In this special episode commemorating the 25th anniversary of the co-stewardship partnership between the National Trust for Historic Preservation and The Montpelier Foundation, host Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey welcomes Tom Mayes, Chief Legal Officer of the National Trust for Historic Preservation. Together, they explore how historic places like James Madison's Montpelier connect us to the origins of the Constitution and why preserving these spaces matters for democracy.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
SPEAKER_01Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey with James Madison's Montpelier. Today, we're exploring the power of place, that emotional, cultural, and historical force that connects people to the landscapes and spaces around us. It's the way certain sites hold memory, meaning, and identity, shaping how we understand ourselves and our shared past. It's also where law and preservation meet.
SPEAKER_02Historic places are safeguarded through legal frameworks that reflect national values, from property law and preservation statutes to constitutional principles that influence how we protect cultural heritage. In many ways, preserving place can be seen as an act of civic responsibility, ensuring that stories written into the land remain accessible to everyone. And I have to say, few places embody that power more deeply than Montpelier, the home of James and Dolly Madison and the enslaved community, this place where ideas that shaped our nation were debated and refined, and where legacies of freedom and slavery intersect in profound ways.
SPEAKER_02So as we reflect on that theme, this year offers a very meaningful moment of celebration. 2025 marks the 25th anniversary of the co-stewardship agreement between the National Trust for Historic Preservation, the nonprofit that owns the property, and the Mount Pillier Foundation, which manages daily operations and stewards the mission of engaging the public with the Constitution. And today we have a very special guest in the studio, Chief Legal Officer and General Counsel for the National Trust for Historic Preservation, Mr.
SPEAKER_02Tom Mays. In this role, he oversees the National Trust's Legal Defense Fund, which advocates for the protection of very significant places and defends and strengthens historic easement program, which protects over 135 historic places throughout the country. Tom has also written and spoken widely on preservation law, the underlying purposes of historic preservation, and the future of preservation. For many years, he's taught historic preservation law at the University of Maryland.
SPEAKER_02And Tom, I can't think of a better guest to have speaking with us today about how this power of place really comes alive here at Montpelier. So welcome to Consider the Constitution.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Katie. I'm delighted to be here. It's wonderful to be at Montpelier and great to have this conversation with you.
SPEAKER_02So we have so much we could talk about today, but let's begin with Montpelier itself. So many of our listeners may be aware that Madison died in 1836. He leaves Dolly in debt, and she sells the property in 1844. It changes hands from several owners until 1901. And that's when William DuPont purchases the property. Now we do see some major alterations to both the house and the grounds until this point when Marion DuPont, William's daughter, she inherits the property and later bequeaths it to the National Trust in the 1980s.
SPEAKER_02Now it's quite a while after that that the Montpelier Foundation is established. But I think this is a good moment to ask you about the challenges of preservation in this context. So we've got this really historic Madison House. It has some alterations, again, both to the structure and to the landscape. So what were the challenges in deciding what to do with this space, whether we're going to restore it, whether we're not, how you balance kind of those stories within this one space?
SPEAKER_00That's a great question, Katie. And this was an issue. This idea of whether to restore the mansion to the James Madison era was a question that was talked about all over the country, and preservationists grappled with, and there were very conflicting views about it. The more commonly held preservation belief would be that in general, you try to preserve the history of a place as it's changed over time. So you would preserve the record of those changes that had historic significance.
SPEAKER_00And of course, the DuPont family was prominent in its own right. So there were many people who thought the trust and the foundation should retain the DuPont era additions to Montpelier. One of the key challenges was whether there was enough information known about the Madison era house to actually do a restoration. So, under preservation standards, you're really not supposed to restore a house unless you know enough about what it looked like and what its appearance was that you can actually do an authentic restoration.
SPEAKER_00So what occurred was really an extraordinary documentation process led by the Montpelier Foundation that sought to do both archaeological investigations, architectural investigations, and documentary investigations to find out what the original Madison House was. And a little bit to many people's surprise, there was enough information to actually determine what the original Madison House was.
SPEAKER_00It's a fascinating thing because what had happened was in an early form of sort of recycling, as the Madison House was rebuilt over time, they had reused all the pieces. So the pieces were found in different parts of the house, they were found in outbuildings, and that was one of the things that contributed to being able to restore the house. One other piece of this was looking at the preservation standards. And there is a preservation standard, there's a rehabilitation standard, and there's a restoration standard and a reconstruction standard.
SPEAKER_00All of those are present here at Montpelier. But the mansion itself, there was a decision to restore it in part so that the story of James and Dolly Madison could be told. And I am I'm a diehard preservationist. You know, normally I would say save that history of the DuPont family, save that history of the other families that were there. But the preeminent historical significance of James and Dolly Madison was so important that even I thought this is one example where the house should be restored to the Madison era so that visitors can have a better understanding of what they were trying to do.
SPEAKER_00And it ties to Madison's and Dolly's thoughts about the new republic because they wanted to have a place that reflected their ideals about what the new republic should be. So it ties back to those constitutional ideas.
SPEAKER_02I love hearing about it because, you know, Montpelier really is a unique case study. As you noted, there's a strong argument that the DuPont, the changes they made to the house and the landscape, I mean, it's historic in its own right. So this idea of almost taking that away, destroying it in an essence to put something else back into place, that's pretty significant. And hearing these different methods used from the archaeology to the architecture, the written documents, it's really fascinating how we put these pieces together to try to reconstruct this image of what the house, the property looked like while Madison is in his retirement years after he's president from 1817 to 1836.
SPEAKER_00One of the things about the DuPont piece, too, is it's not as if the DuPonts are erased from the landscape or erased from Montpelier. As a part of thinking about restoring it to the Madison era, the Montpelier Foundation chose to preserve parts of the house in the visitor center where they're used for public spaces now, and people get to experience that. People love this room called the Red Room, which was Marion DuPont Scott's sort of racing photography room built in this moderne style.
SPEAKER_00So it's a very charming memory of the DuPont era that people really relate to. And of course, it ties to your theme of the power of place. That history is also still remembered here and still preserved here, and people can experience it.
SPEAKER_02And that nod to the DuPonts and that red room, if our listeners haven't visited Montpelier, obviously tour the house, but you really should check out the visitor center in that red room because it is certainly something to see. But it is kind of preserving a piece of that history and her stewardship of this place in willing it to the National Trust. And we also have on the landscape itself the horse tracks. You know, that's something that the DuPonts put in during their time period, which remains an active event at Montpelier and is really central to the community and the region as a whole.
SPEAKER_02And this kind of line of conversation leads me to my next question. Yes, preservation is about the structure itself, the Madison Mansion, but it's also about the meaning of the landscape itself. So can you tell us a bit about why preservation should encompass both the built structures, but also the landscape surrounding it?
SPEAKER_00Well, the landscape is essential for telling the story of Montpelier, of course, because that's why the Madisons were here. It was their source of income. It was a plantation. There were hundreds of enslaved people here who worked the land, who made the lifestyle that James and Dolly Madison lived possible. And they are also still present in the landscape with the burial ground for the enslaved community, which we are in the process of memorializing even more than it's already recognized.
SPEAKER_00But that memory is present throughout the landscape. I'll go back to the restoration of the Madison Mansion for a second, just to give a very personal response about that, which is one reason I thought that people couldn't understand the Madison occupation without the restoration, is because the way the DuPont editions had been done cut off the Madison House from the landscape.
SPEAKER_00So when you're in the Madison House now in those wings, you can tell how they used the cross breezes. You can tell how they had views of the landscape. You could tell how they had views of the garden, that it was a completely integrated whole. They didn't think of the house alone. They thought of the house in the landscape in which it is situated. And you can experience that when you come and visit and take the tour and see how they could see out of both sides of the windows, or see how that central salon has windows that open up that create cross breezes.
SPEAKER_00It's really a very, it's a much more evocative place since the restoration. Now, of course, you see the race course in the front. And of course, we are just getting ready to celebrate the 90th running of the Montpellier steeplechase, which is a great thing, a legacy that Marion DuPont Scott created. And you talked about that race as being an event that gathers the community together. It is incredibly important for these places to continue to be used and enjoyed by people.
SPEAKER_00And it is those uses and events. I mean, you can talk to people all over Piedmont, Virginia. They'll remember coming to a steeplechase race here. They remember coming here with their friends, whether they were in high school, college, or as adults. They remember those first weekends in November when the leaves were turning and you get the excitement of the horses running by. And it is those memories that help people form attachments to the place that help build meaning for the place.
SPEAKER_00And the fact that that can still occur here and does occur here creates that continuity that allows people for generation to generation to come and enjoy being at this place and seeing that incredibly exciting moment when the horses go past.
SPEAKER_02And we've also collected some oral histories of African Americans from the community that worked as horse trainers and who cared for the horses very early on in the DuPont period, whose families have been in the area since the days of slavery. So there's, you know, as you mentioned, there's some really deep, deep connections to this landscape. Yes, from the Madisons to the DuPonts, but it's all part of this continuing story of this place. And I think you you've kind of hinted at this, Tom.
SPEAKER_02When we talk about preservation as a public good, there is something very powerful in preserving the place. It's not just learning from a book or, you know, an autobiography. You're experiencing something. As you were just talking about how the windows opened in the mansion and how the breeze can come in, you know, from being in the house, I felt that before. And so it's evoking real feelings and it's evoking emotions. So in that regard, why is preservation important in connecting the story of Montpelier to this kind of broader public audience?
SPEAKER_00I always say that the best place to learn about history is the place where history happened. And I have been on the regular tour at Montpelier a number of times, most recently, about two years ago. And it's always a wonderful experience to be in the house where James and Dolly Madison lived, where his mother lived, his father, his grandparents were on the land here. But there's that moment where you go into his study, where he studied the histories, the classical writers, the enlightenment writers that informed his creation of the concepts that went into our Constitution.
SPEAKER_00And you turn from the bookcases on the walls and look out through the window to the view of the Blue Ridge and realize you're looking at the same view that Madison was looking at when he was crafting the ideas that became the Constitution. And it is a really moving, powerful experience. And you get just a hint of the human behind Madison, and that this was a person who sat in this room and came up with these ideas.
SPEAKER_00It's really a fantastic experience. And that's the type of experience that people can have, whether they're at President Lincoln's cottage and touching the handrail that he touched, or in Emily Dickinson's house, where she led a very quiet life but created this poetry, or a host of other places all over the country. That capacity to experience history where it happened helps people remember it in a very visceral way.
SPEAKER_02I've given quite a few tours of the mansion myself, and I always enjoy it. But even though I've done it many times at this point, I always get emotional when I go into that room. It's it's almost impossible not to feel something. And I have felt it and I have seen it in other people, and it's so powerful. I mean, I can't, if I had to define power of place, like that is it. It's this magic moment where you experiencing something and you are forever changed by that moment.
SPEAKER_02You know, you may not remember all the details of Madison's birth, death, you know, constitution, but you felt something.
SPEAKER_00Or having a revelation about President Madison's relationship with the enslaved community. All of those things can lead to profound changes among people. Which they can have without being dictated to or told what to think. They can come to their own conclusions about how they're experiencing the place and the stories that they're hearing here.
SPEAKER_02And sometimes that's almost more powerful. You know, I think of the first time I went into the African burial ground here at Montpelier, and you know, I was informed about the space, the significance of that space, but it was almost the lack of like, you know, a lecture or the guided tour that made it more profound. You can go into that space and just reflect on the meaning, the power in that cemetery.
SPEAKER_00I agree completely. And it's powerful also because of its simplicity and because it is in nature and the stones, as you know, are modest, often field stones, and that place has has real power. And to be able to look up from there and see both the site of Madison's own grave and the house where he lived is really powerful.
SPEAKER_02There's so much significance here, cultural, historical. But this is made possible in part because of this co-stewardship partnership between the National Trust for Historic Preservation and the Montpelier Foundation. Can you talk about kind of the impetus for the trust, not just taking on management of the site, but then eventually turning that management over to the Montpelier Foundation, but then kind of staying in that co-stewardship?
SPEAKER_00I worked on that co-stewardship agreement way back when, 25 years ago, believe it or not. And I'm very pleased that eventually I ended up serving on the board of the Montpelier Foundation as the ex officio representative of the National Trust. And I'm so pleased with the work that the foundation has been able to do. From the very beginning, the foundation uh wanted to be able to restore Montpelier. And the National Trust has 27 historic sites around the country.
SPEAKER_00About half of them are what we call co-stewardship sites, managed similarly to how Montpelier is managed. And the theory behind those really is that if there's a dedicated organization that's solely focused on the preservation and care and operation of that particular site, it is both closer to the ground so that it can make informed decisions about what's happening on the ground and can also be effective at raising funds that are necessary for the care and operation of the site.
SPEAKER_00And the Montpelier Foundation has been incredibly successful at both. And also has taken leadership in the historic site world by doing some groundbreaking exhibits that were award-winning, like the mere distinction of color. So the Montpelier Foundation has been incredibly successful at leading the site.
SPEAKER_00These sites are a challenge. Montpelier is nearly 2,700 acres. Mrs. Scott generously left it an endowment. But like most historic sites, the endowment is not sufficient to fully fund the operations. And the Montpelier Foundation has stepped up and taken the lead in raising the primary funds that are necessary to care for this place. And more is always needed.
SPEAKER_02What you're describing, Tom, it makes me think about the challenges of the field in general coming from a public historian perspective, you know, museums, historic sites, you know, a lot of humanities organizations have been struggling for a while and continue to. There's questions about does this model work? Are we still relevant to the public today? And these are really important things we have to be asking. You know, how are we taking the stories that we steward, the buildings we're preserving, the landscapes?
SPEAKER_02How are we bringing that to the public? And, you know, you referenced the trust being this national organization, it has a number of sites, but this co-stewardship has allowed the Montpelier Foundation to really build into the local region as well. So, yes, we tell this really important national story and we do programs on a national level, but we have this unique opportunity to build into those who live around here. And from my own work, I find that really rewarding because this is their history.
SPEAKER_02I mean, it really is a privilege to be able to be part of preserving and telling that history.
SPEAKER_00Earlier we talked about the steeplechase and how it becomes a community event and that that use was important. All of these sites are made relevant not only by what happened in the past here, but how that past is remembered and used and enjoyed by people in the present day. So I am a big proponent of these sites, they should be used.
SPEAKER_00And the ones that are successful are the ones that are fully engaged with the community around them, and the community, even if it is statewide community or national, or even as at Montpelier, an international community. All of those people have a stake in Montpelier and care about Montpelier because of the significance of Madison and his stories. I do not think that these sites should be frozen in amber. I think they have to be used and enjoyed.
SPEAKER_00And that does a couple things. One, it helps people feel attached to the place where they have those meaningful experiences that we talked about earlier. And then they build the sense of connection and identity and memory with the place. And that's true for the local community and for visitors from afar. So I love hearing music in old places. I love eating food in old places.
SPEAKER_00I love participating in archaeology at old places. I like just being in them to do whatever activity the site is doing. So the more they're used, the better.
SPEAKER_02It makes me think of the Montpelier experience in terms of the folks I see here. You know, we have groups, international groups from Asia, Europe, Africa. We also have your school groups from out of town, but then we have your local residents who come here several times a week to walk their dogs. So this idea of this is a living place, people are using it. And with that in mind, so we want places to be used. What are the challenges in terms of the law and policy of preservation?
SPEAKER_02Are there certain things like key laws that protect historic sites that either kind of put obstacles up in terms of accessibility, or is that really the purpose of these laws is to help promote access to these sites?
SPEAKER_00So I do think the purpose of uh preservation law is not only to preserve places in as if in amber, but to allow them to continue to be living parts of our communities. And the way the National Historic Preservation Act words it is to provide a sense of orientation to the American people, that we seek to save places not just so they are walled off or roped off, but so that they continue to serve ongoing functions.
SPEAKER_00There are a couple key ways that's done. I mean, there is the historic tax credit, which provides a federal tax credit for rehabbing income-producing properties, and the National Trust subsidiary, National Trust Community Investment Corporation, is a leader in that field. These projects have the capacity to be really transformative in the neighborhoods where they occur. And it is through the tax code that that is permitted. Most people don't get excited about the tax code, but preservation lawyers will get excited about the tax code.
SPEAKER_00And many states have comparable state-level tax credits that can help them do that as well. When people think of preservation law, though, they mostly think about local historic districts where a local commission will regulate what happens to people's properties within a historic district or for designated landmarks. And people sometimes say that's where the rubber really hits the road, is with that local historic district regulation.
SPEAKER_00I sit on my local historic district commission in Shepherdstown, West Virginia, and we have guidelines that guide all of our work. We don't make a single decision without referring to our guidelines. And we also try to be flexible to help people achieve what they're trying to achieve because we want Shepherdstown to be a living town. We want people to live there and enjoy living there and be able to do that in the 21st century.
SPEAKER_02Now, Tom, it's been a while since I've been in school for this. So you're going to have to remind me, 1960s is the National Historic Preservation Act.
SPEAKER_00That is correct. 1966. And it's a great book. They shared it with all the members of Congress. And somehow the stars aligned and they were able to get this bill passed, which created the National Historic Preservation Act.
SPEAKER_00And the National Historic Preservation Act philosophically was a broadening of historic preservation to apply at the federal level not only to nationally significant places, but also to places of state or local significance. And that was partly because people were seeing interstate highway construction, urban renewal, a host of other federal projects plow through the places that they loved without any consideration whatsoever.
SPEAKER_00So this is a law that just requires the federal agencies to stop, look, and listen and consider the effect on historic resources. It doesn't necessarily dictate that they all be saved.
SPEAKER_02And so we have kind of that important moment, that resource in terms of the landscape of preservation. Are there certain Supreme Court cases that include historic preservation or that were really monumental in this preservation world?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell What a great question. Interestingly, you know, as as you said in the introduction, I taught historic preservation law for quite a long time. And one of the things that's amazing to me is that historic preservation is often where some of these fundamental values in our society are sort of thought over and discussed and become contested.
SPEAKER_00So still to this day, the leading case from the Supreme Court on property rights is a case that is a historic preservation case. It was over whether the company that owned Grand Central Station in New York could build a 55-story tower on top of Grand Central Station or not. And the question was, had the New York Landmarks Commission and law in its application gone so far in regulating the property that it had essentially taken the property from the property owner.
SPEAKER_00So what the court came out with was a decision that looked at all the factors and basically said that the property owners still had the property that fit their investment-backed expectations, and they still had value in the property. Was there additional monetary value that they could no longer access? Yes. But the court suggested that they had to look at the property as a whole, and the property as a whole still had value.
SPEAKER_00So this case, which is still the leading case today, which involves historic preservation, is one of the most important cases interpreting part of the Constitution, that idea of how people are protected. So it's really fascinating to me. The same is true in some other areas of law. Sometimes do process cases come out of historic preservation regulation. We're also at the forefront of free exercise of religion and the establishment clause.
SPEAKER_00Both apply in historic preservation law.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. Can you explain more about that?
SPEAKER_00So first I didn't do my prep work on this one. It's been a little while, but you know, the First Amendment protects people's free exercise of religion, but also prohibits the establishment of religion. So the Establishment Clause piece has come up when the federal government is making grants to historic places, and sometimes those places can be religious organizations, churches.
SPEAKER_00So how far can the federal government go in making grants before it bumps up against the idea that it is establishing religion? And basically, the determination presently is that as long as the grants are being done for historic preservation purposes, not for religious purposes, then they are acceptable grants. The free exercise part comes in when the government is regulating for historic preservation purposes, such as through a local historic district.
SPEAKER_00And a church may want to say demolish a historic building for theoretically religious purposes. And one of the leading cases in this was a church in New York called St. Bartholomew's on Park Avenue, a very significant church. Again, they wanted to demolish one of the buildings in their complex to build a tower, which would have generated a huge amount of money. And a lower court there upheld the decision of the New York Landmarks Commission, denying them permission to do that.
SPEAKER_00But in doing so, they looked at factors about the church's rationale for why they wanted to do it. So looking at those and establishing those factors that courts could look at to determine whether there was a violation of the free exercise clause or not.
SPEAKER_02As we wind down our conversation today, I'm really struck by how preservation is very multifaceted. So we talked about the legal structures put in place, the legal precedents through the court. But then, you know, there's this really uh deeply emotional aspect of it as well. And I think part of this, you know, the purpose of the law, policy stewardship comes back to the experiencing of the place itself. So as we close, I want to refocus us back on Montpelier and ask you.
SPEAKER_02I don't know, this is a big question, but in your opinion, what would we lose, you know, as a nation if places like Montpelier weren't preserved? You know, how does a place like Montpelier help the public understand not just history and how it unfolds, but kind of the essence of who we are as Americans and where we're headed in this moment?
SPEAKER_00Well, that is a profound question. You know I'm a dedicated preservationist, but I think anybody who comes here can leave with a better understanding of Madison and his environment and the context out of which the American Revolution arose, and we're celebrating the 250th anniversary, and out of which the Constitution arose.
SPEAKER_00And at the same time, they're not coming away with some simplified version of it. They're coming away with a more nuanced experience where they understand that Madison lived on a plantation with many enslaved people supporting his lifestyle. They come away with the idea of the agricultural economy of the era in which he lived.
SPEAKER_00They come away knowing that essentially he died bankrupt and Dolly had to sell the property, a really profound human experience that many people can relate to.
SPEAKER_02Tom, through this conversation, you really made me, and I'm sure our listeners as well, think about this fundamental role that preservation plays, yes, in preserving these important places, but also it almost requires us to reflect on what we value, who we think we are, and we want to be. And that is reflected in what we choose or choose not to preserve. And I loved how you kind of tied the intrinsic connection of historic place with these lawn policies that really have safeguarded and been key to ensuring places like Montpelier continue to exist.
SPEAKER_02So thank you so much for your time and talking with us about the role of the trust, but also why Montpelier is so important.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Katie. It's been a pleasure talking with you.
SPEAKER_02And I want to thank all of our listeners. I hope you'll share the show with your family and friends. And join us again soon as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...