Official Message: How Members of Congress Communicate with Constituents
24 minAudio
In this illuminating episode of Consider the Constitution, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey welcomes back Dr. Lindsey Cormack, the pioneering political scientist who created DC Inbox - a first-of-its-kind digital archive preserving congressional newsletters. From James Madison's vision of Congress as the people's branch to today's digital communication tactics, this conversation uncovers the evolution of constituent engagement and the power dynamics of political messaging. Dr. Cormack explains why she invented this crucial archive solution when she discovered these taxpayer-funded communications weren't being systematically preserved.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
SPEAKER_00Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey with James Madison's Montpelier. The Legislative Branch, the U.S. Congress, was designed to be the most representative branch of government. We the people directly elect our representatives, and they're tasked with listening to our concerns, crafting legislation, and shaping national policy. Each member of Congress serves as a direct link between the people and the federal government.
SPEAKER_01But how well do they actually represent us? How accessible are they to their constituents, us, and how do they communicate their decisions? Understanding how Congress interacts with the public is essential for ensuring accountability and strengthening our democracy. So today, we're discussing aspects of the US Congress, how it functions, how it represents the public, and why transparency and accessibility are crucial in a democratic system.
SPEAKER_01Joining us for this conversation is Dr. Lindsay Cormac, a returning guest on Consider the Constitution. Dr. Cormac is an associate professor of political science and director of the diplomacy lab at Stevens Institute of Technology in Hoboken, New Jersey. She is the author of How to Raise a Citizen, a topic she's discussed with us in a September episode in 2024. After earning her PhD in political science from New York University, Dr.
SPEAKER_01Cormac launched DC Inbox, a digital public platform that archives and makes accessible all official e-newsletters sent by members of Congress to their constituents. Welcome back, Lindsay. It's great to have you in our studio today here at Montpelier. Thank you so much for having me. I'm so happy to be back. So as we begin our conversation, let's start with the basics. So James Madison, preparing for the Constitutional Convention in 1787, drafted what we referred to as this Virginia plan from the upstairs study here at Montpelier.
SPEAKER_01So this plan, which proposed a three-branch government with a bicameral Congress, meaning two houses, became the blueprint for the US Constitution. And Madison very much viewed Congress as the branch closest to the people. And he preferred it to be very strong. Now, despite modifications and compromises at this convention, Madison believed in a dominant legislative role. He wanted that to remain kind of clear and prominent.
SPEAKER_01So how does the Constitution define congressional powers and how have these powers kind of shifted over time over the centuries?
SPEAKER_02I really like this question. It's so easy to see how congressional powers are shaped because they are all of Article One. So when we think of the Constitution as it's broken into seven different articles, you can ask, when the people who are writing this, what would they put first? Probably the thing that's the most important, probably the thing that's meant to be the most consequential. And so when you look at the document just on a very ordinal way, it's clear, it's number one. It's also the case that when we think about the founders, Madison, of course, but others too, they come from mostly traditions where they've had some sort of bicameral legislature, but it's like the House of Commons and the House of Lords.
SPEAKER_02And they know that the House of Lords is this like hereditary thing, and the Senate is like an upgrade from that. The Senate is just like the smarter elder statesman picked by state legislatures at the time. The House of Commons then gets turned into what we now have as the House of Representatives, which is the people who are closest to the people on the ground. And they're both really interesting innovations that, though there's problems in them, they bring government to the people in ways that no one on that earth at that time had experienced in this sort of setup. Now we also know that he's working with the backdrop of what came before the Articles of Confederation.
SPEAKER_02And so when we get executive power in Article II, it's sort of a recognition of the failure of not having someone at the head, despite the fact that that power is mostly subservient to Congress. So when we think about checks and balances, I think a lot of times people think it's like this rock, paper, scissors game where like everyone can easily beat each other. But there are far more checks that the Congress has on the president than the president has on them or the president has on the courts or the courts have on anyone. And so it's defined very clearly in Article I, and it's also really easy to see that most of the powers are reserved to Congress, despite the fact that we tend to focus on the presidency today.
SPEAKER_02When we talk about how those powers have shifted over time, there's different sorts of realms. So like in policing power, we give a lot more power to the executive. In sort of like immigration and custom stuff, the executive gets a lot of power. When we talk about sort of talking with the masses or addressing the public, by virtue of our limited attention spans, we can't listen to 435 members in the House and 100 senators, but we can focus on one executive. So while it seems like that person is more powerful, the Constitution is pretty clear on this that Congress is meant to be where the power resides because it's close to the people.
SPEAKER_01Lindsay, I love that point. We have one person in this executive branch in that role of president. It's kind of easier to hear that message as a single individual versus all of the people in Congress. So when we think about the relationship between constituents and congressional representatives, what does that look like? How do we communicate? How does Congress, our members of Congress, communicate with us? And how do we make ourselves heard?
SPEAKER_02So let's start with how we make ourselves heard. Every individual gets to choose their own adventure there. So like you have any ability that you want to contact your representative, whether that's I want to send them a postcard, I want to call them, I want to email them, I want to show up to town halls, I want to go to Washington, D.C. because it's my house, taxpayers paid for it, I can go tour it. We have a lot of agency in how we talk to them. But for them, every member of Congress is given a member's representational allowance, which is sort of their pot of money to say, here's how I can tell my constituents I'm doing work on their behalf.
SPEAKER_02A lot of this used to reside in the franking privilege, which would be I can send mail to my constituents free of charge, presuming that I'm telling them about what I'm doing on their behalf in DC. So it might be here's some legislation I'm pushing, or I met with this trade organization, or these veterans are trying to get this sort of like bonus pension thing, and here's what I'm doing on their behalf. Now most of that comes in the form of electronic communication. We don't really have a lot of snail mail coming from members of Congress to constituents, although the franking privilege still exists, because it's cheaper, it's faster, and it's more likely to be read by constituents themselves.
SPEAKER_02And so we see a lot of these communications either pivoting to official emails, uh, and then there's also, you know, the plethora of online platforms. So we've got members of Congress on Facebook, members of Congress on X, members of Congress on Rumble, members of Congress on Snapchat. Like they're sort of all over the place trying to reach constituents wherever they are. And so we can't say here's how they're all doing it, because they're all really trying a bunch of different strategies.
SPEAKER_01Lindsay, so I'm coming from this kind of historian background, and I've done a lot of research on petitions and how members of the public have petitioned Congress in the 19th century, for example. But just from my own research, I've seen how that's really changed from being the main way that members of a social movement, like abolitionists, for example, have tried to reach members of Congress to bring these issues up. But you mentioned yourself, things are different today. We don't really use snail mail anymore.
SPEAKER_01We have a lot more of these technological abilities to reach members of Congress and vice versa. How has that shifted this interaction between elected officials and the public? How has that changed that dynamic?
SPEAKER_02So I'm not sure that I can speak to how it changes that dynamic historically, because my expertise on this really starts in 2009. In 2009, I started looking at the official communications that members of Congress sent to their constituents. And so while I have like an understanding a little bit about what comes before that, I really know a lot more about this current period, which is nearly all electronic communications. On the question of like sending snail mail, I actually think there could be a really beautiful movement in the United States as we celebrate the semiconcentennial to say like use the U.S.
SPEAKER_02Postal Service, send a letter to someone, it makes their day. Now that's not right, you're Congressperson. I love what you're doing, but I do think there is room to use the Postal Service. That's just not what most members of Congress are doing when they're connecting with constituents now.
SPEAKER_01Can you speak to how direct communication with constituents is unique or significant? So, you know, versus a member of Congress giving us a soundbite or an appeal through like these major media platforms like, you know, Fox News or CNN versus more direct communication with constituents. What's what's kind of significant about that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there's a lot of really interesting stuff that happens in direct communications to constituents. So the area that I look at is their official.gov emails that they send to constituents. And they send them in mass. Sometimes they'll have thematic parts where it's like, I'm sending this to everyone who clicked, I want to hear about veterans' issues, or I'm sending this to everyone who clicked, I want to hear about grants. But often it's just like one e-newsletter that goes out to everyone. And over time, in the last 15 years or so, that has changed in the sense that it used to be a lot of text.
SPEAKER_02It used to be a lot of words describing like, here's this bill, here's what I'm doing on it, or here's what I think the other party isn't doing. And in the Republican Party, you really see this shift in the medium to using more infographics and pictures because there's sort of this understanding, at least this is my read on it, is that the people who are receiving this don't care to read multiple paragraphs about what's happening in Congress, but they do care to get snippets of information in the way that we sort of consume information everywhere, which is like headline level, give me a picture.
SPEAKER_02Democrats haven't really done this as much. Now, Democrats use very different strategies versus Republicans in their online communications, but they tend to be the ones that keep this text heavy. Let me sort of over-explain things. Here's some hyperlinks to get into this. But you can see very clear partisan differences. And then there's there's plenty of other differences that you can see based on the gender of the sender, what caucuses they're in, the exigencies of where they live. But but the partisan ones are the easiest and starkest to kind of figure out.
SPEAKER_01You're using the data that you've collected from this project, DC Inbox. Can you tell us a little bit more about why did you start this and why is this so important?
SPEAKER_02Yes. So in 2009, I'm a graduate student at NYU. And I didn't know this when I started graduate school in political science, but it's very math-heavy. It's very like statistics, formal modeling, things that I hadn't done as an undergraduate. And it made clear to me that like you can get good in two ways. You can either build a resource for others or you can be really good at econometrics. And I was like, I will choose the resource. And I figured that someone else already had this database. I figured that because these were digitally created, they must be digitally maintained or housed in some sort of infrastructure within the Library of Congress.
SPEAKER_02That was my working starting point. In talking with members of the Library of Congress about this, it is the case that at that time the e-newsletters were being maintained, but they were being maintained in hard paper printed-out formats that they said I could scan back in if I wanted to study them. And I was like, oh, well, that's strange. These are digitally created to be digitally disseminated. Why the database is not digital is beyond me. But I'm a grad student and I'd like to like make a resource. I'll start on this. In 2009, the internet was a much stranger place than it is now in some ways, in the sense that every member of Congress has this representational allowance.
SPEAKER_02It's the same for all of them. Leaders get a little bit more for everything. But the way that they set up their websites back in 2009 really looked like whoever's uncle knew the most about IT got to set up the website. Like they were so idiosyncratic and it was all over the place. And at the time, you know, we're learning like a lot of coding and the discipline is changing. Everyone's like, why don't you write a script? That means you can crawl through them all and sign up for all their e-newsletters. And I was like, why don't you go check out eight of them and see how easy you think that's going to be to do? Because they were all so different back then. Now there's like three vendors that mostly set up all the websites for Congress, so it's a little bit easier now.
SPEAKER_02But I started just manually with two research assistants at NYU signing up for every official e-newsletter to go to this dummy Gmail account, which is in existence to today. It has over 200,000 emails in it. And then we started to add layers onto it after we saw that things were actually coming in. So we have filters for like, is this a Democrat or is this a Republican? Now it links up with their bio guide IDs so you can see what district they're from when they came into office. Are they a man or are they a woman? But it's built over time. It is a labor of love. It's for the most part a one-woman operation, and I get a rotating cast of research assistants through my school now to kind of help with it.
SPEAKER_02But I think it is the public's documents. These are taxpayer-funded, disseminated official documents in the members' official capacity. We should have access to these as part of our history. We cannot know the contours of our politics if we don't know the words that were spoken and the people who were saying them. And because things are going digital and because there is not an archive of this, I felt like an obligation to do this. And I've made it freely available for everyone to use. There's researchers who use it, there's journalists who use it.
SPEAKER_02And so I really think of it as like something we all should have access to. And that's why I've kept it up.
SPEAKER_01And these are official government documents, taxpayer funded. And they're telling us, the constituents, what's going on. Just the importance of preserving these communications is so key. And obviously, there's a lot of value for future historians in this, for people in the present who are doing research about it. Two questions for you. What have you found, like broadly from this data? And why is this information important, not just to future historians or policy experts today, but the regular people?
SPEAKER_01Why is it important to preserve this?
SPEAKER_02Okay, so it's important to preserve this because we cannot know something if we don't know the ways that it happens. And the way that a lot of our online politicking governing happens is through these sorts of mediums. Now you might say email is outdated. I disagree on this. I think email is sort of like the post box of today. Not everyone has a Snapchat or a Instagram or a Facebook, but nearly everyone has an email address. And so I think this is sort of like the best universe to get. In terms of what people today can use from it, I actually talk to teachers about this.
SPEAKER_02You can let your students type in any term you want on dcinbox.com and you can go see the original texts of who sent it. You can see over time if Democrats send it more than Republicans. You can do a heat map that says like where do these words tend to get said. And so you can learn a lot about our politics that way. And that's easy for even, you know, middle schoolers to sort of understand things. Something else that I think is important or something that I have learned from this is stuff that's very hard for new users to kind of get. I read three e newsletters every day just to like make sure I'm like getting the lay of the land, figuring out what's happening.
SPEAKER_02Doesn't matter if it's Democrats or Republicans, it's whatever time I first turn on my computer, I'm gonna like see that I have nothing really important, and then I'm gonna go read my three e newsletters. What I have learned is that Republicans do this medium way better than Democrats. And I mean that in a few different ways. One is they send nearly twice as many communications in this free member perk to their constituents, which means if we think things like name recognition matter, this is a free, easy way to get your name out to your constituents. If we think things like building familiarity or rapport with someone matters, they can let their personalities out in this and they do it with their constituents far more than Democrats, despite the fact that everyone has equal access to it.
SPEAKER_02Republicans are also far more consistent in the way that they use these than Democrats. And you can see this in like a few different terms. Like if you're listening and you want to go to DC inbox and figure this out on your own, type in a word like woke and see how it rises in congressional communications for Republicans, not for Democrats ever. Or you can think of things like critical race theory or DEI or defund, all of these words that kind of come out of the political left in the smallest way. Republicans within Congress are able to hold on to these terms and they message with them en masse so that you don't really even need to know the underlying term, but you're gonna know that, oh, we're talking about this sort of thing right now.
SPEAKER_02They are so much better at being consistent on terminology than Democrats are. There's a few reasons for this, but I think one of the things that that is helpful in this medium is that when you're like hearing the same sort of thing over and over, it makes it more likely that media picks up on these. You can see them sort of lead media coverage. So, like, for instance, when inflation, it hadn't been talked about for the first 12 years of DC Inbox. And then someone who doesn't even know me, but like a political scientist, was like, hey, Lindsay, why don't you check out inflation in DC Inbox right now?
SPEAKER_02And he saw that it was spiking in how congressional Republicans were talking about it. And this is before the media picks it up. There are periods that are accepted from this. And during the first five months of the COVID-19 pandemic, Democrats matched Republicans in terms of how much they were emailing. And I'm not really sure why that is, other than they were all sending out stuff like, hey guys, we're trying as hard as we can to figure out what's going on. There was just like a lot of like, this is what we know so far. And that was the only time it was equal. And then as the pandemic wound down, Republicans got that bump again, and they exist today with sending far more messages and tending to be more consistent than Democrats do.
SPEAKER_01This is a conversation that myself and the show's producer, Adam, have constantly about information and the media and the public and how we're getting our information. If it's accurate, how can we make sure it's accurate? You know, there's a lot of, I would say, responsibility, more so on the public nowadays, to try to vet the information that they're getting. And there's so much of it out there. But from what you're talking about, Lindsay, it sounds like these newsletters are actually a really good source of communication, a good source of information, even beyond perhaps maybe these, again, sound bites from television or these messages on social media, which can be very, you know, ephemeral.
SPEAKER_01Um, sometimes there's not a lot of meat there because it's more about getting your attention. Do you think that that's an accurate read? What's your take on that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's certainly true. And I think something that's hard in the social media world, especially for people who want to study this, is nearly all of that content is owned by the person who runs the platform. The content of emails are owned by us. Like this is taxpayer-created emails. And so you don't have to like have some sort of permission to get it from X or get it from Facebook. And so from a like understanding the world perspective, doing it in email is better because it's just like easier and it's ours. It's not ephemeral.
SPEAKER_01And this is really noteworthy because it underscores the power of communication as an active part of our democracy. It's not passive where, okay, we're just getting information and that's the end of the line. It's shaping our thoughts about our elected officials, about policy, and then we take action based on that information. So it is very much an active, I would say, part of how we engage.
SPEAKER_02It's definitely an active part of how we engage, and it's also a lot of agenda setting power that goes to the people who are sending the communications in the first place. Like when Congress gets to set the terms of a public debate, then people can maybe go research as they like or try to figure some things out, but they are not getting to set the agenda. Congress gets to say, here's what we're gonna talk about. Sometimes it's, you know, an administration or a president's gonna like say it and they sort of follow that. But in this environment, they are sending far more to constituents than constituents are sending to them.
SPEAKER_01As we wrap up our conversation today, Lindsay, I'm thinking about James Madison and the ways that he communicated. And two different examples come to mind. So during the constitutional convention, he, even more than the convention secretary, is there taking detailed, detailed notes about what's happening because it's closed door, you know, nobody outside that room knows what's going on. And because he took those notes and later transcribed them with Dolly Madison, his wife, we know what happened in that room.
SPEAKER_01We know how our government was created and structured, and that's so important. But then I also think about Madison as this persuasive writer versus just this document taker when he's writing some of the Federalist papers, which the purpose of that was to try to convince the states to ratify the Constitution. So we've got documentation, but then we've also got, hey, I'm making an argument to persuade you. So when we think about effective communication, how do we reconcile the documentation versus I'm being persuaded towards something?
SPEAKER_02It's a really hard question and it's tough because theoretically, official communications are not meant to be political. They're not meant to tell you vote for me or give me money or support this thing. And there actually are really good guidelines within the House governing documents that say like you can't say this in an e-newsletter. Members of Congress, though, are getting sort of smart to this. And so you can't just like read these documents and think, like, oh, this is just the official recording of what's happening here. I'm so glad they're telling me. That's certainly part of it. But there is also an inherent built-in persuasion piece, despite the fact that it's not meant to be campaign rhetoric.
SPEAKER_02And so it is sort of doing this like double work of let me tell you what I think about things, but also here's this other thing that you might just sort of consider quietly.
SPEAKER_01It's so interesting to hear about the ways that this e-newsletter brings these really important conversations from our Congress members to the public, but also just things that we kind of need to be thinking about when we look at these types of communications, but also broadly as we're engaging with democracy. There's a level of critical thinking that we always need to be bringing to that space.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. You're never going to hear disagreement from me on how you need to approach stuff with a critical eye, not just like a take it in eye.
SPEAKER_01Well, Lindsay, thank you so much for joining us in our studio here today. And thank you so much for all the work you do here. I think this place is magical. And thank you to all of our listeners for tuning in today. Please subscribe to the show and share with your family and your friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...