In this second installment of our special three-part miniseries on global democracy, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey interviews Dr. Tinashe Hofisi, a human rights lawyer and constitutional scholar from Zimbabwe. Dr. Hofisi, an alumnus and instructor of the Young African Leaders Initiative (YALI), shares insights from his research on judicial power in a global context. Funded by Virginia Humanities and produced in collaboration with the Presidential Precinct, this episode explores the complexities of establishing and maintaining effective judicial systems, particularly in post-colonial African nations. Dr. Hofisi discusses the importance of judicial independence, the challenges of creating representative courts, and the surprising effectiveness of lower courts in enforcing constitutional rights.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Well the hammer.
SPEAKER_01Center for the Constitution. James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02Hello, and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. This is the second episode in the special menu series on global democracy. The series features those public servants from Sub-Saharan Africa who participated in the U.S. Department of State's Young African Leaders Initiative this past summer of 2024.
SPEAKER_02In this episode, I speak with Dr. Tanashe Hofisi, who is not only an alumnus of the 2015 cohort of Yali Mandela Washington Fellows, but also an instructor for the 2024 cohort. He connects his research on the complexity of judicial power to a global context. Dr. Hofisi is a human rights lawyer from Zimbabwe who studies international constitutional adjudication. He spent seven years with the Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights and went on to earn his doctorate from the University of Wisconsin Law School.
SPEAKER_02Dr. Hofisi's research examines the emergence and effectiveness of constitutional courts in common law Africa. Dr. Hofisi, welcome to consider the constitution.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much. It feels really great to be here.
SPEAKER_02So before we hear a bit about your experience as a Mandela Washington fellow, I want to first take the opportunity to better understand the fundamental aspects of judicial systems in a global context. So the process of creating a constitution differs from group to group or country to country due to sociopolitical context of the moment, who's leading that group, the need for the constitution at the moment, why it's desired, what's the history and culture of the group or country, and of course the global community and how they're responding.
SPEAKER_02We can, however, identify some broad commonalities. For example, a constitution typically includes provisions for a judiciary, a system of courts. So for us who are familiar with the system in the US, that would be the judicial branch, which is established in Article III of the US Constitution. But in many African countries, there's this legacy of colonialism. So when countries like Britain, France, Portugal colonized most of the continent, and many African nations have only recently gained independence starting about the 1950s, 1960s.
SPEAKER_02And this is why, in part, your work is so important. These constitutions are relatively new, and these judicial systems are in their infancy. So as we start to talk about judicial systems today, what goes into this process of constitution building and what's important about a judiciary?
SPEAKER_00Right. People establish judicial systems for resolution of disputes. Really, you want a platform where people feel confident that they can go each time that they need somebody to act as a neutral third in order to reach a decision for disputing parties. But other than that, sort of like essential form of a court, we're also looking at courts broadly speaking as a mechanism for conflict avoidance. So you will find that in a lot of countries, particularly in the African context, there are a lot of specialized courts that are established, such as electoral courts, human rights courts, South Africa has equality courts.
SPEAKER_00And increasingly, countries give their top courts, whether they say Supreme Court or a constitutional court, this unique power to also settle disputes that arise from a presidential election. And that is in part inspired by some of the election-related violence that has occurred in some countries, prominently Kenya in 2008, Zimbabwe in 2008, and then thereafter there were these reforms to ensure that courts have got this capacity. So in that sense, these courts are actually modeled in order to avoid those sorts of conflicts.
SPEAKER_00But one needs courts to be legitimate in order to achieve that function. So courts must, of course, serve some representative function. People must feel that they are represented um by those courts in order to accept the authority of those courts for courts to be effective in settling disputes, in ensuring that there is avoidance of conflict. And there is also now this role that people also assign courts just to broaden democracy, right? And to strengthen the rule of law. So quite apart from merely engaging in settling the dispute, there is this other substantive question of whether in the process of settling the dispute the court is actually deepening values such as a commitment to human rights, a commitment to the rule of law.
SPEAKER_00And in some instances, countries will in fact establish courts in order to signal this commitment to some of these higher values. So part of the uh reason for the trend in establishing new constitutional courts, which are these courts which are established at the top of the judicial hierarchy for enforcement of the constitution, that is also meant to signal this commitment to the constitution, a commitment to human rights by establishing a standalone body, this visible institution that is set up in order to ensure that the constitution is respected.
SPEAKER_00So I would say we have made progress from thinking of courts as just being set up to settle disputes, but we're thinking of conflict avoidance. We're thinking of deepening values of human rights and increasingly, as you have said, these constitutions which are made in recent times then tend to reflect those values that society is adopting over time.
SPEAKER_02This is a really important thing to keep in mind as we consider the importance of the courts. So not just settling disputes, but conflict avoidance. And as we talked about these courts set up through a constitution, kind of the highest court in the land. How does one group or country go about creating a judicial system? How can you think about structuring something like that? What is needed to do that?
SPEAKER_00If we think about the origins of courts in general, most of these courts are established as an inheritance from what was established during the colonial era. So there is this link between a colonial past and what people accept as legitimate institutions of democracy in general, but judicial institutions as well. So in the African context, um in some countries you actually had a duality where uh you had direct rule where there were courts that were set up um that were formal courts, and then you also had the traditional courts, indirect rule where a lot of local participation and indigenous black Africans were able to apply customary law in those in those settings.
SPEAKER_00And then after independence, countries tend to inherit from the colonial system, and then they tend to reform it a lot of what scholars now call constitutional borrowing. Really, what happens is for most countries at independence, the Supreme Court model was probably the most popular. Um so you had most countries simply adopting a Supreme Court, which is the highest court of appeal, and then you've got a court of first instance, a court of original jurisdiction, and then you have a Supreme Court sitting as an appellate court, right? That is mostly in the Anglophone countries or the English-speaking countries, as opposed to the francophone and lusophone where you uh which follow mostly the French model, the German model, you have constitutional councils or constitutional courts.
SPEAKER_00So there is very little innovation at the level of establishing these top courts, these courts of appeals, because um a lot of countries look at their judiciaries as kind of an opportunity to show that they are part of this community of nations and that disputes are settled in the same ways in this as in these other countries. I mean, there's this claim, right, when you're dealing with law and court cases, some people think of it as a form of science where any um you know anywhere you go, you apply the law to a certain set of effects, you get the same outcome. So that's more or less how people also continue to structure the judiciary as this third branch of government, which we think of as being staffed by these experts.
SPEAKER_00So everyone has got very specific requirements in terms of qualifications, legal experience, expertise in order to sit on these courts, and the expertise uh is what feeds into people's impression of a court as being sufficiently independent from the cause and being able to apply the law in a way in which which fosters greater acceptance. So it's a lot of constitutional borrowing, it's a lot of comparative um experiences and borrowing from countries which have been successful in order to build models that are viewed as effective.
SPEAKER_02So you referenced that in a lot of African countries there's this legacy or kind of enduring court system from the time of colonialism. How do we understand kind of that model in context to the US system and how our court, particularly our Supreme Court, is structured here?
SPEAKER_00The first thing I would say is the US does seem to have um well, there's a jury system here, so there's a lot of people power when it comes to decision making in the courts, which you don't find throughout Africa. Ordinary people you have got more agency that they can sit as juries in order to reach a decision, which we do not have in most of the African countries. And further to that, I mean it's quite unique in the US that judges tend to have life tenure, federal judges. So you talk about the Supreme Court, they tend to be very influential because they have life tenure and that has not been replicated in any of the African countries.
SPEAKER_00And also the fact that the US Constitution can be enforced by even district courts, right? So courts enforce the constitution right down to the lower level, and cases can end up in the Supreme Court, right? But it's from a lower level, right? It can be a district judge sitting somewhere out there who issue a ruling that affects the entire country. And that's not very popular um in Africa. It is there in some countries, such as I believe Liberia. So some of these countries with a very strong influence from the US tend to replicate that system.
SPEAKER_00But usually these powers to enforce the constitution are given a specific court. Either it is the court at the very top, the apex court, if it's a constitutional court, it's a supreme court, or perhaps it's given a lower court, such as the High Court, and it's subject to appeal. But at the lower levels, what we would call Magistrates' courts, this power would not be would not be present in most African countries. But the US process of appointing judges also seems more overtly political process, like the president uh nominates and then the Senate appoints.
SPEAKER_00So it's a process that is uh entirely within these elected branches of government. In a lot of African countries, these judicial service commissions are established as independent bodies that um assess candidates for appointment, even though the executive then eventually appoints, but there is this other independent body that is in charge of actually dealing with appointments. So there are a few more safeguards in that regard. And of course, there are the differences that flow, of course, from whether in Africa we're talking about if these if it's these common law systems where there may be more commonalities with the US than the civil law systems where there's more codification and there's way more enumeration of rights in the civil law systems, and that would be quite uh different from the US system.
SPEAKER_00Even though when it comes to elections, it seems, particularly this year and increasingly, the way that political issues are playing out in the courts resembles somewhat, right, a lot of African countries where for the longest time the belief was in countries like the US, it's probably through the political process, through elections, that people actually have confidence that the system regenerates itself. But in a lot of African countries, that people look to the courts in order to even supervise the electoral process. So you have a lot of cases that go before elections and after elections, and the flurry of cases in the US now is signaling somewhat something similar to quite a lot of African countries where the courts are very central to the electoral process.
SPEAKER_02That makes me think about your earlier point of legitimacy and how necessary that is in order to have this judicial branch and for that to be effective. And when we think about legitimacy, how can we think about the court being independent? Do we consider the judicial branch being influenced by the executive or legislative and vice versa? And why do we need or do we need an independent judiciary?
SPEAKER_00Right, yeah, because at the heart of it, we tend to think of um judicial independence as something that is necessary for effectiveness of courts, so for enforcement of judgments. One of the reasons why people advocate for judicial independence is this requirement that the executive has to enforce the decisions of the judiciary, whether or not the executive agrees. We believe that is baked into judicial independence because without that, then courts would only release the decisions they thought would end up getting enforced. So we need independence so that there is actual effectiveness of the judicial branch.
SPEAKER_00But also for legitimacy, people are not going to bring their cases before the courts if they don't have this impression that the courts are sufficiently distant from the other branches that they can actually issue judgments against them, right? Even if you're the little guy, right, and you're facing and you are confronting the federal government, you must have a belief that the courts can give you a judgment against the government because they are sufficiently independent. And if the courts are not independent, then they are not able to assist particularly minorities and people who have these asymmetries of power.
SPEAKER_00But then judicial independence is something that is kind of fostered, right? It's kind of an outcome of many things that we have to do in order to get it as a result. So appointment, right? There's a question of the extent to which the appointment process fosters independence. Um, you know, when these candidates are being questioned, it's supposed to review whether they are sufficiently independent to be effective judges. And also, I mean, structurally we separate uh the judiciary from the other branches of government, but we also expect that even in the judgments that the court itself is asserting its own independence so that it builds its own legitimacy and it ensures that people follow its own its its decisions.
SPEAKER_00So if you're going to have an institution that is responsible for settling disputes, then you really, really need people to believe that they're going to act fairly. And independence is kind of tied into the courts acting as a fair neutral third. So it is absolutely essential that the courts are independent. But there are certain things we need to do in order to ensure that the courts are independent, right? Structural independence, but also ensuring we've got candidates that are sufficiently independent, and of course the candidates themselves must be removed from the subject matter that is being determined.
SPEAKER_00But also, right, there's that other question of the democratic process. Because what happens with courts is that if one particular political party or side is in power for a long time, it has an effect on people's views on independence. Because the way the system works, right, is that different parties must be making judicial appointments so that there is viewpoint diversity on the court, such that it the courts represent different interests. What happens in a lot in some African countries is that when you've got long-term dominance by one political party, and then people are like, okay, so these courts are not in fact our courts, they only represent one side, and over time people then question whether the courts are sufficiently independent.
SPEAKER_00So there's also an interplay between whether the democratic process allows for a regular uh change in incumbency for the courts to be sufficiently representative.
SPEAKER_02So for people like us to have faith in our government and our system, it's really important for us to believe and to have this judiciary, not, for example, acting in the interests of the president or of Congress members, that they are going to be acting on their own accord based on their expertise. And as you noted, not just the separation of powers and the different branches of government, but having these experts, these qualified legal minds appointed with different viewpoints that represent the diversity of the people.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes, absolutely. It is absolutely important. There's two ways in which we think courts can act in a representative way that fosters their legitimacy. In one sense, we've got the descriptive representativeness of the courts. That is to say, do the courts actually reflect the demographic demographic diversity of the population over which they preside? So for instance, um, what is the relation between the composition of the court and let's say the racial makeup of that particular country? And also questions of gender, right?
SPEAKER_00How are women represented? And there are questions of ethnicity, right? And all of those, they feed into this conception of descriptive representativeness. That is to say, before anybody actually reads any judgment or any outcome, when a person just sees the judges or hears of them, are they going to feel like, oh yeah, that is my court or is it not? And there's very interesting research that shows the support for courts amongst minorities tends to positively correlate to whether they've identified one of their own group on the court, right? And that works for whether it's an actual panel or its nominees to the court.
SPEAKER_00This research actually showed in the case of Justice Clarence Thomas and Justice Sonia Soromayo, people's support for them as black solatinos was unaffected by whether the person concerned considered themselves Democrat or Republican. That ideological divide actually withered just based on this descriptive representativeness, right? I want someone to represent my group on the court. The descriptive representativeness is one side, which is very important for people to actually believe that these are our courts, and it's going to affect how you engage with their judgments.
SPEAKER_00But there's also the substantive aspect, that is to say, our courts being seen to advance the interests, right? Let's say even the interests of their specific demographic group, but the interests of the people as a whole. And courts are affected by both, right? Because in a lot of a lot of times people simply hear the outcome, people read a judgment, and then in with some judgments, people are going to say, okay, the court is actually defending human rights, or it looks like the court is stripping away human rights. It looks like the court is not acting in the interests of the people. And both of those are very crucial in dealing with this question of legitimacy, which ultimately legitimacy is just dealing with this question of whether people accept the authority of the court or they are going to become dismissive of the court.
SPEAKER_02And obviously, your research and the work that you do is really critical. Um, coming from Zimbabwe, where you work. Can you tell us a bit about how your experience as a Yali Mandela Washington fellow shaped that experience?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I um so I was here as a Yali Mandela Washington fellow in 2015, right here in Montpelier. And I think that was the time when I was branching out into dealing with constitutional litigation. So I was very fascinated by the program we did here, learning a lot about um James Madison, but also the history of where we get the Bill of Rights in the United States, learning about constitution building, and then further to that constitutional enforcement. And so when I went back to Zimbabwe, I continued as a constitutional litigator.
SPEAKER_00I appeared in a few cases in the constitutional court, and then I continued to pursue studies that had to do with constitutions, with constitution building, and that is how I came up with um the idea for my doctoral thesis, which is really looking at this question of courts as sites for enforcement of the constitution. And I'm asking I'm answering the question, what exactly do you do to make courts effective in doing so? What are the limitations that courts have faced in Southern Africa in enforcing the constitution? And what are some of the structural design efforts that have been attempted through constitution making in order to make the courts more effective?
SPEAKER_00And ultimately, what is working, right? What are some of the changes that have worked in Southern Africa and what are the lessons that can be taken from what has happened in Southern Africa that can be used in judicial design efforts in other constitution making processes? So I really look at the journey I have gone through, particularly the thesis, and I trace the thesis and my idea for it and my research really to the experiences I had here, because I was incredibly lucky to meet Heinz here, who then acted as my thesis supervisor. So it all really ties together to my experience here.
SPEAKER_02And Professor Heinz Klug is another speaker that we'll hear on our podcast as well. I'm wondering, this is, I think, every scholar's nightmare. I'm gonna ask you if you could distill your dissertation in one or two sentences. What did you find? What was um kind of a challenge in the court system and are there solutions for ensuring that they're operating effectively and representing the people?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I can never get it down, no matter how many times I practice this one. So what I found first is that in the post-independence period there was this problem of representativeness. There was because of the absence of descriptive representativeness, that is to say, after independence in Southern Africa, due to colonial policy, there were no black Africans who qualified to sit as judges. So a lot of these courts in in Malawi and Zambia, they still had British judges. And in Zimbabwe it was white settler judges. So what happened was every time there was a controversial ruling, then the political elites were able to say, who are these judges, right?
SPEAKER_00Why are we listening to these British judges? And so that made the courts ineffective because they were vulnerable to these accusations of dual loyalty. And so what has then happened is through constitutional reform, the constitutions not only require that courts represent the people, but there are specific requirements for gender, ethnic representation on these courts to address all that. That but essentially in terms of the design question, which is at the core of my thesis, boys, I'm asking this question because you have countries increasingly establish constitutional courts to sit at the top of the judiciary.
SPEAKER_00That is what is thought to be the solution. That when you have a new constitution, expand your bill of rights, have more rights, and get a new court, right? That seems to be the solution. New court, more rights, equals a greater democracy, more or less. So I was comparing that to the countries that don't introduce these constitutional courts, but simply continue with a court that sits at a lower level, like a high court, subject to appeal, more or less, but not exactly like in the US, where you can enforce at a lower level. And I was looking at what exactly is effective, how does it work?
SPEAKER_00And the counterintuitive findings are the lower courts are more effective, right? These courts, you come, you introduce a new court at the top, this constitutional court. It turns out that new court, it tends to be it's a high visibility court, so it's subject to more political pressure. And because they are sitting at the very top, they have a bigger burden of ruling with finality, of creating precedent, which is different from the lower courts. Both at the lower courts, you can find younger judges, right? So they want career advancement by showing they can engage with the constitution.
SPEAKER_00And they're also like, well, if I'm wrong, you can just appeal, right? So it's it's not like the top court where oh oh my god, we have to really think about these issues. So that lower level, you can find judges that will give you the decision. They don't worry, they have no problem of finality, they don't sit on panels. So you can find a loan ranger who is just going to give you the decision, right, without worrying about convincing colleagues or building precedent and their lower visibility. Some of these judgments are not even reported. So these judges will not actually face backlash.
SPEAKER_00So, due to a lot of these factors, the that's the uh counterintuitive result that even when you establish this constitutional court, it's actually it actually tends to be these lower courts which will which may act in the shadow of that body. But a lot of lawyers, particularly in Zimbabwe and Zambia, um, are going back to this lower level. This is where they find it's more effective than at the higher level. And certainly in the case of Malawi, where there was a judgment which overturned the presidential election result, that was also at that lower level. It was at the high court. I mean, it was confirmed by the Supreme Court, but it was at that lower level that the decision was made.
SPEAKER_00And if it's the top court that's dealing with something as sensitive as a presidential election, then the considerations are quite, quite different.
SPEAKER_02This is really critical research at this particular moment, not just within African countries, but it's research we should look at on a global scale as well. And I appreciate you sharing not just your research and your experience with us, but you've also addressed these complexities and dynamics of judicial power and just this critical role that the judiciary plays in upholding rights. So I want to thank you for being with us here today as part of our podcast and being a scholar and leading this Yumley group that we have here at Montpelier.
SPEAKER_00Um, thank you very much. It's always wonderful to be back in. I really enjoyed this podcast. Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_02And thank you to all our listeners for joining us for this special episode, the second in a series of three. I hope you'll share the show with family and friends. We'll be back in two weeks with the third and final installment of this mini series as we continue to consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...