This episode is part of a five-part miniseries examining James Madison's role in the American Revolution and the founding of the United States. Part of Montpelier's commemoration of the 250th anniversary of American independence, this series is funded by a grant from the Virginia American Revolution 250 Commission in partnership with Virginia Humanities. What does it actually take to sustain a republic - not just to build one, but to keep it alive across generations? In this episode, part of a special five-part miniseries commemorating America's 250th anniversary, Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey speaks with Professor Colleen Sheehan of Arizona State University, one of the foremost scholars of James Madison's political thought. Drawing on her books The Mind of James Madison and James Madison and the Spirit of Republican Self-Government, Professor Sheehan explains why Madison believed the greatest threat to the republic wasn't foreign invasion or economic collapse, but something far more internal - the capacity of citizens to deliberate well, check their own impulses, and honor what Madison called a "debt of protection" we owe to one another. From the Federalist Papers to Robert Frost, this conversation illuminates why Madison remains essential to understanding what self-government actually demands of us - and what the 250th anniversary asks of us today.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Light and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
SPEAKER_00Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, with James Madison's Montpelier. This episode is one installment of a five-part miniseries funded by a grant from the Virginia American Revolution 250 Commission in partnership with the Virginia Humanities. This special series is part of Montpelier's broader effort to commemorate the 250th anniversary of America's founding with the signing of the Declaration of Independence in 1776.
SPEAKER_01As we mark the 250th anniversary, we're returning to a question that James Madison believed was really at the heart of the American experiment. What holds a republic together? Not just in 1776, not just in 1787, but across generations. Madison really wrestled with this his entire life. These questions of how do liberty and self-government coexist? How do you prevent majorities from becoming oppressive?
SPEAKER_01How do you sustain a republic once it's been created? Madison came to believe the greatest threat wasn't necessarily foreign invasion or even economic collapse, but internal forces, public opinion, factionalism, and the capacity of citizens to deliberate well. And that brings us to today's episode and to Madison's conviction that a republic endures not simply because of its institutions, but because of the character, engagement, and judgment of its people.
SPEAKER_01To help us explore that idea, we're joined by Colleen Chien, who is a professor of politics at Arizona State University. Her primary scholarly area is the American Founding with a focus on James Madison. She is the author of James Madison and the Spirit of Republican Self-Government and The Mind of James Madison. She has edited a number of books on The Framers, the Federalist Papers, and the other Federalists, including most recently, American Founders, leaders at the creation of the Republic, which is available online.
SPEAKER_01So, Colleen, it's such a pleasure having the ability to speak with you today. Thank you for being on the show with us. Thank you, Katie. Good to be here. So in earlier episodes of this mini-series, we've spent some time with James Madison at the very beginning of the American Revolution. So he's still a young man in his mid-twenties. He's watching events unfold. He's thinking deeply, but he's not the figure most people picture when they're thinking about 1776.
SPEAKER_01You know, because he isn't in Philadelphia with Jefferson drafting the Declaration of Independence. He's often absent from popular telling of the revolution's founding moment. And yet Madison is already wrestling with some of the same questions about liberty, power, public opinion, the survival of the republic. And these thoughts are later going to shape the Constitution and Bill of Rights. So, Colleen, as we mark this 250 years of American self-government, why is James Madison in particular such a key figure to revisit?
SPEAKER_01And what does his thinking at this early moment help us understand about the American experiment?
SPEAKER_02I think Madison was important to the American founding, but I can put that in a broader framework, important to America because more than anyone else at the time of the founding, and possibly in the statesman throughout the ages in our country, he thought through the problem of free government. Madison thought that free government had never really worked, never really succeeded in the world. And he wasn't alone in this.
SPEAKER_02The founders tended to say, the eyes of the world are upon us. Liberty hangs in the balance. We're going to decide the fate of millions yet unborn. So the Greeks had tried to make democracy work. But as we know from Aristotle and from history, they couldn't figure out how to overcome the problem of, well, it was a two-fold problem. On the one hand, it's a problem of faction. If you're going to have democratic free government, what do you do when the majority of people who are in power they're ruling?
SPEAKER_02Just think of the Greek assembly, and you get a demagogue up there and they clamor for something and then it's done momentarily, the decision is made and somebody's head is cut off. So that's one problem, the problem of faction, majority faction in particular. The other problem is if you want to make a larger country so it's a little bit harder for the majority to coalesce so easily, you end up with empire. And empires, according to the whole history of thought on this, are despotic.
SPEAKER_02Aristotle thought so, it goes down through Montesquieu. You cannot have an empire without it being despotic. Now, Montesquieu will actually suggest some changes in the way of thinking about that. So Madison takes this problem, he's read all of this stuff, and he rereads it throughout the 80s, and they're still trying to figure out how to make the American government that has won this revolution actually accomplish the principles that they fought for. People have died for these principles. They need to get it right. And that's when he works on, you know, his preparations for the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia and comes up with what he thinks is an answer to the problems that had belabored political thinkers, political philosophers throughout the centuries.
SPEAKER_02I think that's why Madison's important. He was the mind of the founding more than anyone else. Hamilton probably had the highest IQ. Washington was certainly America's first citizen. Madison was the thinker behind the scenes, oftentimes.
SPEAKER_01That's such a powerful line. Madison is the mind of the founding. And Madison, I mean, of course, we're at James Madison's Montpelier. I'm I have a little bias towards him, but he's a really fascinating, complex figure in that he is still very much making his way into politics at this moment of the American Revolution in terms of being part of the process of writing the Virginia State Constitution. And again, he's thinking about all these ideas at this moment, as you also referenced.
SPEAKER_01And yet we can kind of see how these ideas continue to develop. You mentioned he's reading all of these kind of great thinkers like Montesquieu, you know, Locke, Hume, for example. And then he's going this next step of putting these ideals into practice via the Constitution. So as we move from Madison's place in this like founding moment to the substance of his ideas, I want to linger on this question that really seems to animate so much of his thinking, not just how the republic is created, but how it sustains and endures.
SPEAKER_01So Colleen, can you tell us what did Madison believe was key in order to keep a republic together? And does that still translate today?
SPEAKER_02Another great question, Katie. That really gets to the heart of what Madison is more particularly wrestling with. I mean, so so first of all, what's his purpose? He states this in Federalist 39, that wonderful passage where he says, is this really a republic? And he says, no other form of government would be reconcilable with the genius of the American people or the spirit of the American Revolution, or with that honorable determination which animates the votaries of freedom to rest all our political experiments on the capacity of mankind for self-government.
SPEAKER_02That is the key to Madison, in my view. That is what his life was devoted to. Another way to say devotion to proving, demonstrating, not only to the world but to ourselves that we can govern ourselves, really was the human challenge, at least the earthly human challenge from the classics on down. Can we be masters of our own souls? So that we don't need someone else to rule us ultimately?
SPEAKER_02That's the question. So how do you do that? That's what Madison is working on. That's what makes him his friends say to him, Be careful, don't stay up all night and work so hard because you're making yourself sick about this. And he did that sometimes. That was who he was. So, what is his more practical remedy for this? How does he think this through? I would say two things. One has to do with process, and the second has to do with character and substance. So the process is what we see in the Federalist Papers, his explanation of how do you make a government work in such a way that you have a higher chance, you can't guarantee it through mechanisms, through institutions.
SPEAKER_02You need those institutions. What do I mean by need those institutions? Well, the executive, the legislative, the judiciary, and then what you do with them. He wants separation of powers, checks and balances. And then that separation of powers is not only at the level of the government, the central government, but also in the states. So you have federalism. And then that's still not enough because if the people are really going to rule and they're representing you have representation, you put them in the legislature, that's the most powerful branch of government.
SPEAKER_02Separation of powers doesn't mean the branches of government are equal, it means they're separate. So then what do you do? You separate the legislative branch into two houses so that they can check each other. So you've got this whole force counterforce, force counterforce trying to refine and enlarge the public decision that you'll ultimately come up with. So that's the process he works on, and he devotes a tremendous amount of time before and during the Constitutional Convention to see that through.
SPEAKER_02Why isn't that enough? Well, the question is: can machines really go on of themselves? That whole idea that you set a machine in motion and then it's done. You've done with your job. Well, I don't know about AI, but at least for in politics, for the human things, no machines can't go on of themselves. There are people behind them. And there are people behind the laws, or men and women behind the laws. And so here's one way to put it. Bill Allen, a great scholar on the American Founding, once said, you cannot have a republic without Republican citizens.
SPEAKER_02In other words, it matters what the people think, what their opinion is, what they love, what they hate, what they cherish, what they denigrate. It matters who they are and what they're committed to. And Madison understood that as well or better than most. He says in the Federalist Papers, what do you mean if there's no virtue among us, then all the checks in the world won't solve the problem of despotism. So he doesn't expect men to be angels, but neither does he think that a society of devils can turn porridge into gold.
SPEAKER_02It's good old-fashioned hard work of civic education and civic life. And Madison was a very practical politician in that sense and totally understood that politics is about real people with real ideas. And he approached his understanding of the political problem and the political task that way.
SPEAKER_01And I think this is why Madison is such a compelling figure to study, but also to gather inspiration from in the present. He's thinking about these ideas that we've been discussing, but he doesn't see them as only abstract or philosophical. For him, the real test of the revolution is whether these ideas can be put into some type of durable framework. Can liberty and self-rule be actually translated into a functioning system of government?
SPEAKER_01And, you know, I think his experience serving in Congress before the Constitution is drafted and ratified gives him a really front row seat. He's experiencing maybe some of the discord that is happening. So there's philosophy and ideals, but he is very much translating this into practice. He is seeing this vision long term. And I think that's what in part makes him such a brilliant and important figure during this period, obviously, but also beyond for all American history into the present.
SPEAKER_02That is really well said, Katie. I think you've captured so much of the essence of Madison. Remember the Constitutional Convention, the fellow Pierce, his name was Pierce, Deliot from Georgia. He didn't contribute a lot to the debates, but he would write character sketches, listen to people and watch people, and he said of Madison that he combined the scholar and the statesman. And so you've just captured that so well.
SPEAKER_01And Colleen, as Madison is preparing and readying himself for the convention, how is he thinking about the revolution and why the colonists fought this war? How is he taking these ideas and the symbolism of that and then translating it? Is he thinking we need a whole new system? Is he thinking 100 years down the line? What's going through his head as he's trying to put this into practice?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think he's got this big picture in mind, and he's still working on solving the problem that I just laid out. How do you find a way for the people to actually govern themselves? And the problem is if they have the final say, then you've got to do something about the problem of majority faction. Otherwise, if you can't do something about that problem, then there's got to be somebody else that checks the majority. In other words, somebody else actually rules. And for some time in our history, scholars have thought that Madison actually opted for either just leave it up to the institutions, this machine somehow that you've created, and that takes care of things.
SPEAKER_02And so you can have bad characters, but don't worry about it because those devils won't really create a problem in the end because you've got these shrewd institutional arrangements that will solve it. Or on the other hand, the other scholarly interpretation was essentially, well, it's a ghostly body politic. He's created this system that he calls it majority rule, but what he's really done is made them unable to actually rule. And so you actually have an elite that's ruling. And so that's another theory of Madison.
SPEAKER_02Katie, in my study of Madison, Madison is not either of those things. He's not an elitist. He actually really does believe in government of, by, and for the people. And he certainly doesn't just depend on institutional arrangements. And Federalist 51, for example, when he's talking about these institutional arrangements and those famous lines: if men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither internal nor external controls on government would be necessary. And then talks about what we need are these inventions of prudence, checks and balances, separation of powers, and so on.
SPEAKER_02But then he says the primary dependence in Republican government is always on the people. He's practical about this. He doesn't think there are magical solutions. And there's no panacea. The people actually, in the end, in the final analysis, have to be able to make decisions in such a way where they're showing respect for each other. And they don't need a master. They really are capable of that fundamental ability to govern themselves.
SPEAKER_02When we get Madison right, we really see his vision all through the founding period that connects the revolution to the Constitution. It's called the Great Experiment in Self-Government. That's what the founders called it. Madison calls it the experiment in self-government over and over again. That is what the founding is about. Whether we really can create a kind of political community that gives us a fair chance to do that. Now, fast forward to our day, that's a whole nother question of whether these institutions and procedures and so on are still working at the level that we need them to work.
SPEAKER_02That's one question, the process. And then the other question is the substance. Are we still dedicated to those principles of the revolutionary period that are really ensconced in the Declaration of Independence, the idea of human equality such that we have equal natural rights, and that we also have not only rights, but responsibilities to each other. So that's an entirely different set of questions that if Madison were alive today, the founders were alive today, they would definitely be asking.
SPEAKER_01This conversation is actually bringing to mind more questions and giving me things that I want to explore more about Madison. I do want to wrap up with one question in particular to leave our listeners with what can Madison's political theory and then his ensuing work teach us about sustaining a republic 250 years after the revolution?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think, Katie, that it's a complex question because the easy part is to say, well, it depends on whether we still hold these truths to be self-evident. It depends on whether we still believe that. And if we do, are we willing to do the hard work of political architecture, which means in some ways rethinking some of the things Madison thought about. What will it take to refine and enlarge the public views in such a way today that we can make for a reasonable public opinion?
SPEAKER_02Because the the challenge, partly today, is that what worked for Madison and for the founders in the 18th century and worked through the 19th century changed in the 20th century and certainly totally changed in the 21st century with electronic communications. We have instant communication now. So where is the time that Madison discovered by making a larger territory that creates this time to have a second thought, what Fisher Ames called a second sober opinion, a rethinking.
SPEAKER_02You know, when when you get upset about something, you say count to 10. Stop, wait, let your reason control, govern your soul so that your passions, your anger, your ambitions, your envy, all those kinds of passions that sometimes lash out at others don't take over. Well, just as it is in the individual human being, it's that way in the political community. We're just a combination of a lot of human beings. And the problem in politics is the age-old problem of humanity.
SPEAKER_02That sometimes people want to do bad things to other people and succeed in that. And we call it despotism and tyranny. And what Madison is trying to do is create a political environment in which, if we're really created equal, what that means is not that we're equal in every respect, but that we're equal in our capacity to govern ourselves. So no one should be the despot over someone else, just as no one should be someone else's slave.
SPEAKER_02That's the way Lincoln put it later on. And so what that means is there's a flip side of that coin of claiming you have rights. The flip side is you have responsibilities to others. And when Madison talked about self-government, he met both sides of that coing. You have rights and you have responsibilities. He called it in one essay, Katie. He called it a debt of protection that we have to one another. And he said, this is the absolute core of the social compact.
SPEAKER_02Think about that. The social compact is what the Declaration of Independence calls for when it says that because we're equal, consent of the governed is necessary to the just powers of government. That means that people have to consent to it. They have to come together and make that agreement. That's the social contract or social compact. Madison said. At the very core of that, it is a debt of protection to which the public faith is pledged by the very nature of that compact. You know, if I could just bring in a poet here who understood Madison probably better than most historians, was Robert Frost.
SPEAKER_02And there's a famous poem by him that actually is about this social compact. He asked one time, who's the best dreamer of the American dream? He says, Is it George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Governor Morse? He said, You know, I've been reading the Federalist papers lately. And I believe the best dreamer of the American dream was James Madison. And he has a number of poems that are actually dedicated to understanding that. And one of them is this poem, you've probably heard it, called Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening.
SPEAKER_02Whose woods are these, I think I know. His house is in the village, though. He will not see me stopping here to see his woods fill up with snow. And remember the very end of that poem. You know, my little horse must think it queer to stop without a farmhouse near, between the woods and frozen lake, the darkest evening of the year. Right? And then we find out at the very end of the poem this man who's outside this village and decides to go back in, not to stay where he's all alone, to go back to society and all of its problems and all of its noise.
SPEAKER_02Why does he do it? Because I have promises to keep and miles to go before I sleep. Frost told us that those promises are of two kinds: those I make for myself and those my forefathers made for me in the form of a social compact. That's a promise that they made.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely, Katie. And I'm glad that Montpelier is reminding us what Madison thought and believed and what he really sacrificed so much of his time and life for.
SPEAKER_01Well, thank you so much, Colleen, for being with us today, sharing your time and your understanding of Madison. You really helped us understand why he was placing such importance on the work of self-government, the capacity of citizens to deliberate, check their impulses. So I think this gives us really good fodder to learn even more and to discover more about Madison and his role in this 250th year. So thank you so much. Thank you, Katie.
SPEAKER_01Happy to be with you today. And I want to thank all of our listeners for listening to the show today. Please share the show with family and friends. And join us again soon as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...