This episode launches a special five-part miniseries examining James Madison's role in the American Revolution and the founding of the United States. Part of Montpelier's commemoration of the 250th anniversary of American independence, this series is funded by a grant from the Virginia American Revolution 250 Commission in partnership with Virginia Humanities. Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey talks with Dr. Lynn Uzzell about Madison's formative years - from his education at the College of New Jersey (Princeton) under John Witherspoon to his early political activism in 1770s Virginia. The conversation explores how Madison's exposure to Scottish Enlightenment philosophy and religious diversity shaped his lifelong commitment to freedom of conscience. At just 25 years old, Madison contributed critical language to Virginia's 1776 Declaration of Rights, replacing "toleration" with "free exercise of religion" - phrasing that would later appear in the First Amendment. The episode traces Madison's service during the Revolutionary War through the Continental Congress and his growing recognition of the weaknesses in the Articles of Confederation, setting the stage for his pivotal role at the Constitutional Convention of 1787.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackley and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
SPEAKER_00Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, with James Madison's Montpelier. This episode is one installment of a five-part miniseries funded by a grant from the Virginia American Revolution 250 Commission in partnership with the Virginia Humanities. Now, this special series is part of Montpelier's broader effort to commemorate the 250th anniversary of America's founding with the signing of the Declaration of Independence in 1776.
SPEAKER_01And of course, there's much more to the story towards American independence. In this episode, we're tracing the journey of a young James Madison and his role in the American Revolution. Joining me today is Dr. Lynn Uzel, who's an associate professor of political science at Bethel University. And she's also been a guest at the podcast for several times now. So it's wonderful to welcome you back to the show, Lynn.
SPEAKER_02Well, Katie, and it's wonderful to be here. I love Montpelier, and it's been too long since I set foot on these premises.
SPEAKER_01And you actually did a stint here at Montpelier at the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution.
SPEAKER_02That's right. I was four years the scholar in residence here at the Center for the Constitution, and it was four of some of the best years of my life.
SPEAKER_01So it really is special to have you here in the studio, again, kind of back here at Montpelier. Now, Lynn, as we start off today's conversation, you know, we think about James Madison and his early years. So he's born in Virginia Colony in 1751, and he enters the world as a British subject. So the identity, him as this British subject is really shaping how he understands his place in society as he's growing up at Montpelier.
SPEAKER_01But Madison's path to adulthood looks a little different than some of his friends and colleagues. In 1769, when he's 18, he leaves Virginia Colony to study at the College of New Jersey, which is today Princeton. And this really sets him apart from his fellow Virginians like Thomas Jefferson, James Monroe, you know, John Marshall, who all attended the College of William and Mary. At Princeton, Madison encounters a very different kind of intellectual environment, really steeped in Scottish Enlightenment thought.
SPEAKER_01The college's president, John Witherspoon, himself, a signer of the Declaration of Independence, becomes an important mentor to Madison, exposing him to new ideas about government, liberty, equality. And I think it's important that we take a moment just to talk about the Scottish Enlightenment. What is this? Why is it so significant and revolutionary? What is it about this thinking that is important in understanding Madison as a young man in college?
SPEAKER_02So the Scottish Enlightenment is obviously part of the larger Enlightenment project. And so it comes from several different individual thinkers. And they are not in agreement with each other. And not only that, but later scholars don't always agree what it is that they were saying, and to what degree they were consistent with specifically modern thinking, and to what degree they were really hearkening back to some older considerations. For one example of this, John Locke in his essay concerning human understanding had had a radical kind of epistemology.
SPEAKER_02Epistemology is the study of how we know stuff. And John Locke was saying that unlike what the classical thinkers have said, we don't really know for sure moral truths. So we can gather some things by empirical evidence, things that are seen through the senses, you know, touch and hearing and sight, and those things that we can know. But moral truths are something that we have to deduce, and therefore it requires something like a philosopher in order to come to any kind of moral realization.
SPEAKER_02And this kind of thinking some people adopt, but there is more of a reaction against it. And this goes in two different directions according to the Scottish Enlightenment. So on the one hand, you've got Hume, David Hume is part of the Scottish Enlightenment, and he turns into a complete skeptic. He says that Locke was correct, that there are no things that we know intuitively, but that means that essentially we don't know anything. And on the other hand, you've got Scottish Enlightenment figures like Lord Keynes who say Locke was wrong about that.
SPEAKER_02That in fact we do know moral truths intuitively because we have a moral sense. And that is also something that Adam Smith is going to say, also part of the Scottish Enlightenment. So when you talk about the Scottish Enlightenment, you know, you again have to be more specific, which one of the Scottish Enlightenment. And a figure like Jefferson clearly embraced the moral sense school of thought in the Scottish Enlightenment and explicitly rejected thinkers like Hume.
SPEAKER_02And so Madison was, as you say, thoroughly steeped in this because he went to the College of New Jersey, later Princeton, which was different both because it drew more from the Scottish Enlightenment and also because it was Presbyterian, whereas William and Mary was Anglican, later Episcopal. And so Madison got his first taste of religious descent there. And I think that that had a large influence on his later thinking about religious freedom and why that was so important to him, even though ironically Jefferson was the other major figure about religious freedom and he got his education at William and Mary, but he happened to fall in with some rather free thinkers there.
SPEAKER_02And therefore, that's how he came by his bona fides as an advocate of religious freedom.
SPEAKER_01To that point, Lynn, Madison, yes, he is, you know, a believer of the Church of Anglican, he's Anglican. That is the official kind of religion of the colony of Virginia. But because Madison, again, kind of unlike Jefferson and Monroe, he's going to this school where he is interacting with people of different religious backgrounds, much more so than he would had he stayed in Virginia. And freedom of religion, freedom of conscience becomes a galvanizing point in Madison's life.
SPEAKER_01It is kind of the reason why he gets into politics when he's in his twenties. So, how does he take these ideas of the Scottish Enlightenment, of his experience interacting with different people in New Jersey and bring it back to Montpelier? Again, this is kind of like a young Madison in his mid-20s. Like, what's going on in his mind?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's an interesting question. And sometimes we like to think of these founding fathers. We see their portraits when they were painted in their 40s and 50s and older. And we say, well, that's how he always was. But there was a time when James Madison was a callo youth. And if you look at some of his early letters, they're exuberant sometimes. And so he is writing to a college friend asking his friend who is in Philadelphia to explain to him what the history of religious freedom is there.
SPEAKER_02And he writes how he longs to be back and breathing the free air of Pennsylvania. And he's contrasting it to what he sees as a very repressive religious freedom tradition in Virginia, because Virginia does not have a very good record in the 1770s for giving even toleration for religious dissenters. And Madison writes about this in his autobiography, that even in his youngest years, he is advocating for certain ministers who get thrown in jail.
SPEAKER_02And he says, for no other reason than passing out pamphlets, which he says in the main were rather orthodox. But if they were at all deviating from the official state religion in Virginia, then that makes you liable to arrest. And therefore, on the one hand, Madison is longing to breathe the free air of Pennsylvania. On the other hand, he is very young and not always consistent. And so in the first rush of military enthusiasm, as Virginia begins resisting the English, he is bragging about how they are limiting the rights of some loyalist minister to speak his mind.
SPEAKER_02And so the later advocate for freedom of thought and freedom of speech and freedom of religion is engaging in this braggadiccio about how this minister, if he keeps it up, is going to find himself in a surplus of tar and feathers.
SPEAKER_01I have to try to put myself into Madison's shoes as he's returning to Virginia from the College of New Jersey. He's had this profound experience there. And as he returns, he's serving as a tutor to his younger siblings. And he's trying to figure out, you know, what's my career path? What am I going to do? You know, he's he's not uh overseeing the plantation yet, um, but he clearly has this great education. He is an intellectual, he thrives in that environment. And it's kind of at this point where there's a lot of um grumblings from the colonies about the British Crown stepping on their rights, you know, in 1770 we had the Boston Massacre, uh, 1773, the Boston Tea Party.
SPEAKER_01And even though, you know, Virginia is geographically far away, you know, Madison is still hearing about these things. What is he thinking? What is he saying about these almost early echoes of revolution?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I don't think we have a lot of letters from him at this period, but the letters that do survive show, once again, a Madison who is all in for the American cause. And I think a lot of this does come from his College of New Jersey Princeton experience, in which you've got a lot of Whigs. And uh, so this is the political party that is going to champion the Enlightenment principles that is later going to figure uh with such a large part both in the Virginia Declaration of Rights and also the American Declaration of Independence.
SPEAKER_02And so these are the principles that Madison has completely imbibed. And even though, especially in his more mature years, he's going to put his own individual stamp on them. At this time, we can see that he is entirely in favor of defending American natural rights against the oppressor, which is Great Britain.
SPEAKER_01And as you noted, Lynn, Madison is becoming very passionate about freedom of conscience, freedom of religion, particularly because he sees people here in Virginia, Baptist preachers being persecuted. This is around 1773, 1774. What is going on? Like he's feeling kind of inspired from there until, you know, we have the signing of the declaration in 1776. What's going on with Madison in these two years in between as he's starting to kind of tiptoe into the political realm?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there there are a couple of years that you already alluded to this. Madison seems to be where so many young people are, and they haven't figured out yet just what they're going to do with their lives. So he sets himself a course of reading on law, and he's wondering, does he have a future in that? But he admits to his friend that he finds it pretty dry. And so even though Madison has, you know, for a non-lawyer, a pretty good legal education, it's not something that inspires him.
SPEAKER_02And the road towards military glory is closed for him because he has a stint in the Orange County Committee of Public Safety. And his father has actually some rank in this local committee, which is training essentially for a local militia. And during the training exercises, Madison has some kind of fit. And Lynn Cheney, in her book about Madison, her biography, thinks that this is an epileptic seizure.
SPEAKER_02And we don't know for sure, but it's probably a good guess. He he later describes his fits as like an epileptic episode. So this puts him out of commission for at least a few months, but also makes it clear that he's not really military material. And so some of his first real public acts is when he serves in the Virginia Assembly. Now he is serving there in the important year of 1776. And we must remember that as much as we glorify Jefferson when he is in Philadelphia writing the Declaration of Independence, a month before he gets put on the committee to draft the Declaration of Independence, he's begging to come home back to Virginia because he knows he has it rumored that Virginia is going to write its own constitution.
SPEAKER_02And that's where the action is. Jefferson says, because if we don't write good constitutions, then our whole breakaway from England is for nothing. We might as well just keep the bad constitution that we're already under. So he understands that even the most successful war for independence will be a failure if they can't replace their current political association with better ones. So that's the enviable position that Madison is in.
SPEAKER_02He is down in Williamsburg being part of the committee that's drafting the new constitution.
SPEAKER_01And these colonies need constitutions because at this point they're still under colonial government. So if there's discussion about breaking away from the crown, they need some kind of government structure for Virginia if this is going to happen.
SPEAKER_02That's exactly right. And so the Continental Congress actually specifically puts out a recommendation to the states. And it has to be a recommendation because Congress has no power over the states. But the Congress is recommending to the states that they begin drafting their own constitutions because the only other governing structure they have are these sort of royal charters, which are soon going to be dissolved when they break away from England.
SPEAKER_01Now, 1776, Madison is 25 years old. Can you describe this scene that he's walking into as this young man? You know, he doesn't have a ton of experience in politics. Who is he interacting with at this convention while this constitution for Virginia is being written?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so his first acquaintance with Thomas Jefferson is going to be later that year, but they're not going to be close friends for another couple of years after that. But in this circle, he is interacting with George Mason, who is an extremely important statesman in Virginia, probably one of the most famous at the time. And he is the main drafter of the Virginia Constitution and Declaration of Rights. And also Patrick Henry, who is a lion among his contemporaries, and especially for his oratorical abilities.
SPEAKER_02So the young James Madison, just 25 years old, just a few years out of college, is going to tentatively put forth his own amendment to the Declaration of Rights that George Mason has just drafted. And George Mason has a beautifully written provision protecting religious freedom, but he is calling for the fullest toleration of freedom of conscience.
SPEAKER_02And Madison is objecting to that. As we said, this was one of his most important political emphases. He wanted to advance religious freedom, and he thought that the language of toleration, which harkens back to John Locke's letter concerning toleration, was insufficient. After being educated by the likes of Witherspoon at the College of New Jersey, he thought that religious freedom had to be more extensive than that. And so he wanted to replace the language of toleration with free exercise of religion.
SPEAKER_02Now you recognize that language. Later it's going to show up in the First Amendment. And Madison first has it inserted here. But he's shy, he's modest, he knows that no one is going to take him seriously. And so he asks for an ally to be his frontman to actually ask for the amendment. That frontman is Patrick Henry. And so Patrick Henry proposes Madison's amendment, which calls for the free exercise of religion, and it also calls for no special remuneration or penalty based on anybody's religion.
SPEAKER_02And Patrick Henry obligingly proposes that. But then someone points out that if they put that into the Constitution, then that would prevent them from establishing a religion or paying for the promoting of religion. And Patrick Henry says, oh, that's not what I meant. So therefore, he willingly revokes that part of Madison's proposal. And so the free exercise language gets substituted for toleration, but the other provisions that Madison wanted in there get taken out that no remuneration can be given on account of religion.
SPEAKER_02So flash forward in 1785, and Madison and Patrick Henry are going to be on opposite sides of this question. So Henry, who thinks of himself as an advocate for religious freedom, also thinks it's important to lay an assessment, a tax, in order to pay for religious instruction. And Madison is going to object to that and write the anonymous memorial and remonstrance against religious assessments.
SPEAKER_01It's so fascinating to think about, you know, this is almost where the true articulation of what becomes freedom of religion and the First Amendment occurs. It's in this drafting Madison's suggestion that he makes with the Virginia Constitution. And we talk about Madison as more of an introvert. He is very timid. He's kind of short in stature. He's just not that big personality in the room. But when we also kind of reference these moments where he's providing kind of critical intellect into these very important rights and structures, I see a level of confidence there too.
SPEAKER_01He understands what needs to happen and why. And he's willing to put it out there. Even if he doesn't put his name on it, he still kind of takes that step and has that confidence to propose it to this group.
SPEAKER_02And I do think that that is one of the keys to Madison's success, is that he cares so much more about getting his ideas out there and accomplishing his political goals than getting credit for it. And if you're willing to allow other people to get credit and be the frontman, then you're going to be able to accomplish so much more.
SPEAKER_01So as we, you know, have the Virginia Constitution being drafted, and meanwhile, there's plans for Jefferson in this drafting of the Declaration of Independence. Can you kind of just paint the picture of the timeline of this? What's happening after the Virginia Constitution is drafted?
SPEAKER_02So this gets drafted, I believe it is completed in May, because we know that Thomas Jefferson had a copy of the Virginia Declaration of Rights. And we know that some of that language made it into the Declaration of Independence. So that's one way in which Virginia's activities are influencing the nation. So after the Declaration of Independence is written, then it is sent out for the states so that the states are all aware of the new political reality.
SPEAKER_02And at this point, Madison is sort of working his way up in the ranks of political society. He continues to serve in the Virginia Assembly. He does lose one election. And according to his own account, he lost it because he was trying to teach the voters true Republican probity by refusing to offer them treats on election day. In other words, the bowls of rum punch that candidates are expected to provide for their electorate.
SPEAKER_02And he thought that this was a form of bribery and he. He was going to refuse. And so naturally he lost the election. He said that uh was the only election that he did lose, but very soon he was also elected to the Continental, later Confederation Congress. So it's called the Continental Congress until they ratify the Articles of Confederation. And that doesn't happen until 1781. And so Madison is serving at this time, which is a very precarious time for Congress, because they still don't have official recognition as a political entity, not until the Articles of Confederation are ratified by all 13 former colonies, now states.
SPEAKER_02And because that doesn't happen until 1781, they are conducting a war, trying to raise money, and they do not have official status. And even when the Articles of Confederation are ratified, well, we know how weak those Articles of Confederation were. They couldn't raise money. And so almost immediately after they're ratified, Madison there in Congress is trying to get it amended. I mean, his first proposal to amend it is like two weeks after ratification.
SPEAKER_02And most of his proposals have to do with better ways of raising money. So he's drafting these reports, they are getting sent out into the states. And then after his three-year term is up, according to the Articles of Confederation, members can only represent their states for three consecutive years. Then they have to be out of office for three years. So when he fulfills three years in 1783, he has to go back home to Virginia, and that's when he starts serving in the Virginia Assembly again for another three years until his period of banishment is over and he goes back into the Confederation Congress.
SPEAKER_02And by that time, he is working towards the Federal Convention in Philadelphia.
SPEAKER_01So when we think about, you know, this uh celebration of 250 years America since it's been founded, Madison wasn't there drafting and signing the Declaration of Independence because he's in Virginia drafting this very important state constitution that informs Jefferson in the drafting of the Declaration of Independence. I also want to note the role that Madison plays, again, not serving in the militia as part of the revolution, but from 1776 after the Declaration of Independence is drafted through 1783 as this war is being fought.
SPEAKER_01You noted yourself, Lynn, this is a very precarious time. There's kind of a government, but you know, we're still at war with the British Crown trying to establish our own country, our own government. And I can only imagine the experience that Madison gained and the insight. Obviously, it was really pivotal because early on, I would say more than some of his contemporaries, he sees the flaws of this government that's put in place, the Articles of Confederation.
SPEAKER_01And he was long against it. He saw a lot of areas for improvement, so much so that by the time they're calling this constitutional convention in 1787, Madison's going to this convention in Philadelphia not to amend the articles. He's ready to kind of throw it all away. He wants to start over. And he drafts a very detailed plan for what this new structure of government should look like. And arguably, I think he gets a lot of these ideas from experiences he's had from his college days to serving in that Virginia convention in 1776, serving in government through the American Revolution up until that point in the 1780s.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, all of that is true. And another important point that uh some people may not realize is that Madison was by no means the first of the advocates of a convention to change the articles. Although he was trying to change the articles almost immediately, he really was trying to work within the system of the articles. I think that Madison, um, Lance Banning has an argument to this extent that he was always a partisan of Virginian interests. He was a nationalist as well.
SPEAKER_02He believed in the American Union, but he was also defending the interests of his own state. And therefore, he did not immediately want to turn the articles into a kind of national government. But the more and more experience he had with the weaknesses, the more he realized that more radical improvements needed to be made. And it was really, I believe, Alexander Hamilton who first came up with the idea that we should have a convention and just make these radical changes.
SPEAKER_02And Madison was not at first on board. And even when he agreed to go to the precursor of the Philadelphia Convention, this is the is known as the Annapolis Convention, in which all of the states were invited to attend, but only for the purpose of working out certain questions of trade and commerce. Madison had very little hope. He had very little optimism about what could be accomplished. But nevertheless, he thought it was better than nothing. So he went. And I think it was at the Annapolis convention that he turned into a convert.
SPEAKER_02And it was probably the influence of Alexander Hamilton, who was also there. Only five states attended, and therefore they could not accomplish any official business because they didn't have a quorum. So the only thing they were able to do was to plan for a new convention in Philadelphia in 1787. And from that moment on, Madison is full steam ahead. And first in the Virginia Assembly, where he's still serving, and then later that spring of 1787 in the Confederation Congress, he is at the forefront of trying to convince his own state and the other states to all send delegations to Philadelphia so that we can have a true constitutional convention.
SPEAKER_01Lynn, as we wrap up our conversation today and we think back on this chapter in Madison's life and in our country's history too, what lessons can we draw from this? And how can we kind of imply it today?
SPEAKER_02That's a great question. And I've been thinking quite a lot about this. A lot of people think that we're in the midst of a great deal of turmoil and partisanship. And Madison himself lived through a great deal of turmoil and partisanship. And I think one of the lessons is a kind of Madison moderation. And I don't mean by moderation that he adopted some middle position on every issue. Like if you have team blue and you have team red, your position has to be purple.
SPEAKER_02But what it does mean is that even though Madison had very principled positions, which he argued with beautiful theoretical purity, he also had to confront the political reality around him. And he had to adjust what he wanted to accomplish with what he was able to accomplish because of the differences of opinion. And I think today, a lot of times people think that the political object is to destroy the opposite and rival party.
SPEAKER_02And first of all, that's unrealistic. It's not going to happen. Both of the parties are here for a reason. Read Federalist number 10. Parties and factions are always with us. But it's also just damaging. And I think that if we adopted more of the practical politics of Madison, the idea that you have clear in your mind what your principled position is, but you also have clear in your mind the extent to which you can accomplish it and you have to bake into the system the limitations because of the political situation, that I think that it would improve the politics all the way around.
SPEAKER_01Well, Lynn, thank you so much for your time today. This kind of insight into Madison's early years and how his experience at college and then his early political service, I think, gives us a really good sense of how he's contributing to these big moments in American history. You know, maybe they're not the ones that immediately come to mind when you think about 1776, but these are the moments that are shaping what our nation becomes. So thank you again for being here with us today at Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. It is my pleasure, and I never tire of talking things Madison, so anytime, Katie.
SPEAKER_01And thank you to all of our listeners. Please subscribe and share the show with your family and friends. And tune in again for our next installment of this special miniseries on the 250th anniversary of America's founding as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...