. Now, this is where the tricky part comes about the three-fifths compromise, as it was called. What this was a reference to was a huge debate over the northern states didn't want the southern states to be able to count enslaved people at all.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThe southern states, because they knew it would give them more representatives, wanted their states to be counted. The compromise was that taxation and representation would go together. So if the southern states got more representatives by counting their enslaved people for their represented population, they would also have to be paying more taxes. So the North felt that they got some concession there. The Rob is also with the three-fifths figure, which some people take as meaning that black people, enslaved people counted only as three-fifths of a person.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriIt is certainly true that at this time, many white people did not regard black people or enslaved people as equal to whites. At the same time, many white people did understand black people as human. And they didn't believe that black people were three-fifths of a human. What the three-fifths refers to was a very rough calculation on the part of these delegates, desperately trying to come up with a compromise to make sure that they could get a viable document that could be approved by the people.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriThis was a compromise that acknowledged that black people do not produce as much wealth as free white laborers. So I just like to point out that it, while it is an extremely demeaning resolution, and in the long run, it did mean that the slave states did get greater representation in the House of Representatives than they would have if only the free white population had been counted, it still was a very complicated kind of process.
Katie Crawford-LackeyDr. Zagari, I appreciate you kind of breaking that down because it is more nuanced than just what it looks like on the surface of three-fifths of a person. There's a lot more behind that. And yes, you know, it translated into political power for southern states. And the point about we understand it differently today than what they were taught, the context in which they were operating. I want to bring our conversation as we wrap up to today, as we look at debates over citizenship and political participation in the early republic.
Katie Crawford-LackeyWhat can we understand in 21st century America about the way we understand and apply citizenship? How are we as Americans taking the lessons of the past and applying it to how we're participating in the system today?
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriGreat question. Well, I'd first like to make the point that this debate about who was a citizen and what rights they had was evolving continually over the course of American history. And what we see is a progressive broadening of the rights of political participation in terms of voting. So we know that in the early 19th century, the vote expanded to include nonpropertied white males, and then after the Civil War to include black men as well as white men, much to the chagrin of the first feminists.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriOkay, and we know that in the 20th century, women received the vote. But I think what has happened along with that is that there's a narrowing of our conception of what citizenship means. And that is that, you know, we shouldn't discount the importance of these other kinds of non-electoral participation. And by that I mean everybody should vote. But I think that what the women of the revolution show us, even what free blacks show us, what non-white males show us in the period before they could get the vote, is that ordinary people have political means at their power, petitioning the government, protesting, writing for newspapers, publishing their views, speaking out that help shape public opinion and put political pressure on those in power.
Dr. Rosemarie ZagarriAnd that's how change happens. And so while voting is now essential to citizenship and so important in determining the balance of power within legislatures, I think we should recover the importance of these non-electoral means of affecting the political process.
Katie Crawford-LackeyThank you for speaking about how we all have a say. You know, those of us who live in this country, whether or not, you know, we have this definition of citizen, if we are a citizen or not, we live here. And there are ways to participate in our communities and our country. And it's not just limited to voting. Yes, voting is such a critical right that many, many groups have fought long and hard for. But it's empowering, at least in my opinion, to hear about all the ways that we can affect change beyond that. So thank you, Dr.
Katie Crawford-LackeyRosemarie Zaghari, for being in the studio with us today. Thank you. Keep up the good work here. And thank you to all of our listeners. Please subscribe and share the show with family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...
We know James Madison the thinker. The architect of the Constitution. The author of the Bill of Rights. But Madison was also a working politician - and a very good one. Dr. Matthew Goetz, senior historian at the White...