Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

Global Impact of the U.S. Constitution

Aug 28, 202433 minAudio

In this first episode of a special three-part mini-series, host Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier explores the global impact of the U.S. Constitution. Funded by Virginia Humanities and produced in collaboration with the Presidential Precinct, this series highlights the experiences of Young African Leaders Initiative (YALI) Mandela Washington Fellows. Featuring an interview with Professor Heinz Klug, a South African constitutional scholar, the episode delves into the complexities of constitution-building, the importance of context in drafting constitutions, and the role of public participation in shaping democracy. Klug shares insights from his involvement in South Africa's post-apartheid transition, discussing the challenges of balancing diverse stakeholder interests and the necessity of "constructive ambiguity" in constitutional language. Gain valuable perspectives on the fundamental principles and challenges of creating effective governance structures in different cultural and historical contexts.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and sight in the constitutional issues of recording fact and hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lacky, featuring in the women's constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners. We examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. Over the next three episodes, as part of a special miniseries, we're highlighting the impact of the U.S. Constitution on the global community. In these three episodes, you'll hear from international scholars and distinguished public servants studying and working in sub-Saharan Africa. Funded by a grant from the Virginia Humanities and produced in collaboration with the Presidential Precinct, this mini-series provides you a full 360-degree view of the immersive and experiential Constitution Building Simulation hosted here at the Center for the Constitution, as part of the U.S.

SPEAKER_02State Department's Young African Leaders Initiative, or Yali. Each year, it is our honor to host a cohort of Yali Mandela Washington fellows here at Montpelier. These 25 to 35-year-olds are each accomplished leaders from sub-Saharan African nations.

SPEAKER_00And as they will tell you themselves, democracy is not that simple as we think it is. I've learned that democracy is not very straightforward. Democracy is not just a sprint, but it is a marathon that requires eternal vigilance.

SPEAKER_02Their experience here was powerful and will greatly inform their work at home, shaping the democratic futures of their own countries. Today, I want to introduce you to Professor Heinz Klug. He is one of the scholars who is instructing the multi-day constitution building simulation that's taking place here at Montpelier for the 2024 Yali Cohort. Professor Klug is a native of South Africa who participated in the struggle to end his nation's system of institutionalized racial segregation and discrimination, known as apartheid.

SPEAKER_02Heinz spent 11 years in exile and earned his law degree before returning to South Africa in 1990 to take part in the country's democratic transition. Heinz has taught at the University of Wisconsin Law School since 1996. His research interests include constitutional transitions, constitution building, human rights, and international legal regimes. Professor Klug, it's an honor to welcome you here today to the studio at Montpelier.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. That's very kind of you.

SPEAKER_02So as a professional in the legal field, you obviously bring that perspective with you to our conversation today. And perhaps even more significantly, you bring this lived experience, this commitment to furthering democracy, as demonstrated through your involvement in the transition of post-apartheid South Africa. You assisted with the creation of a constitution that allowed for a stable political structure for all citizens in South Africa. Being here at Montpelier, often think about James Madison and what he must have been thinking and feeling going into this constitutional convention in 1787 and the countless hours he spent preparing to engage in that process.

SPEAKER_02And obviously, your involvement in South Africa in the 1990s is very different than the process that the framers in the United States undertook in the 1780s. But it's still this process of building a constitution. Broadly, as we kind of kick off the conversation, can you define the fundamental principles of a successful constitution? Just on a basic level, what should a constitution include?

SPEAKER_01I mean, what's interesting about that is the assumption is what you're talking about is a written constitution, right? When the idea of a constitution is really the idea of a form of governance, as Madison well understood, right? What he was studying was forms of governance from around the world as a way to think about how to construct a constitution for the United States. And so the the real the fundamental principles, if you like, is to think about, well, what form of governance would work for the society, the particular society in which this is taking place.

SPEAKER_01And when one thinks about a particular society, one's thinking about its history, about the context, the moment of the constitution-making process itself, and in ways thinking about its future too. Where is this likely to lead? You know, and we're well aware, if you uh talking about the United States Constitution, that at the time they understood that there were certain things that they couldn't resolve. There were certain issues that they had to bump into the future, and and some pretty significant ones like the issue of slavery, right? That it wasn't able to say, yes, a fundamental principle that we can resolve one way or another.

SPEAKER_01Uh and, you know, a very painful experience, in fact, for the United States, how that was resolved in terms of a civil war. So you can't, you know, to think about a successful constitution, it has to be a successful form of governance for that moment that can take you to the next moments. And those next moments, you know, can't always be predicted exactly how they will work out. Um, in the same way that, you know, at that moment, there was no consideration that women were part of that level of conversation in society, and yet to imagine that women part of aren't part of society and shouldn't be incorporated, today we wouldn't think about that.

SPEAKER_01So one of the interesting questions that goes on at the moment is so if you're having a constitutional moment and are trying to bring people in, should you make sure that it's equal number of men and women? Uh does that representation work? And some societies have tried to do that and other societies not. So it's for me, a lot of this is what I think about in terms of constitutional imagination. And at a particular moment in time, what how can you imagine what the parameters are that you are involved in in that moment and what are the alternatives?

SPEAKER_01And do they work for you and your society in a particular place? It was interesting in even in the introduction, the assumption that I think at the period of Madison where he was preparing himself to go in. Today these are much more collective processes. It was collective enough even in Madison's time. He wasn't there alone. There were many other people with very different ideas. They they contested those ideas, they argued about those ideas, and Madison made compromises too. He may have been one of the major drafters, but he wasn't alone.

SPEAKER_01What I always feel about Madison is that we now know about the whole convention from his minutes. So it's really his memory of what that constitution-making process was actually about. So you ask me, what should a constitution include? Well, many ways that's preset in part by the context of one's imagination. Today, uh one can't imagine thinking about a constitution without having some kind of legislative process, right?

SPEAKER_01Creating a legislature, uh that there should be an executive, that there should be a judiciary. These are just kind of but these are historical artifacts that have been produced over now hundreds of years. But never mind how uh exceptional and revolutionary a constitution wants to be, it seems to be well bed embedded in that imagination of what's possible. Right? It's very few constitutions now that would think there shouldn't be.

SPEAKER_01I mean, we think of such different constitutions around the world, you know, whether it's China or the old Soviet Union or whatever, and when you look at them, well, they they still they may not have had the same relationships between these institutions, but oh look, they've got judges and they've got uh legislature and they have an executive. So these fundamental structures have become such an important part of what constitutions are. And and so, you know, what should a constitution include? There's lots of things it could include, and it is about the moment in time.

SPEAKER_01So for instance, there's uh that we think about the debate about so uh about rights. And you know, you still think people say, well, you know, obviously you can only include political and civil rights, not social and economic rights. And yet there are societies now that have included social and economic rights at exactly the same level, and they're working out how to make that work as well. There's no a priori, some cannot be and some can. You know, some systems will find it harder to grapple with some there rather than others.

SPEAKER_01So I don't think there's there's things that I would say are absolutely necessary or can absolutely not be included. It's gonna be the process.

SPEAKER_02The idea that constitutions really need to be dependent upon the context in which they're written, the history of that group, the culture. And you brought up a really important point about how is that constitution going to be a stepping stone for the future, for future generations. And I'm really intrigued by this idea of yes, what can whoever it is, this collective group that's drafting a constitution, what can they imagine? What should be in this constitution, but also what are they omitting?

SPEAKER_02What information or knowledge are they not considering in this process?

SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell And again, that depends- you know, and sometimes that may be quite conscious. There's certain things they don't want to touch because they know they're politically not viable, that they won't get agreement. Um there's a nice example of that. The death penalty in South Africa. He has a constitution-making process through two different phases, the interim and the final constitution, but really this gets resolved in the first part. In the interim constitution, the parties cannot agree on the question of the death penalty. The old regime believes it's an essential part of a criminal justice system, and the African National Congress, the dominant party on the other side, believes that we must get rid of the death penalty because there's a quite a number of people, there were 400 people on death row at the time, many of whom included some resistance fighters.

SPEAKER_01And so the argument was this is how the death penalty's been used, and it it should not be. And uh but they could not come to agreement. So the interim constitution makes no reference. It has a right to life, but uh many constitutions in the world have a right to life and still include the death penalty. So there's nothing, no mention of it. And the first case, the first major case that comes to the Constitutional Court in 1995, is about the death penalty. It's about what to do with these 400 people who are presently on death row.

SPEAKER_01And the court is now left in a position. You know, a number of the people who had helped design that first constitution were on the court. Right? So if you want to know what the intent of the drafters were, that wasn't hard for them to imagine. But what they were facing was something that hadn't been decided. They knew that. And so the court had to thrash it out itself. And it court came to the decision, famous Makwignani decision, that the death penalty is unconstitutional.

SPEAKER_01And then in the second process, constitution-making process by the elected Constituent Assembly, it's a situation where if you had gone, say, and had a survey or an opinion poll among the majority of South Africans, they probably would have, of all colours, supported the death penalty. Culturally, right? That was the moment. And yet, given the decision of the court, which could they could have changed the second constitution-making process, because it would just be like an amendment, right?

SPEAKER_01It'd be a change, it was a new constitution. And they didn't touch it. They just left it alone. So it's still on the basis of the court decision. As an interpretation of the Constitution, that there cannot be a death penalty. They didn't get resolved either time. Because they didn't want to be seen to be standing up to what they they saw as a both a cultural attitude on one hand, but also couldn't resolve it politically themselves. So, yes, there are these lacuna in all constitutions where for political, cultural, and other reasons, a topic, in this case as important as the death penalty, just gets left aside, doesn't get resolved.

SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Professor Klug, you reference this multiple constitution processes, at least in South Africa. Given that there's no defined what should a constitution include, because it's dependent upon the context. Is there a process that we can look to, like a general guideline, or is that also dependent upon context?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think first of all, that's been his that's historically determined more than anything else, in the sense that there was no question that at some point in time the idea that you get a few men in the room and they write a constitution was just an accepted and an understood way to do it. Then there became the kind of assumption which we see in a lot of uh state constitutions in the United States, where sure we we get an amendment or we get a decision and then we go to the people in a referendum or whatever to endorse that decision.

SPEAKER_01In many ways, the the the U.S. Constitution, right, the gets drafted, but then it goes to the conventions in order to be accepted. And so that becomes a way where you get democratic participation in the process. That then evolves to you know, post the Second World War into this idea of uh constitutional assemblies. Elected constitutional assemblies. Whether it was India, finally South Africa in the final constitution, it's an elected constitutional assembly.

SPEAKER_01And again, the idea that it has a democratic basis, that the people who are making the constitution were democrat democratically elected to represent the people. So there's a move. At the same time, it's increasingly understanding that, well, representative democracy is not the most deep kind of democracy you can have. So there's uh been increasingly pushed to have more participatory processes, public participation in constitution-making processes. So you look around the world and there's various attempts to have greater public participation.

SPEAKER_01And so you saw that uh very famously in the case of uh uh Professor Yash Gai, who led the initial process in Kenya of uh constitutional review, you know, toured the country, went to every village and town, listened to people, consulted, and just to get as much participation as possible. And they produced what was called the Bowman draft, this draft constitution for Kenya, and then it was supposed to go to Parliament for Parliament to adopt it.

SPEAKER_01And you know, the politicians didn't feel as invested in it. And so they pushed back and they didn't take it like it was. So there you can have a highly participatory process and it runs into the political elite who basically, no, thank you. We we want some changes, we need it to be different. And eventually in Kenya it got resolved. But the point I'm making is that it's become clear now that you want public participation, but you also have to deal with the fact that there are elites in society and they need to be dealt with, incorporated in some way in that process.

SPEAKER_01Otherwise, you don't stand a chance. It's not gonna happen. Not gonna get through, it's not gonna be implemented. You so it's some mediation between popular participation, people's involvements, that they believe that this is a legitimate expression of what the people of the country want, um as opposed to uh just what the elites want by themselves, but that the elites are also an element in this and they somehow have to be incorporated. So, you know, in a way that the the this gets resolved in different ways in terms of how how to get there.

SPEAKER_01Um and again, what kind of conflict are you coming out of? Is it a conflict where the domestic participants still can't resolve their differences and you get a lot of international involvement, and that has limits because the domestic crowd are then left with what they get and may not really want it or may wish to change it. Uh they can just ignore it, right? So other problems that that that gives rise to, the international participants often have quite a bit of weight because they you know the international financing bodies and others are going to look to this to see whether they're gonna help.

SPEAKER_01And so there's a real tension in terms of how you make this happen. Another way that this has been thought of is creating these interim processes in South Africa, famously the interim constitution. That resolved a problem where the old regime did not want to hand over to a democratically elected body straight off the bat. Because if they did, they realized they'd be such a minority, they'd have no influence on that final constitution. So they insisted, they were insisting initially, that there had to be a completely negotiated and and and complete constitution before an election.

SPEAKER_01And obviously the Democratic uh participants in the struggle who had fought against the party said no, it must go to the people. They must elect a constituent assembly. And for a while, that was an incredibly tense moment. Talks broke down because of the violence that was taking place. Talks about South Africa as such a peaceful process. There was enormous violence in 91 and 92 and 1993. And in the context of that violence, the realization that that couldn't go on, there had to be a breakthrough.

SPEAKER_01And a compromise came with this idea that there'd be an interim constitution and a government of national unity for five years. Within that period, a two-year period, to write a new constitution which would be by a democratically elected body. And so, well, that's fine, but how do we make sure that that democratically elected body won't just then go do something completely different? Well, so then they uh they developed the concept of constitutional principles. So the first thing they agreed to is a set of thirty-four constitutional principles that would guide that uh democratically elected constituent body.

SPEAKER_01Which of course runs completely against the theory of constituent assembly and constituent power that they should be able to do whatever they wish. So they resolved that by saying, okay, a set of principles. And immediately people said, but who's going to make sure these principles are in fact followed? So the agreement was, well, the constituent assembly would write a new constitution. They would then, if it passed the constituent assembly by a two-thirds majority, would go to the const newly created constitutional court, which would have to certify that they had actually followed these principles.

SPEAKER_01No, what's going to happen now? So they go ahead and do this, and the constitutional court immediately when it has to certify it, all the parties who didn't get exactly what they wanted in the constitution-making body come running to court and say it didn't meet the principles. And it was a really interesting back conversation going on where the lawyers in town were going, Well, let's see if this court's a real court. Is it really going to stand up to the Constituent Assembly? And the court looks at this and goes, What do we do now?

SPEAKER_01And they effectively then say, Well, on this issue and this issue and this issue, they didn't follow the principles. But generally they did. Most of it's fine except for these few issues. The Constituent Assembly goes, fine, they fix those few issues and goes right back. And still people went to the court and said, Oh no, they still haven't followed in significant ways the amount of powers given to regions, etc. Real disagreements still existed. And this time the court said, no, no, no. Basically they followed the principles, that's enough. So there's a process, but it's a process that comes out of a very particular political context.

SPEAKER_01You can't say that you can just reproduce the same processes again and again. You have the Chilean experience that they just had, where there was massive protests on the streets, the government forced into a position where they say, okay, we're going to allow a new constitutional process and they come to an agreement of how that process is supposed to be run. But they also come to an agreement of a different kind of electoral system to produce the participants.

SPEAKER_01And so suddenly the participants in the first process, many of them are independents who are not beholden to particular political parties. Some were, some weren't. But it meant that in the Constituent Assembly, you didn't have these dominant parties who were clear about their positions and could negotiate. You had a whole range of opinions. And in the end, the only way to resolve it was to throw everything in. They had something like a hundred rights in their Bill of Rights. I mean, it's just everybody wanted something in. And of course or not of course, but as a result, I mean it goes to the public uh it's very easy for different people to ridicule it in different ways and attack it and it failed.

SPEAKER_01And it was an extraordinary moment of, you know, constitution making that everybody invested so much in and it failed. And then in response you get it thrown to uh a conservative parliament that's just been elected. And that conservative parliament is a more conservative group within it, right-wing group, who basically say, Well, now we have the t the chance, and they write one that is diametrically opposed to the old one as to the one that had just been defeated. And they come forward thinking, well now this is they're gonna get this now because the other one was turned down.

SPEAKER_01And again the public look at this and you've overreached. The public turn it down again. And so you had two processes of constitution making that then failed. And now they're back to resolving amendments to the old constitution. So sometimes these major efforts to actually produce new constitutions don't necessarily work, even in their process, which is the sad story of the Chilean process. Or they work, but the balan the power is so on one side that in fact uh by the time it gets adopted, the people who are left in charge aren't particularly interested to follow it.

SPEAKER_01You know, whether you talk about Iraq or these other examples where enormous energy gets put into creating a process, making it look but it doesn't draw in enough of the society for it to hold. So the big question is the sustainability of these processes.

SPEAKER_02And what you're describing is this real challenge of balancing these different groups, different stakeholders, different needs and desires for what people want to see in this constitution. And it's dependent upon, again, the country, the group of people, uh, you know, the history. And can you speak a little bit more about those primary stakeholders involved in the process?

SPEAKER_02So as you noted earlier, you know, it's not just James Madison going creating this constitution. It's a group of people. It's these delegates at the convention. But it also requires the states to ratify it. And even still, so there's some Democratic say-so in this process, but there's a lot of people left out, obviously, um African Americans, uh, immigrants to the country, women. So how do we, is there a way to identify who really needs to be involved in the process and how we can make that a successful process?

SPEAKER_01I mean, I think it's increasing um increasingly understood and clear today in the world that you need to have as much involvement as possible. Right? We we can't imagine today a constitution-making process that by definition leaves out women, for instance, right? That wouldn't be something which would gain legitimacy. Because legitimacy is interesting, right? Because it's both the legitimacy domestically with the people who are now going to live under that constitution, and it's legitimacy in the world as a whole. Uh so you know, there's been some wonderful writing about the fact that constitu one one thing constitutions make makers do is they immediately, uh, when they produce a new constitution, is they uh present it to the world.

SPEAKER_01Not just domestically. They sell it to the world. This is who we are, right? As a new people, as a new nation, or as a reformed nation. This is who we are, because no nation is an island unto itself. And they're all related to others. And so that constitution-making process represents a lot more than just making governance for one country. So we can't imagine leaving out whole sections of people. Uh that's no longer acceptable to the world. And the complexities of that become very real from place to place in in different kinds of conflicts.

SPEAKER_01Uh so I think that's so when one thinks of the problem really is how to incorporate people so that they feel they've had their say, that you also have the ability to resolve tensions and sometimes irreconcilable tensions. And one way I see that being done uh quite often uh in the drafting type of process is what I call um constructive ambiguity, where uh positions are adopted and uh uh you know even sections of a constitution are drafted in a way where those who have sometimes fundamentally different views of what should happen can both see the possibility of their view surviving in the outcome.

SPEAKER_01So it doesn't foreclose completely one alternative or the other. It leaves it a little vague. And you know, to be absolutely honest, you think of the US Constitution, it's all vague, right? It's written at a time when it's much earlier than the present. You often get this conversation which says, why doesn't why do other countries not just have a 17-page constitution like the United States? You know, this brilliant, short, clear constitution. I always look at it and go, that's very funny.

SPEAKER_01The the fact that other people now have books for constitution is a reason. The reason is they look at the United States and other places and they look at the history and they look at the case law and they know what's gonna happen. They they they can see what the alternatives might be. And so in their conversation, they want to kind of lock it down. They want to try and make it as clear as possible. Not that they ever can. They can just go another step further. And so they keep on running. And if you really want to understand the U.S. Constitution today, you have to look at those 17 pages in the context of 200 years of court decisions.

SPEAKER_01And so the U.S. Constitution is a lot longer than 17 pages in reality, right? As opposed to, oh, well, there's just these 17 pages.

SPEAKER_02And as we kind of wrap up our conversation today, it strikes me that you know you reference that the United States has a relatively short constitution in comparison with other countries. But that's because, as you said, the courts are interpreting what is written in that constitution and making decisions about what is constitutional and what is not. And there's a lot of institutions and people kind of involved in that process. And can you tell us a bit more about how public participation in democracy and in this process kind of weighs in into shaping what democracy looks like in our current context?

SPEAKER_01That's a very good question, because there's so many levels at which that operates, right? You have the level at which that operates where uh any interpreter of the constitution, acknowledging that it's a democratic system, is also thinking about how their own interpretation is going to be picked up by the society as a whole. Are people going to object to it? What is the impact of the votes that are going to follow because of a particular decision? So there's that part. And there's also the other part where people's demands for particular understanding or or even an amendment or whatever are going to become very much part.

SPEAKER_01So when we talk about participation, it's not always am I at the table helping to discuss or write or formulate. It's also how people in the streets are beginning to understand it. Are they demonstrating, are they pushing in other ways for either a particular understanding of a constitution or for a change in a constitution? So you get that that participation depends so much across a whole wider level. And now with social media and all the rest of it, it takes seconds before everybody has a version of what they believe is correct and not correct.

SPEAKER_01Uh I mean, I think the sad part of that is with disinformation and that uh we have versions of the constitution out there today, both in the US and around the world, which are very strange, to be honest, right? I mean, we now can all have our own version and believe that it is the only version. And that's that's a difficult part of this process today. That's a part that can often lead to quite intense conflict.

SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell And I think that underscores the importance of people being knowledgeable about their constitution, not just what's written in the document, although that's important, but how it's been interpreted and applied over time. And your point about people in the streets being active, they have agency. And I find that very empowering, particularly when sometimes we feel like we don't have a voice or it's not going to matter what I do or what I think. And I think we're we're wrong in that assumption. We actually have a lot more power than we assume.

SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell I think that's right. I think that the, you know, and particularly as long as we have a demo democracy, as long as people have the ability to express themselves democratically, I'm less concerned that somehow the courts rule everything, uh, because the pressures that can come from below can change understandings pretty quickly. And over time, people change at every level, not just institutionally in terms of who's in particular institutions, but also just in terms of the pressures that society brings upon them. And so, yes, I think that it's it's key that people are participants in this process, that people and I think civics become very important in this because understanding it's not just saying what do these words mean in the Constitution, but how's the system work?

SPEAKER_01How does a system of governance work? And, you know, I think we're doing a poor job here, but all around the world in making sure that people understand the governance systems from fairly young, from school on, understanding how they work, because then they get a deeper understanding of what's possible and not possible. And in in my formulation, at least, they develop their own constitutional imagination of what is what this might mean and what kind of form of governance they would like to live under. And that's as deeply democratic, I think, as you can get.

SPEAKER_02Democracy requires participation. Well, I want to thank you, Professor Heinz Klug, for being with us here in our studio and talking to us about the constitution-making process and just kind of going through all these nuances that we might not think about, but there's a real complexity to this process, and it kind of inspires me to understand more, not just about the words in our constitution, but what they mean to me.

SPEAKER_01Well, thank you very much. I really enjoy coming to Montpelier and working with the Young African Leaders Initiative, but it's fabulous. Thank you.

SPEAKER_02And thank you to all our listeners for joining us for this special episode. The first in a series of three. I hope you'll share the show with family and friends. We'll be back in two weeks with the second installment of this mini series as we continue to consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode