Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

Beyond the Founders: How Ordinary Americans Built a Government

May 28, 202537 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode, host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey interviews historian Dr. Peter Kastor about how America's founding generation transformed constitutional ideals into functioning government institutions. Learn about the challenges faced by early federal leaders, the overlooked contributions of thousands of ordinary civil servants, and how this formative period established enduring traditions of public service and constitutional governance.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackin and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.

SPEAKER_01Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey with James Madison's Montpelier. Today we're addressing the story of how a bold and unprecedented experiment in self-government took root and began to grow. After the ink dried on the Constitution, the real work began. What followed were decades of challenges, triumphs, and transformation, as the founding fathers and the often overlooked men and women who served alongside them set about building the institutions that would become the foundation of the United States government.

SPEAKER_02From the creation of the first executive departments to the early sessions of Congress, from shaping the judiciary to defining the roles of public service, this is the story of how ideals were turned into institutions and how those institutions were sustained by a generation of Americans committed to the republic they helped to create. And our guest speaker today is Dr. Peter Castor, the Samuel K. Eddy Professor of History at Washington University in St.

SPEAKER_02Louis, where he also serves as the Associate Vice Dean of Research in Arts and Sciences. He chairs the Board of Trustees of the Missouri Historical Society. Dr. Castor is the author or editor of eight books on the early American Republic and just completed a landmark digital project called Creating the Federal Government, which for the first time reconstructs the federal workforce during the era of the Founding Fathers. Known for his academic scholarship on the early decades of American independence, as well as the history of the American presidency, Dr.

SPEAKER_02Castor is also an actively engaged public historian with over 30 years of experience working on projects that make constructive use of digital methods. Peter, it's so great to have you on the show today, especially with all of the experience that you bring.

SPEAKER_00Oh, thank you so much for having me here. It's really great to be on with you today.

SPEAKER_02So across this, you know, next 20, 30 minutes, we're going to be talking about this early history of the government, but we'll also get to hear a little bit more about why this history is important to preserve, which is something that you do with a lot of your work. So as we start off, this period in American history after the Constitution is drafted and ratified, I find particularly fascinating because this is when the Constitution is being put into practice. This blueprint for the structure of government and what each branch should do, this is where we're seeing all of it actually happen.

SPEAKER_02So can you tell us how the founding generation approached this challenge of translating these ideals and how this government should function as laid out in the Constitution? How did they put that into practice in the early years?

SPEAKER_00I often start by saying they made it up as they went along, you know. Uh and I don't mean to make light of what they accomplished. It was absolutely remarkable. And I think it's all the more remarkable because there wasn't a clearly articulated blueprint. The Constitution itself said practically nothing about what kind of institutions of government there would be. It makes references to an army, you know, to a military that there would be. It makes references to their being diplomats because it says the Senate has to approve of treaties.

SPEAKER_00You assume diplomats would do that. And it also made references to their being agency heads, because again, it says the Senate must approve them. They're only appointed with the advice and consent of the Senate. But what is particularly striking about the Constitution isn't that its authors failed to see this, but rather that they entrusted their successors to deal with it. They said, we're gonna establish a framework. I think they knew that they would be involved in the next steps.

SPEAKER_00Many of them hope to, but it's pretty remarkable, I think, that they entrusted their successors to do this. Many of them became their own successors. George Washington's at the Constitutional Convention, he becomes the first president. James Madison, principal author of the Constitution, then becomes a member of the House of Representatives. And of course, Alexander Hamilton immediately moves into becoming the first Secretary of the Treasury. But for every one of them, there are a host of other people who would take on this mantle of creating a federal government.

SPEAKER_02And so it sounds like a lot of these folks that are drafting or involved with the drafting of the Constitution, they are involved with shaping it in the years later. But of course, as you mentioned, there's many other people who are involved with putting this into practice. Why is it so important to keep that in mind and to keep this period of history in mind when we think about how this experiment in democracy and self-governance started?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think we learn why it's important from the founders, because they knew what was at stake. They had two experiences in their recent history. They could think about the late colonial period, the last years before the revolution, and they said, this is what happens when, in their mind, government runs amok. That when you've got institutions of government with no appropriate checks or balances, you get tyranny. That's the way they remembered the 1760s and the early 1770s. Then they said, we tried this.

SPEAKER_00We tried this under the Articles of Confederation. It didn't work. And what I want to emphasize in all of this is they were, of course, thinking in political terms. How do people get elected? What power should they have? What checks should there be on elected officials? How would voting work? But they also were thinking in very practical terms. The authors of the Constitution wanted a government that would be able to accomplish the goals of the United States, it would be able to tackle big priorities that could govern and could govern effectively.

SPEAKER_00And their experience under the Articles of Confederation was that its diffuse and vaguely articulated system simply didn't work, didn't achieve the policy-making goals, didn't create a good government structure. Some of them would go so far as to say the whole thing was a mess. And their goal was to find that sweet spot where you have a government that is led by political officials who themselves will not succumb to the risks of tyranny, and they supervise appointed officials who themselves would not succumb to those risks, but for whom there would be appropriate checks to prevent them from accumulating dangerous forms of power.

SPEAKER_00Let me give you a short list: fiscal insolvency, war on two fronts, arguments within the nation, and uncertainty about the future. Let me talk about each one of these in turn. One of the first things people often hear about, and it's correct, is that financially the U.S. was a mess. The states had enormous debts that they couldn't resolve. They didn't know what to do with them, and it really limited what state governments could do. And then the central government simply didn't have the financial resources to accomplish its goals.

SPEAKER_00And this had a direct impact on everyday Americans. There were Americans who had bought bonds that were basically loans to these governments that weren't repaid to them, or if they were repaid, it was pennies on the dollar. And then there were things they wanted government to do and the government couldn't pay for it. So that's the first problem. Then I talk about wars on two fronts. Almost as soon as the United States came into being, wars erupted in both the East and the West. In the West, this newly organized United States government faced a newly organized confederacy of Native American societies that were really trying to restrain the United States and especially restrain the settlers who were pouring into native lands.

SPEAKER_00So Native Americans were trying to resist this incursion from Western settlers. And this erupted into warfare. And by 1789, 1790, the U.S. was losing. So the U.S. was losing this war in the West. And then in 1789, of course, the French Revolution gets started. The US has to figure out how it's going to handle that diplomatically. But in 1792, that erupted into war in Europe. And it's a war that went on for over 20 years. So there are conflicts everywhere. And meanwhile, the states are still arguing with each other.

SPEAKER_00States are arguing with the central government. So all of these were different conflicts that the founders had to address. All of these problems were also connected because the solution to the fiscal problem was to generate revenue from duties levied on imported goods. But US imports were thrown into turmoil by the war in Europe and by difficult trading relationships with European powers. Meanwhile, a lot of the founders had really banked the nation's future on the ability of white settlers to move to the West, establish their independence there.

SPEAKER_00They were investing a lot of money in establishing a civil government in the federal territories, and native resistance to that also seemed like a threat. So all of these were connected to each other. They also feared that these external threats would create pressures that would eventually tear apart the union from within. So they believed that only by being united could they face these external threats, but they feared that the external threats would tear apart the union.

SPEAKER_00So these guys were, let's say they were engaged in a lot of intellectual multitasking as they sought to resolve these really, really serious challenges.

SPEAKER_02Peter, when you were talking about the conflicts that this young nation is facing, this war on two fronts, it makes me think about the decades that passed leading up to the war of 1812, because it is rooted in these early years, the 1790s. And then during the war of 1812, Madison is president during that time. And that's a defining moment in this very young government where the United States is still trying to prove its legitimacy, I would say, in this global community.

SPEAKER_02And that's quite a challenge for Madison to be facing during his presidency.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And the War of 1812 wasn't just the first time the United States declared war, but in addition, it's kind of a great schoolroom for all of us now because just about every challenge of federalism played out in the War of 1812. And also all of these domestic and international challenges played out. Why did the War of 1812 happen? Why did the U.S. declare it war? Because it had not found any other way to resolve commercial disputes with Great Britain that were really rooted in the war in Europe.

SPEAKER_00The British government had imposed an increasing number of restrictions on U.S. trade, in large part in an effort to win this war against France. So the British start doing that. And that's why the U.S. declared war. But the U.S. didn't just fight this war against British regulars on the U.S.-Canadian border. The War of 1812 spilled out into conflicts in the Southwest, primarily against the Creek. And later it erupted in the immediate aftermath of a major conflict between the United States and a Native Confederacy in what's now the Midwest.

SPEAKER_00And so all of these conflicts played out then, and every single challenge and opportunity that Madison faced during the war was a reflection of the systems he'd helped to create. The U.S. funded the war on a fiscal plan that had come into being in the 1790s, but hit the limits of that plan. Eventually, Madison basically had to impose large debts in order to pay for this war because the fiscal system he had helped create wasn't really designed for a war like this. Likewise, the balance that Madison had sought between a central government and the states was really put to the test.

SPEAKER_00Some states actively participated in the war, by which I mean they mobilized their militias, they coordinated with the government in Washington, and those were principally southern and western states that saw the war of 1812 tied up in their own conflict with their native neighbors, whereas other states just flat out resisted and undermined the administration's ability to prosecute the war. Meanwhile, the federal territories, which were governed by the administration in that territorial system that Madison had been essential in building, it's it's the territories that really delivered because they were active partners to the administration.

SPEAKER_00Many of the greatest successes that the U.S. found during the war, because some of its greatest military successes were either fought in Western territories or were led by people who had really built their careers in that. So William Henry Harrison, who most Americans know about as kind of a joke, he gets elected president in 1840, gives the longest inaugural, and guess what he deserves? He catches pneumonia and dies. Well, during the War of 1812, he had been a territorial governor, later became a general, and really fought nationally as a result.

SPEAKER_00The most famous battlefield victory in New Orleans, even though its U.S. troops were led by Andrew Jackson, there's widespread support for it among Louisianans. And these are people who had just emerged from an extended period of territorial governance that had really cemented their national attachment. They saw no reason to resist the administration's efforts to prosecute this war because they had always seen the administration as something that would safeguard them against all kinds of threats.

SPEAKER_02As we talk about the landscape of America at this early point, obviously there is a lot going on. There's westward expansion and trying to use the Constitution as a framework for how do we bring this new land, these new territories in? How do we regulate this international trade and prove our legitimacy with these foreign countries? All of this is happening during this period, in addition to these big players like Hamilton, Washington, Madison.

SPEAKER_02Who are the regular folks that are serving in the federal government? And how did their sense of public service evolve during these early years?

SPEAKER_00So let me start with some numbers, because I've been thinking a lot about these numbers. Uh, over the past few years, I've been building a digital project that reconstructs the federal workforce during this period. And by the time James Madison left office as president, when he retired in 1817, federal government had reached a steady state of about 30,000 employees. And the way I often describe it is that for every James Madison, who himself had been a federal employee when he was Secretary of State, there are thousands of Thomas Melvilles.

SPEAKER_00He's the story I often like to talk about. He sort of helps explain this. So when George Washington became president in 1789, Thomas Melville wrote to him personally. Melville was a revenue official in Boston, and he knew that his office would come under the federal regime. And he said, please let me keep my job. And Washington did. And Melville stayed, remained a revenue collector until about 1830. And that's when Andrew Jackson sort of either fires him or forcibly retires him.

SPEAKER_00Melville was about 80 years old. He clearly thought it was a good gig because his grandson, Herman Melville, later worked in the Customs House in New York. But my point is there are thousands of these folks who are like Thomas Melville. They're low-level officials. Very few of them will reach senior administrative roles, and they're the ones that actually make the federal government a reality. They're the ones who populate all these new offices, civil and military. This new system, especially the executive branch, would really have been nonexistent, would have been pointless without agencies and employees that would bring the administration's goals into reality.

SPEAKER_00So there are thousands of these people. They come from all over the country. They serve in all kinds of jobs. Almost all of them were men, but not all of them. It's really striking at a time when there were so few formal employment opportunities for women. Women, of course, were working all the time. They were working on farms. They worked in large numbers of areas. So between 1789 and 1829, which is as far as I've studied, there are about 38,000 men and women who served in the federal government.

SPEAKER_00And those are just the civil branches. That's not including and the officer corps, the military, doesn't include enlisted personnel. And I say men and women because it often comes as a surprise to people to learn that there were women who were federal employees during this time. The largest number of them worked in the post office, maintaining individual post offices. There were some who managed lighthouses. There are a very small number at the tail end of this time who started working as nurses as the federal government started creating uh hospitals in the major ports that were sort of for uh injured sailors mostly.

SPEAKER_00Again, these women are small in number, but I emphasize that to suggest that this federal workforce was larger than most people now assume and different from what they might be picturing.

SPEAKER_02And what did that kind of service look like? What were the different roles and what was the diversity of the workforce at that time?

SPEAKER_00It's a great question. So I'll begin with the fact that in comparison to any workplace in the United States now, you would say this is not a diverse workplace because it's overwhelmingly white men. I want to start with that. And that's completely true. One of the striking things to me, just looking at them, large number of foreign nationals. We have records of who served in it. And you see all these people who were, it would say where they were born, what state they were born in. So you see a lot of people from Connecticut, Georgia, Kentucky.

SPEAKER_00But then you see a lot of people from born in Ireland, Germany, Italy. You start seeing people born in Poland. What's interesting to me is there was no country called Germany at that time. But because these people came from places that spoke German, the record says they're from Germany, not from Bohemia or Prussia or anything like that. I find that very interesting. So the other thing that we don't know is how many people of mixed race ancestry there were who presented themselves as white and who needed to do that in order to be employed in the government.

SPEAKER_00We know this in general for this time. There are a large number of Americans whose parents were Euro-American and African American. And at a certain point in those families, you have members of that family, of those families who join white society because not just of the benefits that brings, but all of the limitations that remaining in African American society would bring with it. One thing we also know is that there were federal employees of mixed European and Native American ancestry. So one thing that people often know about is that there was a woman on the Lewis and Clark expedition named Sakagawea, and that she had a baby on the expedition.

SPEAKER_00A lot of people don't know who the father of that kid was. Well, his name was Toussaint Charbonneau, and he was a Metis, which meant he was of French and Native American ancestry, as were other members of the Lewis and Clark expedition. Charbonneau was a trader and occasional translator by occupation. And sure enough, he shows up in the federal employment records in the 1820s as a translator at an Indian agency in the West. So a lot of people of native ancestry were often part of these Indian agencies.

SPEAKER_00But it does sort of raise this larger question that there must have been other people of mixed-race ancestry in the federal government. We simply don't know who they were.

SPEAKER_02Those are the kinds of stories that fascinate me most along this public history vein is these people that were so integral in creating and supporting this early government, but we don't know a whole lot about them. And I wonder, how do we know what we Know about them and why is it important to know this information in this 21st century era that we live in?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I find their stories amazing also. I really, really do. And the thing I often say about the people I study is that the United States was unusual in that there were a lot of elected offices. There weren't a lot of elected offices in other countries, but there were far more appointed offices on an order of magnitude. You know, for every elected official in the United States, certainly in the federal government, there are hundreds of appointed officials. And for them, that federal service is what it meant to be American. You know, I mentioned Thomas Melville in his letter to George Washington.

SPEAKER_00He said, here's why I want this job. He said, I fought in the revolution. I supported the Constitution. I know what it means to be American. And this is the kind of service that I want to do. And there are 18,000 letters of application and recommendation during this time. And these are people who didn't know each other, but they all make that same claim that service in the federal government would be one of the ways that they demonstrated themselves as good citizens.

SPEAKER_00And the only reason we know that, the only reason we have access to their stories is because the federal leadership chose to save those records. I teach a course on the presidency, and I get to this whole segment about this, and I tell my students, what we know is only as good as the information that we have before us. And of course, for the kind of research that I do, it's absolutely essential. I couldn't do any of it without this kind of records preservation.

SPEAKER_00And for the work I've been doing most recently on the early federal workforce, 90% of this of the information comes from records that were preserved by the federal government. They were first saved either by Congress or later put in the National Archives or the Library of Congress. And that's how we know this. And I'll give you an example of this. So I wanted to understand all these postmasters. And they're about, I'm trying to remember, something like 15,000 postal employees that I found between 1789 and 1829, serving in over, I think around 12,000 post offices.

SPEAKER_00How do I know that? Because the post office kept these books. Every time they appointed someone, they kept a record of it. Well, those books found their way into the National Archives. And in the 1960s, some archivists began organizing this. And it's very old school. They would take a sheet of paper, put it in a typewriter, and whenever they saw the list of a place, they would type here's the state, the county, the locality, and the first postmaster. They take the sheet out. When they found several pages later in the old 18th century or 19th century record, the next person who was appointed to it, they wrote it there.

SPEAKER_00So a number of years ago, I hired an undergraduate who lived in the Washington, D.C. area to go photograph all of these. And I gotta do a shout out to her. Terrific historian, Lauren Henley. She's now a professor at the University of Richmond, a terrific historian in her own right. And she photographed all of these. That material was there because the archives preserved them. That material could be analyzed because archivists had done an inventory. I could see it because our National Archives lets anybody in there without charge, could do unlimited photographing without charge.

SPEAKER_00And once I had those photographs, I had a series of research assistants who then transcribed that information. That is how, in many ways, paper becomes knowledge on the Internet. There's one other example I think of. One of the striking things about this government, I've emphasized how effectively it was organized, but it was in some ways incredibly inefficient because it's a pre-bureaucratic age. There isn't much central organization, and the president had to spend a ton of time doing stuff that a president shouldn't have to do.

SPEAKER_00One of which was that the president would manually write in his own hand, with his own pen, the names of people he was nominating to office. How do I know this? So I went to the National Archives many years ago and I saw a listing that said nominations, Jefferson Administration. I asked for this. And they brought me, I swear they brought me an ammo box, something that probably began life holding 45 caliber ammunition or something like that. But they needed a way to store this, and inside of it were several dozen little slips of paper in Thomas Jefferson's handwriting.

SPEAKER_00And they would say things like, I nominate so-and-so to be the U.S. attorney for the state of New Jersey, I nominate so-and-so to be the revenue collector in Charleston, South Carolina. And just page after page of this, and we only know this, again, because from one of the striking things about the founders was that even though I said they were making it up as they went along, they made a lot of good decisions. And one of the most important ones was they realized that preserving that record was important.

SPEAKER_00And these records also record their mistakes. And I'm struck by the fact that they did not attempt to somehow sanitize their record. They just said, we're going to save this stuff, let posterity sort it out. And we're really the beneficiaries of that. This would be lost to us, but for that meticulous record keeping.

SPEAKER_02And that's where, in part, this project that you've been working on, this digital platform called Creating a Federal Government, really is significant in providing these resources to the public. Why are projects like yours so important for the public to have access to?

SPEAKER_00Well, thanks for asking that. And if you'll bear with me, I'll tell you a little about this project. And I think that will answer your question. So there was a moment when I had to make a decision about what I was going to do. I knew I was working on a project about the early federal government and how the kind of abstractions of the Constitution became real institutions. One of the things I could have produced from that was simply a data set, the kind of thing that a social scientist would know how to use, the kind of thing that an academic researcher would have a software package to interpret.

SPEAKER_00And I thought that's not my goal here, which is Americans are really interested in the founding fathers. They're really interested in that period. One of the amazing things is that the Library of Congress, the National Archives, they're open to everyone. Anyone can go in there, but not everyone can get there. And so my goal was to take all of this material that I get to work with for a living and to share it with a general public that is interested in this time. So that was my first goal. My second goal was to bring material together.

SPEAKER_00What this project does is to reconstruct the public careers of about 38,000 federal employees. It includes civil officials ranging from office clerks to presidents of the United States. It also includes commissioned personnel in the United States Army, Navy, and Marine Corps. And so for each person, it says the person served in this office from this time, this office to this time, this office and this time. You can really see their lives, and in many cases, it has the state and country in which they're born and when they lived.

SPEAKER_00But creating those career profiles was tough. Let's put it this way: there was no HR department in 1800. So nowadays you work somewhere and they have a record of all your previous jobs. It wasn't the case then. So what I needed to do was to take this range of sources, some of them manuscript sources in the National Archives, some of them in the Library of Congress. There were a series of published registers of federal employees that started coming out in the 1790s and then started coming out regularly beginning in 1816.

SPEAKER_00And bring all of those together along with some other sources, quite simply, so other people wouldn't have to do this. So that if you're obviously an academic researcher like me, you can find all these people. But also if you're a genealogist and everyone has said, you know, we had an ancestor who fought in the American Revolution, and later we heard something about him being in a lighthouse in Maine. You can find him. The lighthouse information is in there because I was able to partner with another organization.

SPEAKER_00There's a wonderful organization, the U.S. Lighthouse Historical Society, which has made it their mission to preserve the history of American lighthouses. And I went to them and said, Will you share with me your data on lighthouse keepers just from this early period? And they said, Where do we sign up? We had an agreement. All they asked for is that I credit them for the great work that they've done. And so my goal was to take all of this material from all of these sources, bring them together into one website where you can not only search for people by name, but where there's a map that shows the roughly 2,000, I think it's maybe 1,800 locations throughout the United States and around the world.

SPEAKER_00Honolulu, Hawaii, Canton, now Guangzhou, China, as well as places like New York and Washington, D.C. and St. Louis, where I live, that you can see all these places where people worked and click on them and see who worked there. To combine that information also with a narrative story that would explain things like what is federalism? Phrase people hear but often don't understand. What were the early federal agencies? What did they do? What role did the founders play in creating them?

SPEAKER_00So my goal was to create this public resource that would be helpful for scholars like me, but most importantly, that would be useful for teachers and students, for the general public for history buffs around the world.

SPEAKER_02As we wind down our conversation today, given your decades of research and this labor of love that you've worked on and pulling together these resources, what do you think are the lessons that we can draw from the way the early republic and this early model of public service weathered internal and external conflicts and what we can draw from it and apply today?

SPEAKER_00It could have gone wrong so many times. That's my starting point. There are a lot of ways in which not only the leadership but the membership of the federal government were on the wrong side of history. Two of the major projects of the federal government during this time were to preserve African American enslavement as extended into the territorial West and to accomplish Native American dispossession. So both the low-level employees and the senior leaders totally on the wrong side of history. But there also are all of these moments when they face decisions and they could have made a wrong decision.

SPEAKER_00It starts with people like Washington and Madison, who were quite honest in talking about their desire to surrender power as much as to acquire it. That was not the norm at this time. On both sides of the Atlantic, in the monarchies of Europe, in Napoleonic France, and in newly independent Latin America, the model was that people acquired power, distributed it to their friends, and never gave it up.

SPEAKER_00The most striking thing to me about this government is that the way that the elected officials surrender power and also the ways that the people they hired seemed pretty goal-oriented. I mean, they liked their jobs, they liked getting paid, but they sort of see it as their mission to advance the goals of the union. Again, thinking about the ways they asked for jobs. They would often say things like, you know, I supported you in the last election, but that's the secondary concern. The real concern is I support the Constitution, I support what this government's doing.

SPEAKER_00And what's striking to me is that that culture is kind of there from the start. They made plenty of mistakes. I mean, that's pretty clear to me. And you run into signs of corruption. But that's what's clear to me. The other thing is nowadays people spend a lot of time trying to understand what the founders want. Do they want a big government? Do they want a small government? After studying the government, they actually built. I tend to see a government that was larger and more capacious than many conservatives I talk with now think that it was. It surprises them.

SPEAKER_00But it's also a government that was far more limited than many liberals I know now wish that it were. So no one really gets what they want. But what I want to emphasize is that all of the founders from both of the two major political parties from all ends of the political spectrum believed that governance was a solution. They said there are enormous challenges facing the United States. Governance is a solution to this. Their goal was not to eliminate government, but rather to make certain that there were safeguards so that government could have power without becoming tyrannical, so that government would have resources without destroying the fiscal solvency of the United States.

SPEAKER_00They're always seeking that sweet spot. A lot of people who study Madison in the Constitution, in the debates for the Constitution, focus on Madison's commitment to balance, balance between the states and the central government, balance between Congress, the judiciary, and the executive. I find that Madison and his contemporaries felt the same way about the federal government. They wanted a government that was sufficiently capable to tackle these huge national challenges without being so expensive that it broke the bank, and without being so powerful that it became tyrannical.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, I actually think they managed to find that sweet spot, and that was not an easy thing to do.

SPEAKER_02Well, Dr. Castor, I want to thank you for taking the time to talk with us today. It's a very powerful message to hear about just the ordinary folks that made this early government possible and that forged this tradition of dedication, loyalty to the Constitution, and desire to serve. That being the core of what made this early federal government, a legacy that I think really carries on to the present. So thank you so much for your time.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for having me.

SPEAKER_02And I want to thank all of our listeners. I hope you'll subscribe and share the show with your family and friends. And tune in again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode