Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

Women and the Constitution

Apr 22, 202634 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

When the Constitution was drafted in 1787, women weren't explicitly excluded - they were simply not addressed. Dr. Catherine Allgor, historian and former President of the Massachusetts Historical Society, joins host Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey at Montpelier to unpack what that silence actually meant - and why it wasn't accidental. At the center of the conversation is a word every listener will want to know: coverture. The legal doctrine that erased a woman's identity at marriage - subsuming her personhood, her property, her wages, even her children into her husband - was never abolished by the Constitution or the Bill of Rights. Dr. Allgor traces coverture from the founding era through Abigail Adams's famous "Remember the Ladies" letter, the suffrage movement, and the ERA debate, arguing that its legacy is still very much alive today. A bracing, eye-opening conversation for the 250th anniversary year - and a reminder that the republican experiment is still a work in progress. This episode is supported in part by the Virginia Law Foundation.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.

SPEAKER_00Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey with James Madison's Montpelier. Today, we're talking about women and the Constitution. When the Constitution was drafted, it created a structure of government, and when the Bill of Rights was added in 1791, it identified rights the federal government could not take away. But an important question remained. Who was actually entitled to those rights?

SPEAKER_01For this conversation, we're focusing specifically on women and what citizenship meant in practice. One of the rights we most often associate with citizenship is suffrage or the right to vote. Because voting is how citizens shape the society they live in and influence the laws that govern them. Yet in the United States, citizenship did not always guarantee the right to vote, and voting itself was not always limited to citizens, especially in the early decades of the Republic.

SPEAKER_01Joining us today for this conversation, here in the studio at Montpelier, is Dr. Catherine Al Gore. She was the president emerita of the Massachusetts Historical Society, serving there from 2017 until 2024. She's a renowned American historian who focuses on women, especially in the early American founding era. She has written extensively and lectured on Dolly Madison and the founding generation of American women. Her book, A Perfect Union, Dolly Madison and the Creation of the American Nation, is the only scholarly treatment of Dolly's life to its full extent to date.

SPEAKER_01Catherine, it's so lovely to have you here at Montpelier. Welcome back, and thank you for joining us in the studio. It's such a pleasure. Thank you so much for having me. So I want to start with the drafting of the Constitution. When the original seven articles are drafted in 1787, I'm curious to know more about what they actually say about citizenship and who is considered part of that system or entitled to rights that are outlined in the Constitution and Bill of Rights.

SPEAKER_02Well, we have to exercise really some deep thinking there because there's no explicit language. As you said, I'm a historian of women's lives and gender. And what that means is that we often like to take a look at traditional history through that lens, and it often reveals something quite interesting, I think, and kind of compelling. And that's certainly true when you're talking about the Constitution. So, Katie, on one hand, this could be the world's shortest podcast because women are not addressed in the Constitution, and we could all now go out for coffee.

SPEAKER_02However, let me backtrack a little bit. In the language of the Constitution, actually, it's surprisingly gender neutral. So the framers in those initial proposals and subsequent drafts used terms like persons, inhabitants, citizens. They did use, you know, male pronouns, but that was only for office holders. It's also true that unlike enslaved people, women and along with children were fully accounted in apportioning quotas, but still they're just not.

SPEAKER_02And this decision on the founders, if not completely a hundred percent conscious, was in its way deliberate. And it rested upon assumptions whether women could be citizens, to get back to your point. But I would say it's even persons. So when we're talking about the late 18th century, it's less about whether they could vote, because a lot of white men couldn't vote either. But really, could they actually be citizens?

SPEAKER_01That's really interesting to think about that there's not very defined language about what a citizen is at that time. And as you mentioned, there's not full suffrage or voting rights even for white men at that period of time. How does this lack of definition about what citizenship is, how does that matter when we're trying to understand not just women's political status, but a person's political status in general in this newly formed country at the time?

SPEAKER_02Yes, I agree with you. Let's dive deep into the constitution itself. So reading the constitution, there is a model for the citizen. So you're asking about who's the citizen. It's pretty clear what that model is. It's white, it's male, it's property owning, though that's not specifically mentioned, but that the assumption of the founders is that these would be men who would be, quote, interested in the government, meaning that they would have an interest, so they'd own property. So that citizenship model's pretty obvious. The other model is the status of the stateless.

SPEAKER_02It's enslaved people who are acknowledged but counted only partially. But white married women are not addressed, or women at all, but certainly white married women or wives are not addressed at all. So that means there's um a sort of ghost, if you will, in the machinery, I like to say. Which means the ghost is married white women are in an ambiguous position that's much more akin to the enslaved person's model than it is to citizenship. So sometimes we talk about women as second-class citizens, but really in comparison to citizenship in the Constitution, it's more like steerage.

SPEAKER_02And certainly if it is close to citizenship, it's a citizenship that is partial and contingent, and in fact covert. And Katie, this brings me to the word I would like everyone to know about, so they can go to the next dinner party and discuss the word. Is it time for the word? All right, everybody. It's coverture. C-O-V-E-R-T-U-R, like overture with a C. And I'd like everybody to come away from this podcast knowing what it is.

SPEAKER_02So, coverture. At the time of the revolution, American women, along with their English counterparts, were legally bound under an institution called coverture. And coveture held that no female person had a legal identity. At birth, a female baby was covered by her father's identity, and then when she was married by her husband's, the husband and wife became one, and that one was the husband. As a symbol of this subsuming of identity or this loss of identity, the woman took the last name of her husband.

SPEAKER_02Because they could not legally exist, married women could not make contracts or be sued, they couldn't own anything, they couldn't work in business, obviously, they couldn't vote. But it goes sort of more than bone deep. When I say a woman couldn't own anything, property, for instance, she did not even own the clothes on her back. Married women had no rights to their children, so that if a wife divorced or left her husband or vice versa, she would not see her children again. Married women had no right to their bodies.

SPEAKER_02That meant a husband could send a wife out to labor and he would collect the wages of her labor. It was always about the fruits of her body, so labor could be a fruit of the body. The other fruit of the body was children. So this is why women had no rights to their children. Men had rights to fruits of her body. And more darkly, sexual access to a wife's body was assumed. Her consent was implied. So under the law, all sex-related activity, including rape, was legitimate. His total mastery of this human being stopped short, but just short of death.

SPEAKER_02A man was not allowed to beat his wife to death, but he could beat her. Now that was a law. In real life, it was a little different on the ground. There's something called equity practices, which we are not going to go into. You're welcome. And it ensures that coverture on the ground, it was not as restrictive as the black letter law indicated. So though a woman could technically own nothing, men who wanted to pass their wealth on through daughters to grandchildren devised ways of keeping their money and property out of the hands of sons-in-law.

SPEAKER_02And the demands of commerce played their own parts, though a woman couldn't make a contract. Plenty of women did business and trade either on their own in a legal exception called femme sole or mostly with their husbands. So wives ran businesses along with their mates, and the local community acted as kind of monitors and enforcer. And we must assume, though, that while husbands had a right to marital relations at will, that there was a lot of negotiation around sex.

SPEAKER_01Catherine, it sounds like any type of autonomy or presence or rights within this new government really is within the parameters of what the man's rights were, her husband, essentially. That partnership, she kind of exists within that union of marriage in terms of what she can or cannot do. If they're trading, you know, if she has a partnership with her husband to engage in commerce, or it sounds like the husband is the one that kind of has ultimate authority and based on his perception, he can give her permission.

SPEAKER_02Yes, in fact, that's interesting because when we're talking about the Constitution, the revolution didn't change coverture at all, nor did the Constitution, though some new rights for men meant rights for women. So just by extension, thanks to the Bill of Rights, women partook in many of the rights men enjoyed. Law protected the property of widows and single women. But you're right, married women could assemble freely, they could practice their religion, they could exercise free speech with their husbands' permission. They did have the right to petition and to trial by jury, though of course the jury of their peers would be made up of men.

SPEAKER_02So the Bill of Rights gave women a little bit, but as you say, it was all about their permission. So I'd like to talk a little bit about the history of coveture because I think it'll get us somewhere interesting, though it's a little bit before the Constitution. So coveture is what Abigail Adams is talking about in a very famous letter we all know called Remember the Ladies. And a lot of people read this letter and they think she's talking about some amorphous form of feminism or the right to vote. She's not. She's talking about coveture.

SPEAKER_02She references, and I don't want our listeners to think I've memorized this, so you'll hear some paper as I quote here, but she referenced the long-standing nature of coveture when she bade him to be, quote, more generous and favorable to them, the present-day ladies, than your ancestors. Abigail understood absolute power and corruption as clearly as, you know, Tom Paine. She said, Do not put such unlimited powers into the hands of husbands. Remember, all men would be tyrants if they could. And she even in this letter refers very obliquely to the shame of marital rape and physical abuse when she says, why not then put it out of the power of the vicious and lawless to use us with cruelty and indignity with impunity?

SPEAKER_02Men of sense in all ages abhor those customs which treat us only as the vassals of your sex. And the clue here is in the 18th century meanings and connotations of words like vicious and vassal because they do connote sexual abuse. And, you know, when I finally understood that letter, I realized that we, and we as scholars, teachers, regular Americans, have not come to terms with what it means to have coveture in place at this founding moment and the implications roll on.

SPEAKER_01That's a lot to take in to think about coveture remaining in place even with the drafting and ratification of the Constitution. And as you referenced, perhaps it wasn't a conscious decision, but you said it's an intentional one on the part of the framers. Can you tell us or give us some insight about what the framers might be thinking? You know, I think about James Madison, for example, and he comes from a family where there is a really strong presence of women, strong women.

SPEAKER_01His grandmother, Frances Taylor Madison, for example, after she's widowed in her 30s, she does not remarry. She remains kind of in charge of the plantation, even when her oldest son, James Sr., the president's father, comes of age. Similarly, James Madison's mother, Nellie Conway Madison, is a really strong figure that gives him the education that he needs to start his career eventually. So how do we reconcile these framers allowing coverture to continue, especially for those like Madison who saw the brilliance and kind of the power of women within his own life?

SPEAKER_02Well, Katie, I don't think we have to look actually far to understand that that never works. So all of those fathers of daughters that stand up and speak, you know, right now, the fact that men know women and appreciate them, individual women, and love them doesn't mean that they see themselves as equal. But our listeners may be asking, is it fair of us to be criticizing the founders? Could they have done anything about coveture? Is it fair to take them to task for not doing what Abigail said, which was to abolish it or at least amend it?

SPEAKER_02So let's see what the founders, as you say, have to say for themselves. And at first glance, it is true they seem rather silent on the topic. And so for a long time we've kind of let them off the hook saying, well, they didn't really know, they didn't imagine other options. But if that sounds familiar to you, Katie, that's what we used to say around the issue of the founders and slavery. But just as new research on race and slavery has complicated that assumption they just didn't know, we now understand that this was a moment, and this moment could go anywhere from the Declaration of Independence through the Constitution through the decades of the late 18th and early 19th century when they're changing law.

SPEAKER_02Call that a moment, if you will. There are many moments where the framers could have allowed, say, women of property to vote, or they could have let married women retain property, they could have modified divorce law, or they could have just gotten rid of coverture and started from scratch. So, as was the issue of slavery, it turns out that the silence around women wasn't exactly a vacuum. So when it comes to examining the nature of women and their role based on equality in a republic, this was I like to call one of those uncomfortable silences, punctuated by odd outbursts with all the tension that marks the difference between not seeing and just ignoring.

SPEAKER_02So, for instance, if we may, let's go back to the Adams as my favorite, as you know, I was the president of the Massachusetts Historical Society. For an example of the uneasy silence. So Abigail writes this letter to John, and she does it right on the eve of him drafting the Declaration of Independence, so sort of April. So you may wonder how he responded. Well, it's not heartening. John basically made light of his wife's request. He said, As to your extraordinarily code of laws, I cannot but laugh. And traditionally, one of the ways to dismiss female concerns has been to playfully impute power to them, far beyond that of mere men.

SPEAKER_02So I'm sad to say John Adams is guilty of that in this letter. In mock fear, he characterized women as, quote, a tribe more numerous and powerful than other groups of disenfranchised people. And he also played on that old saw that the law gave women little power because nature gave them so much. Depend upon it, he teased. We know better than to repeal our masculine systems. Although they are in full force, meaning they're in law, you know they are a little more than theory. We dare not exert our power in its full latitude.

SPEAKER_02We are obliged to go fair and softly, and in practice, you know we are the subjects. And what he's talking about is the putative sexual power that women have over men, even though the power under law doesn't exist. He even talks about the despotism of the petticoat. It was not his final answer. So that's an example of if you just took that letter, you'd think to yourself, okay, they're just not talking about it. But there's another letter. Are you ready for another letter?

SPEAKER_01I don't know. I feel like John Adams might have had to sleep on the couch after the last ones.

SPEAKER_02Well, he was in Philadelphia, so she's ready from Braintree, so he's safe for a while. But in a way, Abigail wins, I think, in a way. So even though he's dismissing her and teasing her and all that in 1776, he understood on some level this deep contradiction in the theories that colonists were using to launch a revolution, the power of representation. So just on the eve of declaring independence, he writes a letter to James Sullivan. And James Sullivan is a formidable intellect in the Continental Congress.

SPEAKER_02And in this letter to Sullivan, John Cesawed back and forth in a rhetorical dialogue as he tried to work out his thinking. So this is a quote from that. And I'm going to go fast because it's not that you need to really follow this, but I want you to get a sense of the tone of this letter, which goes on and on. In theory, the only moral foundation of government is the consent of the people. But to what an extent shall we carry this principle? Shall we say that every individual of the community, old and young, male and female, as well as rich and poor, must consent expressly to every act of legislation?

SPEAKER_02No, you will say. This is impossible. How then does the right arise in the majority to govern the minority against their will? Whence arises the right of the men to govern women without their consent? This is a long letter, very complicated, mostly because John Adams is struggling to form a coherent argument, and at some points he seems to be arguing with himself and losing. But why exclude women? You will say because their delicacy renders them unfit for practice and experience in the great business of life and the hardy enterprises of war, as well as the arduous cares of state.

SPEAKER_02Besides, their attention is so much engaged with the necessary nurture of their children that nature has made them fittest for domestic cares. But, as he pointed out, that reasoning can apply to most men, who are wholly destitute of property, who are also too little acquainted with public affairs to form a right judgment, and too dependent upon other men to have a will of their own. And at this point in the letter, I think John's scaring himself. It's getting a little too close to a line of logic, and he spends the rest of it focusing on this idea of white men who own literal property, should they vote?

SPEAKER_02And somehow by the end of the letter, he could class them all together. John Adams throws in the towel. In the end, he's concluding women cannot be given political equality because, you know, they just can't. And it took a lot to kind of befuddle John Adams and get him to that point. So I think we can see that these men are struggling with this issue.

SPEAKER_01Catherine, this is something your work has focused on, and you referenced this a bit already in the conversation about how the constitution is built around ideas like consent and representation. And women are, as you said, use the word ghost. They are referenced and counted towards representation as part of the constitution, but their rights are really limited and it's kind of sporadic depending upon their spouse. And we don't really have, I guess, very logical arguments from the framers.

SPEAKER_01They're struggling with it too, about what does this actually look like, who is being represented, but who's also allowed to participate.

SPEAKER_02There's a great quote, I think it's Aristotle. Women are a problem in the polity, and we certainly are, because we defy characterizations. So here's an example. John Locke, the great theorist, whose work was very influential with the founders. And it was because of this part where he said every man should basically wake up every morning and decide whether he's being well and truly ruled. And you're imagining now like a white man and a British king, right? And if a man decides he is not being well ruled, he doesn't just have permission to rebel, he sort of has a duty to do it.

SPEAKER_02And so that's John Locke. And John Locke does use words like agents and things like that, but he means men. Because what would happen if women did that? If women woke up every morning and said, Am I being treated well? Am I being properly ruled? And if not, I can rebel. So John Locke understood that that was a contradiction. So this is how he made it okay. For John Locke, women before they were married, they had one moment of consent, and that was when they decided who to marry.

SPEAKER_02And that was their consent to representation. And after that it was all implied. That was the extent that they had to kind of stretch to try to fit women under this tent.

SPEAKER_01I'm reminded of the Declaration of Sentiments. So when the Seneca Falls Convention, which is kind of the first collective effort by women to organize for rights, but also, you know, suffrage. That's kind of what we mark as perhaps the start of the women's suffrage movement. Seneca Falls, New York, 1848. And these women and some men gather and they come up with this declaration of sentiments, which is essentially kind of The Declaration of Independence, but drafted to include the word women and the rights that they believe they have.

SPEAKER_01And the language they use in that is they frame it as women have the same rights that men do naturally. But the government has denied those rights to them. Which I find a very interesting way to look at and almost an interpretation of Locke and these other early theorists that Madison and other framers are relying on to draft the constitution.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And you know, the show, now this 8048, so it's a little bit away, but be assured that certainly learned white women and men were aware of this. At the same time, remember, especially during constitutional times, the French Revolution is going on. And women are getting all kinds of rights for better or worse, and they don't always retain them. But the idea that women could participate in the polity was, you know, alive out there. So you may then wonder why did the founders not really do anything about this if they really did kind of know what was going on. And this is my theory.

SPEAKER_02And again, this is not just the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, but all those decades of reframing the law. During the early years of the founding, especially during the constitutional era, the founders were obsessed with an issue, one that they thought was essential to the Republican experiment. Historian Joseph Ellis frames this as the viability of the nation. I call it legitimacy, it was the same thing. In short, no one, a former colonist or a European observer, was certain that the Republican experiment would hold, that the United States would last.

SPEAKER_02It was precisely this uncertainty that led men like James Madison and Alexander Hamilton to create the Constitution in order to consolidate and shore up power. So my theory is this need for legitimacy to prove to themselves and to others that the U.S. was a real political enterprise gave rise to much anxiety and fear. And I think it's this anxiety of viability that prevented the framers from addressing this really glaring contradiction of this weird category of degraded citizenship, which is hundreds of years old, in their shiny new political machine.

SPEAKER_02They just didn't do anything about it. Why? And I'm saying it's the anxiety that anything, they're very sensitive to anything that would seem to diminish or challenge their authority. So this is all about authority, just like the Constitution was all about authority. And in an era that equated masculinity with authority, that meant anything that might make them feel like or seem like less than men and ceding the power they had over wives that coverture gave them would be such an act, not just for them, but for the whole world.

SPEAKER_02I did consult a very well-known historian at some point when I was putting together my remarks and I said, Can I say this is a period where there's a crisis of masculinity? And he said, Honey, it's always a crisis of masculinity. So I think my theory might hold.

SPEAKER_01We're lucky to have words and documents that have survived in the record from Abigail Adams, for example. Her letters to John Adams are really compelling and they tell us a lot about what women like her and her social status are saying and the conversations they're having. What do we know about all the other women? I am thinking about, not just enslaved women, but you know, free African-American women or indigenous women. I am assuming that while white women, elite white women, have very little agency or political power, that women beyond that tier are really at a disadvantage.

SPEAKER_02Oh, absolutely. And historians are at a disadvantage as well, because you have to get really creative with your sources. But what we found is that the language of rights and sort of expectation of one's possibility of being a full human being was very contagious. And so what we find is, for instance, women arguing for divorces or separations, and even enslaved women using the language of rights, using the language of liberty.

SPEAKER_02So we know that it really infects, you know, but it's hard to get at in the historical record, but we can do that by looking at certain kinds of documents. But a lot of time people just, you know, walked with their feet. They just acted as though they were partaking of these moments of liberty. There's a great book by Gloria Whiting called Belonging, which is, I think it's intimate history of slavery in Boston. And it's showing how the institution of slavery in Boston and in Massachusetts, one of the first states to abolish it officially in the 1780s, the disintegration of the state of slavery happened long before that because of the actions of black people, black activists, and their white allies.

SPEAKER_02And there's a great story about a little boy who just simply walks away from slavery. And the point is that he could do that because it was an atmosphere where the whole thing was breaking down. So there are people who are actually asserting their personhood through their feet.

SPEAKER_01And to wrap up the conversation about coveture specifically, so we talked a little bit about what it is and kind of how it worked in practice even after the Constitution was ratified. What happened with it? Did it eventually die out? Was it really a state-by-state basis? How does that conclude?

SPEAKER_02The short answer is we never got rid of it. This is where, in case our audience is now judging the founders for not getting rid of it in the 18th century, we haven't either, so we can't really judge. To answer your question, we chipped away at coverture for the last 300 years, but never getting rid of it completely. And so we get things like native-born American women who lose their citizenship when they marry certain kinds of foreigners. And that happened as late as the 1950s. In many places, women were not permitted to serve on juries till the mid-20th century, which is, of course, a fundamental constitutional right.

SPEAKER_02The Smithsonian American Women's History Museum website has a great exhibit right now on the 50th anniversary of the Fair Credit Act. Women had no access to credit or money until the 1970s. And marital rape wasn't recognized until the 1980s or so. And it's still in our lives. So I know cases where a single woman, because of course coveture assumes all women are married, who encounter coveture in all kinds of ways. If you're a married woman with your own name, you try try filing your taxes.

SPEAKER_02Let me tell you that. My favorite story was a woman with a really good job. She was single, she was a really good job, and she wanted to buy a house, and her mortgage was denied. But her mortgage was denied by the bank that she worked for. She was actually the mortgage broker. But uh, that's my favorite one there. Most of the time these vestiges of crevature are are just annoying or even funny, but then, you know, why do you want to get rid of it? And I found myself thinking, as I was kind of concluding, like, what would it take? And I realized what would take is a constitutional amendment. It took three to really put a lid on slavery.

SPEAKER_02And then I sort of remembered in my own youth something called the ERA. And uh I was in the 70s, I was young, I wasn't paying attention, and I was like, wait a minute, is that what this is about? And the answer is yes. Again, without using the word, it is about getting rid of coverture and allowing women to own their selves and their destinies. So again, the constitution is back in our lives.

SPEAKER_01And the suffrage, the women's suffrage movement, which began really as an effort on a state-by-state basis to get states to alter their constitutions to recognize women's suffrage rights. Ultimately turned into the effort to have a constitutional amendment because they felt like this is the only way that these rights are going to be respected, which led to the passage of the 19th Amendment in 1920. And it was after that point that one of the leaders of the women's suffrage movement, Alice Paul, is starting to think about what an Equal Rights Amendment will look like as early as the 1920s.

SPEAKER_01And yet look at all of her work leading up, you know, and then it was kind of revived again in the 1970s, as you referenced. And today, for those I'm assuming most of our listeners know, but we do not have an amendment, an equal rights amendment recognizing women as full equal participants. It's not part of our constitution.

SPEAKER_02No, like many countries do have that, yes. And the ones who don't have it, you really wouldn't want to be in a room with. I think it's important to understand, too, this idea of being a full human being in the polity. So that's what people like Abigail Adams in the 18th century are sort of pushing toward. And in the early 19th century, when you're talking about the Declaration of Sentiments, it addresses a lot of issues. And there is a lot. There's marriage critique, there was sexual critique, desires about education, dress reform.

SPEAKER_02And it really wasn't until really like right before and then after the Civil War that the women leaders decided to focus in on the vote. So it was just sort of like, well, there's all this reform that needs to happen. We need laws doing this and that and that. Let's just get the vote. And so it kind of narrowed that. But all the, and that's so that's why we have Alice Paul, like in the early 20th century, saying, okay, this is great, but the equal rights amendment means we're actual human beings.

SPEAKER_01And a great example, too, is even when there are protections in the Constitution. So even after the passage of the 19th Amendment, you know, we have indigenous women, for example, who are not recognized as citizens until 1924. So they don't benefit from that until later. And then of course, you know, black women who were involved in not just the suffrage movement, but the civil rights movement, you know, they're kind of being involved in all of these different social movements. It took another act, the voting act, in the 1960s, to really allow them to participate in this system of suffrage.

SPEAKER_02So Yes, but you know, acts like Lily led better, Civil Rights Act, acts can be taken away. They can be changed, they can be amended, they can be destroyed. That's why a constitutional amendment is so important. Just to declare once and for all that we're part of this.

SPEAKER_01And this is a great place to wrap up, especially as we think about all the work that has been done by women over the over the centuries, 300 years. And yet coverture is still technically a thing in this country. So as we think about the early days of this country from the Constitution up until now, are there any parting thoughts, Catherine, that you would want to share with listeners or things that we should be thinking about in today's landscape?

SPEAKER_02I think it's great we're having this conversation on the 250th anniversary. I think we should have, as we have here with your podcast, really start thinking about who we are. We need to know where we've been and just we need to decide what the quote Republican experiment is going to actually be moving forward. And I think looking deeply at the Constitution and understanding the thinking behind it is really going to help us do that. And maybe this is a moment while we're going to enjoy the fireworks and we're going to buy all that kitschy stuff in the gift shops around the world that we also meditate on what our democracy and what the Republican experiment means.

SPEAKER_01That's so well said, Catherine. This year, this semi-quincentennial is, yes, a moment to look back at this history and really celebrate, commemorate, maybe take a critical eye at some of it. But it's not just about the history. It's also about, as you said, who we are. This is a moment for us to fully understand our role and place in society. Democracy requires us all to be active. It's an active process. That's a living thing, really.

SPEAKER_01So thank you for bringing our attention to that.

SPEAKER_02Thank you for the conversations, ours, and all the conversations you're having.

SPEAKER_01And thank you to all of our listeners. I hope you enjoyed the conversation today. And please share this show with your family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode