In this compelling episode, host Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey sits down with Sharon McMahon, "America's Government Teacher" and New York Times bestselling author of "The Small and the Mighty," to explore the remarkable stories of overlooked women who shaped American democracy. From Rebecca Brown Mitchell, who helped secure women's suffrage in Idaho decades before the 19th Amendment, to fifteen-year-old Claudette Colvin, whose courageous stand against bus segregation helped pave the way for the Montgomery Bus Boycott, McMahon brings to light the extraordinary contributions of ordinary Americans who changed history. The conversation delves into how these "small and mighty" individuals' persistent efforts for liberty and justice continue to impact our nation today, reminding us that everyone has the power to make meaningful change. Through these inspiring stories, McMahon and Crawford Lackey demonstrate how progress is born of struggle and why every person's contribution to democracy matters, even when the results aren't immediately visible.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackett and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
SPEAKER_01Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. Today, we're reflecting on some of the remarkable women who have shaped our nation's political landscape and fought for greater constitutional protections. Throughout history, women have played pivotal roles, often without the recognition they deserve. Fighting not just for the right to vote, but for broader access to equality, justice, and opportunity.
SPEAKER_00This episode is dedicated to discovering the stories of a few of those changemakers. Joining us for the conversation is Sharon McMahon, a number one New York Times bestselling author, educator, and host of the Chart Topping Podcast. Here's where it gets interesting. She taught government and law in public schools in the suburbs of Washington, D.C. She became known as America's government teacher during the 2020 election for her viral efforts to combat political misinformation.
SPEAKER_00She quickly gained a large following due to her ability to break down complex topics with clarity, humor, and a steadfast commitment to the facts. And last fall, she published a book, The Small and the Mighty: 12 Unsung Americans Who Changed the Course of History from the Founding to the Civil Rights Movement, which brings to light the extraordinary contributions of influential figures who have been overlooked in the history books. And we'll be talking more about some of these figures today on the show.
SPEAKER_00So, Sharon, welcome to the show. It's wonderful to have you here today. Thank you so much for inviting me. So before we dive into some of these stories that you mentioned in the book, I'm curious to learn a little bit more about your own journey. So, as I mentioned, you were a public school teacher, and then you kind of gained this national spotlight. And then you have this wonderful book that just came out last fall. So, how did you go from being in the classroom with students to this more kind of national spotlight?
SPEAKER_02The pandemic has a lot to do with that. I, like many people, had far more time at home than I ever knew what to do with. And everyone was online and we had watched every episode of Tiger King, and everyone was just arguing in the comments section on Facebook all day long. And I just started noticing some disturbing trends of people who were saying things and they were just confidently wrong.
SPEAKER_02It was not an opinion of this person is better suited to lead or I agree with the policies of that person. It was saying things like, the Electoral College is a university you can graduate from, which is just not true. That's just not a fact. So I decided in that moment I could either spend my time arguing with strangers in the comment section about all the ways they were getting it wrong, or I could start making some little fact-based nonpartisan explainer videos, much like I would have used in a classroom to accommodate children of a variety of different political backgrounds and beliefs and faith traditions, et cetera.
SPEAKER_02I discovered that that kind of content actually applies out in the world as well and was difficult to find.
SPEAKER_00And what led you from that path to writing your own book and focusing on these 12 specific individuals that you feature?
SPEAKER_02This book is really a love letter to the reader. It is what people have been telling me for years that they need, that they want to understand the truth of American history, not just the heroics, not just the battles that we won. And also not just the times that we got it wrong, not just the times we were engaged in oppression, not just the times that we enslaved people or incarcerated an innocent individual, that the truth is in both of those things.
SPEAKER_02And so I wrote this book very much as an answer to the sort of pleas of my community for a book about the truth of American history.
SPEAKER_00Your answer really resonates. You know, I'm recording this at James Madison's Montpelier. He's known as not just the fourth president, but father of the Constitution, architect of the Bill of Rights. And when you think about he did that by age 36, at least the writing of the Constitution, that's a high bar. And he's very much almost like one of these mythical figures. But obviously he was a man. And we do tell the stories of the enslaved community here at Montpelier as well. It's easy to almost get lost in this, the horrors of it all.
SPEAKER_00But what you're talking about, finding this balance of not getting lost in the stories of oppression and this tragedy, but bringing history to life and humanizing people. Obviously, Madison, great ideas, brilliant man, but man, he did some pretty terrible things and made bad decisions. And we try to do that here. And it sounds like your book also strives to highlight some of these individuals that are ordinary people.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And why can't we do both things about James Madison, right? Why can't we talk about the horrors of enslavement and also his incredible political philosophy? Why can't we do both of those things? Why must he only be held up as a hero and a genius or as solely an enslaver? He is both of those things. And to say that he is a very gifted political philosopher does not diminish the horrors of enslavement. It is not an either-or.
SPEAKER_02So that to me is very evident. That's just telling the truth. I'm not diminishing the horrors of enslavement. It is horrible, and there's no excuse for it. But neither am I willing to totally discount the very enduring impact that James Madison and many other ordinary Americans whose names are not on an estate, who did not have family money, who were not famous in their lifetime, many other Americans had very significant contributions in small and mighty ways, despite having backgrounds that perhaps were not what we would regard as perfect, that are not TV-worthy backgrounds by today's standards.
SPEAKER_02And I think sometimes we discount our own contributions because we feel like, well, I'll never be a James Madison. I'll never be an Andrew Carnegie. I'll never be fill in the blank. And that actually is a really good thing. We don't need it. We don't need a second version of any of these people. We need the contributions that only you can bring to the table.
SPEAKER_00When I think about those individuals that are, you know, these ordinary Americans that are not highlighted in the history books. I think about women in particular. I know your book covers both men and women, historical figures, but oftentimes women are perhaps underwritten about in the historical record and history books. And, you know, when I think of women's history, I often associate it with women's rights, women's suffrage, the right to vote. But you highlight several women who are associated with the women's suffrage movement, but also beyond that.
SPEAKER_00And two women in particular I'm thinking about from your book that were suffragists are Inezma Holland and Rebecca Brown Mitchell. And I'm wondering if you could talk a little bit about their stories and what they did to contribute to American history.
SPEAKER_02I would love to. Rebecca Brown Mitchell was a very early worker in the suffrage movement. She was not of the era of the women's marches at the turn of the 20th century during the Wilsonian presidency. She was not the person going to jail and being force-fed, like we tend to think of at the women's suffrage movement at its apex. But the women's suffrage movement of that era would not be anywhere if it were not for the efforts of people like Rebecca Brown Mitchell. She was born in Illinois, and when her husband died, leaving her a widow with small children, she discovered that she was imprisoned, in her words, in the iron cage of the law because of coveture laws that required a woman to legally be covered by a man, whether it was her father, her husband, some other male relative, if she didn't have someone else.
SPEAKER_02And all of her marital property then went to the state of Illinois, with the exception of her family Bible and her family hymnal. If she wanted the clothes off her back, she had to buy them back from the state. She wanted her wedding gifts, dishes, she had to buy them back from the state. And this really chaps her hide. And eventually, to make a long story short, she moves to what was then the frontier, which was a very small town in Idaho. Eagle Rock, Idaho later becomes Idaho Falls.
SPEAKER_02And Rebecca Brown Mitchell is very instrumental, not just in helping the women of Idaho gain the right to vote decades before the 19th Amendment was passed nationwide, but she also had very, very significant contributions despite being a single woman. Despite being a woman in her 40s, 50s, and 60s, she did not have the beauty of youth to trade on for social currency the way that Inezma Holland did. Despite all of those obstacles, she helps found the Idaho Falls public school system.
SPEAKER_02She goes on to achieve something that no woman in the world had ever done before, which is to become the chaplain of a legislative body. She becomes the chaplain of the Idaho legislature after Idaho becomes a state. And the idea that a woman would be the person to pray over the Idaho legislature, many of the men were like, that is ridiculous. We don't listen to the prayers of women. And that's still an attitude that is pervasive in some places today.
SPEAKER_02And Rebecca had an answer for them, which was, why not do the unheard of thing? Let Idaho be among the first. And I just love that question. When people told her over and over, who are you to start a church? Who are you to start a school? Who are you to start the public library? Who are you to become this town historian? Who are you to become a chaplain? Who are you to help create suffrage in the state of Idaho? Her answer was always something to the effect of, why not me?
SPEAKER_02Why not do the unheard of thing? And that audacity, I think, is the foundation of the women's suffrage movement. And Inez certainly shares that audacity.
SPEAKER_00I love that you highlight these women that we may not have heard of. You know, women's suffrage is often associated with Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan B. Anthony in the late 1800s, and then Alice Paul when we talk about early 1900s. So the fact that we're hearing about folks from these under-discussed histories, I think is very powerful. And one figure that really stood out to me from your book is Claudette Colvin. She's only 15 when she challenges segregation in Alabama via the bus system.
SPEAKER_00And this is nine months before Rosa Parks does. And I'm just thinking about, you know, this young black woman, this teenager in the Deep South, taking that courageous act. It's just very powerful. And I want to read a line from your book. You actually include her words. She says, as this is all going on, what's going through her head, Colvin says, history kept me stuck to my seat. I felt the hand of Harriet Tubman pushing down on my shoulder and Sojourner Truth pushing down on the other.
SPEAKER_00Can you tell us how Claudette Colvin kind of set the tone for the civil rights movement, even though we may not have heard of her?
SPEAKER_02I love Claudette Colvin and I love this story because it highlights how each one of us depends on the efforts of another. Claudette Colvin doesn't say, and then an idea came into my head from nowhere, right? She says she knows that history has its eyes on her and that she feels the weight of the work of her ancestors on her shoulders, infusing her with a strength to do what she believes is the right thing, which is to refuse to give up her seat on a bus.
SPEAKER_02And Claudette Colvin and Rosa Parks actually knew each other. They became friends, they spent quite a bit of time together. They knew each other after Claudette was engaged in this act of protest on the bus. And Rosa Parks even remarks to Claudette Colvin, she's like, You're Claudette Colvin. I did not realize you would be such a small little girl. I was picturing, you know, like reading about you in the newspaper. I was picturing some, you know, big loudmouth, for lack of a better word, type figure. You're a very petite little girl.
SPEAKER_02That's how she viewed Claudette Colvin. And she admired her tenacity and her courage. And of course, Claudette was also not the only person to refuse to give up a seat on a bus before Rosa Parks. But because Claudette's actions became well known, she is prosecuted for multiple crimes as a result of refusing to give up her seat on a bus. And she's taken at age 15 to the adult jail. And her parents were involved with attorneys who were working to address segregation on Montgomery's public transportation.
SPEAKER_02And so her pay she had the support of her parents to be willing to sort of fight the system. Had she not had that, it might have been a different outcome. Again, we depend on the efforts of each other. And so eventually, Clavette Colvin, who provides the key testimony in the court case challenging segregation on Montgomery's bus system. And we think about, you know, the bus boycott as being kicked off by Rosa Parks.
SPEAKER_02And in, and of course, Rosa Parks is a very pivotal figure. She's very important to this story. But had it not been for people like Claudette Colvin and the other women who came before her, Rosa Parks would not have been able to step into that moment had all of these other legal challenges not already been sort of set in motion. Her efforts would not have arrived at exactly the right time. So when Claudette provides this testimony, and it's very, very powerful and moving, and the audience in the courtroom is reduced to tears, part of the victory you can attribute to Claudette's willingness to step out and courage.
SPEAKER_00And you said earlier, you've posed this question to us, why not me? And when we think about, well, you know, I'm I'm not old enough or I'm not smart enough, I don't have the political chops to do this. I think Colvin's story really speaks to you just have to be you and bring yourself. If she can take that step and have that level of courage, I think it kind of gives inspiration to all of us.
SPEAKER_02And Claudette feels like she is abandoned by the civil rights movement because after the bus incident, she gets pregnant. And so she is a pregnant teenager who is the wrong face for the movement. She is something that was not socially acceptable, which was an unmarried pregnant teenager. And so even though she felt like I put myself on the line, I acted in courage that she uh does not get her just desserts.
SPEAKER_02And it was not until recently, I mean in the last few years, that Claudette Colvin finally petitions the state of Alabama to have her conviction overturned. These are still ongoing uh stories. These are not just stories that exist in black and white images from the 1950s. These are stories that are still alive today. Claudette Colvin is still alive. So I love the idea that history is alive and our efforts depend on those around us.
SPEAKER_00And it underscores the importance of the work that you do and historians and public historians to kind of delve into the records, to delve into the past and use various sources to try to bring it to light, these stories that we haven't heard about or that we need to devote more attention to. And when I think about the entirety of your book, it spans from the founding era all the way up to the civil rights movement. When you look at that time period, do you see any threads or themes that kind of connect all of those stories?
SPEAKER_02There's a few of them, but one that really comes to mind is that progress is born of struggle. And that is a theme that actually a lot of people don't really like to hear because humans don't like to struggle. Right? Our brains want to protect us from it. Our brains want things to be easy, and ununderstandably so. But the actions of people who changed the course of history required concerted effort.
SPEAKER_02They required people to put in time and effort and sacrifice. And the idea that change happens because we want it to is not supported by facts. You know, you think of Martin Luther King's famous quote about the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice. But what we don't realize is that it doesn't bend towards justice because it's some kind of rainbow shape.
SPEAKER_02It bends toward justice because people reach up and pull it down. And the arc of the moral universe bends toward justice because of the actions of ordinary people, the small and the mighty, the people that I highlight in this book, and of course leaders too. But the idea that your efforts don't matter because you're not famous in your lifetime, because you're not wealthy, you don't have high elected office, over and over and over throughout history, that is proven wrong.
SPEAKER_02Some of the people in this book have impacted tens of millions of people and they don't even know it because they died before that happened. They could not have seen what they were setting in motion when they decided to show up for work one more time. They could not have seen the impacts they would have on future generations because they just kept putting one foot in front of the other. So I would hope that people would read this and understand if you're struggling with how difficult it is to make progress, to make change, number one, that's normal.
SPEAKER_02That's the human experience. It doesn't mean you're doing it wrong. And number two, what you do actually does matter. The idea that what you do doesn't matter is a lie that you shouldn't listen to. And that other people who are invested in maintaining the status quo want you to believe. They want you to believe that what you do doesn't matter because uh they they benefit from keeping things as they are. But what you do does matter. And so because it matters, well, you have to decide how you want it to matter.
SPEAKER_02Or in the words of Eleanor Roosevelt, what you do makes a difference. And so you have to decide what kind of difference you want to make.
SPEAKER_00Sharon, I want to dig into that a little bit more because you know, you really capture the purpose of this book and what you want readers to take away. And it's a powerful message, particularly at this moment when I think a lot of us feel very unempowered that what we do in terms of our civic participation that it doesn't count. How would you respond to that? And in addition to this book, tell folks that we do have agency. We are all gifted, have skills that are very much needed in society and that it requires all of us to participate.
SPEAKER_02First of all, I would acknowledge that I completely understand why people feel that way. Again, it doesn't mean you're doing it wrong. The second thing is I would say that throughout the entirety of world history, that has been the normal human experience. To feel like what I'm doing doesn't matter. That is the normal human experience. But it doesn't make it true. The third thing I would say is some of The most impactful people that we regard as sort of the giants of history today.
SPEAKER_02I'm thinking specifically of, say, Harriet Tubman, somebody who is now just been named by the state of Maryland as a general, a military general. She is now has the title of General Harriet Tubman. Nobody would look at Harriet Tubman's contributions and think, like, what a waste, what a loser. You know what I mean? We'd all be like, incredible woman. Harriet Tubman existed in a time when it was legal to enslave and rape other human beings.
SPEAKER_02She did not overthrow the system of enslavement. She did not overthrow the system of racial segregation. She did not overthrow the systems that underpinned the supremacy of white individuals in government and in society. And yet, despite the fact that she alone could not overthrow this system of legalized, institutionalized racism, she managed to achieve not just an incredible contribution to history, she saved hundreds of people.
SPEAKER_02Both rescuing them from enslavement also saved hundreds of people during her acts as what she would later become known as a Civil War general. But she also found joy in the work. Harriet Tubman was actually during her lifetime well known for her sense of humor. And if you read her speeches, you can see actually how funny she is. She was also a disabled American. In addition to all of these other things, Harriet Tubman was disabled. She had what we would know today as a form of epilepsy as a result of a traumatic brain injury when she is a child.
SPEAKER_02And she regarded her disability not as a detriment. She used her disability for her own betterment, for the betterment of others. She actually believed that when she was having these, what we would know now as epileptic seizures, she believed that she was communing with God and that he was telling her things. And historians have tried to unravel what did Harriet Tubman know? Because how is she able to navigate through the darkened winter woods across rivers without maps as a woman who is cannot read?
SPEAKER_02How did she do that? That's a question I have. Maybe she feels like God showed her the way. I can't answer that question. But I do know that despite evidence to the contrary, despite the fact that Harriet Tubman could not overthrow the systems of enslavement in the United States, she kept moving forward as though what she did mattered because it did. She found joy in her important work, which is a very important component of human existence.
SPEAKER_02And ultimately, we can now look back on the depth and breadth of Harriet Tubman's contributions and understand that there are tens of thousands of people alive today, because I have done the math. Tens of thousands of people alive today who are the descendants of people that Harriet Tubman helped. Like the magnitude of her contribution could not even be measured in her lifetime. And she did not grow weary in doing good.
SPEAKER_02And those are all just things that I like that keep me going when I look at the magnitude of the world's problems. Those are things that keep me going.
SPEAKER_00In wrapping up our conversation today, can you say some final words about how these stories from your book, but also stories of many people from the past, can inform and inspire us, especially as we look to the future and strive to create a better democracy for ourselves and for our children and grandchildren?
SPEAKER_02I think back to something that was said at the funeral of Inez Mill Holland, who we mentioned briefly, but who was a very prominent during her lifetime suffrage worker. She's often the woman at the front of the parades, carrying the signs, driving her car, riding a horse. If you've looked at women's suffrage parade pictures from, say, like 1913 era, you have seen pictures of Inez Mill Holland. You just didn't know it. When Inez Mill Holland dies, she ultimately passes away without having achieved what she views as some of her goals for American democracy.
SPEAKER_02And she has a funeral inside the United States Capitol. That's what a big deal she was during her lifetime, that her funeral is in the Capitol. And one of the people who speaks at her funeral says something that I think is worth remembering that no work for liberty can be lost. That it all changes the fabric of the nation for the better.
SPEAKER_02And this speaks to this idea that all of our efforts depend on the efforts of one another. Inez's work for liberty is not lost because she ultimately doesn't move the ball across the finish line. Rebecca Brown Mitchell's work for liberty is not lost because she couldn't grant every single woman in the country the right to vote. Your work for liberty is not lost because you have not fixed all of the world's problems on a Thursday afternoon.
SPEAKER_02No work for liberty is lost. It all contributes to the fabric of the country. And so I think it helps me to remember that it's actually not my job to fix all of the world's problems. We think out of our human compassion that we want it to be. We want to solve childhood hunger and cure cancer and fix international conflicts. And the list goes on. We want to because we want to alleviate the suffering of others.
SPEAKER_02But it helps me to remember that if it's worth doing for everyone, it's worth doing for one person. And I should not allow my lack of resources to fix international conflicts, keep me from helping the children in my neighborhood. And that my work for liberty and yours changes the fabric of the nation for the better. Our work cannot be lost.
SPEAKER_00That is such a powerful message. Well, Sharon, I want to thank you so much for joining us on the show today. And again, your book, Small and the Mighty, is really incredible and highlights some of these very important figures and inspires us to also model in their footsteps.
SPEAKER_02Thank you.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for having me. And thank you to all of our listeners. I hope you'll subscribe to our show and share it with your friends and family. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...