Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

The Unwritten Role: First Ladies in American Democracy

Mar 19, 202531 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this special episode of Consider the Constitution, Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey explores the evolving role of America's First Ladies with Anita McBride, former Assistant to President George W. Bush and Chief of Staff to First Lady Laura Bush, and co-author of "Remember the First Ladies: The Legacies of America's History-Making Women." Though the Constitution never defines this role, First Ladies, from Martha Washington to today, have wielded significant influence in shaping policy, diplomacy, and national identity. McBride shares fascinating insights about how these women served as essential partners to presidents while carving out their own legacies - from Dolley Madison saving White House treasures during war to Lady Bird Johnson advocating for civil rights in the hostile South. Drawing from her extensive research for her book, McBride reveals how these remarkable women used their "automatic powerful platform" to advance the nation, even when they themselves lacked constitutional rights.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackin and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.

SPEAKER_00Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, with James Madison's Montpelier. In this episode, we turn our attention to an often overlooked role in the American governance, the First Lady. While the Constitution does not define the role of the president's spouse, First Ladies have wielded significant influence, advancing policy and initiatives, shaping public discourse, and representing the nation on a global scale.

SPEAKER_01Today we'll discuss the evolving role of First Ladies, their constitutional significance, and how their leadership continues to shape the nation in ways both seen and unseen. And it's an honor to welcome Anita McBride to the show today. She is an internationally recognized expert on the legacies of American First Ladies and operations of the White House. She has over two decades of experience in three presidential administrations, serving in senior roles under Presidents Ronald Reagan, George H.

SPEAKER_01W. Bush, and George W. Bush. In 2023, Anita co-authored Remember the First Ladies, The Legacies of America's History-Making Women, showcasing the evolving role of the First Lady and its historical influence on the American presidency, politics, policy, and global diplomacy. She serves as an executive in residence at the Center for Congressional and Presidential Studies at American University, where she leads the First Lady Initiative.

SPEAKER_01Anita, welcome to the show today. Oh, Katie, thank you so much for having me. As we start our conversation, I want us to think about the role of the First Lady as it applies to the Constitution. So this role isn't outlined in that founding charter, yet it's become a significant part of American political life. Can you tell us what this role looked like when we think about our first presidents? Um, you know, George Washington, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, and of course, James Madison.

SPEAKER_02Katie, this is a perfect place to start about this topic because as it relates to the Constitution, you know, there's 35 words for the president's oath of office, not one word, of course, about the first lady. So what does that mean? Two things. One, it's a blank slate for every single person that comes into the role to do with it what they want. But it's also an automatic, powerful platform. And throughout history, first ladies have felt the responsibility to use that platform for something, for issues that they care about or something that helps advance the country, helps support the president and the president's constitutional, you know, roles and responsibilities.

SPEAKER_02And starting with our very first first lady, I mean, thanks to George Washington, who recognized immediately that this new position as president of the United States, as both head of state and head of government, was a two-person job. And he really needed the help of Martha, who thankfully for him and lucky for him, was a very experienced social hostess. So the ceremonial role was one that she could really fulfill and help him. And to set that tone for the new nation and the citizens of our new nation, he received her on the shores of New York, actually in New Jersey, and then brought her over to New York, received her with great fanfare to our new capital in New York City, to set the tone for everyone that her role was very important.

SPEAKER_02Now, much to her chagrin, she was immediately handed a list of some uh roles and responsibilities or things that she needed to host. And she felt a little bit like a state prisoner, but she set the precedent, important precedent for this role as a partner to the presidency. And Abigail Adams, you know, had the benefit of being with Martha, accompanying her on the things that she did, part of her social levies. It's not exactly what Abigail wanted to do to the social part of it, but she did fulfill it.

SPEAKER_02She was an advisor, a confidant to her husband that he valued her political skills. And it's so interesting because at this period of time, women did not have rights in our constitution. In fact, Abigail Adams really admonished her husband in the writing of the Constitution to remember the ladies. That's where we get the title of our book that you referenced. But of course, it was 133 years before that happened and women really had rights. But yet she was a powerful force.

SPEAKER_02And so much so and recognized that way that she was criticized for it publicly and called Mrs. President. So it was a bit divisive, yet she was an important part of his presidency. And we're very lucky that there's such a treasure trove of correspondence between John Adams and Abigail Adams that really gives us a window into the and she was an eyes and ears to the revolution. These women, these early women in our country, they were patriots. They were profoundly devoted to the success of their husbands and of the country.

SPEAKER_02But followed by Dolly Madison, who fulfilled this social hostess role for both Thomas Jefferson, who was the widowed president. His daughter Martha lived with him for a little while in the White House, but then she wanted to go home to Virginia. So Dolly fulfilled this role as her husband was Secretary of State, James Madison, fulfilled it for him, and then also for President Madison. And I think the best way to describe her, she was the great unifier. She was the one that knew the standard of bipartisan entertaining was set by her in a way that went unmatched for decades.

SPEAKER_02And I think James Madison valued her social skills, but really valued her political astuteness just as much. And of course, you know, a heroine of the White House in the burning of the White House in the War of 1812 in August of 1814. You know, in saving the portrait of George Washington and in the document or having it cut down from its frame, rolled up, taken to safety, so it would not be a prize of war by the British, and of saving our founding documents that at that time, of course, the president's office and the president's home was in the same place.

SPEAKER_02These are incredible acts of courage. And these three women really set the tone for this position.

SPEAKER_01And in your book, you talk about how this role as first lady is really important. And it's really something only the spouse of the president can fulfill. We have examples through American history where Thomas Jefferson, he didn't have a wife at the time. He was a widower. He had a daughter who could step in. But those family members never really step in or serve the role the way a first lady does.

SPEAKER_02You know, it is different. Yes. And in fact, you know, in our book, we really we'd say that we wrote this book about the spouses, those who served alongside their husbands for the tenure of their administrations. Now there have been some first ladies who were really not involved and want like Jane Pierce, who was in mourning for the first two years of her husband's presidency. And so other members of the family did have to step in. And there have, and then there's the example of our only bachelor president, Ocaris James Buchanan, whose niece Harriet Lane expertly fulfilled that role and really was a de facto first lady.

SPEAKER_02She had also served alongside him as a social hostess when he was ambassador to the court of St. James. She was highly skilled diplomatically. So she fulfilled the role really well. And we do have other first ladies who, with her either reasons of illness or like Ida McKinley, whose daughters had to step in. Of course, uh Woodrow Wilson when his first wife died, and then he was a widow for a period of time, but Edith Wilson swooped in pretty soon after that. But it is different for a family member to fulfill this role as opposed to the president's spouse.

SPEAKER_01And as you talk about, you know, especially these early First Ladies being patriots, being confidants, advisors, what was it that Dolly Madison brought to that role that was unique that earned her that name of the first first lady?

SPEAKER_02You know, her ability to bring all sides together. She was expert at that. And she used her social entertaining skills to help her husband in valuable ways of working the room. You know, her her events at the White House were so crowded. They were called squeezes, as you know, because people literally had to squeeze in the room. But she would, of course, dress in a very, very vibrant colors, a plume on her head. So she would be seen everywhere in the room, work the room for valuable pieces of information that were helpful to her husband.

SPEAKER_02And she was beloved on both sides about that. That was an enormous skill and help to her husband, who maybe didn't have quite the personality that Dolly did. So she was very, very helpful. Again, I think reiterating that her social skills that she brought to this really with the value of using her personality was her political skill and her political astuteness. And as a unifying force, the bipartisan entertaining, I cannot emphasize that enough, how valuable that was.

SPEAKER_02In a time where, you know, it still was not certain that our country would survive. And the other things that she did too was very devoted to supporting burgeoning American industries, right? Having things made in America as showcased in the White House to show that, you know, we really were able to compete with the other nations of the world for their craftsmanship.

SPEAKER_01And Dolly Madison is such an interesting figure, especially when you think about James Madison. He was a pretty short, small guy, 5'2-ish, 110, 15 pounds, you know, more of an introvert, definitely an intellectual, but Dolly, I just see her coming to that relationship and being the perfect foil. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_02A true partner in that way. She complimented him. He needed her. This is definitely an example where the president was so for how many of these presidents would not have been president without their wives, but also would not have been as successful without the skills, the social entertaining skills. That soft diplomacy, those soft power skills are absolutely critical, not only in our early founding years, but to today as well. That is a thread of continuity for first.

SPEAKER_02That's what connects a lot of them together for sure, being able to use their social skills to benefit their husbands.

SPEAKER_01And Anita, I think there's something really to be said about women throughout American history, but particularly during the 19th and early 20th century when women don't really have any rights in this country. And these women, women like Dolly, are using this platform. They do have political savvy. There's a lot of political insight that they bring to the table, like you were mentioning.

SPEAKER_02That's so true. And one of the themes in our book and how we trace the status of women in our country over the period of time and how first ladies pushed up against that were many of them leaders in pushing the nation forward a bit to see the valuable role of women or how they had to be integrated in society. Not all first ladies wanted that, of course. And some felt, you know, that even though they had political power, like a Sarah Polk, really didn't support suffrage because she didn't feel women had to have a formalized role in society.

SPEAKER_02Her power was, she knew her superpower. Her superpower was behind the scenes in supporting her husband. We have people like Caroline Harrison, who in 1890, as many first ladies through our history, are asked to advocate for a cause or raise money for a cause. And she was asked to raise money for Johns Hopkins Medical School in Baltimore, and she said yes on one condition, that they would admit women on an equal footing. This is 1890. And they did.

SPEAKER_02And so again, that shows the power of using that platform even when rights were not codified in our Constitution. And it again would not be until 1920 where women got the right to vote, and Florence Harding being the first to be able to cast a vote for president, of course, for her husband.

SPEAKER_01How does the role of the first lady evolve over time from these early first ladies we were talking about to this modern day?

SPEAKER_02Well, you know, one of the periods of time that sort of changed things too are the social movements of the late 1800s, early 1900s, the temperance movement, labor movement. So you had people like Ellen Wilson, who did not serve very long as a first wife of Woodrow Wilson, yet she cared about labor conditions for women in the workforce as women were coming into the warforce. She would go investigate federal buildings and see the conditions of women.

SPEAKER_02In fact, at the U.S. Postal Service, she thought the conditions for women there were abysmal and complained about it. And the Postmaster General ignored her. Somehow the story got into the New York Times and conditions were improved. So there were these social movements that were happening in the country, and some first ladies were bold enough to be engaged and help move the nation forward. Again, this is before women, of course, had had the right to vote. And then in more modern times, of course, we have examples of activist first ladies like Eleanor Roosevelt, who really did set a standard for activism.

SPEAKER_02Not everybody liked that, of course. You know, Franklin Roosevelt did not want her to have an active role. She really worried that she would be stifled in the role of first lady. She came into this position, of course, having a speaking career. She was making money. She had a radio show. She had a newspaper column. And, you know, Franklin did not want her to have a role. But she pushed up against that and became what also had 12 years to do the job. Now she was followed by a first lady, Bess Truman, who really knew she could never be Eleanor and did not want to go into coal mines, as she said.

SPEAKER_02She didn't really want a public role. But there is no question she was her husband's most important advisor behind the scenes. He counted on her for everything. There was not a decision Harry Truman made without her. And he was criticized for that, relying on his wife too much. And he said, why wouldn't I rely on her? She has better judgment than anybody around me.

SPEAKER_01Anita, are there some particular first ladies that you think have influenced policy and governance and transformed that role of first lady more so than others?

SPEAKER_02Well, I think one first lady that, of course, we talked about Eleanor Roosevelt, and that was a transformative period, of course. You know, Lady Bert Johnson really revived that activist role, and she was deeply engaged in several, you know, important issues, social issues going on in the country. Of course, the Civil Rights Act. And, you know, when her husband signed that, he knew it was a political killer for him. He felt he had lost the South for Democrats for years to come. It was Lady Bur Johnson's really courageous act to take a train trip through nine southern states, starting in Virginia and ending in New Orleans, Louisiana, and going not to all the big cities, but to the small towns too, and to really advocate for why the civil rights legislation was important for our country to be unified.

SPEAKER_02And she felt she could go do it, that she would be better received or the crowds would be kinder to her than they would be to her husband as a southern woman. She felt it would be more helpful that she went. And this trip was not without danger. In fact, a train had to travel 15 minutes ahead of her at every stop because of bomb threats, just for security for her. And this was a real act of courage. She also was really should be considered our nation's first environmental first lady.

SPEAKER_02Her activism, her lobbying advocacy, both overtly and behind the scenes for the passage of the Highway Beautification Act, is really due to her and her belief and her love of our country and its beautiful natural landscape, and that it needed to be protected and that every community in town and every citizen could have a role in that. And how did she learn that? She learned that by driving from Washington, D.C. to Texas when she was the wife of a congresswoman and seeing the condition of our nation's highways and said, our nation's too beautiful for this, and every American needs to be invested in protecting it.

SPEAKER_02So that's a level of activism that we really should shine a light on. Betty Ford in the ERA, of course, is another one. Rosalind Carter in mental health. Pat Nixon, who is so misunderstood and so underrepresented in our history, her role as a diplomat representing our country, even as second lady. I mean, Dwight Eisenhower used to say to Richard Nixon when he would send Vice President Nixon out on foreign trips, he would say to Richard Nixon, take Pat with you, because she was so good and is really showing the heart and soul and compassion of America wherever she went.

SPEAKER_01We've talked about some of the wonderful things that these women have advocated for serving in a role as advisor. How do these women, especially being on a national stage, but how do they balance their own identity and own personal lives amidst all of this?

SPEAKER_02It's a great question, and it's one that has plagued every first lady. From our first first lady, you know, to today. I mean, for example, you know, Martha Washington, who really believed, you know, her name should only be in the paper three times in her life when she was born, when she got married, and when she died. And there was interest in the press, particularly as she was supporting an American fashion industry, only wore American-made clothes. And newspapers wanted to cover that.

SPEAKER_02And she did not really want to be featured. So there's there's always a bit of a complication, of course, with the press. And first ladies don't want to be uh get on the wrong side of what their husbands have said. You know, they always worry about the trick questions. I knew that with the first ladies that I work for. Nancy Reagan, of course, was plagued by this. Her first year as first lady was so difficult on how she was portrayed in the press, how she was admonished for being the gazing at her husband, the adoring looks.

SPEAKER_02Of course, she was there for him. Nancy Reagan didn't care about her own publicity. She was there for Ronald Reagan, but it really hurt. And it hurt him. I mean, he took the podium in the White House press room to say his wife was getting a bum rap. So it does affect them. It does affect the first ladies. I think more importantly, they don't, they don't want to make a mistake publicly in the press. Some are more skilled at using the press than others. Mostly the press tries to define them in a very one-dimensional way and not really looking at them in the full breadth of their life, their experiences, what they're bringing to the table.

SPEAKER_02We really do try and highlight that in the book as an example of what makes a first lady successful in the role. And that's part of it is what they bring, what interests they bring to the table, how they're able to shine a light on that, but also how their husbands view the role, how their husbands allow them to be successful in the role or not. And that's a factor that's really important. And how the media covers them is um, you know, it's hard to shake how you've been defined.

SPEAKER_02This is one example I can give you is Laura Bush in 2000. After the election was finally decided, you know, by the Supreme Court in December of 2000, Mrs. Bush gave an interview and was asked by the reporter, well, Mrs. Bush, who are you going to be like? More like Hillary Clinton or Barbara Bush? And meaning, you know, is she going to be an activist or is she going to be sort of the old-fashioned view of the role, like her mother-in-law? And her response was classic. She said, Well, I know Laura Bush pretty well, so I'm going to be her.

SPEAKER_02And, you know, sort of said, like somehow she couldn't be her own person. And that, you know, was hard to shake in the press's mind. Of course, she ended up being a very popular and beloved first lady for her eight years, was very active, both globally and domestically. And of course, she really showed how she could comfort the nation in one of its most difficult moments, of course, after 9-11.

SPEAKER_01And Anita, you've worked closely with several First Ladies, obviously, and studied their legacies. What moments or experiences stand out to you most?

SPEAKER_02Well, some of the things that stand out to me are things I didn't know before researching this book. Bess Truman is one example of that. You know, I didn't really know the depth of what you know. She was a Senate staffer for her husband when he was sent her from Missouri. And of course, it was her family's connections that made it possible for him to even run for office. And uh, she worked in his office. She did the schedule, she did clippings, she did constituent work, she handled mail, but she also, obviously, as a Senate spouse, built those relationships with spouses on both sides of the aisle and also with senators as well on both sides of the aisle.

SPEAKER_02Why is this important? This is important because when she became first lady, which very reluctantly became first lady because she didn't want a public profile like Eleanor Roosevelt for reasons I had mentioned before, but also because her father had committed suicide, and there was such stigma around that she was afraid the public would find out. And her mother had never really fully recovered from that. So she was dealing with a lot of things. But she was a very close advisor to her husband. But the Trumans, when they were living there, the White House was deemed uninhabitable, and they had to move out for three and a half years.

SPEAKER_02And they moved into Blair House. And so the Army Corps of Engineers deemed it structurally unsound. It had to be completely rebuilt. Several proposals were presented to the Trumans as well as to the Congress who had to fund it. And of course, the Congress wanted to do the cheapest one, which was tear the whole building down and rebuild. The most expensive one was to protect the exterior, dig deep underneath, have to disassemble and assemble all the equipment deep underground the White House, rebuild with steel girded from the interior, rebuild the White House completely.

SPEAKER_02Of course the Congress didn't want to do that. But it was really Bess Truman's advocacy behind the scenes, using her skills, knowing the Senate, knowing the Senate appropriators on both sides of the aisle, knowing the spouses, basically the message that she gave was if you do this, the American people will never forgive you. And when you think about that White House, you have to think of Bess Truman and Harry Truman too, but how they protected this most incredible symbol of our American democracy, where every president except George Washington has lived.

SPEAKER_02The other, you know, and when we think about the protection and historic preservation of the White House, of course, we think about Jackie Kennedy, who I'll mention as well, whose husband did not want her to focus on historic preservation, thought it was an elite, be perceived as very elitist. But she put into place a system that is still operating, the White House Historical Association, as a nonprofit entity who raises all the money for all the restoration, all the preservation, all the painting, all the collection, all the portraits, everything inside that White House, because Jackie Kennedy knew there would never ever be enough government money to keep the White House the museum quality that it deserved to be.

SPEAKER_02And it is considered a museum, is accredited as a museum. So these, you know, two women, one who we know so much about, Jackie Kennedy, an iconic young first lady who really did set a great tone in the modern era for culture in America. But that's true and who we knew less about and really has every bit as much credit for protecting our White House.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's why your book in part is so important. These are stories that I didn't realize that they were thinking about tearing the White House down and my heart almost stopped because I can't I can't imagine. Exactly. It just kind of underscores the importance of these women. You know, we pay so much attention to the presidents and what they brought, but there's also this really important history associated with their lives as well.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, there is, and they wanted to use the platform while they have it. You know, some are more overt and public than others. Some push the envelope a bit much. Of course, when Hillary Clinton came in, put an office in the West Wing, oversaw a White House presidential initiative that the president handed to her. But yet, you know, the country just wasn't ready at that moment. But, you know, things continually evolved. I mean, that's the thing about this position. It's what each person brings to it, what they can make of it, how the president supports them, how the nation responds to it.

SPEAKER_02It's just, as I said at the beginning of this, it's an automatic, powerful platform. Yet it's up to them if they want to use it in that way. There's nothing that's requiring them to do it.

SPEAKER_01And as we wrap up our conversation today, what do you hope people will take away from your research, your experience on first ladies and their place in American history?

SPEAKER_02We're at a real critical moment for the study of history and civic education in our country as we are inching towards our nation's 250th birthday in just a year. You know, it's such an opportunity for us to reflect on the full breadth of our founding, the courage that it took for our founding fathers, our founding mothers to help preserve, protect, support a system of government that exists nowhere else. And if we want to talk about history in our country and we talk about inclusive history, how could we not include these women and the partnership that they were to our leaders throughout the course of history?

SPEAKER_02How women's role in society continued to evolve and how they went from having no rights to gaining a voice in the public square to becoming political actors of their own, and how that really is an important part of our nation's story that will continually change. So I hope people are inspired that even without codified rights, people use their position, and women in particular use their position to push the nation forward in the best way that they could because they were profoundly devoted to our country.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for talking with us today, Anita. You really gave us further insight on the courage, the intelligence, the perspective that these women brought to the office, how they supported their husbands, these presidents, but also how they behaved their own way as well and brought themselves to this role. Absolutely so thank you for that.

SPEAKER_02Thank you for that uh summary at the end. You're absolutely right. And I'm glad our books can do it because this started as a textbook, Katie. We are trying to get the first ever textbook that we, my co-authors and I did, came out in August of 2023. It's hard to believe that this is the first, but we're doing our best to get it into as many colleges and universities as possible. And then just co-authored a children's book from first to fourth grade. Dolly Madison is featured in it. So we should get this book to you all at Mount Pilliard.

SPEAKER_02It's called First Ladies Make History. And the real joy in this is I co-authored it with my daughter, who's studying to be an elementary school teacher, and right now is in the first grade. And it just really, because she saw up close and personal too, as I was working in the White House and had the opportunities to come there, she saw the influence of a first lady as well. So it's been a real joy. We're getting all ages involved in this.

SPEAKER_01And that is very important that we have not only this book, Remembering the First Ladies for Adults, but that we're sharing this history with younger generations.

SPEAKER_02Yes, thank you. Exactly.

SPEAKER_01I want to thank you, Anita McBride, and I want to thank our listeners. I hope you'll subscribe and share the show with your family and friends. And tune in again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode