Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

Executive Authority: Constitutional Leadership in the Modern Presidency

Feb 19, 202537 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What defines constitutional leadership in today's complex political landscape? Dr. Barbara Perry, co-director of the presidential oral history program at the Miller Center, examines how modern presidents navigate their constitutional authority while facing unprecedented challenges. Drawing from her extensive work conducting presidential oral histories, Perry illuminates the delicate balance between executive power and constitutional constraints, from the critical process of peaceful power transitions to the expansion of civil rights. Through compelling stories of presidents from both parties, she reveals how different leaders have interpreted their constitutional role, managed times of crisis, and shaped the office of the presidency. The conversation explores how the founders' vision for executive authority, first shaped by James Madison, continues to evolve as each president grapples with their constitutional obligations to preserve, protect, and defend American democracy.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.

SPEAKER_00Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. Today we're diving into the modern presidency, its immense responsibilities, the delicate process of transitioning power, and the enduring influence of presidential leadership on civil rights and liberties. We'll also explore the power of storytelling in leadership and governance, focusing on the role of oral histories in shaping our understanding of presidential leadership.

SPEAKER_02Our guest today is someone who has dedicated her career to studying the presidency and capturing its complexities through oral histories. It's a privilege to be speaking with Dr. Barbara Perry. She is the J. Wilson Newman Professor of Governance at the Miller Center, where she co-directs the Presidential Oral History Program. She has authored or edited 17 books on presidents, first ladies, the Kennedy family, the Supreme Court, and civil rights and liberties.

SPEAKER_02Dr. Perry has conducted more than 150 interviews for the George H.W. Bush, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, and Barack Obama Presidential Oral History Projects. She earned a PhD in government from the University of Virginia and a master's from Oxford University. Barbara, it's so wonderful to have you as a guest on the show today. Katie, thank you so much. So I am really eager to hear about your work collecting these presidential oral histories. But first, I'm curious to hear more about your knowledge of the role of the president and transition between administrations.

SPEAKER_02So as someone who has studied this extensively, can you share your perspective on how the peaceful transfer of power has evolved over time? Yes.

SPEAKER_01I think that the United States is what Reagan and John Kennedy called, going back to our earliest days as a country, the concept of the shining city on the hill. And one of the reasons we are viewed that way by a lot of countries in the world and a lot of people who want to come here to be part of that shining city on the hill, is that we have this experiment that the founders started with Mr. Madison leading the way 250 years ago. And we have become the, I'll use another metaphor, sort of the jewel in the crown of democracies and democratic republics.

SPEAKER_01And by that I mean that we have had typically peaceful transfers of power starting with George Washington. And I would note that there was no two-term limit on presidents and that George Washington stepped aside willingly and voluntarily, he could have been elected for a third term. We now have the 22nd Amendment that confines presidents to two terms. That came after FDR had been elected four times and sort of a blowback against that. But that concept that someone would step aside from the tremendous power of the presidency.

SPEAKER_01Remember, this is in 1800, late part of this 18th century. So Adams comes in, he becomes president, there's a peaceful transfer there, more important in 1800 with the peaceful transfer from the Federalist Adams to the Jeffersonian Thomas Jefferson who had founded his own party of Democratic-Republicans, they were called. So that's really the first from one party to another peaceful transfer. Now, it hasn't always quite worked that way, as we know. With the Civil War, when Lincoln is elected in 1860 as a pro-union Republican in that new party, we know that states secede from the union and a civil war ensues.

SPEAKER_01So that's our worst example of not having a peaceful transfer of power. But thank goodness the union wins and the union is preserved, and we go on to have peaceful transfers of power until Donald Trump in 2021 and his lack of acceptance of the fact that Joe Biden won that election by both the popular vote and the electoral vote. So that you had the January 6th, 2021 insurrection of those who supported Trump's view that it was a stolen election, which is inaccurate.

SPEAKER_01And secondly, the fact that Donald Trump would not attend the inauguration of Joe Biden. There had been a few other presidents who, including Adams, who did not attend. He and Abigail fled Washington and went back to Massachusetts. So it was a peaceful transfer, but they weren't there for the inauguration of Thomas Jefferson. I would note, however, for the record that both Adams and Jefferson lived a very long time, famously died on the same day, July 4th, 50 years after Independence Day of Origin, but that they did become friends as time went on.

SPEAKER_01So there's hope. There's always hope in this country.

SPEAKER_02And you mentioned this important precedent that George Washington sets during his final second administration. Can you tell us a little bit about what the aspects or elements that are essential to this peaceful transfer of power?

SPEAKER_01The elements that are really required, I think, in a peaceful transfer of power from one president to another, and particularly from a president of one party to a president of another party, would be the understanding that once all the votes are counted, both the popular vote and the electoral votes, that if there is a clear winner, even if it's controversial, as in the case of Bush versus Gore in 2000, I will use that as the prime model if you say, well, what is necessary for peaceful transfer of power?

SPEAKER_01It is Al Gore, after the Supreme Court, in effect declared George Bush the winner, George W. Bush in 2000. And by that I mean they stopped the recount in Florida. It appears that it's probably the case that George W. Bush won Florida in 2000 in the popular vote by maybe about 300 plus votes. So you can't get any closer there because that was then the key state to determine who would win the Electoral College. And so what did Al Gore do when the Supreme Court decided for various reasons that the majority thought was constitutional in their minds on the court, that they would stop that vote count in Florida and that the procedure would go on, the electoral votes would be counted.

SPEAKER_01And here's an irony that Al Gore, as the sitting vice president, had to read out the electoral vote count that went against him by just a couple of votes because the court had stopped the counting in Florida. But the very night that the Supreme Court made his decision, Al Gore went on television and said, it's not the choice I would want, it's not the decision I would want, but I accept it and we will move on. And then on January the 6th of 2001, he stood on Capitol Hill in the Congress, in the Capitol, and read out the decision that had to just cut him to the quick and hurt his heart.

SPEAKER_01And that's those are the characteristics that we need that each side should say, once the votes are counted, I will stand by the decision of this constitutional structure that was set up in 1787 in Philadelphia, led by Mr. Madison.

SPEAKER_02Clearly, Gore had some personal preferences for how he wanted that election to go, but it sounds like there was an understanding of a broader importance or value to recognizing and standing behind the decision that was made.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. That going into an election, both sides, both parties, both voters for both sides should say we have a system in place that we are very fortunate to have had since 1789 when that first new constitution that we have, our first one was Articles of Confederation, but our constitution that is the Democratic Republic with our three branches of government setting up the electoral college that people may now not like, but it's still there.

SPEAKER_01It would have to be abolished through a constitutional amendment. It's unlikely for that to happen. So both sides, whether it's the voter in the street who's casting a ballot all the way up to a sitting president or an incumbent president or a person who's vying for that incumbent presidency, all the people have to agree this is a fair system. And once that system carries out all its steps, each side will accept, no matter how hard it is, to accept a loss.

SPEAKER_02And this is kind of an occurring theme on many of our episodes, this idea that in a democracy, you often don't get your way. And that's actually supposed to happen in a democracy. It's supposed to be about people being able to voice their ideas, vote on them, and then sometimes you're in favor and sometimes not. But that next step of accepting it and moving on is key to keeping democracy intact and this peaceful transfer.

SPEAKER_01I'm so interested in that point that you've just raised, Katie, because uh through the We the People program that I know Montpelier has been a part of for many years, I was asked one time after teaching high school teachers in that program and students, high school students, I was asked to teach first through third grade teachers about the constitution. And the very points that you raise about democracy, about fairness, peaceful transfer of power, the ability to vote, the right to vote, the right to speak.

SPEAKER_01And I said to the organizers, well, I teach at a pretty high level of high school, college, graduate students. And how will I teach teachers who are teaching much younger students? And they said, Well, that's what they face all the time. People who teach in early grades have to figure out how to take complex ideas and teach them to young students. So I said, Oh, well, this sounds like fun. So I was talking about the Bill of Rights and the teachers started engaging with me and they said, you would not believe how democratic culture, political culture, filters down to such an early age.

SPEAKER_01And it's part of our political culture. I'm sure it's part of family cultures of democracy, of everybody has a right to speak, and the majority rules. And that's the key while protecting minority rights. And they said kids get that at a really young age. They said we see that in first grade, second grade, third grade. Good. That's why we need to have our political culture and civics taught to students, but also make them feel like it's just a natural part of our culture.

SPEAKER_02And that's also part of the work and research that you do, this focus on civil rights and civil liberties. So when you think of those topics in context to presidential leadership, how do you see the relationship between the presidency and civil rights today in this moment?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think of those presidents who, like Lincoln, for example, in fighting not only to maintain the Union, but in the midst of the Civil War, then realized that he would have to and wanted to get through the Thirteenth Amendment, the Fourteenth Amendment, and the 15th Amendment. So Thirteenth Amendment barring involuntary servitude or slavery, the Fourteenth Amendment, which has become somewhat controversial again by the current president, who is saying that the explicit statement of birthright citizenship, that is, anyone born in the United States is a citizen of the United States in the state wherein he lives.

SPEAKER_01So there's one issue then of a current president who's contradicting the Lincoln view and what were called radical Republicans in those days who were anti-slavery. That was the reason for founding the Republican Party in the 1850s. And Lincoln then, you know, finally takes that up as president. And the 15th Amendment, then, that was ratified in 1869, granting to those who had just been enslaved people the right to vote if they were male. So we have to make that as a point. But the concept of Martin Luther King's the arc of the moral universe bends toward justice.

SPEAKER_01I would say that so many presidents, particularly Lincoln, but also go back to Andrew Jackson. Now he was a slave owner, as many of our founding presidents were, but he also believed in expanding democracy from white male property owners to white male nonproperty owners. Well, that was a huge expansion. We call that Jacksonian democracy. So that's an expansion of civil rights. Then the expansion of eliminating slavery and granting the right to vote, at least in theory, to black men, and then the right for women to vote.

SPEAKER_01But also I would look again at particularly Lyndon Johnson, a president who comes in at a tragic time, the death of President Kennedy by assassination, and Lyndon Johnson sort of picking up that torch that Kennedy talked about passing from one leader to another, and Johnson getting through the 1964 Civil Rights Act, which Kennedy had proposed before his death, the 65 Voting Rights Act, the 1968 Fair Housing Act. But again, let's also think about, you know, 1920 and the amendment that gave women the right to vote.

SPEAKER_01And the fact that Woodrow Wilson was not in favor of that to begin with, but eventually the suffragists, those who supported women's suffrage, convinced him that he should support that. So we see these advances or the bending of that arc towards more democracy and towards more civil rights and liberties. I also think of the role of the Warren Court. Many people disagreed with that and wanted Warren to be impeached, but Chief Justice Earl Warren in the 50s with the Brown case, Brownburst Board of Education, and the expansion of criminal rights in the 50s and 60s.

SPEAKER_01Those are all parts of our history that maybe the president himself didn't have a role in. But it was Dwight Eisenhower who made Earl Warren the Chief Justice. Now we also have to say that he thought that was a mistake in the end because he wasn't quite as liberal as Earl Warren. But we have all elements of our three branches of government, but particularly presidents who've been important in expanding civil rights and liberties.

SPEAKER_02As you were speaking, it made me think of, you know, Wilson, for example, during his presidency, you have World War I happening, and that's not an ideal time to recognize women's right to vote despite these protest picketing that's happening by these suffragists. And I think about all the marches that have been led by the civil rights movement and leaders like King during Kennedy's administration leading up to Johnson taking that office. So I'm curious if you could speak more about how historical context shapes political leadership.

SPEAKER_01That's a great question because it seems to me that let's think of FDR as someone who created an entire Supreme Court. In other words, by the time he died in April of 1945, he had placed all nine members on the court, including the Chief Justice. Although he had to replace the Chief Justice because of a passing. And he chose someone of the opposite party, he chose a Republican, Harlan Stone, because he knew the war was coming and he thought we needed to be as bipartisan as possible.

SPEAKER_01So that's an example, I think, of historical events that are pushing presidents towards a different perspective. But it was also Roosevelt, Franklin Roosevelt, who allowed Japanese Americans to be rounded up and placed in concentration camps after Pearl Harbor, a real blot on his record. And the Supreme Court supported that because, you know, they said it's a time of war, so we have to do this. But then it was Reagan, who's not viewed as a great civil rights advocate or civil libertarian.

SPEAKER_01But during the Reagan administration in the 1980s, the United States admitted to having made a terrible mistake in violation of civil rights and liberties by taking these Japanese Americans away from their homes and their businesses without any indication that any of them had any guilt. And half of them, and it was over 100,000 who were rounded up and put in these camps, half of them had been born in the United States. So in the case of Reagan, he offered apology and$20,000 restitution to anyone who was still surviving.

SPEAKER_01And if they were not surviving, then their heirs received that$20,000. And there's a memorial in Washington near Capitol Hill to those people. In the case of Franklin Roosevelt, also, there were anti-lynching laws that were being introduced in Congress. And his wife, Eleanor, who was a great civil rights advocate and civil libertarian, said, Franklin, can't you support that? And he said, no, because I'll lose the members of my party, the great Democratic, well, how should we call it the one party region of the South where everybody at that time was a Democrat.

SPEAKER_01But many of them who were in Congress for years and had all the seniority and power, they were white supremacists, they were segregationists. And he said, nope, I can't support that. I'll lose their votes on other issues of the New Deal that I need their votes for, on the economy and fighting the Great Depression. And that was the case with Kennedy. Martin Luther King was very upset with him that he didn't move forward more quickly with the Civil Rights Act to try to bar segregation in private business. And finally, Kennedy in 1963 in the summer proposed what became after his death and with Lyndon Johnson pushing it, the Civil Rights Act of 64.

SPEAKER_01So it's not just history that either puts up roadblocks or removes those roadblocks to expanding civil rights and liberties, but often politics itself and partisan politics.

SPEAKER_02It just underscores the complexity and nuance of not just the situation, but of the individual themselves. These are people trying to make hard calls. And there's a lot of things they factor in, and some of them we see as positive and some negative. So thank you for that. That's helpful in contextualizing. And it makes me wonder too, how your work with these oral histories, collecting these oral histories, what they showed you about presidential leadership, especially as you conducted them with different administrations of different political parties.

SPEAKER_01Right. Well, I think of presidential leadership, I actually take a definition of leadership generally, more generically, from the handbook of West Point, the U.S. Military Academy, that talks about leaders having a vision for moving the institution, in the case of presidents, the country, forward in a positive way. Now, obviously, where we all come to have differences is what is a positive movement and what's forward, or some people might want to go backwards in order to go to a different time, or to stop what they see as an extreme vision of civil rights and liberties, since we're on that subject.

SPEAKER_01So I view leadership in that sense of someone who has a vision, in the case of a president for the country to move us in a positive direction. And oftentimes that has been forward, that is moving out of slavery, moving towards women's votes, moving towards civil rights and liberties, moving towards desegregating schools. So that's how I view I view presidential leadership. But I also view it as a form of character, a character trait. And character, as I understand it, comes from the Greek, how life has stamped upon a person certain characteristics.

SPEAKER_01And for a person to be a presidential leader, I think that in my view, they should have stamped upon them from early in life integrity, honesty, truthfulness. They should also have as part of their character, I think, to be a good, effective leader, charisma. And that is either viewed as destined to lead, but also attracting people to support you because it does you no good if you have vision or honesty and integrity if you can't get people to follow you.

SPEAKER_01Now, where is the line, though, between reaching out to people, having charisma, pulling them in, showing them the vision and saying, vote for me, and I will take us in this direction? And what the Greeks called from ancient democracies, city-states, and direct democracy of the people, would be demagoguery. So there is that concept that demagogues can be, and this was what our founders feared the most, including Hamilton, who said the worst of a politician is someone who starts out as paying what he called a courtly obsequiousness to the people, that is, getting them on their side, beginning, as he says, as demagogues and ending up as tyrants.

SPEAKER_01And the definition of demagogue is someone who tells lies and half truths to the people, appealing to their base instincts, and often causing them to pick on or pick out minority groups and disparaging them or taking away from them their civil rights and liberties and getting the people to follow that demagoguery. That was what. The founders feared the most of our democratic republic and its experiment. They wanted the people to be not in charge, but to have a role of those who would be in charge.

SPEAKER_01That is, select them as representatives. That's the concept of republic. But they worried that if you let the people have too much power, they could choose a demagogue, which then causes the republic to collapse.

SPEAKER_02As I think about those characteristics you just mentioned, I wonder that lack of charisma that I think Madison didn't quite possess.

SPEAKER_01Well, I certainly think of him as a major leader by virtue of his being the father of the Constitution and the fact that he was elected twice to presidency. Imagine if he had had charisma. What he could have been our king. So I guess it also says that leadership can come in many forms. And thank goodness he didn't have to worry about modern media because there was a funny Saturday Night Live scene back in the George H.W. Bush era.

SPEAKER_01H.W. Bush, the first George Bush to be president, was very athletic. He was tall and lean and athletic all through his presidency. He had been on a really good, strong team of baseball players at Yale and had gone to the first World Series of college baseball. I think he played first base and he was really good. And so he had this look of a president and a war hero that he was from World War II. And so Saturday Night Live contrasting him with Michael Dukakis, who didn't particularly look athletic and was rather short of stature.

SPEAKER_01And so they did this chart where they said Lincoln was 6'4, he was a great president. Bush is 6'1, he will be a great president. John Kennedy was 6'1, he would be a great president. James Madison was, was it five? 5'1. 5'1. I was going to say 5'2. So shorter than my little petite mother. And then they said, and Michael Dukakis was something like 5'8 or 9, you know, he can't be president. So there is something about how presidents look. And there have actually been studies that have been done of leaders in the military that they tend to be tall and strong looking and athletic and lean and handsome in the case of men.

SPEAKER_01And I notice this when I see four-star generals and admirals, many of whom we have interviewed for our oral history project, who've gone on to have the top military careers and then go into working for presidents and/or serving as head of the joint chiefs or vice chairs of the joint chiefs. So Madison didn't have to worry about modern media, what he looked like, and he was absolutely brilliant to get us to our current constitution and to be president and to pick Dolly as his spouse and to get us through the War of 1812.

SPEAKER_02Yes, him and Dolly together, I think, are just a formidable couple between his intellect and then her charisma and political mind.

SPEAKER_01I absolutely think that's the case as somebody who also studies first ladies that and uh Catherine Algore's book about the perfect union, which describes both their marriage, but also the fact that Dolly, as you say, with her charisma and her extroverted personality, as we develop these two parties in Washington, she was able to bring people together with soirees and parties at their home. So she was the perfect mate for him.

SPEAKER_02And when you think about those characteristics in the presidents today and of those that you've interviewed, what can you tell us about how those manifest in that very important role of the executive branch?

SPEAKER_01Well, certainly the presidents I've gotten to see in person over the years or see in public or meet and interview them. So one is Bill Clinton. We spent four days with him on top of his library in Little Rock around his dining room table in his apartment there, chatting away with him for an entire day each time. And it really, when you get to see a person speak that open and freely about their lives and their biography and presidency, uh his is not released yet, so we do keep these confidentials so people will feel that they can be candid until they then release their words to us.

SPEAKER_01And then we can release them if they wish to the public. But we say to them, don't hold back. We want you to be candid for history. So don't edit yourself into the microphone. So with Bill Clinton, you could just see his charisma. He just has a presence when he walks into the room. He's tall. He's even as as he ages and becomes a bit enfeebled, as older people sometimes can. I will give another example that people might contrast, particularly in their personal character, and that is between Bill Clinton and George W.

SPEAKER_01Bush, because he famously at age 40, according to the stories, Laura Bush, a formidable spouse, he was drinking too much. And she supposedly said, look, it's either Jim Beam or me. So you pick, but you know, you can't keep doing this. And then he he got religion, he became an evangelical, and he got his head on straight. He could stop drinking. And I think maybe people would disagree with his policies, as they might Bill Clinton's, but he was honest. He was an honest person. And yet he didn't do so well in television.

SPEAKER_01News conferences were not his strength, like a John Kennedy who was very witty and could answer every question. George W. Bush wasn't like that. But when I met him in person in 2007 and spent, this was not part of oral history, but spent about an hour with him at the University of Louisville where he was speaking and then got to engage with him one-to-one in a grip and grin photo. I was completely bowled over by his personality. And so in our oral histories, as we would speak to the people who worked with him, we haven't yet got a chance to speak to him, but for all the top people who worked with him, I would say, was he just not so good on TV?

SPEAKER_01Or what was it that he became nervous or his personality wasn't suited to the microphone and to the video camera? Because he didn't seem like that at all in person. And it also helped me to understand how he won the governorship of Texas twice, including defeating Ann Richards, the incumbent governor I had met at Sweet Bar College when she came to speak. And she was amazingly charismatic. And everybody, all of our female students at Sweetbar, still in all women's college here in Virginia, were really drawn to her. Whether they agreed with her politics or not, I couldn't believe W.

SPEAKER_01Bush had defeated her. But he had a really good way of relating to people, particularly in person, and obviously could do well enough to speak to big groups and then well enough to be on TV. But that wasn't his strength as it was for a Clinton or a Reagan or a John Kennedy.

SPEAKER_02When you think about all of these interviews that you've conducted, are there certain takeaways that stick with you most?

SPEAKER_01There are. And so they speak in complete sentences, complete paragraphs. And then our system, as I've alluded to in our oral history program, is that to get people to speak candidly, we say, don't edit yourself now.

SPEAKER_01You don't have to sign any kind of agreement at this point. We will send you a very lightly edited transcript. By that I mean taking out the ums and ahs and a few nonfluencies, except the military people tend not to have those. And then we send those off to them and we say, you can make any changes you wish, any edits you wish, and then we will input those edits for you, and that will become the authoritative record of the interview. Within a few months, they send back probably very few edits because they speak in complete sentences, they speak in complete paragraphs, and they're diplomatic.

SPEAKER_01That's how they rose in a 30-year career to be a four-star officer. And then they say, and it's ready to clear. You can go ahead and again, our system is we wait till we are finished with the project, then we release. But I am just so impressed with our military leaders. Now, in terms of political leaders, I'm most impressed with both parties. We get to the end of an interview and we always say, thank you for your service to our country. It doesn't matter whether we as individuals who have our own policy preferences or partisan backgrounds, it doesn't matter if we agree with their policies, but anybody who would go from what they could make in a private law firm or a private business to taking a big salary cut and being beaten up in the press and having to, if they have to be confirmed by the Senate, beaten up in the Senate, to serve our country deserves to be thanked for that.

SPEAKER_01And that's what impresses me, that even people that I've seen on TV, I don't agree with their policy preferences, I may not be of their party. And then I get into a room with them and I find them fascinating. And one example was Dick Cheney. And, you know, he had a Gadarth Vader reputation. And one colleague of mine, the University of Virginia, said, I wouldn't be caught dead in the same room with Dick Cheney. And I said, well, then you would have missed out. We spent five days with him at his dining table in Jackson Hole, Wyoming.

SPEAKER_01And was he warm and fuzzy? No, I wouldn't call him warm and fuzzy, but he was charming in his own way. And what I appreciated about him, he was so genuine. He's a conservative man from Wyoming. He hunts and fishes and he has conservative policy views. And yes, you could take real exception to his support of the Iraq war, for example. But I I just found him very charismatic in his own way. And as my colleague Russell Riley says, who's been at this, I've been at it 14 years, he's been at it twice that long.

SPEAKER_01He says there's no place you'd rather be than sitting in a room with these people who have made history and learning about them as individuals, their careers, their biographies, and their policy preferences and what they did in working for our presidents and for our country.

SPEAKER_02Barbara, as we wrap up our conversation today, taking all this research you've done, these interviews, what do you hope to see for the future of our democracy, especially when you think about leadership as you've described it?

SPEAKER_01I will end by saying I wish that we could get back to more bipartisanship. I know that's a bit of a cliche now, and a lot of people don't have hope for that, but I still have hope that we could return to those days when not everybody got along and we had the McCarthy era and we had difficulties to be sure, riots in the streets and protests. But I'm gonna give you the example of two oral histories that the Miller Center conducted. So we've talked about the Bush 43 project, but also Edward Kennedy and his family came to the Miller Center before I arrived in 2010.

SPEAKER_01They came in the early 2000s as he was approaching his 40th anniversary in the Senate. And think of all the history he had seen in his family alone, much less, you know, going back through all of his political work. And so that's our largest oral history. If people go on MillerCenter.org and are interested in any of these, all of the cleared interviews are posted for all of these projects. For the Ted Kennedy project, he did 29 interviews, and we have over 280 interviews with his staff, with his family, with his colleagues on both sides of the aisle.

SPEAKER_01And I point to the fact that he and George W. Bush got along. Now, was Ted Kennedy a partisan and could rip the other party up one side and down the other? But his good friend Alan Simpson, the Republican from Wyoming, senator, said, Boy, Ted could just slash you up on the floor of the Senate, then we'd go out and have a drink. Maybe to excess in some instances for Ted Kennedy. But when George W. Bush became president, he invited Ted Kennedy, his family to the White House to watch the movie 13 Days, which had just come out about the Cuban Missile Crisis and Ted Kennedy's brother, John Kennedy.

SPEAKER_01And they went. So, you know, it wasn't people saying, no, I don't like that president, I'm not going. Ted Kennedy's family went. They watched the movie. Imagine how moving that was in the White House, where Ted Kennedy had come to visit his brother when he was president. And then Ted Kennedy wrote a thank you note in his own handwriting that they display at the Bush Library in Dallas. And Ted Kennedy said, you know, dear President Bush, thank you so much for showing us that movie about my brother and treating us to supper. My family loved it. I hope I'll be coming back to the White House to sign some bills where you will be working with me on health care and education.

SPEAKER_01And sure enough, on No Child Left Behind, they worked together across the aisle, as Ted Kennedy did with Jud Gregg, the Republican from New Hampshire. Those were the days, and I call Ted Kennedy the bipartisan partisan, because again, he was a Democrat to the core, but he could reach out across the aisle. And what Alan Simpson said about him was he didn't have to get the whole loaf. He would work with you across the aisle to get a portion of what he thought was right for the country, a half a loaf, a quarter loaf. And so he would work with Republicans on that.

SPEAKER_01And I happen to think generally for the good of the country, you know, I think it's important for children to have health care. And so that's what was one of the things he worked on. And he did it across the aisle. Bush did it across the aisle. I hope we can get back to that someday.

SPEAKER_02Well, thank you so much for your time. This conversation has taught us about the complexities and demands that the presidency entails, but also these different political offices and what we should be looking for in a leader, but also qualities we can maybe develop in ourselves if we are seeking to lead. And at this moment, I think we all need to really participate in democracy and take that step to lead. So thank you so much for sharing with us today.

SPEAKER_01Well, thank you, Katie. It was my pleasure and certainly an honor to be part of the story of Montpelier and Mr. Madison and Dolly as well.

SPEAKER_02And thank you to all of our listeners who are joining us today. We hope you will subscribe to the show and share it with family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode