When Congress can't pass laws, is the problem in the Constitution - or in the rules that govern how legislators actually do their work? In this episode, Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey welcomes back Dr. Lauren Bell to discuss her new book, Transatlantic Majoritarianism: How Murder, Migration and Modernity Transformed 19th Century Legislatures. Dr. Bell reveals how 19th-century lawmakers in both the United States and Britain wrestled with a fundamental democratic dilemma: how to allow majority rule without descending into chaos or obstruction. From the "vanishing quorum" that paralyzed the House of Representatives to Irish members weaponizing parliamentary procedure in the House of Commons, Bell traces the parallel crises that forced both nations to rethink legislative power. This episode is supported in part by the Virginia Law Foundation.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
SPEAKER_00Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, with James Madison's Montpelier. When the U.S. Constitution was written in 1787, its architects were deeply concerned with how a legislature should function in a democracy. How to allow majority rule without letting it collapse into chaos, obstruction, or tyranny of faction. Those questions did not end with ratification. In the 1800s, as politics became more democratic and parties more competitive, legislatures on both sides of the Atlantic faced a shared problem, how to govern effectively in the face of growing obstruction and conflict.
SPEAKER_02Much of this problem had to do with legislative procedures, meaning the rules and practices that guide how this branch of government does its work of creating and passing laws. This problem, how to balance democratic participation with effective governance, did not evolve in isolation. In fact, it became a transatlantic conversation with lawmakers in the United States and Britain watching one another closely as they struggled with the same procedural dilemmas.
SPEAKER_02And crucially, they often responded not by rewriting constitutions, but by reshaping the rules that structured debate, power, and majority control. And that insight feels especially timely that democratic systems often adapt through procedure rather than through formal constitutional overhaul. And lucky for us, one of our recurring guest speakers, Dr. Lauren Bell, has just published a book that takes this question head on.
SPEAKER_02Her new book is called Transatlantic Majoritarianism: How Murder, Migration, and Modernity Transformed Nineteenth Century Legislatures. Dr. Bell, as many of you will remember, is the inaugural James L. Miller Professor of Political Science at Randolph Macon College in Virginia. And she currently serves as the college's Associate Provost and Dean of Academic Affairs. She is a former American Political Science Association Congressional Fellow on the United States Senate Committee on the Judiciary, and a former United States Supreme Court Fellow at the United States Sentencing Commission in Washington, D.C.
SPEAKER_02Lauren, welcome back to the show. Thanks, Katie. It is really nice to be back here. And I have to say, it's always wonderful to have you here because not only do you teach, you write scholarship, you research, but you have this practical experience as well. And it brings for a really dynamic conversation every time we're here in the studio.
SPEAKER_01Thanks again for having me. I do love being at Montpelier. I love having the opportunity to jump in and talk about the Constitution and particularly today, its evolution over time.
SPEAKER_02And your book. So I want to dive in because you know, Congress is something that's always on the national mind. We're always hearing about it, what's happening or not happening. But before we start, can you break down what is transatlantic majoritarianism in general and what does it mean in context to your book?
SPEAKER_01I don't know if transatlantic majoritarianism is a phrase that other people have used. I'm using it in this context because during the late 19th century, both the United States and Britain were engaged in a project within their national legislatures to figure out how majorities could govern more effectively. The main issue, as you mentioned in the introduction, is obstruction. And of course, obstruction typically takes place or is typically engaged in by small groups of members who don't feel as though the majority process is working for them.
SPEAKER_01But when that happens, that can really stifle the ability of majorities to actually govern within the country. And so what I'm looking at in transatlantic majoritarianism is this conversation that is taking place across the Atlantic about how to make it possible for clear majorities to make decisions in the national legislature.
SPEAKER_02And in our earlier conversations in the months leading up to this podcast, I was really excited by the topic of this because obviously we focus very much on Madison and the time period of the Constitution and when it was drafted and the decades after. But we don't as often focus on the long-term ramifications of a century later what's happening. So as we think about the topics you cover in your book, you really focus on the late 19th century or the late 1800s.
SPEAKER_02Before we get to that point, I want to rewind the clock. What's happening from that period when the Constitution is drafted in 1787 up until the late 1800s? How's Congress working? Is it? Is it not? What's the landscape look like?
SPEAKER_01Sure. Well, that's a really great question. And it's super important to understand that history in order to understand why what's happening in the late 19th century is so different. So, of course, when the framers drafted the Constitution, they intended Congress to be the sort of paramount institution, right? Article one, Congress comes first. And we know that that was their intention by looking back actually at Madison's notes on the Constitutional Convention. But one of the things that they did in the Constitution, and of course this makes sense, was they left it to the individual chambers of Congress to decide what their rules would look like, right?
SPEAKER_01So the Constitution makes each house within Congress responsible for setting its own rules. And of course, you know, in 1789, as the first Congress begins meeting, that's one of the first things they have to do is decide what rules do they want to use. Now, this is happening in both the House and the Senate, but I'll try to focus on the House because that's what my book is looking at. You know, in the House, you have sort of this quick adoption of a relatively limited number of rules. These are rules that the early members of Congress were familiar with from their own state legislatures or even from their study and participation back in colonial legislatures and their understanding of how parliament worked.
SPEAKER_01But as Congress grew, as we added new states, we needed more and more rules. And as it turns out, what the House was not great at was revising its old rules to accommodate new situations. What it would do instead was just add rules to the rule book. And so over time, and when I say over time at this point, I mean really by the early part of the 19th century, 1825, 1830, you have this set of rules in the House that is just sort of a hodgepodge of old and new.
SPEAKER_01So you've got rules that are in conflict or in tension with each other. And so there's a former member of Congress who writes a history of house rules named Dialva Stanwood Alexander. He publishes that in 1916. And he says, you know, if you look back at the rules during the early part of the 19th century, what you see is that they were more like guidelines. And kind of all the time on a case-by-case basis, Congress had to figure out what was it actually trying to accomplish. As we move toward the middle part of the 19th century, obstruction begins to plague the House.
SPEAKER_01This is a common theme, right? And in 1841, the House responds by adopting something called the one hour rule, which says that members of the House are limited to speaking only for one hour on any particular subject. And so at that point, if we think about obstruction, we often think about filibustering, right? Talking something to death. At that point, that becomes impossible because you only have an hour, and that rule becomes very clear. So, of course, members begin looking for other ways in which they can obstruct or make their feelings known.
SPEAKER_01And so by the time you get to, let's say, the 1870s, you have a real problem in the house with something called the vanishing quorum. And the vanishing quorum is really important to this story because what the house rules said about a quorum at that time was that to be counted as present for the purposes of a quorum. And of course, for any listener that isn't familiar with how that would operate, a quorum is the necessary minimum number of members for business to be allowed to proceed.
SPEAKER_01And what the House rules said was that in order to be counted as part of that quorum, you had to be both present and voting. So imagine you are the leader of the House of Representatives and you need to call for a vote and you look out and you see that the room is full, and yet, as the clerk calls the roll, nobody answers. So you could have a room full of members who simply refuse to answer, and therefore you would have no quorum. And so by the time we're getting to the 1870s, this is starting to be a huge issue for the House of Representatives.
SPEAKER_01And that becomes kind of the baseline precursor to understanding the more significant rules changes that are going to happen really beginning in the 1880s, but sort of culminating in 1890, when Speaker of the House, Thomas Brackett Reed, sort of unilaterally says, enough is enough. And from now on, if I can see you present in the chamber, I'm counting you as part of this quorum. So that's like the super quick 80 years of significant procedural history to help frame the conversation about what happens in the last part of the 19th century.
SPEAKER_02You capture so much in your book and in this conversation too. And your response makes me think of how each generation after Madison and the founders, it is really important for them to be shaping what this process, the structure that Madison and others laid out, how that's actually working in practice. And as you noted, there's more states coming into the union, there's more rules on how Congress can operate. It gets very complicated.
SPEAKER_02And this does result in obstruction in Congress, in the House of Representatives. And it sounds like that's really preventing, obviously, important legislation from passing. What are we seeing in the British House of Commons at this period? Is there a parallel phenomenon happening overseas, or are those two kind of comparable phenomenon?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so so what's happening in Britain is different, but not totally unrelated. I mean, one thing to keep in mind, right, is we're talking about the British Parliament. The word Parliament itself comes from the root word means to speak. In the British Parliament, speech and debate was considered paramount. The goal was that people should be able to talk as much or to say as much as they wanted to and to participate as much as possible. But also by the middle part of the 19th century, it becomes really clear that the size of the parliament is growing.
SPEAKER_01Members are speaking longer and more often than they did before. And so again, at mid-century in Britain, you start to have concern being expressed by leadership about how can we make the Commons function more fully. But a key thing that happens is that in 1875, you have an influx of some what we might call firebrand Irish members of parliament.
SPEAKER_01And I cover this in the book, it's extensive, but the history of the Irish addition to the British Empire is a pretty checkered one. And by the time you get to 1875, of course, you've had the major potato famine in the late 1840s, but you've also had subsequent decades of starvation and economic depression, mass emigration from Ireland to the United States. And these Irish members of parliament who enter in the early part of the 1870s really want the parliament to take the plight of the country seriously.
SPEAKER_01But of course, if we think about who the other members of parliament were, many of them were actually landowners who were oppressing the Irish tenant farmers. And so you have this weird juxtaposition of elected members with the same rights and privileges of membership in the parliament, but the Irish are representing the tenant farmers, and others, the British members, are often representing the landowners. And so they're in tension with each other. The Irish members begin to obstruct. And when I say obstruct, I mean they are merciless. So they are among the first legislators to really fundamentally get that you can use the rules of a legislature against it if you're careful and thoughtful.
SPEAKER_01And so at the time, the Commons had a rule known as the half past 12 rule that said that if there were any objections to pending business on the calendar, that that legislation could not be brought up after 12:30 in the morning. As background, they used to meet into the wee hours of the morning all the time. And so the Irish members began objecting to everything. It was a turnabout because the British members had been objecting to Irish bills. So the Irish sort of ratchet that up. And eventually the obstructive behavior becomes so challenging that the Commons is really at a standstill.
SPEAKER_01There are clear majorities who want to be able to take action, and yet the Irish, day after day after day, are simply holding the floor and expressing grievances, and they are unwilling to relinquish that power. And so again, you see obstruction really grinding things to a halt in the Commons. And this is again happening roughly simultaneously. So in the Commons, it's the Irish obstructionists, in the House of Representatives, it's the Vanishing Quorum.
SPEAKER_01But both chambers are dealing with obstruction and widespread, what we might call destructive obstruction at the same time.
SPEAKER_02When I read that chapter in your book, I couldn't put it down because it was so interesting how this group that really was marginalized and oppressed and became part of the British Empire and government. And then they're using the procedures within the House of Commons to challenge or have their voices heard after not having a stake in it for so long. It was fascinating to read how this is playing out overseas. When we turn to look at how obstruction is happening in the United States, particularly in the late 1800s, you mentioned earlier it gets to a point where it's a huge problem.
SPEAKER_02And it's like, okay, we have to figure out how we move forward. What's the catalyst for that moment and what changes happen?
SPEAKER_01Sure. So if we're thinking about the House of Representatives, I can give you the catalyst, but I have to give you the backstory a little bit. So I mentioned the 1870s in the UK. Ultimately, the person who goes on to lead the home rule movement and the obstructionist movement in the UK is a man named Charles Stuart Parnell. Parnell gets elected in 1875. That is roughly coincident with the election of Thomas Brackett Reed to the House of Representatives.
SPEAKER_01Reed is a Republican member elected from Maine. He starts his congressional career just like every member starts their congressional career, right? Backbencher, sort of loyal foot soldier of the party. But eventually he finds his way onto the very powerful and growing in power, House Rules Committee. It becomes more powerful in part because of the actions that Reed takes as a member. But Reed finds his way onto the Rules Committee. And it's the Rules Committee that is responsible for trying to manage this mess, as I mentioned, of House rules and to also help organize the flow of debate on legislation in the House.
SPEAKER_01And so by 1880, the House Rules Committee is proposing some changes to the rules of the House to try to streamline these procedures, to try to correct for some of the deficiencies that we've already talked about. And from Reed's vantage point on the rules committee, he and other members start pushing for rules that will be more supportive of majorities. Now we typically think today of partisan majorities, and there was an element of that, but parties at that time were still developing.
SPEAKER_01There were partisan majorities, but this was also about majorities more broadly defined, right? Like if there's a majority of members in the House who wants to do something, from Reed's perspective, that majority should be able to do it. And as he's looking at the rules in the 1880s, he's seeing that that's actually not possible because minority rights and this vanishing quorum were actually making it impossible in many instances, particularly when majorities were narrow, for the majority to be able to act.
SPEAKER_01And so throughout the 1880s, you get the House Rules Committee sort of increasingly pushing the House toward greater majoritarianism generally. But the catalyst really for substantive change comes in 1890 when Reed, who has been elected speaker, simply declares that the vanishing quorum is not a thing, right? That if members are present in the chamber, they will be counted for the purposes of determining that a quorum exists.
SPEAKER_01And this was like a bomb one-off in the chamber. If you read the congressional records surrounding this, it's days of chaos. And you have members saying, you know, how dare the speaker declare me to be present in voting? And he says, I'm not declaring you to be voting, I'm declaring you to be present. Does the gentleman deny it? Right. I mean, they're engaging in a conversation on the floor. And Reed is saying, it is absurd that our rules do not require that you be counted as present when you are clearly present.
SPEAKER_01And if I'm being fair to members, they of course wanted assurances that the speaker wouldn't see members who weren't there, right? Like if if you are tracking a quorum based on voting, you know for sure that somebody is there. Um and so they were accusing him of, you know, you'll be able to declare that there's a quorum, even if one doesn't exist. But ultimately, Reed refuses to back down. And simply every time there is a move to take a vote, he directs the clerk to count any member as present who is physically in the room.
SPEAKER_01And so he eliminates the vanishing quorum. And having done that, he has taken away the primary means of obstruction at that moment. And he then passes a sweeping set of rules through the chamber that actually promote the rights of majorities and really diminish the rights of minorities within the chamber.
SPEAKER_02What occurs as a result? What's the big takeaway from that big shift?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so on the legislative side, absolutely, it becomes easier to pass legislation. Minorities lose the ability to sit there and not vote and deny that a quorum is present. So it becomes easier to transact legislative business. That's sort of the instantaneous effect of that. The longer term effect is probably at the core of the partisanship and majoritarianism that we see today in the House, right?
SPEAKER_01So if you look at the House of Representatives, where literally the majority party controls absolutely everything, we can compare that, for example, with the Senate, where with the Senate filibuster, at least on legislation, right, you know you're going to need 60 senators, and that rarely does one party have enough senators to reach that 60 vote threshold. But in the House, the majority party has total and complete control over what happens, at least procedurally and in terms of what legislation they want to bring forward and how what those specific rules of debate will be on those bills.
SPEAKER_01And so in the longer term, the Reed rules move us toward the system that we have today, full-fledged majoritarianism in the House of Representatives. This is seismic, right? And the scholars who've written about Reed's rules changes note that this is really the foundation of legislative politics, to be sure, but by extension, really all of our politics today.
SPEAKER_02Lauren, you raise a Interesting question too. Your book, you mentioned that the House of Representatives and the Senate both make up Congress, but they're designed differently in the Constitution and they evolve differently and they have different procedures. How do those differences show up in how each chamber conducts its business?
SPEAKER_01Sure. I actually talk about this in chapter seven in the book because in both the United States and Britain, the upper houses don't do anything at all that looks like what's happening in the lower houses. The House of Lords actually has opportunities to change their rules and they like affirmatively decide absolutely not, we're not interested. But in the United States and the Senate, of course, again, going back to the Constitution, the Senate gets to make its own rules of procedure. And so we know the House and Senate adopted different rules over time.
SPEAKER_01The Senate is smaller, so it actually has fewer rules and relies far more on norms of behavior. But then constitutionally, as you mentioned, if you think about why you would concentrate power in majorities or in leadership in a chamber, that makes sense in the House of Representatives. You have a large chamber, but your leadership is also coming up out of the House. The Constitution doesn't require that the Speaker of the House be an elected member of Congress, but it is always the case that the Speaker is an elected member of Congress.
SPEAKER_01And so that's important because it's members of Congress engaging in leadership of the chamber. In the Senate, if we think about the constitutional design, it's the vice president who is the head of the Senate. And while today we think of the vice president as sort of being the person who shows up to break a tie, if we go back to the 19th century, the vice president was the presiding officer. For the Senate to adopt rules changes that would concentrate power in the hands of its own presiding officer in the way that the House did, the Senate would be, in effect, giving up authority to a member of the executive branch.
SPEAKER_01And so when we think about principles of constitutional design and separation of powers, and also just thinking about fundamentally these rules changes in the House were about House majorities being able to get control over the legislative process. In the Senate, if you were to concentrate the responsibility for that in somebody who was part of the executive branch, that could potentially be harmful to senators' interests or to the interests of Congress. And so I think the Constitution really does form the basis of much of the reason that these rules changes were just sort of non-starters.
SPEAKER_01And of course, the other reason in both cases is that there are no electoral pressures at this time. The House of Lords serve by, you know, sort of functionally divine right or by virtue of birth and blood. And in the Senate, it's state legislatures who are selecting senators right up until 1914 and ratification of the 17th Amendment. So at the time, you have no electoral pressures on either of those chambers. And electoral pressures are one of the factors that I talk about in the book as also helping to move both the House of Representatives and the House of Commons toward majoritarian rule.
SPEAKER_02After writing this book, what strikes you about Madison's legacy in the 19th century? Did his ideas successfully guide the development of democratic institutions, or was what he and others created more of a starting point?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think this is a great question. Of course, Madison was interested in a strong legislature. He thought it was important that the branch closest to the people have most of the power. He was also, though, terrified of factions, including majority factions. So in some ways, you have attention there in terms of the things that he was very thoughtful about as he's developing his ideas for the Constitution and for Congress.
SPEAKER_01His idea of factions included majority factions. And so when I think about this move to majoritarianism, in many respects, what Reed did looks very much like tyranny of the majority in the ways that Madison was sort of fearful of it, right? Because suddenly minorities don't have the same degree of rights within the House of Representatives. On the other hand, when you read Reed's papers, and so I spent a lot of time in the archives at Bowdoin University, which have Thomas Brackett Reed's congressional papers, when you read his papers, you also see that Madison's desire for a strong legislature can't be realized without a set of rules in that chamber that allows ultimately for majorities to be able to take action.
SPEAKER_01And so to more directly answer your question, I think Madison, his ideas about Congress and his ideas in the Constitution ultimately are starting points. I suspect he knew they would be starting points, right? And that, you know, in that Article I says that the two houses are going to have to figure out their own rules. But what we see in what's happening throughout the 19th century in the House of Representatives is a struggle around which of Madison's ideas can actually be realized. Because if you want a strong legislature, you're going to have to make it possible for majorities to act and to act decisively and relatively rapidly.
SPEAKER_01But if you are afraid of faction and are concerned that you need a large representative body, you've ultimately pitted two fundamentally incompatible ideas against each other. So ultimately, I think when Reed changes these rules, or I should say, when he catalyzes these rules changes in 1890, it is an indication that in order to have a strong legislature, you have to subsume concern about faction.
SPEAKER_02This is really helpful to hear you say this because as I was reading the book and mulling it over, I came away with, you know, yes, there's some major issues with how congressional procedures are working before the late 1800s. But Reed, with these changes that he makes, perhaps very um necessary in the moment in order to make law. As we look back on it now, tyranny of the majority is that the result, you referenced this just now about these contradictory thoughts that Madison is espousing back 100 years before.
SPEAKER_02And alongside that thought, I'm thinking about how one of the important arguments I took away was that this is happening, these changes, they're procedural versus an actual change to the Constitution itself and the implications of that in how it really redefined Congress and how it operates.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I think you're exactly right. We typically think about the Constitution being brief and flexible in many respects, right? The idea that the country would grow, that the framers knew it would grow, that the issues would change, and that they were thoughtful about why we would have a republic rather than a democracy and all of these things that they spent so much time at the convention thinking about, and that Madison spent so much time mulling over and considering, you know, we, for better or worse, aren't changing the constitution and aren't adapting kind of broadly to get different outcomes.
SPEAKER_01You're exactly right. We are leaving it to the two chambers of Congress to adapt their own rules. And then we are dealing with the consequences. And so one that's much more modern, right, would be something like in 2013, when the Senate eliminated the possibility of filibustering on judicial nominations. And that's something we could point to and say that's had a real clear impact on who sits on the federal bench and how rapidly those nominees are confirmed and how effectively presidents are able to get their preferred candidates onto the bench.
SPEAKER_01One could argue that that has functionally reshaped Article II, Section II, which is the appointment process in the Constitution. And yet, Article II, Section II remains intact. We have not amended that document. It's harder, I think, to point to a specific example of procedural change as fundamentally reshaping Article I simply because Article I anticipated that Congress would change its procedures or make its own procedures as needed.
SPEAKER_01But I think you're exactly right that when procedures change, there can be significant consequences for the nature of legislation, for those legislative outputs, even for other aspects of governance in the United States. And I think a lot of people would prefer not to think about procedure. It's arcane. Some would say it's boring. But how Congress is using procedures internally to shape lawmaking has incredibly important consequences for all of us.
SPEAKER_02I love that you said this because I have a lot of folks that will be interested in the Constitution and cite the article in the section. And it is so important to read the Constitution and understand what it's saying and the amendments. But there's also a lot of interpretation that's happened in the centuries since through these alterations to legislative procedures, through how the Supreme Court is interpreting certain cases and what that means for how the Constitution is applied.
SPEAKER_02So there is so much to unpack in the centuries after the Constitution was ratified. And as I wrap up this conversation as much as I don't want to, in this moment, there's a lot of question about is the Constitution working for us today? Is it functional? And first of all, who is us? You know, that is a very broad question. And if it's not, what needs to happen? And again, I think it's not simply about a change to the constitution itself, but understanding broadly how it's being implemented in everyday life.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I think to that question, right, is the Constitution working for us? To be clear, I think that's a whole separate podcast. Um but uh what I would say is it does depend on how you define us. What is interesting to me is that there are a lot of people in the United States, many of whom, but not all, come from historically marginalized groups who would say the Constitution has never fully worked for them.
SPEAKER_01And that what has been interesting to me is to see that as we are watching the Constitution be pushed and pulled in some different ways than what we're used to, the voices saying, hey, maybe this doesn't work are growing. But I want to be mindful that the Constitution has never worked for everybody at the same level. And so do we need it to change? I suppose that will depend on who you ask.
SPEAKER_01I think what I would say is it's important to recognize that we can change the constitution, and we should, if collectively we decide that it needs to be changed. But as I think my book points out, and as we've talked about, there are other ways in which change can happen. Congress could reassert itself in the national policy-making arena. Congress could change its own procedures again. There are some who say that the legislative filibuster in the Senate should be eliminated again, something we would need an entire other podcast to unpack.
SPEAKER_01But there are ways in which real change could come from something other than constitutional amendment. I just think as we think about what that means, we also need to be honest with ourselves that our constitution has not universally been applied to everybody always in the same way.
SPEAKER_02Well, Lauren, I want to thank you so much for coming all the way to Montpelier today to have this conversation with us. And again, this book is so important, I think, in order to understand how government, not just how it's structured, because that's something you've talked about on previous episodes, but really how it's functioning, how it's working, and what that means for the people in the United States today and historically. So thank you so much for writing the book and for joining me here today. Thank you again for having me.
SPEAKER_01It's always great to be here.
SPEAKER_02And I want to thank our listeners today. We appreciate you tuning in. And please share the show with family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...