Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

Madison's Revolutionary Legacy: From Virginia Rights to the War of 1812

Mar 11, 202628 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This episode is part of a special five-part miniseries examining James Madison's role in the American Revolution and the founding of the United States. As part of Montpelier's commemoration of the 250th anniversary of American independence, this series is funded by a grant from the Virginia American Revolution 250 Commission, in partnership with Virginia Humanities. James Madison's participation in the American Revolution shaped not only his political philosophy but his entire approach to governance. In this episode, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey sits down with Dr. Jay Cost to explore how Madison's revolutionary experiences - from his work on Virginia's Declaration of Rights at age 25 to his presidency during the War of 1812 - reveal a leader committed to proving that self-government could work. Dr. Cost explains how Madison viewed the Revolution as an opportunity for fundamental reform based on liberal principles, and how his deep distrust of British authority influenced his diplomatic and military decisions decades later. The conversation illuminates Madison's unique talent for translating revolutionary ideals into practical political action, including his pragmatic leadership in creating the Bill of Rights and his determination to secure American sovereignty through what he saw as a "second war for independence."

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.

SPEAKER_01Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey with James Madison's Montpelier. This episode is one installment of a five-part miniseries funded by a grant from the Virginia American Revolution 250 Commission in partnership with the Virginia Humanities. This special series is part of Montpelier's broader effort to commemorate the 250th anniversary of America's founding with the signing of the Declaration of Independence in 1776.

SPEAKER_02In today's episode, we're turning our attention to how the American Revolution shaped James Madison. Not only his ideas and career, but also his impact on the nation as a whole. From his work on the Virginia Plan and the U.S. Constitution to his role as Secretary of State under Thomas Jefferson, and later as president during the War of 1812, Madison's experiences offer a unique window into the practical application of revolutionary ideals over decades of public service.

SPEAKER_02With me in this studio at Montpelier is Dr. Jay Cost, a returning guest who's going to help shape our conversation today. Dr. Cost is a Gerald R. Ford, non-resident senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, AEI, where he focuses on elections, politics, and public opinion. His latest book, Democracy or Republic, The People Under the Constitution, was recently released and is soon going to be out in paperback.

SPEAKER_02So, Jay, welcome back. It's wonderful to have you here at Montpelier again.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for having me. I'm I'm always pleased to be here.

SPEAKER_02And to start our conversation, let's consider the American Revolution itself. Now, we heard on this mini-series that, you know, James Madison is not at the signing of the Declaration of Independence. However, that's still a very important defining period for him. So what lessons or ideas is he taking away from this revolutionary period? How is it defining, and how do they shape his visions for American government moving forward?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think Madison, like Jefferson, sees the revolution as something more than liberation from the political oppression they had been suffering at the hands of Great Britain. It's more than just severing the bonds that had connected these two peoples. That this is in fact an opportunity to achieve fundamental reforms in political society according to liberal rational principles.

SPEAKER_00And Madison, as a young man, was very much inclined to this view. And so he is during the Second Continental Congress meeting and debating and ultimately adopting the Declaration of Independence. Virginia has a constitutional convention in which they are writing a constitution to govern this newly independent Commonwealth of Virginia. And attached to that is going to be the Virginia Declaration of Rights, which becomes very influential.

SPEAKER_00It's influential in and of itself, but it also is influential in Madison's editorial creation of the Bill of Rights a decade and a half later. Madison is very young. He's just 25 years old, and he is on a committee in which they're debating this Mason's Declaration of Rights. And Madison presses for the disestablishment of the Anglican Church in Virginia. The original Declaration of Rights calls for toleration of nonconforming, basically anybody.

SPEAKER_00But Madison wants to press further towards disestablishment. And I think this is a good example of Madison seeing the revolution as something much bigger, that this is an opportunity to revise the entire structure of government and to do away with outmoded, medieval, irrational institutions, which for Madison included the linking of church and state.

SPEAKER_02And this idea that Madison is seeing this period of time, you know, what's happening here? This is an opportunity. This is very significant. And as you said, he's a very young man, he's in his mid-20s. So to have that concept in his head, I think is pretty astounding for somebody that young. How does that knowledge that this is a pivotal moment, how do we see that reflected in his service political career as he serves in Congress and then eventually plays a big part in drafting the U.S.

SPEAKER_02Constitution?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think that there was a sense among a lot of patriots, even after the revolution ends, that this was the test case for a liberal, relatively democratic republic. It had not been tried in the West, and it existed really only as a theoretical concept, that the traditional view of government was that power had to be shared among stakeholders, which included the wealthy and also the established church in most European countries.

SPEAKER_00So that the United States in doing away with these things is doing something not simply for the United States but also is doing something on behalf of these ideals. And I think that this really informs Madison's intense, almost monomaniacal commitment to securing the Constitution. And I think from his perspective that if we don't make self-government work, this is it.

SPEAKER_00Nobody's gonna try it again. And that is a revolutionary impulse that I think he carried with him even well after the revolution, because of course the Constitutional Convention is about six years after Washington's victory at Yorktown. But I think that that would remained an abiding view that he had. And it wasn't just him alone. I think that a lot of delegates had the same attitude that we we have to do this to make this work.

SPEAKER_02That's such a fascinating career trajectory when you think about it too. Madison, again, as he's writing or or commenting on the Virginia Declaration of Rights, at the same time the Declaration of Independence is being drafted. They're still citizens of the monarchy. You know, they are still subjects of the monarchy. And we see then after the revolution, they're under this Articles of Confederation, this government that's not working, but they're still an independent nation. But he's, as you noted, seeing that this is such a unique opportunity, unparalleled, to create this self-government, the government of the people.

SPEAKER_02And then as we follow him into his later career, he serves as Secretary of State under Thomas Jefferson beginning in 1801. And so not only do we see him help create the structure of this government in 1787, but then he's serving in this government structure he helped create in the early 1800s.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And he inherited, and you can see in a lot of his actions and in some of his comments, you can really appreciate he carried on with a real dislike of the English. He, at one point in the negotiations in the lead up to the War of 1812, there was one of the sticking points in diplomacy was the British needing to make reparations for the attack on the USS Chesapeake, which happened in 1807, that precipitated the embargo act and uh really kind of a war preparedness cris.

SPEAKER_00And and the war crisis sort of ebbed, but of course we go to war. But in these ongoing negotiations, Madison at one point wrote to his minister in Great Britain that said that the king should make any apologies that he thinks is appropriate, or basically saying, like, if the king were a real man, he'll apologize. And when the word of that got back to the king, and he was offended. He don't speak about the king in that sort of fashion. And it w this was a view that he had from young early in life.

SPEAKER_00And I think it was maybe in part a generational thing, is that somebody like Benjamin Franklin, who was, you know, almost 50 years older than Madison, had grown up during a time of peace and concord within the empire. And so Franklin had to take a psychological and emotional journey to separate himself. And this is something that Madison simply never had to do. When he went to Princeton, the College of New Jersey, he wrote a letter to his father. He went up early to see the graduating class.

SPEAKER_00This would have just been him as an incoming freshman. And he said that all of the all the graduates walked in the American cloth. In other words, they were dressed with American colors. And it was just something in the younger generation that didn't have any memory of the good times in the empire, that they only remembered the insults of the French and Indian War and then sort of attack on American rights. Because, of course, the first assault on American rights, at least as the Americans saw it, was the proclamation line of 1763.

SPEAKER_00Madison would have just been 12 years old. So he would never have had a memory of a time in his life when there would be warm thoughts about the sovereign.

SPEAKER_02And Jay, Madison, you know, as you noted, he's at Princeton, College of New Jersey. He goes there 1769 to 1771. You know, that's when we have the Boston Massacre happening shortly after Madison finishes his schooling, the Boston Tea Party. And while he's at the College of New Jersey, he's, as we've discussed on this podcast before, he's learning all these ideas, Scottish Enlightenment ideas. And he's thinking deeply about what self-government means and what inalienable rights mean, all while these really key historical moments are happening.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. He really inherits a radical Whig sensibility from the College of New Jersey, which had been in the mix in American political culture for a while. You know, I mean, and and you can sort of see, you know, like Jefferson's summary view of the rights of British America as Jefferson like explaining to the king exactly what their rights are. It's pretty extreme in its Whigishness and a pretty extreme radical view of what the Glorious Revolution was.

SPEAKER_00And of course, Madison, as his instructor at New Jersey is John Witherspoon, who's Scottish. And so he brings the Scottish Enlightenment. He brings a Calvinism, which I think ends up infusing Madison's moral thinking. Even though Madison was a deist, I think his um moral thinking has a lot of influence from Calvin. But also this sort of Whiggish commitment to reforming institutions that don't make any sense.

SPEAKER_00I think Madison just drank all that in when he was at New Jersey, and they formed the ground from which his unique political theory grew.

SPEAKER_02And then shortly thereafter, we do have the American Revolution. And so we have this very open-minded Madison. He's learning these um revolutionary ideas, really. How do we see that come into play as he's serving as Secretary of State from 1801 to 1809, again under Thomas Jefferson, and then into his presidency beginning in 1809 to 1817?

SPEAKER_00Aaron Ross Powell Sure. I think the conflict that the Americans get into during his Secretaryship of State with Great Britain had to do with a trade that was not entirely reputable. The Americans were making a lot of money carrying goods into or out of the Spanish and French Caribbean because the Spanish and French could no longer do it. They were at war with Britain. So they basically subcontracted the Americans to engage in this trade.

SPEAKER_00And it's not a very reputable trade in the sense that it was not really particularly expressive of growth in American economic power. It's basically just drafting off the French and the Spanish. But it's also trade in service of Napoleon's hegemonic ambitions in Europe, against which really the only effective opponent was Britain. And, you know, of course, Madison and Jefferson were very well aware of the dangers of Napoleon, because when they found out that Napoleon had acquired Louisiana, they pretty much hit the panic button.

SPEAKER_00You don't want Napoleon as a neighbor. But that was not the way that they looked at the dispute with the British between 1805 with this first conflict and then 1815, the resolution of the War of 1812. Their view was not we're helping a bad actor in Bonaparte.

SPEAKER_02Being the head of France, upon it.

SPEAKER_00Being the head of France, and then increasingly, I mean, by 1805, being the master of Europe and then trying to populate European monarchies with little Bonaparte, you know, everywhere. This guy is not, you know, he's not one of us. You know, maybe we should back off a little bit and let the British take care of business. That was never a thing that they thought. Their view of it was this is the British once again acting like they don't owe us the respect, not just the respect, but these are our rights.

SPEAKER_00Madison, as Secretary of State, is very intent on making the argument that the law of nations, which is very even today, is a very fluid concept, but without the United Nations, it was even more like, what even is that? But Madison was very intent on arguing that the laws of nations gave the Americans the right to engage in this trade. And so here are the British once again infringing on our rights because they've never really acknowledged our independence.

SPEAKER_00And more than that, you see this in his war message that their ultimate goal is to keep us from realizing our true potential, because we will be a true rival to them. So his view of the war of 1812 is in some respects very similar to a common historical memory, which is that the War of 1812 is a second war for independence. That historical memory, in part, is due at least to the framework in which Madison, if you look at his messages to Congress and you look at his war messages, that was his argument.

SPEAKER_02So it sounds like Madison and perhaps others do not feel that the British see the United States as a legitimate country, and that's in part the War of 1812, is an effort to prove that.

SPEAKER_00Yes, it is. And and look, they had, frankly, good reasons for that. The British were really obnoxious in their attitude towards the Americans. They were very supercilious and they were needlessly provocative. Madison had a handshake agreement with the Foreign Minister Erskine in 1809 that was then just disavowed by the British Foreign Secretary. The Foreign Secretary Canning, who would go on to be Prime Minister, recalls Erskine. It's a huge embarrassment to the Madison administration.

SPEAKER_00This is a new administration that comes in. Congress is not in session because Congress isn't seated in the spring, in the summer, and the early fall. It's only seated in the winter. And so Madison has this period of time where he and his Secretary of State, Robert Smith, are negotiating with Erskine, and they they come up with a handshake agreement. Well, more than a handshake agreement, but it was an agreement between Erskine and the and the government. And Madison, you know, issues a proclamation like, look, we have peace. Oh, we've solved the problem. And Erskine goes home and canning, not only does he disavow it, disavow the agreement, but the next minister he sends comes in and suggests that not only was Erskine operating outside of his scope of authority, but you, Mr.

SPEAKER_00President, knew that he was, and you were operating in bad faith. This is the sort of thing that you don't do in diplomacy unless you're looking to antagonize. And the British did this is not the only time they did that. They they would give very provocative statements to the native tribes in the old Northwest and in and in Lower Canada that if you're a Western settler, these are horrifying things to hear about. And they're the sorts of ways in which the British really, frankly, never really respected the Americans in a lot of it never really came to the accept that America was an independent nation that was due a level of that if they're in the community of nations, they need to be treated like a full partner in that community.

SPEAKER_00And it it also is, you know, one of the reasons why in the before the War of 1812, you know, Napoleon was mistreating American merchant ships and he was engaging in violations of America's right of neutral nations. But Madison sort of cleverly pushes the Napoleonic violations to the side in the public mind, because, well, we can't go to war with both of them. And if we're going to go to war with one of them, we need to go to war with the British, because the British have been a problem since 1783.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that really is one way to think about the War of 1812, is that this was since the Treaty of Paris, the British had been giving the Americans reasons to object to their behavior.

SPEAKER_02I can absolutely see how that would be an insult to President Madison at the time, basically calling him out for acting in bad faith.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. It was remarkable. And the guy that they sent, his name is escaping me, but the guy that they sent, his nickname was Copenhagen, because he was the one who, like before the British started bombing Copenhagen during the first the wars of the French Revolution, they sent him in not to negotiate, but to tell them they were about to be bombed. Like they knew the guy that they sent, and again, I apologize, I can't remember his name, but they knew that he's not somebody you send to get a deal. And Madison actually requested his recall, which is a very extraordinary action. And really, if you think about the amount of time it takes in terms of losing your foreign minister and considering the period of time and the tensions between the two countries, you know, it's not like today where if you ask for a recall, you can get a new minister almost instantaneously.

SPEAKER_00It'd take months and months to get a new minister. You know, the fact that he felt obliged to do that, it was a sign of how, you know, little the British were taking seriously American complaints.

SPEAKER_02And so what does this period look like? How do we end up in this war of 1812? What exactly happens where Madison feels he needs to declare war? And then how does he handle that conflict?

SPEAKER_00Sure. Well, the Republicans, the Jeffersonians, had an idea that the country could engage in commercial, what they would call commercial discrimination. And the United States was particularly well suited to this. And the thinking was, particularly with Great Britain, we buy what Madison would call manufactured superfluities from Great Britain. They buy food from us. So they need us more than we need them. And this was the logic of using the Embargo Act of 1807 and really keeping on it on the books for two years as an experiment in this commercial retaliation, like commercial war, which is something that he had wanted, he had been proposing doing going all the way back to 1789.

SPEAKER_00So it was an old idea. And the problem was that it didn't work. The Embargo Act, well, for starters, was never designed to accomplish that end. So it could have been written better. But beyond that, the bigger issue was that Madison underestimated the ability of the British to feed their people and also underestimated the capacity of an industrializing globe-spanning power to find alternative food sources. Which, by the way, is a similar problem to the South had.

SPEAKER_00When it seceded, they thought that the British would intervene to keep the cotton flowing. But Britain, being a globe spanning power, was able to extract cotton from Egypt and India to keep that from becoming a problem. So it's a recurring theme, underestimating British economic power. So with the failure of commercial discrimination evident, really, by the time Madison takes the office in 1809, then it becomes whether or not he can just Negotiate a settlement and really kind of bluff his way into getting the British to back down.

SPEAKER_00And the British are unwilling. And so then by 1812, they're left with the choice of either war or a humiliating peace. And the anal the way I would look at it, it would probably be similar to the Jay Treaty of 1795, which was that John Jay went to Britain and negotiated just a dog's breakfast of a treaty with the British that was frankly humiliating to American interests. But it was consistent with Hamilton's vision of an economic alliance between the British and the French as being the basis for Hamilton's system of finance in the United States.

SPEAKER_00We need to keep trading with the British. So that's worth it from a Hamiltonian perspective. We will suffer this indignity because in the long run it's good for us. But Madison rejects that. And so he's left with the choice of this indignity or war, and he's going to choose war.

SPEAKER_02As we wrap up our conversation today and thinking about all these different phases of Madison, his life, how can we draw inspiration or understanding from how these ideas that kind of culminated or percolated during the revolution and how they influenced his career trajectory?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think that ideological principles are important, but they are they're necessary but not sufficient, which I think was in evidence with the French Revolution and its sort of ironic and lamentable collapse into murder, totalitarianism, finally Napoleonic hegemony. And one of the things that differentiates the Americans from the French, I think, is that the Americans had a lot of experience in self-government before the revolution because they had, for all intents and purposes, had really been governing themselves on a local level for a very long time.

SPEAKER_00And so they knew how politics could work. And I think that one of the great sort of takeaways from a career like James Madison is that he was imbued with these revolutionary ideals as much as anybody. But he was very good at politics. And by that I I do not mean the way we think about it nowadays, where we think about politics as us versus them, and he's really good at politics because he humiliated his opponent and he won a smashing re-election and all of these things.

SPEAKER_00If we think about politics instead as resolving conflicts within the political community without recourse to violence and finding common ground that is consistent with all of our interests. Madison was very good at these things. And I think that he in that regard represents the best of the revolutionary generation.

SPEAKER_00Because this was a generation that was really good at politics as from that vision. And I and Madison was among the best at them. And I think something we can learn is that it's not enough to have political beliefs that you loudly proclaim and you, you know, stamp your feet and castigate your enemies and think about things in a manichin vision. But if you're actually interested in getting things done, then that requires the creation of consensus and a recognition that somebody who is your a sensible political opponent is actually your only path to getting what you want.

SPEAKER_00And so you need to find a way to figure out what he wants and what you can both accomplish together. And I think Madison, as much as anybody, reflects that kind of ethos, especially in the 1780s. I I mean, when I think about Madison on that, I think about that the existence of the Bill of Rights was a really, in a lot of respects, just an act of political, like it was one of the most broad-minded things to do. He did not think a Bill of Rights was necessary. And in fact, he thought it was potentially dangerous.

SPEAKER_00And he he campaigned on it, but he could have supported it and voted for it and gone back to his voters in the 5th district here in Orange and said, Well, I did everything I could. But he took the lead on it because he knew that skeptics of the Constitution needed to be assuaged and they needed to be brought into the pro-Constitution coalition. That's just such a broad-minded, smart, self-interest, rightly understood kind of act that was so typical of his career in so many respects that I think that he really offers us a lesson in that.

SPEAKER_02Dr. J. Cost, thank you so much for your time today and sharing your expertise. In exploring this topic, you really helped us get a fuller picture of Madison as the father of the Constitution, but also a lot more as somebody who really engaged with revolution, these ideas for his entire life and how that experience defined his career, but also how we continue to practice government today.

SPEAKER_00Thank you very much. Thanks for having me.

SPEAKER_02And I want to thank all of our listeners. I hope you'll share the show with family and friends. And please subscribe and join us again soon as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode