Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey welcomes Dr. Casey Burgat back to James Madison's Montpelier to discuss his new book, "We Hold These Truths: How to Spot the Myths That Are Holding America Back."
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
SPEAKER_00Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey with James Madison's Montpelier. Understanding the ins and outs of our system of government can be daunting, especially when myths and misconceptions shape much of the public discourse. And I suspect that many of us, myself included, hold assumptions about how democracy works. Some true and some far from it. In this episode, we're taking a deep look at some of the most persistent and damaging falsehoods about American politics.
SPEAKER_01We'll explore what we need to understand in order to engage more effectively in our political system. And joining us once again in our studio here at Montpelier is Dr. Casey Burgett, director of the Legislative Affairs Program at George Washington University. A leading expert on Congress and Governance. Dr. Birgitt is the host of the podcast Mastering the Room. And his newly released book, We Hold These Truths, How to Spot the Mists That Are Holding America Back, serves as the crux of today's conversation.
SPEAKER_01So, Casey, welcome back to the studio. It's great to have you here.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. I love the grounds. I mean, uh anniversary day here today. I'm excited to be here. Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_01Well, as we start to think about our political system, I think it's safe to say that it's kind of weighed down by these misleading narratives about how government works. Misinformation and half-truths shape a lot of public perceptions. So how do we think through what these misconceptions are? And I especially want to tap into your expertise. You know, you have been a congressional staffer, like you've seen this in action.
SPEAKER_01Now you're a professor. But what is your experience on the front lines?
SPEAKER_02It's a good opening question. It's hard because when we say government or how it's supposed to work, my first instinct is to say, all right, what are we talking about here? Are we talking about the president? Are we talking about Congress? Are we talking about the budget? Like something very specific because each and every one of those have the way it's supposed to work and then the way it actually works. And so I have found trying to explain to bridge that gap of what we learned as seventh graders about our system genius system of checks and balances, and then how the actors who are playing this system right now see the problems and then develop the processes to come through with it.
SPEAKER_02So bridging that gap, especially to the layman out there who is so busy with their mortgage payments and soccer games and just trying to turn on the news and not yell at it, trying to make it understandable, not only so they are able to see what is happening for good or for ill, but to take better part and better action within it. Because I think that everyone understands that to have the democracy we have, to have the republic that we have, that necessarily requires all of us to be active and engaged citizens. You can't have one without the other. But too much and too recently, people are taking a step back because they don't feel like they have a stake in it, that it is DC, far-off place that we can't have access to, that we can't make an impact on their decisions.
SPEAKER_02But you can and we should, and we should get back to those underlying assumptions about how government is supposed to work and how it does, and then trying to make those two things closer and closer together.
SPEAKER_01So, what is it that inspired this book?
SPEAKER_02Too long of having the same exact conversations more and more. And so stemming from the first answer is that when anyone finds out that I'm in politics or I have a certain access to people or consult on some things, they are so quick to either get mad at me and say, Hey, why are they choosing to do it this way? And then we start explaining, or they're saying, like, man, I wish they could just, right? And then it is always some silver bullet solution that they have convinced themselves we are so able to fix this if we just do something very, very specific.
SPEAKER_02And so I found for years and years trying to walk people back from those underlying assumptions and say it's just not that simple, or this is what a member of Congress sees, or this is what the president sees. And so actually, all of the things that are making you so upset are frustratingly rational on their part. So again, it is just having one by one these myths over and over and talking with my friends, talking with people who do the jobs, talking with other experts in the field of just like, yeah, I wish America knew this, because then we could finally move on to the things that actually need to be debated.
SPEAKER_02All of the problems, and we have huge ones about specific policy. Where we really struggle is getting to the point where we're on common ground about what system we're operating in, to then have the necessary drag out fights about what to do about Medicaid or climate change or gun control. But you'll recognize that we're often talking about process based on fundamentally flawed assumptions, and we'll never get to the other parts, which means those things are going to stay the way they are, well, as they have for the last couple of decades.
SPEAKER_01And Casey, that's one of the aspects of your book that I really appreciated. You got this group of scholars, practitioners together to author these various chapters. And you talk about in your introduction, we as the American people often think that there is this silver bullet, this kind of one suggestion or this one thing that can fix it all. But obviously it's more nuanced than that. And your book really speaks to that. How can we as the public maybe refrain from taking that, oh, well, if they just did this kind of approach when we're thinking about politics?
SPEAKER_02Number one, I mean, it's right there in the subtitle, which I didn't come up with, what how to spot the myths that are holding America Bath. And so there is like a gamification that if you can spot them, then you're less susceptible to fall for them. And so a big step is just knowing these things are out there, that when you see them in the wild, which you will because it's not on accident that they exist in the first place, that alarm bells start ringing in your head of like, ah, we are crossing over into simplicity land and it's actually going to do more harm than good. And we see this play out literally in our politics every single day, not only with conversations that people have about what to do, but the political actors themselves, they know that people want these simple fixes.
SPEAKER_02They promise them, and then ultimately we end up two years, four years, eight years down the line. I'm like, we're still getting these same exact promises. So to take a recent example, like you have a presidential campaign run so explicitly, on day one, I will. I will fix it. I will so fast, it will make your head spin. And that's not a partisan statement because presidents of both parties have been increasingly using executive orders and unilateral actions, even though they know better about the system and how it's supposed to work. But because they know people want to hear it, they want to believe it, and they're saying, yeah, go ahead.
SPEAKER_02If other people in the system aren't going to do their jobs, then go ahead and my president take care of it for us. And so it just makes us susceptible to a lot of things that we may like it in the short term. But when you do that, you're necessarily signing up for someone who you don't believe in, who wants to pursue policies that you fundamentally disagree with, taking those powers and using them even more. Because if we know anything about presidents, whatever the last guy did, the next guy's gonna go even further. And it just creates this whiplash effect about what does the United States believe in? Uh, what policies are we going to pursue?
SPEAKER_02Now, what funding, even though it was passed, is going to be available or legitimate in the next presidency. It just creates us that system. So a long-winded answer to your question of what can we do? Notice these things and then call them out when you see them. It doesn't even have to be, you don't have to go on social media and just start doom scrolling, but just see them and play out and then just be cognizant of if you're promised something simple. I mean, we think about this in in poly in finance or your your budgets or whatever, like if it's too good to be true, it probably is.
SPEAKER_02And that is definitely true in politics when you need a lot of friends to help you do anything.
SPEAKER_01You know, I have to admit, as I was reading through the chapters of the book, the titles are these myths that you've identified. I am guilty of. I am guilty of saying things like, oh, well, we just need congressional term limits, which is what your chapter is about. So can you tell us more about some of the myths that you cover in the book and how you got together with this group of people to author these chapters?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I mean, this is honestly the easiest part. What I thought was going to be harder of like, all right, well, how do we create a layout here where people can use this book as not only like hopefully an entertaining way to get through from cover to cover, but also like maybe put it away because this is you got to chew through this. Like, this is not supposed to be a John Grisham narrative here that keeps you entertained, right? Like this is supposed to make you a more active, engaged participant in our democracy. And as we always say, stuff ain't free, right? So you have to be able to put in the work to get the results you want. But honestly, these 13 miss, which is just such beautiful numerology for American history person, but 13 miss from the Constitution all the way through the media, where we're touching every branch of government, inside and outside of government, where the actual topics themselves, they came up pretty quickly.
SPEAKER_02Like that wasn't the hard part to decide what's in, what's out. That was just a really helpful list of things that I definitely wanted to get talked about. And then just by the course of the years and years of conversations, like when I just sat down on my notepad and just clicked through, it was like, man, there it is. That was really that was a surprise for me, which led to the decision about should I do this myself or should I go out and find people? And what were the pros and cons of doing this? For sales, it's worse when you have a lot of teammates for sure, but because then you're just splitting the pie, but that's fine. But if I want the most impact for people that are skeptical about people telling you the way it is, then I will need a broad cross-section of people, not only uh inside and outside of government.
SPEAKER_02It couldn't be only nerdy professors because that's a certain subset, but it had to be practitioners and it had to be a bipartisan set of practitioners. And so I went and found people that are either the known person in this field or they held the job themselves to be able to tell you from their firsthand perspective of like, yeah, we kind of knew this was a myth and we took advantage of it. Like, this is why, this is how we operationalize it to get more of what we want. And so those conversations were incredibly easy, which leads to the second biggest surprise of writing this. Every single person I asked said yes automatically, which is if you work in any sort of like cross-editing field, that does not happen.
SPEAKER_02You're usually getting down to the bottom of the barrel of people who have time. And this is a list of people who they're not lacking for things to do. And every single one of them, when I presented their what I wanted them to write about and told them why, they're like, absolutely, this makes me mad too. Like, I'm tired of having this talk. I want to put it all in a compendium like we did, and hopefully, hopefully, hopefully just be able to move the needle just one inch further so we can start again, having the right conversation. So again, it is a running list uh from the Constitution all the way through the branches of government.
SPEAKER_02And a lot of these put a burden on the person themselves, our participation, how we choose to engage in our politics, if at all. And so it's not an easy one where you just all of a sudden you get to the end, you get the playbook, and you're like, finally, we're almost at our utopia. It don't work like that. And anyone who's telling you that it can and should, they're just they're they're asking you to be complicit in whatever they want to do.
SPEAKER_01Why is it that these myths persist? Is it because they're the easy answer to how we fix everything? I mean, it seems like there is a shared understanding that there are things within our political system that we do need to address. But why these myths in particular?
SPEAKER_02It's a good question. And there's not even one answer for each of them. And again, it gets to the nuance, which is anytime you're explaining in politics, you're losing people, right? Like that's why bumper stickers and campaign slogans work so well. But often it is the the what you the devil is always in the details and what comes after the period, right? We should speak more in commas than we do in periods if we're trying to solve the big societal problems that we have. And so these myths persist. So most of them do because people genuinely believe them. And so when you're trying to tell people that they're thinking wrong, especially about politics, decades and decades of research will show you that these people, if you believe and are engaged, you're the least likely to be open to new information, right?
SPEAKER_02It's not the person that's sitting on the sideline. They're the ones that are walking in, like, all right, who has the best ideas? It is the people that literally commit their time and energy and resources and more and more their identities to what political party they support. Those are the ones that are least likely to update their beliefs. So they persist because we want them to. And to your point, like the simplicity often wins. Like, this is the answer. Here it is, there I have it. And if we could just get it, then everything would be rainbows and butterflies, but it's not. And then more and more, like politicians know they exist, parties know they exist, candidates know they exist, and they know what gets you fired up.
SPEAKER_02And they know what gets you fired up for them, and especially against the other side. They're the problem, they're the ones that are susceptible to liberal media, or uh they're the ones that are the ones caching the special interest groups, bribery checks, like all of these things that we know about the other side. My team's not susceptible to that. It's only them. So it's starting to be weaponized more and more, which means this book should have came out a long time ago. But there's never a better time like the present because all of them are getting more and more prescient, not only because we're more susceptible to them as politics gets crazier and crazier, but because campaigns and politicians and parties recognize them that this is actually a good way to make people mad to actually win.
SPEAKER_01And Casey, you authored a chapter on the myths surrounding congressional terms. So can you tell us what terms look like and what this myth is founded on? Why do we believe broadly that there should be term limits?
SPEAKER_02Right. So within the Constitution, there's very few qualifiers about what it takes to be a member of the House or the Senate. Basically, age and citizenship requirements. The terms are set for two years for the House, six years for the Senate. Outside of that, you can keep running and running and running. And so listeners are probably thinking, no wonder we have senators that are 804 years old. No wonder we have senators that are freezing at the mile. Like these are guys will just, once you get power, you try to stay in power. Like that is just the history of any political movement outside of maybe George Washington willingly giving up his power.
SPEAKER_02And so this is a really simple equation because A, Congress is incredibly unpopular. It is the least popular branch and it has been for decades and decades. And so the only way Congress can be unpopular is that the members must be really bad at their job, or they don't serve the national interest. Stop me if you said these things or thought these things before or heard these things before, that they're only there to keep and retain power, they're only there to feather their nest, they are disassociated from the people. They don't know what we want. They're just a ruling class. And so the only way to get them out of their seat to refresh the Congress with new ideas and more diversity, whatever your argument is, is to require by constitutional amendment the number of terms maximum that they can serve.
SPEAKER_02So instead of just saying rule until someone votes you out, you are by constitution after a certain period of time, eight years, 12 years is usually the most common examples for the House and Senate, respectively. You got to leave and we got to replace these things. Which sounds good in theory, right? Like Congress is dysfunctional, turn on the news, you ain't gonna get a good news story about Congress, right? It's just not gonna happen. So then the only way, and if they're not gonna willingly give up their seats to someone more dedicated to the public interest, then the only way we can make this more functional is to limit them because they won't limit themselves.
SPEAKER_02Sounds great. It is the most well-pulling thing in the history of polling that term limits are almost universally supported, including by members of Congress, until they reach their term limit deadline. And those are the ones that are calling for it, that ultimately decide for running for re-election. So that is why it's popular. Now we get to why it's not, because it sounds really good in theory. And I don't know how much time you have. This is why the chapter exists. But what really happens is whatever problem you're trying to solve, reducing polarization, making Congress more responsive to the federal interest, less dependent on special interest groups, less dependent on bureaucrats, less dependent on the presidency, if you're trying to increase representation within the House and Senate, all of those things will not be qualified or achieved by term limits.
SPEAKER_02And in fact, they're all going to get worse. And if you want to know why, just ask the follow-up. But they will. Research at the state level with foreign countries will just tell us to say nothing of. If you are new to your job, you don't know how to do your job, what do you do? You go find someone who does, right? If you're responsible for taking a vote and you say, all right, today we have to vote on healthcare subsidies, aid to Ukraine, all of a sudden this doge exists and we have a federal budget deadline at noon tomorrow. How do I do that when I was a plumber two years ago?
SPEAKER_02It's a really hard job. And to treat a member of Congress as just another role that people can play, and anyone at a random draw can serve in that is just a fundamental misreading of how government and process and policy work. And so when you are unsure of it, just like me at an auto mechanic, I have to take the auto mechanic's word for it. I have no idea. I can't call Boo, and that leaves me really vulnerable to what I know he knows more than me. And that's what happens with new members of Congress to not only long-serving members of Congress, but mostly to the presidency. That you're going to defer to the president.
SPEAKER_02If you support him, you're automatically going to reject him if you don't. And you just don't have this good back and forth, good faith legislating movement because you don't know the difference. And so it'll increase polarization for a lot of reasons that the book goes into. But anything that you're trying to solve with term limits, despite how good it sounds on paper, it will just actually make worse, which we don't need any more worse right now.
SPEAKER_01And I have heard that before from many people that, oh, these are just people that have been in the office for decades. There's no change, they're just out for themselves. How do we understand that in context to the truth? Because I think your chapter and a lot of the research you've done beyond that shows that that is not true. So how do we know that that's not true? And what do we do with that information?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think people would be surprised. What we're mislooking at or misinterpreting here is that we have a lot of high-profile examples of the problem when it is not representative of the entire population. So when I say member of Congress, you're probably thinking of Mitch McConnell or Schumer or Pelosi, right? Like these are the right tail experiences, the exception, not the rule. And so, really, if you're looking at a Congress, the majority of the House of Representatives turns over every eight years, just like what term limits proponents want. The senators serve about two terms, which is exactly what term limit proponents want.
SPEAKER_02On average, it is a function of us only looking at the exception of these people who are holding on for literally decades and decades, but these are the less than 1% of the types of members that we're looking at. And so couple that with the fact that the incumbency advantage right now that we used to assume, like the minute you get the job, you can hold it as long as you want because you have all of these institutional levers of keeping yourselves in power, whether it's increased fundraising or you can pass a bill or you can send home pork to the district and be popular. Those things are actually gone or mostly gone.
SPEAKER_02And in fact, being an incumbent right now is incredibly challenging. Like you don't want to be serving in Congress because your voters are odd fundamentally pissed at Congress, right? Like you have to overexplain and you're susceptible to a candidate or a challenger saying, This guy's gone Washington. This girl's gone Washington. He's part of the problem, he's part of the swamp. Send in someone new. And we've seen, again, these campaigns being run on these exact types of messages, which is disqualifying for a lot of these candidates. There are absolutely some advantages to being a member and not being a member, but they have uh been watered down to the point.
SPEAKER_02What you're really frustrated at, I tell my students all the time, solve the problem you're trying to solve. If you're frustrated at a lack of competitive elections, to solve it by term limits is just overturning the card table and then trying to rebuild it. When you can solve or have very specific solutions to what you're really frustrated at, which is a lack of competitive elections, where you can mess with the primary process, when you can get involved, maybe it doesn't necessarily have to be a winner-take-all system in your state where you can have proportional. There's other options to these things where you'll get a lot of the same turnover without having the huge draconian negative consequences that come in with just saying, hey, you're old, get out of here.
SPEAKER_02Because at that point, you're kicking out all of the young, popular, effective members of Congress that are just there, the ones you're not thinking about. If you don't know your members of Congress's name, that's ironically a good sign because they're actually doing the work. The ones that are showing up every single night on the same cable news channels, those are the ones with a different incentive structure that are, uh, let's just say not spending the hours writing policy to make America a little more effective or functional on a lot of different fronts.
SPEAKER_01And this goes back to the point you were making earlier about, you know, there's a lot of complexity to these problems in our system. And we're thinking when we talk about these myths, of solutions that aren't really solutions at all. And we're almost being distracted from, as you were saying, what's really happening. How do we as the public not just recognize these myths, but really kind of pay attention and be engaged with what's happening so that we can be more aware of these myths?
SPEAKER_02The billion dollar question. This is exactly what we should be talking about. And you say distracted. That's that's exactly right. But it gets worse than that because you get distracted and then you start looking at the one thing that you want to get done that will not get done because for a lot of the reasons that we're talking about. And then what do you do? You get mad, and then when you get mad, you disengage. And so it's just this dysfunctional doom loop of want this, don't get it, get pissed, sit out. And it just reduces the number of people who are willing to roll up their sleeves, do the coalition building, do politics.
SPEAKER_02It reduces the people that have this long-term view. And that's a really bad marker of citizen engagement and citizen change because it does take years and years, frustrating long time to get these big wholesale changes that we all want or at least want to have a chance at. So when you are getting information from your cable news channel or your social media, wherever you get your news, just know what messages are being portrayed to you.
SPEAKER_02And again, when simplicity is the rule of the land, just recognize that it ain't that. Whoever is trafficking in simplicity is trying to take advantage of your want for simplicity. And then after that, it is get involved. Get involved. Don't take a step back, take a step forward and get involved. And I will say this as someone who basically only does federal politics. Ignore federal politics. Ignore it. DC is this big shiny hill. There's a lot of incentives for why the media is there. I mean, cable news channels are some of the most popular because they rile us up the same way that wrestling does or sports do, because there's a lot of overlap between them now.
SPEAKER_02But get involved locally. Show up to your city council meeting, show up to your school board. If for no other reason that your impact will be infinitely higher than you being one of 30,000 calls to a member of Congress, who it's not a member of Congress, by the way, it's some poor 18-year-old that is an intern there for a semester just getting yelled at for hour after hour after hour. And what they do when you call them is they just chat tally, pro or con, and then they create a list and hand it to the member. That is not a way of impacting much of that member's decision-making process.
SPEAKER_02Go to the levels of government that have the most impact on your day-to-day life: your roads, your bridges, your education, like the one city councils, local government, and even state legislatures where your access to them is going to be tenfold what it is to members of Congress. And you can actually get things done when it's not in the media spotlight of a federal politics. So get involved. That doesn't mean showing up every single day, but you know, just be involved in your local community building organizing. Like this is a perfect example. Like you open up Mount Pelier on an anniversary, show up, introduce yourself, have a civic conversation with someone who you don't even have to judge.
SPEAKER_02Are you a D or an R? Are we on the same team? Are we not? Show up for your people and show up where it actually makes a difference. And right now, given that it has functioned in DC, I would say 10 times out of 10, go local.
SPEAKER_01And Casey, you're referring to this date, March 16th, which is Madison's 274th birthday. He was born March 16th, 1751, which is why part of the reason you're here with us today to celebrate that. And as we think about this historic day, as we wrap up this conversation, what do you hope people will take away from your book and from places like Montpelier?
SPEAKER_02Just that there is this fabric, right? Like I've I'm fascinated with history. I have been for my whole life of just like there are some common threads between generations, between people, that there is this something unique about America, something unique about Americans, where at various points in our history, like we have come together and found ourselves like just unrobing our partisan identities for something greater, right? And usually sometimes that's because of a historic event or a historic person like James Madison, George Washington.
SPEAKER_02Someone somewhere has just propelled us to something better, something higher. And I don't think we're done with that yet. And the fact is, like, even if we are, we ain't going down without a fight, or I'm not, at least. I like we need people to show up and just start recognizing their bias and how they're seeing the world and start seeing the humanity in other people again, where you don't have to know who did you vote for and should I take your opinion seriously? Like it just has to be a more humanistic type of seeing each other and seeing our politics because we have incredibly difficult challenges ahead of us.
SPEAKER_02We do. But we're not even talking about those. We're talking about funding deadlines, like something that it was just taken for granted and in terms of should we keep the government open or not? Those are the ones dominating our news cycle. We have incredible challenges domestically, internationally. Things are not getting easier and they're not slowing down. And I don't know if we can stem the tide of a lot of the things that are challenging us, but I just know to have a chance at doing this again, we must. And so my hope with this book is like at least some segment of the population is ready to just challenge their underlying assumptions.
SPEAKER_02Just challenge them. Like, I ain't, I'm not happy with what we're getting. Obviously, something's got to change. What is my part in this? And I don't want to be a part of the downward spiral. I don't want to be a part of the reason that America looks back in the history books and I'm like, man, they had a shot at it. The way we look at the Romans, like they fall. That's it. Like the history doesn't have to be that way. It's not written in the stars that way all the time. But it does rely on all of us. Like there's a trade-off in having all of the freedoms that we have. The trade-off is that you have to be engaged in them.
SPEAKER_02They don't just exist because they exist. And Franklin told us the minute the Constitution was debated and signed, right? Like, what do we have, sir? A republic if you can keep it. And that if you can keep it is just the fundamental principle. The trade-off of having all of what we have and what we take for granted is you gotta keep it. It takes all of us to do it.
SPEAKER_01Democracy requires participation. It's not a passive system. And I think this book, We Hold These Truths, How to Spot the Myths That Are Holding America Back, is really important. It's really a key part of understanding the ways we do get distracted and making sure that we are paying attention, that we're aware. And like you were saying, I love the idea of we should be engaged at the local level, at the state level. We hear a lot of rhetoric about what's happening at the federal level, but there's so many opportunities for people to get involved.
SPEAKER_01So thank you so much for writing this book, for bringing these scholars together to do it, and for joining us here at Montpelier for Madison's birthday.
SPEAKER_02Amen. You all are my people anytime. I love it. Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_01And thank you to all of our listeners. I hope you'll subscribe and share the show with your family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...