In this episode of Consider the Constitution, host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey and Professor Kendra Johnson discuss the Fourth Amendment, which focuses on aspects of privacy. The interpretation of the Fourth Amendment has evolved with technology, with cases involving wiretapping and cell phone searches setting precedents. Professor Johnson discusses the historical context of the Fourth Amendment, its impact on everyday life, and its potential future implications, particularly concerning advancing technology and privacy concerns.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. One of the rights many Americans think of is the right to privacy. Though that word privacy actually never appears in the Constitution. On today's episode, we're exploring the Fourth Amendment, which certainly focuses on aspects of privacy. The Fourth Amendment contains just 54 words.
SPEAKER_02So I'll recite those words to get us oriented. The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures shall not be violated and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized. Our guest speaker today to help us consider the Fourth Amendment is Professor Kendra Johnson. Kendra Johnson is currently pursuing a Master of Laws at Howard University.
SPEAKER_02She previously joined the faculty at Liberty University as a visiting assistant professor of law in 2021. Before joining the law school faculty, Professor Johnson practiced law in various courts throughout Hampton Roads, Virginia, primarily as a criminal defense attorney. She also had the privilege of clerking for the Honorable Henry Koch Morgan Jr., senior judge for the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. Professor Johnson has deep ties to Montpelier as one of her ancestors was Benjamin McDaniel, who purchased his own freedom prior to the Civil War after being an enslaved driver and courier for James and Dolly Madison.
SPEAKER_02Kendra, welcome to Consider the Constitution.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Katie. I'm excited to be here.
SPEAKER_02Now to start us off today and give us a little background, Kendra, if you could, I'd like to orient us to the historical aspects of the Fourth Amendment prior to James Madison's making and proposal of the Bill of Rights in 1789. So can you set the stage for us prior to 1789 when Madison proposes what becomes the Bill of Rights, which includes the Fourth Amendment?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. I'm sure from previous podcasts, I know you guys have had one on the Bill of Rights, that you've discussed a little bit of the context. So we had this government and this kind of battle between the states and wanting a more limited federal government versus a broad federal government. And kind of the way to balance that became the Bill of Rights, right? So how are we going to make sure that the federal government doesn't become this overreaching government? And one of the things that was proposed were these bill of rights by the states.
SPEAKER_00So we have the constitutional convention that happens, and the states are submitting what they propose to be these bill of rights, these rights that are going to be ensured protection from the federal government. And the Fourth Amendment comes as part of that. So the context specifically for the Fourth Amendment dealt with this concept of general warrants. So at the time that the colonists are proposing these amendments, there were these general warrants that could be issued by the king. And they were very broad and they were very reaching.
SPEAKER_00They could stay in place for as long as six months and they were not limited in scope. So the Fourth Amendment is really proposed as a way to limit the scope of the government's ability to search and seize property. And that's where we get the language of the Fourth Amendment.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. So it sounds like folks like James Madison are reacting to the reality of their times, with the King, as you mentioned, being able to issue these warrants that are, it sounds like not very detailed, not very specific, lasting up to six months.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And what's interesting, the language that's adopted that we know as the Fourth Amendment now was actually different from the proposed test, just slightly. Now we know the text to say the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures. The proposed text that was part of what James Madison introduced actually said the rights of the people to be secured in their persons' houses, papers, and property from all unreasonable searches and seizures, which is interesting because that actually ends up being significant in a later court case that interprets the language of what does effects mean versus all property.
SPEAKER_00So slightly different there and what's adopted, but largely very similar and largely responsive to limiting the scope. So the scope limiting part of the Fourth Amendment ends up being that second half, which talks about warrants that have to particularly describe the places to be searched or the persons of things to be seized. So they really want to ensure that if the government is going to search someone's home, that the government has had prior authority by a neutral and detached magistrate, and that that warrant that they have is limited in scope and it's particularly describing the things to be seized.
SPEAKER_02So what you're describing, it sounds to me as if the Fourth Amendment is an example of how the founders are trying to protect the rights of the people, which, as we know, is really kind of this challenging balance they're trying to strike in drafting the Constitution.
SPEAKER_00Yes, absolutely. Absolutely. So it's it's one of our earliest examples of limiting that overreach that they're concerned about and assuring the people that their rights are going to be protected in light of the fact that we are establishing this new government and making sure that that new government doesn't mirror what the old government was in breadth.
SPEAKER_02And as we proceed through the decades and centuries, how is the Fourth Amendment playing out in the lives of Americans? How is it being interpreted by the courts?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so it's really interesting, and I think I'll take it starting with the language. So you have kind of two components of the Fourth Amendment. The first component of the Fourth Amendment deals with unreasonable searches and seizures. And I think a lot of people are aware of that. It protects me from unreasonable searches or seizures, which you've mentioned, privacy, which we'll get to, because that's an interpretation that actually happens quite later on in the interpretation of the Fourth Amendment. But broadly, we're talking about unreasonable searches and seizures.
SPEAKER_00So the first part of the Fourth Amendment is really discussing, okay, we want to make sure that whatever reason that the government is choosing to search this property or seize these persons, that it's just reasonable generally. The second part of it deals with the no warrants shall issue. Now, what's interesting about that language, it says you can't be unreasonably searched or seized. And then the second part gets into no warrant shall issue, which raises a question of whether a warrant's actually required under the Fourth Amendment, which is interesting because the courts never really said that a warrant is required under the Fourth Amendment.
SPEAKER_00You kind of have justices taking different positions on that. Some justices will say, like, you know, a warrant is required, but really other justices will say, well, the broad standard here is reasonableness. It just has to be a reasonable search. So that's kind of where we are now. It's got to be a reasonable search. The best way for it to be a reasonable search is if there is a warrant and we want a warrant. And so you'll hear justices say things like, a warrantless search is per se unreasonable, subject to a few limited exceptions. So even though we want a warrant and having a warrant is something that usually ensures the reasonableness of a search, it still has to be executed properly, has to be within the scope of what's described in the warrant.
SPEAKER_00But if you don't have a warrant, the court doesn't say, okay, that's an unreasonable search or seizure. They just say, okay, does it fall into some sort of exception by which a warrant might not have been required in that particular situation? So we have just broadly, that's how the language of the Fourth Amendment has been interpreted, that there's this requirement that all searches and seizures be reasonable. And then that there's the best way for those searches and seizures to be reasonable is if law enforcement has a warrant before they search or seize your home or take your property. But if they don't have a warrant, then there's still the potential that it's considered a reasonable search or seizure if it falls into a certain exception under the Fourth Amendment.
SPEAKER_02So it's not a legal requirement for the government to have a warrant in order to search your house?
SPEAKER_00Not in all cases. Like I said, there are very limited exceptions. And those exceptions kind of depend on what's being searched. There's those categories in the Fourth Amendment: persons, houses, papers, and effects. The category that probably receives the most protection under the Fourth Amendment is the home. And if you think about it just practically, the reason why the home receives so much protection is because, you know, a person's home is their castle. We've heard that. Everybody's heard that. A person's home is their castle.
SPEAKER_00And uh so before law enforcement or the government enters into your home, typically the court's gonna say, for home searches, we almost always want to see a warrant. And there are very, very few situations in which the court says you can go into somebody's home without a warrant. One of the situations where the government can enter your home without a warrant is say, for example, somebody has just committed a felony and they're fleeing and they run into the house and the government's pursuing them in the midst of having just committed that felony, that's gonna be an extenuated or exigent circumstance in which law enforcement is gonna be permitted to enter the home.
SPEAKER_00So it's things like that or an emergency situation. For example, there might be law enforcement outside the home and they could hear screams and somebody shouting, I'm gonna kill you, and they're hearing something very troubling inside. They might be able to enter the home in that situation because really it's reasonableness at the end of the day. And that's a situation where the court would say, okay, it's it's reasonable for them to not have to go get a warrant if somebody's life is immediately in danger.
SPEAKER_02And I would think most people would want law enforcement to intercede in that kind of situation as well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it's very, it's very common sense. Um, well, I'll say there's certain certain times where the amendment has been interpreted that's not really common sense or doesn't seem like common sense. But those types of situations are very general and common sense types interpretations where most people would probably want law enforcement to be able to intervene without having to run and grab a warrant in that situation. So that's an example of a warrantless search that's going to be permitted under the Fourth Amendment. That's one of the ways it's been interpreted. To get to your earlier point about privacy, we've got a line of cases that are interpreting the Fourth Amendment up until the 1960s.
SPEAKER_00So this is this is how recent it's been. There's a case called Cats versus United States that's decided in 1967 that really introduces the idea of privacy-based rights for a person with regard to the Fourth Amendment. So before that case is decided, your view of when like the government has committed a search of your property, right, or is very property-based and property-focused. So to give a contrast in the case law, this came up because of technology. And technology honestly ends up being one of the ways that the Fourth Amendment is becoming stretched in ways that we never thought was possible.
SPEAKER_00Because when our founding fathers were drafting the Fourth Amendment, they were in carriages and, you know, there weren't telephones and the internet or phones that serve as computers. None of those things existed. So when technology begins to change, the law begins to change with the technology. So there was a case that was decided in 1928. The case was Olmstead versus United States, and it's a wiretapping case. And what happened at Olmsted is that the government, they wiretapped somebody's phone and they listened in on that person's conversation and they retrieved those conversations.
SPEAKER_00So they engaged in conduct that, you know, if you're a citizen, you're thinking, did they search this person's telephone conversations? Yeah, I mean, they wiretapped and they listened in on these conversations. But the court actually decided that a search under the Fourth Amendment had not occurred because there wasn't really any physical trespass to that person's property. When they committed the wiretap, they weren't on site. They didn't intrude on the person's home. They did it off-site. There was no trespass to the property, therefore, that wasn't protected by the Fourth Amendment. So when the case comes back in 1967, uh, Mr.
SPEAKER_00Katz has a very similar situation. He's, I would say, not a very smart criminal, right? He's making calls from the same telephone booth every day. He's a bookie and he's taking illegal bets on this phone. So he's in this phone booth, he's making calls. And what the government does, they follow Olmstead. They don't physically trespass. I mean, he's he's in a booth. So he's like in a public space. They don't like trespass on his person, like put a wire on him or anything physically. What they do is they place a listening device outside of the booth and they listen in on his calls.
SPEAKER_00So Mr. Katz raises an issue. He says, hey, like they violated my Fourth Amendment rights here. I have a right to be protected in this phone booth. I was going into this quiet space where I could make a private call and they listened in on it. And the government, relying on Olmsted, says, Well, we didn't physically trespass. The listening device was placed outside of the booth. He doesn't have any rights in this area. He's he's in an open space, you know, you can see the booth. So if you're thinking from a government perspective, that sounds pretty good based on what the court said previously.
SPEAKER_00So in CATS is where we see a shift in how the court interprets the Fourth Amendment. And they say, well, there is a right here under the Fourth Amendment that's protected because he had a reasonable expectation of privacy in that conversation that was occurring inside of that telephone booth. So they go back and they look at what he did to create that reasonable expectation of privacy. So it can't just be subjective. You know, if you're in a phone booth and you're shouting and people can hear your conversation outside and the government walks by, they don't have to avert their ears.
SPEAKER_00They can listen. But if you're actually doing things objectively that are reasonable to protect that privacy of that conversation, the court says there's an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy in that conversation, and therefore your rights are protected. So the government wasn't permitted, even though they didn't trespass, to use that listening device. So that's where we get that reasonable expectation of privacy language that ends up then being the language the court uses in subsequent opinions interpreting the Fourth Amendment.
SPEAKER_02Your response somewhat answered a question that's been on my mind since earlier, and that's how do we determine what's reasonable and who determines it?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So that's a really great question. So reasonableness is interesting just generally in the law, right? Um, and in tort law, I'm gonna borrow a concept from tort law. There's a concept called the reasonably prudent person. And that's kind of the same type of standard we look at when we were looking at Fourth Amendment cases. So a reasonable person in society, you know, what could they expect? And it's a fact-based determination by the court. So what they'll look at is the facts and circumstances surrounding how that person created that expectation of privacy.
SPEAKER_00So the analogy I gave earlier, Mr. Katz shouting in a booth, he can't really expect that his conversation isn't going to be heard by passers-by. But what Mr. Katz did in his case and why the court found that he did have a reasonable expectation of privacy was he went into the booth, he closed the door, and he spoke quietly. And only by using this listening device were they able to hear his conversation. So he had created that reasonable expectation. The same thing would be applicable when you think about your home. So, for example, if you're sitting in your house and you have drawn the blinds so that nobody can really see inside of your home, and then a law enforcement officer he comes up to the cartilage of the home and tries to peek in, then you might be able to argue he had a reasonable expectation of privacy in the home and you know they they came and peeked in.
SPEAKER_00On the other hand, if your blinds are wide open and a law enforcement officer walks by and he just looks into your home and happens to see you doing something illegal in the home, then he's not required to avert his eyes. He can say, even though that's your home, you didn't have a reasonable expectation of privacy in your living room because your blinds were wide open. So really that ends up being kind of a framework by which the court looks at these cases is if something's open to view from the publicly viewable space, then there's no reasonable expectation of privacy, which I think sometimes can cause a rift in perhaps what society would expect and what the court has interpreted, just because there are some times where something might be observable to the public, but you don't really expect the public to really look.
SPEAKER_00One of the cases the court has decided dealing with kind of this idea that what's observable to the public is not, there's no you don't have a reasonable expectation of privacy and something that's observable to the public deals with aerial searches. So an aerial search is a search that occurs when the government maybe flies over someone's property and then looks into their backyard because they couldn't see their backyard from the street level. So, you know, you'd imagine you've got a fence around your property, you've got a pretty high fence around your property, say it's a 10-foot fence.
SPEAKER_00The government can't look over that fence probably without climbing on the fence, which would absolutely be a physical trespass and probably a search under the Fourth Amendment. So, you know, physical trespass is still going to qualify. It's not required, but it's still going to qualify. So if they climb on your fence, Fourth Amendment violation. So they can't climb on your fence, but they can be where other people could be to lawfully view what's in your backyard. Um, so we get some very closely decided cases dealing with aerial searches where in one case, you know, the government's flying over in a helicopter.
SPEAKER_00Um, and that case, the person's yard, they were growing, I think, marijuana in their backyard. And um, the government's flying over, but they're in, you know, navigable airspace and they look into uh someone's backyard and they're able to observe the illegal growing product. And the court says that's okay. That was something, you know, other people in society could view that. Law enforcement, they weren't illegally trespassing on the airspace above your house. Like they were, they were where they could be lawfully. So therefore, there's no reasonable expectation of privacy.
SPEAKER_00So a case like that is a little bit more difficult, I think, for the public to understand. But when it comes to reasonableness, really anything that's observable, and it I think that creates an issue. For example, now we have drones. People fly drones around. And, you know, if the law enforcement starts using drones, you know, is that going to be something where that use of technology ends up violating someone's Fourth Amendment rights? And it's interesting because there are technology changes things both from the government's perspective and from the citizen's perspective.
SPEAKER_00So from citizens' perspective, technology, like for example, a cell phone. It used to be that law enforcement officers could search containers if they had probable cause to search a vehicle, they could search the containers in the vehicle. And so they treated a cell phone like a container, like, oh, I can search a container, so therefore I can search the contents of your cell phone. But the court says no, like that is the complete opposite of what we want for the Fourth Amendment. Like someone has a right to privacy in the contents of their cell phone. So you can't search that. And then there's also on the other end, if the government's using technology on its behalf, they're using a device that can detect heat signatures inside someone's home.
SPEAKER_00They can't use that device because they're essentially searching in someone's home with that heat signature device. So there's there's cases that interpret this new technology, and drones kind of fit in an in-between area because they essentially accomplish what would be an aerial search, but they're doing it using highly powered technology. And the question's going to be: is this technology the type of technology that's generally useful in the public such that person in society would not have a reasonable expectation because anybody can use a drone and fly over.
SPEAKER_00So therefore the government should be able to do it as well. And I think that's where there becomes a question of what's reasonable in a society where technology is being used so much and essentially so expansively that it creates almost like a lower expectation of privacy. So that's kind of one of the newer issues with the Fourth Amendment today. But reasonable expectations of privacy, it's broader than just you physically trespass on someone's property, right? So it creates a broader right, but at the same time, it's that question of reasonableness is constantly being evaluated based on societal standards and things like technology begin to change.
SPEAKER_00Okay, what's reasonable in a society when technology is so expansive?
SPEAKER_02So clearly, the Fourth Amendment is very much a part of our everyday lives. This is affecting every American. What do you see in terms of how the Fourth Amendment will continue to serve American society and what needs to be changed, what needs to be, you know, remain the same given. This is such an issue in American society today?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I think with the Fourth Amendment, the biggest question is kind of getting back to that original intent and thinking about that language. And when we think about general warrants and we think about what the founders were aiming to protect against, and that was that expansive search, that limitless search that was in general warrants, I think that helps inform the court and keep the Fourth Amendment as an adequate protection. So the recent case dealing with cell phones, the court discussed at length that purpose, the general warrants, and how the founders are aiming to prevent that.
SPEAKER_00Because otherwise, I think based on the trajectory of where the court opinions were going with lower expectations of reasonableness based on technology, it very well could have been that they could have thought, oh, well, you know, is there a reasonable expectation there? But when you couple it with that, that language of the protections that we were trying to afford society, right? We were trying to afford that society would not be broadly searched. I think that could serve as almost like a limit or a boundary that would keep the Fourth Amendment from becoming meaningless.
SPEAKER_00And certainly I would say the other part of Fourth Amendment protections comes down to continuing to weigh interests. So I think a society, there's this tension often between wanting to enable the government to conduct investigations and to protect citizens, but at the same time, not wanting it to be so broad that essentially the government can do whatever it wants without any kind of protections for society. And I think we saw a little bit of a breakdown when it came to enforcing the drug war in the 1980s.
SPEAKER_00So there were a lot of court cases that were interpreted during that time that broadened what was allowed under the Fourth Amendment. And I think that that type of tension is always going to exist with regard to how we're looking at the Fourth Amendment. But like I said before, it comes down to let's keep this within the original intent, which is that we do want protections for society. We do want all members of society to have these protections. And it's much better for us sometimes to be restrictive with regard to the Fourth Amendment if we want it to have any meaning in future generations.
SPEAKER_02Kendra, we know, as we mentioned earlier, that Benjamin McDaniel purchased his own freedom prior to the Civil War after being an enslaved driver and courier for James and Dolly Madison. And I think this gives you kind of a unique connection to Montpelier. And I'm wondering if there's something you'd like to share about that connection to your ancestor and your pursuit of a career in law.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so it's really interesting because I didn't know that history until later, after I had my law degree and after I attended James Madison University, ironically. And I will say, like initially it was very hard to grapple with that history. And I don't think it's less hard today. But I think one of the things I appreciate about the way that Montpelier tells the story of my ancestor here, it gives a little bit more context and value to his life in a way that I can be confident that his life is honored at the same time that we had this founder who crafted the Fourth Amendment and who was instrumental in making sure that we have these protections.
SPEAKER_00So it's one of the things I think that comes to mind when I think about my ancestor's story here at Montpelier is just, you know, I want his life to be honored. The second thing is just thinking about how that informs the way that I look at the law and the way that I look at these standards. And, you know, one of the things I think it really continues to challenge for me, it was something that I always thought about before was just how do we interact with a document that meant something different to a different group of people when it was enacted. So when we have the constitution, when we have these amendments, my ancestor was not someone who was taking part in that dialogue.
SPEAKER_00And really what that means for society today is to make sure that we are having conversations about these documents and what they mean and how they impact the individuals who were not considered citizens or even people at the time that they were adopted. So those are just some interesting perspectives, I think, for someone who has the history that I have. And particularly is how do we engage in an honest discussion about even how some of these amendments have not protected individuals who descend from the enslaved communities here in the United States or other persons who look like the descendants of those who are enslaved in the United States over time.
SPEAKER_00And when I teach on the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Amendment, and particularly the Fourth Amendment, I can't help but to consider the overall historical context and particularly how we can, as a society, kind of embrace this is the trajectory our nation has been on based on the founding. And how can we have discussions and dialogues in an open and honest way to ensure that the society we live in now does protect all individuals who should have been protected initially, and that all individuals in this country have a voice with regard to the way that that law is interpreted.
SPEAKER_02Kendra Johnson, thank you so much for sharing your thoughts, not only on your family history, but also your knowledge and expertise on the Fourth Amendment. You've certainly left me with a lot of thoughts in my head about how the Fourth Amendment is going to shape American society, especially as we move forward with these questions of privacy and what is or is not reasonable. And I want to thank all of you for tuning in and listening. Please share the show, Consider the Constitution, with your family and friends. And stay tuned. In two weeks, we'll have our next episode of Consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...