Delve into the heart of the impeachment process in the U.S. Constitution with Professor Michael J. Gerhardt, a distinguished professor of jurisprudence at the University of North Carolina Law School. Explore the historical origins, the framers' intentions, and the complexities of holding high-ranking officials accountable. With insights into recent events and the evolving role of political parties, this episode offers a thought-provoking examination of democracy's safeguard.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crockett and featured in interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. Impeachment has become a topic of frequent media coverage and political debate in recent years. Esconced in the U.S. Constitution by the framers, the impeachment process can serve as a mechanism for holding high-ranking government officials accountable for their actions. But what exactly does this process entail?
SPEAKER_02What is an impeachable offense? And why does civil discourse on this important democratic safeguard seem to elicit so much controversy? Joining us to answer these questions is Professor Michael J. Gerhardt, the Burton Craig Distinguished Professor of Jurisprudence at the University of North Carolina Law School. He is the author of eight books, including the newly released The Law of Presidential Impeachment: A Guide for the Engaged Citizen. Professor Gerhardt's extensive public service has included his testifying more than 20 times before Congress.
SPEAKER_02He is one of only two legal scholars to testify in three different presidential impeachment hearings. He has served as an impeachment expert for CNN and an expert commentator for CNN, Fox, and MSNBC. I can't think of anyone more qualified to speak on this topic. And it's a real honor to have you here, Professor Gerhardt.
SPEAKER_00Well, thank you. I really appreciate being here.
SPEAKER_02So as we start our conversation today, what exactly is impeachment? And can you tell us more about its historical origins?
SPEAKER_00Sure. Impeachment is a term that may refer to two things. It first might refer to the sole power that the U.S. House of Representatives has to impeach someone, which means to formally charge somebody with impeachable misconduct. Impeachment might also refer to the whole process that the Congress may go through to remove somebody from office for impeachable misconduct. That whole process starts in the House, which then may impeach someone, and then it moves to the Senate, which has the power to remove someone if at least two-thirds of the Senate agrees or approves impeachment articles against that person.
SPEAKER_00The whole idea of impeachment and that whole process is based on the British system. In England, impeachment goes back centuries. And it was a process that applied to everybody in England except for the king. So anyone in England could be impeached for anything. And then they could also have imposed on them any sanction, including imprisonment or death. The American founders, the people who sort of wrote the Constitution, liked some of that British process but disliked most of it.
SPEAKER_00So they borrowed the term impeachment. They also narrowed it to only certain officials, including the President of the United States, and they also narrowed the sanctions to removal and disqualification. And they also, unlike the British system, divided it between the two chambers of the legislature, in our case Congress, and in the second chamber, the upper chamber, the Senate had to have a supermajority in order for there to be a conviction and removal. So we learned from the British system, but we tried to improve upon it and make it more fair.
SPEAKER_00Last but not least, as I said in England, the king was the only person not subject to impeachment. But in the United States, the highest ranking elected official, the president, is very much prone and vulnerable to impeachment if that person has committed an impeachable offense.
SPEAKER_02And so the founders and the framers writing this constitution, they are using this British precedent as they're drafting the Constitution. Why was it so significant that they're making these slight changes to the impeachment process as they draft this Constitution?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell The main thing was that the framers are trying to Americanize the process. Obviously, Americans broke away from England and they rebelled against English rule. And they did that in the form of the Declaration of Independence, which, by the way, is drafted in more than 20 impeachment articles against the king. So the framers were emphasizing in the very document that signaled they were breaking free from England that they thought impeachment was crucial for keeping a corrupt king, or in our case, a corrupt president, from becoming tyrannical and instead enabling the national legislature to remove that person because of his corruption.
SPEAKER_02So if I understand correctly, the framers are really seeing the impeachment process as a safeguard in preventing tyranny.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it was a s it was a crucial safeguard in preventing and providing a sanction for tyrannical behavior which would come from the president, the vice president, or other high-ranking officials, including Supreme Court justices.
SPEAKER_02So now that we have a foundational understanding of what the framers were thinking as they're putting this into the Constitution, how does this process begin playing out in the American system? So how is impeachment used over the centuries after the Constitution is ratified?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Well, it's it's used almost immediately, but as the founders quickly learned after the Constitution was ratified, they were going to need to fine-tune impeachment. But before 1800, we have our first impeachment. It's directed against a man named William Blunt, who happens to come from North Carolina. He was a senator from North Carolina, and he had been expelled from the Senate for corruption, particularly bribery. The House nevertheless proceeded to impeach him. And the Senate took a vote on whether or not it had jurisdiction to consider Blunt's impeachment because Blunt was no longer in office.
SPEAKER_00And the Senate voted, this is the first Congress, composed of a lot of people who understood the Constitution, they voted that they had jurisdiction to consider Blunt's impeachment. Nevertheless, they proceeded to hold a trial and eventually voted a majority in favor to convict him, but the majority fell short of the two-thirds required for removal. And the senators explained to some extent at the time that some thought senators were not impeachable. And that makes some sense because Blunt was no longer in office because he had just been expelled from the Senate.
SPEAKER_00So obviously it didn't make a lot of sense to think that a senator could be removed twice. Well, Blunt had already been removed. And so for enough senators, that indicated that maybe impeachment was not the right process for that person.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell So impeachment seems to be a process only used in terms of the political realm. It's not a way to address legal recourse. Is that correct?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Well, it's a unique process. That's one of the things that gets emphasized in the Constitutional Convention and even in the Federalist papers. So impeachment is not really a legal process, and it's not purely a political process. It's a unique constitutional process for addressing the misconduct of the president, among others.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Has this process been used as the framers intended throughout American history, or are there examples of different kinds of interpretation as to what constitutes an impeachable offense?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell It has not been used that much. But having said that, I should note that the House of Representatives has impeached 20 people, and at least one of those twice, and that was Donald Trump. But less than 10 have been convicted and removed from office. And that's largely because the threshold for removal is very high. It's very difficult to get at least two-thirds of the Senate to agree on something as monumental as removing some high-ranking officials. So the only people impeached, convicted, and removed have been lower court federal judges.
SPEAKER_00The one cabinet secretary impeached had resigned. And even though the Senate voted that it had jurisdiction to conduct a trial, that person was ultimately acquitted, even though a majority voted in favor of conviction. So we encounter some difficulties when we're talking about elected people like the president or high-ranking people like cabinet officers because there are a variety of different mechanisms for holding, for example, cabinet officers accountable. They could be fired by the president, or they could be subject to a trial.
SPEAKER_02Is there a different standard of accountability? You mentioned that this process can be used for different high-ranking officials. Is there a different standard of accountability for officials that are a bit higher ranking, like vice president or president versus senators or House of Representatives?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell to begin with, the senators are not impeachable, and consistent with that, House members are not impeachable. But members of Congress are subject to being disciplined within their own chambers. It's been a divisive question with scholars and even members of Congress whether the standard for impeaching a president is the same as the standard for impeaching a cabinet official or a lower court judge. However, we have only one impeachment clause. And so that would suggest that same clause applies to anyone who's impeachable.
SPEAKER_00The tough thing is that the framers generally understood impeachable offenses to be treason, bribery, and serious abuses of power. So abuses of power could differ depending on the office. A judge might abuse power quite differently than a president would. So the differences in the responsibilities might then lead to practically understanding that an impeachable offense is going to look different, perhaps, if done by a judge than a president. Nonetheless, judges and presidents are subject to impeachment for treason and bribery.
SPEAKER_00So those kinds of misconduct could look similar.
SPEAKER_02And what has that looked like, the interpretation of that third clause, this abuse of power?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell There have not been that many times when Congress has had to wrestle with that. A number of successful impeachments have been done on the basis of bribery. But in other cases, a lower court judge has been impeached and removed from office for perjury and even for engaging in an appearance of impropriety. We wouldn't think, however, that an appearance of impropriety would necessarily require or justify a president's removal. It might be more a problem with a judge whose integrity is absolutely crucial for their doing their duty.
SPEAKER_00For a president, we might not think that an appearance of impropriety is necessarily that bad. Presidents do controversial things, they might appear to be less than perfect. Those things might necessarily justify your conviction removal. But I think at the end of the day, what matters as far as impeachment goes for any official are two things. One is the context in which the misconduct occurred, and the other is the gravity or the seriousness of the misconduct that the impeached or impeachable official committed.
SPEAKER_02And you touched a bit on this in your book. You note that presidential impeachment has become very much about the political party to which the impeached president belongs rather than the merits of the actions. How can we, whether it be the public or the Senate, a House of Representatives, how can we as a collective country create a nonpartisan impeachment process?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Well, that's a really tough question. I mean, I wish we all knew the answer to that. I think that what's been discovered, and you've pointed this out, and I do talk about this at some length in the book, is that when we talk about presidential impeachment, the stakes are different than they might be if a lower court judge were being impeached, convicted, and removed. So with presidents, they're different because people are more invested in a president's either getting out of office or staying in office. And so politics and partisanship inevitably creep into the process.
SPEAKER_00And even though we've had presidents that have committed misconduct, none of them have ever been successfully convicted and removed from office. And that's in part because partisans have learned if presidents can keep their party together, the senators especially, from their own party together, then presidents are almost certainly going to avoid conviction removal because a president's political party is likely to occupy almost half the seats in the Senate. And therefore, uh, if you just do your math, that is not going to allow for at least two-thirds of the Senate to agree to conviction remove in the case of a president.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Professor Gerhardt, that raises a question in my mind about the power of the executive branch. How has that affected the impeachment process?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think as the presidency has grown in power, the presidency has become less accountable. And that's a disturbing phenomenon. So as the presidency's has accrued more power, that just means more people are going to be invested in the presidency. And particularly more people from the president's party are going to be invested in the presidency. So for example, if we like what a president's doing in stacking the Supreme Court with people who have a particular outlook, then members of Congress might be reluctant to get rid of that president because they like it, or they might be less inclined to get rid of somebody who's done them a lot of favors.
SPEAKER_00We've been presented in this country with a dilemma. The more powerful a president gets, the harder it is to get that person out of office. We have to rely heavily on elections. And elections can be manipulated or distorted. For example, in what may be a more controversial situation, the facts are clear that Donald Trump tried twice to affect presidential elections. And each time he tried, he was subject to impeachment. So in 2019, he asked the President of Ukraine to make an announcement that Joe Biden, Trump's likely opponent, was going to be the subject of a criminal investigation in Ukraine.
SPEAKER_00There wasn't any proof or any basis for it, but then President Trump was asking President Zelensky of Ukraine back then, well just make the announcement. And if you do that, I'll release the funds that the Congress appropriated for your defense. Zelensky ultimately didn't make the announcement, but later, President Trump, who didn't like the fact he lost the presidential election in 2020, then tried various ways to stay in office, particularly to frustrate the process that was going to be used for certifying electoral votes.
SPEAKER_00And ultimately, on january sixth, the president encouraged his supporters, quote, to fight for their country. They took him at his word, and they descended on Congress, and more than 900 of them, more than a thousand, broke into Congress, destroyed offices, desks, paintings, statues, presumably to try and find a way to keep Congress from being the final institution that's required to certify the outcome of the election. Fortunately, those rioters were beaten back, and Congress, although it had to stop accounting for that final electoral certification, continued later on the same day to certify the election for Joe Biden.
SPEAKER_00That didn't make Donald Trump happy. It certainly upset the House, which then proceeded to impeach Donald Trump a second time. So twice Donald Trump's tried to sort of undo an election or interfere with an election, and twice he's been impeached for it.
SPEAKER_02And I wonder, you know, today we have this 24-hour news cycle, and this access to information or disinformation is much wider. What effect does that have on how these proceedings go, how much we as the public pay attention to impeachment processes?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell I think those changes you refer to are have a gigantic effect on impeachment because they have a gigantic effect on the public's understanding of what's going on. And members of Congress are, to a large extent, very attentive to how their constituents vote and to what their constituents want. And if members of Congress think they're going to be rewarded for keeping a president in office, members of Congress may be reluctant to push that president out.
SPEAKER_02And as we think about the importance of impeachment and the proceedings that have happened just in recent years, what is the main takeaway that you want the public to understand about the importance of the impeachment process and how we move forward as a democracy?
SPEAKER_00Well, one of the most important things to understand is that the framers of the Constitution, the people who wrote the Constitution, put impeachment into it as a safeguard, as you were suggesting at the outset today. It's a safeguard against tyranny. It's a safeguard against corruption. It's supposed to be a safeguard for the democratic, small D democratic process. But if that process itself becomes corrupted or ineffective, then the American people are themselves going to be less safe for something bad to happen when it comes to their government.
SPEAKER_00If impeachment can't be effective as a way to dissuade a president from illegal misconduct, or can't be effective to sanction and remove that person or even disqualify that person from ever being president again, we have less to rely on to protect us from executive tyranny.
SPEAKER_00But what they didn't foresee was the development of political parties and the hold that those political parties would have over the people in Congress and over the president. And now I think party for many members of Congress is more important than the Constitution or even democracy.
SPEAKER_02And I have to ask, I'm at Montpelier, the home of James Madison. I'm curious to hear what he thought about the impeachment process and what his role was in drafting this constitution and adding that in.
SPEAKER_00Well, Madison, of course, played a very important role, and in fact a crucial role as the debate over the impeachment process went on. And there was a critical moment, for example, when some of the people of the convention considered making a basis for impeachment maladministration, which basically just means poor performance in office or bad performance in office. And Madison opposed that. And instead he proposed the language that's in the Constitution today, and the language he proposed was to take the place of a maladministration, and that language was other high crimes and misdemeanors.
SPEAKER_00That phrase had been used in the colonies and was used in England to refer to serious abuses of power. And that's an enormous contribution that Madison made, clarifying, among other things, that impeachment's not designed to go after somebody just because we don't like them. Impeachment's designed for a rare purpose. It's to go after a president, a justice, cabinet member who is corrupt and has committed treason or bribery or abuse their power in ways that the law doesn't easily redress.
SPEAKER_00That's the classic case for an impeachment. And Madison was at the center of it.
SPEAKER_02And as we wrap up our discussion today, would you be willing to share what you hope to see for the future in terms of how this process could be more effective moving forward and keep our democracy safe?
SPEAKER_00Well, I can certainly, you know, express my hope, and it's just that, it's just a hope, that we can as a people, Americans, ultimately put the rule of law and it's best manifested in our Constitution at the forefront and make that more important than any individual or any particular presidency and any particular political party. That's going to take a lot of work. We haven't had a lot of success doing that in American history. But I think that's going to be essential if impeachment is to fulfill its original objective of keeping tyrants out of office and of removing people who are dangers to the Constitution and dangers to the American people.
SPEAKER_02I appreciate you sharing kind of what you hope to see. And I think we all have to have hope. And our conversation today, especially about the context and gravity of the circumstances surrounding impeachment, I think is really important to keep in mind, especially again as we are in this environment of 24-hour news. And it's, I think, even more reassuring to know that this was really one of Madison's key legacies, this mechanism in the Constitution to ensure that this democracy continues, that there's a way to hold high-ranking elected officials accountable.
SPEAKER_00Well, I certainly hope so.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much for joining us. It's been an absolute pleasure. And again, the love of presidential impeachment, your new book, congratulations on it. It really is a fascinating read and one I would encourage all citizens to take a look at.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. And I appreciate your having me.
SPEAKER_02And thank you to all of our listeners. I appreciate you joining us today. I hope you will share the show with your family and friends and join us in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...