Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

The Birth of Executive Power: Creating the American Presidency

Oct 24, 202428 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Dr. Lindsay Chervinsky, Executive Director of the George Washington Presidential Library, joins host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey to explore the evolution of presidential power from the nation's founding through the early republic. Drawing from her new book "Making the Presidency: John Adams and the Precedents That Forged The Republic," she discusses how George Washington and John Adams shaped the executive office, established crucial precedents, and navigated the delicate balance between effective governance and preventing monarchical power.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Black and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. As we go into election season, many of us may be thinking about the office of the president and what that office entails. What powers does the executive branch have, and what does that mean for us the people? And were those powers intended by James Madison and the other authors of the Constitution?

SPEAKER_01And I couldn't think of a better person to have this discussion with than Dr. Lindsay Travinsky. She is the executive director of the George Washington Presidential Library. She is also a scholar with several books, including The Cabinet, George Washington and the Creation of an American Institution. And a newer book she released September of 2024, entitled Making the Presidency, John Adams and the Precedents That Forged the Republic. Lindsay, it's wonderful to have you here at Montpelier with us today.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for having me. I'm excited to be here. As we start thinking about the office of the president, can you take us back to the very early days, just as the Constitution is being drafted in 1787, and what those founders were thinking about when they were drafting this document that was outlining what the office, what powers, what reach, what influence that president would have?

SPEAKER_00So I think there were two big concerns on their minds. So the first was trying to find a balance between the lack of executive power or centralized power that they had experienced during the Articles of Confederation. They had recognized that governing with just one congressional body was maybe not a great idea because trying to get everyone to agree was nearly impossible. And they referred to this as they needed an executive that had energy, had the ability to push things forward. And yet they were trying to balance that against the idea of a monarchy, which they had quite explicitly rejected and had just concluded a war against four years prior.

SPEAKER_00So trying to find that middle ground where someone would have enough authority and power to get things done, but also not be a danger like a monarchy would was their primary concern. The second main question was really a situational one. And it was that talking about the presidency and what it would look like and how it would operate, with the limitations of its office and what to do if someone acted poorly was really, really awkward with George Washington in the room, because everyone understood that he was going to be the first president if this constitution worked.

SPEAKER_00And so they were talking about this office in theoretical terms with the unspoken realization, but the shared realization, that the first president was there. And they really did genuinely trust him to use that authority because he had already demonstrated that he could do so in a trustworthy way. He had given back his enormous power after the end of the Revolutionary War. And that I think allowed them to frankly leave a lot of things undecided, to leave a lot of the presidency unwritten, to leave a lot of vagueness in the language and a lot of decisions to sort of be determined by the first people in office, trusting that he would establish good precedence for those that followed.

SPEAKER_00And so I think those are the two kind of defining pieces of the office that's worth noting from the Constitutional Convention.

SPEAKER_01You mentioned a really important point. Before the Constitution is drafted, this period between the end of the American Revolution, 1783, until 1787, there is just one branch of government that's governing this newly founded country. It's the Congress. And as you reference, there's a lot of fear about if we have a president, how do we ensure it doesn't turn into a monarchy? And you reference this trust, particularly with George Washington, everybody in the room knows he's going to be president.

SPEAKER_01What does that look like as the United States is now guided by this U.S. Constitution? How does he take the helm and lead that office?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think Washington really initially entered office fully expecting to use the office the way the delegates at the Constitutional Convention had anticipated. And that's really important because they had been very clear that they did not want a cabinet or an executive council. They had explicitly rejected several proposals for that type of institution and instead really prefer to the Senate as an advisory body on foreign affairs because the Senate was indirectly selected by the state legislatures and they figured the states would select safe, quote-unquote safe advisors or experienced advisors.

SPEAKER_00And if these advisors turned out to be bad, then the states would replace them. So it felt like a good way to ensure that the people advising the president were even indirectly responsible to the American people and were going to be the right type of people advising the president. And that was fully Washington's expectation. And he met with the Senate just a couple of months into his presidency. It went very badly. The Senate acted like a legislative body and wanted to sort of deliberate privately and not have him involved. And he had wanted to see those interactions such that he could understand the different perspectives and points of view and options to consider all of the details.

SPEAKER_00And on his way out, he reportedly said that he would never again return to the Senate for advice. And he never again returned to the Senate for advice. So I think the main takeaway from this story is that this interaction occurs in August of 1789, which is just a couple of months into his presidency. And that means that a key element of the constitution that the delegates had put in place didn't work just a couple of months into its practice. And so Washington really, I think, approached the presidency with a great deal of experimentation, with a great deal of flexibility, sort of acting in response in real time to the obstacles and challenges that faced him, always doing his best to stick to the spirit of the Constitution, but recognizing that the goal of the Constitution was good governance.

SPEAKER_00And he was much more interested in being a good executive than he was in limiting himself to the explicit text of the document.

SPEAKER_01And is that how he defined that role, this office of the president, especially when we think about who came after him?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think that he defined the presidency very much as a strong central executive. He did believe in the importance of executive power and while also very much respecting and acknowledging the right of congressional oversight and the important roles of the other branches of government. So he was not talking about a president that was supreme over the other branches by any stretch. But he understood that the whole impetus for the Constitution was that there hadn't been this strong executive. And so you need to have that in order for the system to actually work.

SPEAKER_00And then his goal in establishing precedents for those that would follow him was building up an institution that did have that strong power that could act decisively, especially in moments of crisis, but also establishing precedent for respect for the people, respect for the office, what we would call small R Republican virtue. So this is, you know, sort of acting within a certain amount of decorum and restraint and service. These were qualities that he really tried to exhibit in the office, expecting that his successors would follow that example.

SPEAKER_01And your recent book, Making the Presidency, is about John Adams. And from my elementary middle school American history education, Adams kind of gets lost in the shadow of George Washington. Did you find that in your research and writing of that book?

SPEAKER_00Well, that is such a good, accurate interpretation for how they saw it too. So one of I think John Adams' biggest contributions is a recognition that whoever came after Washington was going to have a terrible time. Because despite being a flawed and real human, Washington was revered by the American people and had a stature that was unlike anyone else and unlike any other president ever will have. And that is a very unique position to basically have a lot of your choices and your powers being untested and unchallenged.

SPEAKER_00And so Adams knew that whoever came second was going to fall short of that very lofty image. And yet he did it anyway. He was willing to be unpopular to prove that someone else could be in this office. And that was a real question. Like there were genuine concerns by the American people about whether or not this office could be trusted with someone else at the helm, whether or not the powers were too great or too little, how the other branches of government would interact, whether they would try and kind of steamroll the president, whether foreign nations would respect it or interact with it.

SPEAKER_00And so that was really for me actually the motivating question of starting this book is okay, so Washington establishes all these precedents, but he was so unlike anyone else, how did they continue? And that was actually, I think, Adams' main motivating question as well.

SPEAKER_01George Washington, it sounds like, not only legitimized that office within this newly formed United States, but foreign powers are seeing Washington's legitimacy. Is that correct?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think so. I believe that foreign nations had a great deal of respect for him, even if they didn't necessarily have a great deal of respect for the United States. So they were often very willing to use the United States as a pawn in whatever centuries-long feud they had going with other European nations. There is this great letter where the envoys from the United States are arrive in France in 1800, and Napoleon talks about how sad he was to learn of Washington's passing, which is not necessarily something we would associate with Napoleon, but he made a point of going out of his way to acknowledge this moment.

SPEAKER_00So he definitely, Washington definitely had a stature that could be translated into different nations and different languages. And that meant that when he made a foreign policy decision, his hefty weight kind of went behind that decision in a way that other presidents had to fight a lot harder for.

SPEAKER_00And this is the central bedrock of what it means to be a democracy or a republic. If it is not a peaceful transfer of power, then we are something else. We turn into a different type of government. And Adams understood that that had to be carefully cultivated. And the American people had to be taught both to participate and to uphold this, but also to cherish it. And so he took constant action and very thoughtful action, often behind the scenes, to create those two first transfers to start that precedent, gaining weight and power to serve as the bedrock of democracy.

SPEAKER_01And Lindsay, even though we may not laud John Adams in the same way that we do George Washington, it sounds like Adams played such a crucial role in ensuring this early start to democracy in the United States through taking on that role after George Washington, but it sounds like also as Thomas Jefferson came in.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I really think that he deserves an enormous amount of credit because precedents don't start when someone does something unique. They start when someone repeats them. That's what actually makes a precedent. And so Adams was the one that was saying, here are all the things that Washington did that we should continue. And then also, once he lost, he didn't question it, he accepted it, and he went home. And in the age of Napoleon, that is a radical thing to do. That is extraordinary. And so his recognition that the nation and the constitution mattered so much more than his own personal or political interests is essential and was an essential contribution.

SPEAKER_01And so after Adams, we have Thomas Jefferson. And then after his terms, we have James Madison. And as we are at James Madison's Montpelier, I want to talk a bit about Madison's presidency because we are very focused on him and his role with the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. But we don't often hear as much about his presidency. So what did that look like with him coming in this fourth president? I mean, he's got Washington, then Adams, then Jefferson. And those are some really influential figures.

SPEAKER_00I think if Adams had a particularly bad hand, then Madison probably had equally as difficult for a couple of reasons. One, he was following Jefferson, who, even though I think the last years of his presidency were kind of a debacle, he still was such a force and he was the founder of the party and he was the author of the Declaration of Independence that he, again, his stature was so huge that a lot of people would have trouble following that. And certainly Madison's talents did not lend themselves towards outward stature in that kind of way. His talents tended to be appreciated more in a small setting or behind the scenes, or, you know, the political machinations that we love in history books, but are not necessarily seen by the public at the time.

SPEAKER_00So I think that was the first challenge. The second challenge is Jefferson's bungling of the embargo of 1807 put the United States in really bad foreign policy position. And while I don't ever like to say anything is inevitable, there had been tensions with Great Britain that were coming for a very long time, and many presidents had kind of tried to grapple with them. And so I think Madison had the unfortunate luck of being the person with whom finally these kind of erupted into a second war of independence. The last piece, I think, was also a mentality about executive power.

SPEAKER_00For all of his brilliant thinking about the Constitution, I don't get the sense that Madison had as keen of a sense about how to actually manage men once you're in an executive position, which is a very different talent. And this was something that Adams didn't have as much of a sense of either, which is interesting because, you know, sometimes the people who write or think the most about positions then struggle when they're actually in them. Whereas Washington didn't do a whole lot of writing about the Constitution or the executive branch, but he had done a lot of experiential leadership.

SPEAKER_00And so that type of hands-on learning was not something that I think Madison had a whole lot of. And so he had the misfortune to keep a lot of Jefferson's cabinet, which is always a bad idea. Adams learned that. Madison learned it. Presidents seem to keep having to learn this lesson that you must get rid of your predecessor's cabinet. It's never a good idea to keep them. And then didn't really, I think, manage the cabinet all that well. So his presidency is definitely not known perhaps as his most stellar moment in his long political service career.

SPEAKER_00But it certainly was a monumental one, of course, because of the War of 1812.

SPEAKER_01Yes, you referenced this second war for independence, the War of 1812. Why should we think of it as another war for independence?

SPEAKER_00It's one thing to declare independence. It's another to actually live that reality. And I think that during the American Revolution, in a lot of ways, yes, we won the war, we won our independence, but then we had to live as an independent nation and prove that we could back that up. And this was at a time when the United States really barely had an army and barely had a navy. And so if we said something and Britain or France agreed to it, it was really only because it suited them, not because we could actually make them do what we wanted.

SPEAKER_00And so the reason I referred to it as a second war of independence is because even though we didn't really win, it really we fought it to a draw, basically. It was enough to prove that we could not be pushed around. And that sometimes is sufficient for independence. It's just that you cannot be trampled. And to be sure, Great Britain was distracted by a lot of other things and had a lot of other conflicts going on, but I think just proving that we could at least hold our own enough to fight to a draw was enough to back up the claim of independence.

SPEAKER_01This was a pretty scary war for those living through it at the time. You have the burning of the White House, for example, this is during Madison's presidency when the British land on the shores of the United States and march to the Capitol and burn the White House down. Can you talk a little bit about what was going on with Madison and how he responded to that and maybe some of the political challenges he faced in the aftermath?

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. You're right to say that it was a very scary war for the people living through it. I mean, I think that's probably true of any war, but especially for the United States in this period of time, there were a lot of sectional divisions. The idea of nationalism or emotional ties to the nation, to the flag, to the federal government, those were still incredibly weak. And pretty much everyone knew it, and all foreign nations knew it. So there was constant pressure by foreign empires to try and pick off wavering states, to kind of return them to the fold of the empire.

SPEAKER_00And I think a lot of people genuinely wondered if the United States would survive or whether it would crumble into different pieces or go back to various empires or go back to various imperial folds. And so when the war came to American shores, and especially when it came to Washington, D.C., which was trying to be built up as this image of what a republic is, the architecture was selected to call upon ideas of Rome and Greece and remind people of the ideals behind which the nation was founded. Many of those ideals were articulated by Thomas Jefferson as he was picking the designs of these buildings to see that burn and to see the army, the British army, march into the city practically unopposed, suggested that maybe this idea of a republic was not going to work.

SPEAKER_00And my understanding of Madison, and I will fully admit that my knowledge of Washington and Adams and Jefferson is stronger than Madison's presidency, but my understanding of Madison was that he didn't necessarily see the president as a wartime commander-in-chief. And so he had ceded a lot of the day-to-day military authority to his Secretary of War and then to, of course, the commanders on the ground. And partly this was a technology problem. If you don't have telephones, if you don't have internet, it's very hard to communicate quickly to the front lines of a battlefield.

SPEAKER_00Partly it's also a mentality about how you use executive power and how you seize the opportunity to lead. He also had made some poor appointments to his early positions in terms of the Secretary of War. And once James Monroe came in as Secretary of War, that definitely turned the tide in terms of the Army's ability to function as a fighting force because Monroe did have a lot of military experience and was quite decisive, which was important. So Madison was out of the city when the British marched in. Dolly Madison, of course, famously instructed many of the enslaved individuals in the White House to remove the famous portrait of George Washington to bundle it up and save it so that the British wouldn't be able to steal it.

SPEAKER_00The British forces enjoyed the meal that she had set out for visitors who were coming later that day before setting torch to the White House. I should say a lot of Americans don't know this part of the story. The year prior, Americans had burned York, which was the capital of Toronto. The burning of the White House was in retaliation for said burning of York. So it's not just that they were doing so on a whim. This was wartime and fair is fair. So they burned Washington, D.C., with the exception of the patent office, because the patent office contained the brilliance of mankind and they didn't want to punish inventors.

SPEAKER_00And Madison, of course, was blamed for this because anytime D.C. is burned, the president is going to be blamed. He set up residence at the Octagon House in Washington, D.C., which is just around the corner and is very cool. The house is still in existence. Highly recommend visiting. It's really neat. And was instrumental in ensuring that the seat of government did not move to a different city because there were definitely discussions about well, the city's now in ashes. Should we go somewhere else? Should we start somewhere new? A lot of people didn't have strong positive associations with Washington, D.C.

SPEAKER_00at the time, which having spent a few summers there, I can Understand myself. It's great as long as you're not there in June, July, and August. So Madison was instrumental in ensuring that they stayed, and actually, I think, did encourage a resurgence of national spirit once the British were not able to get through Fort McHenry, and that's where the famous Star Spangled Banner song is written about that battle in particular. So despite this very low period in his presidency, he actually left the presidency with really high approval ratings, which I think is really interesting.

SPEAKER_01As we think about these early presidents and what they contributed, how has the office changed? Would we be able to recognize its structure? What can we say about the office today versus back then?

SPEAKER_00In some ways, it is very much the same in terms of what we expect the presidency to be in control of. So the president is the main person on foreign policy. They are the main voice for the United States on the world stage. When there is a domestic crisis, the president is expected to be the first person to jump in. Congress is very hard to get moving when it comes to domestic crises. And yet in other ways, so I mean that that identity of what the president is is very similar to what Washington created. And yet I think the scope of it has expanded so much, certainly in terms of the number of executive departments, the number of people employed by the federal government, but also the scope of what the federal government is supposed to be responsible for.

SPEAKER_00And as a result, what we expect the president to be responsible for has really exploded. And I think that's actually a very nefarious development, not necessarily because of either, you know, a conservative view of government or a progressive view of government, but rather when we expect the president to do everything, we are going to be disappointed. It is impossible for one person to do everything. It is impossible for the president to be able to completely control the economy and to control foreign affairs on the world stage and to be able to reform the Supreme Court and reform immigration.

SPEAKER_00I mean, these are massive tasks. And the early president would have never been expected to fix all of those things. And so, in some ways, I think if we could go back to our expectations of a slightly more limited president with a more powerful Congress and a better understanding of what the state governments are supposed to do, we would actually like our government a lot better because we would have a clear understanding about who we should ask for things from, who we should petition when we want something done, who is actually responsible for certain areas of public life, and we'd be much less prone to disappointment.

SPEAKER_01As we wrap up our conversation today, is there any piece of advice or any thoughts that are particularly on your mind at this moment, given that we are going to elect a new president?

SPEAKER_00Well, especially in election season, I think it's really important to remind the American people that no matter how much we hear from a candidate, no matter how much we talk to them about their proposed economic policy or foreign policy or their views on women's health or immigration or climate change, almost never is a presidency about what they think it's going to be about. So if we look at George W. Bush, for example, he campaigned on the economy. And eight months into his presidency, September 11th happened, and his eight years in office were completely different than he anticipated.

SPEAKER_00Joe Biden campaigned on restoring sort of normalcy and restoring the economy in a post-COVID world. In February of 2022, Putin and Russian forces invaded Ukraine. And that completely changed foreign policy. And so we just cannot possibly anticipate what's going to come next because we are not the only nation in the world and everyone has a say. And so I think it's much better to assess someone based on how do you think they're going to make decisions? Who are they going to talk to?

SPEAKER_00Who are they going to get advice from? Because again, the president is too, the presidency is too big for one person to have all the answers. How are they going to work with allies? How are they going to try and represent all American people? I would say, are they people of character? I think character matters a whole lot because when you're talking about the decisions that get to the Oval Office, there are no easy decisions that the president makes. Easy decisions get handled many rungs down in the executive branch. And so you want someone who both does have confidence that they can make those big decisions, but is trying to do so with recognition that they need the advice of others, they need input from lots of people and have character in their decision-making process.

SPEAKER_01And that's something that I think the American people should feel very reassured by is that there's a lot of people that are bringing advice and guidance and knowledge into the room. But as you said, it's the president who makes these really hard decisions. And it really struck me when you talked about the peaceful transfer of power and the president's role to facilitate that. So I'm really excited to go into that voting booth. And as you said, it's really up to the people to participate and to cherish this democracy.

SPEAKER_01So I want to thank you, Dr. Lindsay Travinsky, for being with us today to talk about your new books and the presidency.

SPEAKER_00Well, thank you so much for having me. These subjects are so near and dear to my heart, and I think more important than ever. So always grateful for the opportunity to talk about them.

SPEAKER_01And thank you to all of our listeners. I hope you'll subscribe and share this show with your family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode