In the Judiciary Act of 1789, the First Congress created the office of the U.S. Attorneys, which was signed into law by President George Washington. Timothy J. Heaphy, a former U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Virginia, joins host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey to discuss the roles and responsibilities of U.S. Attorneys within the federal justice system and the significance of collaboration between different levels of law enforcement.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every member. Policy and subject matter experts, her professionals and legal practitioners. We examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution promptly. The Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. When James Madison and the other framers signed the U.S. Constitution in September 1787, it included seven articles, including Article III, which established the judicial branch and the Supreme Court. Now, if you page through the U.S. Constitution, you may notice that Article III is quite short. However, two years after it was signed, Congress provided greater clarity on the workings of the justice system with the passage of the Judiciary Act of 1789.
SPEAKER_01This act created a tiered federal court system with the Supreme Court at the top. The Judiciary Act laid out how this federal judicial system would function, and it created the Office of the Attorney General and the Office of the United States Attorneys. And it's the function of the U.S. Attorneys and their role upholding our Democratic government that we're discussing today. Joining us in the studio is Timothy J. Hefey, who served as a U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Virginia from December 2009 through 2014.
SPEAKER_01Currently, Mr. Heavey is a partner at Wilkie Law Firm. He served as Chief Investigative Counsel to the U.S. House of Representatives Select Committee to investigate the January 6th attack on the United States Capitol. He is also University Counsel to the University of Virginia and is a lecturer at the UVA School of Law, teaching courses in federal criminal practice and law and riots. It's a pleasure to welcome you, Mr. Hepey. Thank you for being with us today.
SPEAKER_02It's my pleasure, Katie. Thank you for having me.
SPEAKER_01Now, given your experience as a U.S. attorney, can you start us off with just a brief overview of what that position entails?
SPEAKER_02Sure. So there are 94 U.S. attorneys around the country, one for each federal judicial district. In Virginia, there are two federal judicial districts, the Eastern District and the Western District. And the U.S. attorney is the chief federal law enforcement officer for that district. The position is presidentially appointed. So it turns over at the end of each administration and is Senate confirmed. So the president appoints all 94 U.S. attorneys subject to the advice and consent of the Senate. And then the U.S. attorney essentially supervises the prosecution of federal crimes within that district and the defense and civil litigation of the United States in that federal district.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell So there are 94 of these districts throughout the United States and the U.S. territories. And what is so significant about having this U.S. attorney in each of these districts? What exactly is their function?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Well, each district is a little bit different and has different public safety challenges, has different law enforcement issues. And the system allows for federal justice to be tailored to meet those needs. So the things that I was dealing with when I was U.S. attorney in Virginia may not be exactly the same as the U.S. attorney in Philadelphia or the U.S. attorney in Montana. So having a system that essentially deploys a president's appointed U.S. attorney in each district allows for federal resources to be brought to bear in a more tailored way.
SPEAKER_02If it were just the attorney general announcing priorities across the country, that would be over-inclusive in some places and under in other places. And it wouldn't necessarily match the particular unique public safety challenges that we had in each district. So having one in a smaller area allows him or her to bring to bear prosecutorial and investigative resources to meet the needs that are unique to that district.
SPEAKER_01So as a U.S. attorney, you are representing that district and are in tune with the needs of that demographic and geographic area.
SPEAKER_02Yes. I think to be effective, the U.S. attorney can't be all things to all people. The federal criminal code is really sprawling. For instance, every drug offense that happens anywhere is illegal under federal law. But the U.S. attorney only does a very small percentage of drug cases because that's also a state offense. There are oftentimes particular acts that either could be charged in state court or federal court. Therefore, there needs to be some sort of thoughtful analysis as to which side of the line, which jurisdiction will actually take that case.
SPEAKER_02So a big part of my job when I was U.S. attorney was spending time with my state and local law enforcement partners in each community, getting a sense as to what they faced and where federal resources could be most effectively brought to bear. Again, you can't be everywhere. You have to pick and choose and prioritize. And that is best done with good working relationships with state and local partners.
SPEAKER_01So you're representing the United States government. Yes. But you're also working with the folks on the ground there, people kind of at the state level and the local level.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I mean, I kind of looked at our office as one slice of the pie, right? Like in Roanoke. There's the Commonwealth Attorney, there's the Roanoke City Police Department, there's the sheriff, there are the neighboring jurisdictions, and then there's the FBI and the DEA and the ATF in our office. And unless those entities are communicating effectively, are sharing information about the various threats that are emerging and are thoughtfully responding, everybody's going to be less effective. So again, I spend a lot of my time talking to my counterparts in various counties and cities around the western half of Virginia, just asking, hey, what do you with what do you need help?
SPEAKER_02Where would our office be most useful? Instead of just unilaterally deciding where we were going to invest our people's time and energy, that needed to be the product of some discussion. And candidly, that varies. Some people were very receptive to that, other people were more skeptical. Like it sort of comes down to relationships. So I had to thankfully I inherited a lot of good relationships, but then some bad ones that I had to try to repair. People that were more skeptical of federal authorities or thought that we were there to cherry pick the good cases or to somehow usurp local control.
SPEAKER_02And that was was not the case at all. So I can't say that this operates perfectly in every place, but that's the intention anyway.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell It sounds like it's a unique opportunity to really make those connections, as you mentioned, but it's also you have a challenge of navigating as well. And as you said, representing the United States government. You're under the executive branch, correct? When you're a U.S. attorney.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yes. Appointed by the president and report to the Deputy Attorney General and the Attorney General. Now, there's a tradition at the Justice Department that the department is independent and pursues cases completely without regard to politics, that the White House, the president, never get involved in any specific case. I remember when I was appointed as U.S. attorney, there were about 50 or 60 of us that had been appointed by President Obama. And we went to the White House for a very brief meeting with him.
SPEAKER_02And the first thing that he said when he came into the room, we were all kind of assembled in the East Room. He said, You're not my lawyers. I don't want you all to look at yourselves as lawyers for this administration. You're the lawyers for the people in your district. And you shouldn't think about how a decision that you make is going to affect me or my re-election or politics. You should do what is best for the people of Virginia, Tim, for you, or Barb U in Michigan, or Melinda U in California. And I really appreciated that and took that seriously.
SPEAKER_02And that's frankly consistent with the historical independence of the department, that the Department of Justice, and this is true with Republican administrations and Democratic administrations, has typically just avoided any interference with the day-to-day operation of the Justice Department and out in the field U.S. attorneys. And I think that that's right. That gets us a higher quality of justice. These decisions should be made on the merits, not based on politics. I was lucky that I served in an administration that respected that independence.
SPEAKER_01I have to admit, when you mentioned that U.S. attorneys are appointed by the United States president and that there is turnover whenever the administration changes. I did wonder how partisan plays in, if that was a factor, or as you said, if it is really a nonpartisan process.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it you know, interestingly, the process is not nonpartisan. To get the job, uh, it starts with the senators in that state. So for me, uh, we had two Democratic senators. At the time, it was Jim Webb and it was Mark Warner. And they had a process by which they would take nominations from a committee, like they set up a committee of lawyers who would come forth with names of possible lawyers who would serve as U.S. attorneys. So you could apply.
SPEAKER_02So I literally like submitted my materials to this committee. I was one of the names sent forth to the senators, and then the senators recommended me and two other people to the White House. And then the White House ultimately chose from the list submitted by the senators. So that is a political process. So getting the attention of the senators and getting into the mix with this committee, I did mobilize, you know, support people that knew me, people that knew the senators, people that were willing to speak up for me. But then weirdly, even though it's a political process that results in a political appointment, once you're in the position, then you're completely disconnected from politics.
SPEAKER_02I didn't give money to candidates, go to political events. I was very mindful during my time as U.S. attorney that I would not be affected in any way by politics. So it's this weird hybrid system where it's a political process of appointment, but the work itself, and this is again Republican, Democrat, no matter who is in the White House or has been attorney general, this has historically been the case. Then the job is disconnected from politics.
SPEAKER_01So it sounds like once you are in the position, it's really a public service. You are there to serve, as you said, the people in your district, that you're the lawyer of those people.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Exactly right. Without concern about how it will play out politically. Pay close attention to the needs in the district and bring your scarce resources to bear where they can be most useful.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Do you have any memorable cases or experiences that kind of shed light on how this process plays out in protecting the people of the United States?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Oh, a lot. I mean, uh so many cases. One of the benefits of practicing in a big and diverse district like mine was that we we had everything. We had everything from classic big city type crime, you know, open air drug sales and violence and gang activity to vast open rural spaces where the criminal justice challenges were very different. There are a couple things that I would highlight as sort of manifestations of this. One was that when I was U.S. attorney, I believed we were part of, as I said before, this sort of holistic pie of community safety.
SPEAKER_02We were going to play one role. And I didn't think that our role should be limited to prosecution. So we created a new position in our office called the Community Outreach Coordinator. This was a pilot project for which we got funding from the Department of Justice to try. So this is a person in the office who's not a lawyer, who is not involved in making cases. Her role exclusively was to identify crime prevention programs, re-entry programs where people that are formerly incarcerated were coming back to communities and try to bring comprehensive solutions to particular communities.
SPEAKER_02So we may be doing a big gang case in a particular neighborhood in Roanoke, but we wouldn't be completely considering public safety in that neighborhood unless we thought about prevention and re-entry services brought to bear in that same community. So while prosecutors were making the criminal case, the community outreach coordinator was trying to identify proactive prevention resources, offender re-entry programs, identify funding streams, bring them together with others doing similar work. And then essentially coordinating, I used to call it the sort of three-legged stool of community safety, that the stool is only strong if all three legs are standing firm under it.
SPEAKER_02And that's enforcement, targeted enforcement, but also prevention and reentry. So we brought this kind of comprehensive approach to public safety in our community that we have the unique tools of the federal government and resources to bring to bear. And I think that's the right way to approach it is to listen to your state and local partners, but then try to bring these holistic approaches. There are also just a lot of cases. Like there were so many different kinds of cases. I did a couple myself, even though I was U.S. attorney, I had a very small caseload. And one in particular that I recall was there was a cold case homicide in Orange that the local authorities had not been able to close.
SPEAKER_02They had a suspect, but they weren't able to get enough information to charge that person with the murder. In the federal system, we have an investigative grand jury, unlike the state system, we can subpoena people, put them under oath, bring them in, and we have, you know, the leverage of some pretty significant drug or other offenses to use as leverage to get information. So the Commonwealth's attorney came to us and said, you know, we haven't been able to do anything with this with this case. It was several years old at this point. The murder had occurred and no one had been held accountable.
SPEAKER_02So she asked if we would look at it. Um this was a drug-related murder, so there was a federal hook. Not every murder is a federal crime, but if it's connected to a drug offense, then it could be. So we started putting people in the grand jury. We started diving into the drug distribution network in that community. And we were able to get enough evidence to charge this defendant with this murder of someone that had stolen a package of drugs from one of his suppliers. And that would this was a revenge-oriented murder.
SPEAKER_02And we brought the case in federal court and uh the defendant was convicted and sentenced to life in prison. And then I'll never forget that soon after the verdict, the mother of the decedent, the man who had been killed, had been in trial every day. She'd been coming to the courtroom every day. And I was explaining to her and her family members after the jury had returned its verdict that it meant that this defendant was going to serve a mandatory life sentence in prison. And she was crying. She was weeping. And I said, I'm sorry, ma'am. I I know that this is doesn't bring your son back.
SPEAKER_02I know that it's still a sad day. And she said, Oh no, I'm crying because somebody finally paid attention to my son's murder. Somebody cared enough to put the time into that investigation and to hold somebody accountable. So we were able to help her and her family get justice, right? To feel as if somebody cared, right? There's their her son was a you know a drug user who stole a package of crack cocaine, not the kind of person that often gets a lot of attention in our society. But he was murdered, and that was illegal, and that merited a strong investigative and prosecutorial response.
SPEAKER_02So we filled a gap there where the state wasn't able to bring the case. We stepped in and got this family a sense of justice. That's one very small example of the broader goal. Our goal is to work with state and local partners to do justice and to help people feel as if the system works.
SPEAKER_01But I think that's an important example of how individuals can work together at these different levels, whether it be local, state, federal. It's not always in opposition. It it can actually be very beneficial for all parties, including the families.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Exactly right. For all parties, right? Like our approach was if there are things that you don't have the resources to do, whether it's investigative or otherwise, that's our highest and best use, as opposed to deciding unilaterally what you need, what this community might benefit from. That needs to be informed by the people that are closer to those communities, that the local officials who answer to the constituents there, the officers who walk the streets there. That really is essential information for us to have to decide where to plug in.
SPEAKER_01And so as U.S. attorney, you work in the prosecutor seat on one side of the courtroom. Now you have a little bit of a different role.
SPEAKER_02I do.
SPEAKER_01Can you tell us a little bit about how this gives you different perspective or maybe better insight into the legal system?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yeah. So I've been on both sides of the courtroom. Uh I've been a prosecutor. I've also been a defense lawyer several times. I've been sort of in and out of government several times. And I think I'm better at both because I've been on the other side. So there are times when I was U.S. attorney when there were big corporate investigations. One of the biggest cases we resolved when I was U.S. attorney was an off-label marketing matter against a pharmaceutical company. The law says that the FDA approves medications for particular uses.
SPEAKER_02And it's against the law for the manufacturer of that medication to market it for other uses that are unapproved. And Abbott Labs, the defendant in our case, made this medication called Depacote, was like an anti-seizure medicine. That's what it had been approved for. But it also was sort of a sedative. And they marketed it into nursing homes because it essentially kept nursing home residents docile and quiet. And that was off-label marketing and illegal. And we negotiated this$1.6 billion resolution where they agreed to pay back the federal government for the Medicare and Medicaid money that had gone to this off-label marketing.
SPEAKER_02And I, negotiating that resolution with the big law firm lawyers representing Abbott Labs, I was better at that because I understood the pressures that a big company feels, the collateral effects of these investigations on employees, on shareholders. And I was just sort of better and smarter at the arguments that were being made as to why we should be lenient on the company. And then on the other side, now that I am one of those lawyers representing individuals or companies who are being investigated for something, I have a sense as to what the government's priorities are, what they're looking for in a case, right?
SPEAKER_02Are there victims' interests that need to be vindicated? Is there restitution that needs to be made? Are there compliance changes that they want to see to try to prevent future misconduct? I speak their language and therefore am better able to anticipate their priorities, and that makes me a more effective defense lawyer. So I'm not one of those people that sort of believes you're fundamentally wired to be a prosecutor or a defense lawyer. I think the system depends upon good lawyers on both sides holding each other to their standards and having been on both sides. I think I'm I'm a better advocate because I sort of understand the view from either side of the courtroom.
SPEAKER_01And clearly you have a lot of knowledge to share. I'm sure it's very interesting to be in one of your classes, your federal criminal practice or your lawn riots classes. Do you mind saying just a little bit about what you teach and kind of the message that you want students to take away?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Um, so I teach currently a class at the law school EVA called Lawn Riots. So I I, as you mentioned in the beginning, I led the congressional investigation of the attack on the Capitol S Chief Investigative Council. I also, before that, did a lengthy report about the Charlottesville protest in 2017. As a lawyer, then in private practice, I kind of led an independent review process. So I have this accidental expertise in political violence and the management of mass demonstrations. So Lawn Riots, the class that I teach, is sort of tries to bring a lot of that experience to a one-semester class where we talk about the intersection of free speech and public safety and how it's difficult for local governments like Charlottesville to simultaneously protect the right to free speech.
SPEAKER_02They have to be content neutral in their approach to that. Even if the speech is noxious and hateful, unless it's directly threatening, unless it incites imminent lawless action, then they have to protect it. But they also have to protect people while they're facilitating the speech. And sometimes the speech makes people really angry and it makes them engage in violence, and that's really hard. So law and riots is kind of about that tension between those two fundamental rights. We look historically at how that's been reconciled over time. And I bring a lot of people into the class. Like I've brought some police officers that were in Charlottesville and at the Capitol to the class.
SPEAKER_02I've brought in Loretta Lynch, who is the Attorney General of the United States and a friend of mine. I brought the mayor of Seattle, who's another former U.S. attorney, talking about the autonomous zone in Seattle and the difficult issues that she had. So I also, and I also bring some protesters, including some people that have engaged in violence themselves, have been arrested, some Antifa members who give that perspective to students. So it's a practical class, really for second or third year, primarily third-year law students. And my message to them is always the same: it's these hard issues depend upon people like you, you law students, who are inheriting responsibility to navigate that going forward.
SPEAKER_02You need to participate actively in our democracy, use your legal skills to be a truth teller and an answer, provide an answer to these hard questions that are continue to come up, take them on because we need good people to help navigate this terrain going forward. So it attracts people that are sort of public service-oriented. And I hope it strengthens that desire.
SPEAKER_01One of the key takeaways from this conversation for me is this idea that we're all part of this system. And we have public servants who are doing this work, who are acting in the best interests of all people, and that everybody has a role to play in upholding democracy.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Absolutely right. Look, the system comes down to individual decision makers. It comes down to a police officer making a decision to stop someone on the street, to a prosecutor deciding whether to charge someone or not, to a juror deciding on guilt or innocence. The beauty of the American system is that people make the decisions, right? Regular people. We don't live in a dictatorship or a monarchy where rules are imposed on us from the outside. We live in a system in which the rules are made by people for the people. And that has never been done successfully in human history until America.
SPEAKER_02And I think while imperfect and why we need to keep working on the system, it generally works. And I hope that people take away from this conversation and a lot of the other work that I've done is the sense of personal responsibility, right? That they have to play their part, that democracy is earned, not given, that everybody should care, should participate, should vote, should pay attention, should talk and listen, and should be engaged, right? That's what it takes for this experiment in democracy to work is for people to care and for people to uh to participate.
SPEAKER_01We're not bystanders. No. We are participants. We should be. We have to be engaged. Well, Tim Heafy, thank you so much for joining us today. Um, you shared a lot of your insights and experiences, and it really kind of uplifted my spirits about hopes for the future and how we can all be involved.
SPEAKER_02Good. I'm glad to hear that, and I hope your listeners feel the same.
SPEAKER_01And thank you to our listeners for joining us today. I hope you'll share the show with your family and friends, and join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...