In this episode of Consider the Constitution, host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey is joined by Montpelier Senior Research Historian Hilarie M. Hicks for a conversation about the relationship between James Madison and the Marquis de Lafayette, a Frenchman who became an icon of the American Revolution. The two men first met in 1784 and developed a deep friendship that was both politically advantageous and intellectually stimulating. They exchanged over 65 letters and their political philosophies are discussed in this episode. The podcast also touches on Madison's views on slavery and freedom of religion, and how these views influenced his drafting of the US Constitution. Lafayette's visit to the United States in 1824 and 1825, and his conversations with Madison during these visits, are also discussed.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. On today's show, we're discussing the relationship between James Madison, the fourth president, father of the Constitution, an architect of the Bill of Rights, and the Marquis de Lafayette, a native Frenchman who became an icon of the American Revolution and, in the words of Madison, a champion of liberty. The two men first met in 1784, and, while they would not see each other again for another 40 years, they exchanged over 65 letters.
SPEAKER_01They developed a deep friendship that was both politically advantageous as well as intellectually stimulating. Now, 2024 marks the 200th anniversary of Lafayette's famed return to the United States for a 13-month tour of our young democratic experiment. Joining us to discuss the political philosophies of these two men and their reunions here at Montpelier in 1824 and 1825 is Hillary Hicks, senior research historian here at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_01Before joining Montpelier in 2010, Hillary served as curator of interpretation at Trion Palace Historic Sites and Gardens in Newburn, North Carolina, and executive director of the Rosewell Foundation in Gloucester, Virginia. She is an alum of the College of William and Mary and the Cooperstown Graduate Program and History Museum Studies. Hilary, welcome to Consider the Constitution. Thanks, Katie. I'm glad to be invited. Lafayette is a fascinating figure to discuss. He is born in France to a wealthy landowning family, and he comes to the colonies when he is 19 years old to support this fight for independence from the British monarchy.
SPEAKER_01And it's in the fall of 1784 that Madison and Lafayette meet for the first time. And this is a pivotal moment as we are just one year out from the end of the American Revolution when Britain recognized the United States as an independent country. Hillary, can you tell us how Madison and Lafayette happened to meet?
SPEAKER_02Madison was a member of the Virginia House of Delegates at that point. The House session had concluded in July of 1784, and they wouldn't meet again until November. So in late August, Madison decided to take a trip up north. We don't know exactly where he planned to go, but as he wrote to his father, he fell in with Lafayette's party in Baltimore at the beginning of September. Lafayette was on his way to Fort Stanwix, New York, also known as Fort Skyler, to negotiate a treaty with the Iroquois and invited Madison to join his group.
SPEAKER_02Their trip took them through Philadelphia, New York, and Albany on the way to the treaty negotiation. They visited a Shaker village and also an Oneida village. Afterwards, when the treaty negotiation was over, they traveled down through the Mohawk Valley before they parted ways and Madison went back to New York. So traveling with Lafayette and Company gave Madison some companionship for the journey to places he probably wanted to go, like Philadelphia and New York, and also offered him some novel experiences, witnessing the treaty negotiation and visiting the Shaker Village and the Oneida Reservation.
SPEAKER_01That's interesting, the wordage of they fell in with each other.
SPEAKER_02That's the phrasing he used.
SPEAKER_01And can you describe how at this point in time Madison's political philosophies differ or compare with Lafayette's and what Madison's initial impression is of Lafayette?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Madison's initial impression was that Lafayette was very frank, very talented, but also that he was rather vain. Or as Madison wrote to Thomas Jefferson on October the 14th, Lafayette had, quote, a strong thirst of praise and popularity. Madison also wrote that he took Lafayette to be, quote, as amiable a man as his vanity would admit. In later years, Madison must have been a little embarrassed about this assessment because when he edited that letter for publication, he crossed out the phrase a strong thirst of praise and popularity and changed the phrase as amiable a man as his vanity will admit to as amiable a man as can be imagined.
SPEAKER_02And since he had written to Jefferson and Cypher using a numerical code, he actually altered the coded words so that posterity wouldn't realize he had once had a kind of mixed impression of Lafayette. Lafayette by the eighteen twenties was a very heroic figure. But a good documentary editor figured out that change he had made in the twentieth century. But going back to their politics, Madison and Lafayette both shared ideals of liberty, and they valued the preservation of the union of the thirteen states.
SPEAKER_02So in that same letter to Jefferson, Madison wrote of Lafayette, quote, in his politics, he says that his three hobby horses are the alliance between France and the United States, the union of the latter, and the manumission of the slaves. The two former are dearer to him as they are connected to his personal glory. The last does him real honor as it is a proof of his humanity.
SPEAKER_01Now at this point in time, the 1780s, Madison is in his early thirties. Where is he in his head on this issue of slavery in comparison with Lafayette?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think that last line that I quoted from Madison's letter is significant, that Madison saw Lafayette's commitment to the abolition of slavery as a proof of his humanity. So at this time Madison was still working out his thoughts on slavery and how to reconcile his beliefs about liberty with the realities of slavery. So for example, in Philadelphia, in July of 1782, Madison's ideas about liberty gave him pause when he was trying to decide how to react to an apparent escape attempt by his enslaved manservant Billy Gardner.
SPEAKER_02It would have been typical for Madison to sell Billy as a punishment, but as Madison wrote his father, he couldn't justify punishing Billy, quote, merely for coveting that liberty for which we have paid the price of so much blood and proclaim so often to be the right and worthy pursuit of every human being. So that's really interesting to see Madison thinking about the Americans just having fought for their liberty from Great Britain, and then trying to apply that concept to his dealings with a man that he enslaved.
SPEAKER_02Madison didn't choose to free Billy outright, but instead he sold him into temporary servitude in Philadelphia, knowing that he would be free in a few years. And then Madison was again trying to apply principles of liberty to his own relationship to slavery in 1785. He wrote that quote, one of my wishes is to depend as little as possible on the labor of slaves. So he thought he would try land speculation as an alternate way to generate income.
SPEAKER_02In February of 1786, Madison and James Monroe bought 900 acres of land in the Mohawk Valley, which was the general area where he had traveled with Lafayette. Madison and Monroe's idea was that they would be able to sell the land later at a profit. That actually didn't happen, they just about broke even. But it's interesting to see a young and idealistic Madison trying to figure out how he could step away from the system of plantation slavery and find a different way to make a living.
SPEAKER_02So it's hard to say exactly when Madison gave up on this idea of being independent of enslaved labor. But definitely by the time he inherited Montpelier, his outlook had changed. He was thinking then less in terms of ending his personal dependence on enslaved laborers, and instead looked for a future way to end slavery through colonization. That was a strategy of emancipating enslaved people and resettling them in Africa or in the Western territories of the United States.
SPEAKER_02And this was, as you can imagine, not a realistic approach to ending slavery. One of Madison's visitors in the 1830s was the British abolitionist Harriet Martineau, and she just couldn't see how Madison could put any hope in the idea of colonization. She wrote, How such a mind as his could derive any alleviation to its anxiety from that source is surprising.
SPEAKER_01Thank you for sharing that information. I do think it's important to understand Madison's views on slavery and freedom of religion. At this moment in particular, we're talking about 1784 or 1785, and at this moment there's several important things going on. Late 1785, Madison begins a deep study of ancient governments to try to figure out a new structure of government for America. It's in late 1785 that he begins preparing for the Constitutional Convention where our founders draft a document that became the U.S.
SPEAKER_01Constitution. And his frame of mind in 1785 is the lens through which he drafts the blueprint for our system of government. And it's that year that Madison took a powerful stance on religious freedom as a fundamental right, further legitimized and protected by the outcome of the American Revolution. And this is a really pivotal moment for Madison. Can you tell us more about it, Hillary? Sure.
SPEAKER_02We can actually go back even further to see Madison taking a stand for religious freedom before the American Revolution. In 1774, he spoke out when Baptist ministers in Culpepper were jailed for preaching without a license. So the Church of England was the official state supported church in Virginia. So a minister of a dissenting faith like the Baptist wouldn't be free to preach his own beliefs. And this is not long after Madison finished his studies at Princeton, where he was steeped in the ideals of the Scottish Enlightenment and free inquiry.
SPEAKER_02So the idea of jailing preachers who dissented from the established religion was really an anathema to Madison. And then in the summer of seventeen seventy six, when Madison was a member of the Fifth Virginia Convention, the Convention was considering George Mason's Virginia Declaration of Rights. Mason's draft would have guaranteed, quote, fullest toleration in the exercise of religion. Now that might sound good, but it still implies that there would be an official government sanctioned and supported religion, akin to the Church of England, while other religions would just be tolerated.
SPEAKER_02Madison successfully moved to change the wording of that clause to free exercise of religion, which means that the government doesn't play any role at all in people's religious beliefs or practices.
SPEAKER_01And that's a significant moment for Madison as well, this 1776 convention. He is, what, in his mid-twenties at the time? Yeah, right about that. And he is challenging George Mason, who is very much senior to him. Definitely.
SPEAKER_02And and Madison is really a junior legislator. This is the first legislative office he's holding. So this is clearly something he's passionate about as a young man. Definitely. But going back to your original question about Madison in 1785, I had mentioned that Madison was serving in the Virginia House of Delegates at that point. Patrick Henry and some others in the House were concerned that there had been moral decay in Virginia after the American Revolution and the disestablishment of the Anglican Church. So in November 1784, with Henry's support, the Virginia legislature considered a bill to set up an assessment, a tax that would pay teachers of Christian religion.
SPEAKER_02And even though the bill wasn't picking out one specific Christian denomination to be the official government supported church, it would still require taxpayers to financially support the teachings of Christianity. Madison spoke out against the bill, and at least got it tabled to the next legislative session. That bought some time for Madison and some other like-minded legislators to strategize. Madison agreed to write up a petition against the bill. It was titled Memorial and Remonstrance Against Religious Assessments, and it laid out fifteen arguments against this incursion on religious liberty.
SPEAKER_02Madison wrote that the practice of religion, quote, can be directed only by reason and conviction and not by force or violence. And he went on to state, quote, The religion then of every man must be left to the conviction and conscience of every man. And that's a really powerful statement, that the religion of every man must be left to the conviction and conscience of every man. So no one can tell you what to believe. No one can tell you who to worship, how to worship, or even whether to worship.
SPEAKER_02And the state can't use your tax money to hire teachers of any religion just to try and improve public morality. And then in 1786, Madison shepherded Jefferson's Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom through the Virginia legislature. Jefferson was in France at the time, and Madison was elated to send him the news that the statute had passed. And Madison wrote that he hoped the statute had in this country extinguished forever the ambitious hope of making laws for the human mind.
SPEAKER_02So that's Madison's thinking about religion in the mid-1780s. Free inquiry, freedom of thought, freedom of conscience, freedom for religion. It's all tied together for him. And this is just a few years before Madison writes freedom of conscience into his draft of the Bill of Rights in 1789.
SPEAKER_01And Lafayette was also a proponent of freedom of religion. In 1789, he authors the initial draft of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, which is a core document of the French Revolution. Now it's another four decades before these two men meet again. And this happens during Lafayette's visit to the United States in 1824. Now, this is a long span of time, and a lot has happened since they last met. The U.S. Constitution was ratified in 1788.
SPEAKER_01The following year, Madison, as a congressman, proposed what became the Bill of Rights, as you just referenced, Hillary. He then serves eight years as Secretary of State and then eight years as president. And it's during that time that he is president during the War of 1812. Now, as these two men meet again in the 1820s, why is Lafayette visiting the United States? Why is he visiting Madison? And what is Madison doing at this time?
SPEAKER_02So to start with Madison, he's been retired from the presidency since 1817. He's in his 70s, but still in good health, still riding his horse to show the visitors different parts of his plantation. He's busy organizing his papers, particularly his notes from the Constitutional Convention for posthumous publication. And he keeps up a voluminous correspondence, particularly with old friends like Lafayette. And as to why Lafayette is visiting in 1824-25, this is his big triumphal return to America to revisit significant places from his service as a general in the American Revolution.
SPEAKER_02And the timing couldn't be better. The country had come out of the War of 1812, feeling more united, more confident about its independence. This is the era of good feelings under Madison's successor to the presidency, James Monroe. Monroe actually is the one to issue the invitation to Lafayette to come to the U.S. So since almost fifty years have passed since the American Revolution, that generation of soldiers and statesmen is fading away. People in the eighteen twenties felt about the revolutionary generation the way we've felt about World War II generation.
SPEAKER_02There aren't many left, we want to hear their stories, we need to show our appreciation for their sacrifices while we still can. So when Lafayette came to America, there was a tremendous outpouring of emotion. It was an appreciation of Lafayette's contributions to American independence and the cause of human freedom. But there was also this emotional fervor, a feeling that it was the last opportunity to honor their hero, a last moment to take the hand of this great historical figure.
SPEAKER_02Whatever town Lafayette visited, there were crowds waving handkerchiefs and young ladies in white dresses strewing flower petals and presenting bouquets. There were parades and dinners and balls and speeches. And then just these really touching moments when old soldiers came up to Lafayette and talked about what it meant to serve under him, what it meant to see him again. Lafayette's farewell tour lasted from August 1824 to September 1825.
SPEAKER_02So to give you just a few of the events in the first several months, Lafayette visited Washington's tomb at Mount Vernon. He laid the cornerstone of the Bunker Hill Monument, and participated in ceremonies marking the anniversary of the Battle of Yorktown, which was on October 19th. Then in November, Lafayette came to Monticello to see Jefferson. There was a dinner at the University of Virginia, which Madison also attended. And then finally on November 15th, Lafayette arrived at Montpelier.
SPEAKER_01And when Lafayette arrives at Montpelier, what do they talk about? How do Madison and Lafayette, these old friends, engage in conversation? How do their political views stay the same, change over time? What does this conversation look like?
SPEAKER_02Well we know something of what Madison, Lafayette, and other guests talked about, because Lafayette's secretary, Auguste Levassour, kept a journal of the trip. And the two main topics seem to have been slavery and religious freedom. LaVassur wrote, General Lafayette, who, while he well appreciates the unfortunate position of slaveholders in the United States, and cannot overlook the greater part of the obstacles which oppose an immediate emancipation of the blacks, still never fails to take advantage of an opportunity to defend the right which all men, without exception, have to liberty.
SPEAKER_02He introduced the question of slavery among the friends of Mr. Madison. And Levisor thought that the company expressed quote noble sentiments on that deplorable subject. So that left him hopeful that slavery wouldn't last much longer in Virginia, but he seems to have underestimated Virginia's dependence on slavery. Levisor didn't record anything that Madison said about slavery, but Madison's position was probably about the same as what he had written to Lafayette in 1821, so this is a quote from his letter.
SPEAKER_02The Negro slavery is, as you justly complain, a sad blot on our free country. No satisfactory plan has yet been devised for taking out the stain. If an adequate asylum could be found in Africa, that would be the appropriate destination for the unhappy race among us. Madison also wrote to Lafayette in 1826, it seems to be indelible that the two races cannot coexist, both being free and equal.
SPEAKER_02So as we discussed earlier, Madison supported the colonization movement, resettling freed people in Africa or elsewhere, and he saw that as an essential step in ending slavery in the United States. Now going back to the discussion of slavery that Levasor recorded with Madison's guests, the guests soon turned the topic to what Levasor described as, quote, the no less important question of mental slavery, meaning the limitations on religious freedom in many European nations.
SPEAKER_02And he wrote, The friends of Mr. Madison congratulated themselves that at least this species of slavery is unknown in the United States. And he observed that here, quote, no individual can be compelled to practice any religious worship, nor to frequent any place, nor to support any minister of any religion whatever. None can be persecuted in any manner on account of religious opinions. But all men have liberty to profess and sustain by argument their opinions in matters of religion.
SPEAKER_01And this language, it really harkens back to this memorial and remonstrance. It sounds like some of the arguments Madison's making in that speech that he gives to the Virginia delegates in the 1780s. It really does.
SPEAKER_02And one of the guests actually took Levassor aside to tell him about the memorial and remonstrance and send him a copy the next day. Morning. Lavisor wrote that he perused it with interest and he found its principles so simple and so eloquently maintained and defended. I don't know whether Lafayette himself had seen the memorial in remonstrance. It seems like he would have at some point. But religious freedom is certainly an area where Lafayette and Madison saw eye to eye.
SPEAKER_01Now we've talked a bit about Lafayette's visit to Montpelier in 1824. This is when he's starting his tour across America. Now you did mention 1825. He visits then as well? Yes.
SPEAKER_02So this visit is a little bit different. He comes back to Montpelier in August of 1825, not long before he left for France in September. So this is sort of the last leg of Lafayette's trip. And even though local communities were still sending him invitations to dinners and providing ceremonial escorts, this part of the journey was really just about saying a final goodbye to friends, particularly Jefferson and Madison. So Lafayette stopped at Montpelier on his way to and from Monticello.
SPEAKER_02So he was at Montpelier from August 15th to 18th, and then on the way back he stays overnight again August 21st, 22nd. So I've had to research those dates through newspaper reports, because LaVaseur didn't specifically mention the stops at Montpelier in his journal. He did mention that both Madison and Monroe came to Monticello with Lafayette to see Jefferson. Lavasseur described a scene that was poignant because, quote, the individuals who bade farewell had all passed through a long career, and the immensity of the ocean would add still to the difficulties of a reunion.
SPEAKER_02Jefferson, of course, died on July the 4th, 1826, so there was never an opportunity for another reunion.
SPEAKER_01During this conversation, um, we've talked a bit about slavery, Lafayette's perspective on slavery, and the conversations he has with Madison about it. Are there any particular members of the enslaved community at Montpelier whose stories tie into Lafayette's visit?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell There's actually two people. One is Ailsy Payne, and she told her story to a reporter who published it in a newspaper in 1902 after her death. She was an enslaved housemaid in her late teens at the time of Lafayette's visit, and she had vivid memories of the preparations and the excitement surrounding Lafayette's visit. She was quoted in the interview as saying there were more horses and carriages than you could hardly count, and that Dolly Madison felt obliged to dress the maids well for the occasion, so that she wouldn't have disqualified herself in her own house.
SPEAKER_02And Ailsy Payne went on to say how the ice houses were filled with meat for the elaborate dinner, and that included mutton, beef, chickens, turkeys, ducks, shoats, and most everything you can think of. So there's kind of an irony there that it's the enslaved domestic workers who were doing all the behind the scenes work to make it possible to hold a dinner honoring Lafayette, the champion of liberty. Then there's also Millie, and she's mentioned in a memoir of Dolly Madison that was written by Dolly's niece Mary Cutz, and that memoir includes a few anecdotes about Lafayette's visit.
SPEAKER_02Now Mary Cutz was only eleven years old in eighteen twenty five. She wasn't at Montpelier when Lafayette visited, so these were probably anecdotes that she had heard from her family. Mary Cutz wrote General de Lafayette, when he visited Montpelier in eighteen twenty five, said one of the most interesting sights he had witnessed in America was when he visited the log cabin of Granny Millie, one hundred and four years of age, whose daughter and granddaughter, the youngest nearly seventy, were all at rest, retired from their labors, and living happily together.
SPEAKER_02Their patch of ground cultivated for them, their food and raiment supplied by Mas Jimmy and Miss Dolly. Now there's a lot to unpack in that anecdote. Mary Cutz always tended to romanticize when she wrote about enslaved people. So we need to take a grain of salt with her description of Millie and her daughter and granddaughter living so happily in retirement. And we don't know actually what Lafayette said about Millie and her family. He didn't write about them. And his secretary LaVasur didn't mention them.
SPEAKER_02So maybe Lafayette did find them interesting because of their advanced ages, but probably not because he was impressed with the way the Madisons provided for them now that they were unable to work, which is what Mary Cutz seems to be implying. Remember, after all, Lafayette is the one who never failed to take advantage of an opportunity to defend the right which all men, without exception, have to liberty.
SPEAKER_01Thank you for unpacking that quote for us. It is interesting to consider, yes, these are primary sources and they tell us about the past, but whose perspective is it? How are they writing about and perceiving of the situation? And as you said, we probably need to take that with a grain of salt.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the context is always important.
SPEAKER_01And I appreciate you joining us for this conversation today. It's very interesting, especially as we approach the anniversary of Lafayette's visit, how these two men differed in their ideology regarding slavery, regarding religion. These men are both symbols of liberty in their own way, Lafayette being actively involved in fighting in the American Revolution, whereas Madison is more of this politician and statesman trying to create a structure for our government.
SPEAKER_01So they make almost interesting foils. And it's also fascinating to see how their ideas changed or didn't as they got older. So thank you for sharing all of that information with us. Oh happy to be here. And thank you to our listeners. We hope you will share the show with family and friends and join us again for another episode of Consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...