The Temple and the Republic: Architecture, Liberty, and Madison's Legacy
29 minAudio
This episode is part of a special five-part miniseries examining James Madison's role in the American Revolution and the founding of the United States. As part of Montpelier's commemoration of the 250th anniversary of American independence, this series is funded by a grant from the Virginia American Revolution 250 Commission, in partnership with Virginia Humanities. In this final installment, Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey sits down with Chris Pasch, Montpelier's archaeology field director, to examine one of the property's most symbolically charged structures: the Temple. Built around 1810 while Madison was serving as president, this open-air classical structure draws on Greco-Roman architectural tradition to embed the ideals of Enlightenment, liberty, and self-government directly into the landscape. Pasch brings both archaeological evidence and architectural history to what the Temple reveals about Madison's world. This episode closes the miniseries with a reminder that the Temple's meaning endures: informed, active citizenship is the foundation on which the American experiment still stands. This episode is supported in part by the Virginia Law Foundation.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crocker Lackley and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
SPEAKER_01Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, with James Madison's Montpelier. This episode is one installment of a five-part mini-series funded by a grant from the Virginia American Revolution 250 Commission in partnership with the Virginia Humanities. This special series is part of Montpelier's broader effort to commemorate the 250th anniversary of America's founding.
SPEAKER_02In this final installment of the mini-series, we turn to one of the oldest and most iconic structures at Montpelier, the Temple. This open-air structure, built around 1810 beside the Madison home, was not a temple in the religious sense, but a deliberate architectural expression inspired by the ancient Greek and Roman world. Its columns, symmetry, and open design draw on the language of classical architecture long associated with democratic republicanism, civic virtue, and the duties of citizenship.
SPEAKER_02The temple also reflects a broader early nineteenth century trend as members of the founding generation ornamented their landscapes with classical forms such as temples, porticos, and colonnades to embed political meaning into the American landscape. As that revolutionary generation aged and passed the torch, architecture became one way to root the young republic in an older civic tradition. And at Montpelier, the temple really stands as both a retreat and reminder placing the American experiment within a much longer conversation about liberty and self-government.
SPEAKER_02And to help us better understand both the symbolic meaning and the lived history of this structure, I am joined today by Chris Pash, who is Montpelier's archaeology field director. And he's conducted extensive research and excavations at and around the temple site. He's uncovered material evidence that deepens our understanding of how this space was used and experienced over time. So, Chris, thank you for coming in from the field for a day and joining us in the studio here at Montpelier.
SPEAKER_00Hey, Katie, this is a great opportunity to be able to talk about my favorite site at Montpelier. I wrote my master's thesis on it. And luckily for us, we're going to be returning to the site to be excavating this year. So happy to talk about the symbolic meanings of this structure and everything we found in the past there.
SPEAKER_02So as we've just noted, kind of in this intro, the temple offers insight into how James Madison and many early Americans in the decades following the American Revolution and the ratification of the Constitution, how they are understanding identity as well as the future of this new republic. That really they're creating not just a new government, but really a new sense of self, a new identity to this country. Now, when Madison commissions this structure, this temple, he is serving in the White House.
SPEAKER_02He's president of the United States. So the temple is, I think, symbolic because of the context, but it's also reflecting the classical Greco-Roman architectural style that has becoming more and more prevalent at that period. Can you tell us more? You know, we know a little bit about where it's located on the landscape, kind of what it looks like, but can you go into that a little more deeply as well as expand upon the significance of that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'd love to. So the temple has, as you mentioned, has deep roots in sort of classical architectural designs. Jefferson is often attributed as one of the individuals who brings Palladianism to North America. It's way more complicated than that. But Jefferson and Madison were close friends and therefore influenced each other quite a lot. Jefferson exchanges some letters, sketches of an earlier version of the temple around 1804, that some people are wondering if he originally intended it to be on his property at Monticello, or if it was done for the intention of where it ultimately ended up at Montpelier for Madison.
SPEAKER_00We're not sure we don't have any specific writings about that. But the architecture itself, from being an open-air style temple or a monopteros, or a monopteral temple, don't expect anyone to remember the Greco-Roman terms. That style, it's a set of pillars, open-air structure supporting a dome or a half dome. There's other variants that have a cella or an interior structure, a room. The one at Montpelier does not. You can see, in regards to significance, this style or monopteros appear as almost a symbolic trope or caricature that carries across different architectural styles.
SPEAKER_00So you can see it sometimes as a facade on a plantation. Or uh William Thornton at one point had the original design for the Capitol building would have had a massive monopteros on the top of it. You can see other variants of it, smaller scale, larger scale, from garden follies to art pieces, propaganda. It's everywhere in the late 18th and early 19th century. It's Tuscan order pillars. So the columns are Tuscan order. There are triglyphs on the sort of relief around the dome, which are three vertical lines that repeat.
SPEAKER_00At one point in time, there was contemplation of having a sort of ox skull and floral motif that repeats. That doesn't appear to actually have come to fruition. But again, all these elements sort of call back repeatedly, just in terms of if you're looking at it at surface value stylistically, they all tie back to Greco-Roman influences, as well as some revivals in that architectural style in the 1720s, 1730s in England and France. So Jefferson sees that in his travels, I believe, with Adams, and they write about it.
SPEAKER_00They're very influenced by it, bringing it to the New World, where it starts to pick up in North America in the 1780s, 90s, and then ultimately 1809 time period when Madison is doing that.
SPEAKER_02As you're describing this, it makes sense in my head because we see these men getting away from more traditional British style, like the Georgian, which is very much about, you know, everything needs to be symmetrical. And that's how the landscape and the Madison House itself is structured during James Madison's father's period. But this is kind of James Madison coming into his own. And we're seeing a very different order of the landscape of the buildings.
SPEAKER_02So as you talked about the architecture of the structure of this temple, how does it fit within the lines of sight of the Madison House itself? Again, kind of getting away from that ordered landscape. So what does this look like?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I appreciate you following up on that detail. So I was just talking about the structure in and of itself, sort of in a cultural context, but within that is also the cultural context of garden landscape design that I think you're getting at. So the Georgian era, lots of symmetry in the archaeological work we've done in the past showed the 18th-century landscape, the main house was much smaller. It had a lot of symmetry that spilled out into the formal yard. There were masonry retaining walls that came out to create separation of space, very orderly, funnels your eye in a very specific way, and it's very obvious.
SPEAKER_00Those rules still apply to the picturesque landscape design, which is what Madison Jr., president Madison is coming up in, sort of influenced by what some landscape historians refer to as like the ornamental farm or ornamental plantation. In the picturesque, they are also kind of influenced by early romanticism in the art world, where they want everything to appear natural, but it's all created by humans. So replacing garden walls and obvious symmetry may be hidden symmetries by having undulating landscapes.
SPEAKER_00If you zoom out and look at the plantation from a bird's eye view, you will notice parallels. You know, we have the temple on, if you're looking at the house to the left, and then to the right, you have the boxwood grotto. And they they're not symmetrical with each other in terms of different structures, one's plant, one's building, but they are equidistance to the center of the main, the the front entrance of the main house. So there is intention there, but when you're looking at it, it doesn't look symmetrical, but it's hidden in plain sight, if you will.
SPEAKER_00But that's sort of controlling views and perspectives is still a goal of the elite in designing their plantations. The other thing here in the picturesque design is if you look at the main house or the formal grounds during Madison Jr.'s ownership of the property. You have the south yard on one side, and then you have the pineole on the other. So that's the space that is in between the main house and the box of grotto and the temple on either side.
SPEAKER_02And can you explain the pineole? Because that's one of the important features of the temple.
SPEAKER_00So within, if you are looking to the left of the house, there's the front, the columns of the front portico, which is constructed, and then they spill out into the yard, but the columns are replaced by trees that are spaced almost as column, pine trees specifically, extending out towards the temple. So if you're looking at the house or you're approaching as a visitor to the house, you're gonna see the main house. And then your eye gets drawn over to the temple through the planted landscape away from the south yard.
SPEAKER_02And one of the things I love in doing tours through the house, when you're in the dining room, you can look through the window and see what Madison and his guests would have seen. These pine trees funneling your eye towards the temple at the end of this pineole.
SPEAKER_00Yes. So that was all intentional to a point where there was input from the architect who was overseeing the construction of the temple at the time and also the expansions to the main house, Dinsmore, who was also involved at Monticello. But he wrote to Madison saying, I really think you should have some windows on the north side in your library and the dining room that look out towards the temple. Because if you don't put the windows there, no one's going to see it from inside. And I do think that's really significant when you start as an anthropologist or archaeologist and you're trying to understand how people are living and viewing space, experiencing space, it raises all kinds of new questions that you can have about what is the experience of Madison, the Madison's guests, the enslaved who are in the dining rooms when they're debating, when Lafayette comes to visit and they're debating the ethics and morals of the institution of slavery.
SPEAKER_00And then they have this iconic structure that they're all seeing as they're having these conversations in the background that symbolizes constitutional government, democracy, enlightenment, values, liberty. And it's just an interesting sort of symbolic set piece, if you will, that Madison intends to have as a conversational piece, but also has real lived meanings for everyone who's visiting Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02It's a tangible example, a built structure on the landscape that all those people in that dining room, such as the Marquis de Lafayette, who visits in 1824 and 1825, if they're not talking about it already, they're seeing the structure and they know what it means. They know what it symbolizes. Everybody in the room does. What liberty and constitutional government and what we the people mean to each one of those individuals is different. But it's a very tangible reminder of that. So again, Chris, we talked about how this structure is kind of hearkening thoughts back to ancient Greece and Rome.
SPEAKER_02And we know that Madison is very inspired by the governments of those different civilizations, and it really informs his drafting of the Virginia plan, which becomes a blueprint for the Constitution. What can you tell us about what Madison is saying and thinking about the construction of this temple specifically? Yes, it's on the minds of many of his contemporaries, this kind of architectural style, but what do we know about what he's saying?
SPEAKER_00So that is one of the most frustrating things when you go to actually try to research this topic, is that Madison does not say anything explicitly about the temple being constructed on his plantation and what it meant to him, what his friends thought of it. But that doesn't mean that there isn't enough information out there about the cultural context of it, how it's used, both in his sort of the ecosystem he's living in, as we've kind of discussed earlier in his life when he's at Princeton even and other places.
SPEAKER_00But what we can sort of look at is how does Madison use terms like temple in his writings? So I scoured through a lot of his letters, especially with Jefferson and trying to look for any references to temples. And there's one quote that stands out to me. He's talking about the University of Virginia.
SPEAKER_02Which University of Virginia Jefferson founds, but Madison becomes president of the university at one point. So there's a really deep kind of connection between those two men and that institution.
SPEAKER_00Yes. So there's a letter from 1823. So it's after the temple's constructed, but it's close to us under trying to understand how he may have viewed the structure. He says, You do not overrate the interest I feel in the University of Virginia as the temple through which alone lies the road to that of liberty. He capitalizes temple, he capitalizes liberty. My reading of that is he's referring to education, institutes of education or buildings of education as temples. It's important to remember that for a lot of the founders, they're influenced by enlightenment thought, philosophy, science, these things that boom in the 18th century.
SPEAKER_00Madison and Jefferson are products of that time. And to them, university is the epitome of these temples of learning, temples of science, and that direct through line of a temple through learning as almost it's it's funny because they're almost using the same kind of thoughts in temples of worship, of reaching sort of a state of enlightenment. They're using that through education, knowledge, accumulation, and the sharing of ideas.
SPEAKER_00And that is the path through which they gain liberty. And liberty is a term that has a lot of different meanings. And I think that in this context, specifically, Madison has an intended meaning of what he means by liberty. And that sometimes isn't what we often today assume to be the only definition of liberty.
SPEAKER_02I love this idea of what does liberty mean? And your reading of Madison and Jefferson's back and forth discussion. This temple structure symbolizing enlightenment through education and knowledge, through that is how you become free.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And also one could go, well, the temple at Montpelier is not a house of education. It's just a garden folly, which there have been architectural historians that have argued that in the past and that it's nothing more than a garden folly. But when you start looking at its contemporary examples, it appears as a parade float. I think it's like the Grand Federal Edifice. It was a 13-columned monopteral temple designed by Charles Peel, who's a contemporary of Madison, that was a float being paraded in the streets during the ratification of the Constitution.
SPEAKER_00And it actually had 12 pillars, one was missing to symbolize the 13 states coming together to ratify the Constitution. So it also had connotations of democracy, of constitutional governments or republics. And you see it in a lot of propaganda, political pamphlets, even on sort of proto-feminist literature and abolitionist literature being sort of co-opted to critique these temples as intended to be houses of liberty, houses of constitutional government.
SPEAKER_00And you have folks going, hey, let's expand inclusion into this. And they're having that conversation in 1780, 1790 before the temple is even built at Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02So there's we're seeing before Montpelier's temple here, we're seeing references, like uses of this symbol to either celebrate liberty or as a commentary of, well, liberty means a lot more and you're not including all of these people.
SPEAKER_00But there's still the shared symbol. They're all using this symbol. So it means it clearly has shared significance and meaning to all these different groups that are driven by Enlightenment thought, this desire for liberty through becoming part of essentially what is social contract government. Like to be a participant in social contract government, you need to be informed because you're going to be voting on issues that impact other people. And you're bringing your own personal experiences to it. And these are all the values that Madison is bringing to the Constitution, the Bill of Rights.
SPEAKER_02Well, Chris, this really brings us full circle back to the first episode in this miniseries where Dr. Lynn Yuzell was speaking about some of the ideas and theories that influenced Madison. And the social contract theory is really a core idea that inspires him. So it's just really interesting to kind of pull these threads of inquiry and see how this continues throughout his life and he's echoing those ideas in this temple structure.
SPEAKER_02And we've talked a lot about the symbolism of it. And I want to also get to how it was used and what the archaeology reveals, because this is such a complex and nuanced part of the landscape, not just in how all of these different individuals, whether it's James, Dolly, members of their family, their guests, or the enslaved people here are understanding the meaning of the structure. How are they using it?
SPEAKER_00So use of the structure, because it is a garden folly, a level of critique at those who called it nothing more than a garden folly, but it is a garden folly in terms of its practical everyday use. We can assume a couple things based off of some documentary references. It's sometimes referred to as Madison Summer Studies. So he may have gone out there to read, reflect on some of these very things that we're talking about. We do have some fictionalized accounts from folks that visited Montpelier as children, and they sort of wrote from memory sort of a memoir.
SPEAKER_00So it's some historians have talked about how parts of it are uncertain if the accuracy of it. But we do know that it is possible from these accounts that Dolly Madison and other guests of the Madisons may have been using it for sort of relaxation or eating snacks and things like that, just sort of looking at the beautiful views from the temple, because where it's situated is at the northern edge of the formal grounds around the main house, and it's looking down at this massive ravine.
SPEAKER_00And there's an ornamental ice pond that had ornamental islands in it, and beyond that, massive tobacco fields. And there's a interestingly a painting from the 18th century in an English context that's almost identical to the temple and up on a hill overlooking a pond situation, and aristocrats are having tea in this garden folly monopteral temple style. So from our practical standpoint, it's being used potentially like that by the Madisons, as well as being a symbolic conversation piece on the landscape.
SPEAKER_00But what's fascinating is that underlying the temple is a 24-foot deep brick-lined ice house. I mentioned the ice pond, and that's all part of the same infrastructure. The ice house is totally hidden from view when you're in the main house or approaching it because of the door or access to the ice house is on the back side of the temple below the floor. So if you're looking down the pineoleet, you can't see the entrance to the ice house. There's no way to know there's an ice house under it.
SPEAKER_02So Madison sitting at the dining table with his guests, he is not going to see the enslaved people who are possibly going into the ice house and pulling out meats or ice for drinks or whatever they have in there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's possible. If you do see it, it may just appear as like distant activity. Um, there is a watercolor Madison era, and it shows an enslaved woman and child walking along the front fence, and she's holding a pitcher. And she's presumably there's no kitchen or entertainment space there other than the temple, but the kitchen is on the south side of the main house. So my reading of that is there is tied infrastructure, the fact that you have the kitchen in the south yard. You also have kitchens and the cellar spaces, the dining room and the house, and ice is going to be used from everything from chilled wine, making ice cream, storing cheese, cream, meats, as you're talking about.
SPEAKER_00We do have oral histories and quotes that describe that, plus the archaeology that has shown evidence for all of this stuff. And so we do know that the space is being used, I think to your original question, by the enslaved. They're interacting with it, even though. The temple is at the far end of this formal, pretty landscape. It's the fact that it has this utilitarian structure below, and that's being interacted with and utilized almost on a daily basis by the enslaved. They're going to have all kinds of different readings of that structure or their own understanding of it within the larger contexts of what we've all been talking about this whole time.
SPEAKER_00One of the things with ice house labor specifically, it takes a lot of people, a lot of energy to harvest ice from a source and to fill the ice house. Oftentimes, from our understanding of Monticello, Shirley Plantation, contemporaries of Montpelier, you would have probably had a large number of the enslaved population one or two days out of a year, harvesting the ice as fast as possible on the coldest days, coldest nights, to get that ice fill the ice house, and it would last almost a whole year. And so even if you have enslaved individuals who are usually in the Eastwoods or other parts of the larger 5,000 acre plantation that may not be in the kitchens interacting with the structure on a daily basis, they are interacting with it even if it's one or two days a year.
SPEAKER_00And it's this symbolic structure that's a focal point on the plantation. So in my thesis, I try to also get at sort of their potential readings of the structure.
SPEAKER_02It's interesting that this structure is not just a symbol of democracy, democratic republicanism. And it's this, as you said, main focal point for the landscape. But it really has a significant role in facilitating Madison's lifestyle and the ability to present fancy meals and the things that his guests would be expecting, but all through the labor of the enslaved community.
SPEAKER_02So, I mean, what a conversation that is, especially today, as we try to understand, you know, that's a question we really try to get at from, you know, our interpretive guides to archaeology department to our collections, our research, Center for the Constitution. How is Madison understanding his world? You know, what is his context? How is he trying to create this government on a scale that's never been done before while grappling with these ideas of liberty, perhaps in a contradictory way almost?
SPEAKER_02So I guess as we try to wrap up, how do we understand it today? And what insight does it give into that world of early 1800s as America is trying to understand who it is?
SPEAKER_00I think there's two ideas. One is that social contract theory, that our style of government, democratic republic, constitutional republic, we have a sort of duty to live up to the sort of ideals of the founders and the fact that we have now more than ever so many resources at our disposal to become knowledgeable, to educate, to research. And it is in some ways our duty as voters, the fact that we impact people beyond our own existences and being informed about the impact of our voting is essential to upholding this idealistic structure that is precarious.
SPEAKER_00So that if you want to think about a constitution and our government as a monopteros, this domed structure being held up by these pillars in an open-air style, it requires a lot of balance. So I think that's one takeaway. I think the other is that it is a house and was being used in the 18th century and early 19th century to symbolize the idea of inviting people in. The idea that you were inviting as many people from around the world as possible into this democratic ideal of enlightenment-based government, democracy.
SPEAKER_00And so it is stronger as a house if you have more people involved in it, all of whom are actively participating through that social contract ideal, through education and knowledge and things like that. And I so I think those two things are important. I think Madison's personal motto, veritas nonverba magistri, truth, not the words of a master. And what he means by that is knowledge, like learning truth, not just accepting what is being told to you by institutions of power that have a long history of shutting down or suppressing freedom of speech, liberty of thought, liberty of conscience, which is sort of what I was alluding to earlier, this idea that you can learn things, think things, and repeat what you believe and exercise that through voting and being an active citizen.
SPEAKER_00And the fact that he chose that as his personal motto, I think has these through lines all over the place to the architectural style of the temple, to the Bill of Rights and what ultimately came to be as our government.
SPEAKER_02As you said, I think the temple really is an echo of what he tried to accomplish in the Constitution and Bill of Rights. And from what you've described, it makes me and hopefully our listeners understand that the temple and its significance are still meaningful today. And we, as citizens of this country, have a duty really hearkening back to this social contract. We gain so much by being part of this collective, but that also means that we give up certain things for the betterment of the whole.
SPEAKER_02It's about the good of everybody. And that doesn't happen by being passive. It requires active participation. And not just any participation, but informed participation. That piece about being educated and informed, which is so powerful. Madison is telling us we have so much power by learning and understanding how this works and how we can be involved. So thank you for capturing that message and giving us more insight into this really, really iconic and significant structure here at Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02So thank you, Chris, for joining us today.
SPEAKER_00Thanks, Katie. I appreciate the opportunity to talk about it. And if anyone wants to learn more about the temple, they can always come visit us, especially if you come on one of our excavation programs. I give a two to four hour tour of the Temple and Ice House. If you're really a nerd, I can go deep on it.
SPEAKER_02Yes, Montpelier offers these archaeology expeditions, which are really, really important to helping the public learn about not just the archaeological process, but also what we do here at Montpelier. And thank you all for tuning in today. I hope you'll share the show with your family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...