In this season finale, host Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and producer Adam Belmar reflect on key conversations from the first season of Consider the Constitution Podcast. They revisit notable discussions with constitutional scholars about Article III, judicial review, Madison's vision for managing political diversity, and the evolution of constitutional rights. Highlights include insights on voting rights, the legacy of Reconstruction, privacy in the digital age, and George Washington's approach to the presidency. The episode emphasizes how the Constitution continues to shape American democracy while underscoring the importance of civic engagement and education. Scholars in this episode: 1. Dr. Lauren Bell - discussing Article III 2. F. Michael Higginbotham - on judicial review 3. Dr. Jay Cost - on Madison's vision for political diversity 4. Dr. Beau Breslin - on constitutional endurance and Jefferson's views 5. Dr. Lynn Uzzell - on the Bill of Rights 6. Professor Kendra Johnson - on privacy rights and technology 7. Jade Ryerson - on the right to assembly 8. Dr. Pippa Holloway - on voting rights 9. Professor Julie Suk - on women's suffrage 10. Dr. DeAnza Cook - on the 13th Amendment and mass incarceration 11. Dr. Hasan Jeffries - on Reconstruction and originalism 12. Dr. Lindsay Chervinsky - on George Washington's presidency 13. David O. Stewart - on Washington at the Constitutional Convention 14. Dr. John Ragosta - on early political divisions 15. Professor Michael Gerhardt - on impeachment
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_14Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Black and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_05Hello and welcome to a special season finale episode of Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. Today I'm joined by our producer, Adam Belmar, as we look back at some of the fascinating conversations we've had this season, exploring our nation's founding document. Adam, welcome back to the other side of the microphone.
SPEAKER_14Thank you, Katie. I have to say, it was quite an honor to join you in episode five of this Consider the Constitution podcast. But really, it was a dream that we had together at the Center for the Constitution. We've been doing it 33 episodes strong. And I must say, I have learned as I think our audience has so much about our founding fathers and about our Constitution.
SPEAKER_05I certainly hope so. You know, when we started this podcast in September of 2023, we had no idea how it would resonate with audiences. We began this series as a special program for our Constitution Month, and it's really grown into something much more meaningful. Let's start with one of our earliest episodes featuring Dr. Lauren Bell discussing Article III of the Constitution.
SPEAKER_08I like to start when I talk about Article III by pointing out how short it is relative to the other articles that establish institutions of our federal government. Unlike Article I, which is really extensive in terms of outlining the powers of Congress, and Article II, which articulates in pretty significant detail what the role of the President of the United States is, Article III is incredibly short. It establishes one Supreme Court and such inferior courts as Congress shall ordain and create.
SPEAKER_08It establishes that the Supreme Court will have two types of jurisdiction: original jurisdiction, which means that the court can hear a case for the first time, and appellate jurisdiction, which means that the court can hear cases that come to it from other courts below it. Beyond that, there is very little said about who will serve on the court, what their credentials ought to be. We do know that judges or justices in uh Article III courts serve terms of good behavior or what we traditionally think of as lifetime terms, and that they cannot have their compensation reduced while they're serving in office.
SPEAKER_08Both of those are intended to promote an independent federal judiciary.
SPEAKER_05Adam, as someone who has produced every episode, what struck you about Dr. Bell's insights into the judicial branch?
SPEAKER_14Dr. Bell's episode helped me understand how fascinating it is that such a brief section of the U.S. Constitution, Article III, could give rise to such an important branch of government. And as we further explored the judiciary, I was so compelled by Professor Hagenbotham's analysis about judicial review.
SPEAKER_13You had John Adams as uh the outgoing president, you had John Marshall as his Secretary of State, and who would become, of course, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. You had the incoming president, Thomas Jefferson, and you had his uh Secretary of State, James Madison, and you also had William Marbury, who wanted a job. And so the case had tremendous players, famous players in it. But it also is one of the most important constitutional cases because in the case, the Supreme Court indicated that they had the power of judicial review, and that meant that they could strike down legislation passed by Congress that the court believed was inconsistent with the Constitution.
SPEAKER_13And so when the court articulated that power, it was a surprise to many. And if you look at the case, the real winner is the American people, because the court articulated the power of judicial review, which gave the judicial branch more power, more of a check on the other two branches.
SPEAKER_05We've covered so much ground this season, from the original drafting of the Constitution in 1787 to modern interpretations of the document. Dr. Jay Cost gave us a fascinating perspective on Madison's vision for managing political diversity.
SPEAKER_10It's an incredibly diverse country. Madison's argument is that the diversity is actually the strength. In a small republic, like in a state, you can have some social group or some economic group or some religious group basically act as a hegemon and boss everybody else around. This had happened in Rhode Island. It had happened in Massachusetts during the Confederation period, it happened in Virginia, even though Virginia is religiously diversifying. The Anglican establishment is browbeating the Baptists and also the Quakers.
SPEAKER_10And Madison's point is that on a national level, there's going to be no hegemon. The Anglicans are not going to constitute a national majority, so they're going to have to bargain. And so also will the Congregationalists in New England and the merchants in Philadelphia and the plantation gentry right here in Virginia, they're going to have to bargain with each other. Nobody's going to get everything they want. Everybody has to come to the table.
SPEAKER_14And that theme of compromise, Katie, and negotiation has remained relevant throughout our history. In our episode with Dr. Bo Breslin, the discussion of constitutional endurance was particularly striking.
SPEAKER_00For Jefferson, the idea was that each generation ought to write its own constitution and that a constitution ought to have a sunset clause. And he, being the mathematician that he was, he had figured out that a generation transitions to a new generation every 19 years. So for Jefferson, the idea was to sort of return metaphorically to Philadelphia and make necessary adjustments to the Constitution every 19 years. So he writes that to Madison in a series of letters.
SPEAKER_00Most famously a September 6, 1789 letter, where he writes, the earth belongs to the living and the dead have neither rights nor powers over it. And for Jefferson, that meant that every 19 years a constitution ought to be updated, tinkered with, or scrapped altogether and a new constitution forms every 19 years.
SPEAKER_05As we wrap up our first season, what stands out to you most from all of our conversations?
SPEAKER_14Oh, Katie, what stands out, what really strikes me, is how relevant these constitutional discussions remain today. From Dr. Linuzell's insights on the Bill of Rights to Dr. Hassan Jeffrey's powerful commentary on Reconstruction Legacy. Every episode of this show has eliminated how the Constitution continues to shape our democracy.
SPEAKER_05I appreciate that point, Adam, because I want to take a moment to applaud all of our guest speakers. They did a fantastic job of not just talking about their areas of expertise, but also connecting these historical moments to modern day and why the Constitution, individual rights, how that's all relevant to us.
SPEAKER_14As a Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier, that's your mission as our director here. But every one of the seminars that we have that's brought these scholars here to Montpelier, we've found that connection for educators and law enforcement and practitioners who are trying to educate the next generation. And so every day in the classroom here, we get to see that relevancy and connection. And then when we get into the podcast booth to have these conversations, it really comes out. And I think it's one of the things I'm most proud of in these conversations is that we've been able to share them with so many more people.
SPEAKER_05Let's talk about some of the fascinating discussions we've had around constitutional rights. Professor Kendra Johnson gave us important insights into how privacy rights have evolved with technology, which is obviously an ongoing conversation.
SPEAKER_14Let's hear what the professor had to say.
SPEAKER_02Technology honestly ends up being one of the ways that the Fourth Amendment is becoming stretched in ways that we never thought was possible. Because when our founding fathers were drafting the Fourth Amendment, they were in carriages and you know there weren't telephones and the internet or phones that serve as computers. None of those things existed. So when technology begins to change, the law begins to change with the technology.
SPEAKER_14And Katie, Jade Ryerson showed us how the right to assemble has adapted over time.
SPEAKER_06During the 1960s, civil rights anti-war and student protests informed the development of the standard permitting process that the National Park Service uses to regulate First Amendment demonstrations and other activities at all of its sites. So to be more specific, you would need a permit for a gathering of more than 25 people, even if the protest started spontaneously. In addition to the number of people, the permit can also limit what kinds of stuff you can have with you. Like you couldn't just build a physical structure that would obstruct use of the site or harm historic resources there. Other regulations can also shift from space to space.
SPEAKER_06So if you started out protesting on the White House sidewalk, you'd have other limitations, but if you move to Pennsylvania Avenue versus Lafayette Park proper.
SPEAKER_05Speaking of rights and protests, we had several powerful conversations about voting rights and the ongoing struggle for equality. Let's hear from Dr. Pippa Holloway and Professor Julie Suk on this topic.
SPEAKER_01You know, one of the lessons I take from the past is that, and it's one of the lessons for the Nineteenth Amendment, is not to sit back and be triumphant about our voting rights. That our democracy is one that is always changing. Our democracy is one that is always working to fulfill its great promise. I think we all need to continue to think about our elections, our democracy, and our voting rights. We need to continue to articulate them. We need to continue to think what the right to vote means, how we understand it, what is best for our nation in terms of who is included in our electorate and in our policy.
SPEAKER_01We have to continue to be engaged and think hard about what our rights are and how we articulate and defend them.
SPEAKER_15How do you get the right to vote when you can't vote? You have zero say if you don't have the right to vote. So who's deciding whether women should vote? And the fact is it's really a male electorate and men who are representatives in the state legislatures. And this begins to change a little bit because the Western states, many Western states, start enfranchising women. And that means that women are voting for their members of Congress, for example. So you have a little bit of a voice in Congress that you're missing in those states that limit suffrage to men only.
SPEAKER_15So that creates an opening now. It's not a huge opening because remember, to get a constitutional amendment under Article V, you need two-thirds of both houses of Congress and three-fourths of state legislatures. So the small opening of voice created by women voting in a handful of states is not great, but it's it's a platform that can be used that's different from going state by state.
SPEAKER_14Those episodes really highlighted how the expansion of rights has been a continuous process. Dr. DeNza Cook and Dr. Hassan Jeffries gave us some particularly powerful insights into the challenges following the Civil War.
SPEAKER_03The language of the 13th Amendment left open one legal loophole. Slavery and involuntary servitude as punishment for a crime remained constitutional after the Civil War. Abolitionists who were against slavery had to compromise with slaveholding conservatives and liberal reformers who still believed that black people in the U.S. were inherently or naturally criminal. So, in essence, the amendment permitted what historians referred to as slavery by another name for black Americans who were increasingly victimized by police racism and discrimination within the criminal legal system during and after the Reconstruction era.
SPEAKER_03If you were convicted of a crime in accordance with U.S. law, you could be subjected to forced labor and convict leasing in prison camps or on penal farms or as part of chain gangs who worked in cotton fields and railroads and coal mines and related construction and manufacturing industries for no pay. So unfortunately, life for the first generations of newly emancipated black Americans was still precarious, even with the 13th Amendment in place, because they remained under threat to slavery and forms of involuntary servitude, especially in the South.
SPEAKER_05The legacy of these decisions continues to impact our society today, as we've said. Dr. Cook shared some sobering statistics about mass incarceration.
SPEAKER_03Mass incarceration refers to the fact that more than 1.9 million individuals and loved ones are currently confined in U.S. jails, prisons, detention centers, military facilities, or other forms of containment on native land. America incarcerates more people than any other nation on earth. And on average, black people are imprisoned at rates six times higher than those of white people. So the human costs and consequences of mass incarceration that began in the late 20th century and extend to the present affect millions and millions of Americans.
SPEAKER_14And we've also had fascinating discussions about how to interpret the Constitution in modern times. Dr. Jeffries raised important questions about originalism.
SPEAKER_09One of the great dangers, I think, that we've seen over the last almost a half century now is this idea of original intent. The originalists, which is political conservatives, really trumpeting this idea of the only way to interpret the Constitution is to interpret it from the original intent of the framers and the founders. Well, these are people who are buying and selling other people. So if if that's what you want, then the society that we have is not going to look like a society of equality. And that isn't how we've interpreted.
SPEAKER_09We've added only a handful of amendments because we've had this expansive understanding interpretation of what the Constitution is. And that's what makes it powerful. Not the original aspects of it. That laid the groundwork, but it had to be expanded. It had to be extended. And the more we do that, the more inclusive and the more equitable our society becomes. The more we narrow it, the more we get back to that original intent, the less space there is for all people to be included.
SPEAKER_05Let's turn to some of our episodes about the early presidency. Dr. Lindsay Trevinci gave us fascinating insights into how George Washington approached his role as this new office was created.
SPEAKER_07And he met with the Senate just a couple of months into his presidency. It went very badly. The Senate acted like a legislative body and wanted to sort of deliberate privately and not have him involved. And he had wanted to see those interactions such that he could understand the different perspectives and points of view and options to consider all of the details. And on his way out, he reportedly said that he would never again return to the Senate for advice. And he never again returned to the Senate for advice. So I think the main takeaway from this story is that this interaction occurs in August of 1789, which is just a couple of months into his presidency.
SPEAKER_07And that means that a key element of the constitution that the delegates had put in place didn't work just a couple of months into its practice. And so Washington really, I think, approached the presidency with a great deal of experimentation, with a great deal of flexibility, sort of acting in response in real time to the obstacles and challenges that faced him, always doing his best to stick to the spirit of the Constitution, but recognizing that the goal of the Constitution was good governance. And he was much more interested in being a good executive than he was in limiting himself to the explicit text of the document.
SPEAKER_14What a moving interview that was. And it has been ringing in my head since I heard her say it in the studio, Katie. And it makes me think back to what David Stewart helped us all understand about Washington's priorities at the Constitutional Convention.
SPEAKER_11He was very clear the three things he wanted out of this convention. And I'm sure he was clear about this in conversation. I know he was clear about it in correspondence, which is one, there had to be an executive branch. Two, the national government had to be superior to the state governments. And three, the national government had to be able to levy taxes. Otherwise, you don't have a government. And almost no time is spent at the convention on those three issues, because, well, Washington wants them. So they're not going to say no.
SPEAKER_11And in many ways, the best kind of battle when you win it before it even starts. And he had that ability to let people know what he wanted. And he didn't care, to be honest, about a lot of the particular details he figured that they'd work out. Whereas Madison was a devil on the details and very smart about them.
SPEAKER_05Adam, as we sit here and think about all the episodes that we recorded this past year, I'm reminded of the very first episode we did with Dr. Lynn Uzel and how she talked about the Bill of Rights and this debate over whether we actually needed a Bill of Rights in the early days of the United States. And one of the most fascinating aspects of that conversation was how James Madison was not all on board for a Bill of Rights. He actually didn't think we needed it.
SPEAKER_16So Madison can can be described as someone who was against a Bill of Rights before he was for it. So when he was at the Virginia Ratifying Convention, he came out against a Bill of Rights. Patrick Henry said we should not accept this Constitution. We shouldn't ratify it unless it has a Bill of Rights. And Madison said a bill of rights was not only unnecessary, but even dangerous. Because if you add a bill of rights, you imply that Congress had powers that the Constitution never gave to it.
SPEAKER_14Trevor Burrus And Dr. John Ragosta showed us, Katie, how early political divisions were bridged through leadership.
SPEAKER_04Trevor Burrus Madison and Jefferson really pull back and they realize they participated in the hyperpartisanship. They participated in these battles of the 1790s, and they realized we almost destroyed the country. We almost drove the country off the cliff. Trevor Burrus So I tell people, reread Jefferson's first inaugural address in that light, and it takes on a very different voice. It's Jefferson really pulling back and saying, you know, I know we've been having these partisan battles, but what unites us is more important than what divides us, he says in that inaugural address, I understand, I understand why the Federalists were worried about the French.
SPEAKER_04Remarkable statement for Jefferson to make. The famous line, we are all Federalists, we are all Republicans. But he says we must unite for the common good. That, yeah, we've had partisan battles, but we really share our commitment to the Constitution.
SPEAKER_05Looking back at this first season, what themes stand out to you most or most resonate with you, Adam?
SPEAKER_14Aaron Powell Based on our first season, I think the key theme that stands out for me and hopefully all of our listeners is how the Constitution of the United States continues to evolve. And it does that through interpretation and practice. Yet the core principles of checks and balances, the protection of rights, and the need for compromise remains constant today. Professor Michael Gerhardt commented about impeachment, and he really captured the essence there, this balance between permanence and change.
SPEAKER_12Well, one of the most important things to understand is that the framers of the Constitution, the people who wrote the Constitution, put impeachment into it as a safeguard. It's a safeguard against tyranny. It's a safeguard against corruption. It's supposed to be a safeguard for the democratic, small D democratic process. But if that process itself becomes corrupted or ineffective, then the American people are themselves going to be less safe for something bad to happen when it comes to their government. If impeachment can't be effective as a way to dissuade a president from illegal misconduct, or it can't be effective to sanction and remove that person or even disqualify that person from ever being president again, we have less to rely on to protect us from executive tyranny.
SPEAKER_05For me, what stood out most is how each of our speakers touched on this idea of civic engagement and why we all need to be involved. Some of our speakers commented on how we need to cherish democracy, how we have a responsibility, this idea that we don't have a democracy if we're not involved in participating. And, you know, I have always heard about civic engagement, why it's important, but it was through basically producing this podcast that it really struck home the role we all play as citizens.
SPEAKER_14I think as a producer, I saw all of that through the eyes of the attendees here at the Center for the Constitution. All of these teachers from across the nation that came to Montpelier to commiserate with other teachers about the difficult job that they have, all of them understood how important it was to convey this history and the principles and the idea of engagement to their students. And I think the thing that excited me most was seeing these speakers, our speakers, our guests on this podcast connect with those teachers and see them excited, knowing that they were going to turn around and bring that level of excitement right back to their students.
SPEAKER_05As we wrap up our first season, I want to thank all of our guests who have shared their expertise and insights. And most importantly, I want to thank our listeners who have joined us on this journey exploring the Constitution's past, present, and future. This podcast really came into being because of all of those listeners, because your interest in this show. So thank you.
SPEAKER_14It has been an incredible season, Katie, and you have been a fantastic host. Each episode has deepened our understanding of how this remarkable document continues to shape our American democracy.
SPEAKER_05Thank you all for listening to Consider the Constitution. We'll be back next season with more fascinating conversations about the document that shapes our democracy. For the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier, I'm Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...